TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 1

ARE TRADE UNIONS STILL RELEVANT IN CONTEMPORARY EMPLOYMENT

RELATIONS?

Student’s last name

Institution
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 2

Introduction

Trade unions are organizations that represent the interests of workers and negotiate with

employers on their behalf. They can be an important source of support and representation for

workers, especially in industries where there may be a power imbalance between employers and

employees (Visser, 2019). In many countries, they have played a significant role in advocating

for improved working conditions, fair wages, and other benefits for workers. However, the

influence of trade unions has declined in some countries in recent years, due to a variety of

factors including changes in employment patterns, shifts in the economy, and government

policies. In some countries especially the developing ones, and industries that rely on manual and

risky labor, trade unions remain a powerful force that advocates for the rights and interests of

workers, negotiates collective bargaining agreements with employers, and protects workers from

unfair treatment. In the developed countries and industries that rely on highly skilled labor, the

role of trade unions may be less prominent (Bray et al., 2019). Other reasons for less popularity

are due to a variety of factors such as changing economic conditions, shifts in the nature of work,

and changes in laws and regulations. This essay demonstrates that despite these challenges, trade

unions continue to be an important force for workers and play a vital role in many countries

around the world. While the role they play has evolved over time, they remain a relevant and

important part of the modern workplace in many countries.

Effectiveness of unionization

There are differing opinions on the effectiveness of trade unions. Some people believe that trade

unions are an important advocate for the rights and interests of workers and can be effective in

negotiating better wages, benefits, and working conditions for their members. Others argue that

trade unions may not be as effective in today's globalized economy and may be less relevant in

certain industries or countries (Visser, 2019). Ultimately, the effectiveness of trade unions may

depend on a variety of factors, including the specific goals and tactics of the union, the strength

of the union's membership, and the overall political and economic context in which it operates.

One argument in favor of trade unions is that they give workers a collective voice to negotiate

with employers for better working conditions, pay, and benefits. Trade unions can also provide

support and resources to workers, such as legal assistance or training programs. On the other

hand, some argue that trade unions can be ineffective because they may not accurately represent

the interests of all workers, and may be more concerned with the interests of their own members.

Some believe that trade unions can also be a hindrance to innovation and flexibility in the

workplace, and can lead to conflicts and disputes between workers and management. (Visser,

2019). suggests that trade unions may be less effective in today's globalized economy, as

multinational corporations can more easily relocate to countries where labor is cheaper.

Trade unions renewal strategies

In recent years, there has been a growing recognition that many unions need to adapt and renew

themselves in order to better serve their members and address the challenges of a changing

economy. One strategy that has been proposed for trade union renewal is the development of

new forms of unionism, such as social movement unionism and community unionism, which
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 4

focus on building broad-based coalitions and engaging in grassroots organizing and activism.

Another approach is to prioritize the recruitment and retention of young workers, who are often

underrepresented in unions and may have different needs and priorities (Bray et al., 2019). Other

strategies that have been proposed for trade union renewal include: Developing new forms of

representation and communication, such as using social media and other digital tools to reach out

to members and mobilize them for action. Another way is building partnerships and alliances

with other organizations, such as community groups, faith-based organizations, and social justice

movements. Bray et al., 2019 suggests Focusing on issues that are relevant to workers' lives,

such as job security, health care, and education, rather than just traditional bread-and-butter

issues like wages and benefits. Others are investing in professional development and training for

union leaders and organizers to ensure that they have the skills and knowledge necessary to

effectively advocate for their members (Poole, 2021). As a renewal strategy some unions prefer

engaging in political advocacy and lobbying to influence public policy and promote the interests

of workers. Overall, the literature suggests that trade union renewal is a complex and

multifaceted process that requires a combination of strategic thinking, innovative approaches,

and a commitment to building power and solidarity among workers.

Why the union could still attract new members today

Job satisfaction:

Job satisfaction refers to the feelings and emotions that employees have about their work. Factors

that can contribute to job satisfaction include fair pay, opportunities for advancement, a positive

work environment, and feeling that one's work is meaningful and makes a difference. Some

research has shown that workers who are members of a trade union may have higher levels of
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 5

job satisfaction, as unions can help to negotiate for better treatment and working conditions for

their members. However, job satisfaction is a complex and personal issue and can be influenced

by a variety of factors, including an individual's personality, values, and work environment

(Richards, 2020). Furthermore, trade unions have a long history of negotiating better wages and

working conditions for their members. In general, research has shown that unionized workers

tend to earn higher wages and have better benefits than non-unionized workers. This is because

unions have the ability to negotiate collective bargaining agreements with employers on behalf

of their members (Poole, 2021). These agreements typically outline the wages, benefits, and

working conditions for unionized workers and are often more favorable than what non-unionized

workers receive.

Wages and working conditions

There are several reasons why trade unions are able to negotiate better wages for their members.

First, unions give workers a collective voice and provide them with a platform to negotiate with

employers. By pooling their resources and bargaining power, unions are able to exert more

influence on employers and secure better terms for their members (Murgia et al., 2020). Second,

unions are often able to negotiate higher wages by citing market conditions and the value of their

members' labor. For example, if the demand for a particular type of labor is high, unions may be

able to negotiate higher wages by arguing that their members' skills are in high demand and

should be compensated accordingly(Visser, 2019). In addition, unions may also be able to

negotiate better wages by threatening to strike or engage in other forms of labor action. While

strikes can be disruptive and costly, they can also be an effective way for unions to pressure

employers to agree to their demands. Therefore, the evidence suggests that trade unions are
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 6

effective at negotiating better wages and working conditions for their members. However, it is

important to note that the ability of unions to negotiate better terms for their members is not

uniform and may vary depending on the specific circumstances country and industry in which

they operate.

Voice for workers

Trade unions can give workers a collective voice and representation in discussions with

management and policymakers. This can be particularly important for workers who may

otherwise feel powerless in the face of decisions made by their employers. There is a significant

body of research on the role of trade unions in providing a voice for workers. Many studies have

found that unions can serve as an effective means for workers to advocate for their rights and

interests, particularly in situations where individual workers may not feel empowered to speak up

on their own (Bray et al., 2019). One study found that unionized workers are more likely to

report feeling a sense of collective efficacy, or the belief that they can influence decisions that

affect their work environment. This, in turn, was found to be associated with higher levels of job

satisfaction and organizational commitment. Other research has shown that unions can serve as a

source of support and representation for workers facing discrimination or mistreatment on the

job (Poole, 2021). For example, a study of Canadian nurses found that unionized nurses were

more likely to report feeling supported by their union and to have access to resources and

representation when facing workplace conflicts. Overall, the literature suggests that trade unions

can provide a valuable voice for workers by representing their interests and advocating for their

rights.

Fairness equality and diversity

Trade unions can work to promote equality and diversity in the workplace, for example by

fighting for equal pay for work of equal value and promoting the inclusion of underrepresented

groups. Trade unions have a long history of promoting equality and diversity in the workplace.

Research has shown that trade unions can play a vital role in promoting diversity and inclusion in

a number of ways (Murgia et al., 2020). One ways that trade unions promote equality and

diversity is by advocating for fair and equal treatment of all workers, regardless of their race,

gender, sexual orientation, religion, or other characteristics. This can involve lobbying for laws

and policies that protect the rights of marginalized groups, negotiating with employers to create

inclusive workplaces, and providing support and resources to members who experience

discrimination (Bray et al., 2019). Trade unions can also promote diversity by actively recruiting

and supporting a diverse membership, and by promoting diversity within their own leadership

and decision-making structures. This can help to create a more inclusive culture within the union,

and can serve as a model for inclusivity in the broader society (Poole, 2021). In addition; trade

unions can use their collective bargaining power to negotiate for policies and practices that

promote diversity and inclusion in the workplace. This can include provisions for flexible work

arrangements, training and development opportunities, and anti-discrimination policies.

Trade unions may be less effective in today's perspective

Trade unions may face opposition from employers

Employers may be resistant to the demands of trade unions, particularly if they feel that these

demands will impact their profitability. While they have been instrumental in improving the lives

of workers and advocating for their rights, they have also faced opposition from employers.

There are several reasons why employers may oppose unionization. One reason is that unions
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 8

can be seen as a threat to the authority of management and the efficiency of the organization.

Employers may also object to the demands made by unions, such as higher wages and benefits,

which can increase the cost of doing business. Some employers may also view unions as being

too confrontational and divisive, and prefer to handle employee relations directly. There is a vast

literature on the subject of employer opposition to trade unions. Many studies have examined the

ways in which employers try to prevent their employees from unionizing, such as through the use

of union avoidance strategies (Hodder, 2020). These strategies can include campaigning against

unionization, using persuasive communication to discourage employees from joining a union,

and implementing policies that make it difficult for unions to organize.

Other studies have examined the impact of employer opposition on the ability of unions to

organize and bargain effectively. Some research has found that employer opposition can have a

negative effect on unionization rates and the ability of unions to negotiate favorable contracts.

However, other studies have found that employer opposition may not always be successful in

preventing unionization, and that unions can still be effective in advocating for the rights of

workers even in the face of opposition (Richards, 2020) . These unions have faced and continue

to face opposition from employers. While this opposition can take many forms, it is important

for unions to remain vigilant in advocating for the rights and interests of their members, and to

continue to work towards creating more equitable and just working conditions for all workers.

Trade unions may struggle to adapt to changing economic conditions

In a rapidly changing global economy, trade unions may struggle to adapt to new technologies

and business models, which could limit their effectiveness. In recent years, they have faced a

number of challenges as economic conditions have changed. They have particularly struggled
TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE 9

with is the decline in union membership. In many countries, union membership has declined as

the percentage of workers in unionized jobs has fallen. This can make it more difficult for unions

to negotiate effectively on behalf of their members, as they may not have as much bargaining

power as they did in the past. Another challenge that trade unions have faced is the rise of

globalization and the increasing competition from low-wage countries. Many businesses have

outsourced jobs to countries where labor is cheaper, which has led to job losses in developed

countries (Richards, 2020). This has made it more difficult for unions to negotiate for better

wages and working conditions, as employers may be able to threaten to move jobs overseas if

they are not satisfied with the terms of the negotiation. Trade unions have also struggled to adapt

to changing technological conditions. The rise of automation and artificial intelligence has led to

the displacement of some workers, which has made it more difficult for unions to negotiate on

behalf of their members (Hodder, 2020). Therefore, trade unions have struggled to adapt to

changing economic conditions, including declining union membership, increased competition

from low-wage countries, and technological changes that have led to job displacement.

Less relevant in certain sectors

While trade unions have been an important force in the labor movement for over 150 years, their

relevance and influence have varied over time and across different sectors. There is a debate in

the literature about the relevance in certain sectors of the economy. Some researchers argue that

these organizations are less relevant in sectors where workers are highly skilled, have higher

levels of education, or are more mobile (Hodder, 2020). In these sectors, workers may have more

leverage to negotiate better terms and conditions individually, rather than relying on collective

bargaining through a union. Other researchers argue that trade unions are still relevant in all
 TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE
10

sectors, and that they provide important protections and benefits for workers, regardless of their

skill level or mobility. (Richards, 2020) insist that unionized workers tend to have higher wages

and better benefits than non-unionized workers, and that unions can improve working conditions

and job security(Bray et al., 2019).. Ultimately, the relevance of trade unions in a particular

sector will depend on a variety of factors, including the level of unionization among workers, the

strength of the union, and the nature of the sector. Some sectors, such as manufacturing and

construction, have traditionally had high levels of unionization, while others, such as the service

sector, have had lower levels of unionization.

In sectors where there is a high degree of casualization and precarity, it may be difficult for

trade unions to organize and represent workers effectively.

It is indeed challenging to organize and represent workers in sectors with high levels of

casualization and precarity. Casualization refers to the trend of increasing use of temporary, part-

time, or contract labor rather than permanent, full-time employees. This can make it difficult for

workers to access the protections and benefits afforded to permanent employees, and can also

make it difficult to organize and represent these workers effectively(Murgia et al., 2020). One of

the main challenges in sectors with high levels of casualization is that workers may be hesitant to

join the union or may feel that they do not have the same level of job security and commitment

to the organization as permanent employees(Bray et al., 2019). This can make it difficult for the

union to build a strong membership base and negotiate effectively on behalf of all workers.

Another challenge is that employers may use casualization as a way to avoid the costs and

obligations associated with permanent employment, such as paying benefits and providing job

security. This can make it difficult to negotiate fair wages and working conditions for casual
 TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE
11

workers. Overall, the trend towards casualization and precarity in the labor market presents

significant challenges for trade unions and the ability of workers to access the protections and

benefits afforded to permanent employees. Overall, it seems that the effectiveness depends on a

range of factors, including the sector in which they operate the strength of the union, and the

willingness of employers to engage with them.

Notable decline of unions in the UK

External factors:

Changes in the economy: The decline of heavy industry, such as coal and steel, has led to a

decline in union membership in these sectors (Gall, 2001). The shift towards a service-based

economy has also led to a decline in unionization in certain industries (Brewster et al., 1997).

Government policies: Governments have often implemented policies that have been hostile to

unions and collective bargaining, such as restrictions on strikes and the privatization of state-

owned enterprises (Gall, 2001; Heery et al., 2002).nGlobalization: The increasing integration of

the global economy has led to the relocation of many jobs to countries with lower labor costs,

which has reduced the bargaining power of unions in the UK (Brewster et al., 1997).

Internal factors:

Leadership and organizational issues: Unions have sometimes been unable to adapt to changing

circumstances and have struggled to effectively represent the needs and interests of their

members (Gall, 2001). Demographic changes: The decline of unions in the UK has coincided

with a decline in manual and blue-collar work, which has traditionally been unionized. As the

economy has become more service-oriented, there has been a decline in union membership
 TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE
12

among these groups (Brewster et al., 1997). Attitudes towards unions: Some people may view

unions as unnecessary or out of date, and may not see the value in joining a union (Gall, 2001).

Alternatives to trade unions

There are several alternatives to trade unions that have been proposed in the literature. These

include: Employee representation systems. These are organizations that represent the interests of

employees within a company, but are not as formal or structured as trade unions. They may be

funded and supported by the employer, and can be a way for employees to have a voice in the

workplace without resorting to collective bargaining. Secondly, the employee stock ownership

plans (ESOPs) are plans that give employees an ownership stake in the company, which may

align their interests more closely with those of the employer (Chan, 2019). In addition, works

councils are committees made up of elected employees and management representatives, who

discuss and make decisions on issues related to working conditions, training, and other aspects of

the workplace. Strategic human resource management can also act as an alternative. Some

companies have invested heavily in human resource departments and practices, with the goal of

addressing employee concerns and needs directly, rather than relying on a third party (such as a

union) to represent employees' interests(Hodder, 2020). Lastly, rather than relying on collective

bargaining, some companies have turned to alternative dispute resolution methods such as

mediation and arbitration to resolve conflicts and address employee concerns. It’s worth noting

that each of these alternatives has its own strengths and limitations, and the best approach will

depend on the specific needs and circumstances of the company and its employees.

Future of trade unions

Trade unions have a long and complex history, even though their role in the modern world is a

topic of ongoing debate and discussion. There is a wide believe that unions are necessary to

protect the rights and interests of workers. Lazar & Sanchez, 2019 argue that they can be

inflexible and hinder economic growth. There is a significant body of literature on the future of

trade unions, with various authors offering their perspectives on the challenges and opportunities

facing organized labor in the coming years. Some common themes that emerge in this literature

include the ongoing trend of globalization and the increasing integration of international markets

has had a significant impact on trade unions, as companies have been able to take advantage of

lower labor costs in other countries. This has led to a decline in union membership and

bargaining power in many developed countries (Lazar & Sanchez, 2019). The rise of automation

and technological change has also had a major impact on the labor market, as many jobs that

were previously done by unionized workers have been automated or outsourced to countries with

lower labor costs. This has led to a decline in union density in many industries. Many gig

economy workers do not have the same protections and benefits as traditional employees,

making it more difficult for unions to organize them (Kesküla & Sanchez, 2019). There is also a

debate about the role that unions should play in the future. Some authors argue that unions

should focus on more traditional activities such as collective bargaining, while others argue that

unions should embrace more progressive approaches such as community organizing and

campaigning for social and political change.

In recent years, the rise of automation and globalization has presented new challenges for

unions. Many jobs that were once unionized are now being replaced by machines or outsourced

to other countries where labor is cheaper. This has led to a decline in union membership and

bargaining power in some countries (Kesküla & Sanchez, 2019). Despite these challenges,
 TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE
14

unions remain an important force in many parts of the world. They continue to fight for better

wages, benefits, and working conditions for their members, and they also play a role in

advocating for broader social and economic issues such as equality, diversity, and sustainability.

Looking to the future, it is likely that unions will continue to adapt and evolve in response to

changing economic and social conditions. Some experts predict that unions will increasingly

focus on organizing workers in the service sector and other areas that are less susceptible to

automation (Chan, 2019). They may also explore new forms of representation, such as online

platforms and virtual unions, to better engage with younger and more diverse members.

Ultimately, the future of unions will depend on the ability of their leaders and members to adapt

to the changing world of work and to continue to fight for the rights and interests of workers.

Verdict

In contemporary employment relations, trade unions continue to play a significant role in

many countries around the world. They remain an important force for workers in negotiations

with employers over pay, benefits, and working conditions. Trade unions also advocate for the

rights and interests of their members in public policy debates, such as those related to labor laws

and regulations. It is hard to ignore the literature about the relevance and effectiveness of trade

unions in contemporary employment relations. To some extent, trade unions have declined in

influence and membership in recent years, particularly in certain industries and countries. But

then again, they are still important and continue to play a critical role in shaping employment

relations and protecting the rights of workers in other critical industries and countries where

workers still need them desperately. Without unions, workers may also be more vulnerable to

exploitation and mistreatment by employers. Unions help to level the playing field between

workers and employers, and they provide a mechanism for workers to address grievances and
 TRADE UNIONS RELEVANCE
15

resolve conflicts in the workplace. In summation. trade unions remain a relevant and important

part of the employment relations landscape, and they continue to play a vital role in advocating

for the rights and interests of workers in many countries around the world. Despite the challenges

that they are facing, there is enough evidence that trade unions can play a vital role in addressing

income inequality and promoting social justice. After all with the right renewal and sustainability

strategies, unions can be an important force for positive change, particularly in the face of

growing income inequality and a decline in the power of workers

References

Bray, M., Budd, J. W., & Macneil, J. (2019). The many meanings of Co‐operation in the

employment relationship and their implications. British Journal of Industrial

Relations, 58(1), 114-141. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjir.12473

Brewster, C., Millward, N., & Wilton, D. (1997). Union membership and coverage: United

Kingdom. In R. Freeman & J. Medoff (Eds.), What do unions do? (pp. 115-157).

New York, NY: Routledge.

Chan, A. (2019). Labor relations in foreign-funded ventures, Chinese trade unions, and the

prospects for collective bargaining. Adjusting to Capitalism, 122-149.

https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315503691-5

Gall, G. (2001). Union decline in the United Kingdom: A review of the evidence. Industrial

Relations Journal, 32(3), 169-184

Heery, E., Kelly, J., & Abbot, M. (2002). Trade unions in Western Europe: Hard times, hard

choices. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Hodder, A. (2020). New technology, work and employment in the era of COVID‐19:

Reflecting on legacies of research. New Technology, Work and Employment, 35(3),

262-275. https://doi.org/10.1111/ntwe.12173

Kesküla, E., & Sanchez, A. (2019). Everyday barricades: Bureaucracy and the affect of

struggle in trade unions. Dialectical Anthropology, 43(1), 109-125.

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10624-018-9535-4

Lazar, S., & Sanchez, A. (2019). Understanding labour politics in an age of precarity.

Dialectical Anthropology, 43(1), 3-14. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10624-019-09544-7

Murgia, A., Bozzon, R., Digennaro, P., Mezihorak, P., Mondon-Navazo, M., & Borghi, P.

(2020). Hybrid areas of work between employment and self-employment: Emerging

challenges and future research directions. Frontiers in Sociology, 4.

https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2019.00086

Poole, M. (2021). Pluralism and trade unionism. Theories of Trade Unionism, 72-91.

https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003133360-5

Richards, J. (2020). Putting employees at the centre of sustainable HRM: A review, map and

research agenda. Employee Relations: The International Journal, 44(3), 533-554.

https://doi.org/10.1108/er-01-2019-0037

Visser, J. (2019). Unions and unionism around the world. International Handbook of Trade

Unions. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781781009574.00015