Neanderthal - Living Rules
Neanderthal - Living Rules
Neanderthal - Living Rules
Rules changes in green font are changes between the 1st & 2nd editions. Changes since 2nd edition are in red font.
Card Errata: "STRING-WINDING", there is missing the "3-dice > take into hand" icon that is present on all the
other invention cards. This should be below the "1dice* > black disk" icon.
INTRODUCTION
The biggest mystery in anthropology is what ignited the cultural revolution 45,000 years ago in
Europe, when its upper half was covered with an ice-sheet. The Archaics, Neanderthals, and recently-
arrived Cro-Magnons1, who had never before left any record of art, religion, ritual, or science, and
1 ARCHAIC HOMO SAPIENS (Homo heidelbergensis) refers vaguely to humans intermediate between Homo erectus and his
1
who had not altered their handaxe technology in a million years, suddenly exploded in a flurry of cave
paintings, body adornments, carved venus figures, musical instruments, intentional burials, and new
portable tools. And this revolution spread from one human species to another, each of whom had
enjoyed large brains for a hundred thousand years without any prior cultural activity. Just what had
they been doing with all that brainpower that had not manifested itself in a single new tool or behavior
change detectable in the archeological record? This game suggests they were perfecting their language
skills to a threshold point that opened portals between brain domains and enabled lingual fluidity. 2
A. SUMMARY
The three players represent the Archaic Man 3 (Player Green), Neanderthal4 (Player Yellow), and Cro-
Magnon5 (Player Red) species fighting to survive in Europe during the last glacial maximum from 45,000
to 35,000 years ago. You begin the game vocal (i.e. words for speech but not ideas) and with a sexuality
(promiscuous, harem, or pair bonding). Your repertoire of orange, black, and white disks represents your
vocabulary of social, technical, and nature words. Use them to establish immature Elders or Husbands,
or to bid on cultures represented by daughter cards. Regain vocabulary by hunting Ice Age megafauna,
which also gives you Babies for the next generation. Your cultural daughters open up mental portals,
eventually sparking a cultural revolution converting you to a tribal culture. Historically, by the end of the
game all the species died out except the descendants of Cro-Magnon (that’s us!).
a. Turns. Each game turn represents 40 generations (perhaps 800 years). Each turn has six phases (A1)
during which each player performs his actions for the phase before going to the next.
b.Terminology. Terms being defined are listed in bold, or italicized if defined elsewhere. Capitalized
terms are defined in the Glossary of Tribesmen Roles (player aid).
presumed descendants: Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon. He could be a “garbage taxon”, a label for the museum drawer where all
the skulls with a brain size between 1100 and 1400 cc are kept. But he seems to be a type of large-brained and robust H.
erectus originating in Africa 500 kya (i.e. 500,000 years ago). Midway between Neanderthals and Cro-Magnons in height, by
300 kya he was hunting horses with javelins in Germany. European archaics spawned Neanderthals by 150 kya, and African
archaics spawned H. sapiens by 120 kya.
2 NEANDERTHALS are an extinct species of European and Near East hominids who lived from 150 to 40 kya. Their brain
size of 1200 - 1750 cc is notably larger on average than our own. They have anatomical features adapted for living in glacial
climates, with stout muscular bodies, barrel chests, and short legs. Their remains seem to have suffered a high degree of
physical injuries (similar to those suffered by rodeo riders) and degenerative diseases. They died out 5000 years after Cro-
Magnons reached Europe.
3 CRO-MAGNON is just another name for our physical selves: Homo sapiens - anatomically modern humans with a brain
size of 1200 - 1700 cc. But cognitively their minds were not as inventive or flexible as ours until the cultural revolution at 40
kya, about the time they first invaded Europe. By this time they had already been in Africa for 80,000 years, Asia for 60,000
years, and Australia for 20,000 years. Today, they are the only surviving members of the Homo lineage, albeit with admixtures
of Neanderthal and Denisovan genes.
4 WAR. Despite the development of throwing-spears and game ambush tactics, there is no archeological evidence for
organized warfare until 14 kya. Nomadic hunter-gatherers have no permanent homes, animals, or stored food to raid, confining
conflict arenas to women, contested hunting grounds or big kills. Because weapon use is in the natural history cognitive
domain, and fellow humans are in the social domain, perhaps weapons use against humans of the same species was not
conceivable until the advent of cognitive fluidity. On the other hand, forensic evidence of the Neanderthal skeleton Shanidar 3
indicates that he was struck by an atlatl-propelled spear, and died some weeks later. This is evidence of interspecies conflict or
warfare, since only H. sapiens used spear throwers.
5 THE OVERKILL HYPOTHESIS, as championed by Dr. Paul Martin, proposes that trophy-taking hunters caused the Late
Pleistocene mass extinctions in the Americas and perhaps in Europe and Australia as well.
2
c. The Golden Rule. If the text on a card contradicts these rules, the card has preference. If text on a
play aid contradicts these rules, the rules have precedence.
d.Combination Game with Greenland. See (K1). Greenland is also in the Dominata series, and so
uses many of the same rules, mechanisms, and components.
e. Differences with the game Greenland. Besides introducing new concepts (vocal, sexuality,
blizzards, predators, gathering, portals, neolexia, Wanderlust, precondition tools, and maturity),
Neanderthal uses different disk management (B3), a new Fire Starter (D4), and novel costing for
promotion (E2), marriage (E3), and elder actions (I3). Because there is no re-rolling, the turns
should go faster. Raiders can attempt intermarriage only as solitary Suitors (E3), not as a party of
Sabine Raiders, and cannot raid livestock.
6 THE ICE AGE that has plagued the Earth for the last 2 million years continues today. The glacial periods of this Ice Age
were interrupted occasionally by warmer (but still very cold) periods called interglacials. We live in one of those brief
interglacials, and may consider it “warm” outside, but should not forget that the last time Earth had seen actual ice at the poles
or on mountaintops was 250,000 kya, long before the dinosaurs. So today is abnormally cold. At the start of the game 45 kya,
it was at least 5° C colder with temperatures dropping even further during the Würm glaciation. As more and more water was
tied up in the spreading ice-sheets, Earth suffered desertification, droughts, and dropping sea levels. Humans were forced south
as the ice advanced.
3
h.Survivors. Surviving Hunters are returned to your unassigned tribesmen (B0).
5. DOMESTIC ANIMALS (Part H). Each mature D Card in your tableau gives you the Babies and
frees the disks specified.
6. SPECIES ACTIONS (Part I). You may perform one action:
a. Portal Action (vocal only) adds one portal disk from your vocabulary to your brain map (I1). This
can flip your Placard to tribalism (I1d).
b.Neolexia Action (vocal only) frees one dedicated disk to your vocabulary (I2).
c. Elder Action (tribal only) adds one D or I Card (as specified) from your hand to your tableau (I3).
To perform an Elder Action, you need an Elder of the proper rank (i.e. row on your Placard). You
also must dedicate a vocabulary disk of the specified color by placing it on the D or I Card.
7 NEOLITHIC refers to stone age tools and techniques that were not developed until the Holocene (when H. sapiens was the
only human left standing). Such technology, including polished tools, pottery, farming, towns, and walls, are not included in
the game because at 12 kya they are much too modern.
4
B. COMPONENTS
54 Tribesmen represent Elders if on a Placard, Husbands if on the husband box of a daughter, and
Hunters if anywhere else. There are 18 in each of the player colors (Cro-Magnon = red, Neanderthal =
yellow, Archaic = green). You must keep your unassigned tribesmen separate from the common
deadpile.
3 Large Tribesman. Each player has a larger tribesman, used for his Alpha Hunter (E5).
15 Orange Disks represent social words. Use these to raise daughters with social skills and to promote
tribesmen into Husbands, Warriors, or Chiefs. Your vocabulary (disks of all 3 colors) help keep your
tribe unified and not wandering into chaos.8
15 White Disks represent nature words (including the use of bone, antler, and ivory). Use these to raise
daughters with nature skills, promote tribesmen into Shamans and Trappers, to invent bone tools, and
domesticate animals.
15 Black Disks represent technical words (especially for making and using stone tools). Use these to
raise daughters with technical skills, promote tribesmen into Fire Starters and Knappers, attack first,
and to invent flint tools.
60 Cards (See the side of the box). There are 21 daughter cards, 18 North Europe biomes, 18 South
Europe biomes, and 3 Sexuality Cards.
3 Placards (Each player starts with one, see the side of the box). You start on the “vocal” side,
depicting the Brain Map. Disks placed on your Brain Map indicate portals between your three brain
domains.9 Tribesmen on the vocal side represent up to 4 kinds of Elders, each with the abilities shown.
8 WHY A SUDDEN EXPLOSION OF CULTURE? To put this mystery in game context, suppose the game starts 120 kya
instead of 45 kya, and each turn takes 1000 years. There are three huge-brained human subspecies, all clever enough to
somewhat use fire and make multicomponent (hafted) stone tools and handaxes long before their brains were big. Yet there are
other animals who have learned to exploit fire (e.g. an Australian fire-following hawk that has been observed to transport
burning branches to start new fires) and make tools. As the game begins, the European Neanderthals are hunting big game with
their hafted thrusting spears, alongside Archaics hunting smaller game with their javelins. Meanwhile the African Homo
sapiens are spreading throughout the rest of the world, but for unknown reasons stay clear of frosty Europe. For the first boring
94 turns, there is no innovation, technology, art, or culture. But then (45 kya) “Cro-Magnon” from Africa finally meets
Neanderthals in Europe, and for the next 6 game turns there is an interspecies revolution of culture and art. The Archaics may
have already been extinct by this time, and by turn 100 the Neanderthals are also gone. By turn 135, the Pleistocene is over,
replaced by the warm Holocene interglacial. Men are farming, settling in cities, throwing pots, and hunting with archery. On
turn 148, Jesus is born, and turn 150 is now. What caused the breakthrough in turn 95?
9 NEANDERTHAL EXTINCTION. No Neanderthal fossil younger than 40 kya has been unearthed. After living for 250,000
years with little innovation or culture, in their final 5000 years of cohabitation with Homo sapiens, they made remarkable
advances in tool-use, art, and language fluidity. And yet it was not enough. They did not entirely go extinct, as the entire
Neanderthal genome has been sequenced and it has been found all non-African humans today contain a few percent of their
genes.
5
Flip to the other side if you convert to tribalism, allowing two more Elders.
10 Six-sided dice (10d6). Use for attacks, hunt rolls, and Elder die-off.
1 Achievement Sheet.
1 Arrowhead. Use as a current player marker or alternately as a first player marker, especially during
council of war (A2).
The biome icon in the upper right corner of a biome describes the biome type: either (warhead) big game
hunting, (spear) small game trapping, or (club) courting/flint collecting/etc.
a. Climax. The number next to the icon is the climax. The lower the number, the more likely it is to be
replaced by global warming or cooling (D1).
Note (first edition errata): Unfortunately, card 26 (red deer) and card 35 (chamois) have a climax of 16. Therefore, use dice to
decide which has the lower climax, should it be required.
You will manage a faceup row of cards alongside your Placard called your tableau. Your starting tableau
will contain your Placard and a sexuality card. During the game you will add daughters, trophies,
domestic animals and inventions.
a. Hand. Biomes with the “hand” icon can be taken into your hand per G6. While in your hand they
represent unrealized ideas, and so are not in play and their abilities and VP are not activated until
played into your tableau as an Elder Action (I3). Daughter cards you purchase in auction go directly
into your tableau (alongside your Placard).
b.Hand Size. Your hand size is equal to the number of your mature Elders (tribal side only). (Before
the advent of literacy, only Elders were able to pass information between generations.)
c. Hand Size Reckoning. If you acquire a new hand card and your hand is full, you must choose one to
discard. If your hand size drops (e.g. you lose an Elder), you must discard hand cards until your hand
size is reached.
d.D or I Cards. Biomes that can be taken into your hand are marked with a purple band and a “D”
(domesticable animals), or a brown band and an “I” (inventions).
6
his meeple to indicate he is not yet mature and his abilities are inactive. This disk may be freed by
neolexia (I2), hunting (G3), or domestic animals (H1).
d.Immature Daughters, D Cards, and I Cards. Disks dedicated to bid on a daughter, to domesticate
an animal, or create an invention are placed on the card to indicate it is not yet mature and its abilities
are inactive. These disks may be freed by neolexia (I2), hunting (G3), or domestic animals (H1). The
card is mature once all the disks are removed.
e. MPI Disks. If you have harem-holding or promiscuous sexuality, place disks, called MPI disks, on
your sexuality card where indicated. These disks are removed from your vocabulary and are not freed
unless you change sexuality.10
C. SETUP
1. Events. Separate the daughter cards, and randomly place 10 of them into a shuffled facedown stack.
Set aside the remainder for possible use later.
2. Draw Decks. Separate the North Europe biomes (as stated on the card back), which go into a
shuffled facedown deck. Do the same for the South Europe biomes, in a deck just below the North
deck.11
3. European Biomes. Reveal the top six cards of the North Europe deck and spread them into a row to
the right of the draw deck. Do the same for the South Europe deck. These are the North and South
rows.
4. Starting Placards. Randomly assign each player to a Placard (red, yellow, or green). Place your
Placard in front of you on its vocal side (showing the brain) to start your tableau; see the side of the
box.
10 LEVALLOIS is the distinctive stone knapping technique of this period, commonly associated with the Neanderthal
Mousterian industries. This is incredibly difficult to master. It was replaced by the vastly simpler and more flexible prism core
knapping technique during the cultural revolution.
11 DISKS REPRESENT WORDS. Why? I argue that (1) words are the most important human invention ever, and (2) the
primary function of words is not communication with others, but communication with oneself, as the basis for
“consciousness”. Introspect on your own thoughts, a stream of words with grammar and syntax, running more or less
continuously (even at night, with rather less context). Animals (and humans for most of their history) had no running stream,
as they lacked the vocabulary. But at some point (which I postulate to be the event called “the cultural revolution), the first
word was used both during speaking and as a unit of mental processing. The word came to be used as the medium by which
the left “word building” half of the brain communicated with the right “executive” half of the brain, following the ideas of
Julian Jaynes. See the essay at the end of the rules book.
7
5. Sexuality Cards. Distribute each of the three double-sided cards with a “comet” icon in the upper
right corner randomly to each player. Each player chooses a sexuality by placing this card either
facedown or faceup into his tableau.12
6. Starting Tribesmen. Each player gets the 18 tribesmen and the large tribesman (Alpha) of his color.
Place 6 tribesmen below your Placard; these are your unassigned tribesmen. Put another tribesman
into the elder spot in the lower left corner (marked with a downward arrow); this is your Fire Starter.
Put your Alpha and your remaining tribesmen together with the Alphas and tribesmen of the others into
a communal deadpile. It’s best to use a small bowl to keep the common deadpile separate from the
living tribesmen.
7. Starting Disks. Start each player with 5 disks of each color. Store these 15 disks next to your
Placard. This is called your vocabulary.
a. Starting Portal. From your vocabulary, place one disk of the color specified in the portal spot
marked with a downward arrow on the brain map.
b.Fire Starter. From your vocabulary, place one black disk under your Fire Starter. This indicates he
starts immature.
c. MPI Disks. From your vocabulary, place the number of disks indicated on your sexuality card (B3).
12 SPECIALIZED INTELLIGENCE occupied three ancient mental domains according to Leda Cosmides and John Tooby:
social for ‘mind reading’ and interacting with other individuals, natural history for understanding the natural world, and
technical for the manufacture, manipulation, and hurling of stone and wooden artifacts. Evidence for these modules stems
from the inability of animals and early man to be able to use information obtained from processing in one domain in another.
This changed when the processing units in all three domains came to be mapped to vocalizations that humans can make.
13 ALLEGED NEANDERTHAL RELIGIOUS RITUALS have proven hard to verify. For instance, the supposed sacrifice or
worship of the now extinct cave bear based upon thousands of cave bear remains may represent the accumulation of beasts
which died during hibernation, and arrangements of bones claimed to be artificial may in fact be natural. Nevertheless, both
species frequented caves, and one bear vertebrate found with an embedded stone tip indicates the giant bears were occasionally
hunted or fought. This game assumes that hunters who bring back big game trophies are rewarded by female choice to have
their genes immortalized in subsequent generations.
8
use it as an ice-sheet (i.e. facedown) to replace the lowest climax (B1) card in the north row. The card
which has been replaced shifts directly south, replacing the card already there, which is discarded from
the game.
a. Ice-sheets. Consider ice-sheets to be very high climax, so they are not affected by climate change
other than “Glacial Melt” (next bullet). If the north is entirely ice during global cooling, shift one ice-
sheet directly south (into a gap if any to choose among, or displacing the lowest climax southern card
if no gaps) to make room for another northern ice-sheet.
Example: Global cooling occurs. The existing three cards in the north row are climax 12, 23 and 27.
The climax 12 card is displaced to the south and replaced with a new facedown card drawn from the
north deck, representing the growth of a northern ice-sheet. The displaced card shifts south, and
replaces the card immediately below.
The global warming icon means to reveal the top card of the southern Europe deck and use it to
replace the lowest climax (B1) card in the south row. Shift the replaced card directly north, either into a
gap if there is one there, or displacing the card there which goes out of the game. However, if the card
already there is an ice-sheet, then instead flip it over to reveal its non-ice side, and discard the shifting
card out of the game.
b.Glacial Melt. After the new card is placed, global warming melts any ice-sheets in southern Europe.
Indicate this by flipping these cards faceup.
14 EUROPE, the coldest and most ice-bound corner of the megacontinent, was first invaded 800 kya by Homo erectus.
Subsequent invasions, likely across the Bosphorus and along the Danubian corridor, occurred by 500 kya (Archaic Man), by
150 kya (Neanderthal), and by 45 kya (Cro-Magnon). By the time of the Last Glacial Maximum (20 kya), the whole of
Continental Europe (except Scandinavia and regions covered by ice), had been settled. The hybridization of humans and the
harsh conditions of Europe seemed to have kindled the cultural revolution.
15 SEXUAL DIMORPHISM means a large size difference between males and females, and is a sign of harem-holding mating
strategies. Our distant ancestors the Australopithecines had sexual dimorphism and likely had a sexist society where
promiscuity was strongly chastised. But H. erectus and H. heidelbergensis have little sexual dimorphism, and were likely far
more libertine. Such societies would be driven by “human sperm competition”, with genetic victory going to the males
producing and delivering the most sperm. This is perhaps when people inherited their relatively large male genitals. One way
to avoid the “sperm competition” is “safari honeymooning”, where a male would whisk his estrous partner off to the woods to
be alone. This elopement, aberrant in a promiscuous society, could have led to the first marriage-like pair bonding. The darker
side is that this increases male jealousy and violence.
9
exactly one Elder (of your choice, mature or immature) if you have any. Place the removed Elder
into the deadpile.
a.Chaos Immunity. You are safe from chaos if the number of your unassigned tribesmen is
less than or equal to your vocabulary (B3). If tribal, you are also safe from chaos if you have
a mature Chief in the rank 1 spot. This anti-chaos protection is shown by the ”slashed comet”
icon.
b. Fire Starter. If you have a mature Fire Starter in the rank 6 spot, your chaos losses are
rounded down instead of up, and you do not lose an Elder.
c.Sexuality Decision. If you suffer any losses during this chaos event, you may flip your
sexuality card to its other side, releasing any MPI disks (B3) that were on it. If the new
sexuality requires MPI disks, these must be added or the sexuality change fails.
Note: If you change to promiscuous, you are no longer allowed to place Husbands, but Husbands already placed remain
married. The same goes for Husbands placed if you are promiscuous and have the piper daughter. They remain even if you lose
the piper daughter.
Example: In a chaos event, Archaic has 3 unassigned tribesmen (including his Alpha), but has only 2
vocabulary. He is vocal, and has the Fire Starter, allowing him to round losses down and ignore the
elder loss. He therefore loses one tribesman to chaos. If he did not have the Fire Starter, he would lose
both his tribesmen, leaving only his Alpha. Because of his tribesman loss, he may flip his sexuality.
Example: In a blizzard, you have 5 unassigned tribesmen, 2 unmarried daughters, 2 Elders, and 1
domestic animal. Your 5 tribesmen can only support 2 Dependents and you choose to lose the animal
16 THE BRAIN MAPS, following the ideas of Steven Mithen, hypothesize that the Pleistocene hunter-gatherer brains were
compartmentalized into three domains: technical, nature, and social knowledge. The barriers between these domains
prevented, for instance, an early man from carving bone tools. Why not? Because stones and stone tools were processed in his
technical domain, as artifacts to be knapped, while bones and antlers were processed in his nature domain, as clues for game
animal behavior. These processes were inflexible, like a Swiss army knife with specialized blades or computer programming.
Portals were finally opened when words were used in multiple domains, such as the word “bone” being used in a technical
setting (evidenced by the first bone artifacts). Other crossovers: “people” as objects to be manipulated (the first deceptions),
“animals” as people (anthropomorphisms and totemism), “objects” as people (venus statuettes, grave goods). The fluidity of
words triggered the cultural revolution. The culture cards denoting swear words, jokes, poetry, and other strange quirks of
language are included because of my theory that the lingual features that are the least explicable are the most likely to be
primal in cognitive fluidity.
10
and both the Elders to preserve the daughters.
17 CAVE PAINTINGS, the earliest symbolic art, seem to have spread quickly around the world. The subjects, eerily similar
from Spain to Indonesia, are almost always animals rendered with astonishing skill. People are seldom depicted, why not?
Handprint stencils are a common signature, why? The locations are uninhabited portions of caves, visited only to make the
paintings in torchlit darkness, why? And most remarkable of all, the art shows signs of being retouched over a period of a
thousand years or more. I theorize that the paintings lubricated the recreation of images from the artist’s verbal memory, while
inculcating the concepts. The exercise of specific pathways in the neural network is known to reinforce them, akin to fuzzy
logic, which could have made the brain conducive to this vital step in the road to consciousness. A process repeated today
every time an infant masters language.
11
Example 1: The generous woman is up for bid, who requires black or orange bid media. Players Red
and Yellow each bid one orange disk, and neither is willing to bid higher. Since Player Yellow is the
first player, he wins the bid and places the daughter into his tableau with one orange disk on her.
Player Red gets his bid returned to his vocabulary.
Example 2: A daughter with a bid media of orange is up for bid. But Archaic is the only vocal player
with an orange disk, so he can buy her for one orange (the minimum bid). This disk is placed on the
daughter card in his tableau. Suppose another player is tribal harem-holding and also can bid. If he is
the first player, he can bid two orange disks (each count as half) and win the bid. If he is instead the
last in player order, he can bid three disks and win the bid.
18 VENUS FIGURINES, portable hand-held statues with exaggerated female features, but with reduced or absent faces, arms,
and feet, have been found in Europe. The oldest, carved from mammoth ivory, date back to the cultural revolution. They
strangely have no analogs in cave paintings. Julian Jaynes speculates that they acted as portable mnemonic devices, reminders
to a nonconscious people who could not voluntarily retrieve admonitory lessons given to them by their mothers. Shadows of
this ancient utility are presumably why we still place figurines on our desks, churches, and keychains, for reasons we often
can’t ourselves explain.
12
a.Promotion Costs. Unless you have free promotions, you must set a vocabulary disk under
the figure, of a color the same as the color of the Elder rank icon (orange, white, or black).
This disk indicates he is immature. Once mature (i.e. his disk is freed per B3), all his listed
abilities are activated.
b. Limits. You are limited to one Elder per rank, and Elders cannot change ranks.
c.Phase 1 (Event) Elder Benefits. The Chief protects your tribe from chaos. The Warrior
allows you to specify the player order, if you are the assigned first player. During chaos
(D4), the Fire Starter prevents elder loss and allows you to round losses down instead of up.
d. Phase 2 (Hunter Assignment) Elder Benefits. The Fire Starter gives you cost-free elder
promotions.19
e.Phase 3 (Negotiations/Attacks/Gathering) Elder Benefits. The Chief allows your Hunters
negotiations (F1). The Warrior allows War Party formation (F2).
f. Phase 4 (Hunting) Elder Benefits. The Fire Starter protects your Hunters from frostbite.
The Knapper, Warrior, and Trapper give your Alpha special powers (E5).
g. Phase 6 (Elder Action) Elder Benefits. The Chief lets you perform your elder action without
cost. The Shaman, Knapper, or Trapper can perform an elder action (I3).
h. General Elder Benefits. All tribal Elders increase hand size (B2).
i. Precondition Disks. If Vocal, you may not promote an Elder of ranks 3, 4, or 5 unless you have a
portal (I1) of each of the 3 colors in the specified domain. This is similar to precondition tools (E1),
except the required disks are portals instead of vocabulary.
Example: You have a black venus portal and two Shaman portals (white and orange). This gives you
portals of all three colors in your social domain, satisfying the preconditions for a Warrior (rank 4).
During Phase 2, you promote a Hunter into a Warrior by putting its figure on top of an orange disk
indicated in the upper left corner of the Placard. The orange disk indicates the Elder is immature.
E3. COURTSHIP
Each player may assign an unassigned tribesman as a Suitor, to a maximum of one per daughter, placed
somewhere on the daughter he is wooing. A Suitor of any sexuality can court any daughter (mature or
immature, foreign or domestic, married or single). A Suitor may become a Husband in Phase 4.
Important (Lolita Rule): Since courting always fails if the daughter is immature, you should not assign a Suitor to an immature
daughter unless you think the daughter will mature by the time the courting roll is made.
a. Benefits. If your Suitor becomes an immature Husband, he has a limited attack ability per F2. If he
subsequently matures (i.e. his disk is freed per B3), he makes his wife into a non-dependent, defends
her from suitors as a War Party, and is worth VP at the game’s end. If you are pair bonding, a
Husband (mature or immature) is required to unlock your daughter’s benefits.20
19 THE TECHNICAL, SOCIAL, AND NATURAL HISTORY DOMAINS are depicted on the placards as being in the
neocortex, limbic, and rhombencephalon respectively. These locations are suggestive rather than factual. The
rhombencephalon is the most ancient part of the brain, shared by vertebrates and insects alike. The limbic system governs
emotions, behavior, and long term memory. The neocortex is greatly expanded in humans, and contains the Broca’s and
Wernicke’s language centers.
20 NEOLEXIA is the creation of new words, both for communicating with and thinking with. External communications were
likely pioneered by males in the dominance games or in organized hunts. This is represented in the game by scavenging, flint
mine, and social disks, among others. But perhaps the first use of words for both external and internal communications (i.e.
units of thought) was pioneered by females, who taught this skill to their babies.
13
E4. PERMANENT ASSIGNMENT
Placing unassigned tribesmen on the Placard (E2) or the husband box on daughters (G1) is a permanent
assignment. This means the tribesmen are not counted as unassigned tribesmen (e.g. during chaos) and
are not returned to your unassigned tribesmen during Phase 4.
a. Sultan’s Exception. If harem-holding, during Phase 2 you can shift your Husbands in your tableau
(including immature ones) among your unmarried mature daughters. This can be useful to challenge
Suitors.
b. Almost Extinct Exception. If you begin this phase with all tribesmen assigned as Wanderlusters,
Husbands, or Elders, you may reassign one or two Elders or Husbands as unassigned tribesmen. If all
your tribesmen are dead, you become a Lazarus Species (J1).
Example: You have a black, white, and orange portal in your “nature domain” on your brain map, and
have promoted a Trapper. As long as this Elder is mature and hasn’t died, he allows your Alpha to
automatically roll a “1” in small game hunting.
14
offer or demand unmarried mature daughters for marriage (allowing a Hunter to be promoted into
a mature Husband in a foreign tableau with an auto-success courtship roll (G1)), or make non-
binding agreements about plays on future turns.
a. Leaving. Your Hunters may leave during this phase only if all other players with tribesmen
present allow you to leave. If your Hunter leaves, either return him to your unassigned
tribesmen (so he can’t do anything this turn), or else marry him to a foreign bride (G1), if
agreed to by the player holding the unmarried daughter.
Note: In a trade, hand cards must be exchanged with hand cards and tableau cards with tableau cards.
b. Divorce. Your Husbands may leave daughters during negotiations, joining your unassigned
tribesmen.
c. Oook Rule. During negotiations, a vocal player should say nothing other than “yes” (oook!) or
“no” (ook ook).
Example: Neanderthal is promiscuous and has a Warrior. He sends his Alpha to court a married Cro-
Magnon daughter. The Husband has more black disks and attacks first, but fails to roll a “1” or “2”.
The Alpha is a War Party, and he rolls a “2” and succeeds in killing the Husband. Since the Alpha is
on a club biome, in the next phase he is automatically successful in his “hunt” roll. Because he is
promiscuous, he leaves a Baby per G1.
21 EXOGAMY is the practice of leaving one’s clan to marry elsewhere, perhaps even to another subspecies. In general,
human societies are female-exogamous, i.e. it is the females who leave home to marry, keeping both the gene pool and the idea
pool diverse and healthy. In this, humans are similar to the other social apes (chimps and gorillas), but dissimilar to most
monkeys which are male-exogamous. Genetic analysis proves that Sapiens-Neanderthal interbreeding had occurred by 55 kya,
when Neanderthal genes constituted as much as 1–4% of the Cro-Magnon genome. Ötzi the iceman, Europe's oldest preserved
mummy at 5.3 kya, was found to possess an even higher percentage of Neanderthal ancestry. Even more telling than genes is
the fact that the cultural revolution occurred in both Cro-Magnon and Neanderthal populations.
22 THE CULTURAL REVOLUTION, also called the Chatelperronian culture, was perhaps created by a hybrid human, as
suggested by one of the box illustrations. But remarkably, once started, it spread to both the Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon
peoples between 45-40 kya, as evidenced by sophisticated stonework, multicomponent tools, prism core blade factories,
adornment necklaces of intentionally pierced fox and marmot teeth, and rings and pendants made of ivory. Each greatly
expanded their existing ancient technology in their own fashion, without copying the other. This argues that what was being
spread was language, and symbolic art such as early paintings and sculptures were the first school supplies.
15
F3. GATHERING23
If you are a gathering culture (i.e. you are either promiscuous or have wives/daughters with the
“gathering” ability), you collect 1 Baby (see glossary) for each gathering biome you occupy with
one or more Hunters. These biomes are marked with the basket icon.
Example: After combat, you have Hunters remaining on the tyrant sea bear (a “gathering biome”).
Because you are promiscuous (so are spending more time collecting nuts than in child care), you
gain one Baby in gathering. This Baby is obtained even if the sea bear later kills off all your Hunters.
23 NEANDERTHAL, an awesome übermensch, appeared a quarter of a million years ago in Pleistocene Europe. One of the
biggest, strongest, highest stamina, and smartest creatures who ever lived. With a brain notably larger than our own, he had
mastered a knapping technique so difficult that less than a dozen persons alive today can duplicate it. His multi-component
thrusting spear, the most advanced in the world, could bring down a rhinoceros. He could tame fire, build shelters, and survive
in the harshest corner of the supercontinent. Together with his Asian brethren the Denisovans, he should be able to invade the
whole world including ancestral Africa. In a few tens of thousands of years, he should be inventing the microchip and flying
747's. But it didn't happen. Hundreds of thousands of years pass, and his behavior and tools have not visibly changed. True,
such conservatism, set for the glacial pace of natural selection, is the norm for Earth's millions of species. But what is that huge
brain for, if not for art, culture, or innovation? And when Cro-Magnon finally invaded, 45,000 years ago, he too had spent the
last 100,000 years with a big brain and a stone age toolset but no art, culture, or improvements. The two superpowers were
behaviorally equivalent, with all the culture and inventiveness of a stone. But somehow, their momentous meeting produced
everything that we now regard as human.
24 RAPE. This four-letter word, used in this game’s prototype, proved far too emotional a term to be the name of a game
mechanic. By my use of euphemisms, I am regrettably perpetrating the taboos associated with rape, which cause it to be the
most underreported violent crime. I apologize to its victims (one of whom I know personally) who have to suffer not only the
crime, but the social stigma associated with it. Rape has Darwinian significance in primatology, where it is delicately called
“coerced copulations”. It is estimated that half the orangutan babies are conceived from matings between young males and
unwilling females who are part of a flanged male’s harem. This percentage of rape babies means the genes for aggressive male
16
Each player with a surviving Suitor on a daughter card may use him to make a courtship roll. Each
player can make only one courtship roll per daughter card.
a. Lolita Auto-Fail. If the daughter is immature, the courtship roll cannot succeed.
b.Courtship Roll Procedure. Roll 1d6. The roll is successful if a “1” or “2” is rolled. If a “6” is rolled,
the Suitor is killed (as indicated by the bloody dice).
c. Auto-Success Courtship. Unless the daughter is a Lolita, a Warrior Alpha always succeeds and a
Suitor courting an uncontested and unmarried daughter in his own tableau always succeeds without
rolling. If the courtship is contested (next bullet), a Suitor in his own tableau must compete for her
hand like everyone else, with no “home court” advantage.
d.Multiple Suitors. If there are multiple Suitors, each rolls for success in most vocabulary order,
counting only the vocabulary colors shown on the bid media in the top of the daughter card. (This
represents a verbal wooing.) If tied, the daughter’s father decides between them. The first successful
courtship roll must install a Husband if it is possible to do so (next bullet), and sends all other Suitors
home unrequited.
Example: The singing woman has just matured in the Neanderthal’s tableau, and all three players assign
a Suitor to court her. The singing woman’s bid media is orange. Assuming they all survive the attack
phase, the Cro-Magnon has the most orange disks and rolls first. He fails to roll a “1” or “2”, and
Neanderthal has the next most orange disks. His courtship roll automatically succeeds, because he has a
daughter in his tableau (the Singing Woman herself) who has the “poetry” ability to auto-succeed
courtship rolls. Neanderthal however, is promiscuous, so even though his roll succeeds, he cannot place
a Husband. Because the courtship is in his own tableau, there is no rape baby and the only effect of his
successful courtship is to send the suitor of Archaic Man home unrequited. If instead Neanderthal was
pair bonding, he would not have the auto-success courtship, because Singing Woman’s abilities are
deactivated if she is unmarried. If he rolls a “1” or “2”, he must install an immature Husband, assuming
he has an orange immaturity disk.
e. Successful Courtship. Only one Husband (mature or immature) is allowed per daughter. A
successful Suitor returns the former Husband (if any) to the unassigned tribesmen of whichever
player owns the tableau, and places the Suitor in the husband box as the new Husband. This is a
permanent assignment (E4). If you cannot place the Husband, either because you lack a required
orange disk for an immature Husband or because the Suitor is promiscuous (next 2 bullets), the Suitor
returns to his unassigned pile and the husband box is left unchanged.
f. Husband Maturity. Your new Husband starts mature if in a foreign tableau, and immature, with an
orange disk under his token, if he starts in your tableau. Regardless of maturity, the husband gains the
daughter’s abilities and portal actions (I2), with her “father” sharing these benefits.
g.Promiscuous Courting.25 If your successful Suitor in a foreign tableau is promiscuous, he cannot
rapists are being selected for. This drives the orang society to be ever more solitary, which is harmful because like human
infants the orang young are altricial. In chimpanzees, a promiscuous species, pair bonding is the “crime” and rape the “norm”.
Chimps will mob females who resist promiscuous matings or show favoritism for one male over another.
25 ACHEULEAN STONE TOOL INDUSTRY are represented by black disks in the game. This includes the handaxe, a pear-
shaped flint tool used by humans for a million years and inherited by all three species in the game. But nobody knows what it
was for. It could have been used for all sorts of jobs: butchering animals, cutting plants, stripping bark, extracting marrow, or
all of the above. Since they were sharp all around, perhaps they were a projectile for slings. But why the obsessive attention to
symmetry and refined form? Why were so many needed for the small groups, thousands in some sites? Why does wear
analysis indicate that most were unused? Why were some much too big or too small for any practical use? Why do some seem
to have been abandoned and stuck into the ground point first? These facts argue that the handaxe form was driven not by
technology, which requires both a verbal cognitive template and the ability to manipulate verbal-created images in one’s mind.
Rather, its form was more likely maintained by Darwinian “sexual selection”, assuming lek behavior where females selected
17
become a Husband and instead you add a Wanderluster of your color from the deadpile to the
unassigned tribesmen of whichever player owns the tableau, representing your genetic legacy. This
does not impact her marital status. Then your Suitor returns home.
h.Alpha Husband. If your Alpha becomes a Husband, see B4.
Example (fog of love): An Archaic daughter married to a Neanderthal is being courted by Archaic and
Cro-Magnon. All three players unsuccessfully roll for combat in Phase 3. Then, in vocabulary order
the the two suitors" (Archaic and Cro-Magnon) make a courtship roll in Phase 4. Archaic goes first,
and rolls a “2” which defeats the other suitors. The Neanderthal ex-husband is added as a
wanderluster to the Archaic tribesmen, and the Cro-Magnon is sent home. If instead the Cro-Magnon
succeeded, and Cro-Magnon was promiscuous, then the Archaic Husband remains and all the suitors
go home. A red Wanderluster is added to the Archaic tribesmen.
Example: You have played and matured the “cordage snare” in your tableau. This has a phase 4 dice
modifier with the “javelin-point” icon, indicating that all 3’s rolled in small game hunts become 1’s
instead.
Example: Three Cro-Magnon and two Archaics are hunting wolves. The Archaics, with fewer Hunters,
go first and are successful with one hit. The Cro-Magnon automatically go home in disgrace (with no
attrition). They cannot attempt to domesticate the wolves, for instance.
the tool-maker with the most perfectly-made handaxe. If the handaxe was the product of female rather than technological
choice, it would explain why the design was so static for so long, by far the longest used tool in human experience. Whatever
its function, the cultural revolution abruptly ended the reign of the handaxe. Not a single handaxe has been uncovered in
regions colonized after the revolution, for instance America.
18
G4. PREDATOR ATTACK
If your hunt roll succeeds in a big game hunt, you attract predators, i.e. cards with a red icon in the upper
right corner. To find out which predator attacks, look at all the cards in the same row to see which one is
the closest to the biome being hunted. Do not consider a predator on the other side of an ice-sheet in the
row, i.e. predators can hop “gaps” but not ice. If two are equally close, both attack, starting with the lower
climax.
a. Procedure. Move the surviving Hunters onto the card of the attacking predator. Once all big game
hunts are resolved in this row, your hunters will make a second hunt attempt against the predator..
This hunt is resolved the same way as the first, and so may cause additional casualties or if successful
may give the Hunters more resources or Babies.
b.Predator Piracy. If your Hunters do not get at least one hit on the second hunt roll against an
attacking predator and the predator is not already eliminated, then the predator steals the big game
you successfully hunted, so that you lose all the Babies, disks, trophies, and domestic animals you
gained in the hunt (returning the card to its slot on the map).
Note: Some predators may be taken as trophies (G5), while others may be domesticated (G6).
Example: In South Europe, you have 7 Hunters on the horse, and 1 Hunter (actually a Gatherer) on
the scimitar cat. You opponent has 19 Hunters on the elephant. Both big game hunts succeed, which
puts all your Hunters and all his Hunters on the scimitar cat, joining the one already there. Your 8
Hunters hunt first. If you roll at least one “1”, the cat does not steal your horse. If you roll two “1”s,
you successfully hunt the cat, and your opponent must go home without rolling for the cat, and are
therefore not at risk for losing their elephant. Regardless of the success of the hunt or the piracy, if you
roll quadruples you take the cat card as a trophy.
Example: Five fallow deer-hunters roll a “2” and three 3’s. This is a hunting failure because the deer
requires 2 hits, but nevertheless takes the card as a trophy because of the triples. If they have an atlatl
26 MPI stands for Male Parental Investment, the time and energy the father is willing to invest so that his children will survive
to breeding age. Most mammalian males provide no parental care, and their sperm is their sole contribution to their offspring
and their temporary mate. This is represented by the 6 MPI disks for the promiscuous sexuality. But the big-headed human
babies are born prematurely in comparison to other primates, and for many months are helpless. Human males hunters could
achieve a considerable genetic payback by sharing the handy, dense packages of protein they brought back.
19
allowing 3’s to be converted into 1’s, then the hunt is a success as well as a trophy.
Example: A Trapper Alpha and two Hunters are hunting honey bees. Both Hunters roll 1’s, and, since
this is a small game hunt, the Alpha automatically rolls a “1”. The hunt is a success, and furthermore
the triples allow them to take the bees into their hand. They may later use an Elder Action (I3) to
domesticate it. The honey bee card is replaced per the biodiversity rule (G7).
28 THE WORST ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER IN HUMAN EXPERIENCE? What catastrophe rendered 20%-30% of
the Earth’s land area as lifeless as the moon? Answer: The last glacial maximum, especially the Würm Glacial in Europe from
70 to 11 kya. Except for brief Mesozoic episodes, life had not experienced ice for hundreds of millions of years, and even
today remains extirpated from the interiors of Greenland and Antarctica. But if today’s Ice Age lasts long enough, perhaps the
ice-sheets will turn green with ice-adapted vegetation.
20
a. Phase 2 (Hunter Assignment). By dedicating 1 black disk, he promotes a tribesmen to the 3rd rank
(Knapper). Then he places his remaining 4 unassigned tribesmen, plus his Alpha, onto the horse card
as shown.
b. Phase 4 (Hunt Roll). Let’s assume that Cro-Magnon first makes a successful hunt somewhere
allowing him to liberate the black disk under his Knapper, making it mature. This is necessary to
enable the Alpha powers for his Alpha Hunter. He rolls 4d6 for his five horse-hunters: “3”, “4”, “5”,
“6”. Since only his Alpha succeeds and he needs 2 successes, the hunt fails.
c. Weapon.29 If he has atlatl spear-throwing technology, the “3” acts as a “1”, resulting in hunt success.
He gains 3 Babies and an orange and a black disk. Since he did not roll quadruples, he doesn’t take
the horse into his hand.
d. Predators. Since the hunt was successful, the closest predator, the gray wolves, attack. The wolves
are a “club” biome, and the Alpha is no longer an automatic success since there is no rank 5 Elder.
All five Hunters roll “5”. “5”, “6”, “6”, “6”. Two Hunters are killed off by wolves, and the rest die
from frostbite. Because everyone dies, Cro-Magnon loses the Babies and disks gained from the horse
hunt, and furthermore cannot take the wolves into his hand for domestication.
e. Fire Starter. If Cro-Magnon had a mature rank 6 Elder (Fire Starter), all three Hunters that rolled the
“6” are saved from frostbite. Since no hits were scored, the wolves still steal the horse carcass, so no
Babies or disks are gained. However, the triples rolled with surviving Hunters means that the wolf
card is taken into his hand for possible domestication later.
29 CHAOS refers to the lack of group cohesion caused mainly by the selfish gene. It’s a myth that individual animals act for
the good of their species; they actually act for the furtherance of their genes. Violent struggles during courtship for access to
females lead to the toppling of the alpha male (a theme explored in our game Pax Porfiriana). A toppling leads to mass
infanticide, another source of chaos which is the cause of a third of gorilla deaths. The new dominant male kills off the infants
that he “realizes” do not share his genes. Although most female mammals know when they are ovulating, human females do
not. Concealed ovulation may have evolved in humans to keep daddy at home at all times, protecting the genes invested in
“his” kids, when otherwise he would be tempted to wander off in search for ovulating females to impregnate when his own
mate was not fertile.
21
how metaphoric vocabulary can broach adjacent brain domains. 30
a. Domains and Domain Colors. Each brain map has three brain domains, for technical (black), nature
(white), and social (orange) knowledge.31
b.Portal Spots. The three portal spots are the venus, Shaman, and bison spots.32 Each portal spot can
hold two portals, one of each of the two colors shown. For instance, the venus portal can hold at most
one orange and one black disk.33 Each portal is between two domains, for instance the Shaman portal
is always between the social and nature domains.
c. Portal Use. Portals can be used for precondition disks (E2). They can’t be used for bidding,
precondition tools, or victory. They can be freed only by converting to tribalism.
d.Conversion.34 A brain map with 5 portal disks instantly becomes lingually fluid (all 6 portals in the
solitaire or 2-player game). Flip it to its tribal side, and add the portal disks to your vocabulary.
Transfer Elders (as well as any disks under them) to the equivalent rank on the tribal side.
30 HUNTER-GATHERER SURVIVAL is all about getting through the bad times, the blizzard icon represents a particularly
harsh winter. If your energy supplies run low before spring comes, you must sacrifice elders, unmarried daughters, or farm
animals.
31 MOTHERESE. According to Valérie Fridland, Professor of Linguistics at the University of Nevada, women are the
primary caregiver and accordingly are the vanguard of linguistic changes which they pass on to children.
32 PRECONDITION TOOLS in the game are not applied to predators. This is because assigning hunters to a predator in the
game is interpreted as using torches to drive it away from its kill so you can steal its meat. Not for the faint of heart.
33 FIRE was rarely and opportunistically used by humans since H. erectus. However, Neanderthals were the first to regularly
exhibit fire and hearths in their campsites and show signs they had mastered starting fires, not just transporting live embers.
This happened very late in their tenure, about 60 kya.
34 MENOPAUSE is the natural programmed cessation of the female menstrual cycle, known only in humans and pilot
whales. It likely evolved in humans (and possibly Neanderthals) sometime in the hundreds of thousands of years between the
development of huge brains and the cultural revolution. It is a puzzle why the “selfish gene” would ever select for a process
that prematurely shuts down the possibility of spreading itself. This game follows the “Grandmother hypothesis”, that
menopause promotes the survival of a woman’s grandchildren. This would be especially true in promiscuous societies, where
only mothers and grandmothers care for children. Studies by the anthropologist Kristen Hawkes on the Hazda hunter-gatherers
of Tanzania shows that postmenopausal grandmothers devoted the most time to gathering (7 hours a day, compared to 4.5
hours for young mothers and 3 hours for young brides). Further, the experienced grandmothers brought home more kilograms
of forage per hour than women in their prime. Indeed, as crazy as it sounds, in this game most of the extra hunters doing the
foraging in a promiscuous society are actually grandmothers. Without the natural birth control of menopause, a woman would
be pregnant or lactating her entire adult life, and would be at high risk from death from childbirth (a legacy of bearing babies
with huge brains).
22
Example: You have both venus portals (orange and black), and one portal (white) on your Shaman.
Because your social domain contains disks of all three colors, you may promote a Warrior.
23
Neolexia (i.e. creating new concepts) is an action that frees one disk matching the color of a portal you
have in your brain. It can be from a daughter, Husband, Elder, or D or I Card. The freed disk goes to your
vocabulary.
a. Exogamy Bonus. If you are married to a foreign daughter, you may perform neolexia using one of
the colors already installed on a previous turn in the brain map of the player who owns the daughter.
If he is tribal, you have access to all three colors. 36
Example: Cro-Magnon has both Shaman portals (white & orange), and an immature daughter with a
white and orange disk on her. On phase 6, he performs neolexia and frees the orange disk. During the
next phase 6, he does the same with the white disk, which matures the daughter.
Tip: It is not necessary to convert to tribalism to win. Even to make the attempt invests a lot of vocabulary, and it’s possible you
will never get access to the right portals for conversion. The advantages of tribalism is that it enables VP in domestics and
thoughts could be reconstructed as images, the first imaginations and fantasies, such as imagining a figurine is your mother
speaking to you. This led to dramatic changes in attention to things and persons, indicated in the archeological record by the
appearance of the celebrated cave paintings and bone flutes. Thus both art and culture are explained as artifacts of
consciousness.
36 People normally can’t store memories in picture form, but most can “reconstruct” a crude mental image from sentences
stored in long term memory. However, 2016 it was discovered that many cannot perform this reconstruction, and yet live
normal lives. They enjoy novels more than movies, remember faces from describable features, and have some trouble finding
their cars in the parking places, see: http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20160524-this-man-had-no-idea-his-mind-is-blind-until-
last-week?
37 FOUR COMMANDMENTS OF MATING SYSTEM THEORY: “First, if females do better by choosing monogamous
and faithful males, monogamy will result - unless, second, men can coerce them. Third, if females do no worse by choosing
already-mated males, polygamy (harem-holding) will result - unless fourth already-mated females can prevent their males
from mating again, in which case monogamy will result. The surprising conclusion of game theory is therefore that males,
despite their active role in seduction, may be largely passive spectators at their marital fate.” Matt Ridley, 2003.
38 MARRIAGE “represents prolonged contact between species. This may initially be limited to exchange of goods. At some
point contact will intensify and exchange of technology ideas and behavior will occur. The pinnacle of interracial contact in
this game is exchange of people and interracial marriage and inevitably mating… represented by both the player of the
daughter and the Husband to use the special ability of the daughter. So courtship is just an abstract to represent interracial
contact. But interracial contact does not come easy. The difference between cultures represented in the game is much bigger
than what we see today in the world. They will not easily trust each other. Fighting will be inevitable. People who at some
point manage to live with the other species will find themselves ousted when distrust takes over the advantages of trade...I
think it is wonderful how a simple concept of marriage is used to represent something complicated as contact between
species.” Kyrill Melai, 2015.
39 TOTEMS is my preferred interpretation of the “artifacts” in this game. These are carved records that, like tombstones,
serve as admonitory reminders of deceased leaders. In an era before memories were stored in lingual format, such totems could
have served a mnemonic role. Phil Eklund, 2018.
24
inventions, and also solidifies your culture against chaos.
a. “Selfish Gene” Promiscuous Victory. Elders, Husbands, daughters, and vocabulary count as 1 VP
each. Each unassigned tribesman counts as 2 VP. Trophies and inventions count as 3 VP. The Alpha
and domestic animals count as 4 VP.
b.“Family Values” Pair Bonding Victory. Each unassigned tribesman, daughter (married or
unmarried), and vocabulary counts as 1 VP. Each Elder or trophy counts as 2 VP. The Alpha,
Husbands, and inventions count as 3 VP. Domestic animals count as 4 VP.
c. “Big Man” Harem Victory. Each unassigned tribesman, Elder, Husband, and vocabulary counts as 1
VP. Each daughter counts as 2 VP. The Alpha and inventions count as 3 VP. Trophies and domestic
animals count as 4 VP.
Example: At the end of the game, you are Pair Bonding. In your camp you have 9 unassigned
tribesmen, an empowered Alpha, 1 trophy, 2 daughters, and 12 vocabulary disks for 28 VP. You have 1
Wanderluster and 1 Husband in another player’s camp, for 4 VP. Your total score is 32 VP.
K. LEGACY VARIANTS
K1. COMBINATION NEANDERTHAL-GREENLAND GAME
You can start a Greenland game using the tribesmen leftover at the end of a Neanderthal game. If so, the
VPs you attained in Neanderthal are recorded and added to your final Greenland score to determine the
overall winner. Setup is per Part C (Greenland), except:
a. Starting Tribesmen And Disks. You are limited to the tribesmen (including unassigned Elders of
any maturity, and Husbands of any maturity) and all disks (not bound in immaturity) you had at the
end of Neanderthal. You may allocate your tribesmen either as unassigned, or (Tunit only) Colonists.
40 DIVISION OF LABOR. The Pleistocene hunter-gatherers were quite nomadic, but nevertheless used specific nodes in the
landscape as home bases for the sharing of food. These home bases allowed for a sexual division of labor, so ubiquitous among
modern hunter-gatherers. However, according to Stiner and Kuhn, the Neanderthal sites were exceptional in exhibiting no
signs of a division of labor based upon gender or age! There were no pounders or grinders, no bones of small mammals and
birds, and no food storage. Presumably men, women, and children all had equal tasks in hunting and gathering, and all made
their own tools.
41 A GENETIC BOTTLENECK is associated with the abrupt warming ending the last glacial maximum (see diagram p. 29 in
Bios:Megafauna 2). Only Homo sapiens was around at this time, in two genetic clades called M and N. The M clade went
extinct in Europe, while the N clade barely survived. The Younger Dryas ended in a heat wave so sudden, sea levels rose 20
meters in 500 years from glacial melt.
25
This may give you more or fewer than indicated in Part C.
b. Elders. Exchange your Neanderthal Placard for the Greenland one of the same color. Elders transfer
to the equivalent rank.
c. Domestic Animals. Exchange each of your Neanderthal domestic animals with a Greenland
domestic animal chosen at random from the D biomes. The Norse choose from the unused Norse
animals. The Sea Sami use the Sea Sami animal.
d. Inventions. Exchange each of your Neanderthal inventions with a Greenland invention chosen at
random from the I biomes.
e. Daughters. Exchange each two of your Neanderthal daughters with a Greenland daughter chosen at
random from your side.
f. Vocal. If you ended the Neanderthal game as a vocal, you are not allowed to start the Greenland
game with any Elders, and are not allowed promotion for the first turn.
g. Ice. For each ice-sheet in North or South Europe, start one of the biomes in North or South Greenland
respectively on its cold side.
26
Note: This game, greatly simplified and much shorter than the multi-player game, is intended to teach you the game mechanisms.
Playing time: 0.5 to 1.5 hours.
NEAN
DERTH
N NAL N N N
or or or or or
th th th th th
N N N N N
or or or or or
th th th th th
S S S S S
o o o o o
ut ut ut ut ut
h h h h h
S S S S S
o o o o o
HEIDELB SAPIE
ut ut ut ut ut
ERGENSI
L1. SETUP h NS
h h h h
S is per (C) except in C0.3 form a matrix of 4 rows with 5 facedown cards in each row. These
Setup
represent undiscovered biomes. Use north row cards for the top 2 rows and south row cards for the
bottom 2 rows.
a. Home Biome. Choose a species to play. Your starting position, called your home biome, is
shown above. Your home biome and the cards adjacent to your home biome are revealed. These
represent neighborhoods you are familiar with.
Note: In Variants L and M, adjacent means sharing a border, so diagonal cards are not adjacent.
b. Unassigned Tribesmen. In (C0.6) place your unassigned tribesmen on your home biome to start.
c. Difficulty. Choose how many alien artifacts you need to activate in order to succeed: from 2 for
an easy game, to 5 for a very hard game.
Important: Treat facedown cards as undiscovered; they are not an ice cap.
42 WEAPONS. Humans are one of the few creatures able to kill at range, and the hand-eye coordination required may have
been the reason for the evolution of our large brains. The first evidence of projectile weapons are the miraculously preserved
set of throwing javelins found in Schöningen, Germany. Dated to 300 kya, they were balanced for throwing with sharpened
wooden points. Evidence indicates that Homo heidelbergensis used them to hunt horses. During the cultural revolution, the
first atlatls (spear-throwers) were developed by H. sapiens. In contrast, Neanderthal seems to have exclusively used thrusting
spears. This was at great personal risk, given that analysis of Neanderthal bones of northwestern Europe has shown their
principle diet was mammoth and rhinoceros meat, and not the mid-sized prey that dominate the Neanderthal cave sites.
Presumably the bones from large prey were not dragged back to camp, giving a false impression of their primary hunting
targets.
27
L2. SEQUENCE OF PLAY
a. Events (L3) & Culture Auction (L4).
b. Hunter Movement, Assignment, Discovery (L5).
c. Roll For Hunt (L6).
d. Domestic Animals, per standard game (H).
e. Portal, Neolexia, & Elder Actions, per standard game (I).
L3. EVENTS
This is per (D) except the biomes effects are expanded to account for the presence of Hunters, artifacts,
and unexplored biomes. In general, Hunters follow a moving biome, while artifacts remain rooted to a
matrix position.
a. Ice Caps. When placing an ice cap during global cooling, rotate it 90 degrees (landscape
orientation) to distinguish it from an undiscovered card.
b. Biome movement. An undiscovered biome is treated in events just as a discovered one. Because
in these variants there are several rows, a card shifting downward can push a cascade of cards
downward. Similar with upward.
Example: During global warming, a discovered card moves north into an undiscovered card. Per D1, the
undiscovered card is replaced with the discovered one. Had the card moved into a discovered card it
would have pushed it upwards and this car in turn would have followed the movement rules. Had the
card moved into an ice cap, the moving card would be discarded and the ice cap would have melted,
rotated back 90 degrees, and become an undiscovered biome.
c. Determining Climax. Consult setup diagram (L1) to see which cards are in the north row, and
which are in the south. Consider only the climax of revealed cards, and ignore the event if no
cards are revealed. If you run out of one of the card types (north/south) draw from the other deck
instead.
d. Tribesmen on Shifting Cards. If a biome is shifted north or south, tribesmen follow the shifted
card. If a biome is replaced, tribesmen inhabit the new card. Unrevealed biomes are revealed at
the end of movement (L5b). Do not check for this or reveal any cards during the event phase due
to shifting, wait until the end of movement. (This means that shifting cards can not open up new
biomes for hunt during the same turm)
e. Tribesmen on Removed Biomes. Move the tribesmen to any biome that is adjacent (L1a) and
revealed.
f. Artifacts on Shifting Cards. Unlike tribesmen, artifacts (L6a) are locked to the grid and never
move as cards shift. If artifacts are frozen in ice, they become inaccessible until the biome thaws
again.
g. Chaos. All Hunters on the map count as unassigned tribesmen for the purpose of determining
chaos.
h. Wanderlust. This kills one Hunter.
28
d. Singing Woman. You can use any color disk when paying for a daughter.
L7. VICTORY
Win if you trigger the artifacts per L6b before the game ends per (J). You can score per (J) to see how
well you succeeded.
43 INVENTION indicates a tool or technology created because it was envisioned in the “mind’s eye” before it was made, as
opposed to accidental tinkering or learning. The “mind’s eye” is possible only in a people fully equipped with a syntactic
language and an internal monologue, as I argue in the essay on words at the end of the rules. I believe that very ancient tools,
such as handaxes, are not inventions or technologies because they were developed before the advent of words as tools of
cognition. Although handaxes require an extraordinary amount of intelligence and knapping skills to manufacture, the
motivation to do so comes not from an envisioned product, but by natural selection and/or female preference. The first
invention may have been the hafting of a stone point onto a wooden shaft. Evidence from a Syrian Neanderthal site suggests
that the point was glued to the shaft using fire-softened bitumen, rather than lashed on. Other Neanderthal sites seem to have
used pitch made from birch bark. The mere fact that variations in technique are possible suggests that Neanderthal had some
verbal cognitive software installed very early, perhaps 300 kya. And yet the remarkable non-inventiveness thereafter argues
that hafting was an accidental gradual development, perhaps the result of a long association of Neanderthal glue use for various
purposes.
29
M. 3-PLAYER CO-OP VARIANT “THE BRINK” (by Jon Manker)
Genomic data collected and analyzed by the ADNABIOARC project indicates a genetic bottleneck close
to extinction in Europe before 14,500 years ago.44 Instead of tribes with 500 members, the tribes were
down to 20-30 individuals, with limited genetic diversity between tribes. In this variant, the players each
play a small nomadic tribe during this demographic bottleneck. Their goal is not only survival, but to
maintain a healthy genetic and cultural interchange of cooperation.
a. Scale. Each hunter represents one family unit, and each turn is 3 years. Total game is 1
generation.
b. Setup. Per L1.
M2. AUCTION
The players decide together who will buy the daughter. The recipient must pay disks equal to the amount
of daughters he has already plus one. The disks paid are restricted to colors of the bid media (D7).
a. Abilities. Some daughters have new abilities, see L4.
M4. VICTORY
By the end of the game (J), each player must have achieved the following:
a. Tribal. Have become tribal with at least 1 Elder and 1 Alpha.
b. Assimilation. Have at least 2 mature Husbands, one assimilated (M3b) with each other player.
44 HUMAN-NEANDERTHAL INTERACTION. A single tooth and a few bone fragments found in a cave in Bulgaria prove
that modern humans reached Europe more than 45,000 years ago (45 kya). “Some believe the Neanderthals invented by
themselves what we call the Upper Paleolithic, while others like me claimed it was the result of the arrival of modern humans.
You have modern humans arriving between 47 and 45 kya in Eastern Europe and, bingo, at 44 kya the Neanderthals start to
do things they never did before.” But by 39 kya, the Neanderthals were all but gone. —Jean-Jacques Hublin, Max Planck
Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, 2020.
30
N. NEANDERTHAL SCENARIO MODULE (by Jon Manker)
These rules allow you construct your own adventures, including asymmetrical situations that benefit or
disadvantage specific cultures. This can be used as a handicap system if you have large differences in
knowledge between players.
Setup (Events) Sort the event cards into 3 piles: one for global warming events, one for global
cooling events and one for the other events. Shuffle them all facedown and draw
random cards to build an event pile from bottom up with:
★ 1 global warming card
★ 3 global cooling cards
★ 2 global warming cards
★ 3 global cooling cards
★ 1 global warming card
Special Rules ★ D and I cards need 1 more dice in order to be taken to your hand.
★ To go tribal you need 7 disks in your brain. The 7th disc may be placed on
any portal.
★ If a Würm is drawn, take a card from the other event pile.
Setup (event) Shuffle all 21 daughter cards into the event pile.
Special Rules ★ All 5 Würm events (D2) will appear, so after the 21 daughters have been
revealed, shuffle all discarded daughter cards again and draw 5 of them to
form a new event deck. If any of these 5 have a Würm, take cards from the
unused ones as normal.
★ After the shuffle (previous bullet) you have entered more modern times.
From here on D and I cards require 1 less dice to take domestication and
invention cards into to your hand. (This is in addition to the paintress ability
if you have access to that).
Win conditions As normal except domesticated animals are worth 5 VP each regardless of your
sexuality.
31
N3. MENTAL STRATEGY FOR YOUR FIRST TURNS
You start with one portal in your brain, and the color of this portal is crucial because it enables neolexia
(I2), the only way to mature your daughters, Elders, and Alphas. Immature units are largely useless.
a. First Daughter. You will need daughters to gain more portals. Bid on daughters that give you as
many colors of portals as possible (I1). But if you bid on any daughter with any disk color other
than the color of the portal in your brain, you can’t mature her with neolexia and must use big
game hunting (next bullet). If this means an opponent nabs a useful daughter, try to court her as
soon as she matures (E3).
b. Big Game Hunting. Successful hunting of large animals allows you to mature black and/or white
disks (G3). But this is chancy unless you have many hunters and can handle the predators, so in
the early game don’t rely on this.
c. Fire-Starter. An early goal is to mature your Fire-Starter, or reinstate him if he dies, and for this
you will need a black portal. If you do not start with a black portal, get a daughter that gives you
one.
d. First Alpha. Once you have 3 colors of portals, a goal is to acquire an Alpha. The brain domain
that holds the 3 colors determines what sort of Alpha this is (E5).
e. Flip To Tribal. Once you get 5 colors of portals, it is time to switch from vocal to tribal (I1d).
32
TEXT ON BACK OF BOX:
The first words. The first art. The first bad jokes.
It’s 43,000 BC in Ice Age Europe. You are one of three species: Archaic, Neanderthal, or Cro-Magnon.
Assign your males to hunt Pleistocene megafauna while avoiding predators. Assign women to gather or
teach children new words. Specialize Elders for fire, inventions, or animal domestications. Choose
between promiscuous, harems, or pair bonding mating systems. You may merge this game into a game
of Greenland.
First Edition Cover art by Phil Eklund (foreground) and Mauricio Antón (background). A Neanderthal
father teaches his mulatto son to hunt. Genetic studies indicate that Neanderthals interbred with modern
humans freshly arrived from Africa 45 kya. This hybridization somehow sparked the invention of art
and culture in both species. Waves of innovation obsoleted tools used without change for 200,000 years
such as the handaxes and Levallois thrusting spears shown.
Are you a visual person, or a phonetic one? Do you think better in images or words? Most would insist the former.
But most are wrong.
A MODERN HUNTER-GATHERER. Introspect on one of your thoughts. Pick a simple one, perhaps “I should
go to the market today”. A string of 7 words, with grammar and syntax. For phonetic person, this is a few bytes in
temporary memory, enabling a life-sustaining decision within a fraction of a second. How would a visual person
express this thought and come to a decision without words? Perhaps with a video of herself walking to the market.
This would take megabytes of memory and a minute of time.
THE PRONOUN PROBLEM. But this is only the beginning of difficulties for the visual person. A simple video
of a walking person in no way expresses the pronoun “I” as an analog for oneself. Animals do not recognize or
identify with pictures or movies made of themselves. The very concept of a pronoun can’t be expressed in images,
perhaps the reason why primitive tongues, for instance in the pre-Columbian New World, do not have the pronoun
concept.
UNIT FORMATION. Other words in our sample thought that cannot be translated into pictures include the modal
verb “should”, the preposition “to”, and the adverb “today”. Yet all are vital for the proper decision-making
enactment of this thought. The verb “go” can be expressed in a movie, but only in an excessively concrete-bound
fashion. For instance, a sequence showing a walking person excludes the possibility of alternatives such as a bike
or car. But for a phonetic person, the verb “go” expresses the action without specifying the means. This “unit-
formation” is very much like algebra, where “X” is a unit of any unspecified value. Unit economy enables human
cognition to reduce a vast amount of sense information to a minimal number of units, and the unit becomes the
link between mathematics and reality.
33
MEASUREMENT. A standard named as a word automatically becomes a unit appropriate for the first
measurements of time or distance beyond the perceptual level. For instance, “X” days, or “X” feet. The first
archeological evidence for measurements are tally sticks dating to more than 20,000 years ago (20 kya).
WORDS VERSUS CONCRETES. This “algebraic” flexibility of a word encapsulates the essence of something,
while leaving unnecessary concretes out. A photo isn’t and can’t. Further, a word has enormous flexibility in
input/output. It can be spoken, thought, gestured (as in sign language), written, grammatically combined with
other words, or stored with very little memory. A photo can’t. Words are altered by syntax and grammatical
endings. A photo can’t, other than the temporal sequence in which a series of photos are viewed. As Aristotle
proved in the Organon, words can be logically combined into propositions, arguments, premises, and conclusions.
Finally, a word can be metaphoric, thus opening up mental “portals” and integrating elements through induction.
A photo can’t.
For instance, the phonetic person uses the noun “market” as a placeholder for any market, leaving the decision for
which market for a later thought. But the concrete-bound visual person must picture a specific market. Imagine
what this means if she actually tried to come to a decision without using any words. She would have to run a
video in her head of every possible means of transport going to each possible destination. If there are three ways
to travel, and three possible destinations, she would have to watch nine films, recall the details of each one, and
then choose among them. Making all the decisions at the same time. Add just a few more variables, and the
human head would run out of memory space (video is a memory hog). But a phonetic person would think: “I
should go to the market today. Maybe that new one I haven’t tried yet. But I’ll take the car, since the forecast is
for snow.” This leads to three reasoned decisions, made one after the other, with almost unlimited syntactic
variability! This is because every word is an economy of thought worth a thousand pictures.
Aristotle realized that words for qualities or essences rather than concretes, such as “market” and “go”, were the
common ground between the objective and subjective worlds. Between reality and our metaphors for reality. In
this he disagreed with his teacher Plato, who maintained that qualities were in a higher plane of reality, of which
we only experience the shadows. Today neo-Platonism is the dominant philosophy, although there are still a few
Aristotelians such as myself.
SELF-COMMUNICATION. Notice that the primary use of words is communicating with yourself, not with
others! The key is that a phonetic person is capable of unit-formation, defining “unit” as “a concrete regarded as a
separate member of a group of multiple similar members.” For instance, various specific markets are units
subsumed under the concept “market.” The ability to regard entities as units is distinctive to modern lingual
humans. This is why animals and pre-lingual babies are unable to count beyond the number of concrete objects
they can subitize (i.e metaphysically perceive, up to about seven objects).
THE VERB PROBLEM. Koko and Kanzi, the famed primates able to communicate using American Sign
Language, are quite adept with adjectives and nouns, but seem unable to formulate verbs or sentences. What is the
problem with verbs? Because every action needs an actor, a verb cannot be pictorially visualized without a noun.
And this bonds the verb to a specific actor: “I go to the market”. But unlike a picture, the word “go” divorces the
action from the actor, as well as from specific means of going. Koko and Kanzi seem to be able to use gestural
words with others, but not as a unit of thought.
VERBAL HALLUCINATIONS. 99% of your thoughts are verbal hallucinations. You imagine hearing the spoken
word rather than seeing the written word. Try counting in your head from, say, 10 to 20. Introspect. You mentally
heard the words “ten”, “eleven”, “twelve”, etc. in your preferred language. Now try again, appending images of
the Arabic numbers “10”, “11”, “12”, etc. to the spoken words. This slows down your counting, but with practice
it can be done. Now try imaging the “10”, “11”, “12”, etc. without hearing the words. You will find it impossible.
Purely notational icons such as Arabic numerals, punctuation marks, arrows, stop signs, etc. are useful only in
34
their written form. Only icons you can “hear” can be retrieved and processed as verbal hallucinations, which is
why you can speak before you can read.
Much of this “aha” cognition takes place below our verbal stream of consciousness, including judgments,
reasoning, induction, pattern recognition, and learning. Oceans of information are automatically processed this
way using ancient pathways, as revealed in the Marbe experiments at the Würzburg school. I do not call these
cognitions “subconscious”, reserving this term for the daily routines we consciously program ourselves to perform
automatically.
THE BIG USELESS BRAIN MYSTERY. The human and Neanderthal brains reached their modern size 200 kya,
yet the archeological record shows no advances in tools or behavior until 45 kya. What were they doing in all that
time with their huge brains? Perhaps building up a social vocabulary, used for courtship, dominance, and status
games. Perhaps to verbally express who dominates who, and who belongs to who. These vocalisms, like all
animal communication such as warning cries, birdsong, and snarls, are expressions of behavior, but play no
internal role on how behavior is decided. But one day, the first word was uttered, defining “word” as a
vocalization that can be both spoken and used as a cognitive unit.
THE FIRST WORD. What was this first word? Perhaps someone’s name! Names associated with rank or class
may have been used for millennia, and imitated through the generations. But on one fertile day around 45 kya,
someone used a verbal hallucination of a name as a cognitive placeholder, perhaps to untangle a social problem.
This was the first word, and the first verbal thought, as well as the most momentous invention in human
experience. She was not conscious of her thought, as consciousness was still thousands of years in the future. But
sharing spoken and mental concepts was an effective means to mentally manipulate the named person. And the
spread of words from the social domain to the brain domains associated with technical and natural history
knowledge allowed explosive progress in tools and food storage.
Many young birds and mammals use an “imprinting” algorithm to recognize their mother and others of their
species. This mechanism, quite distinct from associative learning, occurs in the brief period after the beginning of
locomotion and before the onset of fear. It’s very speculative, but perhaps the communicative sound of the word
“mama” in a prehistoric family became imprinted on a child, who was able to use this sound in her thoughts as an
icon for her mother. If so, the very first word may have been the first word of most children: “mama”.
VERBAL MEMORIES. The use of words allowed human memories to be stored in the new verbal format. The
few exceptions seem to be sensations such as tastes, smells, and touch. But what about remembered and imagined
images anyone can form in one’s head? Today’s brain has the remarkable ability to retrieve strings of words out
of storage, and use them to create a manipulatable image in a special mindspace, sometimes called the tabula rasa
(blank slate). By making these verbally-formed images dance in this mindspace, we can use narratization to
compare alternatives and come to a decision.
If a person is asked to give details on a particularly vivid memory, it becomes quickly clear he is not examining a
mental photograph accurately retrieved pixel by pixel. A simple question: “What is the shape of the frame of your
35
memory?” turns out to have no answer. The image has no frame, no boundary, exactly as if its elements were
conjured up from words rather than a certain number of rows of pixels. If the memory is a dynamic one, and the
person is asked at what point does the film stop and replay, again there is no basis for an answer. Nor can the
person give a consistent response to the spatial relationship between remembered elements. Every policeman
knows that eyewitness accounts are valid only for certain notable elements. As if they were reconstructing the
visual crime scene from a description in a book. The gaps are filled logically, using general data the brain has
stored about the category. “Why of course the perp had five fingers on his hand officer, every hand has five
fingers.” If memory was like a surveillance tape, one could in theory run the tape backwards to a certain day when
one was looking out a window, stop the film, then write down the license number of a car going by. But the verbal
data compression of memory is far more parsimonious than that.
Memories stored as sentences explain why you can’t recall scenes from infancy, before you had the vocabulary to
reconstruct images. Infants are able to learn, just as a flatworm in a T-maze can learn. But learning to turn left in a
T-maze is distinct from remembering to “straight-left-straight”, a process that requires mastering the verbal
concepts of “straight” and “right” and “left”.45
“Memory artist” savants, such as Franco Magnani and Stephen Wiltshire, have the remarkable capacity to paint
detailed scenes from childhood memories, or from seeing a landscape just once. Comparing their work to
photographs is stunning. But the distortions are revealing: depicting scenes from a perspective the painter could
not have attained, combining elements from different points of view, shifting spatial relationships, exaggerating
some features, and introducing anachronisms. Exactly the distortions you would expect if the image was
constructed from a rich set of verbal instructions. This is not “photographic memory”.
Are memories verbal or visual? A simple experiment anyone can perform gets to the truth of the matter. Go to
your library, and open any book to a random page. Look at it for a few seconds, enough to get a mental image.
Now try to reconstruct the page from memory. If the page were stored as a picture, you should have a blurred
photograph in your mind’s eye. Maybe a few letters would be recognizable, and you should be able to count the
lines of text, even if too blurry to read. And you should be able to see on this photo which line of text each of the
letters you can recognize are located. Of course, a real remembered reconstruction is vastly different. A few
snippets of phrases are remembered. But their position on the page is unknown. This is because the memory is
stored verbally.
Incidentally, in this experiment, for 999 times out of 1000, the random page you open will contain far more
information in verbal format than in picture format. This is because all book writers know that it is far easier to
express any significant idea with words than pictures, and each word is worth a thousand pictures. And because
the printed word resonates with the hallucinated spoken words we all think with, it’s unlikely the humble book
will ever be supplanted by audio-visual gizmos.
A variation of this experiment was performed in 2013 at the Kyoto University’s Primate Research Center. The
Arabic numbers 1 to 9 arrayed in a random pattern were flashed for less than one second on a monitor.
Chimpanzees performed far better than humans in pointing to where the numerals had been on the screen in the
45 ANIMAL DOMESTICATIONS did not occur until the neolithic, with the dog as the first to be tamed by 15 kya
according to genetic and archeological evidence. If so, their inclusion in the game is rather anachronistic. However, 36 kya
dogs, with DNA more closely allied with modern domestics than wolves, have been discovered in Belgium and Russia.
Conceivably, they might have taken advantage of carcasses left on site by early hunters, assisted in the capture of prey, or
provided defense from large competing predators at kills. Domestication of megafauna was accomplished soon after the
weather turned warm in the Holocene, but in the frigid Pleistocene it was hampered by the lack of hay technology to keep the
animals alive over the winter. Had the weather turned warmer earlier, it’s possible domestications could have occurred as
depicted in this game. However, domestic animals would have been utilized for their meat and hides. The “secondary product
revolution”, using domestic animals for work or milk, was not until the late neolithic.
36
correct numerical sequence. This is strong evidence that the chimp short term memory is far more visual than
human memory. See the video here http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/video-chimpanzees-have-faster-
working-memory-than-humans-according-to-study-8496034.html
PERCEPTS. It is unknown how animals and pre-lingual humans process percepts, which is the name for concepts
formed by direct perception, without the use of words or unit-formation. A baboon, for instance, might see only
the tail of a lion, prompting an integration plunking the percept “lion” into its flight or fight algorithm. There is
evidence that percepts are formed in the “processing” right side of the animal brain, and enacted in the
“executive” left half. Communication between the halves encrypts these percepts in a proto-word format, but is
unable to categorize them into units. But the new verbal format surmounted this limitation.
COGNITIVE FLUIDITY. For almost their entire history, neither Neanderthals or modern humans showed any
trace of what we would call “culture”, such as art or religion. According to Leda Cosmides and John Tooby, this
was because the ancient human brain was compartmentalized into social, technical, and natural history domains.
Information from one domain seemed unable to be utilized in other domains. For instance, a human adept with
knapping was puzzlingly unwilling to whittle antler or bone, perhaps because stone was mentally processed in the
technology domain, while bones were processed in the “natural history” domain. Cognitive fluidity in self-
communication was achieved only when the new verbal format surmounted this software incompatibility.
As words from one domain got entrained in the context of another, the crosstalk sparked the “cultural revolution”
of 40 kya, when the first carved bone and antlers points, cave paintings, figurines, flutes, burials, and other
cultural artifacts appear. By mixing domains, humans for the first time could express multicomponent tools made
from materials other than sticks and stones (the first technology), elders able to be referred to after they died (the
first proper names and grave goods), female statues acting as the authority for actions (the first idols), and
anthropomorphic animals that could walk and talk (the first jokes).
THE CRUCIAL PRONOUN. The discovery that the famous cave paintings had been continually retouched for
thousands of years suggests they were used as blackboards, perhaps to reinforce the neural pathways used in
“blank slate” formation, visually and tactilely reinforcing the neural pathways used to form pictures from words
and to regard animals as units. This didactic purpose explains why the paintings were so eerily similar throughout
the inhabited world. The handprint stencils found on so many may have been the first attempts to articulate the
pronoun “I”, a crucial concept on the road to consciousness.
THE PORTAL THEORY OF JOKES. In the animal kingdom, humans are the only ones to laugh and tell jokes.
What’s so funny? What is a joke, and what possible survival value can come from privately laughing at it? A joke
is an incongruity of language, such that a word created for one context has an unexpected connotation when used
in a different context. Laughter is an audible sign that one recognizes this scope creep of the concept, bridging two
areas as a form of inductive logic. This is simulated in the game by placing an inductive portal.
ART VS. DARWIN. I remember a restless morning in Colorado being bothered by the explanation and
categorization of the Anasazi artifacts we had uncovered the previous day. Labeling them objects of worship or
art, or means to attain the afterlife or to ward off evil spirits seemed facile, given that all irrational beliefs have no
survival value by definition and that no other animal exhibited behavior so contrary to its own survival and that of
its descendants.
CAUSES OF CULTURE. Science is an affirmation of the law of causality, the idea that everything has a natural
cause. (By "natural" I mean anything that can be understood by the study of the Laws that govern its properties
37
and behavior.) What bothered me was that the archeologists were faced with a novel phenomena unprecedented in
the animal kingdom, yet seemed uninterested in including its cause in its definition. Causes are particularly
important for a game-maker, who must either provide a rule, or else tell the players to roll the dice. Nothing can
be left undefined or acausal.
MODERN FANTASIES. But it is not just archeologists. If you ask someone why they decorate their homes or
offices, listen to music on the way to work, tell jokes, or daydream about sex or love, they look at you strangely.
Too immersed in something to realize how bizarre it is. If we can't explain our own motivations, how much more
difficult is it to describe its origins in pre-literate peoples?
DECISION-MAKING. Animals make decisions based upon mental states called emotions, set by internal and
external cues. My thesis is that culture is an alternative authorisation for decisions that superseded (to some
extent) the emotional ones. Culture is stored in memory in the new-fangled lingual format unique to humans,
although it is intertwined with little understood ancient formats. Like remembering "earworm" jingles, both the
words and the artistic music/beat are important. This would ignite both free will and consciousness, previously
defined as decision-making modes based upon the software of language.
CULTURE SCALE. The two types of software associated with the evolution of culture makes it possible to define
one's conscious identity as a measure of art versus ideology. This allows a game-maker to set a scale that can
distinguish the culture of society A from society B. In Greenland, the now extinct Tunit left behind far more art
than the Thule or Norse, such as intricate ivory carvings. Perhaps they used these as portable tactile icons to help
them remember important concepts, lacking the words to put these concepts into thought. Perhaps their limited
language, now lost, is related to their pacifism. The Viking Greenlanders, a literate culture with a sophisticated
lexicon, left a more enduring legacy with their sagas and stone churches.
MODERN CULTURES. Modern cultures are defined by ideology, the power of ideas and concepts to identify the
way the universe works. Humans and their moralities are defined by their specific nature, a nature defined by the
origins and causes of consciousness This was discovered during the Enlightenment, and cemented by Darwin's
discovery that humans are animals. Ideology is at the root of the famed Viking raiding mentality and for their
lesser appreciated mercantile economy. It is even more true for the Nazis, who unambiguously proclaimed what
they stood for and then walked the talk. Nobody can accuse the Nazis of half-heartedly applying their statist
philosophy.
FUNDAMENTALS. In order to learn from history, or to make a game about history, one must distill ideas and
events to their fundamentals. I am puzzled by those who insist I use politically correct terms, such as "European"
instead of "Viking" or "German" instead of "Nazi". Using euphemisms obscures the essential differences between
right and wrong, civilization and savagery. For understanding as in gaming, clear definitions are essential.
D1.0 Added Troubadour option. Changes in green font are errata to published first edition.
C1.2 Graphics and icon overhaul by Karim, all cards and Placards. Small changes to Negotiations. May now court your own
married daughters. Published as first edition.
C1.1 Added sultan’s exception (E4), and made jealous husbands into War Parties. The minimum bid is one disk at all times.
38
E3 and G1 changed to allow contests of married daughters, and also allow the winners of such contests to begin mature.
Removed “rape” as a game term. Cylinder instead of figurine,
C1.0 Wanderlust revised to drop the limbo concept. Removed grooming and bone marrow scavenging from the game.
Revised sexuality cards to remove the Vocal Limits, MPI rating, and Fecundity rating, and to make promiscuous a
grazing species. The two types of “I” cards merged into one “I” card. Revised the special ability of most every daughter.
Removed ability to avoid predator attacks by assigning one Hunter to it per G4. Changed solitaire game per juan’s
recommendations. Change player order, the second star now indicates the color of the second player. In D6, Wanderlust
rewritten so as only one per eye icon is lost, and it retains player color even in service in foreign tableaus. You are safe
from chaos if the number of Hunters is less than or equal to your vocabulary (B3). Victory Points: Hunter Cubes: 1
(PB), 1 (HH), 2 (P), Alpha: 2 (PB), 1 (HH), 1 (P), husbands: 3 (PB), 1 (HH), 1 (P), daughters: 1 (PB), 2 (HH), 1 (P),
trophies 2 (PB), 4 (HH), 3 (P), D cards: 4 (all sexualities), inventions: 3 (all sexualities), disks: 1 (all sexualities). SOP
changed to add gathering to the end of Phase 3, and to immediately discarding down to hand size rather than at end
of Phase 6. 12 biomes modified to add “Gathering”. You now need two Hunters to support each dependant during
blizzards. Added courtship, rapes, homosexuality, and eusocial “human hive”. Conversion to Tribal occurs with 5
instead of 6 portals in the 3-player game. The Fire Starter given the ability to cost-free promote elders, and the Chief
given the ability for cost-free elder actions.
B1.3 Tribal players disallowed from participating in the culture auction! Exception: Tribal players with harem-holding
sexuality can bid, but their bid counts half (rounding up). If promiscuous, Trophies, domestic animals, and inventions
count as 2 VP. Husbands, elders, daughters, and disks are worthless. Changed big game and predator biome cards to
make black disks less preconditional and more accessible.
B1.2 Changes: A. The three Vocal Alphas played as elders with 3 preconditional portals. B. Asymmetry in Brain, started with
one portal (red = Cro-Magnon, black = Neanderthal, white = Archaic) C. Removed cards from rows leave a gap, and
Row cards are NOT shifted (G1). D. Require 6 Portals to go tribal. (i.e. 2 disks on each portal). Require 3 portals (1 of
each color) to gain an alpha ability. E. Added Vocal Actions to Phase 6, so that Neolexia and Portal actions occur each
turn. This means elimination of Speech Balloon Event. F. Reduced elder death frequency. G. Portals do not count
towards preconditions. H. Increase MPI in all sexualities one step. J.Alpha is not a starting piece, and can be brought in
only after its corresponding alpha is installed. K. Promiscuous are not allowed to place husbands, but may attack foreign
husbands in their tableau. M. If you are harem-holding, you need only 5 portals instead of all to convert to tribalism. N.
Neolexia changed to an optional Phase 6 action that does not need a daughter. P. All daughters now have a Portal
Action.
B1.1 In D7, per a suggestion of Chuck Parrot, half of the wanderlust Hunters of all players wander to other players.
Previously it was only the player with the most lost Hunters whose Hunters wandered to other tribes. As a small rule
change, I am making the Vengeful husband rule in F2 effective only for Harem and Pair bonding Sexualities. Card
changes: Flint mines changed, conjugal woman replaced by flutist, Joking woman and Scheherazade have additional
text for what happens if they are married, the front side of brain maps corrected the flip to Tribal conditions from Phase
6 to Phase 1. New B1.1 Vassal created by Stefano.
B1.0 Removed from game Starting Portals, Flint Rule, Survivalist Game, Sexual Arena Auction, Travois, Travel Costs,
Snowflake Icon, Upkeep, Exchanging disks for value, homeland. Monogamy re-instituted.
Married daughters are always faceup.
Wanderlust Event added.
Vocal players can now attack.
Both Portals and Neolexia changed to be an event. Neolexia changed to allow a disk from any domain. SOP changed to
remove Portals from Phase 6, add gathering to Phase 5.
Hand Limit is now # of elders. SOP changed to add discarding down to hand size at end of Phase 6.
Added MPI (Male Parental Investment) to the game in D5.
Cards displaced during global cooling or warming now automatically knock-out the cards they displace to.
Vocal Limits changed.
Players start with two of each disk.
If you are promiscuous, then you count your unmarried daughters as unassigned tribesmen during chaos.
Hand size = # of elders.
39
A1.0 1. Populations are running too low. Solution 1: I am going to try adding an "expend 1 energy, gain 2 Babies" function to
the Fire Starter. Solution 2: Add one more Baby to most of the hunting successes. Solution 3: Added 2 more small
game, birds. Solution 4: Reduce chaos?
2. Acquisition of women avalanches to "harem" style victories, with the number of women far outnumbering the
Hunters.
The basic problem is that women grant you the vocabulary to acquire more women.
Solution 1: Change the snowflake icon into a dependents icon, whereupon you pay disks if you have more dependents
than Hunters + husbands. (Dependents are elders, women, and domestic animals). Solution 2: Have population count
double at game end if you have at least as many Hunters + husbands as dependents.
3. The game is a bit too short. The polytheism is barely getting started at games end.
Solution: Not sure if should start with 2 more events, or add one more Würm glacials.
4. Polytheism is too big of a disadvantage at first, because it scrubs the disk victory condition. Solution: Allow
Polytheism to use either disks or trophies as victory, whichever greater.
5. Problems with order of play in Phase 6. Solution: Add "Portal" action right after Neolexia and before Elder Actions.
6. Predators are too flexible, not allowing strategies for avoiding them. Solution: Change rules so predators attack the
closest only, or the first player if more than one equally close. Solution 2: Special rule that predators can't cross glaciers.
7. Asymmetrical starting, each species gets 1 portal to start,
8. Added human sexuality event, and public deck to auction. The idea is to have players have more interesting decisions
with daughter assignment, a bit like the demography in the Origins Game. Sexuality auction and Procreation added to
the Sexuality Event.
9. The Fire Starter seems weak. I have not done anything about this however.
10. Increased trophy points by 25%.
40