NEW Final Paper
NEW Final Paper
NEW Final Paper
A Research Paper submitted to the Faculty of Social Work Department of South East
Asian Institute of Technology, Inc.
Submitted by:
Johnrey P. Bromeo
Jasmine Rose C. Camos
Daisy L. Lagsumal
SEPTEMBER 2023
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Juvenile delinquency has been a persistent issue in the United States. In 2017,
there were approximately 1,642,646 arrests involving individuals under 18 years old
(Snyder, Cooper, & Mulako-Wangota, 2017). While this number has declined somewhat
in recent years, it still accounts for roughly 9% of all arrests in the United States
(Puzzanchera & Kang, 2017). Another concerning aspect is the arrest rate. In 2014, 3,084
out of every 100,000 individuals aged 10 to 17 faced arrests, compared to 4,151 out of
every 100,000 individuals aged 18 and older (Puzzanchera & Kang, 2017). Once young
people become involved in the criminal justice system, many face a challenging life
marked by dropping out of school, a lack of employment skills, and deficits in other
essential prosocial abilities needed for a crime-free life. High rates of repeat offenses
illustrate this issue. Annually, approximately 630,000 individuals are released from
federal and state prisons (Carson, 2018). Around 44% of this group will be re-arrested
within the first year after release, and over 80% will be re-arrested within a decade (Alper
& Durose, 2018).
The Philippines' Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act currently sets the minimum age
of criminal responsibility (MACR) at 15 years old, offering a unique legal framework for
children in conflict with the law (CICL). Those under 15 are exempt from criminal
responsibility but may face civil liability and engage in intervention programs. However,
a proposed bill seeks to lower the MACR to "above 9 years old" due to concerns about
child exploitation by criminal groups, arguing that this change would deter such
exploitation. Opponents, including medical professionals, psychologists, human rights
advocates, and religious leaders, strongly object to the bill, citing concerns about
exposing younger children to coercion and peer pressure, given their incomplete brain
development. The Catholic Church supports rehabilitation over lowering the MACR,
advocating for improved law implementation and enhanced youth rehabilitation programs
to safeguard young offenders in the justice system.
The population of Tampakan grew from 10,731 in 1970 to 41,018 in 2020, an
increase of 30,287 people over the course of 50 years. The latest census figures in 2020
denote a positive growth rate of 0.78%, or an increase of 1,493 people, from the previous
population of 39,525 in 2015. Tampakan is politically subdivided into 14 barangays. In
2020 there are 15 cases of CICL in the Municipality, in 2021 an increase of 18 cases and
in 2022- 2023 the latest cases with the number of 21 CICL has been recorded in
Municipal social welfare agency Tampakan handle by ma’am Elsei Frugalidad, RSW
Children in conflict with the law. According to her those children in conflict with the law
has many factors that caused them become conflict with the law and we indicate those in
research objectives as our indicators.
Parental Care
Peer Pressure
Adolescents were incited apiece due to the dynamic construct of brain systems
easily and are involved in delinquent acts (Ciranka & van den Bos, 2019). The research
of Gruber and Fandakova (2021) indicated adolescents consisted of a high curiosity level
with surroundings. Adolescents’ sustainable brain development ameliorate the peer
influence and pressure into growth development. Development of ‘social brain’, and
other models stressed on the relatively slow maturation of cognitive control systems.
Adolescents were to be more influenced by peers due to the immaturity of cognitive
control system. Connection with delinquent peers paradoxically heightened the
probability of juvenile delinquency. Yusuf et al. (2021) evinced delinquent peer influence
promoted delinquent impulses. Out of curiosity, adolescents imitated the single same-
gendered unfamiliar peers’ risky decision-making, though the behavior is not likely to be
socially rewarded (Riedijk & Harakeh, 2017).The stress or strains spread by peers to
encourage the duplication of uncomfortable acts (Dhull & Beniwal, 2017) was
conspicuous in the generation. Adolescents’ actions and beliefs were shaped to align with
peers’ opinions and behaviors as a specific response to the pressure to further engage in
delinquent behaviors (Yusuf et al., 2021). Laursen and Baur (2022) claimed that
perceived gaps between peer-group norms and individual behavior guided the
adolescents’ future conformity behavior. The spread of delinquent peers’ cultures
normalized the peer group culture and inclination of committing juvenile delinquency. As
a coercive social contingency, peer rejection that elicited environmental response to the
adolescents’ behavior. People who were excluded and hurt against by peer members,
including overt forms of control, exclusion, and more subtle ways were inclined to the
group orders. In the experiment, Davis and Allen (2021) proved that social rejection by
peers acts as a social stressor that increases a tendency to react aggressively among
children. Yusuf et al (2021) further implicated the fear of isolation drove people to join a
peer group, and indulging in delinquent acts, especially the withdrawal from peers. The
time spent and attachment with peers contributed to the adolescents’ engagement of
delinquent acts. Considerable evidence supports the hypothesis that peer relationships
influence the growth of problem behavior in youth. Developmental research consistently
documents the high levels of co variation between peer and youth deviance, even
controlling for selection effects. Ironically, the most common public interventions for
deviant youth involve segregation from mainstream peers and aggregation into settings
with other deviant youth. Developmental research on peer influence suggests that desired
positive effects of group interventions in education, mental health, juvenile justice, and
community programming may be offset by deviant peer influences in these settings.
Given the public health policy issues raised by these findings, there is a need to better
understand the conditions under which these peer contagion effects are most pronounced
with respect to intervention foci and context, the child's developmental level, and specific
strategies for managing youth behavior in groups. Juvenile individuals undergo
significant physical, cognitive, and psychosocial growth, which makes them more
susceptible to influence from their social relationships (Fitzgerald et al., 2012). As
adolescents grow older, the influence of parents in their lives tends to diminish, with
peers taking on a more prominent role (Franjić, 2020; Kopf & Anderson, 2019). An
individual conceivably lingers longer time with peers plausibly influence individuals’
perceptions and involvement in juvenile delinquency (Utržan et al., 2018). Yu et al
(2021) and Ciranka et al (2019) agreed that the deviant peer influence may increase
delinquent behaviors and risk-taking behaviors. Opposingly, Desrosiers and colleagues
(2016) reported a delinquent act such as drug-usage began in humans’ early life,
delinquent acts were not related with peers’ existence in one’s life. Some researchers
claimed to collect more meticulous evidence for allowing greater confidence of the peer
influences (Yusuf et al., 2021). Past studies are limited to indicate ways of peer pressure
that would be perceived by adolescents in juvenile delinquency (Ramasamy et al., 2020).
Ukyawi et al. (2017) perception of peer pressure is an institution that influences students'
behavior by encouraging them to engage with wrongdoings that cause them to rebel. The
author said that peer pressure significantly impacts students as they see their peers as
someone they can look up to. It implies that peer pressure affects students based on who
they associate themselves with. The effect of peer pressure can reflect on how they want
to act. For instance, the study conducted by Ukyawi et al. (2017) determined that one of
the causes of substance abuse is peer pressure on students. The researchers discussed how
important it is to be associated with peers that would guide them to make better decisions
to improve their behavior. According to Mahmood et al. (2017) and Damm (2018), peer
pressure is defined as a subjective or actual experience of feeling pressured by others to
do things teens do not want to do. Although each author agrees that peer pressure can be
good and destructive, their perception focuses on the adverse effects on the child . This
could lead to a lot of impacts, including underachievement. Due to this information, the
authors found out that when pupils reach adolescence, they are likely to be exposed to
similar types of peer connections and similar peer pressures and levels of compliance.
Peer pressure can lead to psychological issues that hinder the growth of interpersonal
relationships. Peer pressure impacts children's relationships with their parents, family,
and society. Peer pressure affects their future, including their employment and marital
life. ACCAP (2018) and ReachOut (n.d.) states that peer pressure usually happens When
childn worry about fitting in with others. Peer groups' influence on how individuals think,
and act is referred to as "peer pressure." It can vary into various levels of the child's
peers. It can be seeking approval or one of the possible reasons for a child resulting in
bullying. The article also states that peer pressure is well-known for its negative
consequences, such as alcohol, smoking, and drugs. They determine how students are
impacted; it might be through their circle of friends, people they meet online, or any
social media platforms. However, the article also discussed that peer pressure's beneficial
side effects include a sense of belonging and support, as well as greater self-confidence.
Positive hobbies and interests are ntroduced, reinforcing positive behaviors and attitudes.
Meanwhile, it can result in the following adverse effects for a child: peer pressure to use
alcohol, cigarettes, or drugs, peer pressure to engage in risk-taking behaviors, a diversion
from academics, distancing between family and existing friends, and abrupt changes in
behavior and views.
Violence
Substance Abuse
Police civility
Surveillance Camera
Minors now account for most theft and robbery incidents all over the
world. The rise in juvenile criminality is a concern that needs to be addressed and
focused on. There were a lot of juvenile delinquent committed a crime that has been
caught and captured through CCTV cameras or surveillance camera. Minors now
account for most theft and robbery incidents in and most of them are alleged rugby
boys whose ages range from 11 to 17 years old (Cabagnot A. 2022).
An article entitled CCTV Security Cameras do they help fight crime
where stated that The UK has more CCTV camera coverage than any other country.
A recent study examined the effectiveness of UK security cameras as it pertains to
crime prevention. CCTV is clearly an effective deterrence to criminal activity.‖ It
was also stated that CCTV video is often used in police investigations and the writer
believes that most people are convinced of the effectiveness of video surveillance
and may even feel a certain amount of comfort in knowing that it adds to their sense
of personal safety and they understand that their chances of being a victim of crime
In relation to the present study, the researchers believe that CCTV is a very effective
tool to distinguish criminals and secure public places.
(Hester L. 201) The Advantages and Disadvantages published in Ezine Articles
stated that CCTV is highly useful for crime prevention as it increases the chance of
the perpetrator being caught, aiding police investigations, preventing theft from the
till,proving innocence by sense of protecting and defending the people in any
accusations, but CCTV does not always works in proper system. It could not display
every single square of your office, banks, stores, and other areas. Although you set
the location of the system in a very careful way, you still cannot get total guarantee
of security level. This article is related to the present study because it gives the
people the information that CCTV doesn‘t only have its advantages because at some
point it also has its disadvantages are reduced when they find themselves in an area
monitored with CCTV cameras.
Barangay Patrol
Conceptual Framework
Research Objectives
This study aims to identify the impact of children in conflict with the law to the
independents and the factors of why the children conflicting with the law in Tampakan
South Cotabato.
a. Age
b. Sex
c. Status
d. Educational attainment
2. To determine the impact of children in conflict with the law in terms of;
a. Parental care
b. Peer pressure
c. Violence
d. Substance abuse
a. Police civility
b. Surveillance Camera
c. Barangay Patrol
Ho: There is no significant relationship between the impact of children in conflict with
the law and the security and order of the residents of Tampakan South Cotabato.
This research focuses on Children in conflict with the law within Tampakan
South Cotabato. The study includes Children in conflict with the law or CICL aged 9-17
years old in accordance to Ma'am Elsie Frugalidad, RSW the Municipal social worker
and with the definition of juveniles under Philippine law. The research covers data from
2017-2023 providing a recent snapshot trends and experiences within this period. The
study employs quantitative surveys with CICL or children in conflict with the law.
Findings from this research may not be applicable to other municipality or barangay due
to specific geographical scope of Tampakan, south cotabato. The sample size of CICL
and other stakeholders in this study is relatively small, which may limit the generalization
of the findings to a larger population. Furthermore, on the level of participation of the
identified respondents in Tampakan South Cotabato, it would be limited for this school
year 2023-2024.
The findings and conclusions of this study are important to the local society since
they represent the lifestyle and morality of the society, particularly the youth. In the years
2021-2023, data from the project will raise awareness about juvenile delinquency in
Tampakan, South Cotabato. The findings from this study will specifically benefit the
following:
Municipal Social Welfare and Development. The MSWD would be alert on the
situation of the youth in the society especially on how the children adapt to
societal changes. They may support the children in confrontation with the law and
oversee them through proper intervention and discipline.
Parents. Parents would be aware of the current state of teenage criminality in the
community, allowing them to properly punish and guide their children.
Teachers. Educators may use the findings of this study to develop interventions and
programs to raise awareness and correct kids in order for them to prevent juvenile
delinquency and crime in the future.
Citizens. Citizens will be informed about the statistics of youngsters who have run afoul
of the law and will be driven to develop actions and initiatives that will assist
reduce juvenile delinquency rates.
Youth. This study would benefit young people by providing them with information
regarding children in conflict with the law. Furthermore, kids would be aware of
the potential consequences of committing a crime.
Future Researchers. Future researchers would like to investigate the case of children in
conflict with the law and could obtain solid data on this topic in Tampakan South
Cotabato, which would allow them to do more extensive data analysis.
CHAPTER II
METHODOLOGY
Research Design
The respondent of the study were the children in conflict with the law in
Tampakan South Cotabato . Respondents in this study were selected from the age group
of 9-17 years old, in accordance to MSWDO Tampakan Head ma’am Elsie Frugalidad
and with the definition in accordance of Children in conflict with the law (CICL) in our
jurisdiction. CICL who have had documented involvement with the juvenile justice
system, including formal charges or probationary periods are included. Both male and
female CICL are included and in conducting the survey we will obtain informed consent
from each CICL participants explaining the purpose and procedures of the study in age
appropriate language. This will also secure consent from the social worker and the legal
guardians or parents of respondents ensuring they understand the research implications.
The total known population of CICL case in tampakan is 68 and we've decided to use 5%
margin of error.
Slovens Formula:
n= N
1 + Ne 2
n= 68
1+68x(0.05¿2
n= 68
1+68 x 0.0025
n= 68
1+ 1.17
n= 68
2.17
Research Instruments.
Scale Interpretation
5 Strongly Agree
4 Agree
3 Undecided
2 Disagree
1 Strongly Disagree
The researchers gather data through a step by step proceedings. Step 1, the
researchers prepared a letter from the research instructor to be given in the respective
agencies they need to gather the data. Step 2, the researcher deliver the letter to the
designated agencies that they need to gather data and ask for a permission to collect data.
Step 3, there after the researchers will prepare the survey questionnaires and questions for
the both agencies and respondents. Step 4, after preparing the questionnaires the
researchers then start gathering data through distributing the survey questionnaire to the
respondents and conducting the interview to the agency. Step 5, after the agency
interview and the respondents answer the survey questionnaire, the researchers will
collect and gather the data that is needed for the study. Step 6, after the researchers
gathers the data from the respondents, the researchers will analyze the data and make a
conclusion.
Data Analysis.
Formula:
P= F x 100
N
Where:
P= Percentage
F= Frequency
N= Number of respondents
2. Ranking
This is a relationship between a set of items, the first is either
ranked higher than', 'ranked lower than' or 'ranked equal to the second.
3. Weighted mean
This was utilized in treating the answer on the impact of
children in conflict wit the law.
Formula:
WM = ∑fw
N
Where:
WM = weighted mean
Fw = sum of the products of the frequency & weight f = frequency
w = weight
n= number of the respondents
Verbal Description
4.50 – 5.00 Very High extent (VHE)
3.50 – 4.49 High Extent (HE)
2.50 – 3.49 Moderate Extent (ME)
1.59 – 2.49 Low Extent (LE)
1.00 – 1.49 Very Low Extent (VLE)
Ethical Considerations.
Part II: Factors that caused Children in conflict with the law
3- Undecided
A. Parental Care
Indicators 5 4 3 2 1
Indicators 5 4 3 2 1
C. Violence
Indicators 5 4 3 2 1
D. Substance Abuse
Indicators 5 4 3 2 1