DoD Ammunition Safety Standards
DoD Ammunition Safety Standards
MANUAL
NUMBER 6055.09-M, Volume 6
February 29, 2008
Administratively Reissued August 4, 2010
Incorporating Change 1, August 31, 2011
USD(AT&L)
V6.1. PURPOSE
V6.1.1. Manual. This Manual is composed of several volumes, each containing its own
purpose, and administratively reissues DoD 6055.09-STD (Reference (a)). The purpose of the
overall Manual, in accordance with the authority in DoD Directives 5134.01 and 6055.9E
(References (b) and (c)), is to establish explosives safety standards (hereafter referred to as
“standards”) for the Department of Defense.
V6.1.1.1. These standards are designed to manage risks associated with DoD-titled
ammunition and explosives (AE) by providing protection criteria to minimize serious injury, loss
of life, and damage to property.
V6.1.1.2. Due to the size and complexity of this Manual, alternate paragraph numbering
has been approved for use throughout. The initial numeric set (V#) refers to the volume number
within the Manual; the second set (E#) refers to the enclosure number; and subsequent numbers
refer to the section, paragraph, and subparagraph numbers. If there is no E#, the reference is to a
section above the signature of the volume.
V6.1.2. Volume. This Volume provides criteria for contingency operations, toxic chemical
munitions and agents, and risk-based siting.
V6.2.1.1. OSD, the Military Departments, the Office of the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs
of Staff and the Joint Staff, the Combatant Commands, the Office of the Inspector General of the
DoDM 6055.09-M-V6, February 29, 2008
Department of Defense, the Defense Agencies, the DoD Field Activities, and all other
organizational entities within the Department of Defense (hereafter referred to collectively as the
“DoD Components”).
V6.2.1.3. DoD personnel and property when potentially endangered by known host-
nation or off-installation AE hazards.
V6.2.1.4. DoD facilities siting and construction, except as indicated in paragraph V6.2.2.
V6.2.2. Provided the documentation requirements of paragraph V6.E2.3.5. are met, does not
apply to:
V6.2.2.2. Those planned facilities that do not meet these standards, but have been
certified by the Heads of the DoD Components (see section V1.E3.4.) as essential for operational
or other compelling reasons.
V6.2.2.3. Other situations that, upon analysis by the Heads of the DoD Components and
the Department of Defense Explosives Safety Board (DDESB), are determined to provide the
required degree of safety through use of protective construction or other specialized safety
features.
V6.3. DEFINITIONS
Change 1, 08/31/2011 2
DoDM 6055.09-M-V6, February 29, 2008
V6.4. POLICY. As established in Reference (c) and consistent with peacetime, contingency, or
wartime operational requirements and corresponding DoD military munitions requirements from
the broadest and most fundamental explosives safety management perspective, it is DoD policy
to:
V6.4.1. Provide the maximum possible protection to people and property from the potential
damaging effects of DoD military munitions (explosive and chemical). Applying the standards
herein provides only the minimum protection criteria for personnel and property, and greater
protection should always be provided when practicable.
V6.4.2. Minimize exposures consistent with safe and efficient operations (i.e., expose the
minimum number of people for the minimum time to the minimum amount of explosives or
chemical agents (CAs)).
V6.6. PROCEDURES. See Enclosures 3 through 5. Criteria provided in this Manual are given
in English units (e.g., foot or feet (ft), pounds (lbs), pounds per square inch (psi)), with metric
equivalents shown in brackets (e.g., meters (m), kilograms (kg), kilopascals (kPa)).
V6.7. RELEASABILITY. UNLIMITED. This Volume is approved for public release and is
available on the Internet from the DoD Issuances Website at http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives.
V6.8. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Volume is effective upon its publication to the DoD Issuances
Website.
Enclosures
1. References
2. Responsibilities
3. Contingencies, Combat Operations, Military Operations Other Than War (MOOTW), and
Associated Training
4. Toxic Chemical Munitions and Agents
5. Risk-Based Siting
Glossary
Change 1, 08/31/2011 3
DoDM 6055.09-M-V6, February 29, 2008
TABLE OF CONTENTS
GENERAL .................................................................................................................................8
RISK MANAGEMENT.............................................................................................................9
SITE PLAN PROCESS .............................................................................................................9
QD CRITERIA FOR CONTINGENCIES, COMBAT OPERATIONS, MOOTW, AND
ASSOCIATED TRAINING ..............................................................................................12
SCOPE .....................................................................................................................................37
RISK-BASED SITING TOOL ................................................................................................37
RISK-BASED SITE PLANNING REQUIREMENTS ...........................................................37
RISK-BASED EXPLOSIVES SAFETY SITE PLAN DOCUMENTATION
REQUIREMENTS.............................................................................................................38
RISK-BASED EXPLOSIVES SAFETY SITE PLAN REVIEW REQUIREMENTS............39
QUANTITATIVE RISK MANAGEMENT COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS .........................40
EQUIVALENT RISK-BASED ANALYSIS TOOL ...............................................................40
GLOSSARY ..................................................................................................................................41
TABLES
ENCLOSURE 1
REFERENCES
(a) DoD 6055.09-STD, “DoD Ammunition and Explosives Safety Standards,” February 29,
2008 (cancelled by Volume 1 of this Manual)
(b) DoD Directive 5134.01, Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and
Logistics (USD(AT&L)),” December 9, 2005
(c) DoD Directive 6055.9E, “Explosives Safety Management and the DoD Explosives Safety
Board,” August 19, 2005
(d) Military Standard MIL-STD-882D, “Standard Practice for System Safety,” February 10,
2000
(e) Department of Defense Explosives Safety Board Technical Paper 10, Change 3,
“Methodology for Chemical Hazard Prediction,” June 1980
(f) U.S. Army Chemical Research Development and Engineering Center Publication (Report
No. CRDEC-TR-87021, Government Accession No. A-177-622), “Personal Computer
Program For Chemical Hazard Prediction (D2PC),” January 1987 1
(g) DoD Instruction 6055.1, “DoD Safety and Occupational Health (SOH) Program,”
August 19, 1998
(h) DoD Instruction 6055.05, “Occupational and Environmental Health (OEH),” November 11,
2008
(i) U.S. Army Armament and Research Development Command Publication (Contractor
Report No. ARLCD-CR-80049, Government Accession No. A-095-040), “Engineering
Guide for Fire Protection and Detection Systems at Army Ammunition Plants, Volume I,
Selection and Design,” December 198012
(j) Department of Defense Explosives Safety Board Technical Paper 19, Revision 1, “User’s
Reference Manual for the Safety Assessment for Explosives Risk Software,” July 21, 2009
(k) Department of Defense Explosives Safety Board Technical Paper 14, Revision 4,
“Approved Methods and Algorithms for DoD Risk-Based Explosives Siting,” July 21,
2009
1
Available on the Internet at
http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA177622&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf
12
Available on the Internet at
http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA095040&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf
ENCLOSURE 2
RESPONSIBILITIES
V6.E2.2. CHAIRMAN, DDESB. The Chairman, DDESB, shall report to the Deputy Under
Secretary of Defense for Installations and Environment (DUSD(I&E)) and, on behalf of the
USD(AT&L) and the DUSD(I&E), shall collaborate with the Military Service-appointed voting
DDESB members to maintain explosives safety standards.
V6.E2.3. HEADS OF THE DoD COMPONENTS. The Heads of the DoD Components shall:
V6.E2.3.2. Comply with applicable Federal and State laws and regulations. Where this
Volume conflicts with such laws and regulations, ensure the safety of DoD personnel and the
public while complying and notify the Chairman, DDESB, through the Component’s board
member, of the conflict. These standards are not intended to be so rigid as to prevent the DoD
Components from accomplishing their assigned missions.
V6.E2.3.3. Issue DoD Component guidance that implements these standards and provides
DoD Component unique requirements.
V6.E2.3.4. Send a copy of any implementing and supplementary guidance to these standards
to the Chairman, DDESB.
V6.E2.3.5.1. The effective date the applicable DoD explosives safety standards were
first published.
V6.E2.3.5.2. The date the deviant facility was either approved, from an explosives safety
viewpoint, for use or was first used in a manner deviating from the standard.
ENCLOSURE 3
V6.E3.1. GENERAL
V6.E3.1.1. This enclosure provides the minimum criteria for contingencies, combat
operations, MOOTW, and associated training. Full compliance with other enclosures of this
Volume, as well as other volumes of this Manual, may not be possible during such operations.
The DoD Components may establish implementing regulations that are more protective than
these standards. In situations involving combined or joint operations, the Commanders of the
Combatant Commands or the U.S. commander of a joint task force (JTF) shall designate the
DoD Component’s explosives safety criteria to be used.
V6.E3.1.3. This enclosure provides optional criteria and risk management tools not available
elsewhere in this Manual. These optional criteria provide greater protection (asset preservation
distance) for assets deemed sufficiently critical to warrant the greater protection, and, in some
circumstances, provide lesser protection (minimum separation distance) for those assets for
which the mission requirements outweigh the increased risk to those assets.
V6.E3.1.3.1. Asset Preservation Distance. At this distance from the potential explosion
site (PES), assets at the exposed site (ES) are expected to be usable and mission capability is
maintained following an incident. This separation distance should prevent propagation between
PESs. (See subparagraphs V1.E8.2.5.5. and V1.E8.2.5.6. for expected consequences for these
separation distances.)
V6.E3.1.3.2. Minimum Separation Distance. At this distance from the PES, mission
capability will likely be impaired or delayed. This separation distance should prevent prompt
V6.E3.2. RISK MANAGEMENT. Risks associated with AE shall be managed consistent with
operational requirements (see section V6.4.). Exceptions to this enclosure’s criteria are where
equivalent protection is provided or where a risk analysis is performed, as follows:
V6.E3.2.2.1. An event analysis to identify and describe possible events such as the
location, type of occurrence, probability of occurrence, and quantity of explosives.
V6.E3.2.2.2. An effects analysis of the effects of the possible events to persons in the
surroundings such as blast pressure, fragmentation, and thermal hazards.
V6.E3.2.2.3. An exposure analysis of the places, protection, and time history of exposed
personnel in the hazardous areas.
V6.E3.3.1. Site Approval. All explosives locations falling within the scope of this enclosure
shall be approved by the applicable commander or by the DDESB as outlined in subparagraphs
V6.E3.3.2.1.2., V6.E3.3.2.2.2., V6.E3.3.2.3.2., and V6.E3.3.2.4.2., and paragraph V6.E3.3.4.
Site plan packages shall be submitted for:
V6.E3.3.1.1.2. Holding areas (e.g., basic load ammunition holding areas (BLAHAs),
flight-line holding areas, port and railhead holding areas, and marshalling areas).
V6.E3.3.1.1.5. Combat aircraft parking areas (CAPAs) and cargo aircraft parking
areas.
V6.E3.3.1.1.7. Locations used for the treatment or disposal (e.g., open burn or open
detonation) of munitions. Exceptions are those locations used in an emergency response for
burning excess propellant resulting from munitions use during training, and those involved in
direct combat operations.
V6.E3.3.2. Documentation Requirements. The operational situation and the type and
duration of the AE operations conducted at the site or facility determine the type of
documentation required for a site approval. These categories of operations apply:
V6.E3.3.2.1. Permanent
V6.E3.3.2.2. Recurrent
V6.E3.3.2.3. Temporary
V6.E3.3.3. Site Plan Packages. See section V1.E5.1. for the requirements, with these
additions:
V6.E3.3.3.3. A copy of the risk analysis performed by the DoD Component, if one was
performed, to demonstrate equivalent protection.
V6.E3.3.4. Approval Authority for Waivers and Exemptions. The Commander of the
Combatant Command, the U.S. commander of a JTF, or the DoD Component commander may,
for strategic and other compelling reasons, authorize waivers to the explosives safety standards
contained herein for the planning or conduct of contingencies, combat operations, and MOOTW.
All waivers shall be coordinated with the host nation, as required, and consistent with
international agreements.
V6.E3.3.4.2.1. A risk analysis for the proposed operation weighing the need to
conduct the operation and violate the standards against the potential effect of an accident (e.g.,
mission impact, loss of resources, turnaround times).
V6.E3.3.4.2.2. A timeline listing milestones that shall eliminate the need for the
waiver or exemption.
V6.E3.4.1. BLAHA
V6.E3.4.1.1. General. To fulfill their missions, certain units must keep their basic load
ammunition in armored vehicles, trucks, trailers, and structures or on pads. This involves
acceptance of greater risks to unit personnel, facilities, and equipment than permitted by other
volumes of this Manual. The concept of BLAHA storage may also be used to provide QD
separations during mobile operations. A basic load storage area (BLSA) is a location containing
multiple BLAHAs.
V6.E3.4.1.2.1. Net explosive weight for quantity-distance (NEWQD) for use with
BLAHA QD criteria shall be determined as follows:
V6.E3.4.1.2.1.2. The sum of the explosive weight of all HD 1.2 AE shall be used.
The propellant weight of an HD 1.2 item (if present) may be disregarded.
V6.E3.4.1.2.3. QD Computations
a D1 is used for:
1. Side-to-side, side-to-rear, and rear-to-rear exposures between undefined ECMs, provided the earth
cover complies with paragraph V2.E5.5.3. and the explosives are stored at least 3 ft [1 m] from the end of the
ECM.
2. Non-armored vehicle (PES) to non-armored vehicle (ES) when an adequate barricade IAW section
V2.E5.4. is located between them.
3. Light armored vehicle (PES) to non-armored vehicle (ES) when an adequate barricade IAW section
V2.E5.4. is located between them.
4. Light armored or non-armored vehicle (PES) to light armored vehicle (ES) when an adequate barricade
IAW section V2.E5.4. is located between them.
5. Determining D1 and NEWQD for D1:
English Equations (EQNs) (NEWQD in lbs, D1 in ft)
D1 = 2*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-1
NEWQD = (D1/2)3 with a maximum of 8,818 lbs EQN V6.E3.T1-2
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D1 in m)
D1 = 0.79*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-3
NEWQD = (D1/0.79)3 with a maximum of 4,000 kg EQN V6.E3.T1-4
b D2 is used for:
1. Front-to-front exposures involving undefined ECMs when there is an adequate barricade (section
V2.E5.4.) at the ES.
2. Non-armored or light armored vehicles to the side or rear of an undefined ECM.
3. Determining D2 and NEWQD for D2:
English EQNs (NEWQD in lbs, D2 in ft)
D2 = 6*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-5
NEWQD = (D2/6)3 with a maximum of 8,818 lbs EQN V6.E3.T1-6
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D2 in m)
D2 = 2.38*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-7
NEWQD = (D2/2.38)3 with a maximum of 4,000 kg EQN V6.E3.T1-8
c D3 is used for:
1. Non-armored vehicles to non-armored vehicles without an adequate barricade.
2. Light armored vehicles to non-armored vehicles without an adequate barricade at the non-armored
vehicles.
3. Undefined ECM to undefined ECM when positioned front-to-front and no barricade is present.
4. Non-armored vehicles, light armored vehicles, or undefined ECM to the front of undefined ECM when
no barricade is present at the ES.
5. Determining D3 and NEWQD for D3:
English EQNs (NEWQD in lbs, D3 in ft)
D3 = 12*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-9
NEWQD = (D3/12)3 with a maximum of 8,818 lbs EQN V6.E3.T1-10
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D3 in m)
D3 = 4.76*NEWQD1/3 EQN V6.E3.T1-11
NEWQD = (D3/4.76)3 with a maximum of 4,000 kg EQN V6.E3.T1-12
d D4 is used for:
1. Public traffic route distance (PTRD) from non-armored and light armored vehicles.
2. Determining D4 and NEWQD for D4:
English EQNs (NEWQD in lbs, D4 in ft)
NEWQD < 5,500 lbs: D4 = 591 ft
5,500 lbs < NEWQD < 8,818 lbs: D4 = 8*NEWQD1/2 EQN V6.E3.T1-13
D4 < 591 ft: NEWQD = 0 lbs
591 ft < D4 < 751 ft: NEWQD = (D4/8)2 with a maximum of 8,818 lbs EQN V6.E3.T1-14
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D4 in m)
NEWQD < 2,495 kg: D4 = 180 m
2,495 kg < NEWQD < 4,000 kg: D4 = 3.62*NEWQD1/2 EQN V6.E3.T1-15
D4 < 180 m: NEWQD = 0 kg
180 m < D4 < 229 m: NEWQD = (D4/3.62)2 with a maximum of 4,000 kg EQN V6.E3.T1-16
e D5 is used for:
1. Inhabited building distance (IBD) from non-armored and light armored vehicles.
2. Determining D5 and NEWQD for D5:
English EQNs (NEWQD in lbs, D5 in ft)
NEWQD < 5,500 lbs: D5 = 886 ft
5,500 lbs < NEWQD < 8,818 lbs: D5 = 12.2*NEWQD1/2 EQN V6.E3.T1-17
D5 < 886 ft: NEWQD = 0 lbs
886 ft < D5 < 1,146 ft: NEWQD = (D5/12.2)2 with a maximum of 8,818 lbs EQN V6.E3.T1-18
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D5 in m)
NEWQD < 2,495 kg: D5 = 270 m
2,495 kg < NEWQD < 4,000 kg: D5 = 5.43*NEWQD1/2 EQN V6.E3.T1-19
D5 < 270 m: NEWQD = 0 kg
270 m < D5 < 343.4 m: NEWQD = (D5/5.43)2 with a maximum of 4,000 kg EQN V6.E3.T1-20
f D6 is used for:
1. Determining the IBD and PTRD from heavy armored vehicles. When NEWQD exceeds 331 lbs [150 kg]
the IBD and PTRD specified in Volumes 3, 4, and 5 apply.
2. Determining D6 and NEWQD for D6:
English EQNs (NEWQD in lbs, D6 in ft)
NEWQD < 110 lbs: D6 = 66 ft
110 lbs < NEWQD < 331 lbs: D6 = -4.49 + 0.487*(NEWQD1/3) + EQN V6.E3.T1-21
2.928*(NEWQD1/3)2
D6 < 66 ft: NEWQD = 0 lbs
66 ft < D6 < 138 ft: NEWQD = (0.0833 + [1.5421 + 0.3416*D6]1/2)3 EQN V6.E3.T1-22
Metric EQNs (NEWQD in kg, D6 in m)
NEWQD < 50 kg: D6 = 20 m
50 < NEWQD < 150 kg: D6 = -1.37 + 0.193*(NEWQD1/3) + EQN V6.E3.T1-23
1.512*(NEWQD1/3)2
D4 < 20 m: NEWQD = 0 kg
20 m < NEWQD < 42.3 m: NEWDQ = (0.0640 + [0.9108 + 0.6615*D6]1/2)3 EQN V6.E3.T1-24
From Î
Heavy Light Non-Armored
To Ð
Heavy (IMD Exposure) IMD Not Required IMD Not Required IMD Not Required
Light (IMD Exposure) IMD Not Required D1 from V6.E3.T1 D1 from V6.E3.T1
Non-Armored (IMD Exposure) IMD Not Required D3 from V6.E3.T1 D3 from V6.E3.T1
IBD Exposure D6 from V6.E3.T1 D5 from V6.E3.T1 D5 from V6.E3.T1
PTRD Exposure D6 from V6.E3.T1 D4 from V6.E3.T1 D4 from V6.E3.T1
a Application of D1 distance may require the use of a barricade between PES and ES. Refer to Table
V6.E3.T1. footnotes regarding the need for a barricade.
b For asset preservation, rather than using D1 and D3, use one of these equations:
English EQNs (W in lbs, d in ft)
d = 24*W1/3 EQN V6.E3.T2-1
d = 30*W1/3 EQN V6.E3.T2-2
Metric EQNs (Q in kg, d in m)
d = 9.52*Q1/3 EQN V6.E3.T2-3
d = 11.90*Q1/3 EQN V6.E3.T2-4
V6.E3.4.2. Ports. The following criteria shall apply to ports where DoD AE is loaded or
unloaded.
V6.E3.4.2.2.1. ILD (K18 [7.14]) shall be provided between the explosives loading or
unloading section of the anchorage and the loaded ship section of the explosives anchorage (see
Figure V4.E4.F12.).
V6.E3.4.2.3. AE Facilities
V6.E3.4.2.3.3. Loading Docks. Loading docks shall be sited at IMD (K11 [4.36])
from all ESs.
V6.E3.4.3. Field Storage and Handling Areas. These areas shall be sited IAW Table
V6.E3.T3. Use separation distances from the applicable QD tables in Volumes 3 and 5 for the
HD and NEWQD of the AE involved with the PES. AE will be segregated IAW Volume 1,
Enclosure 6, by storage compatibility group. The clear zone surrounding the field storage and
handling areas is bounded by the applicable IBD. No unrelated, occupied structures are
permitted within this clear zone.
V6.E3.4.3.1. Explosives Locations. These areas may consist of all or some of these
explosives locations:
V6.E3.4.3.1.1. Field Storage Sections. These sections are used to store AE. Field
storage sections are used for dispersing AE in multiple, widely separated storage sections to
prevent the loss of any one section from causing the loss of other sections, thereby seriously
degrading the mission. AE may be stored in existing structures, caves, and tunnels as prescribed
in Volumes 3, 4, and 5. The construction and use of barricades and revetments shall be IAW
Volume 2.
V6.E3.4.3.1.2. AE Staging Area. These areas are normally used for temporary
holding of outgoing AE and for ready access to combat aircraft loading areas.
V6.E3.4.3.2. Non-explosives Locations. These areas may consist of all or some of these
non-explosives locations:
Captured
From Î AE AE
Storage AE Staging Enemy Sling Out
Operations Destruction
Sections Area Ammunition Area
To Ð Area Area
Area
IMD IMD PTRDc IMD IMD Footnote d
Storage Sections c
Footnote b Footnote b PTRD Footnote b Footnote b
c
IMD IMD PTRD IMD IMD
AE Staging Area c
Footnote b Footnote b PTRD Footnote b Footnote b
Captured Enemy IMD IMD IMD IMD IMD
Ammunition Area Footnote b Footnote b PTRDc Footnote b Footnote b
AE Operations IMD IMD PTRDc IMD IMD
Area Footnote b Footnote b PTRDc Footnote b Footnote b
Not
Not Required PTRDc IMD IMD
Sling-Out Area Required
Footnote b Footnote b PTRDc Footnote b Footnote b
c c c c
Administrative and IBD IBD IBD IBD IBDc
Billeting Area IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc
IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc
Boundaries
IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc IBDc
Manned Non- ILD ILD IBDc ILD ILD
Explosive Support
Facility Footnote b Footnote b IBDc Footnote b Footnote b
Unmanned Non- Not Not Not
Not Required PTRDc
Explosive Support Required Required Required
Facility Footnote b Footnote b PTRDc Footnote b Footnote b
AE Destruction
Footnote d
Area
a The distance criteria in the upper half of each row are the minimum separation distances required by
Volumes 3, 4, and 5. The distance criteria in the lower half of each row are the asset preservation
distances.
b 1. For HD 1.1 material, use one of these equations:
English EQNs (W in lbs, d in ft)
d = 24*W1/3 EQN V6.E3.T3-1
d = 30*W1/3 EQN V6.E3.T3-2
Metric EQNs (Q in kg, d in m)
d = 9.52*Q1/3 EQN V6.E3.T3-3
d = 11.90*Q1/3 EQN V6.E3.T3-4
2. For HD 1.2, 1.3, or 1.4, apply PTRD from Volumes 3, 4 and 5.
c Includes minimum fragment distance.
d IAW Volume 5, Enclosure 3.
V6.E3.4.4. FARP. Storing AE and fuel at the same location is inherently hazardous and
should be avoided when possible. If it is necessary to refuel and rearm aircraft at the same
location, all precautions must be made to minimize the hazards involved in these operations.
Armament pads shall contain the minimum amount of AE to conduct efficient operations. For
example, where armament pads support only one aircraft, that pad shall be restricted to the
amount of ammunition necessary to rearm that aircraft. Required separations are:
V6.E3.4.4.1. Use K24 [9.52] for asset preservation between FARPs and other ESs.
V6.E3.4.4.3. AE-ready storage (i.e., AE staged to support the next load) shall be
separated by AGM IMD from the armament pads with only armament pads considered as the
PES. Ready AE storage structures and locations shall be separated from other ready AE storage
structures and locations by AGM IMD.
V6.E3.4.4.4. Build-up locations shall be separated by AGM IMD from all other
explosives storage and operations with only the build-up locations considered as the PES.
V6.E3.4.4.5. Distances prescribed by the owning DoD Component shall separate other
support structures and sites.
V6.E3.4.4.6. AE shall be separated from operational fuel supplies by at least 100 ft [30.5
m]. Fuel supplies shall be diked or placed downhill from AE.
V6.E3.4.5. Airfield Operations. Special consideration must be given to phased plans where
the peacetime operation and positioning of aircraft transitions to contingency operations with
increased quantities and use of AE. Exposures given adequate protection under the peacetime
phase may be at greater risk during the contingency phase. Commanders must consider these
changes when approving these plans. The proper use of such features as barricades or earth-
filled, steel-bin-type barricades (ARMCO, Inc., revetment or equivalent (see section V2.E5.4.))
can decrease the magnitude of a potential event and increase the explosives capacity of limited
areas.
V6.E3.4.5.1. Airfield QD Criteria for PESs. Table V6.E3.T4. provides criteria for
airfield PESs.
V6.E3.4.6. Static Missile Battery Separation. To ensure optimal effectiveness, offensive and
defensive missile batteries many times must be deployed in a static (non-mobile) role in the
proximity of other AE operations such as field storage or flight lines. These criteria apply to
deployed static missile batteries and associated support functions:
V6.E3.4.6.1. IMD (K11 [4.36]) shall be maintained between missile launchers, reloads,
and other AE storage locations to include parked AE-loaded aircraft.
V6.E3.4.6.2. Missile batteries deployed within the IBD of AE storage areas may be sited
at K18 [7.14] to manned functions considered related to area AE operations. Likewise, missile
batteries deployed in the clear zones of flight-line operations may be sited at K18 [7.14] to
manned flight-line facilities.
V6.E3.4.6.3. Those functions solely providing support to static missile units, such as
motor pools, may be sited at K18 [7.14] to batteries and other AE activities when the missile
battery is located in these areas. For asset preservation, use PTRD.
V6.E3.4.6.4. No separation is required between missile batteries and the security force
structures exclusively supporting them.
V6.E3.4.8.2. Bulk Fuel Storage. For more than 5,000 gallons [18,927 liters] apply
section V4.E5.13.
ENCLOSURE 4
V6.E4.1.1. This enclosure sets forth standards for protecting workers and the general public
from the harmful effects of toxic chemical munitions and agents associated with research,
testing, training, preservation and maintenance operations, storage, and demilitarization at
laboratories, manufacturing plants, and depots as well as other DoD Component agent
operations, exclusive of combat training and operations. They apply to:
V6.E4.1.1.1. Blister Agents. Examples include, but are not limited to:
V6.E4.1.1.2. Nerve Agents. Examples include, but are not limited to:
V6.E4.1.2. Toxic chemical munitions may present additional hazards of blast, fragments,
and thermal effects. Standards relating to these explosives hazards are addressed in other
enclosures of this Volume, as well as other volumes of this Manual.
V6.E4.1.3. This Manual does not apply to the immediate disposal of toxic chemical
munitions or decontamination of toxic CAs during an emergency when the delay will cause a
greater danger to human life or health.
V6.E4.1.4. The DoD Components are responsible for developing implementing instructions
and safety procedures for logistical movements, training, and field operations.
V6.E4.2.1. Hazard Distance Calculations. (See the definition of “public exclusion distance”
in the Volume 8 Glossary). Hazard distance calculations shall conform to DDESB Technical
Paper 10 (Reference (e)). DDESB approved software (e.g., as provided in U.S. Army Chemical
Research Development and Engineering Center publication (Reference (f))) that implements the
methodology of Reference (e) may be used to perform these calculations. The calculated hazard
distance is based on the greater of the maximum credible event (MCE) or the toxic CA MCE and
is bounded by the one percent lethality arc for a toxic CA source containing a dose of more than:
V6.E4.2.2. Personnel Control. Positive means shall be taken to ensure that unprotected
personnel do not enter hazard zones and shall include written procedures that must be reviewed
and updated, as necessary. However, positive control of an area, which ensures personnel can
evacuate or be protected before exposure in the case of an accident, may be developed instead of
absolute exclusion. Details of such control procedures shall be included in the site and general
construction plans.
V6.E4.3. WORKPLACE AIRBORNE EXPOSURE LIMIT (AEL). The Army Surgeon General
establishes the maximum permissible concentrations (AELs) listed in Table V6.E4.T15. AELs
are time-weighted averages (TWAs) or ceiling values that define the permissible limits of
exposure for unprotected personnel.
CA (mg/m3)
Exposure Limit H/HD &
GD GA/GB VX La
H/HT
Unmasked Agent Worker
8-hour TWA in any work shift 3 x 10-5 1 x 10-4 1 x 10-5 3 x 10-3 3 x 10-3
(Footnote b) (Footnote b)
Non-Agent Worker and General Population
72-hour TWA 3 x 10-6 3 x 10-6 3 x 10-6 1 x 10-4 3 x 10-3
(Footnote c) (Footnote b)
3 x 10-3 3 x 10-3
Ceiling Valued 3 x 10-5 1 x 10-4 1 x 10-5 (Footnote b) (Footnote b)
Source Emission Limit
1-hour TWA 1 x 10-4 3 x 10-4 3 x 10-4 3 x 10-2 3 x 10-2
V6.E4.4.1.1. Hazard analyses shall be conducted for all new operations involving toxic
CAs or when there is a change in existing production, process, or control measures that may
result in an increase in airborne or contact concentrations of toxic CAs. Hazard analyses shall be
retained for 40 years.
V6.E4.4.1.2. If hazard analyses indicate that an operation may expose personnel to toxic
CAs above the AEL, control measures shall be instituted and procedures shall be established so
that the actual exposure is measured.
V6.E4.4.2. Measurements
V6.E4.4.2.1. Devices for sampling and analyzing workplace air shall measure and alarm
within 10 minutes when toxic CAs are present in excess of the 8-hour TWA concentrations.
V6.E4.4.2.2. When the interior of reservoirs, pipes, and such systems are sampled, the
volume of the item or system being sampled as well as the volume of the sample must be
recorded and associated with the measured concentrations.
V6.E4.4.2.3. Decontaminating solutions shall not be analyzed for residual toxic CA for
the purpose of certifying a level of decontamination. Suspected toxic CAs shall be extracted
from samples with suitable solvents where analyses are required. Air may be an appropriate
solvent for volatile agents.
V6.E4.4.3.2. Before beginning toxic CA operations, the hazard zone associated with
those operations shall be under positive control IAW paragraph V6.E4.2.2.
V6.E4.4.3.3. If personnel exposures will equal or exceed the applicable AEL, personnel
shall be protected by personal protective equipment (PPE) specifically approved by the Army
Surgeon General or as indicated in Table V6.E4.T26.
a Qualitatively fit all workers required to use respiratory protective devices. Quantitative fit testing may be
performed using surrogate masks.
b Employee exposure potential is based on an 8-hour TWA measurement. All values in this table are 8-hour
TWAs unless otherwise noted. The TWA is the concentration to which workers may be repeatedly exposed, for
a normal 8-hour workday and 40-hour workweek, day after day, without adverse effects. TWAs permit
excursions above the limit provided they are compensated by equivalent excursions below the limit during the
workday. Excursions above the TWA should be controlled even where the 8-hour TWA is within
recommended limits.
c Air-purifying masks may not be used in oxygen deficient atmospheres.
d Determined by required continuous air monitoring.
e This represents ceiling value determined by continuous real time monitoring (with alarm) at the 0.003 mg/m3
level of detection. Respiratory protection must be immediately available in case concentration rises above
0.003 mg/m3. Engineering and work practice controls shall be used to limit employee exposure potential to the
extent practical.
f Examples of such protective ensembles include Toxicologic Agent Protective Ensemble, Self-Contained and
the Demilitarization Protective Ensemble.
g For emergency masked escape, a full facepiece, chemical canister, air-purifying protective mask (DoD
Component-certified masks) is acceptable.
h Because agents H and L are potential carcinogens, the highest level of respiratory and dermal protection shall
be provided to all workers exposed. An air-purifying protective mask is not suitable for this purpose.
V6.E4.6.3. Personnel shall use PPE recommended by the hazard analysis. (See Table
V6.E4.T26.)
V6.E4.7.1. Containment
V6.E4.7.1.2. Containment is not required for operations associated with field storage and
maintenance activities (e.g., shipping, storage, receiving, re-warehousing, minor maintenance,
surveillance inspection, repair, and encapsulation).
V6.E4.7.2. Training and Information. Anyone who works with toxic chemical munitions
and agents (e.g., agent workers, firefighters, and medical and security personnel) shall receive
training to enable them to work safely and to understand the significance of toxic CA exposures.
This training shall include, but is not limited to, information on sources of exposure, adverse
health effects, practices and controls used to limit exposures, environmental issues, medical
monitoring procedures, and employee responsibilities in health protection programs.
V6.E4.7.4.1. Signs and labels to warn personnel of hazards of toxic CAs are required for:
decontaminated of the indicated toxic CA. Further decontamination processes are required
before the item is moved or any maintenance or repair is performed without the use of PPE.
V6.E4.7.5. Emergencies
V6.E4.7.5.2. Special medical surveillance shall be started within 24 hours for all
personnel present in the potentially affected area at the time of the emergency.
V6.E4.7.5.3. The DoD Component shall maintain up-to-date chemical accident and
incident control plans and conduct practice exercises of these plans at least annually.
V6.E4.7.6.1. When toxic CAs are spilled or released, immediate action shall be taken to
contain the spill and clean up the agent in the immediate area of the spill.
V6.E4.7.6.2. Before leaving contaminated work areas, the external surfaces of the PPE
shall be decontaminated.
V6.E4.7.6.3. When PPE becomes contaminated with toxic CAs, the outside layer of
clothing shall be removed and decontaminated as soon as possible.
V6.E4.7.6.4. PPE that has been worn in known contaminated areas (toxic CA detected)
shall be decontaminated and monitored before reuse. Because mustard penetrates into many
protective materials with time, reuse of any PPE that has been contaminated with liquid mustard
is not permitted. PPE that has been worn in potentially contaminated areas (when no agent
leakage has been visually observed or detected by use of field detection equipment) shall be
monitored before being moved to areas accessible to non-agent workers.
V6.E4.7.6.6. PPE found to emit toxic CA concentrations above the XXX level after
decontamination shall not be reused. It shall be disposed of IAW the DoD Component guidance
and in compliance with all Federal, State, and local requirements.
V6.E4.7.6.7. Before toxic CA disposal systems are converted to different agents, the
piping, tanks, etc. of the disposal systems shall be filled with decontaminating solution and a
contact time of 10 half lives or greater shall be provided. Walls and floors of process areas shall
be decontaminated to ensure the absence of contact hazards.
V6.E4.8.1. Air Ventilation Systems. Air ventilation systems shall be designed and
periodically tested to ensure that control of toxic CA-contaminated exhaust shall not exceed
source emission limits of Table V6.E4.T15.
V6.E4.8.1.1. Filters or scrubbers for exhaust air shall be designed and approved for the
MCE of the operations involved.
V6.E4.8.1.2. Redundant filters shall be used when filter breakthrough of the toxic CA is
expected. Filters shall be changed when agent breaks through the filter that is just upstream of
the last filter.
V6.E4.8.1.3. All exhaust equipment shall have backup blowers that automatically engage
if the main blower fails.
V6.E4.8.1.4. Filter systems shall be fitted with the means to measure the pressure drop
across the filters.
V6.E4.8.1.5. Exhaust hoods and glove boxes shall be designed to contain toxic CAs so
that concentrations specified in Table V6.E4.T15. for unmasked agent workers are not exceeded
outside engineering controls. The design of these items shall permit airflow adjustments
sufficient to maintain the required protection level when laboratory equipment is in place.
V6.E4.8.1.5.1. Catch basins and traps or spill trays of sufficient capacity to contain
the quantity of toxic CA involved shall be provided within hoods and glove boxes.
V6.E4.8.1.5.2. Glove boxes shall be used when the hazards analysis indicates that
toxic CA aerosols or dusts may be present during an operation.
V6.E4.8.1.6. Special design features shall be used when exposed explosives are involved
to segregate explosives from air ventilation systems.
V6.E4.8.2.1. The design parameters shall consider equipment and process layout,
makeup airflow, and operational positions with regard to maintaining flow balance and cross
currents. The system shall maintain negative pressure in operating areas in relation to hallways,
offices, and other nontoxic CA areas.
V6.E4.8.2.2. Working surfaces, walls, floors, and ceilings within a facility likely to be
contaminated shall be constructed of agent-resistant materials. Flooring material shall cover wall
surfaces to a height of 6 inches [15.2 centimeters].
V6.E4.8.2.3. Access to nontoxic CA areas (e.g., utilities, mechanical rooms, etc.) shall
be accomplished without entry into toxic CA areas.
V6.E4.8.2.4. Electrical systems shall be equipped with a backup power source designed
to start automatically and supply sufficient power to support critical functions in the event of
power outage.
V6.E4.8.2.5. Safety showers and eyewash fountains shall be readily accessible and
tested.
V6.E4.8.2.7. Dedicated liquid waste systems shall be designed to collect and hold
potentially toxic CA-contaminated effluent produced by the activity until disposal IAW
applicable laws. Vents or other openings in the waste system shall be fitted with approved toxic
CA filters or connected or exhausted to facility toxic CA air filtration system.
V6.E4.8.3.1. Facility Alarms and Monitors for Engineering Systems. Each toxic CA
facility shall have a master alarm and control panel that will permit functional verification of the
exhaust blowers and air handlers. Visual and audible alert alarms shall be keyed to this master
alarm panel to indicate failures.
V6.E4.8.3.2. Fire Detection and Protection. Fire detection and protection systems for
production and maintenance facilities shall comply with the requirements and guidelines in U.S.
Army Armament and Research Development Command publication (Reference (i)).
V6.E4.8.3.3. Bulk Storage Tanks. Impermeable dikes to hold at least 110 percent of the
tank capacity, plus the required volume of decontaminant solution, shall be placed around all
bulk agent tanks, reactors, and mixers. However, a system designed to pump the toxic CA from
the dikes to a vessel designed to accommodate the decontamination will satisfy this requirement
that the dike contain sufficient volume for the decontaminating solutions.
ENCLOSURE 5
RISK-BASED SITING
V6.E5.1. SCOPE. This enclosure provides guidance and minimum requirements for
quantitative risk-based siting. It provides the basis for quantifying the risks from a PES to
personnel at each exposed ES (individual risk (probability of fatality (Pf ))) and at all exposed
ESs (group risk (expected fatalities (Ef))) by performing a quantitative risk assessment when the
QD criteria of this Manual cannot be met. Procedures are provided for preparing, submitting,
and periodically reviewing risk-based site plans.
V6.E5.2.2. The approved model for risk-based siting (Reference (k)) provides risk estimates
for individual and group risks.
V6.E5.2.2.3. The approved model treats those risk estimates as statistical distributions.
V6.E5.2.3. The approved model is only applicable if all PESs are separated by IMD IAW
this Manual, or the individual NEWQDs for each PES are summed and treated as a single PES.
V6.E5.3.2. Use the latest approved version of the SAFER© code or equivalent DDESB-
approved analysis tools for risk-based explosives safety site plan assessments. (See section
V6.E5.7. for requirements for equivalent analysis tools.) The DoD Components may submit
explosives safety site plans to the DDESB for approval that were initiated under previous
versions of SAFER© or the equivalent DDESB-approved analysis tool.
V6.E5.3.3. Evaluate all ESs within the ES group exposed by the PES (of the PES/ES pair
not meeting QD separation criteria). The ES group contains those ESs out to a distance from the
PES where contributions to Pf are no longer significant (i.e., out to the risk-based evaluation
distance where Pf is equal to 1x10-8 for an individual present 24/7/365 in the open or IBD,
whichever is greater).
V6.E5.3.4. Determine Pf by summing the risks from all PESs that expose the ES to
significant risk (i.e., from all PESs for which the ES is in the ES group exposed by the PES).
V6.E5.3.5. Evaluate ESs exposed to a new PES and include significant risks from all other
PESs.
V6.E5.3.6. Determine group risk by summing all Pf, as explained in paragraph V6.E5.3.4.,
for all of the ESs within the ES group, as described in paragraph V6.E5.3.3.
V6.E5.3.7. Use (i.e., input) the full siting amount (NEWQD) and full yield.
V6.E5.3.8. Accept, as the DoD Component, the risks not evaluated by the DDESB-approved
risk tool (i.e., risks to facilities, equipment, assets, and mission). This risk acceptance by the
DoD Component does not address other violations of this Manual.
V6.E5.3.9. Ensure the results of the quantitative risk assessment satisfy the criteria of Table
V6.E5.T17.
V6.E5.4.1. The DoD Component approved justification for not meeting QD. (See paragraph
V6.E5.3.1.)
V6.E5.4.2. Explanation of assumptions made for the inputs in the DDESB-approved risk
tool to define the situation to be analyzed.
V6.E5.4.4. Summary of results compared to the risk-based siting acceptance criteria IAW
Table V6.E5.T17.
V6.E5.4.5. Data required IAW paragraph V1.E5.1.3. (Site plan documentation is required.)
V6.E5.5.1. By the originating DoD Component a minimum of every 5 years to ensure that
siting conditions have not changed. If conditions have not changed, this information shall be
documented in the site plan files at the installation and at the DoD Component confirming the
continued acceptable status of the site plan. If conditions have changed, paragraph V6.E5.5.2.
shall be applied.
V6.E5.5.2.1. If risk does not violate the acceptance criteria in Table V6.E5.T17., a
revised risk-based explosives safety site plan shall be prepared IAW the procedures in sections
V6.E5.3. and V6.E5.4. and submitted to the DDESB for approval.
V6.E5.5.2.2. If risk does violate the acceptance criteria in Table V6.E5.T17. but does not
increase beyond the DDESB-approved risk-based siting criteria in effect at the time the
explosives safety site plan was previously approved, a revised risk-based explosives safety site
plan shall be prepared IAW the procedures in sections V6.E5.3. and V6.E5.4. and submitted to
the DDESB for approval.
V6.E5.5.2.3. If the risk violates both the acceptance criteria in Table V6.E5.T17. and the
DDESB-approved risk-based siting acceptance criteria in effect at the time the explosives safety
site plan was previously approved, the DDESB-approved risk-based siting is no longer valid, and
the DDESB must be so notified.
V6.E5.7.1. Address all applicable aspects of the approved risk-based model. (See Reference
(k).)
V6.E5.7.2. Document all data sources used to develop the algorithms used in the model.
V6.E5.7.3. Provide software validation and verification results to the DDESB for an
assessment and have the software certified by the DoD Information Technology Security
Certification and Accreditation Process.
V6.E5.7.4. Provide the results of a peer review of the model to the DDESB for an
assessment.
GLOSSARY
°C degrees Celsius
CA chemical agent
CAPA combat aircraft parking area
°F degrees Fahrenheit
FARP forward arming and refueling point
ft foot or feet
kg kilogram
kPa kilopascal
m meter
m3 cubic meter
MCE maximum credible event
mg milligram
mg-min milligram-minute
MIL-STD Military Standard
MOOTW military operations other than war
QD quantity-distance