Journal
Journal
Journal
net/publication/362445049
CITATIONS READS
0 34
7 authors, including:
Mongomake Kone
Université Nangui Abrogoua
23 PUBLICATIONS 282 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
AfSM project on African soil microbiology, FCIAD project on tomato diseases management, FCIAD project on Aulacode breeding with granulated food from a local
legume, FCIAD project on implementation mycorhizal in plantain culture substrat , etc. View project
INTERACTIONS ENTRE PLANTE, RHIZOBACTERIE SYMBIOTIQUE ET/OU CHAMPIGNON MYCORHIZIEN ARBUSCULAIRE : APPLICATIONS POUR LA GESTION DE STRESS
BIOTIQUES OU ABIOTIQUES DU MAÏS, DE l’HÉVÉA ET DE LA TOMATE View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Serges Doubi on 03 August 2022.
Abbreviations
MS-Murashige and Skoog
DNA-Deoxyribonucleic Acid
PCR-Polymerase Chain Reaction
TAS-ELISA- Triple Antibody Sandwich Enzyme-Linked Immuno Sorbent Assay
ACMV-African Cassava Mosaic Virus
BAP-6-Benzyle Amino-Purine
NAA-Naphthalene Acetic Acid
CTAB-Cetyltrimethylammonium Bromide
MS-Murashige and Skoog
2.4-D-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid
Abstract
Grown in Côte d'Ivoire by smallholders, cassava takes great part of food security and poverty decreasing.
Cassava is most important crops in climate change context. Cultivation is done with cuttings derived from
local varieties. Unfortunately, these cuttings are susceptible to cassava mosaic disease which is transfer
from one crop to another one. Infected cassava plants produce low yields and tubers are bad quality. The
aim of this paper is to evaluate performance of thermotherapy engineering associated with meristem culture
for cassava cuttings sanitation. Ten cultivars of cassava were used. Fifteen cuttings of each cultivar were
collected and subjected to a temperature varying from 32 to 39°C under a photoperiod of 16/8h and
evaluated after three weeks. Thermotherapy associated with meristem culture was used to treat variety Yacé.
The results obtained showed that thermotherapy allowed a cleaning of cassava cuttings at percentages
ranging from 6 to 33%. In addition, thermotherapy and meristem culture of cultivar Yacé allowed to obtain
a percentage of sanitation of 92 %.
Keywords : Cassava - Côte d’Ivoire - Meristem culture - Sanitation - Thermotherapy
__________________________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Once used as a subsistence crop during times of hunger, cassava has become a cash crop today (Thresh,
2006). This change is the result of high demand for derived products from cassava tubers such as attiéké
(fermented cassava semolina), for local consumption and sub saharan export (N’zué B, 2007). Cassava plant
adapts well to the effects of climate change and can grow on different soil types. Indeed, cassava is resistant
to periods of prolonged drought and produces average yields on marginal soils (FAO, 2013). Despite the
agronomic and economic benefits of cassava for food security and poverty reduction, the cassava during its
development faces to major constraints such as viral diseases. In Côte d'Ivoire, cassava mosaic disease is
caused by two major viruses, African Cassava Mosaic Virus (ACMV) and East African Cassava Mosaic
Page 1
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
Virus (EACMV) (Toualy et al, 2014). These are geminiviruses of the family Geminiviridae (Ogwok et al,
2015). Cassava mosaic disease is a systemic disease and is propagated by whitefly (Bemisia tabaci) by a
semi-persistent method (Jeremiah, 2015). After cassava plant infection, the using of infected cuttings as
planting materials becomes the second mode of disease spread (Munga et al, 2002). The use of cuttings
prone to infection promotes transmission of mosaic disease from one cassava field to another and from one
crop cycle to another over long distances (Legg JP et al, 2013). This results in a decrease in production
ranging from 20 to 90 % (IITA, 2000). This pandemic therefore becomes a real threat to food security in
Africa if it is not contained (Segnou et al, 2002). Various means of struggle exist. Those are : use of resistant
varieties, or virus-free cuttings, as well as sanitation of the plot limit the occurrence of diseases in newly
established plantations (Hillocks et al, 2003). Also, the systematic elimination of cassava shoots showing
symptoms of juvenile stage virosis greatly reduces the spread of the disease (Legg et al, 2011). However,
producers are reluctant to adopt improved varieties for reasons of late maturity and inadequate organoleptic
properties (Mwamachi et al, 2005). To address this, plant biotechnology techniques such as thermotherapy
and meristem culture are used as alternative ways to clean up local varieties of cassava (Zapata et al, 1995).
Meristematic areas of infected plants are generally virus-free because they have not differentiated cells or
contain minimal viral load (Wasswa et al, 2010). These same authors report that heat hinders the replication
of viruses. In Côte d'Ivoire, these techniques are not vulgarized or are little used for the remediation of local
plant species. The objective of this study is to contribute to improving the quality of cassava planting
material by using thermotherapy and meristem culture methods.
Plant samples
The plant material consisted of cuttings and leaves collected on ten local cultivars of cassava namely
Nsakperne, Antenne, Six-month and Gnonrongouin (South-East), Zogloblé, Afery and Demoiselle (Center),
Diarassouba (North), Glagban (West) and Yacé (South). These cassava cultivars were grown in
experimental field at the University Nangui Abrogoua. The leaves of excised cuttings exhibited symptoms
of cassava mosaic disease.
Experimental design
The incubator is a cubic shape box of 1 m of side. The upper and lower faces are covered with plywood and
the other four (4) faces are covered with transparent plastic. Six incandescent bayonet bulbs (60-watt) were
installed indoors to serve as a source of heat and light (Figure 1). The electrical cable connecting the six
bulbs simultaneously was connected to the mains voltage via a timer. Inside the incubator, 2-liter jars
contain autoclaved soil at 121 ° C, at a pressure of 1 bar for 30 min.
Cuttings thermotherapy
Cuttings were excised on plants with positive response to TAS-ELISA tests against the ACMV or the
EACMV. For each cultivar, five cuttings were used, and three replicates were performed. The cuttings were
planted in 2-liter pots in five rows in the incubator. The experiment was carried out with a photoperiod of
16/8 hours, a temperatures of 40 °C and 36 °C and a relative humidity of 65 %. Watering was done regularly
to keep the substrate moistened. After four weeks of incubation, the number of cuttings inducing shoot buds
was counted, then young leaves were excised to perform the TAS-ELISA.
Page 2
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
The cultivar Yacé was used in this experiment. It is the most cultivated cultivar by producers in Côte
d'Ivoire. Its tuber is used to prepare a dish called "Attiéké" very appreciated by most of the Ivorian
population. However, this cultivar is highly susceptible to cassava mosaic disease. In addition, compared to
other cultivars, the rate of recovery of healthy plants by the thermotherapy technique remains low in Yacé
cultivar. In order to improve this low rate, the apical meristems were isolated on the cuttings subjected to the
treatment of thermotherapy. A pre-disinfection was performed by washing segments with tap water, then
disinfection was carried out under a laminar flow hood, by soaking in 70 % ethanol for 3 min, followed by
immersion in a calcium hypochlorite solution (3 %) containing a drop of Tween 20 for a duration of 3 min.
The segments were subsequently rinsed four times in sterile distilled water. Then, the apical meristematic
domes were excised under a binocular microscope with scalpel blades n°11 and placed on culture media
(Figure 2).
PCR program
The PCR program is constituted a first denaturation phase at 94 °C for 4 min. After the second, which lasted
1 min, the hybridization process was started at a temperature of 55 °C for 1 min. This phase was followed by
the elongation phase, carried out for 1 min at 72 °C. This is followed by another phase of elongation, done
for 10 min at the same temperature as before. Those three phases (denaturation, hybridization and
elongation) were carried out in 35 cycles. The PCR products were electrophoresed on 1.2 % agarose gel for
2 hours. Then, the gel was visualized using a transilluminator and then photographed.
Data analysis
The data collected during heat therapy of the ten cultivars, the number of rooted seedlings and the number of
seedlings sanitized after thermotherapy coupled with the meristem culture were calculated with Excel 2010
software. The percentages of budburst and rooting were transformed by the Arcsinus √(x) angular formula
and analyzed using the STATISTICA version 7.1 software. The analysis of variance has a factor (ANOVA
1) was used to compare the averages. When a significant difference is observed, the Newman-Keuls test is
used to separate the means at the threshold α = 5 %.
RESULTS
Thermotherapy of cuttings
In this experiment, cuttings of different cultivars with symptoms of cassava mosaic disease were heat
treated. After four weeks of incubation, the severity index of cassava mosaic disease was estimated and
compare to severity before heat therapy. The results obtained are shown in Table 3. The analysis of this table
shows that the average severity index of the disease was reduced following the treatment of thermotherapy.
It ranged from 0.73 to 2.56 as opposed to a variation of 1.27 to 3.4 before thermotherapy. In addition, the
highest disease severity index before (3.40) and after (2.50) thermotherapy was recorded in the cultivar
Yacé.
The recovery rate in healthy plants after indexing by the TAS-ELISA test was calculated. The results
obtained are shown in Table 4. The analysis of this table shows that the rate varied from 6.66 to 33.33 %.
The highest rates of healthy plants recovery were recorded with the following cultivars: Afery, Diarassouba,
Nsakperne, Antenne, Demoiselle, Six-mois and Zogloblé. On the other hand, cultivars with low rates of
recovery of healthy plants are: Gnonrongouin (13.33 %), Glagban (13.33) and Yacé (6.66 %). The
appearance of the leaves of two cultivars (Six-mois and Yacé) after thermotherapy is shown in Figure 3. The
leaves of six-mois after heat treatment are colored uniform (green) and well full-blown without deformation
(Figure 3a). In Yacé cuttings non-sanitized after heat treatment, the leaf blade has deformities and a mosaic
color shown by red arrows (Figure 3b).
Page 4
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
explants with frequencies varying between 0 and 63.25 %. M2 and M3 media favored the emergence of
shoot buds. The highest percentage (63.25 %) was recorded on M2 medium whereas no shoot induction was
recorded on the control medium (Cm) and the M1 medium (1/2 MS + 0.5 mg/l BAP + 0.1 mg/l 2.4-D).
DISCUSSION
Cassava mosaic virus was removed from cassava cuttings treated with thermotherapy with a rate varying
between 6 and 33 %. This difference in sanitation rates could be explained by a cultivar effect. Some
cultivars are more susceptible to cassava mosaic disease than others. This is the case of the cultivar yacé
whose sanitation rate is 6 %. Concerning viral particles neutralization in plant material could be explained
by the temperature variation of 36 °C in the dark and 39 °C in the light (Sastry et al, 2014). Their work
revealed that temperature conditions above 30 °C slow or block the replication of viruses. In addition, heat is
important to the slowing or stopping of the multiplication of viral particles (Astier et al, 2001). The heat
hinders the activity of the replicase and creates an instability of the viral particles. Moreover, in a condition
of increase temperature, there is a weakening of the links between the protein subunits of the genetic
material of the viruses. This induces cracks that cause their destruction by nucleases (Allam, 2000). The
whole process of the viral cycle including replication and distribution that would be affected by the rise in
temperature in this virus-plant interaction (Del Toro et al, 2015).
This methodology is based on the principle that the apical meristem does not contain or has very few viruses
(Morel, 1948). In our study, the thermotherapy preceding the meristem culture would extend the apical zone
devoid of viral particles around the meristem. Indeed, the alternation of the temperature (32 ° C and 39 ° C),
would limit the movements of the viral particles towards the apical tissues. This facilitates the excision of a
large meristem to generate plantlets. This would explain the high percentage of remediation (92.31%).
Elimination of ACMV at 95 % by applying thermotherapy associated with meristem culture on four cassava
accessions have been reported (Yandian, 2015). Sanitizing of potato infected with potato virus X (Solanum
tuberosum) by combining thermotherapy and meristem culture have been successfully done (Li et al, 1994).
Concerning sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas), similar results have been reported (Mervat, 2009). The results
of their work showed the effectiveness of thermotherapy coupled with the meristem culture for the
elimination of the marbling virus from sweet potato.
CONCLUSION
Cassava mosaic disease caused by the ACMV is a real threat to a sustainable cassava crop. The
thermotherapy technique resulted in a recovery rate of 6 to 33 %, with the cultivar Yacé having the lowest
rate of recovery of healthy plants is 6 %. The thermotherapy associated with meristem culture in this cultivar
was able to neutralize the viral particles of cassava mosaic with a recovery rate of healthy plants of 92 %.
The healthy in vitro plants will be acclimatized after a mass production from nodal segments and deliver to
producers for field establishment.
REFERENCES
i. Allam E.K. (2000). Eradication of Banana bunchy top virus and Banana mosaic virus,
from diseased banana plants. Annals of Agriculture Science., 45:33-48.
Page 5
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
ii. Astier S., Albouy J., Maury Y. and Lecoq H. (2001). Lutte contre les maladies à virus des plantes : le
génie génétique pour la résistance. In : Principes de Virologie Végétale : Génome, Pouvoir
Pathogène, Ecologie des Virus. INRA (ed), France, p. 299-322.
iii. Clark M.F. and Adams A.N. (1977). Characteristics of the Microplate Method of ELISA for the
detection of Plant viruses. Journal of General Virology., 34:475-483.
iv. Del Toro F.J., Aguilar E., Hernández-Walias F.J., Tenllado F., Chung B.N. and Canto T. (2015).
High temperature, high ambient CO2 affect the interactions between three positive sense RNA
viruses and a compatible host differentially, but not their silencing suppression efficiencies. PLoS
One,10: e0136062.
v. Doyle J.J. and Doyle J.L. (1987). A rapid DNA isolation procedure for small quantities of fresh leaf
tissue. Phytochemical Bulletin., 19: 11-15.
vi. FAO (2013). Guide pour une intensification durable de la production, Rome.
vii. Hillocks R.J. and Jennings D.L. (2003). Cassava brown streak disease a review of present
knowledge and research needs. International Journal of Pest Management., 49: 225-234.
viii. IITA (2000). Annual report.54p.
ix. Jeremiah S.C., Ndyabula I.L., Mkamilo GS., Haji S., Muhanna MM., Chuwa C., Kasele
S., Bouwmeester H., Ijumba J.N. and Legg J.P. (2015). The dynamics and environmental influence
on interactions between cassava brown streak disease et the whitefly, Bemisia
tabaci,Phytopathology., 105(5):646-55.
x. Legg J.P., Jeremiah S.C., Obiero H.M., Maruthi M.N., Ndyetabula I.and Okao-Okuja G. (2011).
Comparing the regional epidemiology of the cassava mosaic and cassava brown streak virus
pandemics in Africa. Virus Research.,159: 161-170.
xi. Legg J.P. and Thresh J.M. (2003). Cassava virus diseases in Africa. Proceedings of the first
international conference on plant virology in Sub-Saharan Africa. IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria, p. 517-552.
xii. Li Y.H., He Y.K., Zhang Z.K., Lu H.F., Wu C.J. and Zheng P. (1994). Study on virus-free potato
seedlings from apical meristem culture in vitro, Xinan Nongye Xuebao. Southwest China Journal of
Agricultural Sciences., 2: 28-31.
xiii. Mervat M.M., Far E.L. and Ashoud A. (2009). Utility of thermotherapy and meristem tip culture for
freeing Sweet potato from viral infection. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences., 3 (1)
:153-159.
xiv. Morel G. (1948). Recherches sur la culture associée de parasites obligatoires et de tissus végétaux,
Annales des Epiphyties, 1 : 123-234.
xv. Munga T. and Thresh J.M. (2002). Incidence of cassava mosaic and cassava brown streak virus
diseases in coastal Kenya. Roots., 8 (1): 12–4.
xvi. Murashige T. and Skoog F. (1962). A revised medium for rapid growth and bio-assays with tobacco
tissue cultures. Physiologia Plantarum., 15: 473 – 497.
xvii. Mwamachi D.M., Muli B.M., Ndungu J.M., Muinga R.W. and Kiura J. (2005). Research priorities
for KARI-Mtwapa mandate area, coastal lowland (Kenya).
xviii. N’zué B (2007). Caractérisation morphologique, sélection variétale et amélioration du taux de
multiplication végétative chez le manioc (Manihot esculenta Crantz (Euphorbiaceae)). Thèse de
doctorat, Université de Cocody, Abidjan. 141 p.
xix. Ogwok E., Alicai T., Rey M., Beyen G. and Taylor N. (2015). Distribution and accumulation of
cassava brown streak viruses within infected cassava (Manihot esculenta Crantz) plants. Plant
Pathology., 64 (5) :1235-1246.
xx. Sastry K.S. and Zitter T.A. (2014). Plant virus and viroid diseases in the tropics, Springer Science +
Business Media B.V. 2: 489p. doi: 10.1007/978-94-007-7820-7_2.
xxi. Segnou (2002). Développement végétatif et potentiel de rendement chez le manioc. Tropicultura.,
20(4): 161-164.
xxii. Thresh J.M. (2006). Control of tropical plant virus diseases. Advance Virus Research., 67:245–295.
xxiii. Toualy M.N.Y., Akinbade S.A., Séka K., Diallo H.A. and Kumar P.L. (2014). Incidence and
distribution of cassava mosaic begomoviruses in Côte d’Ivoire. International Journal of Agronomy
and Agricultural Research., 4(6): 131-139.
Page 6
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
xxiv. Wasswa P., Alicai T. and Mukasa S.B. (2010). Optimization of in vitro techniques for cassava brown
streak virus elimination from infected cassava clones. African Crop Science Journal., (4): 235 – 241.
xxv. Yandian S.P., Gandonou B.C., Silla S., Zinga I., Dambier D. and Toukourou F. (2015). Elimination
of african cassava mosaic virus (ACMV) in cassava (Manihot esculenta Crantz) using meristem
culture associated to thermotherapy. International Journal of Development Research., 05(10): 5655-
5660.
xxvi. Zapata C., Miller J.C. and Smith R.H. (1995). An in vitro procedure to eradicate Potato
viruses X, Y and S from russet norkotah and two of its strains. In vitro Cell Development
Biology.,31:153-159.
FIGURES LIST
Figure 1. Experimental device adopted for the thermotherapy of diseased cuttings of cassava mosaic
a b
c d
e f
Page 7
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
Figure 2. Different steps of thermotherapy associated to meristem culture of cultivar Yacé.
(a) emission of young buds. (b) twigs containing the meristematic buds. (c) meristem sampling. (d) meristems on
culture medium. (e) leafy shoot from meristem after three weeks of culture. (f) evolution of the leafy shoot into
seedling.
a b
Figure 3. Leaves of cassava plants after a treatment of thermotherapy. (a) Cultivar six-mois sanitized with healthy
leaves; (b) non-sanitized Yacé cultivar, the red arrows indicate cassava mosaic disease symptoms.
1500 Pb
1000 Pb
500 Pb b
1500 Pb
1000 Pb
500 Pb
Figure 4. Electrophoresis of PCR products of cassava leaf samples after thermotherapy associated with meristem
culture. (a) gel showing seven virus free samples. (b) gel contract seven samples with CVMA-positive Sample 20. M
= molecular weight marker. 1Kb= DNA Ladder size. A = ACMV. E = EACMV. TA +(ACMV positive control = 783
bp). TE + (positive indicator EACMV = 780 bp). TA- (ACMV negative light). TE- (Negative Witness EACMV).
TABLES LIST
Page 8
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
Table 3. Effect of heat therapy on the disease severity index in ten cultivars showing symptoms of cassava mosaic
disease
Cultivars Average severity index before Average severity index after
heat therapy thermotherapy
Gnonrongouin 2,27±0,11b 1,60±0,21b
Glagban 2,80±0,35ab 1,73±0,27b
Zogloble 2,73±0,31ab 1,40±0,16b
Yacé 3,40±0,21a 2,56±0,28a
Antenne 2,73±0,11ab 1,80±0,24b
Nsakperne 1,93±0,34b 1,47±0,16b
Demoiselle 2,87±0,16ab 1,73±0,11b
Afery 2,58±0,12a 1,60±0,21b
Diarassouba 2,58±0,12a 1,60±0,13b
Six mois 1,27±0,22c 0,73±0,11c
F 6,39 8,25
P ˂ 0,000 ˂ 0,000
The figures followed by the same letter are statistically identical to the threshold α = 5% (Newman-keuls test); Mean ± standard
error.
Table 4. Indexing and recovery rates of healthy plants after thermotherapy treatment
Cultivars Serological Number of cuttings by serological status after Recovery rate of healthy plants after
status thermotherapy thermotherapy (%)
+ 13
Gnonrongouin 13,33
- 02
+ 13
Glagban 13,33
- 02
+ 10
Zogloblé 33,33
- 05
+ 14
Yacé 06,66
- 01
+ 12
Antenne 20,00
- 03
+ 11
Nsakperne 20,00
- 04
+ 12
Demoiselle 20,00
- 03
+ 05
Afery 33,33
- 10
+ 10
Diarassouba 33,33
- 05
+ 10
Six-mois 33,33
- 05
+: no virus-free sample. - : virus-free sample,
Page 9
International Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences- ISSN (2522-6584) Jan & Feb 2022
February 28, 2022
Table 5. Shoot buds induction from meristem explants of cultivar Yacé after a treatment of thermotherapy
Culture media Percentage of meristem explants inducing
shoot buds (%)
Control medium(Cm) 0.00±0.00 c
Medium 1 (M1) 0.00±0.00 c
Medium 2 (M2) 63.25±9.00 a
Medium 3 (M3) 11.75±7.43 b
P ˂0.000
Statistics
F 26.720
In the same column, the mean ± standard deviation followed by the same letter are statistically identical at α = 5%
threshold (Newman-keuls test).
Table 6. Effect of the composition of the culture medium on the rooting of seedlings
Basal media BAP (mg/l) ANA(mg/l) Percentage of rooting (%)
MS 0 0 100 a
MS 0.05 0.01 85.60 b
Table 7. Percentage of sanited after thermotherapy combined with Yacé cultivar meristem culture
Page 10