Income Taxation: Foods (Phils.), Inc., G.R. No. 143672, April 24, 2003)
Income Taxation: Foods (Phils.), Inc., G.R. No. 143672, April 24, 2003)
INCOME TAXATION
entitled to deductions allowed to avail of
under Section 34. exclusions under
Section 32 (B).
OVERVIEW
Paid v. Incurred
Tax Payable/(Overpayment) (Sec. xxx An expense is considered paid, when the money is
76) already paid, nabayaran na. On the other hand, an
expense is incurred when it was already utilized,
although not yet paid, nangyari na, pero di pa
ALLOWABLE DEDUCTIONS bayad.
NOTE: It is a different case, however, for Value- Example: We are engaged in a legal profession.
Added Tax. Our law office from time to time sends us to
seminars. We can easily establish the correlation
between these seminars and this business in
Requisites:
engaging legal practice.
● An expense will be considered
"necessary" where the expenditure is
The taxpayer has a sale of only One Million and the
appropriate and helpful in the
travel expenses is 50 Million. So evidently, it is
development of the taxpayers business.
grossly disproportionate to the sales. Definitely, it is
It is "ordinary" when it connotes a
extraordinary.
payment which is normal in relation to the
business of the taxpayer and the
Bribes, Kickbacks and Other Similar Payments
surrounding circumstances. (Atlas
- These are not allowable deductions. This is
Consolidated Mining & Development
obvious because it is immoral and contrary
Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal
to public policy.
Revenue, G.R. No. L-26911, L-26924,
January 27, 1981)
So the important here in Trade, Business and
● Bribes, Kickbacks and Other Similar
Professional Expense is the ordinary and
Payments. - not allowable deduction.
necessary, and substantiated by records
Ordinary expense v. Necessary expense YES. Because the amount material, the benefit is
expected to last for more than a year. That’s capital
expenditure.
NECESSARY ORDINARY
Q: What is the normal treatment of CAPEX?
A: The normal treatment of CAPEX is the option tending to increase the value of the property
number 2 on the slide [(b) to deduct allowance for assessed)?
depreciation]. A: This is a special assessment tax. This is a
charge against those property owners who were
Q: What do we mean by DEPRECIATION? benefited by the project of the government.
A: In Capital Expenditure, it is spread over its used
to life. Example: If gumawa ka ng road, yung
madadaanan ng road mag iincrease ng value. So
Example: If the building is worth 1 Million, the the local government collects special tax and that
expected life of the building is 10 years. So P 1M special tax cannot be claimed as a deduction.
divided by 10, hence, P 100,000 per year. Every
year, the company will be deducting 100,000. It will a. Income tax
not be an outright deduction of 1M. The whole cost
of CAPEX is spread over it is used to life. That’s The income tax cannot be claimed as a deduction
what we meant for depreciation. because before you can get the income tax you
need to have your deductions.
The normal treatment for CAPEX is that only the
depreciation will be deducted and not the total b. income taxes imposed by authority of any
capital made. foreign country which was availed as tax
credits
But for some exceptional cases, for private
educational institutions. 2 options are You recall that a resident citizen is subject to
provided : income tax for incomes earned from within and from
1. You may ought to deduct that whole P 1M without. Yang mga resident citizen na yan may mga
at the time incurred it or you pay it. binabayaran din na income tax abroad, so those
2. You spread over in the form of income taxes paid in other jurisdiction, they have
depreciation. the option to:
1. Claim it as a deduction
2. Claim it as tax credit
(3) Interest.
(4) Taxes, except:
You recall our formula: Gross income - allowable
income tax; income taxes imposed by authority of
deduction. That payment of income tax abroad can
any foreign country which was availed as tax
be claimed as a deduction or claim as tax credit
credits; estate and donor's taxes; and Taxes
from tax due.
assessed against local benefits of a kind tending
to increase the value of the property assessed.
Ang sinasabi sa Sec. 24, if the taxpayer has opted
to use the tax payment in the form of tax credit, then
This other deductions are governed by the rule on hindi mo na siya pwede ilagay sa deduction
Ordinary and Necessary Expenses. otherwise it would be dual availment.
4. Taxes
This must be covered by the rule of ordinary and
necessary.
Taxes can be allowed as deduction except for the
following: Q: You are engaged in the sale of furniture and
a. income tax; the finished products were stored in a
b. income taxes imposed by authority warehouse. Unfortunately, the warehouse was
of any foreign country which was razed by fire and as a result you lost all your
availed as tax credits; inventories, your finished product. Can you
c. estate and donor's taxes; and claim the value of those inventories and
d. Taxes assessed against local finished products as a deduction?
benefits of a kind tending to A: The answer is yes because these are your
increase the value of the property losses and definitely the loss is related to your
assessed. business.
Q: Are you familiar with number 4 (Taxes Q: Pano kung yung bahay nyo? Kunwari
assessed against local benefits of a kind business mo furniture, you form a corporation,
your furniture stored in the warehouse pero ang Depreciation, as mentioned, is the expense or
nasunog yung bahay mo. Can you claim the allowable deduction of the taxpayer based on the
losses dun sa bahay nyo? use over the life of the depreciable asset. Note that
A: No, they're not related at all. It is qualified by that depreciation is applicable to tangible properties that
phrase, “it should not be compensated by insurance are capital expenditures such as machinery or
or other forms of indemnity. equipment.
10. Research and Development Unless the taxpayer signifies in his return his
intention to elect the optional standard deduction,
he shall be considered as having availed himself
(10) Research and Development of the itemized deductions. Such election when
(11) Pension Trust made in the return shall be irrevocable for the
taxable year for which the return is made.
Research and Development is self explanatory.
Again, it should be governed by the ruling on Q: What is the distinction between OSD and
ordinary and necessary. itemized deductions?
A: The deductions that we have been discussing,
Example: If you are say engaged in manufacturing such as the business expenses, donation are
of furnitures and at the same time you are trying to itemized deductions. It is itemized because
discover and manufacture a certain drug. Definitely nakalista sila. In lieu of itemized deductions, the
that research and development will not be allowed taxpayer may avail of OSD.
as a deduction because they are not related.
Q: How about OSD? Q: For your future reference, when should you
advice availing of Itemized Deductions and that
Optional Standard Deduction (OSD) of OSD?
· In lieu of itemized deductions, a A: If you avail of OSD, that’s an automatic 40%
taxpayer may avail of OSD equivalent deduction without need for substantiation.
to: Remember that one of the general requirement, is
a) 40% of gross sales or gross that the expense should be supported by receipts,
receipts for individuals; or invoice or other pertinent records? So, if you avail
b) 40% of gross income for the OSD, automatic may 40% deduction ka, kahit
corporations wala kang gross receipts.
Ø Unless the taxpayer signifies in his
return his intention to elect the Atty LJ’s Advice: ‘Pag nagtayo kayo ng law offices
optional standard deduction, he at di kayo masipag sa mga receipts niyo, pakalat-
shall be considered as having kalat or nakapangalan kung kani-kanino, mag-avail
availed himself of the itemized na lang kayo ng OSD. But if you are very diligent,
deductions. Such election when your Invoice and Other Requirements and Other
made in the return shall be supporting documents complied with the
irrevocable for the taxable year for regulations of the Tax Code for deductibility, then
which the return is made. definitely, avail of Itemized Deducitons – IF YOU
CAN FORESEE, that the Itemized Deductions is
A: Magkaiba yung tax base. For individuals, gross more than that of OSD.
sales or gross receipts.
ITEMS THAT ARE NOT DEDUCTIBLE
Q: What’s the difference between gross sales
and receipts, as against gross income?
A:
Items not Deductible
Gross Sales or Receipts, you deduct your Cost of
Sales. (1) Personal, living or family expenses
(2) Any amount paid out for new buildings or for
So: Gross Sales – Cost of Sales = Gross Income permanent improvements, or betterments
made to increase the value of any property or
So, if you’re an individual trying to avail of itemized estate;
deduction, the basis is not the gross income. But for (3) Any amount expended in restoring property or
corporation, the basis is the gross income, which is in making good the exhaustion thereof for
40%. which an allowance is or has been made; or
(4) Premiums paid on any life insurance policy
Unless the taxpayer signifies in his return his covering the life of any officer or employee, or
intention to elect the Optional Standard Deduction, of any person financially interested in any
he shall be considered as having availed of himself trade or business carried on by the taxpayer,
the Itemized Deduction. Such election will take in individual or corporate, when the taxpayer is
the nature of irrevocable toward the present taxable directly or indirectly a beneficiary under such
year. policy. (Section 36 of the Tax Code)
NB: The default is itemized deduction.
(1) Personal, living or family expenses
Meron kasi yan sa Tax Return. There’s a box that
you have to check – OSD or Itemized Deduction.
This option has to be made during your quarter Again, the expenses must be related to the
filing. Remember that a corporation is required to business.
file quarterly – Q1, Q2, Q3 and then, Annual Income
Tax filing. So, sa Q1 filing, dun niya gagawin yung Situation: Bill for wifi, electricity used in his
election, whether OSD or Itemized Deduction. house for his work, in a work from home setup
during the pandemic – can this be used and be
If you have availed OSD, that choice cannot be charged in his office?
revoked at least for the present taxable year. A: No, kasi most likely, his bill, naka-name sa
Next year, during Q1, pwede ka na ulet mag- parents niya in his personal capacity, and that is not
Itemized. allowed to be deducted.
So, the default option is Itemized if there was no (2) Any amount paid out for new buildings
OSD selected. or for permanent improvements, or
betterments made to increase the value of
In lieu of Itemized Deduction, you can offer OSD. any property or estate;
(A) Definitions. - As used in this Title – NB: DST is present to either OA or CA, so
it is NOT a deciding factor.
(1) Capital Assets. – The term ‘capital assets’ This is another kind of Tax Avoidance.
means property held by the taxpayer (whether or
not connected with his trade or business), but 2.) There are certain rules that only applies to
does not include stock in trade of the taxpayer or Capital Assets.
other property of a kind which would properly be
included in the inventory of the taxpayer if on a) Limitation on Capital Losses - Losses
hand at the close of the taxable year or property from sale or exchange of capital assets
held by the taxpayer primarily for sale to shall be allowed to the extent of gains from
customers in the ordinary course of his trade or such sale/ exchange.
business, or property used in the trade or
business, of a character which is subject to the Example:
allowance for depreciation provided in i) 1st transaction, assuming there is a Capital Asset
Subsection (F) of Section 34; or real property of 100k, but only sold 80k. Can you consider the
used in trade or business of the taxpayer. loss of 20k as a deduction?
NO, because of the Limitation on Capital loss
Capital Gains and Losses ii) In this 2nd transaction, the Capital Asset is 90k,
and selling price is 100k. Thus profit of 10k. Can you
Capital Asset v. Ordinary Asset offset the 20k loss in the 1st transaction, against the
2nd transaction?
Ordinary assets include inventory or those YES, only to the extent of 10k.
held primarily for sale to customers, as well
as those assets used in trade or business of
the taxpayer. Any other assets which are not Q: Can you offset the first capital asset
considered ordinary assets are classified as transaction with the gain of the second capital
capital assets. asset transaction?
A: the answer is only to the extent of 10,000. That
Sec.39 actually made less things of those assets is what is meant by the limitation on capital loss.
that can be considered as ordinary. There are 5.
And then, the following paragraph goes on in saying
Q. What if it is an ordinary asset transaction? A. Period of In the next Carry over of
Kung may ordinary asset transaction yan and there Carry-over succeeding operating loss
is a resulting loss, it can be claimed in full as a taxable year in 3
deduction. That is why it is important to distinguish succeeding
between capital and ordinary. taxable years,
or 5 years in
b) Net Capital Loss Carry-Over: If any the case of
taxpayer, other than a corporation, sustains mining
in any taxable year a net capital loss, such companies
loss (in an amount not in excess of the net
income for such year) shall be treated in the
succeeding year as a loss from the sale or
exchange of a capital asset held for not
more than twelve (12) months.
NACOLCO it can be carried over only up to the next
If any tax payer, other than a corporation.. year. So if ngayon nagkaroon ng losses of sale of
remember that this particular rule does not apply to capital asset, you can claim it as against next year.
a corporation. So if any tax payer other than a
corporation sustains for any taxable period a net TAX FREE EXCHANGE TRANSACTION
capital loss, such loss in an amount not in excess of
the net income for such year shall be treated in the
succeeding year as a loss from the sale or There are 2 general classifications of tax free
exchange. exchange transactions:
1. Reorganization – no gain or loss shall be
Remember our concept of NOLCO (Net Operating recognized on a corporation or on its stock
Loss Carry-Over), our NOLCO is an allowable or securities if such corporation is a party to
deduction more than the gross income. a reorganization and exchanges property in
pursuance to a plan of reorganization solely
Net Capital Loss Carry-Over (NCLCO) is the for stock or securities in another
difference between the cost of the capital asset and corporation that is a party to the
the selling price for that asset. So NCLCO, excess reorganization.
of losses from sale of capital assets over selling
price. NOLCO on the other hand, is allowable 2. Property for share swap – no gain or loss
deduction of your gross income. shall also be recognized if property is
transferred to a corporation by a person,
alone or together with others, not
NCLCO NOLCO exceeding (4) persons, in exchange for
stock or unit of participation in such a
corporation of which as a result of such
Source Excess of Excess of exchange the transferor or transferors,
losses from allowable collectively, gains or maintains control of
sales or deduction said corporation.
exchanges of over gross
capital assets income Atty. LJ: Don’t worry we will not dwell on this much.
over the gains If you check sec. 40, the type of reorganizations
from such have already been identified. Mergers and
sales or reorganizations between group of companies. We
exchanges will focus rather on property for share swap.
Review:
Capital gains from sale of shares of stock not traded ● Requisites:
in the stock exchange shall be subject to 15% (1) issued by domestic corporation
capital gains tax. (2) not listed shares
● If it is issued by a foreign corporation
Don’t be confused with the concept of capital asset - all other income subject to regular tax.
that we discussed a while ago. The capital asset ● If it is a listed share
transactions on sale of shares and capital asset - subject to stock transaction tax
transactions on sale of land or real property are
governed separately by different Tax Code 3. Capital Gains from Sale of Real Property
provisions. The (inaudible) Rule or Limitation on
Capital Loss will not apply here. Don’t apply these
rules on sale of shares of stocks or lands.
C. Capital Gains from Sale of Real Property
- Subject to 6% CGT provided that:
It’s 15% capital gains tax and the base is net capital
i. Real property is located in the
gains.
Philippines; and
ii. Real property must be classified as a
Q: How do you compute the net capital gains?
capital asset.
A: That’s basically selling price less cost. You
- Ordinary assets are those for sale or use
acquire shares of stocks – Php100,000.00, and you
in the ordinary course of business or
sell it for Php150,000.00. Your net capital gain is
trade; all other assets are capital assets.
Php50,000.00. That is your tax base. The rate is
- Tax base is the highest among (i) gross
15%.
selling price, (ii) market value per tax
declaration, and (iii) zonal value.
Q: What are the requisites?
- Doctrine of presumed gain – in case of a
A:
sale of real property located in the
1. Shares sold should be issued by a
Philippines and held as capital assets,
domestic corporation.
there is no need to prove that there is
- The 15% capital gains tax shall apply if
income gained before the transaction
the subject shares are shares of a
can be subject to income tax.
domestic corporation
To simplify, highest of the gross selling price, the i. Sold to the govt, its political subdivisions,
zonal value which is the value determined by the intrumentalities or GOCC.
Commissioner, and the market value per tax
declaration which is the value determined by the so if you are selling to government, political
assessors. So again, the basis is the GROSS and subdivisions, intrumentalities or GOCC, the
not the NET as compared to Shares of Stocks and individual tax payer has the option:
because of that way of computation, we have now a) pay the 6% CGT, or
the Doctrine of Presumed Gain. b) subject the income from sale to the
schedular income tax rates
Q: What is this doctrine of Presumed Gain?
A: In case of a sale of real property located in the The schedular income tax rates is the usual regular
Philippines and held as capital assets, there is no income tax that I keep on mentioning. The option is
need to prove that there is income gained before with the seller, who is the individual tax payer but
the transaction can be subjected to income tax. this option is only applicable if the buyer is a
government, political subdivisions, instrumentalities
So even assuming, you acquire a real property or GOCCs. So even if the property is a capital asset,
amounting to 500,000php (capital asset in the even if the property is in the Philippines, this
Philippines), and then you set it at 400,000php. The individual tax payer may still ought to subject the
zonal value and the market value per tax transaction to schedular rates.
declaration are also below 500,000php. If you will
compute mathematically, may lugi ka- you acquire
ii. Sale of principal residence (this is the favorite bar Kasi di naman agad ma-iidentify ni BIR na qualified
question) sya dun sa exemption until the construction of the
new principal residence. That’s the reason why, it is
A principal residence by nature is a capital asset, required in the Tax Regulation that the 6% CGT is
and if it is located in the Philippines then this one deposited in the mean time in an escrow account,
will apply. So even if in the sale of principal asset, it and if after the construction the tax payer did not
should be subjected to 6% CGT, it will be exempt meet the requirements for exemption then that
from CGT provided the following requisites Escrow or the bank holding the Escrow account will
concur: remit the balance to the BIR. But if all the
requirements are met, the escrow account will be
a. Proceeds are fully utilized to given in favor of the tax payer.
acquire/construct new principal residence
within 18 months from the sale of old principal d. Tax exemption must be availed once every 10
residence. (Note: The sale must precede the years only
acquisition/construction)
Ang premise dyan ng Tax Code, di ka naman dapat
The sale must precede the acquisition/construction, papalit palit ng principal residence- kaya once every
why? Because the requirement of the Tax Code is 10 years lang.
that you disposed of your principal residence for the
purpose of acquiring a new- that’s the rationale. The Remember this requirements, 18-30-10.
Tax Code is giving you an exception because the [use within 18 months, notify within 30 days,
Tax Code or the Congress realizes that you needed available only once in 10 years]
a Principal Residence. So there must be a sale of
the old to acquire a new. Full utilization within 18 months from the time of sale
of the old residence .in which case the sale must
In one of the questions, I gave to my students, precede the construction or acquisition of the new,
pinagpalit ko lang. Sinabi ko lang na the new notification within 30 days to the BIR, and the
principal residence was already acquired and then availment once every 10 years. Those are the
sinabi ko that the cost of acquisition is say 5M, so requirements under the Tax Code. But if you want
this is the situation: to impress your examiner, you can add the
requirement of escrow.
Q: There was an acquisition of a new principal
residence and to acquire this, a loan has to be Again,
obtained with the bank (assuming 5M). After 1. Passive Income, IRPOD = Final
that transaction, the tax payers sold the old Withholding Tax.
residence for 5M and the 5M was used to pay off 2. Capital Gains on Sale of Shares, shares
the liability with the bank. Will that qualify for must be issued by domestic corporations
the exception? not listed in the Stock Exchange = 6% CGT
A: No, because the sale must precede the (?).
acquisition of liability. 3. Capital Gains on Sales of Real Property,
RP must be located in the PH and must be
b. BIR is notified of the intention to avail tax a capital asset = 6% CGT.
exemption within 30 days from sale
So, if a transaction will not fall under those three
This is a notification requirement. general or broad categorizations, then it will be
considered as other income.
c. 6% CGT is deposited in an escrow account
Q: What’s the treatment of other income?
Third requirement is not seen in the Tax Code, but A: The income earner may be a Purely
it is provided in the Revenue Regulations. The 6% Compensation Income Earner, meaning to say, his
CGT is deposited in an escrow account. sole source of income is the compensation,
empleyado.
Q: What do you mean by an escrow account?
A: It is like an account in trust. A person may also be a Purely Self- Employed
Individuals/Professionals. Hindi siya empleyado,
At the onset, the presumption of the BIR is that “oh pero mayroon siyang sariling business na, or he is
di ka naman nag qualify with the requirements for engaged in the practice of his profession. Practice
the sale of principal residence, and therefore your of profession, let me qualify. If you are a lawyer, me,
6% CGT will be deposited in a bank account and by for example, I am a lawyer but I am an employee of
the end of the construction- if we can see that you Atty. Nilo,, for tax purposes I am not considered as
utilize the proceeds from the sale of the home within engaged in the practice of profession. I am
18 months we will release to you or the escrow considered as an employee.
account shall revert to you the CGT that we
deposited. Let us clarify that. When I say you are engaged in
the practice of profession, you have your own law
office. Like, Atty. Nilo for example. He is engaged in over 8m, 35% bracket. So that’s how you determine
the practice of profession. your tax rate.
The third is Mixed Income Earner. So, on one side You know how to compute for taxable income right?
you have your own business or you are engaged in Gross Income less Allowable Deductions. But
the practice of profession, and on the other side you under Section 34 introductory paragraph, no
are also considered an employee. deductions shall be allowed for purely
compensation income earners.
Q from Student: So does that term employee
include senior partners?
Income Source of Tax Tax Base
Atty: It depends on the Article of Co-partnership.
Earner Income Rate
There are General Professional Partnerships where
the Senior Partners or Partners are considered as
employees, but there are also articles of co- Graduat Taxable
partnership where these partners are considered as ed Income
partners. So if they are _ partners, they are Income
considered engaged with a profession, not an Tax
employee. These are definitely the major rates
classifications of income earners. Purely Business
Self- Income or
Income Source of Tax Tax Employed Professional
Individual Income OR OR
Earner Income Rate Base
s/
Professio
Purely Compensation Graduat Taxabl nals Gross
Compensa Income ed e Sales or
tion income Income Gross
Income tax 8% receipts,
Earner rates and other
Non-
Operating
Now, if the taxpayer is a Purely Compensation Income in
Income Earner, the source of income is definitely excess of
just compensation income. Yan lang talaga. P250,000
If you are over 800k but not over 2m, you are
subject to the 25% bracket. If the annual income is
2m but not exceeding 8m, then 30% bracket, and
income tax rate shall be applicable to business or
professional income
Q: How about a mixed income earner?
Income taxation of RC, NRC, RA, NRA-ETB
Income Source of Tax Rate Tax Base
Earner Income Basic conditions to avail of the 8% income tax
rate option:
Compensation Graduated Taxable a. Taxpayer must not be a VAT-registered
Income; income Income person;
tax rates b. The gross sales/receipts and other
income should not exceed P3M;
AND AND AND c. The income is not compensation income
Mixed
Income Benefits of Availing the 8% income tax rate
Earner Business Graduated Taxable option:
Income or income Income a. In lieu of graduated income tax rates;
Professional tax rates and
Income b. In lieu of 3% percentage tax under Sec.
OR OR 116 of the Tax Code
In the case of Mixed Income Earner, he has A. Capital Gains from Sale of Shares of Stock
compensation income and business income. The not Traded in the Stock Exchange
compensation income shall be subjected to - Sales of Shares of Stock, issued by
schedular rates. The schedular rate already has the Domestic Corporation and not listed in the
250,000 deduction, it has 250,000 exemption. Stock Exchange = 15% CGT.
B. Capital Gains from Sale of Real Property
That is why in the business income, there is no - Sale of real property in the Philippines,
longer a 250,000 deduction, otherwise, it will be classified as capital asset = 6% CGT.
doubled. C. Other income, including passive income,
that may be earned by NRA-NETB = 25%
Thus, compensation is always subjected to FWT.
graduated income tax rates and it will never be
subject to 8% optional income tax. The 8% optional
NOTE: Do not forget the Rule on Situes under Sec.,
42.