Facilitator Guide - Managing by Project
Facilitator Guide - Managing by Project
Facilitator Guide - Managing by Project
– Managing by Project
This module gives you an overview of project management and your role as a project manager in an
organisation. It looks at the functions of the project manager and the benefits of managing by project
management principles. You will also be introduced to different project management methods and
models, including the key concepts of planning, implementing, controlling and closing projects within
the organisation.
Learning Outcomes
By the end of this module you will be able to:
Project Management has been practiced for thousands of years dating back to ancient times. The early
Egyptians use project management principles to build the pyramids, the Chinese to build the Great
Wall of China, and the Greeks the Parthenon.
Project management, in the modern sense, has its roots in mid-1950's when organisations began
applying formal project management tools and techniques to complex projects – for example the
United States Space Programme. The need for project management was driven by organisations that
realised the benefits of organising work around projects and critical need to communicate and co-
ordinate work across departments and professions.
In the modern history of project management, we can see that in the 1980's the focus was on quality, in
the 1990's globalisation impacted on the way in which project management was practiced and in the
2000's velocity and sustainability is having the greatest impact. In order to keep ahead of their
competitors, businesses are continually faced with the development of new, and often complex
products, services and processes with very short time-to-market windows combined with the need for
cross-functional expertise. In this scenario, project management becomes a very important and
powerful tool in the hands of organisations that understand its use and have the competencies to apply
it.
Explain that while it is impossible to learn all there is to know about the field of project
management. Theoretical development and practical experience are continually producing new
insights.
The purpose of a PMP is to provide organisations and project managers with a structure and format that
is common and repeatable, the PMP is not specific to a business unit or corporate department. The
PMP can therefore be used by all departments for projects specific to them or for projects that reach
across multiple business units.
Project management is a process that includes planning, putting the project plan into action, and
measuring progress and performance through the application of knowledge, skills, tools, and
techniques to project activities in order to meet or exceed stakeholder needs and expectations from a
project.
Planning is one of the most important functions you will perform during the course of a project. It sets
the standard for the rest of the project’s life and is used to track future project performance. Project
planning involves identifying the project requirements, establishing project objectives, balancing
constraints, and taking the needs and expectations of the key stake holders in to consideration.
More recently, this has given way to a project management diamond, with time, cost, scope and quality
and the four vertices and customer expectations as a central theme. No two customer’s expectations are
the same so you might ask what their expectations are.
Note however, that while implementing the project, the outcome, time and budget are interrelated, and
during a project you may need to do trade-offs between them. For example, if you want to get
something done more quickly, you may have to pump in more money into your project for additional
resources.
delivers the outcomes, thereby meeting the needs and expectations required by the
organisation, its delivery partners and other stakeholders (the scope of the project)
For the purposes of this programme, we define a project as an activity or a group of activities with a
defined scope, execution timeframe and an established budget. Thus a project must have:
An established budget (in terms of Men (i.e. people), Money, Machines, Materials &
Man-hours – the 5Ms of a Project).
Project Management can therefore be understood as the process of Planning, Organizing, Leading &
Controlling a project so that the defined desired outcomes are safely met within specified timeframe
(schedule) and budget. It is the process of ensuring effective project delivery.
The term project management is sometimes used to describe an organisational approach to the
management of ongoing operations. This approach, more properly called management by projects,
treats many aspects of ongoing operations as projects in order to apply project management to them.
The techniques of project management also help organisations manage and anticipate risks in a
structured manner. Surveys of organisations using project management have shown that project
management allows for better utilization of resources, shorter development times, reduced costs,
interdepartmental cooperation that builds synergies across the organisation, and a better focus on
results and quality.
Check with learners whether this sounds familiar, whether they have ever been involved with or
managed a project.
It is important to clarify that many managers have actually implemented aspects of project
management without even realising that they were in fact managing by project.
Instruct learners to read through the following article and have a brief discussion regarding the
potential benefits of managing by project.
Driving into work one morning, I was listening to surgeon and author Atul Gawande talk about a study
he's done at the Harvard Medical School. I found the NPR story titled, Atul Gawande's 'Checklist' for
Surgery Success, interesting - I think you will too.
"Our great struggle in medicine these days is not just with ignorance and uncertainty," Gawande says.
"It's also with complexity: how much you have to make sure you have in your head and think about.
There are a thousand ways things can go wrong."
Because doctors are human (just like everyone else), they sometimes miss things. So Gawande looked
at other fields that deal with complex circumstances and visited, among others, Boeing to see how they
make things work. He cites the "pilot's checklist" as a good example of how other complex tasks are
completed outside of medicine.
Unlike a pilot, there is no checklist in surgery, just the surgeon's experience and intuition that dictates
how a procedure is performed. So as an experiment, he brought a two-minute checklist into the
operating room of eight hospitals-after having worked with a team of folks that included Boeing to
show them how to put the checklist together.
"We caught basic mistakes and some of the stupid stuff," Gawande reports. "We also found that good
teamwork required certain things that we missed very frequently."
Something as simple as making sure that everyone in the operating room knew each other by name
turned out to be incredibly valuable. Isn't it interesting how similar some of these issues sound to the
work management issues project teams face every day?
Not unlike some project managers I have met, many of the surgeons weren't originally too keen on
operating with a checklist. However, when all was said and done, 80% of the surgeons saw the value of
the checklist. And, although 20% said they didn't need the checklist, 94% said that if they were going
to have surgery they would want their surgeon to be using a checklist.
Despite all the evidence, Gawande wasn't sure that using a checklist would help save the lives of his
patients-after all, he was from Harvard. However he started using the checklist and says, "I was in that
20%. I haven't gotten through a week of surgery where the checklist has not caught a problem."
Like surgery, capturing best practices and formalising processes are critical for success. Like the
surgeon's checklist, the right project management tools can help. Fortunately, there is a lot we can learn
from Dr. Gawande's study. As well as what a heart surgeon could learn from a project manager.
If you were going into surgery, would you feel more comfortable if you knew the operating team was
using a checklist to make sure nothing got missed? I think I would.
Project Smart is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels
to improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those
involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates it keeps you in
touch with the latest project management thinking. http://www.projectsmart.co.uk
Ty Kiisel makes the concepts and best practices of web-based project management accessibility to both
the expert and novice project professional. Ty Is also the host of popular podcast TalkingWork.com.
Projects are performed by people, and most projects require more than one person to perform all the
activities. If you’ve got more than one person working on your project, you’ve got a team. And if
you’ve got a team, you’ve got a wide assortment of personalities, skills, needs, and issues in the mix.
The develop project team process is about crating an open, encouraging environment for your team and
developing it into an effective, functioning, coordinated group. Projects are performed by individuals,
and the better they work together, the smoother and the more efficient the execution of the project will
be. The tools and techniques of developing a project team are as follows:
Training
Ground rules
Defining the project, reducing it to a set of manageable tasks, obtaining the appropriate
resources and building a team to perform the work.
Setting the final goal for the project and motivating his/ her team to complete the
project on time
Project managers are generalists with many skills in their repertoire. They are also problem solvers
who wear many hats. Despite having the required generalist skills, project managers might possess
specific technical skills required for a particular project.
Project managers have been likened to small business owners. They need to know a little bit about
every aspect of management. General management skills include every area of management, from
accounting to strategic planning, supervision, personal administration, and more. The general
management skills listed below are the foundation of good project management practices:
Communication Skills
Budgeting Skills
Leadership Skills
Explain that aside from attracting the right resources, forming a cohesive team, keeping the team
motivated and meeting individual aspirations, the Project Manager’s greatest challenge is
“getting the work done” – all within scope, cost, time, and customer satisfaction!
Direct the learners to read through the following three articles for additional insight in to the
characteristics of a project manager.
What qualities are most important for a project manager to be an effective project leader? It's a question
often asked and one that makes us sit back and think. Over the past few years, the people at ESI
International, a leader in project management training, have looked at what makes an effective project
leader. They quizzed some highly-talented project leaders and compiled a running tally of their
responses. Below are the top 10 qualities in rank order, according to their frequency listed.
An effective project leader is often described as having a vision of where to go and the ability to
articulate it. Visionaries thrive on change and being able to draw new boundaries. It was once said that
a leader is someone who "lifts us up, gives us a reason for being and gives the vision and spirit to
change." Visionary leaders enable people to feel they have a real stake in the project. They empower
people to experience the vision on their own. According to Bennis "They offer people opportunities to
create their own vision, to explore what the vision will mean to their jobs and lives, and to envision
their future as part of the vision for the organization." (Bennis, 1997)
A Good Communicator
The ability to communicate with people at all levels is almost always named as the second most
important skill by project managers and team members. Project leadership calls for clear
communication about goals, responsibility, performance, expectations and feedback.
There is a great deal of value placed on openness and directness. The project leader is also the team's
link to the larger organization. The leader must have the ability to effectively negotiate and use
persuasion when necessary to ensure the success of the team and project. Through effective
communication, project leaders support individual and team achievements by creating explicit
guidelines for accomplishing results and for the career advancement of team members.
Integrity
One of the most important things a project leader must remember is that his or her actions, and not
words, set the modus operandi for the team. Good leadership demands commitment to, and
demonstration of, ethical practices.
Leadership motivated by self-interest does not serve the well being of the team. Leadership based on
integrity represents nothing less than a set of values others share, behavior consistent with values and
dedication to honesty with self and team members. In other words the leader "walks the talk" and in the
process earns trust.
Enthusiasm
Plain and simple, we don't like leaders who are negative - they bring us down. We want leaders with
enthusiasm, with a bounce in their step, with a can-do attitude. We want to believe that we are part of
an invigorating journey - we want to feel alive. We tend to follow people with a can-do attitude, not
those who give us 200 reasons why something can't be done. Enthusiastic leaders are committed to
their goals and express this commitment through optimism. Leadership emerges as someone expresses
such confident commitment to a project that others want to share his or her optimistic expectations.
Enthusiasm is contagious and effective leaders know it.
Empathy
What is the difference between empathy and sympathy? Although the words are similar, they are, in
fact, mutually exclusive. According to Norman Paul, in sympathy the subject is principally absorbed in
his or her own feelings as they are projected into the object and has little concern for the reality and
validity of the object's special experience. Empathy, on the other hand, presupposes the existence of the
object as a separate individual, entitled to his or her own feelings, ideas and emotional history (Paul,
1970). As one student so eloquently put it, "It's nice when a project leader acknowledges that we all
have a life outside of work."
Competence
Simply put, to enlist in another's cause, we must believe that that person knows what he or she is doing.
Leadership competence does not however necessarily refer to the project leader's technical abilities in
the core technology of the business. As project management continues to be recognized as a field in
and of itself, project leaders will be chosen based on their ability to successfully lead others rather than
on
Trust is an essential element in the relationship of a project leader and his or her team. You
demonstrate your trust in others through your actions - how much you check and control their work,
how much you delegate and how much you allow people to participate. Individuals who are unable to
trust other people often fail as leaders and forever remain little more that micro-managers, or end up
doing all of the work themselves. As one project management student put it, "A good leader is a little
lazy." An interesting perspective!
In a perfect world, projects would be delivered on time, under budget and with no major problems or
obstacles to overcome. But we don't live in a perfect world - projects have problems. A leader with a
hardy attitude will take these problems in stride. When leaders encounter a stressful event, they
consider it interesting, they feel they can influence the outcome and they see it as an opportunity. "Out
of the uncertainty and chaos of change, leaders rise up and articulate a new image of the future that
pulls the project together." (Bennis 1997) And remember - never let them see you sweat.
Team-Building Skills
A team builder can best be defined as a strong person who provides the substance that holds the team
together in common purpose toward the right objective. In order for a team to progress from a group of
strangers to a single cohesive unit, the leader must understand the process and dynamics required for
this transformation. He or she must also know the appropriate leadership style to use during each stage
of team development. The leader must also have an understanding of the different team players styles
and how to capitalize on each at the proper time, for the problem at hand.
Although an effective leader is said to share problem-solving responsibilities with the team, we expect
our project leaders to have excellent problem-solving skills themselves. They have a "fresh, creative
response to here-and-now opportunities," and not much concern with how others have performed them.
(Kouzes 1987)
References:
Bennis, W., 1997. "Learning to Lead," Addison-Wesley,MA.
Kouzes, J. M: "The Leadership Challenge," Jossey-Bass Publishers, CA.
Norman: Parental Empathy. Parenthood, Little, Brown, NY.
www.projecttimes.com/articles/top-10-leadership-qualities-of-a-project-
manager.html
Timothy R. Barry is a trainer and consultant for ESI International with more than 20 years of
experience in project management. He has worked with over 40 major organisations worldwide.
With over 20 years experience, ESI International is the world’s largest Project Management Training
and Consulting provider. A comprehensive mix of project management, E-training, tailored corporate
courses, consulting, assessment and mentoring means they are able to provide their clients with proven
methods that enable them to achieve their goals. To put ESI International’s Project Management
Solutions to work for your company, or for more information, call +44 (0)20 7915 5099 or visit the
website at www.esl-inl.co.uk..
An excellent manager taps into talents and resources in order to support and bring out the best in
others. An outstanding manager evokes possibility in others.
1. Creativity
Creativity is what separates competence from excellence. Creativity is the spark that propels projects
forward and that captures peoples' attention. Creativity is the ingredient that pulls the different pieces
together into a cohesive whole, adding zest and appeal in the process.
2. Structure
The context and structure we work within always have a set of parameters, limitations and guidelines.
A stellar manager knows how to work within the structure and not let the structure impinge upon the
process or the project. Know the structure intimately, so as to guide others to effectively work within
the given parameters. Do this to expand beyond the boundaries.
3. Intuition
Intuition is the capacity of knowing without the use of rational processes; it's the cornerstone of
emotional intelligence. People with keen insight are often able to sense what others are feeling and
thinking; consequently, they're able to respond perfectly to another through their deeper understanding.
The stronger one's intuition, the stronger manager one will be.
4. Knowledge
A thorough knowledge base is essential. The knowledge base must be so ingrained and integrated into
their being that they become transparent, focusing on the employee and what s/he needs to learn, versus
focusing on the knowledge base. The excellent manager lives from a knowledge base, without having
to draw attention to it.
5. Commitment
A manager is committed to the success of the project and of all team members. S/he holds the vision
for the collective team and moves the team closer to the end result. It's the manager's commitment that
pulls the team forward during trying times.
Employees value leaders who are human and who don't hide behind their authority. The best leaders
are those who aren't afraid to be themselves. Managers who respect and connect with others on a
human level inspire great loyalty.
7. Versatility
Flexibility and versatility are valuable qualities in a manager. Beneath the flexibility and versatility is
an ability to be both non-reactive and not attached to how things have to be. Versatility implies an
openness - this openness allows the leader to quickly change on a dime when necessary. Flexibility and
versatility are the pathways to speedy responsiveness.
8. Lightness
A stellar manager doesn't just produce outstanding results; s/he has fun in the process! Lightness
doesn't impede results but rather, helps to move the team forward. Lightness complements the
seriousness of the task at hand as well as the resolve of the team, therefore contributing to strong team
results and retention.
9. Discipline/Focus
Discipline is the ability to choose and live from what one pays attention to. Discipline as self-mastery
can be exhilarating! Role model the ability to live from your intention consistently and you'll role
model an important leadership quality.
Excellent managers see the big picture concurrent with managing the details. Small actions lead to the
big picture; the excellent manager is skillful at doing both: think big while also paying attention to the
details.
Project Smart is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels
to improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those
involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates it keeps you in
touch with the latest project management thinking. http://www.projectsmart.co.uk
Copyright © 2002 by Jan Gordon. All Rights reserved. This content may be forwarded in full, with
copyright/contact/creation information in tact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-
for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Jan Gordon is required.
Project management is a tough role. You often find yourself being pulled between keeping users,
subordinates, team members and senior people happy. Given these demands, what do the best project
managers do that makes them stand out from the crowd?
1. Focus on Solutions
Problem solving and breaking through constraints is an essential part of managing projects. Those that
excel as project managers have a mindset where they focus on finding solutions to problems. They
keep asking themselves how they can overcome whatever barriers arise.
All the best project managers understand the need to communicate and consult. They also know that
lots of talking and procrastination achieves nothing. Finding the right balance between consulting,
deciding and acting is what separates the best from the rest.
3. Focus on Customer
In every project there are customers. They might be internal or external or a combination of both. The
best project managers keep customers at the forefront of their mind. They listen effectively, take on
board the feedback they are getting and look for ways of incorporating it whenever they can.
In any project there will be many stakeholders, all of whom will see their issues as being the most
important. The challenge that the best project managers respond to is finding solutions that address the
issues without compromising the overall project structure.
Project managers need to lead by example. The example they set determines how the rest of the team
behave and respond to the challenges that arise. Those project managers who want to encourage
openness and honesty are open and honest themselves. Those that take risks and learn from their
mistakes empower others to do the same.
You can set out the best plans in the world, think about the risks, put great tracking in place and even
then the unexpected will show up from time to time.
Adaptability is a key characteristic of the best project managers. View adaptability in projects a bit like
the flight path of an aircraft. It can be off course along the way but it needs to be right on target when it
comes to landing.
Those that excel as project managers realise they cannot do it all on their own. They recognise the
importance of the collective team effort in getting results. They find and utilise the strengths in
everyone and try to ensure that they allocate roles to those best placed to deliver. They learn to keep
everyone motivated and pushing the boundaries to get results.
Project management is a complex and demanding role. Starting to work on these 7 habits can take you
to the next level.
Project Smart is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels
to improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those
involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates it keeps you in
touch with the latest project management thinking. http://www.projectsmart.co.uk
Duncan Brodie is a Leadership Development Coach and Management Trainer at Goals and
Achievements http://www.goalsandachievements.co.uk . He specialises in helping accountants and
professionals to make the transition from technical expert to manager and leader.
Suggested reading
1. Research paper: Modeling Project Management, R. Max Wideman, 11/09.2003, AEW Services,
Vancouver, BC.
The waterfall method assumes a set number of phases. It is recognised as a waterfall model as the
phases take place in succession. In the same way that it is impossible to swim upstream against a
waterfall, the pure waterfall method does not allow returning to a phase after it has been completed.
Once the phases have been defined and a project plan in place, as a rule, it is not desirable to adapt the
design, thereby bringing a particular phase to a standstill.
In their project plans, project managers must include estimates of the amount of time (and therefore
money) that will be needed for each phase. It is generally understood that time estimates are generally
difficult for any project, particularly if they must be made in the early stages of a project. Both external
and internal influences can impact in the both the budget and project schedule and this model allows
very little fluidity or adaptability.
In cyclical project management, the project goal is pursued in several short, successive consecutive
cycles, with each cycle being relatively short. Within each cycle, a portion of the project is carried out.
Analysis, design, implementation and testing occur within each cycle.
The most important advantages of working with the cyclical method are as follows:
Higher quality.
Cyclical methods of project management are particularly suited to projects in which the goal that is to
be achieved cannot be clearly established beforehand, as in creative projects or research projects.
Take some time to brainstorm with learners the types of project each of these methods could be
applied to.
The two generally accepted models of the Project Manager's role include:
Putting him or her at the centre of the hub, co-ordinating activities between teams or individuals
Project co-ordination
The danger with this model is that the Project Manager can easily lose control of the management
process, as all work is carried out by, and decisions are taken between, parties at the rim, with no more
than token reference to the Project Manager.
An alternative model reflects the traditional organisational hierarchy. This recognises the authority of
the Project Manager, but implies that decisions are taken at the "top" and communicated downwards.
This is unsatisfactory since it ignores the fact that expertise in specific areas lies near the "bottom" of
the hierarchy - and decisions are, wherever possible, arrived at by negotiation rather than by
declaration.
Discuss with learners the advantages and disadvantages of each of these models. Ask them to
think about the types of projects where each of these models could be applied effectively.
The highly competitive business environment organisations are operating in, is forcing them to make
high-quality products at a lower cost and in a shorter timeframe. The growing interest in project
management as a management approach requires organisations to adopt an operational culture that
supports project management principles and practices. Organisations are increasingly using project
management because it allows them to plan and organise resources to achieve a specified outcome
within a given timeframe.
In this project management culture framework we have considered “the way we do things round here”
(Deal and Kennedy, 1982), to this end we will look at the following aspects:
Project process: includes descriptive elements such as project life-cycle phases; results and speed of
delivery; controlled/disciplined procedures; learning and continuous improvement and customer
orientation and systems thinking.
People in the project: refers to people’s behaviour in projects, socio-cultural aspects such as
interpersonal relationships, stakeholder commitment, affinity for conflict, learning orientation, results
orientation, open-systems thinking, team orientation and interdependence.
Systems and structure: includes project methodology, tools and techniques used in project
management.
Environment: relates to internal and external aspects influencing the way in which the project is being
managed: such as strategic emphasis, upper management support; project planning support;
customer/end-user support; project execution support; communication and information flow across
boundaries and general organisational support with project execution.
Direct learners to Learning Activity 1 – explain that as the learners work through this section
they will begin to develop a project plan. This plan will be based on a project/operation that they
are currently involved in. This project should be directly related to their position within the
organisation, link with other people in the organisation and the output would ideally become the
input to another project within the organisation. There are additional sheets at the end of the
learner guide for learners to make notes.
As we have already learned project management provides an integrated framework for project
organization, planning, leading and control which is designed to:
achieve for the enterprise the benefit for which the investment in the project has been
made.
Projects have a set lifespan, with clear phases or lifecycles. There are different types of lifecycles
applicable different types of industries that make sense in specific projects. The type of industry and
type of project will determine which lifecycle phase option to use.
A Six-phase lifecycle:
A Five-phase lifecycle:
A Three-phase lifecycle:
Encourage learners to make notes on key points in the framework in the learner guide Pg 27 –
29.
Initiation
Definition
Implementation, and
During the initiating process, you will refine the project goals, review the expectations of all
stakeholders, and determine assumptions and risks in the project. You will also start project team
selection -- if the project team has been imposed, then you need to familiarize yourself with their skill
set and understand their roles in the project. At the end of this phase you will produce a Statement of
Work (SOW), which is a document that provides a description of the services or products that need to
be produced by the project.
The Idea
Develop a solid business case for your projects. Where appropriate, ensure you obtain
the required approval before you start the project. Research points out that too many
projects are started without a firm reason or rationale. Developing a business case will
identify whether it is worth working on.
Ensure your project fits with the organisational, departmental or your personal strategy.
Identify key stakeholders. Consider how much you need to consult or involve them at
the business case stage.
Produce a written project definition statement (sometimes called PID) and use it to
inform stakeholders. This document is ‘your contract’ to carry out the project and
should be circulated to key stakeholders. It should include:
Identify in detail what will and will not be included in the project scope.
Avoid wasting time by working on those areas which should not be included.
Identify the roles and responsibilities in the project and the project team.
Analyse whether they have the skills required to enable them to carry out their
role? If not, ensure they receive the right training. Check they are available
for the period of the project. NOTE: this includes any contactors you may
need to use
Use the project definition statement to prevent creep. It can also be used to prevent the
project going beyond the scope through its use in the review process.
Identify who the stakeholders are for your project – those affected and ‘impacted’ by
the project. This should be an in- depth analysis which needs updating regularly.
The project driver must be recognised early in the life of the project, eg: a drive to
improve quality, reduce costs or hit a particular deadline. Discuss with the sponsor
what is driving the project and ensure you stick to this throughout the project. Keep
“the driver” in mind especially when you monitor and review.
Instruct learners to work through point 1 and 2 in learning activity 1 – scoping the project.
During the planning process, you will detail the project in terms of its outcome, team members’ roles
and responsibilities, schedules, resources, scope and costs. At the end of this phase, you will produce a
project management plan, which is a document that details how your project will be executed,
monitored and controlled, and closed. Such a document also contains a refined project scope, and is
used as the project baseline.
Delivery Planning
Create the network diagram (eg: Gantt chart and milestone chart) – this is also
understood as the project roadmap. When one wants to create a network diagram, the
following steps must be followed:
Make a list of all the tasks to be performed (the work breakdown structure -
WBS)
Determine which task starts and which one ends the project;
Determine which task precedes and which one follows a given task;
Estimate how long each activity will take. Be aware that research points out we are
notoriously bad at estimating – so be sure that you plan your time as accurately as
possible.
Identify the critical path for the project. The critical path identifies those activities
which have to be completed by the due date in order to complete the project on time.
Draw up a milestone plan. These are stages in the project. You can use the milestone
dates to check the project is where it should be. Review whether activities have been
delivered against the milestone dates and take a look forward at what needs to be
achieved to deliver the next milestone.
Use your network diagram to monitor progress against the plan and to involve key
stakeholders in the communications process.
During the executing process, you apply your project management plan. In other words you direct your
team so that it performs the work to produce the deliverables as detailed in the plan. The executing
process also involves implementing approved changes and corrective actions.
Monitor and manage performance. Use your network diagram to monitor progress
against the plan, remember to involve key stakeholders in the communications process.
Monitor and manage the schedule. Where the project is experiencing slide, implement
change management or corrective action as required to protect the schedule. Use
change control forms and obtain formal sign off (agreement) by the sponsor, before
action a change.
Ensure you review the project during each stage of the project – involve relevant
stakeholders in the review process - check progress against the business case.
During the controlling and monitoring process, you supervise project activities to ensure that they do
not deviate from the initial plan and scope. When this happens, you will use a change control procedure
to approve and reject change requests, and update the project plan/scope accordingly. The controlling
and monitoring phase also involves getting approval and signoff for project deliverables.
Have a clear project management monitoring and reviewing processes included in the
project plan. This must include what will be monitored, how they will be monitored
and the frequency.
Review the items on the critical path checking they are on schedule. Review risks,
review yours stakeholders and your communication plans and whether you are still on
track to deliver on time, to budget and to the required quality standard.
Keep accurate records of your project not only for audit purposes but to ensure you
have documents which enable you to monitor changes.
Use a Planned v. Actual form. It is easy to create – it allows you to monitor how you
are progressing with specific tasks – time and money. Link these forms into milestone
reviews.
Identify with your sponsor the type of control that is needed – loose or tight or a
variation of these, e.g. tight at the start, loose in the middle, tight at the end. Ensure the
system you develop reflects the type of control intended.
Agree on a system for project changes – have an agreed system for monitoring and
approving changes. Look for the impact of the change on the project scope as well as
the “key driver” - quality, and cost and time.
Make certain you have agreed who can sanction changes in the absence of your
sponsor. If you haven’t agreed this, what will you do in their absence?
Set a time limit for project meetings to review progress. Have an agenda with times
against each item and summarise after each item at the end of the meeting.
Report progress against an end of a stage – are you on schedule? Time, cost or
quality? Ensure that if something is off schedule the person responsible for delivering
it suggests ways to bring it back on time, within budget or to hit the right quality
standard.
Develop an issues log to record items that may be causing concern. Review at your
project meetings.
See whether you are still delivering the original project benefits when reviewing your
project. If not, consider re-scoping or if appropriate abandoning the project. Do not be
afraid of abandoning a project. Better to abandon now rather than waste valuable time,
money, and resources working on something no longer required. If you close a project
early – hold a project review meeting to identify learning.
Use a series of templates to support the monitoring process, e.g. milestone reporting,
change control, log, planned v. actual. Apply traffic lights to illustrate how you are
progressing – red, amber and green. Use these in conjunction with milestone reports.
Remind learners that this phase of project management does not take place in isolation simply at
the end of the executing phase, but that many of the activities are interwoven throughout the
project lifecycle.
During the closing process, you formally accept the deliverables and shut down the project or its
phases. You will also review the project and its results with your team and other stakeholders of the
project. At the end of the project you will produce a formal project closure document, and a project
evaluation report.
Agree well in advance a date to hold a post project review meeting. Put this onto the
network diagram. Invite key stakeholders, sponsor, and project team to the post project
review. If the date is in their diary well in advance it should make it easier for them to
attend
Focus your meeting on learning – identifying what you can use on the next project.
Share the learning with others in the organisation.
Check whether you have delivered the original project objectives and benefits and not
gone out of scope.
Make sure that you have delivered against budget, quality requirements and the end
deadline.
Understand how well you managed risks and your key stakeholders.
Prepare a list of unfinished items. Identify who will complete these after the project
and circulate to any stakeholders.
Hand over the project formally to another group (it is now their day job) - if
appropriate. You may need to build this into the project plan and involve them early in
the plan and at different stages throughout the project.
Write an end of project report and circulate. Identify in the report key learning points.
Close the project formally. Inform others you have done this and who is now
responsible for dealing with day to day issues.
Celebrate success with your team! Recognise achievement, there is nothing more
motivating.
Project Organization
Business Case
Network Diagram
Resource requirements
Team Management
Quality Control
Progress Control
Change Control
Issues Management
Exception Situation
Project Completion
Process Improvement
Suggested reading
Explain that in this workshop learners have been given a brief overview of project management
and that in order to be an effective project manager, it is important for the learners to continue
their own learning. This list includes a few examples of “user-friendly” documents to help
learner’s further their understanding of project management.
2. www.projectsmart.co.uk
1. Describe the project structure/ project management method you plan to use for your project.
Explain why.
Which task start the project and which one ends it.
Determine which task precedes and which one follows a given task;
Identify milestones
4. Select a network diagram (Gantts Chart/ PERT/CPM) and transpose the WBS on the
network diagram
8. Decide how to monitor and review your project (what systems and structures will you use)
Reporting procedures
Timeframes
Learners will complete the different elements of this activity as they work through the section on
Project Management Lifecycles – refer to the notations in the specified section.
On a macro level organisations are motivated to implement project management techniques to ensure
that their undertakings (small or major) are delivered on time, within the cost budget and to the
stipulated quality. On a micro level, project management combined with an appropriate information
management system has the objectives of:
(b) customising the project workplace to fit the operational style of the project teams and
respective team members;
(c) proactively informing the executive management strata of the strategic projects on a real-time
basis;
(d) ensuring that project team members share accurate, meaningful and timely project documents;
and
Whilst the motivation and objectives to apply project management in organisations is commendable,
they do not assure project success.
Effectiveness and efficiency may be facilitated through the introduction of best practices that are able
to optimise the management of organisational resources. It has been shown that operations and projects
are dissimilar with each requiring different management techniques. Hence, in a business environment,
project management can:
(b) provide a greater assurance to stakeholders that resources are being managed effectively.
Overview
Company XYZ has been aware that their production of widgets will not continue to satisfy clients’
demands. They have seen an increase of 10% year after year for widgets over the last five years with
no end in sight for the increase in demand. The CEO had asked an internal team to review current
manufacturing processes and propose changes to the processes, along with upgrades to equipment to
meet the demands for the future.
When the team’s proposal was submitted to the CEO, it recommended an upgrade to manufacturing
equipment and a redesign of the production line with no solid metrics relating to the number of
anticipated increases. Also missing (and critical to the outcome) was an analysis of what would happen
in procurement, delivery, as well as warehousing, if these changes were made to the manufacturing
process, and whether these departments would be able to manage those changes. After seeing such
deficiencies in the team’s plan, and with past experiences in such projects at another company, the
CEO chose to engage a project management consulting company, ABC Projects, to outline a project
plan for this initiative. ABC Projects specialized in process improvement initiatives. The CEO knew
that these efforts were more likely to be successfully implemented when run as a well-managed project.
ABC Projects outlined a project plan with tentative timelines and cost ranges until discovery was
completed. The project plan included the discovery and identification of needs for increased
production, as well as identification of affected departments and/or processes, if the increase in
production were carried out.
The project team developed a detailed plan for identifying the stakeholders and how they would
proceed to gather the data necessary to accurately document the manufacturing processes. The plan
included a detailed list of questions to ask each stakeholder to ensure that all interviewers asked the
same questions and gathered the same data. The project team knew from experience that documenting
processes required a thorough understanding of the business, because, when being interviewed,
individuals often unintentionally skipped relevant details. Thus, experienced people were required to
extract information needed for an accurate and detailed documentation of processes.
The project team also developed a plan for potential risks and strategies for managing them should they
come to fruition. They wanted to be sure that once they determined the options for making changes to
the manufacturing processes, that they could accommodate potential changes to other processes. They
knew that changing one process would likely have a domino effect throughout the company. For
example, during one of the scenario planning sessions, the project team found that if procurement was
unable to fulfill the material needs of manufacturing from one vendor, without a back up vendor in
place, there would potentially be a shortage of materials which would cause a delay in production or
costs would increase by at least 30%. This would be unacceptable and would ultimately cause customer
dissatisfaction which could lead to a loss of business to competitors.
Additionally, the project team sent out a company-wide communication so that employees knew what
was happening and why, and they asked for suggestions from employees. By getting the input of the
individuals who were doing the job day in and day out, they increased the likelihood of success on the
project.
The Work Breakdown Structure included several milestones to allow the company to move forward
with working with new processes and upgrades to equipment without interrupting the current
production schedule. At each milestone, there were several tasks for measuring progress and comparing
it to expected results and baselines. Assessments were completed regularly to ensure the current plan
held true to the objectives. At any point during the project, if the assessments showed deficiencies from
the objectives, then an evaluation of the process design and, if necessary, a correction occurred. The
Work Breakdown Structure included training time to get individuals up to speed on new equipment.
The Risk Management Plan included contingencies, should current employees be incapable of learning
the new equipment and performing their role in a timely fashion. Part of the contingency plan was to
use employees who adapted quickly to the new equipment on the new production line and maintain the
old production line with employees who learned less quickly, until they were able to get up to speed.
An integrated team concept, including mentoring, was put in place to assist people in getting up to
speed on new equipment.
Regular status meetings were scheduled with manufacturing, procurement, delivery and other
departments to maintain lines of communication and general awareness of the project status. These
meetings also served to ensure that employees were comfortable with change and were able to
participate in decisions that would affect how they perform their job.
Prior to undertaking the project, Company XYZ was producing 250 widgets per day. At the time of the
undertaking of the process improvement initiative, client demand had just reached 250. Demand had
increased by 10% annually over the last five years and it appeared that the increase would continue for
the foreseeable future.
The directive from the executives was to improve manufacturing processes through changes in
processes as well as upgrading equipment, toward a goal of producing up to 400 widgets per day.
Based on current projections, the company would experience a five year timeline before having to
undertake another increase in production to satisfy growing client demand. At that point, if client
demand continued to increase, the company would be in a better position to invest in another
manufacturing site in order to meet demands after the five year mark.
Additionally, in the current production line there was, on average, a 3.6% defect rate in widgets
produced. One of the directives specific to this project was to attempt to reduce this defect rate by at
least half within the next two years.
Capacity for procurement was limited due to cash flow and budgetary issues, as well as storage. Any
new process needed to take this into consideration once production increased and would have to allow
for a smooth flow between procurement and manufacturing.
It became apparent that once the number of widgets manufactured increased, demands on warehousing
and delivery would increase accordingly. A plan was put in place to change warehousing and delivery
processes to reduce the strain on these functions.
The project had run slightly over the projected timeline, but did remain within budget. The increase in
the timeline resulted from an underestimate of the space required to store manufactured widgets prior
to delivery. This occurred to a great extent because the decrease in the defect rate was .06%,
significantly exceeding the goal of 1.8%, thus causing an increase in the number of widget units to be
stored. Although this was not anticipated in a contingency plan it did not cause the executives to be
unhappy. It was a good problem.
A project management approach enabled the company to meet their production needs for the future,
while at the same time not disrupting their current production to fulfill client demand. There was never
a glitch in the production line while new processes were being tested and evaluated. Continuous
communication ensured that everyone was in the loop on changes to processes and actually had the
benefit of increasing participation from employees on how to improve processes to better meet client
needs. Additionally, continuous review and adjustments to the risk management plan ensured that the
end result was well thought out and tested and ensured that any glitches in proposed changes were
caught immediately and could be addressed.
Adhering to a standard project management methodology enabled this company to implement a very
high risk project efficiently, on budget and within reasonable time to meet long term strategic goals.
Project Smart is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels
to improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those
involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates it keeps you in
touch with the latest project management thinking. http://www.projectsmart.co.uk
Highlight the key project management tools that were implemented at XYZ Company.
Explain how taking a project management approach has improved their productivity.
List the potential benefits to the company if they continue to take this approach in their
other areas of operations.
Instruct the learners to spend about 10 – 15 minutes reading through the case study. They should
then divide into groups and discuss the case study and complete the activity.
Time permitting, ask learners to share some of their responses to this activity. Note pertinent
points on a flipchart or white board.
Debrief by reading and discussing the article “Four Keys to Project Integration Management”.
Ask how the four points highlighted in the article was evident in the case study.
Integration management is the project management knowledge area that includes processes that are
required to ensure that all the projects components are co-ordinated correctly in order to achieve the
project goals. To help you better co-ordinate and manage the various elements of the project, may I
suggest four keys to integration management:
Get Buy-In
Get Buy-In
For integration management to be effective, you need to get buy-in from key stakeholders and team
members. Getting buy-in from the get go will ensure that your project receives the support and funding
needed for it to be successful.
To get buy-in, start by creating a project charter and a preliminary scope statement. The project charter
initiates the project and includes the necessary approvals and sanctions. It gives the project manager
authority to act and apply organisational resources to the project. The charter also defines the
objectives and participants in a project, with the preliminary delineation of roles and responsibilities.
Along with the project charter, you will need to develop a preliminary scope statement. This is a high
level definition of the project scope and defines the reasons for undertaking the initiative, the objectives
and constraints of the project, directions concerning the solution, and identifies the main stakeholders.
The document further defines the project's product or service, methods for approval, and tactical
strategies for the change control process.
With the project charter and preliminary scope statement in hand, you have the ammunition, and most
importantly, the authority to guarantee that resources are co-ordinated and scheduled in the manner and
time you request.
Now that you have a project charter and the objectives of the project have been clearly defined, it is
time to create a plan of attack. Start by identifying the activities needed to effectively execute, manage,
and monitor the project. Project management software can really help with this step and allows you to
plan and monitor the project from anywhere at anytime. The software helps you create the project
timeline and tasks, allocate the required resources, and get the day-to-day status updates needed to
effectively manage the project.
As you develop your plan, verify that your team is all on the same page. Make sure each team member
can login to the project management software and ensure that they all know how to update their task
completion status. Performing this simple step will make reporting and monitoring more accurate and
timely.
One of the biggest challenges you will face in executing the project is managing people, their opinions,
and the changes they request. For you to be effective, you must be willing to make tradeoffs.
Everybody won't get everything they want, but the project should meet the objectives and requirements
established in the project charter.
Orchestrate how the team implements the project plan and make sure they complete the work required
in the Project Scope Statement. Monitor and control the project work by measuring and balancing the
progress of the project. Take corrective or preventative actions as needed to assure that all objectives
are being met.
Use the pre-established process for change requests and ensure that all changes go through the proper
channels before they become a part of the plan. Evaluate all change requests and approve those changes
that will help you meet the project objectives. Only validated and approved changes should be
implemented.
Hopefully, before you ever started the project, you clearly defined what it means for the project to be
complete. As you finish up, verify that all of the project activities are complete and that the final
product or service meets the expectations of the client and/or stakeholders. Obtain a written approval of
the project completion.
Project Smart is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels
to improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those
involved in managing projects of all kinds. With regular updates it keeps you in
touch with the latest project management thinking. http://www.projectsmart.co.uk
Jessie L. Warner, MBA and a life-long student of project management, seeks to promote the need for
and benefits of project management software. Employed by @task, Jessie understands how project
managers and team members use project management tools to plan for and execute projects. You can
learn more about @task by visiting www.attask.com. .
Clearly define the project outputs and identify where these would link up as inputs to
another project team.
Write a short motivation to a senior manager for the implementation of this project
plan.
Explain to learners that they can work in groups to complete this assignment. Each group should
develop a clear (if basic) project plan (ideally showing how their project or project activities
would link to other projects/ departments in the organisation (one team’s output in another
team’s input).
Additionally, groups must write a letter (short proposal) to a senior manager to motivate for the
implementation of the planned project.
Explain to learners that in order to be more effective in developing their project plan, they must
take the time to access and read the material on the suggested reading list.