Understanding The Self-Lesson 1-4
Understanding The Self-Lesson 1-4
Socrates was a Greek Philosopher and one of the very few individuals who shaped Western
thoughts. However, unlike the other philosophers during his time, Socrates never wrote
anything. Knowledge about Socrates is through-second hand information from the writings of
his student Plato and historian Xenophon.
Socrates was known for his method of inquiry in testing an idea. This is called the Socratic
Method whereby an idea was tested by asking a series of questions o determine underlying
beliefs and the extent of knowledge to guide the person toward better understanding. Socrates
was described to have gone about in Athens questioning everyday views and popular Athenian
beliefs. This apparently offended the leaders in his time. He was then accused of impiety or lack
of reverence for the Gods and for corrupting the minds of the youth. At 70 years old, Socrates
was sentenced to death by drinking a cup of poison hemlock.
St. Augustine
~Also called St. Augustine of Hippo, is one of the Latin fathers of the church, one of the Doctors
of the church, and one of the most significant Christian thinkers. His philosophical approach to
Christian thinking is the most influential theological system. His written works are among the
foundations of medieval and modern Christian thought.
~He was deeply influenced by Plato's ideas. He adopted Plato's view that the self is an
immaterial (but rational) soul. Giving the Theory of Forms a Christian perspective, Augustine
asserted that these Forms were concepts exiting within the perfect and eternal God where the
soul belonged. Saint Augustine said that the soul held the truth and was capable of scientific
thinking.
~He also reasoned that human beings through the senses could sense the material, temporal
objects as we interacted with the material world; the immaterial but intelligible (def. able to
understood only by the intellect, not by the senses) God would only be clear or obvious to the
mind if one tune into his/her immaterial self/soul.
The aspect of the self/soul according to St. Augustine are;
• It is able to be aware of itself
• It recognizes itself a holistic one.
• It is aware of its unity
Saint Augustine believed that the human being who is both soul and body is meant to tend to
higher, divine, and heavenly matters because of his/her capacity to ascend and comprehend
truths through the mind.
Rene Descartes
A French philosopher, mathematician, and scientist. He is considered the Father of Modern
Western Philosophy. Descartes is often regarded as the first thinker to emphasize the use of
reason to describe, predict and understand natural phenomena based on observational and
empirical evidence.
~He proposed that doubt as a principal tool of disciplined inquiry. His method was called
hyperbolical/metaphysical doubt, also sometimes referred a methodological skepticism. It
is a systematic process of being skeptical about the truth of one's beliefs in order to determine
which beliefs could be ascertained as true.
~~"Cogito Ergo Sum" -"I think, therefore I am" became a fundamental element of western
philosophy as it secured the foundation for knowledge in the face of radical doubt. He asserted
that everything perceived by the senses could not be used as proof of existence because human
senses could be fooled. He added that there was only one thing we could be sure of this world,
and that was everything could be doubted. In turn, by doubting his own existence, Descartes
proved that there is thinking entity that is doing the act of doubting. Descartes' claims about the
self are:
It is constant; it is not prone to change; and it is not affected by time
• Only the immaterial soul remains the same throughout time
The immaterial soul is the source of our identity.
he further asserted that this thinking entity could exist without the body because it is an
immaterial ….
John Locke
~A philosopher and physician and was one of the most influential Enlightenment thinkers. The
Age of Enlightenment or the Age of Reason.
If Descartes describe the self as a thinking thing, Locke expanded this definition of self to include
the memories of that thinking thing. Locke believed that the self is identified with consciousness
and this self consists of sameness of consciousness. This usually interpreted to mean that the
self consists of memory; that the person existing now is the same person yesterday because
he/she remembers the thoughts, experiences, or actions of the earlier self.
A person's memories provide a continuity of experience that allows him/her to identify
him/herself as the same person over time. This theory of personal identity allows Locke to
justify a defense accountability.
The person is the same self in the passing time, he/she can be held accountable for past
behaviors. However, Locke insisted that a person could only be held accountable for behaviors
he/she can remember. Locke believe that punishing someone for behaviors he/she has no
recollection of doing is equivalent to punishing him/her for actions that was never performed.
David Hume
A Scottish philosopher, economist and historian during the age of Enlightenment. He was a
fierce opponent of Descartes's Rationalism. Rationalism is the theory that reason, rather that
experience, is the foundation of all knowledge. Hume alongside with John Locke ad bishop
George Berkeley, was one of the three main figureheads of the influential British Empiricism
movement. Empiricism is the idea that the origin of all knowledge is sense experience. It
emphasized the role of experience and evidence (especially sensory perceptions) in forming
concept, while discounting the notion of innate ideas.
Hume is identified with the bundle theory wherein he described the self or person (which He
assumed to be the mind) as a bundle /collection of a different perceptions that are moving in a
very fast and successive manner; it is in a perpetual flux. Hume's theory began by denying
Descartes' view of immaterial soul and of its experiences. Empiricists like Hume believed that
human intellect and experiences are limited; therefore, it is impossible to attribute it to an
independent persisting entity (i.e., soul). David Hume concluded that the self is merely made up
of successive impressions.
Hume divided the mind's perceptions into two groups stating that the difference between the
two "consists in the degrees of force and liveliness with which they strike upon the mind."
1. Impressions. These are the perceptions that are the most string. They enter the senses with
most force. Theses are directly experienced; they result from inward and outward sentiments.
2. Ideas. These are the less forcible and less lively counterparts of impressions. These are
mechanisms that copy and reproduce sense data formulated based upon the previously
perceived impressions.
Hume asserted that the notion of the self could not be verified through observation. For Hume,
the self was nothing but a series of incoherent impressions received by the senses. This
description of senses revealed, according to Hume, no permanently subsisting self.
Hume compared the self to a notion; whereby a nation retains its "being a nation" not by some
single core or identity but by being composed or different, constantly changing elements, such
as people, systems, culture and beliefs. In the same manner, the 'self' according to Hume is not
just one impression but mix and a loose cohesion of various personal experiences. Hume
insisted that there is no one constant impression that endures throughout your life.
Hume did not believe on the existence of the self. He stressed that your perceptions are only
active for a long as you are conscious. According to Hume, should your perception be removed
for any time (such as when you are sleeping), and you can no longer sense yourself then you also
cease to exist. In this line, Hume seemed to reduce the self as a light bulb that may be switched
on or off.
Hume's self is a passive observer similar to watching one's life pass before the eyes like a play or
on a screen; whereby the total annihilation of the self comes at death.
Immanuel Kant
A central figure in modern philosophy. His contributions to metaphysics, epistemology, ethics,
and aesthetics have had a profound impact on almost every philosophical movement that
followed him. Among other ideas that Kant proposed was that, the human mind creates the
structure of human experience.
Kant's view of the self is transcendental, which means the self is related to a spiritual and
nonphysical realm. For Kant, the self is not in the body. The self is outside the body, and it does
not have the qualities of the body. Despite being transcendental, Kant stressed that the body and
its qualities are rooted to the self. He proposed that it is knowledge that bridges the self and the
material things together.
Two kinds of consciousness of self (rationality):
1. Consciousness of oneself and one's psychological states in inner sense, and 2. Consciousness
of oneself and one's states y performing acts of apperception. Apperception is the material
process by which a person makes sense of an idea by assimilating it to the body or ideas he or
she already possesses.
Kant's point is that what truly exist are your ideas and your knowledge of your ideas; that you
perceived the outside world through the self with your ideas. Kant pointed out that the material
world is not just an extension, and that you are merely seeing objects. He insisted that you
perceived the outside world because there is already an idea residing within you. These ideas
are what connect you to the external world. He defended the diverse quality or state of the body
and soul (self) presenting that "bodies are objects of outer sense; souls are objects of inner
sense." Two components of the self.
1. Inner self. The self by which you are aware of alteration in your own state. This includes your
rational intellect and your psychological state, such a moods, feelings, and sensation, pleasure,
and pain.
2. Outer self. It includes your senses and the physical world it is the common boundary between
the external world and the inner self. It gathers information from the external world through the
senses, which the inner self interprets and coherently expresses.
Kant proposed that the self organizes information in three ways:
• Raw perceptual input
• Recognizing the concept
• Reproducing in the imagination
Kant's self has a unified point of self-reference you are conscious of yourself as the subject, and
you are conscious of yourself a common subject of different representations. Here Kant confirms
that the impressions you perceive point to one single common fact- the self is the subject of
these experiences.
~Modernization has significantly changed society, and this has affected how an individual build
and develop his or her self-identity. Pre-modern society was centered on survival.
Modernization, has improved people's living conditions. A person in the modern society is free
to choose where to live, what to do and who to be with. However, stability has also decreased as
traditions and traditional support systems, such as the family, have decreased in importance. In
modern societies, individualism is dominant, and developing one's self identity is central.
~Social network refers to the ties or connection that link you to your social group. the
connection your have in your barkada is your friendship; and the connection you have with your
classmates is the common interest to learn.
A social group is either organic or rational. An organic group is naturally occurring, and it is
highly influenced by your family. This is usually formed in a traditional society because there is
little diversity in these communities. Sociologist Georg Simmel stated that you join these groups
because your family is also part of it,. He called it Organic Motivation. The positive effect of
organic groups is rootedness. Gving the person a sense of belongingness. Organic group imply
less freedom and greater social conformity. You are expected to act and behave according to your
community's standards.
Rational groups occur in modern societies. Modern societies are made up of different people
coming from different places. The family in modern societies is not the main motivation when
joining rational social groups. Rational groups are formed as a matter of shared self-interest;
moreover, people join these group out of their free will. Simmel called this Rational Motivation.
Rational groups imply greater freedom, especially the freedom of movement.
Self as Representation
Ewing asserted that a self is illusory. People construct a series of self- representations that are
based on selected cultural concepts of person and selected chains of personal memories. Each
self-concept is experienced a whole and continuous, with its own history and memories that
emerged in the specific context to be replaced by another self-representation when the context
changes. By self-representation, Ewing meant culturally shaped self-concepts that one applies to
oneself; it is the mental entities that are supposed to represent the self.
"The self thus becomes aware of itself, at least in its practical action, and discovers itself as a
cause among other causes and as an object subject to the same laws as other objects."
- Jean Piaget
The Self as a Cognitive Construction
Psychology is the scientific study of how people behave, think, and feel. It includes topics, such
as how the brain works, how our memory is organized, how people interact in groups, and how
children learn about the world.
Psychologist Jean Piaget was a Swiss Clinical Psychologist known for his pioneering work in
child development. He pioneered the "Theory of Cognitive Development," a comprehensive
theory about the development of human intelligence. The theory deals with the nature of
knowledge itself; and how humans gradually come to acquire, construct, and use it.
False Self
Winnicott expressed that the false self is the product of early experience. It is a defensive
organization formed by the infant because of inadequate mothering or failures in empathy. He
added that the false self is developed as the infant is repeatedly subjected to maternal care that
intrudes upon, rejects or abandons his or her experience. The false self is also based on being
completely obedient to the parent's wishes. Winnicott asserted that when the child is constantly
expected to follow rules, a false self develops. The false self is a mask or a persona. It is a form
defense that constantly seeks to anticipate others' demands and complying with them, as a way
of protecting the true self from a world that is felt to be unsafe.
However, when the person has false self but can still function both as an individual and in the
society, then he or she has a healthy false self. The healthy false self feels that it is still connected
with the true self. Thus, it can be complaint without feeling guilty that it abandoned its
true self. On the other hand, there is also the unhealthy false self. An individual who may seem
happy and comfortable in his or her environment but actually feels forced to fit in and constantly
needs to adjust his or her behavior to adapt to the social situation is said to have an unhealthy
false self.
True Self
True self flourishes in infancy if the mother is positively responsive to the child spontaneous
expressions. Winnicott described true self as a sense of "self" based on "spontaneous authentic
experience." It is an awareness that bodily functions are working, such as the heart pumping, as
well as simply breathing. Moreover, true self, according to Winnicott (1960), is part of the infant
that feels creative, spontaneous, and real. It has a sense of being alive and real in one's mind and
body, having feelings that are spontaneous and unforced. This experience of aliveness is what
allows people to be genuinely close to others and to be creative. Winnicott believed that people
unconsciously repeat early relationships (particularly the mother-infant relationship) in one
form or another. A child whose mother is positively responsive and supports the child's natural
process of individuation will grow up as an adult with a stable self- image; views other people
realistically; and accepts both the positive and negative side of every person including
himself/herself.