Japan: Economic

Outlook and Policy

Priorities
JUNE 9, 2022

Ranil Salgado
Assistant Director and Japan Mission Chief
Asia and Pacific Department
International Monetary Fund
Manuel
IMF Cosentino
| Asia (Unsplash)
and Pacific Department 1
 Roadmap
I. Outlook and policy priorities
• Outlook and risks
• Key policy recommendations
 Fiscal policy
 Monetary policy
 Financial sector policy
 Structural policy
II. IMF research highlights
• Model-based analysis of post-pandemic fiscal policy path
• Options for revenue mobilization
• Low for long rates and bank profitability
• Climate change policy options
• Climate finance in Japan
• Digitalizing the Japanese economy
III. Summary

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 2

 Outlook and risks

Asia remains the world’s growth engine

Growth Projections: Selected Asia

(percent change from a year earlier)

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 3

 Outlook and risks

Japan’s economic recovery is expected to

continue in 2022 despite strong headwinds
Growth in 2022 is underpinned by fiscal support … but the war in Ukraine and the omicron wave
and pent-up demand... in Q1 have slowed the recovery.
Japan: Real GDP Growth Downward Revision to 2022 Growth
(in percent) (relative to January WEO, in percentage point)
3
Projec�ons -0.1
2
Omicron wave and
1 supply chain disruptions
0
Ukraine effect: higher
-1 -0.2 -0.4 commodity prices
-2
Ukraine effect: weaker
-3 Private consumption external demand
Private investment
-4
Government Ukraine effect: other
-5 Net Exports channels (uncertainty,
Real GDP
-6 financial conditions, etc)
-0.2
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

Sources: Haver and IMF Staff Projections Sources: IMF Staff Calculation

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 4

 Outlook and risks

However, downside risks dominate

• Risks are tilted towards the downside

mainly due to the pandemic and the war in
Ukraine.
• Faster-than-expected monetary policy
tightening in the US and other AEs could lead
to further yen depreciation
 Positive effects: improve Japan’s export
competitiveness and help achieve the
two-percent inflation target
 Negative effects: reduce firms’ profit
margin if prices cannot adjust fully and
dampen consumer demand
• A new fiscal package was announced to
soften the impact of rising oil prices.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 5

 Outlook and risks

Headline inflation is accelerating but underlying

core inflation remains subdued
So far, headline inflation is driven by external Inflation is projected to remain below the BoJ’s 2
cost-push factors percent target over the medium term.
Japan: Inflation Indicators Japan: Inflation Forecast
(in percent) (April WEO)
3.5 1.2
Headline
3
Headline (excl. one-off factors)
2.5 1
Core (excl. fresh food, energy, and one-off factors)
2
1.5 0.8
1
0.5 0.6
0
-0.5 0.4
Headline inflation
-1
-1.5 0.2 Core inflation (excl. fresh food and energy)

0
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027
Sources: Haver and Staff Calculation.
Note: the effect of the VAT rate hike is excluded from all series. Sources: IMF Staff Projections

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 6

 Outlook and risks

The recent depreciation of the yen reflects a

change in fundamentals, mainly policy divergence
Yen sharply depreciated in early 2022, …a shift toward a tighter monetary policy stance
coincided with... by other key central banks.

Exchange Rates Exchange Rate and Interest Rate Differential

(Index) (2021-2022)
130 130 2.8
125 2.6
USD/yen
125
120 2.4
10-year bond yield differentials (US minus Japan, RHS)
115 2.2
120
110 2.0
105 115 1.8
100 1.6
110
95 1.4
90 1.2
105
85 1.0
NEER REER Spot Rate (JPY/USD)
80 100 0.8
Jan-18 Aug-18 Mar-19 Oct-19 May-20 Dec-20 Jul-21 Feb-22 202101 202102 202104 202106 202108 202110 202112 202201 202203

Sources: INS and Haver Analytic. Sources: Haver

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 7

 Fiscal policy

Japan’s fiscal policy responded decisively to

the pandemic, helping mitigate the downturn

• Japan’s fiscal response to the pandemic

amounted to about 19 percent of GDP.
Japan: Size of Fiscal Responses to the COVID-19
(In trillion JPY)
• Two recent packages (November 2021 and
April 2020
FY2020 second December November COVID-19 April 2022) will provide needed near-term
suppl. budget 2020 2021 Reserve
package
(May 2020) package package Fund support. However,
Above-the-line measures after
adjustment
32.0 13.6 18.8 26.3 12.3
 Fiscal measures could have focused
Total 103.0 (18.5 percent of 2022 GDP) more on economic transformation and
promotion of a digital and green
Sources: Ministry of Finance, the Cabinet Office, IMF staff estimates.
Note: See Annex III of 2022 Article IV Consulation Staff Report for details of IMF staff's adjustments.The April 2022 package that was announced after
release of the Staff Report is not included.

recovery.
 Some measures could have been
better targeted (e.g., cash transfer to
child-rearing households).

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 8

 Fiscal policy

Near-term fiscal support should be followed by

medium-term fiscal consolidation
Fiscal stance in 2022 is expected to be …on the back of rising age-related
supportive. In the long-run, debt expenditures, pointing to a need for fiscal
sustainability concerns could rise… consolidation.
Japan: Gross Public Debt and Primary Balance 1/ Japan: Gross
Financing PublicCare
of Health Debtand
andLong-Term
Primary Balance
Care 1/
(In percent of GDP) (In(In percent
percent ofof GDP)
GDP)
2 18 2
Government contributions
16 Premium contributions
0 0
14 Copayment
-2 12-2 Total spending (HC and LTC) 250
250
10-4
-4
8 Primary Balance
Primary Balance
-6 -6
6 Gross Debt (RHS)
Gross Debt (RHS)
4-8
-8
2
-10 200 -10 200
0
2014 2018 2022 2026 2030 2014 2018 2022 2026 2030

1995

2000

2005

2010

2015

2020

2025

2030

2035

2040

2045

2050

2055

2060
Sources: Cabinet Office; and IMF staff estimates and projections. Sources: Cabinet Office; and IMF staff estimates and projections.
1/ Gross debt of the general government including the social security fund. 1/ Gross
Sources: debt of
Ministry ofHealth,
the general
Labor, government including
and Welfare; IMF the socialOutlook
World Economic securitydatabase;
fund. and IMF
staff estimates.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 9

 Fiscal policy

A credible medium-term fiscal framework would

help such a transition
• The framework should be
Japan: Cabinet Office's Nominal GDP Growth Projections 1/
 Well-specified (In percent)
4
 Based on conservative projections
3
 Sustain the growth momentum 2

 Predictable 1

• Fiscal adjustment on the expenditure side should 0

Actual
focus on age-related spending: -1 Baseline/Prudent/Reference
Growth Achieved/Economic Revitalization
-2
 Promote generic drugs T=2010 T=2011 T=2012 T=2013 T=2014 T=2015 T=2016 T=2017

 Limit the scope of covered services and drugs Sources: Cabinet Office and IMF Staff estimates
1/ Compound average growth rate of nominal GDP of 3-year ahead (T+3) over that
of the previous year (T-1). Fiscal-year basis. Projections are as of January each year
 Shorten the duration of in-patient care except 2010 (June), 2013 (August) and 2015 (February).

 Increase out-of-pocket spending by the non-

poor elderly

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 10

 Fiscal policy

Fiscal adjustment will require revenue

mobilization efforts
Japan: Options for Revenue Mobilization
Address
Revenue implications Mobilize Growth-
Tax handle Reform options distributional
(% of GDP) revenues? friendly?
concerns?

Raise the tax rate to 15 percent 2 1/2  

Consumption tax
Replace the reduced rate with a
Neutral  
targeted tax credit scheme

Eliminate the preferential treatment

Property tax 0.5   ()
for residential land

Streamline the pension and

0.3  
employment income deductions
Personal income
tax Raise the tax rate for capital income
0.1  
to 25 percent

Merge the special rate for SMEs with

0.1  
the standard rate
Corporate
income tax Introduce an Allowance for Corporate Depends on its

Equity design/impact on output

Raise the rate of TCCM (Tax for

Environmental tax 0.3 
Climate Change Mitigation)

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department Source: IMF staff estimates. 11

 Monetary policy

The BoJ’s commitment to maintain monetary

easing until the 2 percent target is reached
durably is appropriate
Underlying inflation and inflation expectations Further measures could be considered to make
remain below the 2% target easing more sustainable
Japan: Bank Capital of Regional Banks
(Percent of risk-weighted assets)
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7 Capital adequacy ratio

6 Tier 1 capital ratio

Core capital ratio
5
4
FY2002 FY2004 FY2006 FY2008 FY2010 FY2012 FY2014 FY2016 FY2018 FY2020

Source: Bank of Japan.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 12

 Monetary policy

Enhancing the stimulative impact of

monetary policy
The low natural rate of interest and subdued The impact of negative interest rates is
inflation expectations have limited the effective constrained by the small share of bank reserves
monetary easing subject to negative rates

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 13

 Financial sector policy

The impact of the pandemic on the financial

sector has been moderate
Coordinated swap line arrangements Strong and pro-active policy support by the FSA and the BoJ
with the Federal Reserve helped ease helped the financial sector to weather the pandemic and avoid
international dollar funding stress. potential adverse spillover effects on the financial sector.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 14

 Financial sector policy

Financial supervision should remain vigilant to

contain vulnerabilities
• A policy priority is to avoid resources locked in non-viable firms, which could hinder
medium/long-term growth.

• Pandemic-related financial support should be gradually phased out as the pandemic

recedes.
 Government loan guarantee and concessional loan programs should be scaled down
once the recovery takes hold, and the public credit guarantee ratio should be
lowered further from the current 80-100 percent.
• Medium-term structural headwinds to the profitability of the sector continue (low interest
rates and demographics challenges).
 Several measures undertaken to increase banking sector profitability are welcome
(BoJ’s special deposit facility for regional banks, subsidies or enactments incentivizing
regional bank consolidation).

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 15

 Structural policy

After the pandemic, comprehensive reforms will be

needed to promote strong, sustainable, and inclusive
growth.

A shift to a low-carbon economy

Digital transformation

Reforms to increase labor supply and

boost productivity

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 16

 Structural policy

Japan’s carbon neutrality commitment is an

important and positive step.
Japan, the world’s sixth largest carbon emitter, Further efforts to execute the emission target
committed to reduce net GHG emission to zero could be considered.
by 2050.
Annual CO2 Emissions by Country Japan: Greenhouse Gas Emissions Targets
(Percent of total, 2020 data) (Millions of tons of CO2)
1600 1600

1400 1400
United States EU-28 India 1200 1200

1000 1000
Russia
800 800
China
By 2030, 46 percent reduction
Japan 600 from 2013 level
600
Iran 400 400
Indonesia
200 Greenhouse Gas emissions 200
South Korea 2030 target
Saudi Arabia 0 0
Rest of the world 2050 target By 2050, Carbon neutrality
-200 -200
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
Source: Our World in Data. Sources: Our World in Data; IMF staff calculations.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 17

 Structural policy

Progress towards digital transformation would

help boost productivity.
Digital adoption by businesses, government, Recent initiatives to encourage digitalization in the
and the financial sector lags other countries. private sector could catalyze digital investment.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 18

 Structural policy

Accelerating reforms will be critical to improve

growth potential and income distribution.
Given the demographic challenges, reforms to Skill training and reforms to eliminate productivity
increase labor supply, including for female and and wage gaps could boost labor productivity and
older workers, should be prioritized. wages as well as income equality.
Labor Force Participation Rate Nominal Wage Growth per Full-Time Employee
(In percent) (Average annual rate, in percent)
74 55 3.0 Wage growth per hour
73 54 2.5 Growth in hours worked per employee
Wage growth per employee
72 53 2.0
71 52 1.5
70 51 1.0
69 50 0.5
68 49 0.0
67 48 -0.5
66 Male Female (RHS) 47 -1.0
65 46 -1.5
64 45 -2.0
2011Q4 2013Q4 2015Q4 2017Q4 2019Q4 2021Q4 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Source: Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications. Source: Haver Analytics.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 19

 Roadmap
I. Outlook and policy priorities
• Outlook and risks
• Key policy recommendations
 Fiscal policy
 Monetary policy
 Financial sector policy
 Structural policy
II. IMF research highlights
• Post-pandemic fiscal policy: Implications from the Buffer-Stock Model
of Government
• Options for revenue mobilization
• Low for long rates and bank profitability
• Climate change policy options
• Climate finance in Japan
• Digitalizing the Japanese economy
III. Summary

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 20

 Post-pandemic Fiscal Policy:
Implications from the Buffer-Stock Model
of Government

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 21

 Post-pandemic Fiscal Policy

A stochastic structural model advises optimal

pace of unwinding the fiscal stimulus for Japan
• Our model-based analysis presents the optimal
Structural Primary Balance fiscal policy path, taking account of a trade-off
(General Government, percent of potential GDP) between output stabilization and debt
2.0 sustainability.
1.0
Near-term
0.0
-1.0 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 • The model suggests a wider structural
primary deficit in 2022.
-2.0
-3.0 • Policy implication: In response to the Omicron
-4.0 spread and the war in Ukraine, the government
-5.0 could deploy the contingent measures included
model advice in recent economic packages decisively to
-6.0 current policies
minimize hysteresis.
-7.0
-8.0 Medium-term
-9.0
• After 2024, the model advice deviates from the
Sources: IMF staff calculations. current policy scenario, recommending gradual
fiscal consolidation to stabilize debt and
rebuild fiscal buffers.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 22

 Post-pandemic Fiscal Policy

The recommended pace of consolidation

depends on the r-g assumptions
• Our baseline model-advice builds on an
Structural Primary Balance
assumption that the interest rate is equal to
(General Government, percent of potential GDP) growth in the long-run (r-g=0).
2.0
 With a small downward change (r-g=-0.3),
1.0
the model suggests a more gradual fiscal
0.0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
consolidation.
-1.0
-2.0  With a small upward change (r-g=0.3), the
-3.0 structural primary balance should be
-4.0 higher than in the baseline.
-5.0
model advice
-6.0
current policies
• Given sensitivity of the model results to r-g,
-7.0
r-g=-0.3% the medium-term fiscal framework could
-8.0
r-g=0.3% include a contingency plan that is readily
-9.0
implementable in cases of unfavorable
Sources: IMF staff calculations.
developments of economic growth and/or
interest rates.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 23

 Options for Revenue Mobilization

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 24

 Options for Revenue Mobilization

Distributional implications of revenue

mobilization
• A static micro-simulation is conducted to study distributional effects of six
tax reform options:
Japan: Change in Tax Burden Relative to the Current Policy  Lower the ceiling of the Employment Income Deduction of the
Settings by Income Groups (in ppt) Personal Income Tax from 1.95 to 1.5 million JPY
10 VAT credit
8 Fixed Asset Tax
 Lower the floor and the ceiling of the Pension Income Deduction of
the Personal Income Tax to 0.55 million JPY and 1.5 million JPY,
6 Emp. Insurance
respectively
4 Health Insurance
 Raise the VAT standard rate to 15 percent, with no reduced rate
2
Pension Insurance
0  Raise the capital income tax rate to 25 percent
Resident Tax
-2  Eliminate the preferential treatment of residential land in the Fixed
Personal Income Tax
-4
Asset Tax
Consumption Tax
-6  Introduce a VAT credit (equivalent to the GST Credit in Canada)
Total changes
I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X
Sources: KHPS, IMF Staff calculations.
• Simulation results after every option is implemented show:
Note: The data for this analysis, the Keio Household Panel Survey (KHPS), was
 A tax burden for each decile increases by 2 to 4 percentage points
provided by the Panel Data Research Center at Keio University.
 Before considering a VAT credit, roughly a half of the increase in the
tax burden in every decile is explained by a rise in the burden of the
consumption tax
 Redistributive effect of a VAT credit scheme is large
IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 25
 Options for Revenue Mobilization

Dynamic effects of tax reforms

• The IMF’s Global Integrated Monetary and Fiscal
Real GDP growth Model (GIMF) simulation is conducted to study
(ppt difference from the baseline) dynamic effects of three tax reform options:
1
VAT Increase by 1 percent of GDP 1. A permanent increase in consumption tax
Targeted Transfers of 0.3 percent of GDP revenues by 1 percent of GDP
Switch from CIT to CFT
0.5 2. An increase in targeted transfers by 0.3 percent
of GDP, in order to offset the impact of the
consumption tax hike on vulnerable households
0
3. A shift from the current Corporate Income Tax (CIT)
to a Cash Flow Tax (CFT) (as a proxy for an
-0.5
Allowance for Corporate Equity) in a revenue-
2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 neutral manner
Sources: GIMF simulations.
Note: The blue line traces out the impact of Option 1, the red dashed line shows the • Simulation results:
impact of both Options 1 and 2, and the black line illustrates the impact of all three
options.
 Adding targeted transfers mitigates the impact of
the consumption tax increase on output growth.
 A shift to a CFT results in output growth for an
extended period.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 26

 Low for Long Rates and Bank Profitability

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 27

 Low for Long Rates and Bank Profitability

Prolonged monetary accommodation and

structural shifts have weighed significantly on
bank profitability

Note: The highlighted area in blue represents the minimum and maximum of the
net interest margin in that particular year.
IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 28
 Low for Long Rates and Bank Profitability

Japan’s accommodative monetary policy stance

remains appropriate, but should be accompanied
by measures to safeguard financial stability.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 29

 Climate Change Policy Options

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 30

 Climate Change Policy Options

Japan’s Climate Change Policies

Adaptation Adaptation
(Clean energy and environment
(Resilient infrastructure) innovation)

International
cooperation

Carbon Mitigation Green finance

(Pricing and taxation) (ESG finance, green bond)

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 31

 Climate Change Policy Options

A comprehensive policy package—including green investment

and more reliance on carbon prices—could have net positive
growth impacts in the near- and medium-term

Japan: CO2 Emissions

(Gigatons of CO2) Japan: Impacts on Real GDP
(Deviation from baseline, percent)
2
5
4
1.5 3
2
1 1
0
-1
0.5
-2
-3
0 -4
2020 2023 2026 2029 2032 2035 2038 2041 2044 2047 2050 -5
2021-23 2036-38 2050-2052
(1) Baseline (2) 1 + Deviation of Infrastructure
Infrastructure Carbon tax Avoid Damage
(3) 2 + Deviation of Green subsidy (4) 3 + Deviation of Transfer Green subsidy Transfer Simulation Total
(5) 4 + Deviation of Carbon Price Source: IMF staff calculations.
Source: IMF staff calculations.

Avoid damage indicates the estimated benefits (output gains) of climate change
IMF | Asia and Pacific Department policies that will reduce climate-related damages over the medium- to long- term. 32
 Climate Finance in Japan

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 33

 Climate Finance

Japan is exposed to climate physical and

transition risks.
Natural disasters have occurred more frequently in On transitional risks, reaching net zero GHG
Japan. Climate change is expected to increase the emissions by 2050 will require higher carbon pricing
frequency and severity of extreme weather events. and large shifts in Japan’s economic structure.

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 34

 Climate Finance

Progress is being made in greening the financial

system, but additional efforts will be needed.
Stock market valuations in Japan do not appear Flows into sustainability themed funds have been
to reflect firms’ emission intensities. strong in Japan, in line with the global trend.

Valuation Difference between High and Low GHG ESG Equity Fund Flows
(Millions of US Dollars)
Emitters
(Difference in price-earnings ratio) 40,000 1000
15
All Developed Markets (LHS) Japan (RHS)
35,000
10 800
30,000

5 25,000 600
P/E ratio

0 20,000
400
15,000
-5
10,000 200
Materials Industrials
-10 5,000
Consumer Discretionary Consumer Staples
0
Information Technology Total 0
-15
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 -5,000 -200

Jan-16

Jan-17

Jan-18

Jan-19

Jan-20

Jan-21
May-16

Sep-16

May-17

Sep-17

May-18

Sep-18

May-19

Sep-19

May-20

Sep-20

May-21

Sep-21
Source: Bloomberg and IMF staff calculation.
Note: "total" includes all 11 sectors according to the GICS sector calssification. Emission intensity
measured by GHG emissions scaled by assets.
Sources: EPFR

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 35

 Digitalizing the Japanese Economy

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 36

 Digitalizing the Japanese Economy

The government’s digital transformation

strategy will help boost productivity and growth
The planned increase in public ICT investment This translates into a 0.8% increase in labor
and a new tax credit can boost ICT investment productivity, higher than the average increase of
by 5 percent 0.4% over 2010-19

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 37

 Digitalizing the Japanese Economy

Further measures are needed to ensure a safe and

inclusive digital transition of the Japanese economy
Investing in labor training on IT and digital Strengthening cybersecurity, consumer and
related skills, including digital financial literacy data protection will help build the public’s trust
should be prioritized in the digital economy

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 38

 Roadmap
I. Outlook and policy priorities
• Outlook and risks
• Key policy recommendations
 Fiscal policy
 Monetary policy
 Financial sector policy
 Structural policy
II. IMF research highlights
• Post-pandemic fiscal policy: Implications from the Buffer-Stock Model of
Government
• Options for revenue mobilization
• Low for long rates and bank profitability
• Climate change policy options
• Climate finance in Japan
• Digitalizing the Japanese economy
III. Summary

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 39

 Summary

Japan: Outlook and policies

• The recovery is expected to continue in 2022. Consumption will lead the recovery, with pent-up demand
being unwound. There is significant uncertainty around the outlook, including from the war in Ukraine.
• Near-term policy support to underpin the recovery. Fiscal policies should be supportive in the short-
run, while shifting towards facilitating resource reallocation. The BoJ should maintain monetary
accommodation.
• Medium- and longer-term policies to build back better after the pandemic.
• Fiscal buffers should be rebuilt gradually once the recovery takes hold, guided by a medium-
term fiscal framework underpinned by concrete policy plans.
• The BoJ should maintain monetary policy accommodation while taking further measures to make
that stance more sustainable.
• Financial supervision should remain vigilant to contain vulnerabilities.
• Digital and green transformations could be leveraged to promote strong, sustainable, and
inclusive growth after the pandemic. Reinvigorating reforms to increase labor supply, boost
productivity, and support investment would lift potential growth and facilitate reflation.
IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 40
 Thank You!
IMF Japan papers can be downloaded at: https://www.imf.org/en/Countries/JPN
2022 Japan Article IV Staff Report
2022 Japan Selected Issued Papers
Press Release: English |日本語

IMF | Asia and Pacific Department 41