SMLL
SMLL
To cite this article: Hongmei Qiu, Xuechun Wang & Yan Shao (2023) Forward and reverse
typing discrepancy and crossmatch incompatibility of ABO blood groups: cause analysis and
treatment, Hematology, 28:1, 2240146, DOI: 10.1080/16078454.2023.2240146
Figure 1. The flowchart about blood crossmatch incompatibility test. DAT: direct antiglobulin test; IAT: indirect antiglobulin test;
BCEIRRS: blood crossmatch by examining the interaction between the recipient’s RBCs and serum.
(2) Observe the results of all test tubes for 1 min, and autoantibody and warm autoantibody, 18 cases with
determine the agglutination intensity according to a combination of alloantibody and autoantibody, 6
the size of the clot. cases of alloantibody, 6 cases of warm autoantibody,
3 cases of cold autoantibody, and 1 case with a combi-
3. Step (10) above: Directly record the results and nation of daratumumab therapy combined with auto-
end the test. antibody. Among these causes, combinations of cold
autoantibodies and warm autoantibodies accounted
for the largest share (40.35%), while combinations of
3. Results alloantibodies and autoantibodies accounted for the
second-largest share (31.58%) (Table 3).
3.1 Cause analysis for discrepant forward and
reverse blood group typing
Different factors contribute to discrepant forward and 3.3 Specificity test results of blood transfusion
reverse blood group typing, the most common of recipients
which is a serotyping weak response or no response. The most common cause of crossmatch incompatibil-
11 cases in total, including 6 instances of cold aggluti- ity among the 24 blood transfusion recipients was an
nin, 2 instances of monoclonal immunoglobulin, 2 irregular antibody of the Rh blood group system,
instances of bone marrow transplant, and 2 instances with 6 cases of anti-E (25.00%), 5 cases of anti-c, E
of blood group subtype (Table 1). Conditions that (20.83%), 2 cases of anti-C, e (8.33%), 1 case of anti-c
cause weakened serotype included multiple (4.17%). The MNS blood group system accounted for
myeloma (MM), pancytopenia, and leukemia che- the second biggest proportion, with 7 cases of anti-M
motherapy. There was 1 case of cold autoantibody in (29.17%) and 1 case of anti-S (4.17%). The Lewis
a patient with hemolytic anemia; 1 case of acute hepa- blood group accounted for the third highest pro-
titis E among the 6 cases of cold agglutinin (high portion, with 1 case of Lea (29.17%) (Table 4).
potency cold agglutinin); 1 case of abnormal mono-
clonal immunoglobulin secretion due to MM; and 1
case of bone marrow transplant in a patient with 3.4 Blood transfusion recipient disease type
acute leukemia (Table 2).
Types of diseases among the 57 blood transfusion reci-
pients: there were 11 cases of immune disorders,
including immune hemolytic anemia, rheumatoid
3.2 Cause of crossmatch incompatibility
arthritis, and immune thrombocytopenic purpura; 32
Among the 57 cases of crossmatch incompatibility, cases of hematologic diseases, including MM, myelo-
there were 23 cases with a combination of cold dysplastic syndrome (MDS), diffuse large B-cell
4 H. QIU ET AL.
Table 1. The forward and reverse blood group typing in our study.
Forward blood group typing Reverse blood group typing
Anti-A Anti-B Anti-AB Ac Bc Oc Autoantibody Blood type
Serotyping weak response or no response. 0 4+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 B
0 0 0 0 4+ 0 0 O
0 0 0 4+ 0 0 0 O
4+ 0 4+ 0 0 0 0 A
0 4+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 B
0 4+ 4+ ± 0 0 0 B
0 0 0 4+ 0 0 0 O
0 4+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 B
4+ 0 4+ 0 0 0 0 A
4+ 0 4+ 0 0 0 0 A
4+ 0 4+ 0 0 0 0 A
Cold agglutinin 4+ 4+ 4+ 4+ 4+ 4+ 4+ O
0 4+ 4+ 4+ 3+ 3+ 3+ B
4+ 0 4+ 2+ 3+ 2+ 2+ A
0 4+ 4+ 3+ 3+ 3+ 3+ B
4+ 0 4+ 2+ 2+ 2+ 2+ A
0 4+ 4+ 3+ 3+ 3+ 3+ B
MM 0 4+ 4+ 3+ 1+ 1+ 1+ B
4+ 0 4+ 1+ 4+ 1+ 1+/± A
Bone marrow transplant 0 0 0 3+ 0 0 0 Positive O negative B
0 4+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 Positive B negative AB
ABO subtype 1+ 4+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 AB subtype
4+ 1+ 4+ 0 0 0 0 AB subtype
MM, multiple myeloma.
已将部分血型结果0修正为O.
Table 2. Cause analysis and treatment of forward and reverse blood group typing discrepancy.
Number of
Cause cases Disease Method
Serotyping weak response or 11 (47.83%) MM, pancytopenia, leukemia chemotherapy, Placement at 4°C for enhancing antigen-antibody
no response. tumor, etc. reaction, absorption, and diffusion test.
Cold agglutinin 6 (26.09%) Hemolytic anemia, acute hepatitis E, anal Wash red blood cells with normal saline at 37°C, 2-ME
papilla hypertrophy, skin mass inactivation.
M protein 2 (8.70%) MM Saline doubling dilution[3]
Bone marrow transplant 2 (8.70%) Acute lymphoblastic leukemia, acute Learn about medical history, etc.
myelogenous leukemia
ABO blood group 2 (8.70%) Atherosclerosis, acute myelogenous leukemia Add special typing reagent, H substance test and
absorption and diffusion test
tumor, B-cell lymphoma, plasma cell lymphoma, acute occur in clinical practice. Diseases, individual patient
myelogenous leukemia, and aplastic anemia; 4 cases of circumstances, and medication administration are
tumors, including pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, just some of the causes.
and others; and 10 cases of other diseases, such as cir- Among all other causes of discrepant forward and
rhosis, hepatic failure, tuberculous pleurisy, and others. reverse ABO blood group typing, serotyping weak
response or no response accounted for the largest pro-
portion (6 cases of MM, 1 case of whole blood cell
4 Discussion decrease, 1 case of tumor, 2 cases of leukemia che-
motherapy, and 1 case of ectopic pregnancy) with
Safe blood transfusions depend on consistent positive
reverse blood group typing agglutination < 2 + in all
and negative blood group typing and cross-matching
cases. Herein we provide four treatment options for
of blood. Blood group typing and agglutination, as
the exclusion: enhancing the serum volume for the
measured by major and (or) minor crossmatch, can
Table 3. Cause analysis of 57 cases of crossmatch Table 4. Specificity of irregular antibodies in anti-ethmoid
incompatibility. positive patients with cross-matched blood.
Percentage Antibody specificity Percentage (%)
n (%)
Anti-M antibody 7 29.17
Cold autoantibody combined with warm 23 40.35 Anti-E antibody 6 25.00
autoantibody Anti-c, E antibody 5 20.83
Alloantibody combined with autoantibody 18 31.58 Anti-C, e antibody 2 8.33
Alloantibody 6 10.53 Anti-c antibody 1 4.17
Warm autoantibody 6 10.53 Anti-S antibody 1 4.17
Cold autoantibody 3 5.26 Anti-M, E antibody 1 4.17
Retuzumab combined with autoantibodies 1 1.75 Anti-Lea antibody 1 4.17
Total 57 100.00 Total 24 100
HEMATOLOGY 5
reverse blood group typing in the tube test (serum: red discrepancy; (2) consistent forward and reverse ABO
blood cell = 3:1); centrifuging the specimen after it is blood group typing with forward blood group typing
stored in a refrigerator at 4°C [4];incubating the speci- response intensity ≤ 3 + or reverse blood group
men for 30–60 min at 4°C and submitting it for absorp- typing response intensity ≤ 2, as seen in the two
tion and diffusion test; and enhancing antigen– cases of subtype AB in this study. Anti-H agglutination
antibody response by adding a low ionic solution [5] intensity is the major criterion for defining ABO sub-
to the specimen to lower its red blood cell surface types. From strong to weak, the H antigen of each
potential. blood group is O>A2>B>A1>A2B>A1B. The antigen
MM, a malignant plasma cell dyscrasia, produces a identification method was determined based on the
considerable quantity of aberrant immunoglobulins, results of the absorption and diffusion test in which
the M-protein. Significant amounts of M-protein can the absorptive capacity of subtypes was lower than
invert the ratio of plasma albumin to globulin [6]. An that of normal red blood cells but the diffusion
excessive increase in plasma globulin and plasma glo- capacity was higher [10]. The absorption and
bulin-coated red blood cells decreases negative diffusion tests are typically used to detect ABO sub-
charges on the surface of red blood cells and repulsion types when there are discrepancies between forward
between blood cells, ultimately leading to aberrant and reverse ABO blood group typing, or when
rouleaux agglutination of red blood cells [7]. Herein forward blood group typing is O. This method,
we provide two treatment options. Option 1: Isotonic however, has a few drawbacks. An additional genetic
saline dilution. Add 1 drop of saline onto a glass test based on molecular biology is recommended if
slide; the abnormal rouleaux agglutination of red possible.
blood cells disappears instantly [8]. Option 2: Saline Serum cold agglutinins are typically IgM, which can
replacement. Replace the clear plasma supernatant agglutinate an individual’s red blood cells or isotype
liquid for reverse blood group typing with 100 μl red blood cells at temperatures below 32 °C, and rever-
normal saline and resuspend it. The agglutination dis- sibly disperse agglutinated red blood cells at 37°C [11].
appears instantly [9]. Cold agglutinins are most effective at a temperature of
Blood groups of bone marrow transplant patients 4°C, where their agglutination abilities are at their
more closely resemble those of donors as a result of highest. In addition, cold antibodies are active at temp-
hematopoietic reconstitution of hematopoietic stem eratures lower than 30°C, suggesting that temperature
cells in recipients [1]. Considering that both donor plays a significant role. However, nonspecific aggluti-
and recipient red blood cells can be found in the per- nation, the reaction product of red blood cell and
ipheral blood, forward blood group typing is a hybrid cold agglutinins, can interfere with forward and
technique. Variations in reverse blood group typing reverse ABO blood group typing due to its role in
are to be expected after a transplant. Using forward mycoplasma pneumoniae infection, autoimmune
and reverse blood group typing, we found that a hemolytic anemia, and other diseases. Treatments:
patient with blood group B could successfully receive Forward and reverse blood group typing should be
a bone marrow transplant from a donor who was performed at 37°C. For forward blood group typing,
typed as blood group O and B in forward and the red blood cells of the patient can be repeatedly
reverse blood group typing, respectively. Our study washed with normal saline at 37°C, and the serum of
also included a patient with blood group AB who the patient can be absorbed and reused multiple
received a bone marrow transplant from a donor times for reverse blood group typing. Forward blood
with blood group B. This donor was typed as B and group typing should be performed after specimens
AB in forward and reverse group typing, respectively. have been incubated for 15 min in a water bath at
Within 4 months of their non-homotypic hematopoie- 37°C and the red blood cells have been treated with
tic stem cell transplants, both patients underwent a 2-Mercaptoethanol (2-ME) to prevent red cell suspen-
transformation that rendered ABO blood group sion preparation failure caused by high potency cold
typing difficult. Patients with forward and reverse autoantibodies [1]. The capacity of cold agglutinin to
blood group typing discrepancies should have their agglutinate corresponds with its potency. Patients
medical records reviewed to learn more about their with low potency requiring a blood transfusion
diseases, and both the patient and donor involved in should have a crossmatch conducted in a 37°C water
the bone marrow transplant should be questioned bath. Crossmatching with absorbed serum and
about their blood types. With this information, it is diffused red blood cells should be performed on
possible to confidently determine the blood group of patients with high potency requiring a transfusion.
the patients and provide them with the correct Patients with high potency should get a gradual
blood transfusion. blood transfusion using an infusion warmer while
ABO subtype, also known as ABO variant, is associ- their vital signs are closely monitored [12].
ated with the following blood group test results: (1) Most warm autoantibodies are IgG, while IgM is
forward and reverse ABO blood group typing uncommon. Warm autoantibodies can obfuscate
6 H. QIU ET AL.
clinically relevant alloantibodies and impede blood occur if this antibody is present, making a compatible
transfusion assays. Life-threatening complications can crossmatch more difficult [20]. The Rh blood group
arise from transfusing the wrong type of blood. system accounts for the vast majority of the reported
Treatments: The presence of alloantibodies in instances of significant irregular antibodies, although
serum can be determined by performing a diffusion the MNS blood group system and the Lewis blood
test on red blood cells with positive direct antiglobulin, group system also play a role. This result is consistent
which exposes the antibody binding site, absorbs with prior findings [21].
autoantibodies in the serum, and prevents autoanti- Treatments: Antibody identification should be per-
bodies from disturbing the red blood cells, allowing formed on positive antibody specimens to determine
for accurate blood group typing and crossmatching the type and clinical significance of the antibody.
[13]. (1) In the event of a transfusion emergency, it is
best to use blood from a donor whose ABO and Rh
types are consistent with those of the recipient’s, 5 Conclusion
whose blood has fewer reactive direct antiglobulins Forward and reverse ABO blood group type, as well as
than the recipient’s blood, and whose blood agglutin- crossmatch incompatibility, may occur for a variety of
ates only slightly with the recipient’s serum. (2) For reasons. The study of blood types and crossmatch
blood transfusions under normal circumstances, it is incompatibility is of utmost importance, and those
best to use blood from a donor whose ABO and Rh working in the field of blood transfusions must have
types are consistent with those of the recipient’s, and a comprehensive awareness of all test techniques.
with isotypic MN, Ss, and kidd. The diagnostic process should not, however, prevent
MM has high levels of CD38 expression. When it or postpone an emergency blood transfusion. If a
comes to treating relapsed, refractory multiple blood transfusion facility does not have the necessary
myeloma, daratumumab (DARA), a monoclonal anti- equipment, it should send blood samples to the
body that targets CD38, is both safe and effective regional blood center so that they may be properly
[14,15]. In this study, we found one case of daratumu- typed. This allows for a more precise crossmatch, and
mab therapy combined with autoantibodies. CD38 is hence a safer and more effective blood transfusion.
widely expressed in human cell membranes and is a
type II transmembrane protein. Indirect antiglobulin
tests (IATs) including those used for screening and Disclosure statement
identifying abnormal antibodies, red blood cell No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
antigen phenotyping analyses, and crossmatch tests
rely on the ability of DARA to agglutinate with the
reagent or donor red blood cells [16,17]. However, Funding
DARA has no effect on crossmatching between ABO The author(s) reported there is no funding associated with
blood groups, RhD blood groups, or saline medium. the work featured in this article.
Consequently, polybrene can be used for blood speci-
mens, antibody screening tests, and crossmatches for
patients with CD38 monoclonal antibodies. Despite References
its limited capacity to detect Kell antibody, polybrene [1] Zheng ZL, Liu J, Cheng XM. Cause analysis and solution
crossmatch remains a relatively safe test in China and of ABO positive and negative stereotypes inconsistency
Southeast Asia as the Kell antibody is quite rate in in 51 cases. Chin Mod Med. 2021;28(29):170–173.
these populations [18]. Dithiothreitol (DTT), a thiol- doi:10.3969/j.issn.1674-4721.2021.29.049.
[2] Shang H, Wang YS, Shen ZY. National operating pro-
reducing agent, may inhibit anti-CD38 antibodies
cedures for clinical examination. 4th ed. Beijing:
from binding to donor red blood cells by denatured People’s Medical Publishing House. 2015; p. 118–143.
CD38 on the surface of the cells by breaking disulfide [3] Yudin J, Heddle NM. A 13-question approach to resol-
bonds in the extracellular region. Anti-globulin cards ving serological discrepancies in the transfusion medi-
are used to identify red blood cells; it has been cine laboratory. Lab Med. 2014 Summer;45(3):193–
observed that treating them immediately with 206. doi:10.1309/LMEWVSNT2F3O5JDN
[4] Sun Y, Wang XN, Liu B. Clinical analysis of positive and
0.04 mol/L DTT for 15 min at 37°C totally eliminates
negative typification of blood group in 152 cases.
the action of the CD38 monoclonal antibody. At the Chinese J Labor Diag. 2020;24(7):1218.
same time, the detection abilities of K antigen, LW [5] Ma HL, Yun ZQ, Yang B, et al. Application of"three step
antigen, JMH antigen, Lub antigen, Dia antigen, Jka analysis"of complicated ABO blood group. J Clin Hemat.
antigen and Rh blood group system antigen are still 2011;24(2):75–77. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-2806-B.2011.
01.005.
present and functional [19]. Red blood cell antibodies
[6] Liu ZY, Zhang GQ, Yu WZ, et al. Experimental study of
that are neither anti-A nor anti-B are referred to as irre- hypercoagulability in patients with multiple myeloma.
gular antibodies. Extreme hemolytic transfusion J Exp Hemat. 2015;23(1):142–145. doi:10.7534/j.issn.
responses and failed red blood cell transfusion may 1009-2137.2015.01.027.
HEMATOLOGY 7
[7] Park J, Jekarl DW, Park SY, et al. Combined group I and multiple myeloma. N Engl J Med. 2016;375(8):754–
III ABO discrepancies in multiple myeloma with IgG- 766. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1606038
lambda type: A case report. Med Princ Pract. 2017;26 [15] Chari A, Suvannasankha A, Fay JW, et al. Daratumumab
(1):90–92. doi:10.1159/000450579 plus pomalidomide and dexamethasone in relapsed
[8] Cui Y, Du J, Yang SM, et al. The influencing factors and and/or refractory multiple myeloma. Blood. 2017;130
treatment of blood grouping and cross matching in (8):974–981. doi:10.1182/blood-2017-05-785246
patients with multiple myeloma. Chin J Cell Mol [16] Chapuy CI, Nicholson RT, Aguad MD, et al. Resolving the
Immunol. 2017;33(10):1419–1421. doi:10.13423/j.cnki. daratumumab interference with blood comp atibility
cjcmi.008465. testing. Transfusion. 2015;55(6pt2):1545–1554. doi:10.
[9] Cheng J, Jiang M, Lin CY, et al. Cause analysis and treat- 1111/trf.13069
ment of ABO blood type abnormality in patients with mul- [17] Oostendorp M, Lammerts van Bueren JJ, Doshi P, et al.
tiple myeloma. Chin J Clin Lab Sci. 2020;38(6):440–442. When blood transfusion medicine becomes compli-
doi:10.13602/j.cnki.jcls.2020.06.13. cated due to interference by monoclonal antibody
[10] Cao HR, Meng XJ, Wang ZJ, et al. Analysis and report of therapy. Transfusion. 2015;55(6 Pt 2):1555–1562.
ABO subtype identification results: one case report of B doi:10.1111/trf.13150
(A)04 subtype. Journal of Clinical Hematology. 2017;30 [18] Liu F, Liu J. Possible insensitivity of the polybrene anti-
(2):152–154. doi:10.13201/j.issn.1004-2806-b.2017.02. body screen to detect anti-Jka. Ann Clin Lab Sci.
024. 2006;36(1):101–102.
[11] Meny GM. Recognizing and resolving ABO discrepan- [19] Song J, Kong YK, Wang SY, et al. To remove monoclonal
cies. Immunohematol. 2017;33(2):76–81. doi:10.21307/ anti-CD38 interference from compatibility testing:A
immunohematology-2019-012 simple method. Chinese J Blood Trans. 2021;34(9):974–
[12] Xie HY, Zhou ZX, Gu HH, et al. Blood type incompatibil- 977. doi:10.13303/j.cjbt.issn.1004-549x.2021.09.010.
ity caused by cold agglutination: a study of 16 cases. [20] Noiret L, Slater A, Higgins JM. Determinants of red
Chinese J Blood Trans. 2021;34(1):40–43. doi:10.13303/ blood cell alloantibody detection duration: analysis of
j.cjbt.issn.1004-549x.2021.01.013. multiply alloimmunized patients supports peritransfu-
[13] Yang R, Luo YP, Xin H. Autoantibody combined with sion factors. Transfusion. 2017;57(8):1930–1937.
anti-Wra in a patient with autoimmune hemolytic doi:10.1111/trf.14157
anemia. Chinese J Blood Trans. 2019;32(07):718–720. [21] Hou RQ, Yang HY, Cui YP, et al. Analysis of the results of
doi:10.13303/j.cjbt.issn.1004-549x.2019.07.031. irregular antibody identification in patients and its clini-
[14] Palumbo A, Chanan-Khan A, Weisel K, et al. cal significance. J Exp Hemat. 2020;28(3):961–966.
Daratumumab, bortezomib, and dexamethasone for doi:10.19746/j.cnki.issn1009-2137.2020.03.040.