A Trident of Organized State Crime: Corruption As A Basis For The Power Structures Interaction

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 59

=)-.8.3!

*&'358$
N!*.'"! >.!*.'8.! 2.2)*-.!.
!!!!!!!!"#$%&'&!()!*!+,&-!+./0##1#.-!2%3456-

+*!.'&88?! *;3D)+.!.9! +#52D.9! -.3


7843./!)#9&,94/0/!(%&/4%:#0,;/
0<4-!='.1./&958#>#!?@!80-!?A
=)-.8.2)!+*!)!>.+)2.!;3;!.+.1)3; BCD?D!$-!E50%0!
8)'.28;(!2&>"*)*5!!<-')98;!)!D#&8
>')!..(.'.88.9!25?#,8.+*5$
!"#$#%&'()*+('(%(&*(++),-#.+--)(%/0#123#()'45#1678

9#:#;#<#=#;
6.2)*.-O!8)!"!)'-$!"!"!>';3$!8
>5?27@2 # A7"155B575@C2 # D2EFD" # 7GDH1 # ?"IJI5 # ?@KLMNIF # ?167@6@@J#
I"DKO#E2D5OP

%,*,6)!7,8#9&90!
+0 # 45E51" # Q> #R31"3CJI6' # 1"S# ?"AKI # I" # 1D"?"@2 # 1KO54K # TU7J351545#
D5@I"DI@545#C6@I7MVW
(0 # 3K76DI57 # XY< # RZ575D[6I167I6' # T>51235OE6@@J # A75 # D7KO2@"EF@6#
A7"15A57MS6@@JV # ZI5Z51@5 # \6?32JEF@5ZI2 # A23E64EKB] # 5I7KO"@6 # +%'45#
1676Z@J# G # +/ # 453 # (/ # B1 #R # ^_`a8bGc8de*fGc'gaHhij] # RZ575DAkJI6' # (&'45#
1676Z@J# G # +l # 453 # (- # B1] #RZ575DS5ZI6' # +('45 # m51I@J# G # (/ # 453 # +, # B1 # H#
RZ575DZF5Oi'#(,'45#m51I@J#G#+&#453#(n#B1W#
/0 # =6@8 # A75DM757' # RZF5O6 # @"3"@2 # 35D"?K # ZI5Z51@5 # AM@DI21 # + # 2 # (#
"@"E542[@KO#EKZI5O#$#/+*/'l(+&-'((#123#/'45#m51I@JW
&0#>76?K36@I#UD7"o@K'#MZ2#A5A6763@2#3"@2#D5A2oW
l0#Z6D76I"7#<QYp'#[5IK7K#123A51H3@2#9D"74KW
-0#UA51@51"m8#q<#?#A7"1#EN3K@K'#@"3"@2#35D"?K#M#D2EFD5B#EKZI"BW
)0#A75DM757#O8#:Kr1"'#36ZJIDK#357M[6@F#=>]#15ZI"@@r'#e@"E542[@KO#
EKZI5O#$#/+*/'++-+l'(&#123#l'45#1676Z@JW
n0#Q;YU'#MZ2#A5A6763@2#9D"74KW
,0#Q;s:'#36ZJIDK#A51235OE6@F#A75#D57MAC2NW
+%0#O2@2ZI7#tq9'#D2EFD"#123A51H3@Ku#9D"74W
++0#:5O2I6I#q<#?#AKI8#"@IKD57MAC8#A5E2IKDK#DHEFD"#9D"748
s#54EJ3M#@"#ZMC2EF@2#?E5[K@I1"#1D"?"@Ku#D6721@KDH1]#@"A5EJ4"N#@"#
ZI1576@@2#ZE23[Go#D5O2Z2o#?423@5#s"D5@M#T>75#IKO["Z512#ZE23[2#D5O2Z2o#vV#@"#
A23ZI"12#A8#(#ZI"II2#&8

&#EKZI5A"3"#(%(&#78
!"#$%! #! &'%(! )! *"#+! ,"-.$-/0,,1! #20*,0,3(! #%+4&! 15'.! ,0! 2+-6$2+-"7!
#"5$,)!"8$!2'.$-'&3!#"!%0/+!5$%60&0,9+:!"-*04"&"(!$4&",,+;!,0!#$8$2<1#",';!
#"-$2$=3,1&'! 2'%$>'! #"6'&)! "8$! 6*';%"&'! 6*$6$#'9+?(! 15"! %+4&'&341! )!
#20*,0,,+@! A0! 2'6='2"7! #! 6$=$/0,3! B"4&','! -*)>$:! 4&"&&+! "#! C$,4&'&)9+:!
D5*":,'(! #>+-,$! #! 15'%'! $*>",'! -0*/"2,$:! 2="-'! &"! $*>",'! %+4902$>$!
4"%$2*1-)2",,1(! :.! 6$4"-$2+! $4$8'! 6$2',,+! -+1&'! ='E0! ,"! 6+-4&"2+(! 2! %0/".!
6$2,$2"/0,3!&"!)!46$4+8(!F$!60*0-8"B0,+!C$,4&'&)9+7?!&"!#"5$,"%'!D5*":,'@!
G*".$2)?B'! 2'F0#"#,"B0,0! &"! 5$,&054&! 6$*)E0,$>$! G"%'! 6'&",,1(!
#20*&"7%$!G"E)!)2">)!,"!&0(!F$!2+-6$2+-,$!-$!6*'6'4+2!B"4&','!60*E$:!4&"&&+!
"$! 2'F0#>"-",$>$! H"5$,)! 45"*>"! ,"! -+:! B'! *+E0,,1! $*>",)! -0*/"2,$:! 2="-'(!
$*>",)! %+4902$>$! 4"%$2*1-)2",,1(! 6+-6*'7%4&2"(! )4&",$2'(! $*>",+#"9+:(!
$8<7-,",,1!>*$%"-1,(!#"4$8+2!%"4$2$:!+,I$*%"9+:(!6$4"-$2$:!$4$8'!6$-"7&341!)!
6$*1-5)! 6+-=0>=$4&+! 2'F$%)! $*>",)! "8$! 6$4"-$2+;! $4$8+(! F$! ,0! 6$#8"2=17!
>*$%"-1,',"!6*"2"!#20*,)&'41!-$!4)-)!2+-6$2+-,$!-$!B',,$>$!#"5$,$-"24&2"(!
"! 2! *"#+! 2+-4)&,$4&+! &"5$>$! $*>",)! "8$! ,0#>$-'! >*$%"-1,',"! #! 6*';,1&'%! #"!
45"*>$?!*+E0,,1%!%!80#6$40*0-,3$!-$!4)-)@

!!"#$%&#'

!%()*"+,-!.#/#$,!0#12)3)*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!4"!56!7.89
!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'&!()!*!+,&-!./0%#.-!1'*2'3,!---
!"#$%4!"#$-!()!*!+,&-!%.&'56-!736/8.,!9#!:;

&!'%()*+",-.,')/)*0$-)'$1"/.2)
/3'4*56(7()-,8!"9"*:;*!/4*:<
=>?:?*@4*A8/$/!

!"#"$"%"#
&'()*+(,- " ./'01,* " 234,5 " 6)6'76808 " 890+6 " :9;<52 " 7'*=85>,,;"
?6,/43@""7'0855<5'5,,*<"6=-0,58"A+5+0>-B=;CD"."4B526"8=39;/5"=7'*;E-B"
7'5?39B,3"F523-(-*"%GH")I('3J0EK*"I()+3;9B,3=-B"+58:("'5/6D"L,0=93+5/"
73+'*86"/5,=-*-643@,5J5"90+6"-0"+(25/'0-*K,5J5"6=-'5E")08+0,5":/5+*"
,0435, " I()7(43 " @ " 4*8393)04D " '5)8*-/6D " M3N,0'5+,*@ " '5)J595= " 8/0)0,*<"
8*/'*89(,B"+('N08,5J5"67'0893,,;"=-85'E>"),0K,3"7('(:/5+*",0":9;<6"
./'01,*"+5"O#PQ"-0"3,-(J'04D"7'54(=6"8"RSD
&'575,6E"'5)J9;,6-*"75+00,3")95K*,=-80"&'()*+(,-T"./'01,*")0+9;"
6=6,(,,; " )0J'5) " ,0435,D " I()7(43 " -0 " 5I5'5,5)+0-,5=-3 " ) " >8'57(@=B/*2"
,07';2/52"'5)8*-/6D

U"=('7,;"VWVX"'D
!"#$%&'( )%*+,)+*'( -.*+"
!"#$%&'( )%*+,)+*'( -.*+"
!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'
./%,0"12+3-'+"4$%,0,
!"#$%&'()*+,'-!./.+"0"'1"2$3*34'56'
!.5.6&/0"'(-'(-7'8/./6&/0"'9-':-7'
' ';21#$6'8-'<-'=#&1&/&3>0,?':-'@-7'
A,/0.1&/0"'B-'8-7'9"C&/&3>':-'(-7
D1$*'B-'(--'BE./$F"E'G-'H-7'@I#.1'(-'<-7'
:J.16&/0"'8-'9-7'K0.6&/0"':-'9-

7!)89.'6":3,:).-.'5$3.)$;"-,(.
-4)<'=*9>9.3:?!"0"'@A'!-<'@B
CDE@E'2<'F?-$-'
!"#$#%&'()*()')%)+*(),&)+#-()(../,0#123#(+'45#67819:

;#<#=#>#?#=
@87AB379C # DE8"F9B # 1GC"951B1 # 85H5CI # J8"155K58599BK # IGC"951 # I#
87LBM2#E58IJN2O95F#GC8IECI8BP#37#1A"QM95#J8BK51IRCS#GTILH512#AT56B9BU#
V5E87M"P#3B87EC58#W=XD#J85351LIQ#IKBT:CBG:#123#1BE59"99:#GTILH51BK#
5H51Y:AE21P # A"TI6B1ZB # J23T74TBK # 35 # J53[TSZBK # J2385HT79SU # \"E5L#
<5M2C7C#]>#A#JBC"9S#J8"155K58U#32:TS95GC2#J85C:45M#85EI#97#1LB1#32Q1BK#
A"K5321#^535#9":19BK#_"EC21#-353"QCSG:0U
V#54T:3I#9"#85AM"K#584"92A51"95F#@87AB379C5M#DE8"F9B#AT56B995GC2P#
9"J5T:4"R # 9" # GC1587992 # GT236`F # E5M2G2F # A42395 # V"E59I # a@85 # CBM6"G512#
GT2362#E5M2G2F#bc#9"#J23GC"12#6U#)#GC"CC2#&U

(#!"#$9:#)%)+#8U
!!!!!!!!"#$%&'&!()!*!+,&-!+./0##1#.-!2%3456-
!"#$%7!&'()*+,!-.-)"/"+0"1$2(23+45!89/2:;<!=-!>-?!
>/04@<!A-!(-?!A,1/B4@<!C-!8-?!A/$</!C-!A-?
A%65<#!D-!=-?!E'<4@2#0!(-!A-!?!=4F<9FF0!D-!8-?
G/6;H/!8-!=-?!I/<;$#0!8-!D-?!JH,<!K-!C-?
!A'236,<!(-!=-?!=.'L#6<#0!(-!K-?!I#.#2%6!(-!(-?
I;M/695<,B!A-!=-?!C/4;L<#!A-!N-?!G/6%4#0!(-!!I-?
G$,&.;<!=-!C-?!O/1/.:'6<#!(-!(-?!"#4F0!8-!(-?
";6,H5<,B!8-!8-?!A/$#36!D-!P-?!Q9&%6#0/!8-!K-
!"#$67+>.'*,2'6&!Q<./R6,!8)-+
9+::;<:=>:?@AB+,$C+D@/"+!,$2)6E
!"#$67++.#<;./&;./!$-!",F0S!8)-+
9+BA;B@AAB<,*F@:B+,$C+:@/"+&(G,)6E
D<43./!)#9&,94/0/!(%&/4%B#0,:/
0;4-!T'.1./&95<#U#!VW!<0-!V?
XYZVZ!$-!N50%0!

!"#$#%&'()*+('(%(,*++-&.%#/+(%,0,)1#234#,%'56#78"29:

;#<#=#>#?#=
?6@62" # AB # C4DE:7D # 9D # 9"4"2 # 234F62343G # H"I6J # 9KL # M9DN7C2"9O#
9"E7CF9KP # M"FK7 # QR8:462656 # I697"I79656 # SD978CT # $ # UV'+.-)&(WWG#
B32768" # 86IK # F62346L@D93 # EKE7DL"7KX93 # Y"N8"PE72" # E@CJZ62S: # 9"43P96#
F8KN62C[ # 4K8DI768 # \]>^ # 264K9"4S:7D # M9K_K2YK # QB62346L@D99: # F86#
I8KL39"@`9D # F8"26F68CYD99:T # E76E6296 # ZDM43:@`96E73 # F34@D5@KN^#
678KL"9D#(0'56#78"29:#O#+,#564#+(#N2#a#bcdGeOfGgh*iOf'jdklm^#C42"9"4S:7D'#
(-'56#XD829:#O#+.'++^#C78K9"4S:7D'#()'56#XD829:#O#+.',.^#2X67K89"4S:7D'#
,'56 # @KF9:# O # +&'(W # k # # CFn:79"4S:7D' # +%'56 # @KF9:# O # +,',,# /464"[7`E:1G#
B6FD8D493#;I"85K#M9K_D93#EDI8D7"8DL#>A]o'#CXD72D87D#,+'56#78"29:G
p#65@:4C#9"#ECS3@`93#M@6XK972"#2I"M"9Kq#ID8329KIk2^#9"F6@:5"r#9"#
E7268D993#E@34XOs#I6L3E3s#M53496#p"I69C#QB86#7KLX"E623#E@34X3#I6L3E3s#tT#9"#
F34E7"23#FG#(#E7"773#&G

+-#@KF9:#(%(,#8G
!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'
+./0""1".-'2$3456"7%$
: !!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'+./0'482,6,'---
: !!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'.&94/#&6%:'---
!"#$%&'()*+,*#&-&'./+&#/0)-,1&
-2#3'45%6%&+*7")8)'9:'"-3'9;
<=>9>'?3'@7-/-'

"!#!$!%!&!$
'()*+)*,-.+, ! /% ! 0 ! (1,* ! 2345+5 ! 6567.8,759+) ! :;52<=7>6< ! *?4!
+,2.-+)@) ! 1)0@2<4: ! "A,1@5B ! +. ! +,4,395 ! *?4()*?4? ! +,*?7> ! +,1)4+58!
4.(:7,7,8!C4)4,=7>6<DE
F,()2<@,3 ! +, ! +,2.-+)8: ! 1)0@2<4? ! "A,1@5 ! 7, ! (157<@+.++?!
62:-G)*H<!4)!*?4()*?4,2>+)67?E

IJ!A*?7+<!KLKK!1E
!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'+./0'123-'---
!"#$%&'()*+,*#&-&'./+&#/0)-,1&
-2#3'45%6%&+*7")8)'9:'"-3'9;
<=>9>'?3'@7-/-'

!"#$#%&'()*+,'(%((*-,)-,#./0#(+'12#3./456

7#8#9#:#;#9
<=2.52.">?5"#=@24612A#@23B#5"@2CBD#=/0@2EF?556#4"#3@B4/GH4."#I#
A?42J#BKLF?556#./0#HFB>E2.LK#2E2.M6I3/.#N020"D4OH6PQ#R"0F6#SO212#EBF2#
@/TBU? # I5LC?52 # A2J # 73"@1BV # 24@LA"5B # (W'12 # H?@=56 # 2 # (X # 120 # && # K. # B#
YZ[\]^_`a[bcdefbg_Qh[iQdgj # 4" # 0./U/ # 020"5B # B # =20"FOTLK # FLH4"KV # /I#
I"=L42A # =?@?F/3B # 5?2EK/052k # 020"432.2k # /5l2@A"S/kV # 324@" # 5?IA/552#
.LA"1"D4OH6V # K2U" # .H/ # 5"6.5/ # l"34L # EBFL # ./0@"IB # 5"0"5/ # I # =/04.?@0'
>?556A#m"S/25"FO5212#E"53B#N020"D4OH6#0"F/PQ#n"32>#I5?5"SO3"#5"12F2'
T?52#5"#./0HB452H4/#=2.42@5212#@2I1F60BV#32FL#./5#02H/#5?#@2I=2U".H6o
m"=2F61"J # 5" # 5"F?>52AB # @2I1F60/ # 73"@1L # 4" # =@L4615?55/#
HFB>E2.S6#02#./0=2./0"FO52H4/Q

(&#4@".56#(%((#@Q
!"#$%#$&'()*+),)"-&$)./01%1
!"#$%&'()*+,*#&-&'./+&#/0)-,1&
-2#3'45%6%&+*7")8)'9:'"-3'9;
<=>9>'?3'@7-/-'

!"#$#%&'()*(+,-.%%)&*&+%.+%'*%#/01#.&-23#456789

:#;#<#=#>#<
?6514@"/8AB # C* # D568"EFB # /756@3 # GHAI9J@K49 # /01 # E"HA4@G#
756438"IK8AH#1"8AH*#D5E109IK8L4@K#73I92"J#/#85/AB38"88L#/AM32A#4@"@@0#
N # O"B38G # P?63 # E"HA4@ # 756438"IK8AH # 1"8AHQ # R313 # 13S63/0IK834@0#
/3I5/A9/I5889 # 343SA* # ?34AI"889 # 8" # 4@"@@F # .. # O"B38G # 85 # 1365T85*#
?3231UGJ@K49#E#P?3I0@AB3F#B38V0158W0X834@0#S"8BGQY#B3@6"#76AMGZGJ#13#
8"1"889 # 13E/3IG # 8" # 3S63SBG # 756438"IK8AH # 1"8AH* # ?6A # WK3MG # WA80T83#
8"23I3ZGJ#8"#P13S63/0IK834@0#H"6"B@56GQ#/01834A8#E#S"8B3M#E8"FTAY#R3#
4"M5#76A4/3J889#S"8B3M#B3Z@0/#/AMGZGJ#E10X48F/"@A#PB"43/G#3I56"W0FQ*#
["B3U # 734@0X83 # E2"1GJ # P3SM5U58G # B0IKB04@K # 08V36M"W0\QY # 7014@G783 # 85#
/B"EGFTAY#T323#U#R5#85#/A4@"T"J#704I9#8"1"8AH#/AT5678AH#7394858K*#]#
@3X # U5 # T"4Y # 08V36M"W0\ # 1I9 # /A23631U5889 # 4IGUS3/W0/ # S"8BG # W0IB3M#
/A4@"T"J^
_"73I92"F # 8" # 8"I5U83MG # 63E2I910 # :B"62A # @" # 76A@9285880#
4IGUS3/W9#13#/0173/01"IK834@0*

%`#456789#%a%.#6*
!"#$%&%'(')*%+'),-.'/01*2*'+++
!"#$%&'()*+,*#&-&'./+&#/0)-,1&
-2#3'45%6%&+*7")8)'9:'"-3'9;
<=>9>'?3'@7-/-'

!"#$#%&'()*+,'(%(+*--%%%(#./0/&,+1#234#(/'56#76289:

;#<#=#>#?#=
@A62962"7B#C>#D#AE"2#FG4H9H#2HD9"2#D9HIJ99:#2K"D"96L#;K"E5H#8"#
234M62H2N:#234A623N8H#3#9"#9"4"9O#K6A3G#.464"P8QN:1B
R"A6F:5"G # 9" # 9"FJ796MO # E6D5F:43 # ;K"E5H # 8" # AEH8:59J993#
NFO7S62T:#46#234A6234"FQ96N83B

+/#FHN86A"4"#(%(+#EB
!"#$%#$&'()*+),)"-&$)./01%1
!"#$%&'()*+,*#&-&'./+&#/0)-,1&
-2#3'45%6%&+*7")8)'9:'"-3'9;
<=>9>'?3'@7-/-'

!"#$#%&'(&)*+,+%--).+/0+12+%3)/#456#(789#8:;6<=
>"#$#/%(*')*+?70//'%)%+/0+/()/#456#0%789#@A:B<=

C#D#E#F#G#E
H"I:"J@KLMJ # 6;A> # ; # @LN"65 # B:A6@>"4<MLO4 # P) # QA:<"RSL # >" # T)#
Q":45UKL989 # B9V6<"4 # R;@MNN= # 6N= # B96"NKW989 # ;IMNA<<= # 456 # @N;XY)#
9Y94Z=RL54 # WN=I9[ # R<M\A<<= # 69L;[A<>54) # QAR65=NK<O@>K # ] # R"IM@>O#
BA:@9<"NK<MI#6"<MI#B9N=8"V#4#<A4ML9<"<<O#4M[98M#@>">>5#&#^"L9<;#_`:9#
R"IM@>#BA:@9<"NK<MI#6"<MIa#\969#69Y:945NK<9@>5#49NA4M=4NA<<=#9@9YM)#
`9@MN"<<=#<"#@>">>S#00#^"L9<;#<A#69:Ab<A)#`9896X;V>K@=#R#_`9N5>ML9S#
L9<c56A<U5J<9@>5 # Y"<L;ad # L9>:" # B:M[;W;V # 69 # <"6"<<= # 69R49N; # <"#
9Y:9YL; # BA:@9<"NK<MI # 6"<MI) # `:M # UK9[; # UM<5b<9 # <"89N9W;V # <"#
_69Y:945NK<9@>5 # I":"L>A:;a # 456<9@M< # R # Y"<L9[ # R<"SbMd # \9 # @"[A#
B:M@49V<<= # Y"<L9[ # L9W>54 # 4M[;W;V # R65J@<S4">M # _L"@94; # 9NA:"U5Sa)#
e"L9X # B9@>5J<9 # R8"6;V # _9Y[AXA<; # L5NKL5@>K # 5<c9:["U5fad # B56@>;B<9 # <A#
4L"R;SbMd#b989#X#\A#<A#4M@>"b"V#B5@N=#<"6"<MI#4MbA:B<MI#B9=@<A<K)#g#
>9J # XA # b"@d # 5<c9:["U5f # 6N= # 4M89:96XA<<= # @N;XY94U54 # Y"<L; # U5NL9[#
4M@>"b"Vh
1"B9N=8"S # <" # <"NAX<9[; # :9R8N=65 # CL":8M # >" # B:M>=8<A<<5#
@N;XY94UO4#69#456B9456"NK<9@>5)

0*#8:;6<=#/3/0#:)
!"#$%&%'()'*'+,%-'+./0'123,4,'---

!! "#$%&'!5./67$8'99':;0."+-'<"1$3/.4$=%>?
!!!!(!"#$"#%&'()&*+,#-#.//0120.#345#.6#789,:,)

"#$%&'!5./67$8'99':<1@A/'4/."3@?
(-#6;06.<..0=6==<>;?>=#345#.=#@&'3*A)

"#$%&'!B.@+/'@'()':C"0$./?
"#$%&'!9.&3=%/04,7%0"';<
"#$%&'!9.&*,3&4%'D6./E4,

*"+&,-!.#/01/+-2-!3%0-+%4#215-
26+7!89,:,-0/;"#<#!=>!"27!=?
@AB=B!C7!D;2%2!

B(#-#6;0=2<.C0=6==<>6?6?#345#10:,#@&'3*A

D#E#F#G#%#F
HI,3*,3(J" # $G # K # I'(3 # 785L*L # 345'(KM # J # MKA3NA # K( # 5O(P7L3&#
I7&+(**A#I45',O7&*Q#9(#R(S'(PN93#I,I&'&5*L+(#T5,5(U9QNAV"
W(I,7A:(8 # *( # *(7&J*,XM # ',K:7A54 # D+(':L # 9( # I'L9A:*&**4#
N7MJO,3YA#5,#345I,345(7Q*,N94"

2#3&'&N*A#=6==#'"

You might also like