Vitamina D
Vitamina D
1. Queensland Centre for Mental Health Research, The Park Centre for Mental
Australia.
* Corresponding Author:
Queensland Centre for Mental Health Research, The Park Centre for Mental Health
Wacol QLD 4076 Australia
www.qcmhr.uq.edu.au
www.qbi.uq.edu.au
This article has been accepted for publication and undergone full peer review but has not been
through the copyediting, typesetting, pagination and proofreading process which may lead to
differences between this version and the Version of Record. Please cite this article as doi:
10.1002/jbm4.10419
Our work over the last 2 decades, particularly results from our cellular and animal
models has confirmed the numerous ways in which vitamin D differentiates the
developing brain. As a result vitamin D can now confidently take its place amongst all
other steroids known to regulate brain development.(2) Others have concentrated on the
possible neuroprotective functions of vitamin D in adult brains. Here these data are
integrated, and possible mechanisms outlined for the various roles vitamin D appears to
play in both developing and mature brains and how such actions shape behavior. There
is now also good evidence linking gestational and/or neonatal vitamin D deficiency with
and adult vitamin D deficiency with certain degenerative conditions. Indeed the author of
this review has been heavily invested in this analytical epidemiology. However in this
mini-review I will not be discussing this clinical epidemiology but rather focusing on what
we have learned over this time period regarding the genomic and non-genomic actions
models.
I. Introduction
II. Vitamin D signaling and metabolism in the brain
III. Developmental vitamin D (DVD)-deficiency and brain development
IV. Developmental vitamin D (DVD)-deficiency and animal behavior
V. Adult vitamin D (AVD)-deficiency/supplementation and brain and behavior
VI. Vitamin D regulates essential processes in normal brain development and
function and is neuroprotective in adult brains
VII. Conclusions
Readers of this, and other contributions to this issue will be aware of the wide range of
non-skeletal targets for vitamin D. In particular the last 20 years have been a fertile
period for the investigation of vitamin D and its diverse functions in the brain. The
distribution of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) and the enzyme associated with the
synthesis of the active form of the hormone 1-alpha hydroxylase (CYP27B1) have been
mapped in human brain,(3) along with studies showing the VDR is present in numerous
number of clinical brain disorders. For more than a decade now inadequate levels of
vitamin D have been linked with numerous adverse brain related outcomes. In particular
developmental vitamin D (DVD) deficiency has been linked with schizophrenia (8,9) and
more recently autism.(10-12) Adult vitamin D (AVD) deficiency has also been linked with
review see (13)). There are also strong links with Parkinson’s disease.(14)
literature. For detailed reviews of these associations I refer the reader to two excellent
literature at the end of article. Rather my purpose here is to focus on the latest
clinical conditions. The biological plausibility that low levels of vitamin D adversely affect
brain development and function is now well-established. Our task now, is to discover
exactly how low levels of vitamin D change the function of specific brain cells/ circuits
Like many of the other contributors to this special edition I would like to honour Tony
Normans legacy. When I went to my 1st Vitamin D workshop in Maastricht in 2003 I felt
like a total imposter. What was a neuroscientist doing in an endocrine meeting where to
the best of my knowledge no one had even mentioned the brain before? I acknowledge
Tony for creating and sustaining this meeting which for me at least has become a truly
The major circulatory form of vitamin D, 25-hydroxyvitamin D3, (25(OH)D3) and its active
Whilst the exact concentrations are debatable, they are likely to be much lower than
those levels found in blood. Various technical issues in their extraction and method of
quantification make claims of absolute amounts difficult at this time. We have dealt
Immunohistochemical evidence for the VDR is far stronger. The VDR has been
confirmed in human, mouse, rat, chick and zebrafish brains.(3,18-22) VDR’s in brain are
adult rodent brains which identified five unique VDR peptides with a confidence interval
greater than 99%.(26) The regional organization of VDR in human brain is remarkably
consistent with that published for the rat. For example, VDR expression in both rat and
human cerebellum is restricted to the granule cells and was completely absent from
CA1 and CA2 pyramidal cells with a marked reduction within CA3,(3) a finding replicated
in rats by two separate groups.(19,21) Within both the rat and human hypothalamus the
most densely labeled nuclei were the supraoptic and paraventricular nuclei.(3,18) VDR
neurons from the nucleus basalis in both rat and human brains.(27) Finally the
concentration of VDR protein within the large dopaminergic neurons of the substantia
nigra has now been confirmed in both rat and human brain.(28) Most importantly VDR in
elements when bound to ligand.(23) This close cross-species overlap in VDR distribution
The temporal nature of VDR expression in the developing brain has been qualitatively
mapped in both rat(29) and mouse brain.(30) The immunohistochemical presence of VDR
there is a broad distribution across a variety of brain regions. In the developing rat brain,
the VDR appeared to be localized in differentiating fields.(29) This may be highly relevant
given the role of vitamin D as a potent differentiation agent in a variety of cell types.(31)
We have provided more evidence that VDR signaling may be relevant to brain cell
ependymal surface of the lateral ventricles in neonatal rats.(32) This is a site that
Our initial studies of the time course for VDR protein and mRNA expression in the rat
brain showed a general increase between embryonic days 15 and 23.(33) Since then we
have studied the ontogeny of the VDR in developing rodent brain at the
immunohistochemical, mRNA and protein levels. We confirmed earlier findings that the
VDR is present at the early embryonic age of E12, but this staining did not appear to be
cellular. By E15, clear punctate staining was obvious in the nucleus of dopaminergic
pattern of expression was largely confirmed at the mRNA and protein levels.(28) We
have confirmed VDR protein and mRNA were present in the neonatal brain in a
subsequent study.(26) The appearance of the VDR and its increasing expression in the
embryo coincides with the onset of neuronal differentiation in the developing brain.
Finally the enzyme which catalyzes conversion of 25(OH)D3 to the active or hormonal
form of vitamin D, 1,25(OH)2D3, CYP27B1, is clearly present in the fetal human (34) and
adult brain(3,35) suggesting local production of the active hormone may be possible in
human brain. The enzyme was detected in the cytoplasm of both neurons and non-
neuronal cells.(3) As with the VDR, the pattern of expression of this enzyme had regional
and sub-regional specificity. The regions that stained the strongest were the supraoptic
and paraventricular nuclei within the hypothalamus and the substantia nigra.
deficiency. Here we will not discuss brain functional data from the genetic models
further as the physiology of these animals is often compromised thus distorting behavior
(see section IV below). However there is abundant research from models of dietary
normal calcium and phosphate levels i.e. neither the dams nor their offspring have a
rickets-like phenotype.(40) Since we developed this model in rats in 2003 it has been
adapted in both other rat or mouse strains to examine the long-term neuropsychiatric
expression. These findings in DVD-deficient embryonic brains are in accord with in vitro
studies in brain cells.(46,47) When the anatomy of DVD-deficient embryonic brains was
examined it was revealed that the newborn offspring of DVD-deficient rats had slightly
larger brains. This corresponded with an increased volume of the lateral ventricles and
deficient mice however would appear to be quite different with lateral ventricles being
shown to be reduced in the embryonic mouse brain.(44) This was also accompanied by
reduced brain length (44) rather than longer brains as seen in DVD-deficient newborn
into adulthood. The enlarged lateral ventricles seen in the DVD-deficient rat neonates
(38)
persists into adulthood if vitamin D deficiency is continued until weaning.(49) The
appears to persist into adulthood.(48,50) Two separate groups have also now shown
adult males.(48,50) The reason for why DVD-deficiency would induce contrasting brain
structural findings between species remains unknown. There may be a differential effect
of DVD-deficiency on brain cell proliferation between rats and mice but until this is
directly studied in mice this remains speculative. Vitamin D deficiency has also been
brains the VDR appears very early at embryonic day (E)12.(28,29) This represents the
peak age when most dopamine neurons are being born.(55) When mesencephalon was
embryonic brains had a reduction in Nurr 1 and p57kip2a which are two crucial
specification factors for the maturation of DA neurons.(56) Genetically ablating these two
neonatal forebrain and showed that, although dopamine levels were normal, its
metabolism was altered with increased ratios of the two major dopamine metabolites,
converts DOPAC to HVA.(61) Additionally, a recent study has shown gene expression
(TH) is reduced in DVD-deficient fetal mouse brains.(44) This same study has shown
(BDNF) at early stages of brain development with a reversal at later stages.(44) This
adulthood with DA transporter density in the caudate putamen and DA binding affinity in
DVD-deficiency also has long-term effects on gene and protein expression in adult
brains. Gene array analysis on whole brain and proteomics in the prefrontal cortex and
in the expression of 74 genes and 36 proteins involved with such diverse functions as
although the degree of gene dysregulation was mild there were significant alterations in
several proteins involved in either calcium binding (calbindin, calretinin and hippocalcin),
maturation.(49)
via pup ultrasonic vocalisations and how the dam retrieves pups once separated from
the main nest can all produce long-term effects in adult behaviour. Pup/Dam
interactions have recently been examined in DVD-deficient animals. Yates and co-
workers showed vitamin D-deficient dams exhibited decreased licking and grooming of
increased. As adults, males that had been exposed to vitamin D deficiency in early life
exhibited decreased social behaviour, impaired learning and memory outcomes and
DVD-deficient rats. Again, we show an increase in pup vocalisations (69) and similar
show some early climbing and self-righting reflex deficits indicative of delayed
deficient rats is associated with a significant reduction in MK-801 binding in the caudate
putamen.(72) We have also shown that the later period of gestation was most relevant
period of DVD-deficiency for this effect.(40) This is reminiscent of our earlier findings
behavioral outcomes.
studies have also shown that DVD-deficient rats are selectively sensitive to postsynaptic
recordings from the hippocampus of freely moving rats, a subsequent study investigated
was shown that DVD-deficient rats had enhanced LTP, and this was reversed by
treatment with haloperidol. DVD-deficient rats also appeared to have normal pre-pulse
inhibition (PPI) (71) and working memory but disrupted latent inhibition, which is a
can affect all of these three behaviors, this potential mechanism has not yet been
investigated in vivo.
produced animals that had both increased premature responding, reflecting increased
lack of response inhibition.(75) Importantly both of these behaviors were normalized with
acute treatment with the antipsychotic clozapine.(75) Finally we have recently shown
in the open field arena, similar to DVD-deficient rats.(71) Another widely used strain
induces similar deficits in response inhibition in both species. However all other
behavioural phenotypes of DVD-deficient mice are distinctly different from the rat.
DVD-deficient mice from both strains demonstrate an increased frequency of head dips
to findings from DVD-deficient rats on the same test.(42) Also the robust locomotor
deficit was seen on the final day of training, with DVD-deficient mice showing a
Clearly the behavioral phenotype of the DVD-deficient rat is distinctly different to that of
the mouse. However, the array of behaviors examined indicate subtle alterations in
function in children is far from clear. One study has shown children who were vitamin D
deficient during pregnancy had delayed cognitive development,(79) but this finding was
not replicated in a larger study when a broader array of cognitive outcomes was
behavioral outcomes in DVD-deficient rats and mice has recently been published,(81) an
exhaustive comparison between the effects of DVD-deficiency in both species has not
yet been conducted. Perhaps a more useful line of inquiry would be an examination of
which critical developmental window of exposure and which critical threshold of vitamin
To induce vitamin D deficient signaling via a genetic approach, groups have either
ablated the receptor (30,82-84) or the major synthetic enzyme for 1,25(OH)2D3
To date there are no published studies using conditional or brain specific VDR mutant
mice to test the effects of transient or regional receptor disruption on brain development.
Although tissue specific inactivation of CYP27B1 has been demonstrated (97) these
behavior.
As previously mentioned, there are also numerous studies linking low vitamin D status
detailed summary of this literature see (13)). In order to investigate the biological nature
of these links, various preclinical models of adult vitamin D (AVD) deficiency have been
was the failure to address hypocalcemia which can radically affect brain function
deficiency this behavior has been the most commonly assessed in AVD models
however the picture is far from clear. Six weeks of vitamin D deficiency is insufficient to
change cognitive responses in an AVD rat however it did lead to premature responses
indicating some effect on vigilance.(98) There were also small changes in striatal
months) increased reactive oxygen production in the brain (99) it also did not affect
cognition.(100) Mild cognitive deficits have been shown in some studies using AVD-
deficient mice (101) along with alterations in the major excitatory neurotransmitter in the
brain, glutamate and the major inhibitory transmitter GABA.(102) How these alterations
could directly relate to impaired cognition however is not immediately obvious. The
addition of high dose cholecalciferol (10 x normal dietary levels) did however appear to
to stressful events and increased avoidance times.(104) One specific learning task did
aversive spatial learning. Importantly these findings were correlated with connectivity
abnormalities in the major brain region associated with spatial navigation, the
hippocampus.(105)
mimicking the brain pathology of the disease. Given the ongoing reports of vitamin D
deficiency in patients with AD a number of studies have been initiated to see if cognitive
decline and or brain toxicity could be attenuated by vitamin D treatment in such models.
These studies have mostly supported the idea that vitamin D is neuroprotective. For
instance vitamin D enriched foods decrease brain pathology and prevent cognitive
Similar outcomes were found using acute exposure to 1,25(OH)2D3 (108) with the
Amyloid proteins from the brain.(109,110) Models of dietary insufficiency have also shown
Hydroxylase (TH).(116,117) We have now outlined the direct mechanisms for how vitamin
D regulates TH gene expression (117,118) (and see below). 1,25(OH)2D3 also ameliorates
So far, we have outlined how vitamin D deficiency may adversely affect essential
normal processes in brain development, adult brain function and behaviour. In this next
section we review the basic evidence for how vitamin D exerts influence over crucial
neurotransmitter synthesis and how it can act to protect neurons from a range of
adverse exposures.
We were the first group to show the addition of 1,25(OH)2D3 to embryonic hippocampal
explant cultures increased neurite outgrowth.(46) This finding was replicated more
1,25(OH)2D3.(47) Both groups described a small but significant elevation in NGF and
assumed this effect was causal. Another group chose to examine the ability of
These authors chose ergocalciferol based on an older study that claimed this was a
more potent form than cholecalciferol in elevating 25OHD2 levels in rats.(120) These
authors were able to demonstrate increased axiogenesis, axon diameter and higher
lesioning.(121) We also now have new unpublished data replicating the neurite promoting
enhances neurite extension. We are now exploring the molecular mechanisms for these
effects.
Vitamin D’s actions in promoting neurotrophic factors such as NT-3, NT-4 (122) and nerve
growth factor (NGF) in particular (46,47,122-124) have been well described. NGF is
also induces NGF expression. Therefore the evidence that vitamin D may be required
for ongoing neuronal survival in adult brains via such mechanisms appears strong.(127)
Given its role in dopaminergic neuron differentiation and survival there has also been a
such as glial derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) (128,129) and brain-derived neurotrophic
factor (BDNF) again for its broad trophic actions in the developing and adult brain.
Neural stem cells treated with 1,25(OH)2D3 show increased expression of NT-3, BDNF
with an increase in DA cell number also. This vitamin D mediated increase is blocked
genomic evidence for how vitamin D directly regulates the transcription of both
receptors for GDNF. 1,25(OH)2D3 suppresses GDNF family receptor alpha 1 (GFRa1)
but the liganded VDR directly binds to the promoter of the proto-oncogene tyrosine–
protein kinase receptor Ret (C-Ret) which is the other major receptor for this
Very few studies to date have examined the effect of vitamin D on these neurotrophic
factors in the developing brain. In the studies that have, one showed DVD-deficiency in
rats induced deficits in neonatal whole brain NGF and GDNF protein.(38) A much more
recent study also showed early reductions in BDNF and transforming growth factor-β1
Almost universally, the breadth of work over the past two decades indicates
1,25(OH)2D3 increases, and the absence of vitamin D in the maternal diet reduces the
brains. These factors remain highly attractive candidate pathways in understanding the
strongly and consistently indicates the absence of this vitamin during fetal brain
neurons within the human substantia nigra.(3) Since then we have confirmed that TH
positive neurons in the neuromelanin containing human nigra are VDR positive and we
have now mapped the ontogeny of VDR expression in rat brain.(28) As previously
crucial specification factors for dopamine neurons (56) and reduces enzymes involved in
compared with the ventral tegmentum along with reductions in the expression of Nurr1
Chromatin immuno-precipitation data confirm the liganded VDR binds to the COMT
group has shown 1,25(OH)2D3 may drive TH and therefore DA production via a GDNF-
mediated mechanism.(131) We and others, are now engaged in trying to understand how
such early changes in the formation of dopaminergic systems could affect downstream
newborn rats and dopamine and noradrenalin measured in a variety of brain regions in
these animals as adults. These authors showed that dopamine and noradrenalin were
DVD-deficient adults, coupled with our most recent data showing vitamin D signaling in
cultured neurons drives neuron maturation down a dopaminergic lineage, all combine to
strongly suggest vitamin D plays a crucial role in the early ontogeny of dopamine
epidemiological risk factor for schizophrenia (8,9) and that dopamine abnormalities are
also strongly linked with this disease, these data may prove important for the etiology of
psychiatric disease.
brain
species (ROS) and corticosterone which are all naturally occurring in the brain but when
are elevated experimentally and by analogy in various disease states, are known to
adversely affect brain function and in some cases lead to long-term pathology. These
exposures are all exacerbated by vitamin D deficiency and ameliorated by the addition
Calcium transients are essential for normal neuronal function, however unbuffered
calcium is neurotoxic for brain cells. It is well known how vitamin D regulates calcium
uptake in non-neuronal cells such as osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells via direct
regulation of calcium channels.(138,139) Now the actions of vitamin D are being studied in
neurons and brain. Studies in vitro show 1,25(OH)2D3 blocks calcium influx and
vitamin D produce the opposite effect with an increase calcium influx in cortical slices
which is again dependent on L-type calcium channel activity.(143) Recently we have used
calcium imaging, electrophysiology and molecular biology to further explore the non-
concentrations of 1,25(OH)2D3 rapidly enhance calcium influx but only in a small subset
signaling on the activity of these channels is worth further scrutiny given the close links
oxygen species and extracellular calcium in the brain. This occurred along with
impairments in GABA and Glutamate release. Importantly all deficits were normalized
the potential inhibition of Nitric Oxide (NO) production.(4) In the brain, microglia are the
inducible nitric oxide synthetase in the rat brain during either experimental allergic
mechanisms. Microglia when activated with LPS increase production of CYP27B1 and
presumably via local synthesis of the active hormone 1,25(OH)2D3. Confirmation of this
came from treating these same microglia with silencing RNA directed against CYP27B1
which reversed the inhibitory effect of 25(OH)D3.(152) Treatment with 1,25(OH)2D3 also
deficient adult rats showed increased ROS and higher calcium influx indicating
increased excitability. Importantly this was reversed in rats in which vitamin D deficiency
represent the site for the anti-oxidant actions of vitamin D in the brain.
exposure to increased levels of this hormone induces neuronal atrophy and eventually
cell death.(154) In general the cellular effects of 1,25(OH)2D3 and glucocorticoids are
considered to be antagonistic.(155-159) This would also appear to be the case in the brain
DVD-deficiency also adversely affects maternal care (68) which as previously outlined
VII. Conclusions
caution when interpreting previous constitutive knock out strategies to genetically alter
vitamin D signalling given the vast array of non-brain related alterations they induce.
there are also clear species and even strain differences in respect to the dietary effects
have no such impediments producing animals which are normocalceamic and appear
physiologically normal. The breadth of data obtained from such models confirm vitamin
D as an important neurosteroid for both developing and adult brains producing animals
development such as autism and schizophrenia continue to emerge. Similarly, the link
disorders. This of course would be difficult to test directly for developmental conditions
with an adult onset such as schizophrenia and therefore this association can only be
made retrospectively. However, for childhood onset psychiatric conditions and ongoing
supplementation in such risk groups are likely to yield interpretable data in a timely
fashion.
We again would like to insert a note of caution in the light of certain recent high-profile
and psychiatric outcomes the issue of reverse causality (the condition induces low
levels of vitamin D rather than the reverse) is often not, or poorly addressed. This is
made all the more relevant give a very high-profile recent report in the New England
Journal of Medicine showing virtually all mental illnesses were associated with an
any proposed association between low vitamin D levels reported in adults with any
epidemiological studies that seek to examine the relationship between vitamin D and
It is also salient to mention another recent landmark study that used mendelian
concentrations. This study could find no evidence that genetic factors involved in the
any link between 25(OH)D3 levels and any brain related outcome are likely to be solely
By now there has been sufficient interest in the links between vitamin D and brain-
related disorders for contrary findings to begin to emerge. For instance, it is illustrative
between DVD-deficiency and autism.(10-12,169) These studies all had mean 25(OH)D3
levels of <50nM which is considered by some authors to represent a cut off for vitamin
D deficiency. Two recent studies have failed to find this inverse association.(170,171) So,
at face value, this appears a failure to replicate previous studies. However, it is crucial
to note that in these last two studies, the mean levels of 25(OH)D3 were actually very
deficient meaning the association could not be properly addressed. These same six
studies all used the same laboratory to analyse samples so technical bias (so common
amongst vitamin D studies in different populations) could be ruled out. This suggests a
threshold effect rather than any continuous relationship between DVD-deficiency and
regarding statements regarding potential causality between vitamin D and various brain-
We believe that if all such possible confounds can be carefully considered in the future,
remains an extremely attractive option to use such a simple, safe and inexpensive
intervention to alleviate the substantial disease burden these conditions carry for
and their newborns (172) and in the general population, ensuring the diverse functional
capacities of this neuroactive steroid in the developing and adult brain are preserved
health priority. Ultimately only well-designed randomized double blinded clinical trials
Figure 1. Vitamin D and its effects on brain and behavior. A) Depicts the progressive
molecular, cellular, brain structural and behavioural abnormalities induced in the DVD-
deficient rat model. B) Far less investigation has been conducted on AVD-deficiency
reflecting less certainty regarding the use of this model to study brain disorders. C)
therapeutic potential.
Acknowledgements This research receives funding from the National Health and
Medical Research Council (APPS 1124721 and 1141699) and the Queensland State
References
Figure 1. Vitamin D and its effects on brain and behavior. A) Depicts the progressive molecular, cellular,
brain structural and behavioural abnormalities induced in the DVD-deficient rat model. B) Far less
investigation has been conducted on AVD-deficiency reflecting less certainty regarding the use of this model
to study brain disorders. C) There have however been numerous studies in models of relevance to either
Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s disease indicating intervention with vitamin D may have therapeutic potential.