Unit 5 SD
Unit 5 SD
Unit 5 SD
Step 1: Plot the poles of G(s )H (s) on the s-plane. Then find P.
da enclosing the
Step 2: Perf orm the conformal mapping or find the image of the cont our abc
encirclements of the
righ t-ha lf s-pl ane on the G(s )H(s )-pla ne and then determine the num ber of
- 1 + JO point.
to the left- side of
If the pole s of G(s )H (s) lie at the origin of the s-plane, then they are taken
the s -pla ne by drawing an inde nt ef a of radius, r ➔ 0 ·as shown in the Fig.
6.12.- Then , we find
t (- 1 + JO) point
the num ber of encirclements mad e by the image of the contour abc def a abou
on the G H (s )-plane.
Frequency-Dom•ln An•& •I• 359
-joo
d
Step 3: Determine : Z = P + N.
HZ is z.ero, the close d-loo p syste m is stable.
I Example 6.5
' . ;.
O Solution
s i .
Jm
s:. plane
10
GH(j w) - (jw + l)(jw +2)
10
-
J w2 + l /tan -- 1 w xJ w2 +4 jtan- 1 (I)
=
10 L- tan-• {J) - tan- 1 !
Jw2 + 1 ✓ w2 +4
lim GH(j(!)) = 5&__ (point a')
w➔O
lim GH(j w)
w➔ oo
- 0./-180° (point b')
The net angular variatton from point a' to point ·b' is .-180~. Hence, the GH(j w) locus
can
lie .0nly in two quadrants hav_ing the'an.gu:lat V·ariation from 0° to -180°.
r
I
- 270 lrn GH
G(s)H(s )-plane
- 180° - - -.
a' o Re GH
0
-90°
age o f path b ed :
Section II: To fin d the im
Iim 10
lim G H (R eio)
Then , R ➔ oo
-
R➔ oo (RejO + 1) (RejO + 2)
10
Iim
R ➔ oo RejO x RejO
. 10
I1m
R ➔ oo R2 ej20
. 10
I1m )
R➔ oo R x 1/2(
2
- 0/ 2()
0 /- 1 8 0 ° ➔ 0° ➔
180°
t b' t c' t d'
origin of the G (s )H
(s)-
ane is mappe d to the
ce, th e in finite se m icircle bed on the s-pl of (- 1 + jO ), the angles of the points
Hen ent
w e are in tere sted only in the encirclem
Plane. Since, no . gm'fl cance.
s1
h
· t e G H (s )-
b'' c' and d' m pl ane have
G(s)H(s )-plane
- 2700 Im GH
b' c' d'
---- - -- -~ ---------
/ ;0~o....,Re GH
- 1800
362 CHAPTER :8 · •· Control Sy•t•m•
JmGH
Gf/(,Y )-plane
-180°
-90°
ImGH
-270°
GH(s)-plane
Fig. Ex.&~s
Since, (- 1 .+ jO) point is not encircled -by the plot a' b' c' d' a' in the G H (s )-plane, we have
N=O .
The Nyquist stability criterion is Z = P + N·.
Hence, Z = 0 + 0 = 0.
_ . . }\lyquis~ s~ _1_•~Yen enon, vestigate the closed .. toop stability of a system whose open-toop
vs•~ fURCbOR 15 gtven by1
t,1f1S
O(s)H(s} == . (s + 2)
. (s + l)(s - 1)
o so1ut1on
SteP t: Plotthe poles of G(s)H(s) on the s-plane.
jm
s-plane
'
We find that one pole of G(s )H (s) lies to the right-side of the s-plane. Hence, P = l.
Step 2: To find the image of the contour abeda in the G(s) H (s )-plane and N:
jm
s-plane
. f)
~ - s::;:; limRe 1
R~oo
s=jro---. ..i
s = -j(J)- --+I
-Joo d -
364 CMAPTIR ,6 • Control System•
Then, (jw + 2)
GH( jw) -
(jw + 1) (jw - 1)
J w2 + 4 /tan- 1 (I)
-
J w2 + 1/tan- 1 w J w2 + 1/ 180° - tan- 1 w
- J w2 + 4 /-18 00 + tan-1 (~)
(w2 + 1) - 2
fun G H (j w)
Ct>-+00
= 0 / -90° (point b')
Toe net angular variation from point a' to point b' is -90° - (-180
°) = 90°. Hence, the
GHU w)-lo cus is confined only to the 3rd quadrant where the
angle varies from -180° to -90°.
ImGH
-270°
G(s )H(s )-plane
---
- 1 8 0 ° - d - --. 2
- - - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - - Re GH
b' oo
-90°
Section II: To find the image of path bed.
· Puts = lim Rei8 in G(s) H (s), where 0 changes from +90° ➔ 0°
R➔ oo ➔ 90°.
/ __
-1 80 °- -- ~ _ ReG H
00
-90°
Section III: To find the image of path de.
ect to the real axis.
Path d' e' is the mirror image of the path a' b' with resp
,, ..- - --4- - .... , , _ 2700 · Im GH
/,,, ''
I .
/ \ G(s)H(s)-plane
I \
I \
--- --- -,- 2-·- ---
. - 1 8 0 ° - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - - Re GH
d ~
d
-90°
.
The complete Nyquist plot is as shown in Fig. Ex. 6.6
_,. - ... .... ... -2700 Im GH
,,, ., - ''
,,, G(s )H(s )-plane
I
/ \
I \
I \
I \
- 90°
Fig, Ex,6.6
■ Example 6.7
Investigate the stability of a negative feedback control system whose open-loop transfer function
is given by,
100
G(s)H(s) = (s + l)(s + 2)(s + 3) ·
□ Solution
-3 -2 -1
Since, all the poles of G(s )H (s) lie to the left-side of the s-plane, P = 0. This means that the
' ·· open-loop control system is stable.
.SteJ, 2: To find N-.
SeC;(it)iil~To<fipd the imag~ of path ab.
· :. ».-:lf1· ,S. :::::..
, ··_ .• . ·1
J (i) •
1D .
o·_'<·,S)H. <·) ·
.. . S •
. Ftequenoy-Dom11ln ,_,, .,,.,• . 367
jro
s-ptane
s= - jro --M
I •• f +
\!
. · · . 100
whe re, \GH (jw )\ =
M - · .. . 2. . . ·
✓ w2 +1 ✓ w +4 ✓ w2 +9
• ' ·. l
. • .
{iJ ; , . . ' . . . ' . . ; .
a - L GH (jw ) = -ta n- 1 w - tan - 1 - - tan - 1 -{J)
. • . 2 3
00
fun GH (jw ) - .. l
w--+O
6
f_sr_ (po int a')
lim GH (jw )' _ o/~ 270 ° (po int b')
w--+o o
The net angular cha nge from poi nt a' to poi nt b' is -27 0° - (0°) = - 270 °. Hen
locus lies in the thre e qua dra nts whe re the ce, the G H (j w)
ang le cha nge s from 0° to - 270 °.
lmG H
-2700
G(s) H(s) -pla ne
Puts = lim Rei9 in G(s)H (s), where 0 chang es from +90° ~ 0° ~ -90°.
R ➔ oo
100
Hence, J~moo GH(R eiO) = J!..moo (Rei 0 + 1) (Rei 0 + 2) (Rei 0
100
- limoo R3 el·30
R➔
0/-3 0
0/-27 0° ~ 0° ~ +270 °
t b' t c' t d'
e is mapped onto the
The above analy sis implie s that the infinit e semic ircle bed on the s-plan
of ( -1 + jO) point and
origin of the G H (s )-plan e. Since , we are intere sted in the encirc lemen ts
not on the encirc lemen ts of the origin of the G H (s )-plan e, the angle
s of the points b' , c' and d'
have been left out while perfor ming confo rmal mapp ing.
,, '
I '
I \
J \
\
The complete Nyquist plot is 11s shown in the Fig. Ex. 6.7.
-~100 Ith GH
Fig. Ex.6.7
1efilld M1:
Atr,Jintx ',£. GH(jw )-:-- ft ' :; ~180° .
Hence, - 1an-
1
r,i - 1an-
1
G) - G) = -180'
1an-
1
• 1an- [ l
1
!~] + 1an-
1
G) = 180'
tan ..... 1 [ · 3w ] + tan-1 (w) = 1800
2-w2 3
3w +w]3 = 180°
tan- 1 r-;;;,:
[ 1 3w2 2
- 3{2-w )
-1 [ 9w + w (2 - w2) ] = 1800
tan 3 (2 - w2) - 3w2
9w + w(2 - «>2) =0
Since, w 1f 0, we get
wz == 11
w· Jl1 rad/sec'.
370 CHAPTER 6 • Control Sy,tfm•
Hence, M1 - IGH(jw)lw==JIT
100
- ✓ w2 + 1 ✓ w2 + 4 ✓ w2 + 9 w=JTT
100
-;=:.======~~ > l
✓ 12 X 15 X 20
Since, Mi is greater than 1, the (-1 + j0) point is encircled twice in the clockwise directio
n.
This means, N = 2.
The Nyquist stability criterion is Z = P + N. .
Z=0 +2= 2 .
This means that two roots of the characteristic equation lie to the right-side of the s-plane.
Hence, closed-loop control system is unstable. However, since P = 0, the open-loop
control
system is stable.
■ Example 6.8
5
G(s)H (s) ~ --
1 s(s + 1)
Investigate the closed-loop stability of the system using Nyquist stability criterion.
D Solution -
Step 1: Plot the poles of_G(s)lf (s) on the s-plane.
jm
s-plane
,-1 0
Fig. Ex.e.a
'· . '
. The pole at the origin is taken to the left.. si9e of the s .. p}ane by drawing an indent of zero rad!US
around this pole as shown in Fig. Ex. 6,8(a). Since, the pole at the origin is taken to the left-side
· of the s-plane, P = 0. - ., , .-;, . ·
,:requency..Dom•ln An•ly.,• 371
..,. To find N:
steP ~- ·· .
. 1. To find the image of path ab.
section . '
.im
s-plane
f"ag. Ex.6.8(a) Modified right-si_d.e ~f the s-ptane that takes the pole at the origin to the left-side of
'· · the s-plane.
5
- ·w/90° x ,Jw 2 + 1 /tan-l w
5
- +
w✓w2 1· /90° + tan l w
_ 5 . /-90° - tan- l lv
- w✓w2 +1
lim G H(jw) = oo L-9~o (point a')
~+o
lim GH(Jw) = 0 L-1800 (point b')
·., -~u.
'l'L
e net .· . w➔ .+oo. . . -1 800 ( 900) -
• ta' to point b' 1s - - - -
900 H
. ence, the
l
_Gfl Ucv) ang~l~ van~qon fromdpoJnt 1-.ere the angle varies from -900 to - 1800.
~ ,. . · :OCU:s, hes only 1n the qua ran Wi 1 ·
372 CHAPTER 8 • Conff'OI Sy•,.m•
lmGH
- 270° G(s )H(s )-plane
- - - - ---,+.- : - - - - - -~ReGH
-180° 0 b' o
a'
-90°
Fig. Ex.6.S(b)
Um GH(reltl>) = lim . S.
r➔O r➔O reN> (reJ<I> + l)
I' 5
= ,!!i reJ;
·, I
= ooct ..I.
';=;
00 /CJ0° ➔ 0° ➔ -90°
t e' · t f' · t a'
, ' l ,
Frequenqy-Dom11/n Analysis 373
e' .
,,
I
G(s )H(a )-plane
I
1
'\
+jO~j
-180°---l-= ()---:'?,~~-;-;;,----/'l-- -oo· ReGH
a'
-90 °
N = 0.
Since, -1 + jO point is not encircled by the plot,
Hence, Z= P+ N= 0+ 0= 0
5
Then, lim G H (rejfP) _ lim reJ.,."', (reJ.,."',
r➔O + 1)
r➔ O
5
- lim reJ.,'"', x I
r➔O
- 00 b_
L
00 90
0 ➔ 1so ➔ 210°
0
, z= ) '- 1 =O ·
, :nee, the dosed-loop control syste m unde r investigation
is stable.
0
solu tion . .: : :
. Plot the pole s of G H (s) on the s-plane.
SteP 1• .
jm
s-pla ne
0 1
Fig. Ex.6.9
Tue pole at the origi u is take n to the left- half of the s-pla
ne by mod ifyin g the righ t-sid e of the
s-plane by the contour abc def a as show n in the Fig. Ex.
6.9(a ).
Then, P = l.
Step 2: To find N. jm
Fig. l!x,&.9(a)
376 CHAPTER 8 • Control s,-,.m•
5
- L-270° + tan-• w
w✓w 2 + 1
Jim GH(jw) - oo L-210° (point a')
w➔ +-0
lim GH(jw)
w➔ OO
- o L-1so 0
(point b')
5
Then, lim GH(Rei 8 ) - lim . (
R ➔ oo R➔ oo Rel 0 Rel.0 - 1)
5
- lim .
R➔ oo R2 el 20
- 0 /-20
oI -1 so ➔ 0° ➔ 1so
0 0
. 5
Then, lim G H (re14') = I1m - - -- - -
r➔O r➔ O relt/J (re14' - I)
. 5
- Itm '"'
r..:+o reJ .,, x - 1
- lim
5
.
r➔O r x 1 /i__ L
x 1 180°
. 5
- I1m--:- ----
r➔O r /180° + </J
Frequ•noy•Dom11n An,1y,1, 377
-· -,-_ ..
' " ' ' ', ' . -
> ':
._,_ ., ,,. contplete Nyquist plot is as sh
c . .. . .
. .
t e' t f 1 . t a'
. < -; ___. . . -, -_- own m Fig. Ex. 6.9(b).
~ ' '
lmGH
-270° or+ 900
- .. •
., '
•'\ !.
. :: ·.
G(s)H(s)-plane
r -
\
~ \
\
\
e'
-90° or 270°
Fig. Ex.6.9(b)
· _-' Sin~,{- I + jO) point is encircled once in the clockwise direction, N = +1.
' .
·Hence, Z - P+N
- 1 + 1 = 2.
: . - , .i
' :·. Jl~t~ ,~~e two roots of the characteristic equation lie to the right-half of the s-plane.
, ~~~;~plo sed~loop control system is unstable .
.. ·, . . . •, ,, ,,_ . '
~ s:~ i1o
·.~-~ .~Y~'1·5U!bility criterion, jn\'estigate the closed-loop stability of a negative feedback control
ill,~~~,~.fun::::(::v::::~ s) .
378 CHAPTER 8 • Control Systlms
D Solution
Step 1: Plot the poles of G (s) H (s) on the s-plane.
joJ
s-plane
-----.---J4)(r----► (j
0 1
The pole at the origin is taken to the left-half of the s-plane by modifying the right-half of th
s -plane as shown in Fig. Ex. 6.I0(a). . e
Thus, there is one pole to the right-half of the s-plane and hefce P = 1.
jw
s-plane
-Joo ._d-~
Step 2: To find N.
Section I: To find the image of path ab .
. Putting s = jcv in GH(s), we get
5
GH(Jw) =
jcv(l - jw)
Fffq u.nc y..0om,1n Anltytl• 119
w✓ w 2
1+ 1
1
· m➔
lim+O GH (jw ) /
- 00 -90° (point a')
-I
lim
w➔ +oo GH (jw )· - o/ - 90° -fl-I 90° = 0 /JL (point b')
ImG H
-270° G(s)H(s)-plane
-180°--------:b➔,~ -
- - - - Re GH
00
a'
-90°
5
Hence, lim GH(Rei 8 ) = lim .
R ➔ OO
R➔ oo Rel 8 ( 1 - Re 1.8)
5
- lim 2 1·20
R ➔ oo -R e
5
_ lim .120
R ➔ oo R2 e x- l
5
- i~~ R2 x l /20 x l /-1 80°
_ oL1so 20 0
-
lmGH
-270° G(s)H(s)-plane
a'
-90°
0 [ 180° - 20
Loo ➔ 180° ➔ 360°
0 , t d' tC
t b'
380 CHAPTl:R 8 • Cohtrol Systems
,· ➔ O
5
Then, JimO reJ,p 1 - rel"'
r➔ ·.1. ( '"')
5
- Jim--.
r➔ O rel<P
00 / c/>
00 /+90° ➔ 0° ➔ -90°
t e' t f' ta'
The complete Nyquist plot is as shown in Fig. Ex. 6.1 0(b).
ImGH
-270° or + 90°
e'----
\
\
G(s)H(s)-plane
\
\
l
I
I
-90° or 270°
Fig. Ex.6.1 O(b)
From the Nyquist plot, we find that the (-1 + JO) point is not encircled. Hence,
N = 0.