Dynamic - Characterstics of Instruments Aug 2023
Dynamic - Characterstics of Instruments Aug 2023
2
Generalized Mathematical Model of Measurement System:-
The widely useful mathematical model for the study of measurement
system (Instrument) dynamic response is the ordinary linear
differential equation with constant coefficients. The relation between
input and output can be written as
d n qo d n −1qo dq0 d m qi d m −1qi dqi
an n
+ a n −1 n −1
+ .... + a1 + a q
o o = bm m
+ bm −1 m −1
+ ... + b1 + b0 qi
dt dt dt dt dt dt
where q o = output quantity
q i = input quantity
t = time
a' s, b' s = combinatio ns of system physical parameters
d
define the differenti al operator D =
dt 3
then the above equation can be written as
(a D
n
n
) ( )
+ an −1 D n −1 + .... + a1 D + ao qo = bm D m + bm −1 D m −1 + .... + b1 D + bo qi
4
Zero order instrument:-
d n qo d n −1qo dq0 d m qi d m −1qi dqi
an n
+ a n −1 n −1
+ .... + a1 + a q
o o = bm m
+ bm −1 m −1
+ ... + b1 + b0 qi
dt dt dt dt dt dt
All a’s and b’s other than ao and bo are taken as zero, the differential equation
then degenerates into the simple algebraic equation
ao qo = bo qi
Any instrument or system that closely obeys the above equation over its
intended range of operating conditions is defined to be a zero order
instrument.
The above equation can be b
qo = o qi = Kqi
b ao
K= o
= static sensitivity
ao
The zero order instrument represents ideal or perfect dynamic performance.
Input and output are related by an equation of the type
qo
qo = kqi =K
qi
Potentiometer Zero order instrument:-
Displacement sensors using potentiometric principle have no energy storing
elements. The output voltage e0 can be related with the input displacement
xi by an algebraic equation:
An example of a zero order linear instrument is a wire strain gauge in which the
change in the electrical resistance of the wire is proportional to the strain in the
wire.
A zero order linear instrument has an output which is proportional to the input at
all times in accordance with the equation
y(t) = Kx(t)
where K is a constant called the static gain of the instrument. The static gain is a
measure of the sensitivity of the instrument.
All instruments behave as zero order instruments when they give a static output in
response to a static input.
7
First order instrument:-
d n qo d n −1qo dq0 d m qi d m −1qi dqi
an n
+ a n −1 n −1
+ .... + a1 + a q
o o = bm m
+ bm −1 m −1
+ ... + b1 + b0 qi
dt dt dt dt dt dt
All a’s and b’s other than a1 , ao and bo are taken as zero, we get
dq
a1 o + ao qo = bo qi
dt
Any instrument that follows the above equation is, by definition, a first
order instrument.
The time constant τ always has the
The above equation can be dimensions of time, while the static
a1 dqo bo sensitivity K has the dimensions of output
+ qo = qi
ao dt ao divided by input.
9
10
11
Thermocouple
A bare thermocouple has a mass (m) of the junction. If it is
immersed in a fluid at a temperature Tf , then its dynamic
performance relating the output voltage e0 and the input
temperature Tf , can be expressed by the transfer function:
a0
n = un damped natural frequency, in rad/time (3)
a2
a1
= damping ratio dimension less (4)
2 a0 a2
b0
K= static sensitivit y (5)
a0
Second order Instrument or System
D 2 2 D
2 + + 1 q0 (t ) = K qi (t ) (6) qi (s )
K
q0 ( s )
n n s 2 2 s
2 + + 1
n n
a1
2 D
D2 2 a0 a 2 b
+ + 1 q0 (t ) = 0 qi (t )
a0 a0
2
a0
a2
q0 ( s) K
a 2
G( s) = =
qi ( s) s 2 2 s
2 + + 1
a1 n n
2 D
D + 2 + 1 q0 (t ) = 0 qi (t )
2
a0 a 2 b
a a0 a0
0
a2 a2
q0 ( s) K
q0 (t ) K = (8)
= (7) qi ( s) s 2 2 s
qi (t ) D 2 2 D 2 + + 1
2 + + 1 n n
n n
Second order Instrument or System
16
Seismic Sensors
Seismic sensors are commonly used for vibration
or acceleration measurement of foundations. The
transfer function between the input displacement
xi and output displacement x0 can be expressed
as:
18
Step function:
e − at
dqo (t )
a1 + ao qo (t ) = bo qi (t )
dt
a1 Dqo (t ) + ao qo (t ) = bo qi (t )
24
Impulse Response of first order Instruments:-
Impulse Function:-
It is defined as, the input applied instantaneously(for short duration of time ) of
very high amplitude.
It is the pulse whose magnitude is infinite while its width tends to zero.
Consider the pulse function p(t) defined graphically in Fig. The impulse
function of “strength” (area) A is defined by the limiting process
Impulse function of strength A = lim p(t )
T →0
Since, up until time T, this is no different from a step input of size A/T,
our initial condition is q0 = 0 at t = 0 + , and the complete solution is
27
−t
KA
q0 = (1 − e )
T
This solution is valid only up to time T. at this time we have
−T
KA
q0 at t =T = (1 − e )
T
Now for t>T, our differential equation is
Which gives
−t
q0 = Ce
28
The constant C if found by imposing initial condition
−T −T
KA
(1 − e ) = Ce
T
−T
KA(1 − e )
C= −T
Te
−T −t
KA(1 − e )e
Gives finally q0 = −T
Te
29
Fig.1b shows a typical response, and fig.1c shows the effect of cutting T in
half. As T is made shorter and shorter, the first part(t<T) of the response
becomes of negligible consequence, so that an expression for q 0 is obtained
by taking the limit of above equation as T 0.
−T −T
KA(1 − e ) −t −t 1− e
lim −T e = KAe
lim −T
T →0 T →0
Te Te
−T
1 − e 0
lim
T →0
= an indeterminate form
T 0
30
Applying L’Hospital’s rule yields
−T 1 −T
1 − e ( )e 1
lim = lim =
T →0 T →0
T 1
−t
KA
q0 = e
31
Fig:1 Impulse response of first order instrument.
32
Impulse Response of first order Instruments:-
➢ The output qo is peculiar in that it has an infinite (vertical) slope at t=0 and thus goes
from zero to a finite value infinitesimal time. Such behavior is clearly impossible for a
physical system, since it requires energy transfer at an infinite rate.
➢ In thermometer example, for instance, to cause the temperature of the fluid in the bulb
suddenly to rise a finite amount requires an infinite rate of heat transfer.
➢ Mathematically, this infinite rate of heat transfer is provided by having the input Ti(t)
be infinite, i.e., an impulse function.
➢ In actuality, of course, Ti cannot go to infinity: however, if it is large enough and of
sufficiently short duration (relative to the response speed of the system), the system may
respond very nearly as it would for a perfect impulse.
➢ Graphical comparison of the exact and approximate response, showing excellent
agreement. The agreement is quite acceptable in most cases if T/ τ is even as large as
0.1. It can be shown that the shape of the pulse is immaterial; as long as its duration is
sufficiently short, only its area maters.
33
Fig:2 Exact and approximate impulse response (more points for discussion).
34
Ramp function:
35
Fig: Ramp function
Ramp Response of first-order instrument:-
qi ( s ) = 2 −t
s
q0 ( s ) = 2
1 qo (t ) = t − + e
s (s + 1) −t
qo (t ) = t − 1 − e
t0
Taking partial fractions and applying
Laplace inverse transform
1 A B C
= + 2+
s (s + 1) s s
2
( s + 1)
A = − B = 1 C = − 2
1 − 1 2
= + 2+
s (s + 1)
2
s s ( s + 1)
36
Ramp Response of first-order instrument:-
➢ The first term of em gradually will disappear as time goes by, and so it is called the TRANSIENT
ERROR.
➢ The second term, however, persists forever and is thus called STEADY-STATE ERROR.
➢ The transient error disappears more quickly, if time constant τ is small.
➢ The steady-state error is directly proportional to time constant, thus small-time constant τ is
desirable here also.
➢ Steady-state error also increases directly with magnitude of input, the rate of change of the
measured quantity.
➢ In steady state, the horizontal (time) displacement between input and output curves is seen to be
the time constant τ and so we may make the interpretation that the instrument is reading what the
input was τ seconds ago. 37
An important property of linear time invariant systems:-
1. In the analysis above, it has been shown that for the unit-ramp input
the output q0 (t ) is
−t
q0 (t ) = t − − e (t 0)
2. For unit-step input, which is the derivative of unit-ramp input, the
output q0 (t ) is
−t
q0 (t ) = 1 − e (t 0)
3. Finally, for the unit impulse input, which is the derivative of unit step
input, the output q0 (t ) is
−t
1
q0 (t ) = e (t 0)
38
Comparison:- of the system response to these three inputs clearly
indicates that
39
Step Response of Second order Instrument or System:-
qi (s ) K
q0 ( s )
s2
2 s
2 + + 1
n n
qi (t ) = 1 K 1
q0 ( s) =
1 s 2
2 s s
qi ( s ) = 2 + + 1
s n n
qi (s )
qi (s )
time
Unit step input function
Sensors and Transducers 40
K As + B C
= 2 + (11)
s 2
2 s s 2 s s
2 + + 1 s 2 + + 1
n n n n
s 2 2 s
k = As + Bs + C 2 +
2
+ 1 (12)
n n
Cs 2
2C s
k = As + Bs + 2 +
2
+ C (13)
n n
if k = 1 (14)
C =1 (15)
C 1 1
A+ = 0; A + = 0; A = − (17)
2
n 2
n 2
n
−s 2
−
2
n 1
q0 ( s) = 2 n
+
s 2 s s
2 + + 1
n n
Sensors and Transducers 42
−1 s
+ 2
n n 1
q0 ( s) = + (18)
1 s 2
s
+ 2 s + n
n n
s
− + 2
n 1
q0 ( s ) = 2 +
s s
+ 2 s + n
n
−1
s + 2 n
n 1
= +
1
n
s 2 + 2 n s + n2 s
Sensors and Transducers 43
1
q0 ( s) = − 2
s + 2n
s s + 2 n s + n
2
1 s + n + n
q0 ( s ) = −
s (s + n )2 + n2 (1 − 2 )
1 s + n n
q0 ( s) = − − (19)
s (s + n ) + n (1 − ) (s + n )2 + n2 (1 − 2 )
2 2 2
1 s
q0 ( s) = − 2 −0
s s + n
2
1 s
q0 ( s) = − 2
s s + n2
Taking Inverse Laplace transform
q0 (t ) = 1 − cos nt
(21)
n − Undamped natural frequency rad/sec
If the damping ratio ζ is equal to zero, the
response becomes undamped and
oscillations continue indefinitely. Sensors and Transducers 45
For ζ=1 ; damping ratio is
Critically damped case
equal to one
1 s + n n 1
q0 ( s) = − − −1
L 2
= te − at
s (s + n ) + 0 (s + n )2 + 0
2
( s + a )
1 s + n n
q0 ( s) = − −
s (s + n ) (s + n )2
2
1 1 n
q0 ( s) = − −
s (s + n ) (s + n )2
Taking Inverse Laplace transform
− n t − n t
q0 (t ) = 1 − e − nte
q0 (t ) = 1 − e −nt 1 + nt
Sensors and Transducers 46
For ζ<1 ; damping ratio is
UNDER DAMPED SYSTEM
less than one
0 1
1 s + n n
q0 ( s) = − −
s (s + n ) + n (1 − ( ) ) (s + n )2 + n2 (1 − ( ) 2 )
2 2 2
1 s + n n
= − −
s (s + n )2 + n2 − 2n2 (s + n )2 + n2 − 2n2
1 s + n n
= − 2 −
s s + 2n + 2n2 + n2 − 2n2 s 2 + 2n + 2n2 + n2 − 2n2
1 s + n n
= − 2 − 2
s s + 2n + n s + 2n + n2
2
1 s + n n
qo ( s) = − −
s ( s + n ) + d (s + n ) 2 + d2
2 2
s + n − n t
−1
L 2
= e cosd t
( s + n ) + d
2
d − nt
−1
L 2
=e sin d t
( s + n ) + d
2
− nt − nt
qo (t ) = 1 − e cosdt − e sin dt
1− 2
e − nt 1 − 2
qo (t ) = 1 − sin( dt + tan −1 ) t0
1− 2
Sensors and Transducers 49
d = n (1 − 2 )
d
n =
(1 − 2 )
n d
=
( s + n ) + d
2 2
1− 2 ( s + n ) 2
+ 2
d
Delay time
Rise time
peak time
Settling time
1 s + n n
q0 ( s) = − −
s (s + n ) + n (1 − ) (s + n )2 + n2 (1 − 2 )
2 2 2
n2
q0 ( s ) =
s (s + 2sn + n )
2 2
2
q0 ( s ) = n
( s + n + jd )( s + n − jd ) s
d = n ( 2 − 1)
n2
q0 ( s) =
( s + n + jn ( 2 − 1) )( s + n − jn ( 2 − 1) ) s
( )
where s1 = + 2 − 1 n and s 2 = − 2 − 1 n ( )
Thus, the response qo (t ) includes two decaying exponential terms.
q0 (t ) = 1 − cos n t t 0 if = 0
•The error signal for this system is the difference between the input and
output is
e(t ) = qi (t ) − qo (t )
− n t
e(t ) = e cosdt + sin dt t0
1− 2
• This error signal exhibits a damped sinusoidal oscillation. At steady
state or at t → , no error exists between input and output.
Sensors and Transducers 56
Fig: Step response of second order system damping cases
Delay time
Rise time
peak time
Settling time
2. Rise time:- t r :- Is the time required for the response to rise from
10 to 90% or 5 to 95% or 0 to 100%of its final value. For under
damped second order systems, 0 to 100% rise time is normally
used. For over damped systems, the 10-90% rise time is commonly
used.
3. Peak time:- t p :- Is the time required for the response to reach the
first peak of the overshoot.
5. Settling time:- t s :-The settling time is the time required for the
response curve to reach and stay with in a range about the final
value of size specified by absolute percentage of the final value
(usually 5% or 2%). The settling time is related to largest time
constant of a control system.
3. Note that not all these specifications necessarily apply to any given
case. For example, for an over damped system, the term peak time
and maximum overshoot do not apply.
1
The ramp input has a finite slope equal to T
is applied to a second order
system, the differential equation is
D 2 2D .
2 + + 1q0 = K qis t
n n
dqo
qo = =0 at t = 0 +
dt
For ζ>1 ; damping ratio is
OVER DAMPED SYSTEM
greater than one
.
qo . 2 qis −nt n t
= qis t − 1 − e 1 +
K n 2
For ζ<1 ; damping ratio is
UNDER DAMPED SYSTEM
less than one
2 1 − 2
tan =
2 2 − 1
Fig: Ramp response of second order instrument
.
1. Steady state error 2 qis .
n
2. The steady state error can be reduced only by reducing ζ and
increasing n .
2
3. Steady state time lag .
n
Sensors and Transducers 66
Impulse Response of Second Order System:-
D 2 2D
2 + + 1q0 = 0
n n
dqo
qo = 0 ; = KAn2 at t = 0 +
dt
For ζ>1 ; damping ratio is
OVER DAMPED SYSTEM
greater than one
qo −n t
= nte
KA n
For ζ<1 ; damping ratio is
UNDER DAMPED SYSTEM
less than one
qo
KAn
=
1
1− 2
e − nt
(
sin 1 − nt
2
)
Fig: Non dimensional impulse response of second order instrument
• The amplitude and phase of the output may be different from that of
the input.
• The output comprises of two parts namely transient and steady state.
Consider the sine wave f (t) = sin ωt, with unit amplitude and angular
frequency ω.
qo ( j ) K
=
qi ( j ) 1 + j
Apply complex conjugate for term 1+jωτ
K 1 − j
=
1 + j 1 − j
K (1 − j )
=
1 + 2 2
qo ( j ) K jK
= −
qi ( j ) 1 +
2 2
1+
2 2
qo ( j ) K K
2 2
= 2 2
+ 2 2
qi ( j ) 1+ 1+
qo ( j ) K (1 +
2 2 2
)
=
qi ( j ) (1 + )
2 2 2
qo ( j ) K
=
qi ( j ) (1 + )
2 2
b
Phase angle:- The phase of complex number a+jb is tan =
a
b
= tan −1
a
K
−
= tan 1 +
2 2
−1
K
1 + 2 2
= tan −1 (− )
= − tan −1 ( )
• The time constant τ becomes smaller the amplitude ratio plot tends to
become flatter, approaching an ideal situation.
qo ( j ) K
=
qi ( j ) 2 2
4 2 2
1 − +
n n2
The phase shift between output and input is given by
−1 2
= − tan
n
−
n
• The various frequency response plots namely, bode plot, polar plot and
Phase angle Vs Magnitude plot can be obtained for the above function.
qo ( j ) qo ( j )
Vs Let M=
Kqi ( j ) n Kqi ( j )
n
Fig: Amplitude plot-Second order system.
n
Fig: Phase angle plot-Second order system.
• A transducer is considered to be good if it has a flat amplitude plot and
zero phase shift for all frequencies.
• From the above fig it is observed that, the amplitude plot is flat for the
largest frequency range when damping ratio, ζ lies between 0.6 to 0.7.
• The phase shift, ϕ also varies linearly with frequency ω for the same range
0.6 to 0.7.
Bandwidth:-
• Bandwidth is used to quantize the flat useful region of the amplitude plot
of the frequency response.
•The input signal contains frequency component outside the bandwidth, the
output will be distorted.
Dynamic Characteristics:
Frequency response:
Describe how the ratio of output and input changes
with the input frequency. (sinusoidal input)
Bandwidth:
the frequency band over which M(ω) ≥ 0.707 (-3 dB in
decibel unit)
Cut-off frequency:
the frequency at which the system response has fallen to
0.707 (-3 dB) of the stable low frequency.
https://archive.nptel.ac.in/courses/112/107/112107242/
https://archive.nptel.ac.in/courses/108/105/108105064/
https://archive.nptel.ac.in/courses/108/105/108105088/
95
• General concepts and terminology of measurement systems, transducer
classification, general input-output configuration, static and dynamic
characteristics of a measurement system, Statistical analysis of measurement data.
Text Books:
1. John P. Bentley, Principles of Measurement Systems, Pearson Education, 4th Edition, 2005.
2. Doebelin E.0, Measurement Systems - Application and Design, McGraw-Hill, 4th Edition, 2004.
3. S.M. Sze, Semiconductor sensors, John Wiley & Sons Inc., 3rd edition, 2006.
Reference Books:
1. James W. Dally, Instrumentation for Engineering Measurements, Wiley, 2nd Edition,1993
2. John G. Webster, Sensors and Signal Conditioning, Wiley Inter Science, 2nd edition,2008
3. Patranabis, Sensors and Transducers, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition,2003.
4. Alok Baura, Fundamentals of Industrial Instrumentation, Wiley India Pvt. Ltd,2011.
5. Murthy D. V. S, Transducers and Instrumentation, Prentice Hall, 2nd Edition,2011
6. Neubert H.K.P, Instrument Transducers - An Introduction to their Performance and Design,
Oxford University Press, 2nd Edition,1999.
7. Waldemar Nawrocki, Measurement Systems and Sensors, Artech House,2005
8. B.E. Noltingk, Instrumentation Reference Book, Butterworth- Heinemann, 2
nd Edition 1995.
9. Kirianaki N.V., Yurish S.Y., ShpakN.O., Deynega V.P., Data Acquisition and Signal Processing
for Smart Sensors, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK, 2002.
96