Polity 06 - Daily Class Notes - UPSC Prarambh 2026

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

DAILY CLASS NOTES

NCERT: Indian Polity

Lecture -06
Constitution as a Living
Document and Philosophy of
the Constitution
2

Constitution as a Living Document and Philosophy of the Constitution

❖ Constitution as a Living Document

❖ Types of Majority

Constitution as a Living Document:

❖ The Constitution of India is a living document. This means that the Constitution of
India can be amended or changed from time to time, as the conditions emerge.

❖ Amendment means any change, modification, addition, or deletion to the Constitution.

❖ The Constitution of India has provided a specific procedure that has to be followed for
its amendment.

❖ It is seen that almost all the Constitutions of the world were rewritten as time or

situation changed. Thus no constitution in the world can be called static.

➢ Example: The constitution of the Soviet Union was rewritten four times whereas the

French Constitution was rewritten five times. This shows that the Constitution

cannot be static.

❖ However, the Indian Constitution has not been rewritten even once in the last 73 years

since its commencement because the Constitution itself provides the method to change

it according to the changing needs of the people.

➢ The Indian Constitution was enacted on 26 November 1949 and it commenced on

26 January 1950 (Republic Day).

❖ A constitution cannot be unalterable as it is the worst thing that can happen to people.

➢ Societal needs and challenges will keep on changing as time changes. The past

generation cannot bind the future generation otherwise society would not progress.
3

Question to Ponder upon:

Why there has been a broad agreement on the acceptance of the Indian Constitution?

Answer: The elements that contributed to the acceptance of the Indian Constitution among
the people of India are as follows:

❖ Mode of Deliberation: Discussed in the previous class

❖ Institutional Agreement: Discussed in the previous class

❖ The way India’s Constitution has been Framed: All the groups living within India have
a reason to accept the Constitution of India as the interests, concerns, and welfare of
all the groups have been taken care of.

Constitution of India: Rigid or Flexible

❖ The constitution can be classified into Rigid or Flexible based on its method of

amendment.

❖ Features of Rigid Constitution:

➢ A Rigid Constitution is resistant to change. Example: American Constitution.

➢ Thus, it is something that cannot be easily changed.

➢ Some parts of the Indian Constitution

are rigid. Examples: Fundamental

Rights, Directive Principles of State

Policy, etc.

❖ Features of Flexible Constitution:

➢ A Flexible Constitution is open to

change. Example: British Constitution.

➢ Thus, it is something that can be easily

changed.
4

➢ Large parts of the Indian Constitution are flexible. Examples: Citizenship provisions,
Admission or establishment of new states, etc.

❖ The Indian Constitution is a mixture of rigid and flexible provisions.

➢ Flexibility in the Indian Constitution: Certain provisions in the Constitution can be


amended by a simple majority of both Houses of Parliament.

➢ Rigidity in the Indian Constitution: Certain cases can be amended by a special


majority of all the members of the Parliament. Certain features relating to the
federation require ratification by half of the states besides requiring a special
majority.

❖ Thus, the amendment procedure of the Indian constitution combines the features of
rigidity and flexibility.

Types of Majority:

❖ Simple Majority:

➢ A Simple Majority refers to


more than 50% of the
members present and voting.

➢ It is an easy method through


which the government is run.

➢ The ordinary laws (related to


administration) are passed by
a simple majority in the Parliament and State Legislature.

➢ Suppose an ordinary law has to be passed in the Lok Sabha. The total number of
members present on that day in the House is 250. So for the law to be passed it
needs to be approved by at least 126 members (more than 50% of 250) present
and voting.
5

❖ Special Majority:

➢ Case I:

✓ A Special Majority refers to 2/3rd of the members present and voting

and

It must be more than half of the total strength of the House.

✓ The total strength of Rajya Sabha is 245 and Lok Sabha is 545. Therefore,
any amendment must be supported by a minimum of 123 members in the
Rajya Sabha and 273 members in the Lok Sabha.

✓ It is applied to those constitutional amendments which don't involve the


interest of the State Government.

✓ Example: The 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act, of 1985 introduced the


Anti-Defection Law. It provided for the disqualification of members of
Parliament and State Legislature on grounds of defection. Defection means
when an MP or MLA gives up her allegiance from one political party to another
for her personal gains. Since the amendment did not involve any article
related to the distribution of powers between the States and the Central
Government, it was passed by a special majority without ratification by the
States.

✓ Suppose that a law has to be passed in the Lok Sabha with a special majority.
On that day, 450 members were present. Then it has to be passed by 2/3rd
of the 450 i.e. 300 members and more than half of 545 (total strength of
Lok Sabha) i.e. 273 members.

➢ Case II:

✓ Another case of Special Majority requires state ratification.

✓ It refers to 2/3rd of the members present and voting

and

It must be more than half of the total strength of the House

and

Half of the States should ratify it with a simple majority.


6

✓ Presently, there are 28 States in India therefore the ratification by 14 States


will be required for the passing of the amendment bill.

✓ A simple majority is required in the State to make it easy for so many States
to pass the law.

✓ A special majority is required at the Centre (Parliament) to make the process


of amendment difficult for the Government. The Government would need the
support of the opposition parties to pass these laws.

✓ It is applied when an amendment aims to modify an article related to the


distribution of powers between the States and the Central Government. This
is done to protect the federal features of the Constitution.

✓ Example: The 101st Amendment Act, of 2016 introduced the Goods and
Services Tax (GST). It combined all the Central and State taxes (except for a
few) under one head i.e. GST. Since the amendment involved an article related
to the distribution of financial powers between the States and the Central
Government, therefore it was passed by a special majority with the ratification
by the States.

❖ The constitutions of the U.S., South Africa, Russia, etc. have employed the principle of
special majority for the amendment of their constitution. In the case of the
constitution of the US, it is the two-thirds majority, while in South Africa and Russia,
for some amendments, the three-fourths majority is required.

❖ Thus, the special majority of two-thirds of the members present and voting has been
adopted from the American Constitution in the Constitution of India.



You might also like