The Salt Lake Route
The Salt Lake Route
THE
SALT LAKE
ROUTE
www.ModelRailroader.com
The Salt Lake Route part 1
The inspiration
for a small layout
M
y wife and I had just re-
turned from a trip to Nor-
way to see the homeland of
my ancestors and renew
the acquaintance of a cou-
ple of Norwegian model railroading
friends. After 28 years of work at Kalm-
bach Publishing Co. as – at various
times – Model Railroader’s copy editor
and managing editor, editor of Classic
Toy Trains, and editor-in-chief of Kalm-
bach Books, the Norway trip was a post-
retirement treat Diana and I had
planned for several years. But now we
were back home and had both slipped
into retirement pretty comfortably.
Then the phone rang.
Model Railroader’s managing editor,
David Popp, and editor, Neil Besougloff,
made a proposal. They wondered if I’d
be interested in building an N scale
project railroad for the magazine. The
parameters were broad, the deadlines
reasonable, and the compensation was
within the guidelines of what one on
Social Security can receive. So after
consulting with Diana, I agreed.
Here was the guidance I got from
MR: The N scale layout needed to fea-
ture modern-era Western railroading,
preferably feature Digital Command
Control (DCC), and use Kato’s new Uni-
track with superelevated curves. It also
had to be portable, roughly 4 x 8 feet,
and be aimed at those in the beginner-
to-intermediate skill level.
Most of these criteria left me little
wiggle room: N scale (standard gauge),
DCC (brand left up to me), Kato’s su-
perelevated curved track (thus main-
line railroading), portable (lightweight
materials), and skill level (I consider
my skills intermediate, at best). There
were two elements that would require
more thought and decision-making.
3. A BNSF Ry. detour train passes under the Nevada state highway 317 bridge in Caliente, Nev.
4,296 feet
Salt
Caliente,
Las Vegas, 2,034 feet
Lake
Caliente Lund
Crestline 6
Meadow Valley Wash
Moapa State
Las Vegas
Boulder Junction highway
Meadow 317
CALIFORNIA Valley Wash
Los 3
Angeles Daggett
Riverside Junction
The Salt Lake Route
Long Whittier Junction N scale (1:160)
Beach Layout size: 4 x 9 feet
Scale of plan: 3⁄4" = 1'-0", 12" grid
Numbered arrows indicate 4
BNSF Ry. trackage rights photo locations
Third Subdivision (Las Vegas – Caliente, Nev.) Meadow
Valley
Wash
to stick with mostly ready-to-run equip- Pacific’s Historic Salt Lake Route. Orig- inception in 1900 as the San Pedro,
ment, that meant BNSF Ry. or Union inally published in 1977, by 2008 it no Los Angeles & Salt Lake RR (soon
Pacific. Burlington Northern took over longer covered the modern era (and dropping the San Pedro and becom-
the Santa Fe (one of my favorite rail- most, if not all, of the photos were black ing the LA&SL) to its publication-date
roads, and I bear a bit of a grudge), so I and white). status as the South Central District of
zeroed in on the UP. During a conversation with Matt the UP (the “Salt Lake Route”).
But where along the UP? Wyoming, VanHattem, senior editor at Trains
though a beautiful state, really doesn’t magazine, he asked if I’d seen Mark Rugged mountain desert scenery
offer a lot of dramatic scenery. North- Hemphill’s well illustrated and com- Salt Lake City is 784 miles (via the
ern Utah and northern California? prehensive book, Union Pacific Salt UP) from Los Angeles, and the layout
Maybe, though the Feather River Can- Lake Route (Boston Mills Press, 1995). MR wanted was to be roughly 4 x 8
yon has certainly been modeled many It was exactly what I needed. Beau- feet. So, which scale half-mile should I
times before. Southern California? tiful color photographs taken along build? For several hours I paged
Mojave Desert, Sullivan’s Curve, Cajon the entire line from Los Angeles to through the book, front to back and
Pass – also pretty well represented by Salt Lake City; a well-written and de- back to front. There was plenty to
layouts in all scales. tailed description of the line; and choose from. I envisioned the layout
In the back of my mind, I recalled maps that include elevations, grades, would in some way be divided into
John Signor’s book, The Los Angeles and mileposts. The text describes in parts, probably by a backdrop down
and Salt Lake Railroad Company: Union detail the history of the line from its the middle, so that meant two scenes.
The sheer rock cliffs west of Stine, Nev., provide a dramatic backdrop for a Caliente industrial area
Union Pacific GP30 and two U50Cs climbing the 1.5 percent grade along the I hoped that I could find similar in-
Meadow Valley Wash in October 1972. This photo provided the inspiration for spiration in other photos for the Cali-
half of the Meadow Valley Wash side of the layout. Note the riverbed with gray ente, Nev., side of the layout. No such
rock, bushes and trees, and how the Meadow Valley Creek disappears from luck. Elements of several photos pro-
view behind a rock outcropping. Keith Ardinger photo vided inspiration, but nothing like the
mountain photos. That being the case,
I let available structure kits determine
what would appear on the other side.
One key element would be the intermo-
dal yard; for that, I’d need a Walthers
Mi-Jack Translift intermodal crane kit
(933-3222) and some sort of office for
the yard.
Engine servicing ought to be avail-
able also. The Walthers car shop (933-
3228) is good-sized, has an interesting
roofline, and looked like it would be
easy and fun to build. Most of us have
more locomotives than we have main
line, so this would also be a good spot
to store a couple extra engines. A sand-
ing tower would add interest and be ap-
propriate for mountain railroading.
At the other end on the layout, I
needed an industry or two. The Wal-
Sand, rock, bushes, and tunnel portals were about all the scenery Dick needed thers Hardwood Furniture Factory kit
to complete the Meadow Valley Wash side of the layout. Pretty simple, except (933-3232) has covered loading docks –
there are a lot of bushes! This photo, taken in March 1992, captured Union an interesting feature. Another possible
Pacific freight NPLAF-15 (North Platte, Neb.-Los Angeles), a unit vehicle train, industry to include would be the Wal-
passing through tunnels 7 and 8 east of Stine, Nev. Dick modeled this scene thers Interstate Fuel & Oil (933-3200).
along with the one west of Stine, shown above. Jamie Schmid photo Finally, a small, modern yard office
along the main line wouldn’t look out
One should probably represent either Ardinger, shows a UP extra struggling of place. With that somewhere near the
desert or mountain scenery (maybe up the 1.5-percent grade west of Stine, middle of the layout, the space would
both); the other should be somewhat Nev. The other photo (bottom), by be pretty well filled.
more urban, including an industry or Jamie Schmid, features a pair of big As far as track goes, the mountain
two for switching and a yard of some UP locomotives hauling a long string of side would make use of the Kato Uni-
sort – an intermodal yard would be in- auto racks through tunnels 7 and 8 east track with superelevated curves in an S
teresting and appropriate. of Stine. The scenery is quite different configuration, with a couple straight
At this point two photos on facing even though the two photos were taken sections here and there. On the real
pages of the Salt Lake book caught only a few miles apart. Keith’s picture line through the narrow canyons,
my attention. The first (top), by Keith includes a small stream, known as most of the right-of-way is single-track
Benchwork
with folding legs
Stener Harildstad holds one end of the
N scale Salt Lake Route with the legs
How to make portable L-girder benchwork folded up inside the L girders. This
month, learn how to build easy-to-
transport benchwork with folding legs
By Dick Christianson • Photos by the author for our 4 x 9-foot project layout.
A
s I noted last month, in May our host, chauffeur, and tour guide. We I did a lot of doodling and planning.
2008, my wife, Diana, and I had first met him in 1984 when he at- I used Kato’s track template, but the
took a post-retirement trip to tended Model Railroader’s 50th anniver- scale is small, so the resulting plans
Norway. We’d long wanted sary celebration in Milwaukee; he stayed weren’t particularly accurate. In deal-
to visit the beautiful home of with us then and has visited us on sev- ing with sectional track (Lionel, Atlas,
my ancestors, and the trip gave us the eral other occasions. Stener models the and others), I’ve found that templates
opportunity to renew our acquaintance- Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe and Union have their limitations. Nothing beats
ship with some Norwegian model rail- Pacific over Cajon Pass in N scale. having sections of track you can lay
roading friends. Stener Harildstad was Not too long after we returned home, down on plywood. Eventually, though,
I got the call from Model Railroader I came up with a pretty good sense of
▸▸ Union Pacific Salt Lake Route magazine with the N scale layout pro- what the layout would look like.
posal. Soon after that, I mentioned the
project to Stener via e-mail. I noted General shape of the layout
January 2010: Design that if he came to visit in the fall, he’d I started out with a box of Kato’s
Coming next month: Track be welcome to help me build the layout; new N scale superelevated track, set
we set up a visit for early November. V11, on a piece of 4 x 8 plywood on the
43"
81⁄2"
11"
1 x 2 cross brace
1 x 2 girder brace
3515⁄16"
Hole for
raised
position 2 x 2 legs
Fig. 2 Adding legs. The legs need to
be absolutely perpendicular to the
L girders for the layout to be stable. Fig. 3 Folding benchwork. This illustration shows how Dick incorporated the
Here Stener is using a square to check folding legs into the L-girder benchwork. Having the legs tuck inside the girders
the position of the legs. makes the N scale layout easier to transport. Illustration by Rick Johnson
L-girder benchwork and nailed the two girders, rather than 3-foot end and run parallel the length of
L-girder benchwork is ideal for rail- screwing them together. the layout.
roads with grades. There are no grades Each of the four legs is a 43"-long
on this layout, and only Meadow Valley 2 x 2. I’m really happy with the result- Folding legs
Wash would be below grade. However, ing 50" height of the layout (leg length, The layout needed to be portable and,
one of the other advantages of L-girder plus nominal 4" stringers, plus 3 ⁄8" ply- when completed, it needed to fit through
benchwork is that it provides plenty of wood, and casters). I’m about 5'-10" a roughly 4-foot-wide door and rest in a
strength using a minimum amount tall, and I found it to be a very comfort- 10-foot-long space (the back of the Kalm-
of wood. One of my requirements was able height to work on, wire under, and bach van). Stener, being an architect, is
that the layout needed to be portable, watch trains pass by. very handy with a pencil and rule. To-
and anything I could do to keep the It’s important when you attach the gether we figured out how the legs of the
weight down would be a good thing. legs to the L-girder that they’re square to layout could be made so that they would
Rather than go into nut-and-bolt de- the girder. See fig. 2. We used two 31 ⁄4"- fold up inside the benchwork.
tail about L girders here, I recommend long carriage bolts to attach each of the There are eight bolts on the layout
that you get a copy of Jeff Wilson’s Ba- legs to the girders. Girder braces (1 x 2) attached with wing nuts. We began at
sic Model Railroad Benchwork (Kalm- attached with the leg square to the girder one end, removing the two wing nuts
bach Publishing Co., 2002). help keep the layout from swaying from at the bottoms of the legs and pulling
Step one is to build two L girders. end to end. Cross braces (1 x 2) keep the out the bolts. This allows the length-
We used 10-foot lengths of 1 x 4, with a benchwork from swaying side to side, as wise angle braces to hang down. Then,
10-foot 1 x 2 for the flange. [A 1 x 3 is shown in fig. 3. The girders are inset with the same end supported (a person
even better for a flange. – Ed.] We glued 4" from each side of the plywood at the can hold it), we loosened the wing nuts
Transition sections
Set V11 included half-sections that
transition from a left-hand curve direct-
ly into a right-hand curve (or vice versa). Discard
At the end of each curve I installed the plug
appropriate half-section to keep the track
geometry intact.
The half-section transition was what Fig. 2 Wire modifications. Kato Fig. 3 A solid bond. Dick used five-
I needed to bring the curve at the left turnouts use control wires with a plug minute epoxy to cement the miniature
end toward the center of the layout, in- at one end. Dick removed these plugs plug to the Unitrack. This prevents
stead of parallel to the edge. It func- so he could slip the wires through the plug from falling out when the
tioned the same way at the other end. holes drilled in the plywood subroad- feeder wires are pulled through the
With the proper placement of straight bed. The turnouts operate manually. holes he drilled in the layout surface.
sections between the curves, the track
fit perfectly along the Meadow Valley would absorb some sound. Molded plas- After connecting the miniature plug
Wash side of the layout at both ends. tic on plywood didn’t seem like a great to the track, I cemented it with five-
Those half sections came into play sound-deadening combination. minute epoxy. See fig. 3. Only after I
on the yard side as well, determining had glued and nailed down some of the
where the molded double-track sec- Two kinds of feeders track did I realize that one of these sec-
tions would end and the single-track Kato has two options when it comes tions was without power. Apparently,
straights and curves would begin. It to feeder wires, and I used both on the as I pulled the wires down through the
was just a matter of which sections to Salt Lake Route. First, Kato offers short holes in the plywood beneath them, I
use. I knew it could be done. track sections with sockets built in un- must have tugged hard enough to pull
der the roadbed for the feeder-wire plug. the plug from its socket. Fortunately, I
Cork roadbed too? See fig. 1. A miniature plug on one end tested the connection before I had laid
I began by tracing along the edges of of the two wires (blue and white) snaps much track. Now the epoxy keeps the
the roadbed of the track on the Mead- into the socket. A larger plug, part of plug from pulling out.
ow Valley Wash side. Then I cemented Kato’s plug-and-play direct-current sys-
N scale cork roadbed along the outsides tem, is attached to the other end of the ▸▸ Union Pacific Salt Lake Route
so that the beveled edge of the cork wires. Since I used DCC on the layout, I
aligned with the slope of the molded clipped the plug off, as shown in fig. 2.
roadbed. I attached two strips of cork It’s important to orient the blue and January 2010: Design
down the middle to provide support the white wires the same throughout the February 2010: Roll-away
and a surface to apply Liquid Nails. layout so the polarity isn’t reversed. benchwork
You’re probably asking, “Why would That way blue is always the same rail, April 2010: Wiring
he add cork roadbed?” I felt the cork and white is always the other rail.
No. 60 bit
Fig. 4 Oh, that’s what it’s for. The blue Fig. 5 Hidden holes. From above, it Fig. 6 Securing the track. To prevent
plastic tool included with Kato appears the Kato Unitrack doesn’t the track from coming loose when
Unitrack is for removing the track clip/ have holes for track nails. Underneath moving our portable layout, Dick
rail joiner. The tool levers the clip/ the track are hollow tubes that Dick further secured it to the cork with
joiner out of its socket. opened with a no. 60 bit. Liquid Nails for Projects.
Fig. 7 Testing the track plan. Dick laid Fig. 8 Spacing guide. Dick used a Fig. 9 Track alignment. While main-
out the Kato Unitrack on the Caliente notecard to maintain proper track taining the desired spacing between
yard side of the layout. He positioned spacing on the layout. The red marks tracks, Dick placed a metal yardstick
the track as far away from the back- of the main line match up with the along the edge of the molded-plastic
drop as possible to make room for the superelevated double track from roadbed to make sure the parallel
enginehouse and furniture factory. the Unitrack V11 set. tracks would be straight as an arrow.
Rust
Fig. 11 Bumping posts. To finish the Fig. 12 Roughing it in. Since the track Fig. 13 Quick weathering. Dick used
intermodal yard and industrial sidings, spacing for the Walthers enginehouse Floquil’s three-pack of organic solvent-
Dick installed 2" track sections with is different than the geometry of based track weathering markers to
bumping posts. He secured each Kato’s no. 6 turnout, the tracks aren’t paint the web of the rail on the Uni-
section to the layout with track nails parallel. The difference is only visible track. From front to back are Rust,
and Liquid Nails for Projects. from the far end of the layout. Railroad Tie Brown, and Rail Brown.
wanted the passings sidings to be as yard to the double track at the right used the bases of the enginehouse and
long as possible. end. The curved sections all had to be furniture factory kits to assure there
As I installed each turnout, I drilled precise to keep the track spacing con- would be room for these buildings. I
a small hole through the roadbed di- sistent. I wish I could say my track even cut the enginehouse floor to ac-
rectly under the position of the wires planning skills made it work, but I ma- commodate the track clips.
attached to the turnouts. I fed the red jored in English, not math, and geom- In fig. 12 you’ll notice that the tracks
and black turnout wires (minus the etry definitely isn’t my strength. It was going into the enginehouse aren’t par-
plug) through the hole and, like the all a matter of trial and error. allel. The turnout angle didn’t match
power leads, left them dangling. Speaking of consistent track spac- the spacing of the track grooves in the
I’ve always liked the look and sound ing, here’s a simple little tip. On a note- enginehouse floor.
of crossings, and it was my Norwegian card I marked the spacing I wanted
visitor and benchwork-building buddy between tracks (main line in red, pass- Painting the rails and the ties
Stener Harildstad who suggested the ing tracks and yards in black). As seen I used a set of Floquil’s track weath-
configuration that put the diamond be- in fig. 8, the mainline spacing through ering markers to tone down the shiny
tween the engine terminal and furni- the yard simply continues the spacing Kato Unitrack, as shown in fig. 13.
ture factory. Getting those sidings far between the rails on the superelevated I started by painting the rails using
enough away from the backdrop to sections. Then, when I eventually came the Rail Brown marker. I set the mark-
make reasonable-looking scenery pos- to spiking down the tracks, I used the er’s tip in the web of the rail and
sible was a bit of a challenge. You can marks as an alignment guide. I also used dragged it along the track. I used it on
see in fig. 7 on page 36 that the jog in a long straightedge, shown in fig. 9, to both the inside and outside of the main-
the tracks going to the furniture factory keep the track arrow-straight. line rails and along the passing sidings
and enginehouse is there to move them and intermodal tracks. I used the Rust
away from the backdrop. Last puzzle piece marker along the diamond, furniture
The passing siding is a little closer to During a visit to the hobby shop, I factory, and enginehouse tracks, sug-
the edge of the layout than I would have saw a short section of track on the Kato gesting that they’re not heavily used. I
preferred, but the curve diameters of rack. It looked like a grade crossing, cleaned any paint off the railhead with
the superelevated tracks on the Mead- with simulated wood planks running a track cleaning block.
ow Valley Wash side determined where parallel to and between the rails. Closer After studying prototype photos in
everything – track, turnouts, and struc- examination revealed that it was an ex- Mark Hemphill’s Union Pacific Salt
tures – would be on the Caliente side. pansion section, meaning that it was a Lake Route, I could see that in real life
I can’t overstate how challenging it flexible length – anywhere between 3" to the ties and ballast between the rails
was to connect, without kinks or gaps, 41 ⁄4". See fig. 10. get heavily discolored as well. So, I
the double track at the left end of the This track section changed every- next dragged the Railroad Tie Brown
thing. In addition to using the expan- marker between the rails. Later, the
Now on ModelRailroader.com sion tracks as “fitters” to provide the crew at MR used an airbrush and
needed, but unavailable, track lengths, thinned Polly Scale paints to further
Registered users can read Dick’s log I used them as grade crossings. So, I weather between the rails and along
book entries as he built the layout dur- ended up using about a dozen. the edge of the ballast.
ing a 10-month period, and subscrib- I used Kato track section 20-048 With the track in place, it was nearly
ers can take a video tour of the Salt (with bumping post, shown in fig. 11), time to try running some trains. Next
Lake Route at ModelRailroader.com. at the end of each of the intermodal yard month, I’ll explain how I wired the lay-
tracks and furniture factory sidings. I out for Digital Command Control. MR
Digitrax
DCS50 Zephyr Digital Command
Control system
RJ12 cables, 48" long, 2
RJ12 plugs, 4
UP5 universal interconnect panel
(remote terminal), 2
UT4 throttle, 2
Kato
24818 terminal joiners, 8
Miscellaneous
32 wire terminals, fork type
Barrier terminal strips, 2
Drawer tracks/slides, 12", 1 pair
Rosin soldering flux
Solder
Wire, 24 gauge, blue Fig. 6 Wiring access. Dick began wiring the layout on his hands and knees.
Wire, 24 gauge, white Then his wife, Diana, suggested he tip the model railroad on its side so he could
wire the layout from a more comfortable position.
Fascia to be
removed
Fig. 7 Terminal strips. A pair of ter- Fig. 8 Position faceplate. Dick used
minal strips make it easy to organize the Digitrax faceplate as a template to
the layout’s wiring. Labeling the wires mark the fascia for the mounting bolt
helps troubleshooting later on. holes and the cutout for the sockets.
S
Union Pacific road diesels lead a stack
ome model railroaders enjoy book Union Pacific Salt Lake Route, train along the Meadow Valley Wash.
laying track. Others get a kick which provided inspiration for this lay- This month, Dick Christianson ex-
out of wiring. I’m happiest out. Then Stener sat down with paper plains how he scenicked this side of
when I’m building scenery. The and pencil and sketched the Wash as he our N scale project layout. Photo by
desert landscape of the Mead- thought it might look on our N scale lay- Bill Zuback
ow Valley Wash would be the signature out. [His vision is shown on page 41 of
scene of this layout, and I couldn’t wait the January 2010 issue. – Ed.] we began cutting 11 ⁄2"-thick extruded-
to get started. foam insulation board. I used a sharp,
My friend Stener Harildstad and I Pink hills serrated kitchen knife (bought specifi-
looked closely at the photos of the Mead- On the last day or two before Stener cally for this purpose – not borrowed
ow Valley Wash in Mark Hemphill’s was to return to his home in Norway, from the kitchen). I’d tried a knife
Amaco
41819M Sculptamold
Bachmann
42506 telephone poles, 2 packages
Noch
58460 sandstone rock wall
Fig. 12 Spreading sand. Woodland Fig. 13 Brush by the boatload. Dick Fig. 14 Bald spots. Where the terrain
Scenics buff ballast captured the look populated the hillsides with Woodland would be too steep for vegetation
of desert sand quite well. Scenics Olive Green underbrush. growth, Dick left the hillside bare.
Talus Woodland Scenics underbrush for the Scenics Scenic Cement so the granules
Once I finished painting the rock brush, but I hadn’t figured out how I’d would stay in place.
faces, I worked on the talus pile. Wood- capture the look of millions of plants.
land Scenics talus was the right color But first things first. I went to my local Shrubs
(gray) and about the right size, though home center and picked out a paint I used Liquid Nails to attach the
pretty uniform. I painted on full- color I thought would look right for the Woodland Scenics ground foam I used
strength Elmer’s White Glue at the base hills and brought it home. When I com- for desert brush. After plopping about
of the outcroppings and then poured pared the color against the Woodland 30 or 40 dots on the side of the hill, I
on some of the talus. To my chagrin, Scenics ballast I’d chosen to use as the broke off little shrubs and stuck them
more of it rolled into the creek bed desert sand, I realized once again that into the adhesive, as shown in fig. 13.
than stayed on the talus pile. I can’t trust my memory when it comes When I stepped back to admire my
To fix this, I curved a piece of thin to colors. Back to the home center, but work, my impression was that the hill
cardstock to generally match the cur- this time with the ballast in hand. had chicken pox. My wife agreed. So
vature of the talus pile. Holding it near Starting at track level and working did David Popp, MR’s managing editor,
the bottom of the hill, I carefully poured up until I had covered maybe a square when I sent him a photo. After discuss-
on some talus. The card kept the excess foot of hill, I slathered on a thick coat ing the problem with them, I decided the
from falling to the bottom. I carefully of tan paint. While the paint was still clumps were too big and too far apart.
moved it up the slope as I continued wet, I sprinkled a thin layer of ballast I left a few of the steeper parts of the
pouring the talus out of the bag. onto the paint, staying an inch or so hillside bare, rationalizing that nothing
When that dried, there were still too away from the edges of the painted would grow on a hill that steep! In fact,
many gaps. I applied more white glue area. That way when you apply more
to the gaps and sprinkled on pieces of paint, you can overlap the paint with- Now on ModelRailroader.com
talus. There are still some holes in the out painting into a “sandy” area. I con-
pile, but the overall effect is good. tinued this process until the hills were Registered users can read Dick’s log
covered with paint and sand, as shown book entries as he built the layout dur-
Ground (sort of) cover in fig. 12. ing a 10-month period, and subscrib-
The predominant look of the Mead- The paint held most of the ballast, ers can take a video tour of the Salt
ow Valley Wash is tan sand and gray/ but some was loose on the surface. I Lake Route at ModelRailroader.com.
green brush. I’d already decided to use soaked the sandy areas with Woodland