Discourse Analysis and Teaching Booklet
Discourse Analysis and Teaching Booklet
Week 3-4
Logical Progression: The ideas in the text should follow a logical sequence, ensuring that readers or
listeners can understand the message without confusion.
Consistency: Consistent terminology, style, and tone contribute to coherence.
Relevance: All content in the text should be relevant to the topic and purpose, avoiding irrelevant
digressions.
5.3.2 Cohesion
Cohesion focuses on the grammatical and lexical devices that link different parts of the text.
Cohesion ensures that a text flows smoothly and that readers or listeners can follow the connections
between sentences and paragraphs. Cohesive devices include:
Pronouns: Words like "he," "she," "it," and "they" that refer back to previously mentioned nouns.
Conjunctions: Words like "and," "but," "however," and "therefore" that link ideas or indicate
relationships.
Repetition: Repeating key words or phrases to reinforce the main ideas.
5.4 Types of Text Structures
Text structures can vary depending on the purpose and genre of the text. Common text structures
include:
5.4.3 Problem-Solution
This structure introduces a problem or issue and then proposes one or more solutions. It is often
used in argumentative essays, reports, and policy papers.
5.4.4 Compare and Contrast
In a compare and contrast structure, similarities and differences between two or more subjects are
highlighted. It is common in comparative essays, academic research, and analysis of various subjects.
Summary
Text structure and organization are essential aspects of discourse analysis. Coherence and cohesion
play a significant role in making a text understandable and engaging. Different types of text
structures are used in various contexts, each serving specific purposes. Analyzing text structure helps
us decipher the strategies used to communicate effectively.
Key Terms:
Text structure
Macrostructure
Microstructure
Coherence
Cohesion
Chronological order
Cause and effect
Problem-solution
Compare and contrast
Chapter 6
Introduction to Discourse Units
Discourse analysis involves examining language beyond individual words or sentences. Discourse
units are the building blocks of communication and play a vital role in conveying meaning, structuring
information, and maintaining coherence and cohesion within a text or conversation.
Summary
Discourse units, including sentences, paragraphs, and larger text units, are integral to effective
communication and discourse analysis. Sentences are the smallest meaningful units, paragraphs help
structure information, and larger text units provide a higher-level organization. Analyzing how these
units contribute to coherence and cohesion is essential in understanding the underlying structure of
discourse.
Key Terms:
Discourse units
Sentences
Paragraphs
Syntax
Coherence
Cohesion
Sections
Chapters
Titles
Headings
Chapter 7: Discourse Markers and Transitions
Learning Objectives
By the end of this chapter, you will be able to:
Showing Contrast: Discourse markers like "but," "however," and "on the other hand" indicate a
change in direction or contrast between ideas.
Adding Information: Markers such as "furthermore," "in addition," and "moreover" indicate that
more information is coming.
Expressing Cause and Effect: "Therefore," "thus," and "consequently" signal a cause-and-effect
relationship.
Sequencing Ideas: Discourse markers like "first," "next," and "finally" help structure ideas in a specific
order.
7.3 Transitions
7.3.1 Definition
Transitions are words, phrases, or sentences that bridge the gap between different parts of a text,
making the connections between ideas explicit. Unlike discourse markers, transitions can be whole
sentences or paragraphs. They serve a similar purpose by facilitating smooth transitions between
sections.
Additive Transitions: These transitions add information or ideas, such as "in addition" or
"furthermore."
Adversative Transitions: Adversative transitions express contrast or conflict, such as "however" or
"on the other hand."
Causal Transitions: Causal transitions indicate cause and effect, like "because," "therefore," and
"since."
Sequential Transitions: Sequential transitions show the order of events, such as "first," "next," and
"finally."
7.4 Coherence and Cohesion
Discourse markers and transitions contribute significantly to the coherence and cohesion of a text:
Coherence: Discourse markers and transitions help create a logical flow of ideas, ensuring that
readers or listeners can follow the connections between sentences and paragraphs.
Cohesion: These devices provide the grammatical and lexical connections necessary to link different
parts of the text, enhancing the text's overall cohesion.
7.5 Analyzing Discourse Markers and Transitions
In discourse analysis, examining the use of discourse markers and transitions is essential for
understanding how the text is structured and how ideas are interconnected. Analysis involves
identifying the types of markers or transitions used, their frequency, and their impact on the text's
overall coherence.
Summary
Discourse markers and transitions are essential tools for creating coherent and cohesive texts. They
help connect ideas, guide readers or listeners through a text, and provide structure. Understanding
the functions of these devices is key to effective discourse analysis.
Key Terms:
Discourse markers
Transitions
Coherence
Cohesion
Additive transitions
Adversative transitions
Causal transitions
Sequential transitions
Chapter 8: Coherence and Cohesion in Texts
Learning Objectives
By the end of this chapter, you will be able to:
Logical Progression: The ideas and information should follow a logical sequence, allowing readers or
listeners to follow the development of the text.
Consistency: A coherent text maintains consistent terminology, style, and tone throughout.
Relevance: All content in the text should be directly related to the topic or purpose, avoiding
irrelevant or off-topic information.
8.3 Cohesion in Texts
8.3.1 Defining Cohesion
Cohesion is the grammatical and lexical quality of a text that makes it flow smoothly. Cohesion
ensures that the sentences and paragraphs are connected in a way that is structurally sound and
linguistically cohesive. It helps prevent fragmentation and disjointedness.
Reference: The use of pronouns (e.g., "he," "she") and demonstratives (e.g., "this," "that") to refer
back to previously mentioned nouns, providing clarity and avoiding repetition.
Conjunctions: Words like "and," "but," "because," and "therefore" that link ideas, indicating
relationships between sentences and paragraphs.
Repetition: The strategic repetition of key words or phrases to reinforce important concepts.
8.4 Enhancing Coherence and Cohesion
Effective communication relies on the seamless integration of coherence and cohesion in texts. To
enhance these qualities, consider the following strategies:
Outline and Structure: Plan the organization of your text, ensuring a clear and logical progression of
ideas.
Transitions: Use transitional words and phrases to guide the reader or listener through your text and
indicate relationships between ideas.
Editing and Revision: Review your work for clarity, consistency, and relevance. Remove any content
that does not contribute to the central message.
8.5 Analyzing Coherence and Cohesion
In discourse analysis, it is important to analyze how coherence and cohesion are achieved in a text or
spoken discourse. Researchers examine the use of coherence and cohesion devices, their placement,
and their impact on the overall effectiveness of communication.
Summary
Coherence and cohesion are vital for effective communication in written and spoken discourse.
Coherence ensures that ideas are logically connected, while cohesion provides the linguistic and
structural links that make a text or discourse flow smoothly. Understanding and applying these
concepts is essential for producing clear and meaningful communication.
Key Terms:
Coherence
Cohesion
Logical progression
Consistency
Relevance
Reference
Conjunctions
Repetition
Week 5-6
Pragmatics in Discourse
Introduction
Pragmatics is the study of how language is used in context. It delves into the subtle nuances and
unwritten rules that govern language in conversation. In this chapter, we will explore the role of
pragmatics in discourse analysis, specifically in the context of language teaching at the college level.
Understanding pragmatics is crucial for effective communication in both native and non-native
speaker interactions.
What is Pragmatics?
Pragmatics is a subfield of linguistics that deals with the use of language in context. It goes beyond
the study of sentence structure and grammar to examine how people use language to achieve their
communicative goals. To understand pragmatics, it's essential to be familiar with some key concepts:
1. Speech Acts
Speech acts are the basic units of communication. They include assertives (statements of fact),
directives (requests, commands), commissives (promises, offers), expressives (expressing emotions),
and declaratives (making things happen by saying them, like pronouncing someone married).
Understanding speech acts is vital because they underpin all communicative interactions.
2. Grice's Maxims
Grice's Cooperative Principle suggests that people in conversation are generally cooperative, and
they follow four maxims:
Maxim of Quantity: Provide the right amount of information, neither too much nor too little.
Maxim of Quality: Say what you believe to be true based on your knowledge.
Maxim of Relation: Be relevant to the conversation.
Maxim of Manner: Be clear and avoid unnecessary complexity.
Understanding these maxims is crucial for interpreting what people really mean when they speak,
especially when they seem to be violating them.
Implicature
Implicature is the process by which listeners infer meaning beyond what is explicitly stated. For
instance, if someone says, "I have no money in my wallet," the implicature may be that they want to
borrow money from you. Implicatures can be cancellable – meaning they can be withdrawn or
altered during the conversation.
Politeness Strategies
Pragmatics helps us understand how politeness operates in conversation. Politeness strategies are
used to mitigate the potential threat to a person's face (their social identity and self-esteem).
Understanding these strategies, such as indirectness or hedging, is important for effective
communication.
Teaching Pragmatics
In a college language teaching setting, it's crucial to integrate pragmatics into the curriculum. Here
are some practical tips:
Explicit Instruction: Teach students about speech acts, implicature, and politeness strategies
explicitly. Explain how these concepts operate in real-world communication.
Role-Playing: Engage students in role-playing activities to practice using pragmatics in context. This
helps them experience real-life situations where pragmatics is crucial.
Contextual Analysis: Analyze real-world discourse examples in class. Break down conversations,
written texts, or media excerpts to highlight pragmatic elements.
Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Discuss how cultural norms and expectations impact pragmatics. Highlight
the differences between direct and indirect communication styles in various cultures.
Conclusion
Pragmatics is the key to unlocking the intricacies of real-world communication. Understanding
speech acts, implicatures, politeness strategies, and context is essential for effective discourse
analysis and language teaching. By incorporating pragmatics into the curriculum, college students can
become more proficient communicators, both in their native language and when learning a new one.
Locutionary Act: This is the actual utterance or sentence produced. For instance, saying "It's raining"
is a locutionary act.
Illocutionary Act: This is the intention behind the utterance – what you are trying to achieve with
your words. For instance, if you say "Pass the salt," your illocutionary act is a request.
Perlocutionary Act: This refers to the effect your utterance has on the listener. If the listener passes
the salt as a result of your request, the perlocutionary act has been successful.
Face: Face represents an individual's social identity and self-esteem. Face-threatening acts (FTAs) can
be minimized through politeness strategies, which help maintain positive interpersonal relationships.
Politeness Strategies: These include indirectness, hedging, mitigation, and redress. For instance,
when making a request, you might say, "Could you possibly pass me the salt?" (indirectness) to
minimize the threat to the other person's face.
Explicit Instruction: Teach students about the different types of speech acts and their corresponding
language structures.
Role-Playing: Engage students in role-playing exercises to practice using speech acts in context.
Real-Life Scenarios: Present authentic dialogues and situations where speech acts are used. Analyze
these situations in class.
Cross-Cultural Awareness: Highlight the differences in speech act usage across cultures. What may be
a polite request in one culture could come across as a command in another.
Pragmatic Competence: Encourage the development of pragmatic competence, which is the ability to
use language effectively in various social contexts.
Conclusion
Speech acts and communicative functions are integral to effective communication. They enable us to
perform various actions through language, from asserting facts to making requests and expressing
emotions. Understanding the nuances of speech acts and their relationship to politeness is crucial for
both discourse analysis and language teaching. By mastering these concepts, college students can
become more proficient and confident communicators in their target language.
Conversational Implicatures
Introduction
Conversational implicatures are a fascinating aspect of pragmatics and discourse analysis. They deal
with the hidden meanings and inferences that we make during conversations, often going beyond
what is explicitly stated. In this chapter, we'll explore conversational implicatures in depth, from their
basic concepts to their significance in language teaching for college students.
Understanding Implicatures
1. What Are Implicatures?
Conversational implicatures are a way that people convey additional meaning in their
communication. These implied meanings are not explicitly stated but are inferred by listeners based
on the context and the speaker's intentions.
3. Generalized Implicatures
Generalized implicatures occur when a statement is stronger than necessary. For instance, saying "I
have a few dollars" might generalize to "I don't have much money."
4. Particularized Implicatures
Particularized implicatures are more specific and context-dependent. They arise when a speaker
provides additional information that could have been left out. For example, "John ate some of the
cookies, and Mary ate some too" particularizes that each ate some of the cookies, but not necessarily
the same ones.
Explicit Instruction: Teach students about the concept of implicatures and provide examples of how
they work.
Contextual Activities: Engage students in activities that require them to identify implicatures in real-
world conversations or texts.
Practical Exercises: Encourage students to create and interpret sentences with implicatures. For
instance, they can practice producing sentences with scalar implicatures.
Cross-Cultural Awareness: Discuss how implicatures may vary across languages and cultures.
Emphasize the importance of context in understanding these subtleties.
Critical Thinking: Implicatures require critical thinking skills. Encourage students to analyze
conversations and texts for what is implied but not explicitly stated.
Conclusion
Conversational implicatures are an essential aspect of pragmatic language use. They reveal how
people communicate beyond the surface of their words, relying on context and shared knowledge.
For college students, grasping the intricacies of implicatures is valuable not only for understanding
real-world conversations but also for becoming more proficient and effective communicators in their
target language.
Positive Face: This is the desire for approval, appreciation, and social inclusion. Positive face wants to
be liked and valued by others.
Negative Face: This is the desire for autonomy and freedom from imposition. Negative face wants to
be unobtruded upon and free to make choices.
Polite Address: Using titles, honorifics, or terms like "sir" or "ma'am" to show respect.
Compliments: Praising or complimenting someone to make them feel valued.
Agreement: Agreeing with someone's opinions or suggestions to show support.
2. Negative Politeness Strategies
Negative politeness strategies aim to protect negative face by avoiding imposition or intrusion. These
strategies are employed to acknowledge and respect a person's desire for autonomy. Examples of
negative politeness strategies include:
Hedging: Using phrases like "I was wondering if..." to soften a request and show hesitancy.
Apologies: Apologizing for potential inconvenience or disruption, even if unintentional.
Indirectness: Expressing requests or suggestions indirectly to avoid being too direct or forceful.
Brown and Levinson's Politeness Theory
The most well-known framework for politeness is Brown and Levinson's Politeness Theory, which
introduces the concept of politeness strategies as face-saving acts. The theory emphasizes that
individuals choose their politeness strategies based on several factors:
How do interlocutors use politeness strategies to maintain or threaten each other's face?
How does politeness change according to the social context and relationships between interlocutors?
What implications do politeness strategies have on the overall success of the communication act?
Teaching Politeness Strategies
Integrating politeness strategies into language teaching at the college level is crucial for students to
become effective communicators. Here's how to do it:
Explicit Instruction: Teach students about the concept of politeness, positive and negative face, and
various politeness strategies.
Real-Life Scenarios: Present authentic dialogues and situations where politeness strategies are used.
Analyze these situations in class.
Cross-Cultural Awareness: Discuss how politeness norms and strategies may differ across cultures
and languages. Highlight the importance of cultural sensitivity.
Critical Analysis: Encourage students to critically analyze texts and conversations, identifying
politeness strategies used and their impact on communication.
Conclusion
Politeness strategies are a fundamental aspect of effective communication, especially in maintaining
positive interpersonal relationships. Understanding how people use these strategies to manage face
is vital in both discourse analysis and language teaching. College students can benefit significantly
from mastering politeness strategies, as it enables them to communicate effectively and respectfully
in a wide range of social contexts.
Week 7-8
Sociocultural Factors in Discourse
Introduction
Language is not just a system of words and grammar; it is deeply intertwined with the social and
cultural contexts in which it is used. Understanding sociocultural factors in discourse is essential for
both discourse analysis and language teaching. In this chapter, we will explore how culture, society,
and identity impact communication, and how this knowledge can be integrated into language
teaching for college students.
4. Contextual Variability
The same individual may adapt their communication style depending on the social context. They
might use one style of speech at home, another at work, and yet another when interacting with
peers. Understanding this contextual variability is vital for accurate discourse analysis.
In some Asian cultures, silence is valued as a form of politeness, while in Western cultures,
continuous talking is often seen as a sign of engagement.
Gendered language differences exist in various languages, with distinct vocabulary, speech patterns,
and politeness strategies for men and women.
In professional settings, specific jargon and formal language are used, reflecting the influence of the
workplace on communication.
Sociocultural Factors in Discourse Analysis
Discourse analysis involves studying language use in real-world contexts. When analyzing discourse,
consider the following sociocultural factors:
Speech Communities: Examine how language is used within particular communities, such as
academic, professional, or cultural groups.
Power Relations: Analyze the ways in which power dynamics are reflected in language use. Who has
the authority in a conversation, and how is it asserted or challenged?
Identity and Group Membership: Investigate how identity markers, such as age, gender, ethnicity, or
social class, influence language choices.
Norms and Values: Explore how cultural norms and values are reflected in the language and
communication style of a particular community or context.
Pragmatic Competence: Consider how well speakers navigate sociocultural factors, demonstrating
their ability to use language appropriately in different social contexts.
Cultural Sensitivity: Teach students about cultural norms and values in communication. Encourage
them to be culturally sensitive and adaptable in various social contexts.
Identity Awareness: Promote awareness of identity and group membership as they influence
communication. Discuss how language choices can vary based on identity markers.
Real-Life Scenarios: Use real-world examples and case studies to illustrate the impact of sociocultural
factors on communication.
Pragmatic Competence: Foster the development of pragmatic competence, enabling students to use
language effectively in diverse social settings.
Conclusion
Sociocultural factors play a significant role in shaping how people communicate and understand one
another. For college students, grasping the intricacies of these factors is essential for both discourse
analysis and effective language teaching. By integrating sociocultural awareness into their language
skills, students can become more culturally competent and proficient communicators, capable of
navigating diverse social contexts.
4. Contextual Variability
The same individual may adapt their communication style depending on the social context. They
might use one style of speech at home, another at work, and yet another when interacting with
peers. Understanding this contextual variability is vital for accurate discourse analysis.
Cultural Variation: In some Asian cultures, silence is highly valued as a form of politeness, while in
Western cultures, continuous talking is often seen as a sign of engagement.
Gendered Language Differences: Many languages have distinct vocabulary, speech patterns, and
politeness strategies for men and women. Understanding these differences is crucial for analyzing
gendered discourse.
Professional Jargon: In professional settings, specific jargon and formal language are used, reflecting
the influence of the workplace on communication.
Speech Communities: Examine how language is used within specific communities, such as academic,
professional, or cultural groups. Understand the language practices, values, and norms within these
communities.
Power Relations: Analyze how power dynamics are reflected in language use. Consider who has
authority in a conversation, how it is asserted, and how it affects communication.
Identity and Group Membership: Investigate how identity markers, such as age, gender, ethnicity, or
social class, influence language choices and communication styles.
Norms and Values: Explore how cultural norms and values are reflected in the language and
communication style of particular communities or contexts. Analyze how these norms and values
shape discourse.
Pragmatic Competence: Consider how well speakers navigate cultural and social influences in
communication. Assess their ability to use language appropriately in different social contexts.
Cultural Awareness: Teach students about cultural norms and values in communication. Encourage
them to be culturally sensitive and adaptable in various social contexts.
Identity Awareness: Promote awareness of identity and group membership as they influence
communication. Discuss how language choices can vary based on identity markers.
Real-Life Scenarios: Use real-world examples and case studies to illustrate the impact of cultural and
social influences on communication.
Pragmatic Competence: Foster the development of pragmatic competence, enabling students to use
language effectively in diverse social settings.
Conclusion
Cultural and social influences play a significant role in shaping how people communicate and
understand each other. For college students, grasping the intricacies of these influences is essential
for both discourse analysis and effective language teaching. By integrating cultural and social
awareness into their language skills, students can become more culturally competent and proficient
communicators, capable of navigating diverse social contexts.
Discourse Communities
What Are Discourse Communities?
A discourse community is a group of people who share a common interest, goal, or purpose and
communicate with one another through specific language practices. These communities can be
found in various domains, such as academia, professional fields, social networks, or even hobbyist
groups. Discourse communities have their own sets of rules, conventions, and language practices
that enable effective communication within the group.
Specialized Terminology: These communities often develop specialized terminology or jargon that
may not be easily understood by outsiders.
Communication Practices: Discourse communities have specific ways of communicating, which may
include formal or informal language, particular genres of communication, and styles of interaction.
Knowledge Sharing: They serve as platforms for knowledge sharing and collaboration, allowing
members to convey and exchange information within their field of interest.
Genres
What Are Genres?
A genre is a category or type of discourse characterized by a particular form, style, and content.
Genres are present in all aspects of written and spoken communication, from essays, letters, and
reports to conversations, interviews, and advertisements. Understanding genres helps us navigate
and create texts effectively.
Features of Genres
Form: Genres have a recognizable structure, format, and layout. For example, a research paper has a
specific structure with sections like introduction, methods, results, and conclusion.
Style: Each genre has a unique linguistic style, which includes vocabulary, tone, and rhetorical
devices. A formal report has a different style compared to a friendly email.
Content: Genres deal with specific content or subject matter. A news article, for instance, focuses on
reporting current events, while a short story centers on fictional narratives.
Purpose: Genres serve different communicative purposes. A job application letter aims to persuade
the employer to hire the applicant, while a recipe provides instructions for cooking.
Discourse Analysis
Studying Discourse
In discourse analysis, researchers examine how language is used in real-world contexts. They
investigate how discourse communities employ genres to communicate, share knowledge, and
achieve their goals. The analysis involves looking at the structural, linguistic, and rhetorical features
of texts.
Language Teaching
Integrating Discourse Communities and Genres
In language teaching, introducing students to the concepts of discourse communities and genres is
beneficial. Here's how these concepts can be integrated:
Genre-Based Writing: Teach students to recognize and use different genres, such as essays, reports,
and emails, in their writing tasks.
Discourse Communities: Discuss the idea of discourse communities in various fields and industries,
helping students understand the language and communication practices within these communities.
Practical Exercises: Engage students in analyzing real-world texts and identifying the genres used.
Encourage them to create texts in specific genres to address different communicative purposes.
Critical Analysis: Develop students' ability to critically analyze and adapt to the conventions of
different discourse communities and genres.
Research Projects: Encourage students to explore and write about discourse communities and genres
relevant to their academic or professional interests.
Conclusion
Discourse communities and genres are integral to understanding how language functions in diverse
contexts. By recognizing the roles these concepts play in communication, college students can
enhance their language proficiency and effectively navigate different discourse communities, genres,
and social contexts.
Power Relations: CDA focuses on how power is exercised through language. It examines how power
imbalances are constructed and maintained.
Language as Social Practice: Language is not just a tool for communication but a social practice
embedded in societal structures. CDA investigates the social context in which language is used.
Ideological Analysis: CDA explores the ideologies embedded in language, including how they
influence our perceptions and reinforce or challenge dominant beliefs.
Identify Discourses: Recognize the dominant discourses present in a text, and understand the
ideologies and power relations they reflect.
Language Strategies: Examine language strategies used, such as metaphors, framing, and lexical
choices, to assess how they shape the message.
Intertextuality: Analyze how a text relates to other texts and discourses, understanding the interplay
between different sources of meaning.
Contextual Analysis: Consider the broader social and historical context in which the text is situated,
as this provides insights into the motivations behind the discourse.
Practical Analysis
As students of language, analyzing specific texts and engaging in practical exercises will help them
grasp the concepts of CDA:
Critical Text Analysis: Provide students with diverse texts, such as political speeches, advertisements,
news articles, and social media posts, for analysis. Encourage them to identify power dynamics and
hidden ideologies.
Role-Playing: Engage students in role-playing exercises that involve taking on different discourse
positions. This helps them understand how language can be used to uphold or challenge dominant
discourses.
Media Literacy: Explore how CDA can be applied to develop media literacy skills. Encourage students
to critically analyze media content, discerning underlying ideologies and power structures.
Deconstruction of Bias: In writing assignments, ask students to critically assess and challenge biased
language and discourse within their chosen topics.
Language Teaching
CDA can also be a valuable tool in language teaching:
Critical Thinking: Promote critical thinking skills by encouraging students to question and analyze the
language they encounter in texts, helping them become more discerning consumers of information.
Multimodal Literacy: Explore how CDA can be applied to analyze visual, auditory, and digital modes
of communication, making students aware of the persuasive power of various media.
Debate and Discussion: Use CDA principles to facilitate debates and discussions in the classroom,
enabling students to critically engage with a wide range of topics.
Research Projects: Encourage students to undertake research projects that involve the critical
analysis of language use in specific contexts, empowering them to become active contributors to
critical discourse.
Conclusion
Critical Discourse Analysis is a valuable approach for analyzing language in its social and ideological
contexts. By introducing college students to CDA principles and engaging them in practical exercises
and discussions, educators can empower them to think critically, challenge prevailing ideologies, and
become more conscious and proficient users of language.