SUPPORTING INFORMATION

LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF LEACHATE TREATMENT STRATEGIES

Lingyue Zhang a, Hao Bai b, Yawei Zhang b, Yang Wang c, Dongbei Yue a, *
a
School of Environment, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
b
Symgreen Environmental Technology Co. Ltd., Beijing 100043, China
c
Chengdu Xingrong renewable energy Co. Ltd, Chengdu 610000, China

The supporting information consists of 18 pages,2 figures and 6 tables.

*Corresponding author: School of Environment, Tsinghua University, Haidian District, Beijing

100084, China
Email address: [email protected]
S1
Content

Figure S1. Description of specific processes and scenarios.

Figure S2. Ecotoxicity(a), human toxicity, cancer (b), human toxicity, non-cancer

(c) of 4 scenarios.

Table S1. Brief description of 7 representative leachate treatment plans (LTPs)

surveyed in this study.

Table S2. Inventory for operation phase.

Table S3. Inventory for construction phase.

Table S4. Direct gas emissions on nitrification and denitrification processes and

gas combustion.

Table S5. Comparison of three energy supply alternatives.

Table S6. Ranges of parameters for uncertainty analysis.

S2
Figure S1. Description of specific processes and scenarios.

S3
Figure S2. Ecotoxicity(a), human toxicity, cancer (b), human toxicity, non-cancer
(c) of 4 scenarios.

S4
Table S1. Brief description of 7 representative leachate treatment plans (LTPs) surveyed in this study.

MSW* Raw leachate Effluent from MBR Effluent from NF Effluent from RO
Capa
treatmen Locatio Carbon
Name Type city NH3- NO3- BOD NH3- NO3- NH3- NO3- NH3- NO3-
t n Source COD COD COD COD
N N /COD N N N N N N
methods
t/d mg/l mg/l mg/l -- mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l mg/l
Waste-
Raw
LTP1 to- Beijing Glucose 900 40000 1800 0 0.3 500 14 900 420 7 900 3 5 30
leachate
energy
Raw
LTP2 Landfill Beijing Glucose 600 10235 3063 0 0.32 1478 17 900 475 8 900 12 0.3 2
leachate
Raw
leachate
LTP3 Landfill Beijing Glucose 1200 5999 2157 5 0.29 1662 6 967 409 4 800 17 1 200
and aged
leacahte
Raw
leachate Methan
LTP4 Landfill Beijing 1000 4454 1210 0 0.21 2130 12 100 333.2 0.97 100 17.7 0.05 20
and aged ol
leacahte
Aged
LTP5 Landfill Shanxi Glucose 200 2500 2200 0 0.1 900 14 200 700 8 200 35 0 40
leacahte
Aged
LTP6 Landfill Sichuan Glucose 1000 10862 2109 10 0.05 1100 5 250 - - - 14 2 10
leacahte
Aged
LTP7 Landfill Sichuan Glucose 1200 11715 2159 10 0.05 1500 5 100 43 1 100 - - -
leacahte
*: Municipal Solid Waste

S5
Table S2. Inventory for operation phase.

Inputs for Operation Phase (per tonne influent leachate)

Treatment Plants Code Name

Materials Unit
Process LTP1 LTP2 LTP3 LTP4 LTP5 LTP6 LTP7
Direct Discharge No inputs kg -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Glucose kg -- -- 3.54 -- 8.90 18.20 15.70
Methnol kg -- -- -- 3.23 -- -- --
Biochemical HCl 32% kg 1.00 0.90 0.13 2.72 0.32 0.48 1.59
processes coped Antifoaming agent kg 0.12 -- -- 0.08 0.55 0.10 0.05
with Membrane NaClO kg -- -- -- -- 0.34 -- --
Bio-reactor NaHCO3 kg 0.06 -- 0.02 -- 0.09 -- --
(AO+MBR) NaOH kg 0.05 -- 0.58 -- 0.08 0.89 0.57
Na2CO3 kg -- 6.75 2.11 0.60 -- -- --
Electricity MJ 39.13 47.50 43.20 61.53 52.84 92.70 116.00
HCl 32% kg -- -- 0.06 -- 0.32 -- --
NaClO kg -- 0.72 -- -- -- -- --
NaOH kg 0.04 -- 0.03 0.27 0.08 -- --
Electricity MJ 2.51 3.04 3.30 3.94 3.39 -- 4.63
Nanofiltration NaHSO4 kg 0.04 0.17 -- -- 0.01 -- --
(NF) H3PO4 kg 0.25 0.97 0.01 0.11 0.01 -- --
Operation Inputs for NF concentrate
Natural gas kg 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 -- 10.04
Antifoaming agent kg 0.0023 0.0023 0.0023 0.0023 0.0023 -- 0.0031
Electricity MJ 8.64 8.64 8.64 8.64 8.64 -- 11.52

S6
 HCl 32% kg -- -- 0.06 -- 0.32 0.12 --
NaClO kg 0.05 0.70 -- -- -- -- --
NaOH kg 0.05 -- 0.03 0.03 0.32 -- --
Electricity MJ 10.56 12.82 6.76 16.61 14.26 16.60 --
NaHSO4 kg 0.05 -- -- -- 0.01 -- --
Reverse Osmosis
H3PO4 kg 0.10 0.96 0.02 0.11 0.01 -- --
(RO)
H2SO4 kg -- -- 0.24 -- -- -- --
Operation Inputs for RO concentrate
Natural gas kg 12.55 12.55 12.55 12.55 12.55 15.07 --
Antifoaming agent kg 0.0039 0.0039 0.0039 0.0039 0.0039 0.0047 --
Electricity MJ 14.40 14.40 14.40 14.40 14.40 17.28 --

S7
Table S3. Inventory for construction phase.

Inputs for Construction Phase* (per tonne influent leachate per day)

Treatment Plants code name

Materials Unit
process LTP1 LTP2 LTP3 LTP4 LTP5 LTP6 LTP7
Direct
No inputs mg -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Discharge

Construction inputs for major infastructure and equipment

Concrete C20-25 mg 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00
Aluminium mg 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.59 0.43 0.30 0.39
Cast iron mg 423.14 423.14 399.34 479.20 401.49 315.34 409.94
Steel section mg 3.52 3.52 3.52 4.23 3.07 2.17 2.82
Stainless steel (304) mg 143.66 143.66 143.66 189.53 186.19 145.55 223.50
Fiberglass mg -- -- -- -- 25.27 21.98 28.57
Membrane
Copper mg 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.72 0.52 0.37 0.48
Bio-reactor
Nitrile rubber mg 0.003 0.003 0.003 0.003 0.002 0.002 0.002
(MBR)
Styrene-butadene-rubber (SBR) mg 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.26 0.15 -- 0.17
Steel rebar mg -- -- -- -- 200.00 200.00 200.00
Crude oil mg 0.32 0.32 0.32 0.39 0.28 0.20 0.26
Polyester resin mg 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.02
Stainless steel (316) mg 297.14 297.14 11.14 9.14 8.09 7.03 --
Structural steel mg 2381.00 2381.00 -- -- -- -- --
Construction inputs for membranes

S8
 Stainless steel (304) mg 1193.08 1193.08 1193.08 714.04 750.83 824.18 714.29
Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) mg 16.70 16.70 16.70 10.00 10.51 11.54 10.00
Polyvinylchloride film (PVC) mg 100.22 100.22 100.22 99.97 99.99 100.00 100.00

Construction inputs for major infastructure and equipment

Aluminium mg 300.00 300.00 300.00 300.00 300.00 -- 300.00
Copper mg 300.00 300.00 300.00 300.00 300.00 -- 300.00
Steel rebar mg 2310.00 2310.00 2310.00 2310.00 2310.00 -- 2310.00
Polyvinylchloride film (PVC) mg 870.00 870.00 870.00 870.00 870.00 -- 870.00
Stainless steel (316) mg 125.00 125.00 125.00 68.86 66.57 -- 64.29

Construction inputs for membranes

Stainless steel (316) mg 4.77 4.77 4.77 5.71 7.20 -- 8.69
Structural steel mg 110.24 110.24 110.24 131.83 166.25 -- 200.68
Nanofiltration
Polypropylene (PP) mg 300.66 300.66 300.66 299.61 301.84 -- 304.06
(NF)
Polyester resin mg 501.09 501.09 501.09 499.35 503.06 -- 506.77
Epoxy Resin (EP) mg 100.22 100.22 100.22 99.87 100.61 -- 101.35
Fiberglass mg 11.93 11.93 11.93 14.27 17.99 -- 21.72
Isopropanol mg 100.22 100.22 100.22 99.87 100.61 -- 101.35
Phosphoric acid mg 100.22 100.22 100.22 99.87 100.61 -- 101.35
Polyvinylchloride film (PVC) mg 300.66 300.66 300.66 299.61 301.84 -- 304.06
Construction inputs for NF concentrate
Cast iron mg 977.14 977.14 977.14 977.14 977.14 -- 1302.86
Stainless steel (304) mg 2571.45 2571.45 2571.45 2571.45 2571.45 -- 3428.60
Stainless steel (316) mg 2575.50 2575.50 2575.50 2575.50 2575.50 -- 3434.00

S9
 Construction inputs for major infastructure and equipment
Stainless steel (316) mg 142.85 142.85 142.85 211.14 303.37 395.60 --
Steel rebar mg 4390.00 4390.00 4390.00 4390.00 4390.00 4390.00 --
Cast iron mg 33.00 33.00 33.00 33.00 33.00 33.00 --

Construction inputs for membranes

Stainless steel (316) mg 9.54 9.54 9.54 17.17 11.88 6.59 --
Structural steel mg 220.37 220.37 220.37 396.65 274.48 152.31 --
Reverse Fiberglass mg 23.85 23.85 23.85 42.92 29.70 16.48 --
Osmosis (RO) Epoxy resin mg 11319.87 11319.87 11319.87 11318.58 11309.29 11300.00 --
Ethylene propylene diene --
mg 5008.79 5008.79 5008.79 5008.22 5004.11 5000.00
(EPDM)
Polyester resin mg 8014.06 8014.06 8014.06 8013.16 8006.58 8000.00 --
Polypropylene (PP) mg 2003.52 2003.52 2003.52 2003.29 2001.64 2000.00 --
Construction inputs for RO concentrate
Cast iron mg 1628.57 1628.57 1628.57 1628.57 1628.57 1954.29 --
Stainless steel (304) mg 4285.75 4285.75 4285.75 4285.75 4285.75 5142.90 --
Stainless steel (316) mg 4292.50 4292.50 4292.50 4292.50 4292.50 5151.00 --
*Lifetime of all plants are set as 20 years.

S10
Table S4. Direct gas emissions on nitrification and denitrification processes and gas combustion.

Energy alternatives 1
AO+MBR NF RO
Unit Leachate anerobic AO
SCE treatment SCE treatment
(per tonne digestion (N&D*
Scenarios Name (Natural gas combustion) (Natural gas combustion)
influent (Biogas combustion) processes)
leachate)
N2O CH4 N2O CO2 N2O CH4 CO2 N2O CH4

LTP1 g 14.37 315.43 26.6 -- -- -- -- -- --

LTP2 g 2.24 49.06 64.4 -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 -- -- -- -- -- --
Scenario
LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 -- -- -- -- -- --
2
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP6 g -- -- 55.9 -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP7 g -- -- 61.9 -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP1 g 14.37 315.43 26.6 20958.25 0.04 0.37 -- -- --
LTP2 g 2.24 49.06 64.4 20958.25 0.04 0.37 -- -- --
Scenario LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 20958.25 0.04 0.37 -- -- --
3 LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 20958.25 0.04 0.37 -- -- --
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 20958.25 0.04 0.37 -- -- --
LTP7 g -- -- 61.9 27944.33 0.05 0.5 -- -- --
LTP1 g 14.37 315.43 26.6 20958.25 0.04 0.37 34910.45 0.06 0.62
LTP2 g 2.24 49.06 64.4 20958.25 0.04 0.37 34910.45 0.06 0.62
Scenario
LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 20958.25 0.04 0.37 34910.45 0.06 0.62
4
LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 20958.25 0.04 0.37 34910.45 0.06 0.62
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 20958.25 0.04 0.37 34910.45 0.06 0.62

S11
 LTP6 g -- -- 55.9 -- -- -- 41916.49 0.07 0.75

Energy alternatives 2
AO+MBR NF RO
Unit Leachate anerobic AO
SCE treatment SCE treatment
(per tonne digestion (N&D*
Scenarios Name (Biogas combustion) Biogas combustion)
influent (Biogas combustion) processes)
leachate)
N2O CH4 N2O N2O CH4 N2O CH4

LTP1 g 14.37 315.43 26.6 -- -- -- --

LTP2 g 2.24 49.06 64.4 -- -- -- --
LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 -- -- -- --
Scenario 2 LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 -- -- -- --
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 -- -- -- --
LTP6 g -- -- 55.9 -- -- -- --
LTP7 g -- -- 61.9 -- -- -- --
LTP1 g -- -- 26.6 14.37 315.43 -- --
LTP2 g -- -- 64.4 13.22 290.02 -- --
LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 13.22 290.02 -- --
Scenario 3
LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 13.22 290.02 -- --
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 13.22 290.02 -- --
LTP7 g -- -- 61.9 17.62 386.69 -- --
LTP1 g -- -- 26.6 13.22 290.02 22.01 483.09
LTP2 g -- -- 64.4 13.22 290.02 22.01 483.09
LTP3 g -- -- 35.7 13.22 290.02 22.01 483.09
Scenario 4
LTP4 g -- -- 32.9 13.22 290.02 22.01 483.09
LTP5 g -- -- 59.6 13.22 290.02 22.01 483.09
LTP6 g -- -- 55.9 -- -- 26.43 580.03
S12
 Energy alternatives 3
AO+MBR NF RO
Unit Leachate
(per anerobic AO SCE treatment SCE treatment
Scenarios Name tonne digestion
influent Biogas (N&D* Natural gas Biogas Natural gas Biogas
leachate) combustion processes) combustion combustion combustion combustion
N2O CH4 N2O CO2 N2O CH4 N2O CH4 CO2 N2O CH4 N2O CH4
Scenario LTP1 g 14.37 315.43 26.6 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
2 LTP2 g 2.24 49.06 64.4 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Scenario LTP1 g 26.6 -- -- -- 14.37 315.43 -- -- -- -- --
3 LTP2 g 64.4 17412.9 0.03 0.31 2.24 49.06 -- -- -- -- --
Scenario LTP1 g 26.6 12410.13 0.02 0.22 5.39 118.29 20663.58 0.04 0.37 8.98 197.15
4 LTP2 g 64.4 19628.75 0.03 0.35 0.84 18.4 32694.62 0.06 0.58 1.4 30.66
*Nitrification and denitrification

S13
Table S5. Comparison of three energy supply alternatives.
AP FAETP MAETP Ecotoxicity Human cancer Human non-canc.
-9
Scenario kg SO2 eq. kg DCB eq. kg DCB eq. CTUe CTUh×10 CTUh×10-9
Name
s Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternat Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternati Alternati
ve 1 ve 2 ve 1 ve 2 ve 1 ve 2 ive 1 ve 2 ve 1 ve 2 ve 1 ve 2
LTP1 0.05 0.05 0.12 0.12 2136.46 2136.46 0.01 0.01 1.71 1.71 0.17 0.17
LTP2 0.11 0.11 0.15 0.15 2674.10 2674.10 0.01 0.01 1.99 1.99 0.21 0.21
LTP3 0.08 0.08 0.25 0.25 2554.83 2554.83 0.01 0.01 2.05 2.05 0.19 0.19
Scenario
LTP4 0.09 0.09 0.19 0.19 3426.97 3426.97 0.01 0.01 2.53 2.53 0.26 0.26
2
LTP5 0.09 0.09 0.47 0.47 3340.11 3340.11 0.03 0.03 3.15 3.15 0.25 0.25
LTP6 0.15 0.15 0.89 0.89 5880.62 5880.62 0.03 0.03 4.74 4.74 0.42 0.42
LTP7 0.18 0.18 0.88 0.88 7020.79 7020.79 0.03 0.03 5.33 5.33 0.51 0.51
LTP1 0.08 0.07 0.18 0.16 2861.94 2995.71 0.02 0.01 2.81 2.68 0.22 0.22
LTP2 0.16 0.16 0.23 0.26 3630.83 5461.51 0.03 0.06 3.37 12.15 0.27 0.40
Scenario LTP3 0.10 0.10 0.32 0.35 3278.95 5355.88 0.02 0.06 3.13 13.72 0.25 0.40
3 LTP4 0.12 0.12 0.26 0.29 4219.74 6436.99 0.03 0.06 3.68 14.27 0.33 0.48
LTP5 0.12 0.12 0.53 0.56 4081.26 6298.51 0.04 0.08 4.26 14.85 0.30 0.46
LTP7 0.21 0.21 0.96 1.01 7988.10 10944.43 0.05 0.10 6.68 20.80 0.59 0.80
LTP1 0.13 0.12 0.30 0.33 4350.66 7977.39 0.05 0.09 4.33 20.90 0.34 0.58
LTP2 0.23 0.23 0.37 0.44 5391.57 10673.88 0.07 0.15 5.12 30.40 0.40 0.77
Scenario LTP3 0.15 0.15 0.42 0.51 4549.16 10319.33 0.05 0.14 4.50 32.73 0.35 0.76
4 LTP4 0.18 0.18 0.40 0.48 6024.81 11935.30 0.05 0.15 5.39 33.61 0.47 0.88
LTP5 0.17 0.17 0.66 0.75 5766.58 11677.07 0.07 0.16 5.91 34.13 0.44 0.85
LTP6 0.21 0.21 1.05 1.11 7845.20 12279.61 0.06 0.13 6.66 27.84 0.58 0.89

S14
 Human Human non-
EP GWP AP FAETP MAETP Ecotoxicity
cancer canc.
Scenario kg P eq. kg CO2 eq. kg SO2 eq. kg DCB eq. kg DCB eq. CTUe CTUh×10-9 CTUh×10-9
Name
s Alter Alter Alter Alte Alte Alter Alter Alter Alter Alte Alter Alter
Altern Altern Alternat Alternati
nativ nativ nativ rnati rnati nativ nativ nativ nativ rnati native native
ative 1 ative 3 ive 1 ve 3
e1 e3 e1 ve 3 ve 1 e3 e1 e3 e1 ve 3 1 3
Scenario LTP1 1.47 1.47 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
1 LTP2 1.24 1.24 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Scenario LTP1 0.12 0.12 32.28 32.28 0.05 0.05 0.12 0.12 2136.46 2136.46 0.01 0.01 1.71 1.71 0.17 0.17
2 LTP2 0.16 0.16 43.62 43.62 0.11 0.11 0.15 0.15 2674.10 2674.10 0.01 0.01 1.99 1.99 0.21 0.21
Scenario LTP1 0.12 0.12 63.66 36.36 0.08 0.07 0.18 0.16 2861.94 2793.95 0.02 0.01 2.81 2.68 0.22 0.22
3 LTP2 0.14 0.14 79.08 74.47 0.16 0.22 0.23 0.23 3630.83 3619.36 0.03 0.03 3.37 3.35 0.27 0.27
Scenario LTP1 0.03 0.03 117.28 87.59 0.13 0.23 0.30 0.28 4350.66 4276.71 0.05 0.03 4.33 4.19 0.34 0.33
4 LTP2 0.04 0.04 135.45 129.18 0.23 0.40 0.37 0.37 5391.57 5372.88 0.07 0.06 5.12 5.08 0.40 0.40

S15
Table S6. Ranges of parameters for uncertainty analysis.

Ranges of input parameters for uncertainty analysis

Electricity Electricity Electricity Electricity Electricity
Antifoam Glucose Methanol
(AO+MBR) (NF) (RO) (NF SCE) (RO SCE)
Scenarios Name
kg/t kg/t kg/t MJ/t MJ/t MJ/t MJ/t MJ/t
Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max
LTP1 0.10 0.14 -- -- -- -- 31.31 46.96 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP2 -- -- -- -- -- -- 38.00 57.00 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP3 -- -- 0.93 6.89 -- -- 34.56 51.84 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Scenario 2 LTP4 0.07 0.10 -- -- 0.00 6.30 49.22 73.84 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP5 0.44 0.66 3.89 9.63 -- -- 42.27 63.41 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP6 0.08 0.12 3.70 19.11 -- -- 74.16 111.24 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP7 0.04 0.06 3.52 16.49 -- -- 92.80 139.20 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
LTP1 0.10 0.14 -- -- -- -- 31.31 46.96 2.01 3.01 -- -- 7.78 9.50 -- --
LTP2 -- -- -- -- -- -- 38.00 57.00 2.43 3.65 -- -- 7.78 9.50 -- --
LTP3 -- -- 0.93 6.89 -- -- 34.56 51.84 2.64 3.96 -- -- 7.78 9.50 -- --
Scenario 3
LTP4 0.07 0.10 -- -- 0.00 6.30 49.22 73.84 3.15 4.73 -- -- 7.78 9.50 -- --
LTP5 0.44 0.66 3.89 9.63 -- -- 42.27 63.41 2.71 4.06 -- -- 7.78 9.50 -- --
LTP7 0.04 0.06 3.52 16.49 -- -- 92.80 139.20 3.70 5.56 -- -- 10.37 12.67 -- --
LTP1 0.10 0.14 -- -- -- -- 31.31 46.96 2.01 3.01 8.45 12.67 7.78 9.50 12.96 15.84
LTP2 -- -- -- -- -- -- 38.00 57.00 2.43 3.65 10.26 15.38 7.78 9.50 12.96 15.84
Scenario 4 LTP3 -- -- 0.93 6.89 -- -- 34.56 51.84 2.64 3.96 5.41 8.11 7.78 9.50 12.96 15.84
LTP4 0.07 0.10 -- -- 0.00 6.30 49.22 73.84 3.15 4.73 13.29 19.93 7.78 9.50 12.96 15.84
LTP5 0.44 0.66 3.89 9.63 -- -- 42.27 63.41 2.71 4.06 11.41 17.11 7.78 9.50 12.96 15.84

S16
 LTP6 0.08 0.12 3.70 19.11 -- -- 74.16 111.24 -- -- 13.28 19.92 -- -- 15.55 19.01

Ranges of emission parameters for uncertainty analysis

CH4 emission N2O emission
COD Emission Ammonia Emission Nitrate Emission
(AO+MBR) (AO+MBR)
Scenarios Name
g/t g/t kg/t kg/t kg/t
Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min Max
LTP1 -- -- -- -- 30000 50000 1600 2200 0 0
LTP2 -- -- -- -- 8100 13500 2150 3350 0 0
LTP3 -- -- -- -- 4750 7000 1650 2500 0 10
Scenario 1 LTP4 -- -- -- -- 3000 6000 1000 1550 0 0
LTP5 -- -- -- -- 2000 3500 1750 2500 0 0
LTP6 -- -- -- -- 8000 14000 1700 2200 5 20
LTP7 -- -- -- -- 8000 15000 1700 2300 5 20
LTP1 227.32 403.54 24.61 60.24 425 600 5 25 800 1100
LTP2 30.25 77.83 32.13 79.90 1000 1650 5 25 800 1100
LTP3 -- -- 16.20 51.27 1250 2000 1 10 800 1100
Scenario 2 LTP4 -- -- 25.80 43.95 1650 2500 5 20 80 120
LTP5 -- -- 42.75 70.35 700 1200 5 25 150 300
LTP6 -- -- 41.85 60.57 900 1300 1 10 200 300
LTP7 -- -- 46.35 67.17 1200 1800 1 10 80 150
LTP1 227.32 403.54 24.61 60.24 350 550 1 15 800 1100
LTP2 30.25 77.83 32.13 79.90 350 550 1 15 800 1100
Scenario 3 LTP3 -- -- 16.20 51.27 350 550 1 15 700 1000
LTP4 -- -- 25.80 43.95 255 400 0.5 5 80 120
LTP5 -- -- 42.75 70.35 550 800 1 15 150 250

S17
 LTP7 -- -- 46.35 67.17 25 60 0.5 5 80 120
LTP1 227.32 403.54 24.61 60.24 1 10 1 10 15 40
LTP2 30.25 77.83 32.13 79.90 5 25 0.1 5 1 20
LTP3 -- -- 16.20 51.27 5 25 0.05 5 150 250
Scenario 4
LTP4 -- -- 25.80 43.95 10 25 0.01 5 10 30
LTP5 -- -- 42.75 70.35 25 40 0 0 20 50
LTP6 -- -- 41.85 60.57 5 25 0.05 5 5 25

S18