TRB1221 Ezine Nov Dec 2021 Web
TRB1221 Ezine Nov Dec 2021 Web
TRB1221 Ezine Nov Dec 2021 Web
Compressor Trends
IN Oil & Gas
FEATURES
[email protected]
[email protected]
24 34 36
DEPARTMENTS
COLUMNS
TURBO SPEAK
DOUBLE YOUR
6 ARE COMPRESSORS EXPOSURE WITH
THE REAL HYDROGEN AN ENHANCED
MARKET? LISTING
Hydrogen-fired gas turbines may well be
the future, but the market is still in its
8 very early stages. For now, a bigger
opportunity is staring the industry in
the face - hydrogen compression.
8 INDUSTRY NEWS
HANDBOOK 2022 • VOL. 62 NO. 6
Drew Robb
ARE COMPRESSORS
THE REAL HYDROGEN
MARKET?
A
lot has been said of late about enabling gas VARIED ISSUE
turbines to be able to operate on hydrogen. Beyond the cover story and the Elliott grand
All of the OEMs are going to great lengths opening, we have a varied issue in store for you.
to discuss their hydrogen capabilities, their There are articles on: sensors in challenging hot
roadmaps to 100% hydrogen fuel, and how they gas path and turbine blade locations; a case study
are surmounting the various challenges – particu- about a gas compression plant that needed to
larly surrounding combustion. It is possible that this expand its capacity but wanted to avoid adding
may one day represent the future of the gas turbine. another compressor; a dry gas seals mainte-
But the market is in its very early stage. And in nance tip; a show report on a recent Siemens
any case, there isn’t the availability of hydrogen or
the pipeline infrastructure to feed gas turbines. It
may not be until the end of this decade or into the Turbomachinery OEMs are confident they can
next before the picture materially changes.
A bigger opportunity, however, is staring the provide whatever equipment is needed to serve
industry in the face – hydrogen compression. the hydrogen compression market.
Centrifugal compressors are already well estab-
lished in the hydrogen marketplace. Some OEMs
have been providing compressors for hydrogen Energy summit; a description of how to safely
service for many decades. In other words, it is a conduct chemical cleaning of lube oil and hydrau-
mature marketplace that can easily evolve to take lic systems; an article on the controls needed for a
in additional duties such as supporting hydrogen power recovery train; a story on applying stone-
electrolysis, liquifying hydrogen for transportation, wall control to a turboexpander; and a vendor
as well as in various of aspects of a low-carbon showcase on Solar Turbines. Meanwhile, our col-
future such as carbon capture, utilization, and stor- umnists delve into: Technical challenges of CO2
age (CCUS). It certainly looks like the market for compression; and a case study about how to deal
hydrogen compression is going to get bigger fast. with issues surrounding a centrifugal compressor
Our cover story, Compressor Trends in Oil & with side stream. Plenty for everyone.
Gas, offers input from all large turbomachinery On the good news front, we are looking for-
OEMs. Almost all of them are talking up hydro- ward to seeing you all at two upcoming shows.
gen compression. They are confident that they The Turbomachinery Symposium in December
can provide whatever equipment is needed to in Houston, and the PowerGen International
serve this space. In many cases, the equipment is show in Dallas. Come by the booth, say hello, and
already available. It can easily be customized for pick up your copies of our annual
specific areas of the hydrogen ecosystem – wheth- Turbomachinery Handbook as well as our
er pipeline compression, liquefaction, carbon stor- November/December issue. ■
age, and more.
As a case in point, we recently attended the
grand opening of a new Elliott Cryogenic testing
facility. A tour of the new plant, in tandem with
their extensive existing facilities, demonstrates that
they are prepared for whatever the hydrogen
DREW ROBB
economy or the carbon-reduction trend throws at Editor-in-Chief
them. You can read about the new facility inside.
FIVE-AXIS
ASSOCIATE EDITOR
[email protected]
Joseph McDonald
[email protected] GERMANY, AUSTRIA, SWITZERLAND
SVEN ANACKER
MACHINING
SENIOR DIRECTOR—DIGITAL MEDIA
Michael Kushner, 732-346-3028 InterMediaPartners GmbH
[email protected] Beyeroehde 14
Wuppertal, D-42389, Germany
EXECUTIVE CORRESPONDENTS Tel: 49-202-271-690 Fax: 49-202-271-6920 AND
ADDITIVE
Klaus Brun, Amin Almasi [email protected]
CONTRIBUTING EDITOR UK, BENELUX, SCANDINAVIA, ITALY, FRANCE
Mark Axford FERRUCCIO SILVERA
CREATIVE DIRECTOR—PUBLISHING
Melissa Feinen
Viale Monza 24
20127 Milano, Italy
MANUFACTURING
Tel: 39-022846716 Fax: 39-022893849
ART DIRECTOR [email protected]
Wassana Techadilok PRAEWEST.COM
JAPAN
MJH Life Sciences YOSHINORI IKEDA
Pacific Business, Inc.
PRESIDENT AND CEO Kayabacho 2-chome Bldg., 2-4-5, Nihonbashi Kayabacho
Chuo-ku, Tokyo 103-0025, Japan
Mike Hennessy Jr
Tel: 81-3-3661-6138 Fax: 81-3-3661-6139
VICE CHAIRMAN [email protected] PRÄWEST_2003_Anzeige 57x120_75-Years_RZ.indd 1 18.03.20 11:41
Jack Lepping
INDIA, MIDDLE EAST
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER FAREDOON KUKA
Neil Glasser, CPA/CFE RMA media
EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT, GLOBAL MEDICAL Twin Arcade, C-308
AFFAIRS AND CORPORATE DEVELOPMENT Military Road, Marol Defining the Standard for
Joe Petroziello Andheri (E), Mumbai-400059, India
Tel: 91-22-6570-3081/82 Fax: 91-22-2925-3735
Electric Discharge protection
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, CONTENT [email protected] for Five Decades
Silas Inman
KOREA, SOUTHEAST ASIA
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, OPERATIONS LEITHEN FRANCIS
Michael Ball Francis and Low (Pte) Ltd.
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, INDUSTRY SCIENCE 77 High Street, #08-01 High Street Plaza
Michael Tessalone Singapore 179443
Tel: 65-6337-0818
VICE PRESIDENT, HUMAN RESOURCES & [email protected]
ADMINISTRATION
Shari Lundenberg
VICE PRESIDENT, MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
Chris Hennessy
EXECUTIVE CREATIVE DIRECTOR, CREATIVE SERVICES
Jeff Brown
Better
BETTERPerforming
PERFORMINGMachinery In Less Time
TURBOMACHINERY
IN LESS TIME
Comprehensive Engineering Services
Specialized Products
Training
conceptsnrec.com
+1-802-296-2321
BUSINESSES PLANNING TO
DIGITALLY TRANSFORM
An Aveva-commissioned survey re-
vealed that 85% of businesses plan to in-
crease their investment in digital
transformation over the next three
years. Nine out of ten industrial compa-
nies see combining advanced technolo-
gies such as the industrial internet of
things (IIoT), AI, and cloud as key to
driving better performance.
Sustainability-led demands will conse-
quently drive innovation across the val-
ue chain, 85% of companies say. 89% Sulzer’s new service center in the UK.
are committed to achieving net-zero
carbon emissions. SULZER OPENS SERVICE CENTER IN UK
Located in Birmingham Business Park, UK, Sulzer’s latest service center has been designed
to optimize workflows. It ensures customers receive quality service and speed of repair.
RESEARCH INTO HYDROGEN Sulzer invested in 50-tonne overhead cranes and constructed an overspeed balancing pit.
INNOVATION
General Electric, GRTgaz, Ineris,
McPhy, and the network of universities ROTATING MACHINERY EXERGY APPOINTS CEO
of technology in France have established ACQUISITION Exergy, a provider of new-generation
a hydrogen research framework for Rotating Machinery Services (RMS) ORC power plants, has named Dario
power generation. A research cluster acqu ired A x is Techn ica l Ser v ices Puglisi as Chief Executive Officer. Puglisi
based in France will evaluate the con- (ATS). ATS offers technical field ad- has a degree in Engineering obtained
crete application of hydrogen as a fuel visors, rotating equipment planners & from Politecnico di Milano University
for gas turbine power generation. In ad- schedulers for turbine, compressor and has worked at major corporations
dition, it will model their operation, de- and generator repair, overhaul, in- such as Tecnimont and Techint. At
velop accessories and specific spection, and installation. ATS and Techint he held positions of increasing
components, and address safety and cer- R MS have worked a longside each responsibility over the years, both in
tification of systems. other for years. technical and management functions.
Louis Pinkham
CEO, Regal Rexnord
All trademarks, service marks and company names are the property of their respective
owners. © 2021 Regal Rexnord Corporation, All Rights Reserved. MCAD21055E • MB0130E Creating a better tomorrow™...
TURBO TIPS
R
eal-world operational turboma- around 3.5 times the main suction flow. The lesson learned from this event:
chinery problems can be chal- During operation at night, a malfunc- When the side-stream flow is consider-
lenging. Fast decision making is tion in the gas drier system raises gas ably higher than the main flow, the
often required. The questions temperature around 40°C compared to suction temperature alarm requires
such as “what to do now?” and “how do normal operation. The compressor careful attention since there could be a
we deal with this issue?” during live oper- experienced a sharp increase in suction possibility that internal temperatures
ation can be difficult to answer. It is temperature. As a result, compressor reach a high level and pass the limit
important to be prepared. vibration increased by around 10%, while the final discharge temperature
requiring operation team and may only show a small rise due to the
machinery engineer attention. cooling effects of the incoming large
TEMPERATURE LIMITS A large flow of gas with a relatively volume of side-stream flow.
Temperature limits inside a compressor low temperature came from the side-
are dependent on compressor design, stream nozzle and cooled the compressed
material selection, and component gas at the mixing section inside the For an alarm case when
manufacturing and process gas proper- compressor. The suction temperature
ties. Mechanical considerations usually sharp rise caused an increase of about all operating parameters
differ from compressor to compressor. As 9°C at the discharge. Gas temperature are still within allowed
a rough indication, temperature limits increased at the discharge of the first
associated with mechanical design could section (before the mixing section) inside limits, the general
be about 210°C. However, sealing the compressor.
elements and non-metallic components Based on measured data, operating
recommendation is not to
might limit the gas temperature to parameters were not beyond limits shutdown machinery.
around 175°C. But some gases should be except for the suction temperature.
kept lower than these temperatures based However, there was a concern about
on process requirements. high temperatures inside the For an alarm case when all operating
For example, polymerization could compressor. An operator recommended parameters are still within allowed limits,
be a concern for some gases. If gas tripping the compressor to prevent the general recommendation is not to
temperature passes the limit, polymeriza- damage due. The trip was not approved shutdown machinery. In the case of
tion can result in fouling or unbalance by the machinery engineer and the shift increased gas suction temperature for a
masses on impellers which could cause operation leader. Their assessment was short time when no parameter passes its
performance deteriorations, long-term that the internal temperature had not limit, the recommendation is to continue
vibration, and operational problems. For passed the limit and any trip could cause operation unless there is a reasonable
some process gases, the process limit on a thermal shock in the compressor inter- evidence of the need for a shutdown. ■
temperature could be somewhere nals. It would also interrupt production.
between 80°C and 140°C. The operations team acted quickly and
corrected the problem in the gas drier
system within seven minutes. Suction Amin Almasi is a Chartered
CASE STUDY temperature and vibration levels Professional Engineer in Australia
A centrifugal compressor with a high- returned to normal with no sign of and U.K. (M.Sc. and B.Sc. in
flow side-stream was located at the damage or malfunction. Additionally, it mechanical engineering). He is a
downstream of a complex gas drier was confirmed that process gas was senior consultant specializing in rotating
system. The side-steam flow was not polymerized. equipment, condition monitoring and reliability.
They’re Also
Preventable.
The best way to maintain ignition reliability is to know when ignition
faults are going to occur so you can replace the igniter tip before that happens.
Chentronics ignition solutions not only perform reliably for a wide range of frames,
they include fully integrated predictive diagnostics so you can do just that.
CENTRIFUGAL
COMPRESSORS
IN OIL & GAS
The Latest Products, Services, And Trends Including
Hydrogen Compression, Carbon Capture, And Bigger Machines.
BY DREW ROBB
C
entrifugal compressors lie at the heart of oil
and gas and industrial operations. They
represent one or the most vibrant areas of
the turbomachinery landscape and are
supported by a thriving vendor community. These
include Baker Hughes, Howden, Siemens Energy,
Elliott Group, Atlas Copco Gas & Process,
Kobelco, Mitsubishi Compressor, Man
Energy Solutions, Ingersoll Rand, and Sundyne
Let’s hear from each of them concerning the
latest trends, products, and services.
BAKER HUGHES
“The energy supply chain, including natural gas and
hydrogen, requires varying levels of compression, de-
pending on the type of gas and the application,” said
Leonardo Baldassarre, Executive General Manager,
Engineering, And Platform Leader, Compressors,
Pumps And Expanders, Turbomachinery & Process Baker Hughes High Pressure Ratio Compressor.
Solutions, Baker Hughes.
Accordingly, Baker Hughes provides centrifu-
gal compressor and pumps as well as reciprocat- “The energy transition is spawning unprecedented
ing compressors. Its portfolio spans from
horizontally split machines to barrel type. They demand and interest in green and blue
can range from almost atmospheric compressors
to very high pressure (up to more than 820 bars hydrogen production and supply
for centrifugal or above 2000 bars for reciprocat-
ing compressors) and from a few hundred cubic
management as well as carbon
meters per hour to several hundred thousand capture, utilization, and storage,” said
cubic meters per hour flow. They can also
accommodate any type of gas, from H2 to heavy Leonardo Baldassarre, Baker Hughes.
refrigerating gases and from almost inert gases to
very corrosive ones. high-performance stages for various applications,
For example, the Baker Hughes High Pressure including hydrogen. These compressors can spin
Ratio Compressor (HPRC) is a high-speed impellers at very high speeds, thus reaching high
rotor-compressor with a small footprint and pressure ratios while handling very large flows.
“Today, we are working to leverage this archi- process stages; up to 10 impellers per casing; inter-
tecture to increase impeller tip speeds, particu- cooling, side streams, and extractions; standard oil
larly for H2,” said Baldassarre. “This requires the lubricated or active magnetic bearings; optional
development of high strength alloys coupled with adjustable inlet guide vanes (IGV); and ultra-low
an aero and mechanical impeller design aimed to temperature service.
minimize stresses.”
Typically, components are tailored to cus-
tomer needs and applications. The OEM “A standardized package design offers
designs each compressor with a mix of custom shorter delivery times, common spare
and standardized components for a specific
plant and for a specific gas composition, flow, parts, and is easier to maintain,” said
and pressure.
In addition, the company is focusing on how
Scott Tackett, Siemens Energy.
to maximize the use of any energy cascade
through optimized bottom cycles like sCO2. Pipeline compressors with features such as:
Another area of attention is connected to energy Flange sizes (20’’, 24‘’, 30’’, 36’’, 42’’); max inlet
storage either associated with compressed gas or flow rates of up to 106,700 m³/h); maximum
with batteries. working pressure of up to 2250 psi; Up to five
stages; and a maximum power rating of up to
75,000 BHP / 56 MW)
SIEMENS ENERGY Custom-designed compressors covering perfor-
Siemens Energy offers: mance requirements outside the above ranges such
Single-shaft centrifugal compressors with fea- as those required for compressor head stations and
tures such as: dry gas sealing systems; up to four natural gas storage and withdrawal operations.
EDITORS
EDITORS ’ SERIES
’ SERIES
TURBOMACHINERY,
TURBOMACHINERY, CARBON
CARBON CAPTURE,
CAPTURE, HYDROGEN,
HYDROGEN, AND
AND
ACHIEVING
ACHIEVING AA NET
NET ZERO
ZERO CARBON
CARBON FOOTPRINT
FOOTPRINT
Event
Event Overview
Overview
L IVL E
IVW
E EBC
W EBAS
C ATS T
This
This webinar
webinar discusses
discusses thethe various
various applications
applications andand technical
technical challenges
challenges for for
thethe turbomachinery
turbomachinery
Thursday,
Thursday, September
September 9, 2021
9, 2021 required
required for for carbon
carbon capture.
capture. TheThe presentations
presentations include
include discussions
discussions about
about hydrogen
hydrogen compression,
compression,
11am
11am EDTEDT
| 8am| 8am
PDTPDT
| | hydrogen
hydrogen combustion
combustion in gas
in gas turbines,
turbines, carbon
carbon dioxide
dioxide compression
compression separation
separation andand injection
injection as well
as well as as
4pm4pm
BSTBST
| 5pm| 5pm CEST
CEST
associated
associated infrastructure
infrastructure needs
needs andand impacts.
impacts.
Presenters
Presenters
Key
Key Learning
Learning Objectives
Objectives
KlausKlaus
BrunBrun
Director
Director of R&D
of R&D • How
• How thethe reduction
reduction of the
of the carbon
carbon footprint
footprint willwill require
require thethe capture
capture of CO
of CO from
2
from combustion
combustion processes.
processes.
2
Elliott
Elliott GroupGroup
• The
• The combustion
combustion of hydrogen
of hydrogen or hydrogen-natural
or hydrogen-natural gasgas blend
blend fuels
fuels in gas
in gas turbine
turbine combined
combined cycle
cycle power
power
plants
plants hashas potential
potential as aasroute
a route to reduce
to reduce greenhouse
greenhouse gasgas emissions
emissions in the
in the electric
electric power
power industry.
industry.
Rainer
Rainer KurzKurz • Power
• Power plant
plant post-combustion
post-combustion carbon
carbon separation
separation turbomachinery
turbomachinery willwill be required
be required to compress,
to compress,
Manager
Manager for for
Systems Analysis
Systems Analysis
transport,
transport, andand inject
inject thethe carbon
carbon dioxide
dioxide intointo permanent
permanent geological
geological storage
storage formations.
formations.
SolarSolar Turbines
Turbines Incorporated
Incorporated
Who
Who Should
Should Attend
Attend
Moderator
Moderator
• Turbomachinery
• Turbomachinery engineers,
engineers, manufacturers,
manufacturers, researchers,
researchers, andand designers
designers
DrewDrew
Robb Robb
Editor-in-Chief
Editor-in-Chief
• Power
• Power plant,
plant, oilgas,
oil & & gas,
andand industrial
industrial facility
facility owners,
owners, operators,
operators, andand maintenance
maintenance personnel
personnel
Turbomachinery • Turbomachinery supply chain
Turbomachinery • Turbomachinery supply chain andand aftermarket
aftermarket partners
partners
Sponsored
Sponsored by by Presented
Presented by by
Register
Register
Register for for
today tothis
this free
watch
free a webcast
replay
webcast at:
at:on-demand
at www.turbomachinerymag.com/turbo_p/zero
www.turbomachinerymag.com/turbo_p/zero
turbomachinerymag.com/webcasts
For questions
For questions or concerns,
or concerns, email
email
[email protected]
[email protected]
reliable remotely operated compressor on the sea- non-geared compressors for main air handle flow
floor,” said David Kodz, Solution Manager volumes of up to 500,000 m3/h, with a maximum
Subsea & Unmanned Compression + ETES at input power of 30 MW.
MAN Energy Solutions. “The compression unit is
qualified for wet gas operation and significantly
reduces the process complexity by eliminating liq- “The overarching trend in the industry is
uid separation. The technology allows for fully decarbonization, which impacts many areas of
remote and unmanned operation.”
Beyond subsea, MAN operates in many other centrifugal compression and is driving advancement,”
markets. In CCUS, MAN supplies the compres-
sion technology for purifying CO2 and storing the
said Ulrich Schmitz, Atlas Copco Gas and Process.
CO2 in a depleted oil field or a saline aquifer. It
also operates in liquid air energy storage (LAES) For hydrogen transportation, the company
and molten salt energy storage (MOSAS). already has a cryogenic (-253°C) integrally geared
compressor solution for hydrogen carrier vessels.
For applications where the hydrogen content is
ATLAS COPCO GAS AND PROCESS 100% and the gas is non-cryogenic, compressor
Atlas Copco Gas and Process provides both inte- suppliers are focusing a lot of their R&D efforts on
grally geared and non-geared centrifugal turbo- developing efficient compression technology, said
compressors for hydrocarbon processing, power Ulrich Schmitz, Marketing Manager at Atlas
generation (both renewable and conventional), Copco Gas and Process.
and industrial gases. The integrally geared com-
pressors cover pressures up to 205 bar (up to eight
stages), flows up to 500,000 m3/h, and have max- ELLIOTT GROUP
imum input power of 35 MW. The Compander is Elliott Group provides the following centrifugal
also integrally geared: Here compressor and compressor lines:
expander functionalities are installed on one single
gearbox and skid. The Compander is used in
many hydrocarbon processing applications, “In all of our market segments we are
including small-scale LNG, chemical/ petrochem-
ical, as well as supercritical CO2. seeing a push toward reducing the
For the non-geared compressors, Atlas Copco
Gas and Process provides solutions for polyole-
carbon footprint,” said Ronald
fines and main air, respectively. These compres- Josefczyk, Elliott Group.
sors for PP/PE handle flows up to 65,000 m3/h,
with a maximum input power of 10 MW and
maximum pressure of 45 bar. The company’s Single-Stage: Elliott’s TC and PH compressor
product lines are single-stage overhung compres-
sors. Their typical application is in services that
require lower head requirements than that of a
multi-stage between-bearing compressor. The low
maintenance design with axial flow inlet and ability
for rear pull rotor removal make these compressors
a good fit for processes in dirty and corrosive appli-
cations such as petrochemical plants, refineries, nat-
ural gas processing, coal gasification, and ethylene
oxide/ethylene glycol (EOEG). To further expand
peak operating range, adjustable inlet guide vanes
can be installed to improve performance for chang-
ing conditions or partial load operation. Single-
stage compressor designs are standardly available
with inlet flows up to 90,000 ACFM and an 800
PSI discharge rating.
An eight-stage integrally geared Multi-stage: The M and MB compressor prod-
turbocompressor for high-pressure CO2 duty by Atlas uct lines are between-bearing centrifugal compres-
Copco Gas and Process. sors. They are typically used in hydrocarbon
markets including oil & gas production and pro- MHI COMPRESSOR
cessing, petroleum refining, petrochemical process- MHI Compressor Group manufactures and ser-
ing, cryogenic refrigeration, and industrial gases. vices API 617 beam-style and integrally geared
Elliott’s M line of compressors are horizontally split (Part 2 & 3) centrifugal compressors at its
while the MB product line is a vertically split con- Hiroshima, Japan and Pearland, TX facilities. It
figuration. M-line compressors are typically applied offers a range of custom designed compression
for lower pressure and fouling services. The
MB-line is better suited for high pressure and clean
gas service. Both of these compressors share major “Globally we’re seeing a rise of energy
components of rotor design, bearing and sealing
options, and aerodynamics staging, ensuring reli-
transition related projects that support
ability. While utilizing many standard components, various decarbonization objectives,”
each is engineered to order based on customer
specifications to optimize aero performance, rotor- said Clayton Jurica, MHI Compressor.
dynamics, and reliability. Elliott Group’s M and
MB line of compressors provide compression solu-
tions for inlet flows from 1700 to over 850,000 acfm
and pressures up to 10,000 psi.
The EDGE M-line compressor is the most
commonly applied compressor in Elliott’s product
line. This model is available in 15 standard frame
sizes. The horizontally split casing makes this
compressor a good fit for dirty, corrosive or foul-
ing services that provide maintenance challenges
to vertically split compressors. The frame size uses
standard casing and endwall designs, while the
aerodynamics components are custom tailored to
the application. The EDGE compressor design
uses a fully scalable aerodynamics flow path to
allow scaling across all frame sizes. Stage line ups
are available in straight through, sideload, iso-
cooled, back-to-back, and double flow configura-
tions. Advances in stage and nozzle design have
increased flow coefficients beyond 0.25 and
increased capacity per frame with the largest dou-
ble flow compressor capable of volume flows in
excess of 850,000 cfm. M-line compressors allow
end users to achieve greater capacity without the
typical frame increase of previous generation com-
pressors without negatively impacting reliability An MHI Compressor low pressure (LP) syngas compressor
or serviceability. for a large-scale ammonia plant in the U.S.
varying from low pressure / high flow compressors “This covers the entire energy value chain
(horizontally split) to high pressure / low flow com- such as carbon capture at new and existing facili-
pressor (vertically split). This includes upstream, ties as well as plants utilizing electrolysis,
such as FPSOs and CO2 reinjection, to mid and Autothermal Reforming (ATR), and/or Methane
downstream in NGL processing, LNG, ethylene, Pyrolysis to produce hydrogen and ammonia,”
ammonia, propane dehydrogenation (PDH), car- said Clayton Jurica, Director of New Unit
bon capture, refining, and power generation. Equipment at MHI Compressor International.
In addition, the company is strong in syngas
compression. Synthesis gas, a relatively low mole
weight gas mixture, plays a key role in many pet- INGERSOLL RAND
rochemical plants such as ammonia and metha- The Ingersoll Rand Turbo-AIR and MSG inte-
nol. Based on the low mole weight and grally geared centrifugal compressor product lines
compression ratio capabilities, there is a require- provide flexible, high-performance oil-free com-
ment for many stages of compression, sometimes pressor technology for industries powered by air
handled in multiple compressor bodies along with or gas. Since they are oil-free, they are a good fit
intercooling, in order to provide adequate dis-
charge pressure and temperature for the overall
process requirements. In North America, the “The cost of power over the life of
company reports positive momentum on several
blue ammonia projects in which the owner intends the compressor will dwarf the capital
to export the ammonia to utilize as a fuel or as a cost in most cases,” said Sam Gooldy,
carrier for hydrogen. There is also more interest
in energy transition and decarbonization.” Ingersoll Rand.
HOWDEN
The Howden Centrifugal Compressor group
includes brands such as Turblex, HV-Turbo,
Kühnle, Kopp & Kausch, Bryan Donkin, CKD,
and Roots. Each brand offers single-stage and
multi-stage centrifugal turbocompressors. Dual
vanes are available on many of the single-stage
models, and several have the option for both inlet
guide vanes and variable diffuser vanes for process
power optimization. A few typical applications
include process air for environmental processes
like wastewater, combustion air, compression for
sulfuric acid plants, mechanical vapor recompres-
sion (steam compression), and process gas com-
Ingersoll Rand MSG Turbo-AIR NX 5000 pression. These models can be configured to meet
oil-free compressor. API-617 and API-672 specifications.
The Roots OIB single-stage centrifugal com-
for industries that need to avoid oil contamination pressor, for example, has its beginnings in the
for product safety or quality. They are equipped early 1930’s. It can handle a wide range of appli-
with features to reduce energy expenditure and cations from standard industrial to high specifica-
other costs. tion API type process requirements. The OIB
• Maestro Controllers continuously optimize the
operation of the compressor by monitoring
operating parameters and adjusting discharge “Digital solutions are critical to these plants, as they
pressure and outlet flow to match the user’s
demand for a given application. gather, interpret and analyze rotating
• VIGVs offer efficient flow control.
• Non-contacting seals ensure energy efficiency
equipment data using preventative
does not diminish over time. maintenance to solve problems before
• A pinion bearing, gear design and stainless-steel
compression elements deliver durability. they occur,” said David C. Hokey,
Howden Roots Turbo Product Leader
For example, the Ingersoll Rand MSG Turbo-
AIR NX 5000 is an oil-free air and nitrogen com-
pressor that provides optimized energy efficiency
and operational flexibility. It generates oil-free air
or nitrogen that meets IS0 8573-1 standard. The
VIGV design enables a 35% turndown range,
enabling it to be used in various demand scenarios
to compress air or nitrogen for a process. During
periods of low or fluctuating demand, the opera-
tor can adjust production without the need to shut
it down or deploy energy-wasting blow-off.
While reliability measured in decades as an
absolute, we see today’s compressor owners focus
more and more on efficiency as the first among
equals. As power costs seem to be on a perpetual
march ever higher, we don’t see this changing any
time soon.
Sam Gooldy, Senior Global Product
Manager at Ingersoll Rand, said that a couple of
years ago, a typical 7,500 cfm compressor dis-
charging at 125 psig would require about 1500hp
of power at full flow. The Turbo-AIR NX can The Howden Roots OIB handles the main process gas compressor duty in
achieve that same flow and pressure, but it only a metals industry application that operates in a corrosive gas environment.
consumes 1400hp. The two OIB compressors shown have 8 MW drive trains.
M
echanical Dynamics & Analysis (MD&A) MD&A’s scope included a 7EA gas turbine
recently completed an overhaul at a major with a gas turbine rotor inspection and
combined-cycle plant consisting of gas assessment in its St. Louis repair facility. Upon
and steam turbine majors, a steam tur- incoming inspection, the aft coupling patch ring
bine generator minor inspection, and a gas tur- migrated, leading to galling on the aft f lange
bine generator major inspection. The customer’s coupling no. 12 bolt hole, galling in forward-flange
combined scope was the largest single project coupling no. 10 bolt hole, wear groove and
implemented at the site since the combined-cycle scratches on no. 3 journal, and circumferential lines
plant was commissioned. and scratches on no. 2 journal. Our experts
M D& A sent all three rotors—the steam removed the damaged patch ring, manufactured
turbine, gas turbine, and gas generator—to its and installed a new ring, and machined the ring fit.
one-stop-shop, which was a huge selling point for Incoming runouts and low-speed balance
the customer. MD&A was able to leverage the full checks were performed on the gas turbine rotor
capabilities of its state-of-the-art 250,000 square- with no runout issues found.
foot turbine-generator repair facility, centrally The M D& A team obser ved t he coat ing
located in St. Louis, MO to inspect and repair the peeling from S1 buckets. They measured dovetail
major components all under one roof. wear and bucket rock and found them to be well
To ensure the success of this large project, within the MD&A acceptable range; therefore,
coordination between all MD&A divisions was dovetail coating was not recommended. Bucket
critical, in addition to constant communication rock is often caused by cycling power plants that
with the customer. MD&A assigned a dedicated spend a considerable amount of time on a slow
project manager responsible for all on-site roll or turning gear, and the result was wear
services, including subcontractors, parts supply, between the wheel and the buckets, which often
and shop services. abrade the fir tree surfaces, causing a loose fit.
M D& A performed an S1- S3 bucket cracked and deformed main lead copper tops-on/tops-off internal alignment on
replacement during the repair portion leaves. The field was rewound with new the gas turbine.
and conf irmed f inal assembly w ith creepage blocking, the main lead was A long w it h hav ing access to
a low-speed balance. Its fuel nozzle replaced, and the company’s experts M D& A’s t u rbi ne- gener ator repa i r
s e r v ic e s d i v i s io n a l s o p e r for m e d incorporated an end-winding blocking facility, the customer also benef ited
a 7E A dual-fuel dr y-low NOx modif ication to optimize the f ield’s from choosing MD&A to execute the
Sy s t e m 1. 0 ( D L N1) pr i m a r y a n d future reliability. out age by hav ing a single point of
secondary refurbishment. contact for multiple services across the
The steam turbine major included entire combined-cycle platform.
removal of the rotor and shipping it to Single point project management
our steampath division for L-0 and L-1 allowed for coordinated scheduling of
buc ket r e pl a c ement s . D u r i n g t he concurrent work on-site and in-shop,
incoming inspection, MD&A experts leading to an optimized execution that
found heav y damage to the Stage 2 was achieved on schedule. The project
buc ket s: T he y, t o o, ne e de d t o b e manager had clear and responsive
replaced, which the end customer agreed communication with the elimination of
to. T he M D& A tea m removed t he multiple vendor interfaces and provided
buckets and performed a rotor-blast daily div isional job activ ity reports
cleaning to include the affected wheels. directly to the end customer. With the
It reverse-engineered and manufactured elimination of multiple vendors, there is
the Stage 2 buckets and covers, and clear warranty responsibility, which
installed L-0 buckets. It also reamed for gives peace of mind to the customer.
new pins, machined to fit the wheel, and Lastly, the customer was able to derive
installed L-1 buckets. Lastly, the final After rewind, the field was balanced sig n i f ica nt va lue from hav i ng one
N DE and a low-speed ba lance in its modern high-speed balance facility vendor supply ser v ices, pa r t s, a nd
were performed. in its repair. The high-speed balance repairs due to the inherent efficiencies
bunker can excite the field while at speed of this approach. ■
to ensure no shorted turns when oper-
ating at load.
O n - s i t e , M D & A’s g e n e r a t o r
specialist performed a test and inspec- MD&A is a full-service combined-cycle provider
t ion on the gas turbine’s generator and OEM-alternative—services, repairs, and
stator, which included a visual inspec- parts for your gas or steam turbine or generator.
tion, ending winding inspection, bore- For every job, large or small, the speed and effec-
s c op e i n s p e c t ion , a nd b or e c r awl tiveness of its response team are matched only by
through and inspection. The electrical the depth and breadth of its engineering exper-
testing consisted of winding insulation tise. Call MD&A today for your combined-cycle
“megger” testing, polarization index outage at (518) 399-3616.
(PI), winding resistance, DC leakage
testing, and RTD testing. The specialist
also per formed a wedge-tap test to
determine tight and loose wedges to
produce a wedge tightness map in addi-
tion to a thorough cleaning. A minor
In addition, the scope included a full inspection was also performed on the
rewind on the 7A6 gas turbine generator steam turbine’s generator.
field. After the field was removed from Lastly, MD&A’s alignment division
the stator, it was shipped to MD&A’s performed a topless laser alignment on
repair facility’s generator clean room. the steam turbine that eliminates the
Upon incoming inspection, the team reassembling of the turbine for “tops-on”
found Nomex ® tab-style end blocking measurements, sav ing hundreds of
with broken and torn tabs, damage to man-hours and labor per turbine section.
the original creepage blocking, and Its experts per formed a traditional
T
urbomachinery International vis- redundant in-line heat exchangers, ves-
ited Jeanette, Pennsylvania to wit- sel-mounted tube bundle heat exchang-
ness the opening of Elliott Group’s ers, and insulated vessels. In addition, its
new $60 million Cryodynamic liquid storage tank farm houses a
Products test facility. Construction kicked 60,000-gallon liquid nitrogen (LN2) tank,
off in December of 2019. The ribbon a 60,000-gallon liquefied natural gas
cutting ceremony in late October of 2021 (LNG) tank, and a 36,000-gallon lique-
included industry representatives as well fied petroleum gas (LPG) tank.
as county, local, and company officials. There are two cryogenic pump test
The speakers were: Toichi Maeda, stands. Test train 1 has three vessels (two
Chairman and Director, Ebara Corp., pump and one dedicated to expander
parent company of Elliott; Curtis testing) with a maximum pressure of
Antoniak, Mayor of Jeanette, PA; and 2,160 psig and a maximum flow of 4,000
Mike Lordi, CEO Elliott Group, who M3H. It has a 5 MW medium-voltage
ended the formalities with a toast. drive (range of 2,300 to 6,900 volts) and a
1 MW low-voltage drive (380 to 690
volts). Test train 2 has two pump vessels
A TOUR FOLLOWED: with a maximum pressure 3,600 psig and
The new complex includes six buildings, a maximum flow of 1,300 M3H, as well
with about 30,000 sq. feet under roof on as medium- and low-voltage drives with
the 13-acre campus. It will generate the same specs as test train 1.
approximately 100 jobs. The test loop The dedicated cryogenic liquid
features two cryogenic pump test stands expander test stand has an easily configu-
and a dedicated cryogenic expander test rable test loop, standardized loop designs
stand. As it is indoor and enclosed, for upward or downward flow, and can
(Left to right): Michael Lordi, CEO, Elliott
weather conditions have no impact test pumps while setting up the expander Group; Toichi Maeda, Director, Ebara
on testing. test loop. Its modular piping design can Corporation; Toshihiko Miyashita, Deputy
“We can test a full range of cryogenic deal with inlet pressures up to 2000 psig. CEO, Elliott Group.
pumps and liquid expanders, from the Babyak said a few pumps had been
smallest units, to units larger than those tested as trial runs and that the facility
currently available in the industries we would shortly go into full production. On ongoing. That means far more tests can
serve,” said Mark Babyak, Vice President the agenda are major tests for pumps and be done, the size of unit that can be
of Cryodynamic Products and Industrial expanders destined for LNG projects tested has doubled, testing times are
Products at Elliott. “We can test units around the world. decreased, and delivery schedules can be
with liquid nitrogen, natural gas, or pro- “We can test both column-mounted brought forward. The electrical load lim-
pane, depending on their specific appli- and vessel-mounted units,” said Babyak. itations of the older facility have also
cation, and we’re equipped with the The company’s previous testing facil- been eliminated.
latest instrumentation technology.” ity was not completely enclosed so “The size of liquefaction plants and
The facility has its own dedicated 25 weather such as strong winds often expanders continues to grow,” said
kV electric utility service, a 25-ton crane delayed tests. Further, only one test loop Babyak. “Hardly anyone else on the
with a 10-ton independent auxiliary was available. Now with two test loops, planet can conduct such tests, and our
hook, an energy-efficient cooling system, Elliott can carry out lengthy setup proce- facility is much larger and more modern
vacuum-jacketed insulated piping, dures for one test while another test is than any other.” ■
POWER RECOVERY
TRAIN CONTROLS
Operation of an Integrated Control System
BY NABIL ABU-KHADER
P
ower recovery trains (PRTs) are available, and possibly to convert expander inlet and bypass valves. The
common to industrial processes, excess process steam to rotating power recovered by the expander is
such as fluidized-bed catalytic energy that the generator will then regulated by the main control loop
cracking units (FCCUs) in refiner- convert to electricity and deliver to (primary or alternate), which manipu-
ies and nitric acid sections of ammonia the grid. lates the expander inlet valve to keep the
fertilizer plants. Their purpose is to expander flow equal to the process fluid
recover energy from a process regenera- production rate. The expander inlet and
tor’s flue gases and convert it into INTEGRATED CONTROL SYSTEM bypass control applications use the same
mechanical energy to produce power; An integrated control system has been process setpoint (SP) for both loops.
subsequently reducing the consumption developed to drive, protect, and sequence Typically, if the inlet valve control appli-
of traditional energy sources. the entire PRT. Speed, performance, cation uses a local SP, it passes that SP
A typical PRT includes a flue-gas expander, and anti-surge control applica- to the bypass valve control application.
expander, a main air blower, and a syn- tions run continuously to coordinate the The bypass valve is kept closed as much
chronous or inductive motor/generator. control of the expander inlet and bypass as possible to maximize energy recovery.
Some also include a steam turbine (ST) valves to maintain the proper flow and Flow is shifted from the inlet to the
or an auxiliary motor-driven air blower pressure for a catalyst regeneration pro- bypass valve in certain circumstances
for starting the unit. A PRT integrated cess. Excess energy developed by the sys- including when a limit loop is beyond its
control system provides automatic con- tem is applied to an electrical grid acceptable range.
trol during various operating conditions. through the hot gas expander and
PRTs are commonly employed in the generator.
FCCUs, in which: A PRT control system should regu-
• Catalytic pellets circulate between a late the air flow and pressure in the The purpose of power
cracking reactor and a regenerator, regenerator by manipulating the air
where the carbon deposits that form blower inlet guide vanes (IGVs) and recovery train is to recover
during cracking are burned off. expander inlet and bypass valves. It energy from a process
• Compressed air from the blower should also manipulate the blow-off valve
passes to the reactor and regenerator, to protect the air blower from surge and regenerator’s flue gases and
where it oxidizes the carbon deposits control the rotational speed when the
on the catalyst pellets and maintains generator is disconnected from the utility
convert it into mechanical
the fluidization of the bed. grid by manipulating the turbine energy to produce power.
• Hot flue gases from the regenerator governor and expander inlet valves.
pass to the expander, which converts Additionally, it should adjust the
the energy into mechanical power to expander or turbine power output if the
drive the train. generator breaker unexpectedly trips to Control system stability is essential in
• If the expander delivers more rotating reduce the power and prevent the unit maintaining a constant delta-pressure
energy than is needed to drive the air from over-speeding. However, it must between the reactor and regenerator, as
blower, the excess is converted to also maintain an adequate air flow to the well as a proper flow of air through the
electrical energy and delivered to the reactor and regenerator to prevent the catalyst. This prevents hydrocarbon
local electrical bus or public utility catalyst bed from collapsing. vapors or liquids from entering the regen-
grid. If not, the generator will motor Here is how it works: The regener- erator and causing an explosion and, at
(draw power from the grid). ator pressure is controlled by an inter- the same time, avoiding the ingress of air
• The optional ST is used to drive the acting pair of PRT expander control into the reactor which might lead to
air blower when insufficient flue gas is applications that manipulate the a major equipment damage.
The FCCU PRT developed by Compressor Controls Corp. (CCC) consists of the following units on a common shaft: A hot gas expander (TK-50)
which uses the energy developed by the regeneration process; an axial air blower (K-50) supplying air to a catalyst regenerator; an ST
(TK-50A); and a two-pole synchronous generator. The control applications for this train consists of: A speed controller (SC-501) which controls
the speed of the turbine during start-up; a steam flow controller (PRT-03) which controls the steam flow and discharge temperature limit
(measured by TT-536) for the turbine during normal operation; a performance air flow controller (FC-050) for the axial air blower, which
maintains the air flow to the catalyst regenerator by modulating the IGVs; an anti-surge controller (UC-051) positions the blow-off valve to
protect the air blower from surge; a performance inlet controller (PDC-070A), which controls the expander inlet valve (PV-050) to maintain the
proper delta-pressure between the reactor and regenerator; and a performance bypass controller (PDC-070B), which controls the bypass valve
(PV-070) to assist the inlet valve controller in maintaining the proper delta-pressure between the reactor and regenerator.
PRT START-UP USING AN ST synchronous speed with the breaker open configurable amount to immediately put
PRT start-ups using an ST are per- and no load. some load on the generator. Control of
formed using the speed control applica- When the breaker is closed to connect the turbine governor valve then switches
tion automatic start-up and warm-up the generator to the electrical grid, the from the speed to the steam flow control
sequences avoiding critical speed ranges. steam flow control application typically application, which maintains the flow of
This ramps the turbine up to the steps the governor valve open by a steam to the turbine blades. The air
blower is also loaded to begin supplying power (to reduce the load on the train) if This integrated control system can
compressed air to the reactor and regen- the PRT was generating power, or begin run a PRT in an FCCU, safely overcom-
erator. The performance control applica- producing enough power to continue ing breaker trip incidents by utilizing the
tion controls the mass air flow to the air driving the train if the generator was load-shedding algorithm. The control
blower by modulating the IGVs. The motoring. The system will also begin system also maintains a proper flow and
anti-surge control application modulates controlling the speed of the train, which is pressure for a catalyst regeneration pro-
the blow-off valve as necessary to protect no longer fixed by the grid frequency. cess under different conditions. Other
the air blower from surge. features like loop decoupling can help to
Once the air blower is supplying com- eliminate cyclic interactions between
pressed air to the reactor and regenerator SUMMARY controller applications. The technology
and the process is stabilized, the PRTs require precise and reliable control described is equally applicable to PRTs
expander can be loaded. This initiates over a broad range of operating condi- found in other processes. ■
the flow of hot flue gases through the tions to maximize FCCU availability.
inlet valve and transitions the control of FCCUs are operated continuously for
the main process variable from the long periods, with the main goal of maxi- Nabil Abu-Khader, Ph.D.
bypass valve to the inlet valve. As the mizing feed cracking. Occasionally, refin- Training Manager and
expander is loaded, the steam flow to the eries are forced to operate production Global Training Specialist at
turbine is reduced, and the PRT will shift units at reduced rates because of machin- Compressor Controls
from motoring to generating mode. ery or process issues, downstream bottle- Corporation (CCC), Abu-Dhabi, UAE.
If the electrical breaker trips during necks, upstream process unit trips, For more detailed information about
normal operation, the PRT control system seasonal factors, market economics, and the CCC control system developed for
will react quickly to either shed the excess feed availability. the PRT, [email protected]
Editors’ Series
Hydrogen Blending at Compressor Stations
Event Overview
ON -D E MAN D WE B CAS T
This webcast will discuss the primary considerations when blending hydrogen in pipelines and compressor
Aired: stations. Above concentrations of 10%, the properties of the blended gas begin to significantly change the flow
Tuesday, November 9, 2021 capabilities of the stations. Compressors may not be able to meet delivery requirements without modification.
• Engineers
Moderator • Pipeline operations
• Repair and maintenance personnel
• Oil & gas facility owners, operators, and maintenance personnel
• Turbomachinery manufacturers and designers
• Turbomachinery supply chain and aftermarket partners
• Control and software vendors and operators Sponsored by
Drew Robb
Editor-in-Chief
Turbomachinery International
Register
Register
Watch today
thefor to watch
this
replay free a replayat:
at: webcast on-demand at
www.turbomachinerymag.com/turbo_p/stations
turbomachinerymag.com/webcasts
For questions or concerns, email
[email protected]
TURBINE SENSORS
Measuring Rotating Temperature and Strain in Gas Turbines
BY JOSHUA MCCONKEY
A
s market forces push towards de-carbon- cracking and intra-grain conductivity failures in a
ization and lower cost of operation, effi- short amount of time. In gas turbine operational
ciency and reliability of gas turbines have conditions, a lifetime of less than 20 hours is typi-
become key differentiators among compet- cal. Adding 5% and 20% or 0% and 13% rho-
itors. For Brayton Cycle machines, those effi- dium to the platinum leads to create a Type R
ciency gains mostly come via higher combustion thermocouple can increase functionality to
temperatures, lower volumes of cooling flows, and 1,730°C for hundreds of hours. However, rho-
larger blades. As those parameters are pushed to dium costs >$2,000 per ounce in recent years. By
new limits, this also puts pressure on comparison, platinum is less than $1,000/oz.
component reliability. Type R also has a much lower sensitivity than
Intimate knowledge of component temperatures most other thermocouple types, at only 10µV/°C.
and strains is key to designing around this complex Most thermocouple manufacturers recom-
series of trade-offs. But as these components are mend that the long-term operating temperatures
made of materials that can survive ultra-harsh envi- of Type S and Type R thermocouples only inter-
ronments within high performance gas turbines, mittently approach 1,600°C, with continuous use
sensors must be able to mechanically survive the limited to below 1,400°C. Regardless, thermocou-
temperatures and g-loads inside turbines while also ples are the most widely used instrumentation
performing electrically or chemically. within the hottest parts of gas turbines. They are
often also installed on rotating parts.
The thermocouple wires are routed along the
TEMPERATURE MEASUREMENTS rotor to get to a cooler, exposed section of the
Platinum thermocouples (Type S) are the only rotor where active electronics on the rotor take in
way to get accurate real-time measurements on the thermocouple signals, converting them into
the most extreme stationary hot gas path tempera- short-range wireless signals. These electronics can
ture readings. Technically, they can function up only work up to 230°C, so are typically installed
to about 1,800°C. But effective lifetimes above on the rotor between the turbine compressor and
1,650°C are limited as foreign material diffusion, the generator. Thermocouple wires are thus
annealing, and other material failures lead to routed from the hot turbine section through the
The differences
Thermal Infrared Filtered Rayleigh
Feature Sensatek Thermocouples Thermal Paints Crystals Cameras TDLAS Scaltering
Continuous Temperature Range (◦C) 0-1700 0-1650 200-1500 500-1700 300-1700 600-1800 200-1800
Setup/Use Effort Low High (Wiring) High High Medium High Medium
Time to Obtain Data Real Time Real Time Months Months Real Time Real Time Real TIme
atomic order locally. By analyzing the before and heat transfer with the blade. A fixed antenna
after size distribution, an inference of maximum inside or outside the hot gas path pings the sensor,
temperature is established. While this seems to be which resonates at a frequency representing its
a complex method of measuring maximum temperature. They work above 800°C in the field
exposed temperature, vendors claim accuracy at on blades and up to 1,700°C in laboratory set-
temperatures around 1,400°C +/- 3°C. tings. The antenna is available in forms that
Thermal crystals have cost and testing incon- intrude into the hot gas path, if desired. The
venience disadvantages. The longer the test, the antenna and flexible cable can withstand tempera-
more ambiguous and inaccurate results become tures up to 800°C. Non-flexible versions work up
as dislocation relaxation is a function of tem- to 1300°C. Each antenna can read up to 5 sensors
perature and time. A long engine test at 1,100°C simultaneously. No external cooling is required on
may give the same result as a short engine test at the antenna or cable probes, which are 2-7mm in
1,200°C. Embedding and carefully removing diameter. The wireless range is 4-5cm in fielded
crystals is laborious. It can take months to obtain systems, though 15-30cm range versions are possi-
the results. ble at lower temperature applications.
Alternatively, infrared cameras can be used for
hot gas path measurement. This technique offers
2D temperature measurements of turbine surfaces
in real time, unlike thermal paint or thermal crys-
tals. The components glow with blackbody radia-
tion based on surface temperatures. The camera
looks at a range of infrared colors, and attempts to
rebuild the Wein displacement graph of that item.
If this can be done, the uncorrected temperature
of the item can be known. But a correction must
be applied based on wavelength, temperature, and
the material’s emissivity.
Unfortunately, the emissivity of the materials
within a gas turbine varies greatly, and there is
a lot of reflection of infrared light. Coatings, too,
inhibit accuracy. Finally, infrared camera lenses
have sensitivity to contamination, vibration, tem-
perature, and thermal expansion. These reasons
combine to make the use of infrared cameras in
turbine hot gas paths somewhat rare.
Further methods for measuring air tempera-
tures in hot gas paths are Filtered Raleigh mea-
surements and Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Sensatek recently commercialized passive wireless RF technology based on
Spectroscopy (TDLAS). They provide optical high temperature electrical resonators.
measurements of different molecular absorptions
and reflections of the hot gas itself. While they
show promise, they are expensive at this time.
PASSIVE RF WIRELESS
Passive wireless RF technology based on high
temperature electrical resonators is a new
approach. These sensors can be braze-bonded or
Rockide-bonded to turbine blades. Typical sensor
sizes are 10mm x 8mm x 0.3mm, resulting in
a mass below 0.3 grams and a bonded profile
height of less than 0.4mm (16 mils), which help
maintain expected blade mass loading and lami- Multiple sensors can be read simultaneously from the same antenna. Two sensors at
nar flow across the blade surface. The sensors slightly different blade radii that are both within 5 centimeters at their closest
require no attached antenna, as they are their own approach to the antenna can be read simultaneously, as shown (where two resonant
antenna. They are bonded in a way that has high humps are visible).
CHEMICAL CLEANING
Cleaning of Lube Oil and Hydraulic Systems Increases Uptime
BY BERNARDO SEQUEIRA AND OYSTEIN HALDORSEN
O
perators of larger rotating machin- In the past, it was common practice If varnish is detected at an early stage,
ery are often confronted with var- to replace the oil. The new oil dissolved it is possible to increase the solubility of
nish deposits on journal bearings. most of the remaining varnish from inter- the lube oil using additives for several
Varnish is an oil-derived deposit nal parts. However, lube oils used nowa- months before a planned oil replace-
based on machine operating conditions, days have low solubility. Oil replacement ment. An ESP (electrophysical separation
the formulation of the oil, and contami- only helps for a short period before prob- process) filtration unit can also be used to
nation. It is responsible for continuous lems return. remove the existing varnish. On heavy
temperature increases on journal bear- OEMs and lubricant vendors tend to contaminated systems, though, this
ings as it acts as an insulator, preventing recommend a flushing oil to clean out the becomes inefficient as the ESP filters can-
the lubricants from performing one of system. But the use of a flushing oil with high not handle high amounts of varnish since
their most important tasks: cooling. This solubility and high temperature makes it they saturate quickly.
can lead to unplanned machinery down- necessary to continue flushing for at three or The most effective solution is a chem-
time and bearing damage. more weeks to dissolve all varnish deposits. ical cleaning between oil changes. Most
CHEMICAL CLEANING
BEST PRACTICES
Here is a high-level summary of best
practices for chemical cleaning:
Effective chemical cleaning of a lube
oil or hydraulic oil system begins at the
planning phase. It is important to pre-
pare a complete mapping of the system
and walk visually through it to verify that
Inspection of journal bearings for varnish.
piping and instrumentation diagrams are
correct. Also check flange sizes as there
are often flanged connections that do not enough. Otherwise, chemical cleaning 10-micron filters use five-micron filters
follow normal industrial standards. is performed. for commissioning to ensure all particles
Flushing loops in the system should When the system is ready, the com- are removed. Begin the oil circulation
be planned based on Reynolds Number pressor deck has to be cleared for half pump system and continue until particle
calculations, and on minimizing the an hour to do a pressure test of the sys- levels are continuously on a low level.
number of bypasses and blinds needed. tem. This is the time to fix potential Chemical cleaning of oil systems is
That makes it possible to calculate the leakages when only water is in the sys- the most effective way to remove all var-
correct pump size to guarantee turbulent tem. For a typical two- to three-week nish deposits and prevent contamination
flow and chemical flowrate. Choice of overhaul, flushing is done during night of new oil. The complexity of this pro-
chemical depends on temperatures that shifts when no one is working on the cess, however, requires high-level knowl-
can be achieved, time constraints, envi- compressor deck. edge on chemistry, fluid dynamics,
ronmental constraints, construction Flushing with water removes chemi- and filtration. ■
materials of system, and other factors. cal residues. Thus, it is important to use
During the execution phase, the oil chemicals that are soluble in water.
system is drained before installing the Water flushing takes one day on average.
flushing equipment. Close out or dis- Afterwards water is drained, and flushing Bernardo Sequeira is Global
mantle equipment that cannot be skids are disconnected. Development Director Rotating
exposed to chemicals. Remove oil filters The auxiliary oil pump can now be Equipment Services at Bilfinger
from casings. put into operation and the system filled SE, an industrial services provider
Manually cleaning of oil tank inter- with the minimum amount of oil needed that offers consulting, engineering, manufac-
nals can be performed if the tank is big to test run the system. A short oil flushing turing, assembly, maintenance, plant expan-
removes any remaining water then drain sion as well as turnarounds and also includes
the system again and do a manual clea- environmental technologies and
nout of the bottom of the oil tank. digital applications.
It is now time to introduce new oil
through a 10-micron filter to remove par- Oystein Haldorsen is Technical
ticulate. Chemical cleaning can leave Director Rotating Equipment at
behind solid particles that were suspended Bilfinger Nordics.
in varnish. Therefore, it is recommended
to install a high-volume circulation filter For more information please contact:
on the oil tank to remove them. [email protected]
Prior to start up, install new oil filter +49 172 1029525 or Oystein.haldorsen
Mesh filters for bearings. cartridges. If the system usually runs with @bilfinger.com +47 920 87 108
SOLAR TURBINES
Hydrogen Top of Mind at Solar
BY DREW ROBB
S
olar Turbines, a Caterpillar Company, has Solar Turbines. “Solar is committed to continue
been a mainstay of the turbomachinery increasing our H2 capabilities and investing in H2
landscape for many decades. It offers a technology, offering energy solutions that are clean,
wide range of products including centrif- safe and reliable.”
ugal gas compressors and packages, mechanical
drive packages, and gas turbines for oil & gas and
power generation. Solar Turbines has been providing solutions for
It offers a series of gas turbine lines such as the Hydrogen-rich fuels since 1985.
Titan, Taurus, Mars, Mercury, Centaur, and
Saturn. These range from 1 to 23 MW. Solar
dominates the market for small gas turbines. Within pipeline gas applications, H 2 will
displace some portion of the natural gas in the
pipeline. It is expected that the H2 content of the
HYDROGEN gas will not exceed 20% in the near future. But
Solar Turbines has been providing solutions for within the industrial process market, H2 content is
Hydrogen (H2) rich fuels since 1985. It has logged already greater than 20% and as high as 100%.
over two million hours of operation, some units This market may include fuel gas with significant
today using as much as 80% H2 content. levels of other gases than methane, leading to
H 2 in gas turbine operation enables carbon careful consideration of safety, especially for high
reduction opportunities across a broad range of carbon monoxide. The best candidate today for
applications and industries. This will become this market and fuel type is a conventional
increasingly more important as renewable pene- combustion system.
tration rises and gas turbines are needed to
provide stable baseload and renewable support.
“Increased global usage of H2 is needed to meet SOLAR’S H2
increasing energy demands from customers as well TECHNOLOGY EXPERIENCE
as carbon reduction targets set by companies and Solar has extensive experience in high H2 tech-
countries,” said Wade Willden, a spokesperson for nology. It has 46 generator set packages operating
SoLoNOx Conventional
GAS COMPRESSION
Boosting Capacity at a Compression Plant
BY TALAL AL-RASHIDI & HAMAD K. AL-RUZIHI
T
wo multistage 16,000 HP electrical centrifugal compressor performance.
motors are used to drive two The required system polytropic head and
onshore gas compressors feeding a differential pressure are indirectly pro-
gas plant commissioned in 1984 portional to molecular weight. Generally,
(Figure 1). These compressors needed to centrifugal compressors operating at
produce gas at a higher capacity. higher molecular weight than design can
Unfortunately, the existing units were deliver higher actual volumetric flow rate
unable to meet the new demand. One at the new gas condition. But at a lower
option considered was purchasing and molecular weight, more head needs to be
installing an additional compressor. developed. Therefore, the inlet flow rate
Engineers also evaluated the possi- would need to be decreased, moving to
bility of utilizing the available capacity the left on the Head-Flow curve, to sat-
of adjacent offshore compressors. Figure 1: Onshore compressor skid. isfy higher head requirements. In fact,
Although onshore and offshore gas com- varying centrifugal compressor operating
pressors are located on the same plat- number of online producing wells. conditions result in different dynamic
form and discharge to a common Understanding the effect of changes in behavior which in adverse cases become
header, they were designed to process gas molecular weight can enhance per- impossible to accommodate.
different gas molecular weights due to formance prediction and capacity control To assess existing compressors for the
separate feeds for onshore and offshore of centrifugal compressors. new conditions, a site performance test
units (Figure 2). The challenge was to The original 1980s design assumed a was conducted. It revealed that the
ensure that offshore compressors could molecular weight of 32 g/mole. But recent onshore compressors could handle an
handle not only the new capacity but simulations and forecasts predicted a additional 5% capacity. When added to
the new gas conditions. 12-18% reduction. This simulation was offshore compressor capacity, this
As the plant receives gas from two validated through test samples that enabled the facility to meet the new
associated crude oil fields that produce showed a molecular weight of 27 g/mol. requirements by expanding an existing
different API oil grades, changing gas In addition, inlet temperature and jump-over line that connects the feed
molecular weight is prevalent due to the pressure have significant impact on stream header.
Trap Onshore
MORE HEAD REQUIRED and the lower the system head pressure CONCLUSION
During the conducted site performance required from onshore compressors. The The current onshore compressors at an
test, the inlet conditions differed from the compressor was operated at five different average molecular weight of 27 g/mole can
originally designed inlet parameters in flow rates but stopped before the choke exceed the required new flow demand.
terms of high pressure and low tempera- region as the targeted flow was achieved Therefore, instead of an additional com-
ture. This change had a positive impact and to prevent any negative impact on the pressor, the plant fully utilized existing
on compressor capacity and developed downstream compressor performance compression capacity at adjacent units.
head. This is mainly attributed to the fact (Figure 3). The new rated point per each compressor
that onshore compressors are operated To estimate the impact of molecular has conservatively 5% more capacity avail-
within different compression stages which weight changes in the available compres- able than the design point. Also, the motor
allow for better control of any compres- sor flow, a correlation formula was has enough horsepower to run at the new
sion stage inlet conditions in case of any devised between flow element design capacity and molecular weight. ■
compression stage poor performance. conditions and the measured gas condi-
It is evident that differential pressure is tions. Compensation or correction of
not maintained due to increased gas rates. flow measurements are common pitfalls
The more pipeline compressors operating, that can be major sources of errors in site Talal Al-Rashidi is a compressor
the lower the required differential pressure tests (Figure 4). and steam turbine engineer for
Saudi Aramco. He holds an M.S.
degree in Mechanical Engineering
Onshore compressor field performance test from Drexel University. For more information,
visit Aramco.com
Polytropic head lbf-ft/lbm
250
240
230
220
210
200
26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33
Molecular weight (g/mole)
100% new 110% 100% original
Figure 4: Plot of onshore compressor capacity showing the corrected flow of the onshore compressor based on the corrected flow measurement
correction and molecular weight changes.
NORTH AMERICAN
ENERGY WEEK
Siemens Energy Talks Decarbonization, Hydrogen, and
the Future of Gas Turbines
BY JOSEPH MCDONALD AND DREW ROBB
S
iemens Energy hosted a roundta-
ble in advance of its recent North
America Energy Week event. Tim
Holt, member of the executive
board, began by saying that half the com-
pany’s portfolio is decarbonized. The
company is spending more than a billion
Euros annually on R&D to heard toward
the goal of zero-emissions power genera-
tion. It targets carbon neutrality by 2030.
Holt believes that plans to produce
hydrogen from renewable energy via
electrolysis may not be the most efficient
way forward. He characterized it as turn-
ing an electron into a molecule and back
to an electron.
He pointed out that the lifespan of a Siemens intends to have its gas turbines 100% hydrogen ready by 2030.
gas turbine plant is around 25 years.
That ties in with many projections on Take the case of Germany. With gov- on 100% hydrogen. Currently, the com-
how long it will take to achieve carbon ernmental policy making it a challenge to pany commits to 50% hydrogen in its
neutrality and eliminate of fossil fuels. He build or operate gas turbine plants, the largest model.
suggested that investment in such facili- unforeseen circumstance was that the “The challenge is how to produce,
ties made sense. However, customers country fell back on burning lignite. CO2 store, distribute, and utilize hydrogen at
need reassurances about longevity. emissions are now higher than they were scale,” said Voorberg.
“Many customers want to know that 10 years ago. How do you sell in a market where
the turbines they are evaluating can “You have to ensure you achieve the everyone wants hydrogen power but a)
eventually run on 100% hydrogen,” said right balance that offers a sensible transi- the turbines are not quite there and b)
Holt. “They want to be sure they do not tion,” said Holt. “Storage is not develop- hydrogen is not available in quantity and
end up with a stranded asset.” ing fast enough. Gas is the best choice.” at a low cost?
Statistically, emissions currently from
power generation in the US are a third of
THE DISCUSSION HAS SHIFTED NORTH AMERICAN PERSPECTIVE what they were in 2005. No other sector
Holt added that the discussion has shifted Richard Voorberg, president of Siemens can boast such progress. Yet Public
markedly from a year ago. Suddenly, there is Energy North America, acknowledged Utility Commissions, grid operators and
momentum behind hydrogen and decarbon- that 51 utilities have set the goal of universities don’t want to even consider
ization in the U.S. However, there is a need decarbonizing by 2050. But when it gas as an option.
for balance. As it is impossible to achieve net comes to shifting from burning natural “At the end of the day, they need
zero overnight. Holt said natural gas will be gas to hydrogen, he believes the gas tur- power; we have to explain that you can’t
the transition fuel. Even today, 40% of global bine is the easy part. By 2025, all the run a grid only on renewables,” he said.
power is generated by coal. That represents a company’s turbines will be hydrogen “We need some rolling mass there and
big opportunity for natural gas. capable. By 2030, all will be able to run natural gas generation provides that.” ■
Primary vent
Secondary vent
To flare header
Figure: Using a back pressure control valve in the primary vent as part of the monitoring of secondary seal condition in a dry gas seal.
I
n the last 10+ years there has been a high enough for the user to be able to set By trending the position of this valve,
significant increase in the technology a low-pressure alarm and trip (if one can predict at what point the valve
and instrumentation used on dry gas required), indicating the secondary seal will no longer be able to control the pres-
seal systems to monitor the condition has failed. This pressure should probably sure. If the valve position stays relatively
of the seals. Most notable has been the be set somewhere between 15-25 psig, as steady throughout a run on a compres-
call to monitor secondary seal condition this will provide a good differential pres- sor, it is not recommended to change the
– there have been significant failures of sure across the secondary seal and dry gas seals. However, if it has changed
the secondary seal without any issue improve its lifespan by slightly increasing by more than 20% over a run time, it
with the primary seal. The majority of the gap between the faces (less wear). would be recommended to do so. ■
these failures have been due to oil By using a positioner (wireless posi-
migration across the separation seals. As tioners are available) on the back pressure
the oil is not drained out, it accumulates control valve, a user will be able to be pro-
around the secondary seal, fills the active in determining if the secondary or Michael Forsthoffer is President of
grooves, and causes the secondary seal primary seal is going to fail. For example, Forsthoffer Associates (FAI), a
faces to contact. if the valve is normally set at 60% open Rotating Machinery Consultancy
There are various approaches to and it starts to open more, this could indi- that focuses on optimal machinery
monitoring secondary seal condition. cate excessive primary seal leakage reliability in projects and during the life of a
Probably the most beneficial is utilizing a (assuming if intermediate nitrogen is being plant. FAI conducts site-specific training and
back pressure control valve in the pri- supplied, the flow has not increased). condition assessments/ troubleshooting glob-
mary vent (Figure 1). This sets the pri- Likewise, if the back pressure control valve ally for machinery of every type of applica-
mary vent at a pressure below the begins to close more, this could indicate tion. For more information, contact michael@
primary seal gas supply pressure, but excessive secondary seal leakage. forsthofferassociates.com.
ADVANCED TESTS
FOR FAST INSTALLS
API 617 PTC 10 TYPE 2 COMPRESSOR TESTING
As one of the only OEM’s to have a compressor test stand performing PTC 10 Type 2 testing in the Gulf
Coast region, this local offering allows the customer access to timely explanation of shop test results. Our
teams boast competitive project delivery by minimizing schedule risks and offering simplified logistics
to site for installation. The new test stand will offer substantial capacity to conduct performance and
mechanical tests on small to mid-sized API 617 centrifugal compressors, enabling MHI to manufacture,
assemble and test all in the USA. Contact [email protected] for questions
type for one or two Users can access coupling data by scanning rack mounted format. Multiple outputs
independent chan- a QR code or entering a serial number. are available on the back of the rack for
nels, plus the ability The app will then present data for the up to 3 alarm levels and 2 analogue
to scale output either specific coupling like filling volume, filling outputs per channel. Dual redundant
to peak or RMS units, angle, power, speed, or operating fluid. Modbus communications to a module
and an LED indicates The app is available from Google Play and level provide a robust communication
alarm levels. the Apple App Store. system. It also features an LCD display.
metrixvibration.com voith.com sensonics.co.uk
Compressor technology
with a digital advantage
Howden offers unparalleled expertise in every application
where reliable, round the clock operation is paramount.
low sonic speed, which can result in and do not necessarily represent those
high Mach numbers, causing shock of Solar Turbines Incorporated,
losses and a reduced operating range. Elliott Group, or any of their affiliates.
AD INDEX
American Air Filter Concepts NREC 9 Mechanical Dynamics & Rotoflow 33
Company, Inc. 15 conceptsnrec.com Analysis, Ltd. 22 rotoflow.com
aafintl.com Elliott Company CV2 mdaturbines.com Sohre Turbomachinery,
Atlas Copco - Gas & elliott-turbo.com Mitsubishi Heavy Inc. 7
Process Division CV4 Franke-Filter GmbH CV3 Industries Compressor sohreturbo.com
atlascopco.com franke-filter.com International (MCO-I) 43 Rotating Machinery
Camfil Power System 19 mhi.com/group/mcoi Services, Inc. 5
Howden
camfil.com North America 45 Praewest 7 otatingmachinery.com