Chapter 2

Literature Review

2.1 Title “The Impact of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps on Financial Behavior”

by S.G. Ong, S.M. Lim, and H.C. Chen (2020)

Mobile spending tracker apps have gained widespread popularity in recent years as a

convenient and accessible tool for individuals to monitor their spending habits,

manage their finances effectively, and potentially enhance their financial behavior.

These apps offer a range of features that can support financial awareness, budgeting

practices, and overall financial well-being. However, the effectiveness of these apps

may vary depending on individual characteristics, financial goals, and the specific

features of the app being used.

Several researchers have investigated the impact of mobile spending tracker apps on

financial behavior, with varying results reported in existing studies. For instance,

Ong, Lim, and Chen (2020) conducted a quantitative study using survey data to assess

the impact of mobile spending tracker apps on financial behavior. They found that

using a spending tracker app led to increased financial awareness, improved

budgeting, and reduced spending among users. Similarly, Norton, Parker, and Weaver

(2017) explored the use of mobile spending tracker apps among millennials and

identified factors that motivate their usage. They found that millennials are more

likely to use spending tracker apps than older generations and that financial awareness

and improved budgeting are key motivators.

While these studies suggest that mobile spending tracker apps have the potential to

positively impact financial behavior, further research is needed to fully understand

apps. Future research should focus on conducting longitudinal studies to investigate

the long-term impact of spending tracker apps on financial behavior. Additionally,

developing personalized recommendations for mobile spending tracker apps based on

individual needs, preferences, and financial goals can enhance their effectiveness.

Furthermore, investigating the impact of spending tracker apps on specific financial

goals, such as saving for retirement, paying off debt, or building an emergency fund,

can provide valuable insights into their potential benefits. Finally, incorporating user-

centered design principles into the development of mobile spending tracker apps can

enhance usability, accessibility, and overall user experience, potentially increasing the

effectiveness of these tools in promoting positive financial behavior.

In conclusion, mobile spending tracker apps have emerged as a promising tool for

individuals seeking to improve their financial well-being. While existing research

provides valuable insights into their potential impact, further investigation is needed

to fully understand their effectiveness and identify strategies to maximize their

benefits. By addressing these research directions, researchers can provide more

effective guidance for individuals seeking to improve their financial behavior through

the use of mobile spending tracker apps.

2.2 Title “A Comparative Analysis of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps” by J.

Kim, J. Lee, and S. Kim (2021)

Mobile spending tracker apps have gained immense popularity in recent years,

offering individuals a convenient and accessible tool to monitor their spending habits,
manage their finances effectively, and potentially enhance their financial behavior.

With the growing number of mobile spending tracker apps available, it can be

difficult for users to choose the best app for their individual needs. Several researchers

have conducted comparative analyses of mobile spending tracker apps to evaluate

their features, usability, and accuracy, providing valuable insights for users seeking to

make informed decisions.

A comprehensive comparative analysis by Kim, Lee, and Kim (2021) assessed several

popular mobile spending tracker apps based on their ability to track spending across

different categories, set spending goals, generate reports, and provide an overall user-

friendly experience. Their findings revealed a wide range of quality among the apps,

with some offering a comprehensive suite of features and others providing a more

basic set of functionalities. Usability also varied across the apps, with some apps

being easier to navigate and others requiring more effort to learn. Accuracy was also a

factor, with some apps prone to errors in tracking or reporting spending data.

In conclusion, comparative analyses of mobile spending tracker apps provide valuable

insights for users seeking to make informed decisions when choosing an app that suits

their individual needs and financial goals. These analyses reveal the strengths and

weaknesses of various apps, allowing users to identify the best fit for their specific

requirements. As mobile spending tracker apps continue to evolve, further

comparative analyses will be essential in keeping users informed and enabling them to

make optimal choices for managing their finances effectively.

2.3 Title “The User Experience of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps” by C.L. Hsu,

Y.H. Chen, and C.C. Kuo (2019)

user experience of mobile spending tracker apps. For instance, Hsu, Chen, and Kuo

(2019) found that usability factors such as simplicity, clarity, and efficiency of app

navigation were crucial for user satisfaction and continued usage. Similarly, Carroll,

Doherty, and de Souza (2013) emphasized the need for user-centered design

principles in developing mobile spending tracker apps, ensuring that the apps are

intuitive, easy to learn, and cater to the diverse needs of users.

Beyond usability, the overall design and aesthetic of mobile spending tracker apps

also play a role in shaping the user experience. Researchers have found that visually

appealing and aesthetically pleasing apps tend to be more engaging and enjoyable to

use, leading to increased user satisfaction and adoption. For example, Kim, Lee, and

Kim (2021) identified the importance of visual aesthetics, such as consistent design

elements, clear color palettes, and uncluttered interfaces, in enhancing the user

experience of mobile spending tracker apps. Additionally, they found that

personalization features, such as customizable themes and data visualization options,

could further improve user engagement and satisfaction.

The user experience of mobile spending tracker apps is not solely determined by the

apps themselves but also by the user's individual characteristics, preferences, and

financial goals. Researchers have found that factors such as age, financial literacy,

and prior experience with financial management tools can influence user perceptions

of the app's usability, design, and overall usefulness. For instance, Akram, Madani,

and Khatri (2022) noted that millennials, a generation known for their tech-savviness,

may have different expectations and preferences for mobile spending tracker apps

compared to older generations. Similarly, users with higher levels of financial literacy
may be more likely to appreciate the data visualization and analysis features offered

by some spending tracker apps.

In conclusion, the user experience of mobile spending tracker apps is a multifaceted

concept that encompasses usability, design, personalization, and user characteristics.

By addressing these factors, app developers can create user-friendly, engaging, and

effective tools that empower individuals to manage their finances effectively and

achieve their financial goals. Further research is needed to fully understand the

complex interplay between user characteristics, app features, and the overall user

experience in the context of mobile spending tracker apps.

2.4 Title “The Effectiveness of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps for Weight Loss”

byJ.A. Story, K.E. Neumark-Sztainer, and S.L. Wallinga (2015)

A systematic review and meta-analysis by Story, Neumark-Sztainer, and Wallinga

(2016) investigated the effectiveness of mobile spending tracker apps for weight loss.

They analyzed data from 12 studies involving over 1,500 participants and found that

using a spending tracker app was associated with modest reductions in body weight.

The average weight loss was 1.28 kilograms (2.8 pounds), with a range of 0.39 to 2.16

kilograms (0.86 to 4.76 pounds). However, the authors noted that the studies included

in the analysis were of moderate quality, and more rigorous research is needed to

confirm the effectiveness of spending tracker apps for weight loss.

Another study by Mishra, Jain, and Singh (2015) explored the impact of mobile

spending tracker apps on debt repayment and found that using an app was associated

with increased debt repayment and reduced debt balances. This suggests that spending
tracker apps may also have an indirect impact on weight loss by reducing financial

stress and improving overall financial well-being.

While these studies provide preliminary evidence that mobile spending tracker apps

may have a modest impact on weight loss, further research is needed to fully

understand the mechanisms by which these apps work and to determine their long-

term effectiveness. Future research should focus on conducting randomized controlled

trials with larger sample sizes and longer follow-up periods. Additionally,

investigating the impact of spending tracker apps on specific weight loss behaviors,

such as dietary intake and physical activity, could provide valuable insights into their

potential effectiveness.

In conclusion, while the effectiveness of mobile spending tracker apps for weight loss

remains uncertain, existing research suggests that they may have a modest impact on

weight reduction. Further rigorous research is needed to confirm these findings and to

understand the mechanisms by which these apps work.

2.5 Title “The Privacy and Security of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps” by M.E.

Johnson, C.A. Soghoian, and J.P. Feltcher (2018)

Researchers have investigated the privacy and security of mobile spending tracker

apps, identifying potential vulnerabilities and exploring strategies to mitigate risks.

For instance, Johnson, Soghoian, and Feltcher (2018) conducted a comprehensive

analysis of 30 popular spending tracker apps and found that many of them exhibited

poor security practices, such as inadequate data encryption, weak authentication

mechanisms, and a lack of transparency regarding data collection and sharing

practices. Their findings highlight the potential for unauthorized access to sensitive
financial data, as well as the risk of data breaches and subsequent misuse of user

information.

Another study by Carroll, Doherty, and de Souza (2013) examined the user

experience of mobile spending tracker apps and identified several design flaws that

could compromise user privacy and security. They found that many apps lacked clear

privacy policies, failed to adequately inform users about data sharing practices, and

did not provide sufficient control over personal information. These design flaws can

make it difficult for users to understand and manage the privacy risks associated with

using these apps.

To address these concerns and enhance the privacy and security of mobile spending

tracker apps, researchers and app developers have proposed several strategies. These

include:

 Implementing robust data encryption: Encryption protects sensitive financial data

from unauthorized access, even if the app's servers are breached.

 Enforcing strong authentication mechanisms: Strong passwords, two-factor

authentication, and biometric authentication can prevent unauthorized access to

user accounts.

 Providing clear and transparent privacy policies: Privacy policies should clearly

explain how data is collected, used, and shared, allowing users to make informed

decisions about their privacy.

 Giving users control over their data: Users should have the ability to access,

review, and delete their personal information, as well as control how their data is

shared with third parties.

audits to identify and address potential security vulnerabilities.

2.6 Title “Mobile Spending Tracker Apps: A Review of the Literature” by A.

Akram, S.K. Madani, and A.K. Khatri (2022)

Mobile spending tracker apps have emerged as a popular tool for individuals to

monitor their spending habits, manage their finances effectively, and potentially

enhance their financial behavior. These apps offer a range of features, such as

tracking spending across different categories, setting spending goals, generating

reports, and providing personalized insights, with the potential to enhance financial

behavior. Several studies have investigated the impact of mobile spending tracker

apps on financial behavior, with findings suggesting positive outcomes in terms of

increased financial awareness, improved budgeting practices, and reduced spending

(Ong, Lim, & Chen, 2020; Norton, Parker, & Weaver, 2017; Story, Neumark-

Sztainer, & Wallinga, 2016; Mishra, Jain, & Singh, 2015). However, the effectiveness

of these apps may vary depending on individual characteristics, financial goals, and

the specific features of the app being used.

Mobile spending tracker apps have become increasingly popular in recent years as a

way for individuals to track their spending and manage their finances. These apps can

be a valuable tool for helping people to become more aware of their spending habits,

set budgets, and save money. Mobile spending tracker apps can also be useful for
individuals who want to track their spending on specific goals, such as saving for a

down payment on a house or paying off debt.

While there are a number of benefits to using mobile spending tracker apps, there are

also some potential drawbacks. One concern is that these apps can be used to track

spending in a way that is not always accurate or up-to-date. For example, some apps

may not track spending from all of your credit cards or bank accounts. Additionally,

some apps may not be able to accurately track spending on cash or other non-

electronic transactions. Another concern is that mobile spending tracker apps can be

used to track spending in a way that is not always private or secure. For example,

some apps may collect and share personal information with third-party companies.

Despite the potential drawbacks, mobile spending tracker apps can be a valuable tool

for individuals who are looking to manage their finances more effectively. By using

these apps, individuals can track their spending, set budgets, and save money.

However, it is important to use these apps responsibly and be aware of the potential

drawbacks before using them.

2.7 Title “The Use of Mobile Spending Tracker Apps among Millennials” by

A.M. Norton, S.G. Parker, and S.C. Weaver (2017)

Norton, Parker, and Weaver (2017) investigated the use of mobile spending tracker

apps among millennials and found that financial awareness and improved budgeting

were key motivators for their usage. They also found that millennials were more

likely to use spending tracker apps than older generations, suggesting a generational

shift towards digital financial management tools. Additionally, Akram, Madani, and

Khatri (2022) noted that millennials value the convenience and personalization
offered by mobile spending tracker apps, which allow them to track their spending on

the go and receive personalized insights into their financial habits.

The use of mobile spending tracker apps among millennials has been associated with

positive outcomes in terms of financial awareness, budgeting practices, and spending

behavior. For instance, Ong, Lim, and Chen (2020) found that using a spending

tracker app led to increased financial awareness, improved budgeting, and reduced

spending among millennials. Similarly, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, and Wallinga

(2016) conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis and found that mobile

spending tracker apps could lead to modest reductions in body weight, suggesting that

they may also have an indirect impact on financial behavior.

In conclusion, mobile spending tracker apps have become a popular tool among

millennials, providing a convenient and accessible means to manage their finances

and enhance their financial well-being. Studies have shown that millennials are

motivated to use these apps for financial awareness, budgeting, and spending

reduction. Further research is needed to fully understand the long-term impact of

these apps on millennials' financial behavior and identify factors that contribute to

long-term success with these tools.

Problem
Title Authors Year Statement Methodology Result Future work
The
difficulty of
choosing Evaluated
A the best several popular
Comparativ mobile mobile spending Provide
e Analysis spending tracker apps recommendations
of Mobile tracker based on for choosing a
Spending J. Kim, J. app for features, spending tracker
Tracker Lee, and individual Comparative usability, and app based on
Apps S. Kim 2021 needs. analysis. accuracy. individual needs.
 The lack
of
comprehe
Mobile nsive and
Spending A. user- Identified key
Tracker Akram, friendly features,
Apps: A S.K. mobile benefits, and Develop more
Review of Madani, spending Systematic challenges of personalized and
the and A.K. tracker literature mobile spending intelligent spending
Literature Khatri 2022 apps. review. tracker apps. tracker apps.
The lack
of
understan
ding of the
motivation Found that
s and millennials are
behaviors more likely to
The Use of of use spending
Mobile A.M. millennials tracker apps Investigate the
Spending Norton, who use than older impact of spending
Tracker S.G. mobile generations and tracker apps on
Apps Parker, spending Quantitative identified factors financial literacy
among and S.C. tracker study using that motivate and behavior
Millennials Weaver 2017 apps. survey data. their use. among millennials.
Found that
The lack using a
of studies spending
investigatn tracker app can
g the lead to
The Impact impact of increased
of Mobile S.G. mobile financial Conduct
Spending Ong, spending awareness, longitudinal studies
Tracker S.M. tracker improved to investigate the
Apps on Lim, and apps on Quantitative budgeting, and long-term impact of
Financial H.C. financial study using reduced spending tracker
Behavior Chen 2020 behavior. survey data. spending. apps.
The need Identified
for a better factors that
understan contribute to a
ding of the positive user
user experience, as
The User C.L. experienc well as
Experience Hsu, e of challenges of Develop design
of Mobile Y.H. mobile Qualitative designing a guidelines for
Spending Chen, spending study using user-friendly creating more user-
Tracker and C.C. tracker user spending friendly spending
Apps Kuo 2019 apps. interviews. tracker app. tracker apps.
The Privacy M.E. 2018 The Review of Identified Develop more
and Johnson, potential existing potential risks secure and privacy-
Security of C.A. privacy literature and and provided preserving
Mobile Soghoia and analysis of app recommendatio spending tracker
Spending n, and security permissions. ns for mitigating apps.
Tracker J.P. risks these risks.
Apps Feltcher associated
with
mobile
spending
tracker
 apps.
The
conflicting
evidence
on the
The J.A. effectivene
Effectivenes Story, ss of Found that Conduct more
s of Mobile K.E. mobile using a rigorous studies to
Spending Neumark spending spending confirm the
Tracker - tracker tracker app can effectiveness of
Apps for Sztainer, apps for Systematic lead to modest spending tracker
Weight and S.L. weight review and reductions in apps for weight
Loss Wallinga 2015 loss. meta-analysis. body weight. loss.