Grapes Vitis Vinifera Forwriting Ink Making
Grapes Vitis Vinifera Forwriting Ink Making
Grapes Vitis Vinifera Forwriting Ink Making
Naic, Cavite
Gonzales, Jemima
Ligaya, Yani
Lozano, Jherkkios
Madlangbayan, Ramilyn
Regalado, Sherwin
DECEMBER 2020
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
ABSTRACT
The research study entitled "GRAPES (VITIS VINIFERA) FOR WRITING INK
MAKING" aims to determine the effectiveness of grapes as a source of tannins for creating ink
using the experimental method. The research was also conducted to specifically learn the
properties of iron gall ink made from grapes and the quality of the ink in three different
concentrations: 60% concentration, 80% concentration, and 100% concentration. The data
gathered was analyzed using the one-way ANOVA that results in the rejection of the null
hypothesis. Findings from the experiment show that grape is an effective tannin source for iron
gall ink and that the 100% concentration ink is the most acceptable among the three
concentrations.
i
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
APPROVAL SHEET
Approved in partial fulfillment of the requirement for Practical Research 1, by the final
defense panel with a rating of _______
ii
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The researchers would like to thank the people that helped in the success of the study.
Mr. Darniell C. Balbuena, the principal of the school, for his approval and guidance
Mr. Bienvenido Garcia, their research adviser and coordinator, for his guidance, his
continuous support, and his helpful suggestions for the betterment of the study.
Mr. Ronnie Pasigui, Mr. Danilo Cabalu, their research panels, for giving corrections
To their loving parents who have supported them throughout the study, financially and
To their peers who have stood beside them in times of hardships, for their never-
And above all, to our Almighty God, who made things possible. It is Him who
provided wisdom and knowledge to the researchers, who gave them strength to face and
overcome the obstacles that came their way, who gave them the hope to fight the fight until
iii
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
DEDICATION
This research is dedicated to the people who believed in us. Without them, their help,
insights, and support, we would not have been able to accomplish this. Without their never-
ending motivation and encouragement, this study would not have been well.
All of these wouldn’t have been made possible if it weren’t for the people who
iv
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract i
Approval Sheet ii
Acknowledgement iii
Dedication iv
Chapter 1
Introduction 1
Theoretical Framework 3
Conceptual Framework 4
Hypothesis 6
Definition of Terms 7
Chapter 2
Related Literatures 8
Related Studies 13
Chapter 3
Research Design 18
v
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Research Locale 18
Research Process 19
Gathering of Data 21
Statistical Treatment 23
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Summary 31
Conclusion 32
Recommendation 32
Research Output 33
References 34
Appendices 37
vi
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
List of Figures
List of Tables
Table 6: ANOVA 29
vii
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
CHAPTER 1
1.1 Introduction
Iron gall ink was considered to be the most important ink in Western history because it
was the standard ink formulation used in Europe from the fifth century until the beginning of
the twentieth century (Liu et al., 2017). A vast number of famous and important manuscripts
have been written using iron gall ink. It has a high quality of permanence and water resistance
that when it is used, the writing will still be readable even after centuries. However, due to its
corrosive properties and the development of various useful synthetic inks, it was considered a
major threat to the library and archival heritage and was rendered obsolete in the twentieth
Grapes are fruits of the flowering plant genus Vitis. According to Ware (2017), grapes
were first cultivated approximately 8,500 years ago in what is now the Middle East. Its three
primary uses are for fresh table grapes, wine, and dried fruit (raisins).
In this study, the researchers plan to conduct an experimental research to learn the
1
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Ink is a pigmented liquid or paste which is commonly used for writing and drawing
with mediums such as a pen, brush, or quill (Adkins, 2017). It has been used by people
worldwide for millenniums, but the emergence of technology has significantly lessened its use.
People nowadays spend money on expensive high-quality writing inks without knowing the
The iron gall ink was widely used for fourteen centuries and was known for its water-
resistance and permanence until it met its downfall due to its corrosive properties and also the
emergence of modern inks. As stated by Mohamed et.al (2018), its corrosive constituents, the
tannic acid and the iron sulfate which provide the ink’s brownish-black pigment, are
Grapes contain several groups of organic and inorganic compounds which depend on
environmental factors, vineyard management practices, and the variety of grapes. The grape
skins consist of coloring matters such as anthocyanins and tannins (Nayak, 2016). However,
tannins are more abundant in the grape seeds and stem. Anthocyanins, which is a group of
naturally occurring phenolic compounds, are responsible for the color of red grapes. Often,
anthocyanins react with other phytochemicals that lead to the production of relatively stable
colored compounds, thus resulting in the vivid color of red grapes (Harrison, 2018).
Iron gall ink caused loss of text, bleeding, fading, and acid migration. Libraries and
archives around the world have implemented several stabilization methods over the last three
decades to prevent paper degradation by ink corrosion (Mohamed et. al, 2018). Even though
experts partially solved the problem of ink corrosion through microfilming and paper
deacidification, no one tried to use grapes to increase the pH level of the ink itself to prevent
2
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
ink corrosion. The researchers came up with an idea to recreate iron gall ink using grapes at its
tannin source, unlike the traditional oak galls from which the name of the ink was derived.
The main source of pigment in iron gall inks were tannins; it provides the brownish
color to the ink that darkens into black when mixed with iron sulfate. The traditional iron gall
ink uses oak gall or nutgall, and both contain gallic and tannic acid. The researchers have read
an article about the high amount of anthocyanins and tannins in grape seeds, skin, and stem,
and theorized that grapes can be an alternative for oak gall in creating iron gall ink (Harrison,
2018). The researchers assume that the iron gall ink will retain the high-quality property of the
ink.
3
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
3.33.1 Adding
Packing ferrous
the finished
The grapes seeds, skin, and stem must first be removed, then crushed using mortar and
pestle, and then transferred into a pot. A small amount of water will be added to the crushed
4
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
grapes seeds, skin, and stem, then it will be heated to extract the color. After, the solid grape
bits will be filtered from the extracted juice. Ferrous sulfate will be added to the grape juice to
create ferrous tannate. Gum Arabic, which serves as a binding component, will be added to the
mixture to ease the flow of the ink. The ink will be exposed to oxygen for a few hours to
darken the color of the ink. After that, the finished product will be packed.
This study aims to determine the effectivity of grapes as the tannin source of iron gall
Specifically, this research study was conducted to answer the following questions:
1. What are the properties of iron gall ink from grapes as tannins in terms of:
1.1 Color
1.2 Water-Resistance
1.3 Lightfastness
1.4 Permanence
1.5 pH level
3. What is the significant difference between the quality of iron gall ink and the
5
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
1.6 Hypothesis
of the product.
This study covers the idea of red seeded grapes as the tannin source to iron gall ink and
its ability to increase the pH level of the ink. The iron gall ink also uses several ingredients
such as ferrous sulfate, which serves as the mordant, and gum Arabic which serves as a binder
and helps improve the body and flow of the ink. The study is delimited to iron gall ink which is
Community- the study will inform the mass about the iron gall ink and the possibility
of grapes as an effective alternative tannin source for iron gall ink. They will be able to
Researchers- the study will help them know the other uses of grapes and they will be
Future researchers- it will help them have an idea when the topic is related to iron
gall ink and grapes, as it is unusual to use grapes in creating writing ink. The result will
guide and benefit other researchers in acquiring as well as generating an iron gall ink
using grapes.
Businessmen- the product can be manufactured easily and sold at an affordable price
6
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Writers- the product will be useful to the writers because they will be able to write
Students- the product will be useful to students because they will be able to write
Acid hydrolysis- a process in which acid caused by the presence of sulfate groups in
vitriol or additives hydrolyze the glucose molecules of paper, eventually causing the
Ferrous sulfate- it serves as a mordant and color-shifter of the ink. It helps the ink
penetrate the paper and it shifts the color of the ink into a darker color
Grapes- the source of phenolic compounds, tannins, and anthocyanins, which will
produce the color of the ink. The tannins are in the skins, stem, and seeds and the
Gum Arabic- it is used as the binder of components and for viscosity control in the
ink.
Iron gall ink- an ink made from iron salts and tannic acids often from vegetable
sources.
Tannin- organic substances used in ink manufacture. It provides color to the ink and
7
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
CHAPTER 2
This chapter presents the available literature and studies concerning the topic that the
Inks were primarily made from plant dyes before the emergence of synthetic inks.
(Condy, 2017). For hundreds of years, natural products like barks, berries, and leave extracts
are mixed with other substances to make int, dye, or paint. Plants that contain tannins are also
reliable for creating inks. Galls nestled from oak trees were a primary ingredient to form black
ink during the Middle Age. The rich tanning color of flowering plants like dogwood and alder
tee also creates natural inks. However, galls and barks achieve more intense and lasting
Grapes are made up of seeds, skin, and pulp. According to Nayak (2016), grape skins
contains coloring matter, tannins, aromatic substances, potassium, and other minerals. Certain
grapes have seeds that are rich in tannins while others are purely seedless. Venkitasamy et.al
(2019) stated that grape pomace, which consists of the remaining skin, seeds, and stalks, is a
rich source of phenolics and antioxidants. Some antioxidants have been studied primarily for
use in archival conservation; they have the potential to affect positive charge in corrosion
caused not only by iron ions but also by other transition metal catalysts. A commonplace book
8
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
from the late 17th century included pomegranate rind in its recipe for iron gall ink. Interestingly,
pomegranates have antioxidant properties and it has been suggested that its addition to ink
Iron gall ink was not used solely for writing. Several well-known artists used it to
make exquisite drawings, including Van Gogh and Victor Hugo. Some authors believe that
artists of the Early Renaissance were already using the ink though the first specific mention of
drawing with iron gall ink was made in the late 17th century. But due to its inherent corrosive
action on paper and parchment, the iron gall ink has become a serious threat and a challenge
for many institutions around the world. In the last 25 years, a great deal of research has been
done for treating the materials corroded by iron gall ink. And it was in the 1990s that a
successful treatment using phytic acid was developed in the Netherlands. However, the
treatment of iron gall ink remains controversial and research to further understand its molecular
and elemental composition and its possible treatment is still ongoing. Most studies conclude
that the most probable cause of ink corrosion is the excessive presence of sulfate groups within
the composition of the ink. Yet, the contribution of other ingredients should not be neglected.
The gallic acid and tannic acid has a role in acid hydrolysis, because they, along with sulfuric
acid, hydrolyze the glucose molecules of paper, eventually causing physical degradation of
cellulose. Many attempts have been done to treat acid hydrolysis in old texts using an aqueous
technique which was proved unsuccessful. The use of alternative treatments for iron gall ink
corrosion is undermined by the lack of factual data on the consequences of treating the
corroded materials. However, it is suggested that the inherent alkaline nature of parchment and
the presence of alkaline fillers in paper play a significant role in slowing down the degradation
9
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Traditionally, iron gall ink is made from four ingredients: gall nuts as the source of
tannins, iron sulfate for the source of iron, water as the solvent, and gum Arabic as the binder.
Tannins are complex organic molecules, which are also known as polyphenols, that can be
extracted from different parts of plants. Since the early times, it has been used for tanning of
leather and dyeing of textiles. Traditionally, classifying tannins is through observing what color
is obtained after iron salts are added, whether is it blue-black or green-brown. ‘Iron-blueing’ or
hydrolyzable tannins contain large amounts of gallotannins which will create gallic acid
through acid hydrolysis. It is the reaction of gallic acid with iron sulfate that creates the ferrous
gallotannate which is responsible for the dark, grayish, or black color of the ink. ‘Iron-
greening’ or condensed tannins polymerize and oxidize through acid hydrolysis to create
brown or green compounds in combination with iron salts. Iron sulfate or ferrous sulfate is a
metal salt that has been historically used as a mordant for textile and leather dying. When it is
combined with gallic acid, it will form a brown soluble complex. Iron sulfate makes the ink
able to penetrate paper, which is why its excessive presence could lead to higher chances of
paper degradation. However, when it is mixed with a sufficient amount of gum Arabic, there is
a tendency that the iron sulfate’s negative effect on the paper will be significantly lessened.
Gum Arabic, which is also referred to as acacia gum, is a natural, water-soluble gum made
from the hardened sap of the acacia tree. It has been used for hundreds of years as a binder in
inks and paints, as well as a varnish for watercolors, to control viscosity, to add luminosity, to
reduce feathering and bleeding, and to prevent the cracking of the ink. Gum Arabic binds the
pigments to the paper so that the pigments would not wipe away after the ink is dry. To know if
there is enough gum Arabic in an ink, it must be tested. If it smears in any way, there is a lack
10
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
A freshly applied iron gall ink reacts with atmospheric oxygen, causing the color of the
ink to develop and become significantly darker. This reaction can also occur while the ink is in
the container before it is used. It is suggested that iron gall ink’s permanence is enhanced by
applying it before it is oxidized. The logic is that if the oxidation process occurs when the ink
has already sunk into the fibers of the support, the iron-tannate complex will be deposited
within the paper fibers. If the oxidation occurs in the container of the ink, it will lead to the
formation of a precipitate of the fine black pigment particles. The precipitate risks diminishing
the ink’s writing properties and tends to sit more on the surface of the fibers instead of sinking
in. Several iron gall ink recipes advised to let the ink rest before use. A commonplace book
from the 16th or 17th century advised letting the ink sit for fourteen days after the addition of
Grapes are abundant in the Philippines. There is a wide variety of grapes that are
grown here in the Philippines. Large grape plantations can be found in Cebu, Ilocos Region,
South Cotabato, Zamboanga, and other regions in the Visayas and Mindanao, but it is in La
Union that they have been cultivating grapes since the 1950s. There are several varieties that
can be grown in the Philippines since grapes like loose, deep soil with a pH level lower than 5.
Harvest is done three times a year- September, December, and during the summer as well. In
the first year, a hectare of land planted with grapes can produce 1,700 kilograms per tree. In the
third and fourth years, approximately 10,000 kilograms per tree can be harvested. Grapes are
said to be most productive from their third to the eighth year. Varieties that were proven to
11
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
adapt to the local condition of the Philippines are the Cardinal, White Malaga, Ribier, and the
The Philippine forests inhabit a large number of extractives producing plants and these
have been sources of important livelihood opportunities from people in areas where these
species are abundant. Gums, oils, resins, and other extractives are among the many products
from the forest that are considered to have commercial importance and have a wide range of
potential uses for industrial chemicals, bio-chemicals, and pharmaceuticals. Plant gums are
solids that are either water-soluble or absorbs water. The wide variety of gums with
commercial importance include gum Arabic, karaya gum, ghatti gum, and tragacanth gum. In
the Philippines, there are a few plant species producing gums such as narra, acacia, and ipil-ipil.
The bark is an abundant source of gums and resins used as gum Arabic for binding components.
Other extractives such as dyes, tannins, and latex can also be sourced from different parts of
plants and trees that can be found in the Philippines. Tannins are water-extractable materials
from certain plants and in the Philippines, those forest plants growing in mangroves are the
About 25 million people live in the uplands of the Philippines, most of whom depend
on the forest for their livelihood. However, their incomes from timber and crop trading are
limited. The valorization of disregarded biomasses such as bark, twigs, roots, shells, and fruit
husks as a source of condensed tannins is a preferable option for the improvement of their
12
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
The potential of black grapes as ink is the anthocyanins in its content (“Making Grape
as An Ink”, 2016). White grapes are green in color, and they are evolutionarily derived from
the purple grape. The mutation in two regulatory genes of white grapes turned off the
production of anthocyanins which are responsible for the pigment of grapes. Even though
grapes are costly, it is harmless compared to commercially produced inks that have dangerous
chemicals. Black grapes are less costly when it comes to health compared to commercially
produced ink since one requires medical attention once they swallowed ink. The investigatory
project has led to the production of ink that has a thick consistency and consistent color which
is good for the usage of ink. The researcher’s observations prove that adding vinegar to the
mixture made it consistent and darker. The color of the black grape ink in the paper turned into
“Ink Out of Teabags” (2013) uses the tea plant (Camellia sinensis) to create a viable
permanent ink. The method of extraction of leaves used is the brewing method. The theoretical
framework of the study is that the chlorophyll, anthocyanins, and other pigments in the leaves
will serve as the colorant of the ink, showing a brown ink color. The brown color of the leaves
A study conducted by Singh et. al (2017) about the ink formulation from natural
colorants promotes the use of anthocyanin-based inks and aqueous extraction. It is stated that
though synthetic inks have long-lasting color and are available at a low cost, it also has a few
disadvantages, like health problems and environmental issues, and these disadvantages boost
13
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
the amount of research about natural ink. Natural inks are considered eco-friendly because they
are derived from natural resources such as plants leaves, roots, fruits, and mineral sources. In
their study, an attempt was made to generate water-based ink with a simple aqueous method
using Jamun. The aqueous extraction is a traditional method for extracting color from natural
resources. In this method, the compound containing the pigment is made into smaller pieces
and boiled in water to get the coloring component dissolved in the water. The major difference
that natural inks have from synthetic inks is that its colorants, resins, solvents, and additives are
natural and/or does not cause any harm. The objective of their research was to prepare inks
from natural colorants by aqueous extraction method which is safe to human health and free
from volatile organic compounds (VOC) emissions and to provide safe and good quality ink
for printings. The research resulted in the production of inks that were deemed effective, easy
to apply, and was stable during printing, although the inks needed proper preservation and
storage.
made use of berries for natural ink making. Two cups of berries were crushed using a potato
masher and a half cup of water was added. The large pieces were filtered after and kept in a
glass with a tight-fitting lid. A binder was not added to the mixture since the ink was going to
be used as a watercolor, thus resulting in a thin ink that took a few layers to darken.
Ingredient in Making Ink” conducted by Sese and her fellow researchers in 2014 focused on
producing ink made from materials that are abundant and provides quality ink. The research
14
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
aims to contribute to the development of the science of ink making through creating an ink
from a natural source that people deem to have no other purpose; the researchers believe that
the product has the potential to be widely used by students, faculty members, and office
workers. The Alugbati fruit is always neglected and thrown away because people do not find
any purpose for the said fruit and only the leaves were sold in markets. For this reason, they
came up with a study about making ink out of Alugbati fruit to discover and prove that there
can be a new use for it. The research resulted in an ink that has good color and viscosity, thus
proving that their hypothesis that Malabar Nightshade’s fruit can be used as the main
ingredient in making ink is correct. But some improvements were recommended regarding the
findings that the color of the ink turns brown after 4-5 days.
Another experimental research titled “Plant Extracts as an Alternative Ink for Markers”
(2015) conducted by Grade 9 students in St. Mary’s Academy of Talisayan, Misamis Oriental
uses natural sources for creating marker ink, specifically Mayana (Coleus blumei) and Alugbati
(basella alba; Malabar spinach) extracts. The pigment was extracted through the boiling
method and therefore the produced ink was dye-based. On the first try, the inks were too pale
due to excess water and little amount of mayana leaves and alugbati leaves. On the second try,
the research was deemed successful. The consistency of the inks lasted like standard inks. The
odor of the ink was identical to how the herbal leaves smelled and the absorption of the ink
depends on the amount of the water mixed with the leaves and fruits. The consistency of the
ink differs from the surface it was applied to. The mayana leaves created a dark violet marker
ink while the alugbati leaves created a brownish-yellow ink. They concluded that to create ink
from plants, there must be a balance between the amount of water and the source. (Talines et.al,
2015)
15
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
(Pterocarpus indicus) bark extract as an ingredient for permanent marker ink. Typically, the
inks used in most markers are made from synthetic materials such as petroleum and chemical
solvents. Such materials are hazardous especially to the health of the users and to the
environment as well. As been made into dyes, their hypothesis states that Narra can be an
alternative ingredient for ink instead of petroleum. Inks with alternative organic ingredients is a
growing demand among artists, calligraphers, and people. The research makes use of ferrous
sulfate as a compound responsible for the black coloration of the ink and a disinfectant that will
inhibit the growth of microorganisms. The Narra bark extract was obtained by pounding the
bark and mixing it with Benzalkonium chloride, which prevents the ink from solidifying and
molding and helps in reducing the surface tension of the ink solution, allowing the ink to
penetrate quickly into the paper fibers. Glycerol and ferrous sulfate were added to the mixture
as well. Glycerol was used because of its viscous nature and high absorbency on paper, as well
as its ability to increase the rate of extraction of tannin in the pigment. The formulated ink was
transferred to glass bottles and was left undisturbed for a full 24 hours before undergoing a
series of tests. The result of the experiment was a waterproof Narra ink which according to
their survey is averagely acceptable in terms of color and odor but not in absorption and rate of
evaporation. When the researchers conducted a waterproof test, the ink had some halo but there
was little change in color, thus the letters are still clear and dark. (Antioquia, 2013)
“The Potential of Tannin Found in Avocado Seeds as Ink” (2014). Their research
focuses on searching for a cheaper and safer alternative for the traditional commercial ink by
replacing the main components of synthetic inks, which are toxic and harmful substances, with
organic compounds. Their research promotes the creation of tannin-based ink which is
16
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
economic friendly and high-quality ink; to introduce new ways to produce ink, and to find
ways to fully utilize the use of avocado seeds by using it as a major component in ink making.
According to their study, avocado seeds are a viable source for ink making since they contain
13% tannins which are responsible for the reddish appearance of the avocado seed when
exposed to air. They found out that the avocado seed produces a milky fluid that acts as the ink
when exposed to air. They hypothesize that tannin found in avocado seeds as the primary
ingredients of ink would enable them to create a cheaper ink. The seeds were pounded and
boiled with a specific amount of vinegar, alcohol, and agar. The result of the research is an ink
with a powdered avocado seed scent and an appearance that resembles that of a soy sauce.
An investigatory project in 2013 made use of tea (Camilla sinensis) to create ink for
printing. Tea extract usually appears in brown colors due to the chlorophylls and other
pigments present in tea leaves. The objective of their project is to create a cost-effective printer
ink and to produce an alternative printing ink from tea, as printing tea has become more
expensive through the years. Their ink is made up of tea extract, vinegar, which can strengthen
the color of the ink, and cornstarch, which effectively contributes to achieving the right
consistency of the ink. The project resulted in the production of a viable brown ink. (Bulusan et.
al, 2013)
17
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
CHAPTER 3
Methodology
This chapter describes and discusses how the researchers gathered data and
information that will be used in the entire study. It describes the focus of this study. This also
shows the procedure of the data collection. This chapter also discusses the research design,
research method, and the research locale where the study will be conducted.
This study uses an experimental research method to know the effectiveness of grapes
in making iron gall ink. It will test its permanence to know if it can be used as an ink for
researcher wishes to trace cause and effect relationships between defined variables. However,
there are major constraints on causal inference in experimental research, and the chosen type of
experimental design has a significant influence on the inferences that can be validly drawn
from the results of the experiment. Within the information field, experimental designs are
much more common in information systems research than in library and information
management research.
The research will be conducted within the researcher’s house in Barangay San Miguel
Cavite, Philippines. It is 54 kilometers (33.6 mi) south of Metro Manila and lies in the western
part of the province of Cavite. Maragondon is an upland town situated along the foothills of the
18
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
mountain ranges bordering the provinces of Cavite and Batangas and is bounded to the north
by Naic and Indang, to the south by Nasugbu, Batangas, to the west by Ternate, to the east by
approximately at 120° 44’ east longitude 120° and 140° 10.6 minute north latitude. Per the
2015 census, it has a population of 37,720 people in an expanse of 164.61 square kilometers
3.3.1 Ingredients
1. 2 kilograms grapes
19
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
4. 60mL Water
3.3.2 Equipment
3.3.3 Method
Water
Ferrous The grape seeds, skin, and Iron gall ink
t
stem will be heated for color
Sulphate
Ferrous Sulphate Using grapes
extraction, and then filtered,
Gum
Gum Arabic
Arabic leaving only the juice.
Using the materials needed, the grapes seeds, skin, and stem must first be removed,
then crushed using mortar and pestle, and then transferred into a pot. A small amount of water
will be added to the crushed grapes seeds, skin, and stem, then it will be heated to extract the
color. After, the solid grape bits will be filtered from the extracted juice. Ferrous sulfate will be
added to the grape juice to create ferrous tannate. Gum Arabic will be added to the mixture to
20
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
bind the structure of the ink and to lessen the precipitates created by the insoluble condensed
tannins. After mixing all the ingredients, the ink will be exposed to oxygen for a few hours to
darken the color of the ink. After that, the finished product will be transferred to an amber glass
jar.
The researchers will be doing an experiment of making an iron gall ink out of grapes.
They will be mixing all the materials written above by using the equipment for the iron gall ink.
In that way, they will have their ink and they will be able to know if grapes are effective as a
source of tannins. After finally having the finished product of the study, the researcher will try
to use the iron gall ink and observe the color after oxidation. The ink will also undergo three
days of observation for permanence, three hours of sunlight exposure for lightfastness, and the
water-resistance test. The researchers will prepare three different concentrations of ink, 60%
volume, 80% volume, and 100% volume. The researchers will record the qualities of the ink
Rating Scale:
Color:
21
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Water-Resistance:
Lighfastness:
Permanence:
22
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
To effectively interpret the data, the researchers will employ the following statistical
treatment.
���
� = ���
F = Anova Coefficient
���
MSE = �−�
SSE = (� − �)��
23
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
CHAPTER 4
In this chapter, all the data gathered from the experimentation were presented and
interpreted in detail followed by the discussion of the research findings. The writing ink was
made with grapes, water, ferrous sulfate, and gum Arabic. It aims to provide a more suitable
4.1.1 Properties
Table 1.
QUALITIES CHARACTERISTICS
24
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
observation, it is determined that the color of the ink is dark brown. To test the
lightfastness of the ink, it is applied to a paper and the paper is exposed to sunlight
for three to four hours. A before and after comparison was made and it is observed
that the ink slightly fades after hours of exposure. To test the water-resistance, the
ink is applied to a paper and the paper is soaked with water. Upon drying of the
paper, it is observed that the ink fades into a green-brown color upon contact with
water. For permanence, the ink was applied to a paper and observed for four days.
Throughout the observation, the ink has produced slight brown halos. To test the
pH level of the ink, a pH tester strip was dipped in it, and the strip turned into a red-
Table 2.
QUALITIES CHARACTERISTICS
Color Brownish-black
25
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
observation, it is determined that the color of the ink is brownish-black. To test the
lightfastness of the ink, it is applied to a paper and the paper is exposed to sunlight
for three to four hours. A before and after comparison was made and it is observed
that there is little to no change in the ink after hours of exposure. To test the water-
resistance, the ink is applied to a paper and the paper is soaked in water. Upon
drying of the paper, it is observed that the ink fades into a brownish color and
produces brown halos after being soaked. For permanence, the ink was applied to a
paper and observed for four days. Throughout the observation, the ink had little to
no change. To test the pH level of the ink, a pH tester strip was dipped in it, and the
Table 3.
QUALITIES CHARACTERISTICS
Color Black
26
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
observation, it is determined that the color of the ink is black. To test the
lightfastness of the ink, it is applied to a paper and the paper is exposed to sunlight
for three to four hours. A before and after comparison was made and it is observed
that there is little to no change in the ink after hours of exposure. To test the water-
resistance, the ink is applied to a paper and the paper is soaked in water. Upon
drying of the paper, it is observed that the ink produces brown halos after being
soaked in water. However, it still does not smudge when touched. For permanence,
the ink was applied to a paper and observed for four days. Throughout the
observation, the ink had produced slight brown halos. To test the pH level of the ink,
a pH tester strip was dipped in it, and the strip turned into a red-orange color which
Table 4.
This table shows the percentage by volume of grape juice in different concentrations.
27
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
A. Level of the effectiveness of grapes as an alternative tannin source for iron gall
ink.
alternative source of tannin for iron gall ink. The level of acceptability is based on the
The results below show the degree of effectiveness in terms of color, water-
Table 5 shows the rating on the quality of the ink based on the observations of
the researchers. For the 60% concentration, its color was rated 3 (acceptable), its water-
meaning that its overall quality is acceptable. For the 80% concentration, its color was
5 (most acceptable), and its permanence is 5 (most acceptable). The 80% concentration
28
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
has a mean total rating of 4.25, meaning that its overall quality is acceptable to
moderately acceptable. For the 100% concentration, its color was rated 5 (most
has a mean total rating of 4.5, meaning that its overall quality is moderately acceptable
to most acceptable.
B. Difference between the quality of iron gall ink and the concentration of the
solution
One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to assess whether there was no
significant difference between the quality of iron gall ink and the concentration of the
solution: 60%, 80%, and 100%. The results are shown in Table 6.
Table 6.
Source
SS df MS F P-value F crit
of Variation
Between
5.17 2 2.58 4.043478 0.055856
Groups
Within
5.75 9 0.64
Groups
29
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Based on Table 6, the p-value is 0.055856 which is greater than the level of
significance 0.05. The F value is less than the F critical value which is 4.26, then the null
hypothesis of the three groups of inks that do not differ in terms of properties will be accepted.
30
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Chapter 5
5.1 Summary
The study was conducted from November 2019 to November 2020 to determine the
effectiveness of grapes as an alternative tannin source for iron gall ink. Specifically, the study
iron gall ink using grapes as its main source for tannins in different concentrations: 60%, 80%,
and 100%. It is also to determine whether using grapes for making iron gall ink lessens the
The researchers developed grapes as an alternative source of tannins for iron gall ink to
be beneficial not only to students and writers but also to the community. The experiment was
Findings from the experiment show that the level of effectiveness of grape as tannin
source for iron gall ink in different concentrations was found effective to be used for creating
writing ink. The study also shows that there was no significant difference in the level of
effectiveness between the writing ink in 100% concentration, 80% concentration, and 60%
level, the ink with 100% concentration is the most acceptable among the three concentrations.
31
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
5.2 Conclusion
The research study has met almost all of its objectives. The study found out that grapes
can be an alternative source of tannin for iron gall ink. All concentrations of the grape writing
ink are effective. Also, the study found out that the ink retains its permanence and lightfastness,
specifically the 80% and 100% concentration. In regards, the research accepts the null
hypothesis that there is no significant difference in the quality of the iron gall ink and the
5.3 Recommendation
Despite having proven the hypothesis, this study can still be improved by having the
ink tested by the Department of Science and Technology (DOST) to identify whether the ink
has harmful chemicals in its composition. It is also recommended for future researchers to
study the effects of anthocyanins on the color of the ink and how it interacts with iron sulfate.
Finally, the researchers want to recommend this study to future researchers to have some
improvements and testings to the existing product for it to become more effective. The given
data from this study will help them to easily conduct their study.
32
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
OUTPUT: Procedure
Grape iron ink
Summary of Findings,
Conclusions, and
Recommendations
33
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
References
Liu, Y., Kralj Cigić, I., & Strlič, M. (2017). Kinetics of accelerated degradation of historic iron
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymdegradstab.2017.07.010
Díaz Hidalgo, R. J., Córdoba, R., Nabais, P., Silva, V., Melo, M. J., Pina, F., Teixeira, N., &
Freitas, V. (2018). New insights into iron-gall inks through the use of historically accurate
Ware M. (2017, Nov 15). Grapes: Health benefits, tips, and risks. Medical News Today.
Mohamed, W. A., Abdel-Rahman, A. M., Ali Hassan, R. R., & Hegazy, A. K. (2018). A NEW
Nayak, S. (2016). Medicinal significance of grape variety cabernet sauvignon and Vitis
Harrison, R. (2018). Practical interventions that influence the sensory attributes of red wines
34
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Venkitasamy, C., Zhao, L., Zhang, R., & Pan, Z. (2019). Grapes. In Integrated Processing
Technologies for Food and Agricultural By-Products (pp. 133-163). Academic Press.
in-the-Philippines
d/gums-resins-oil-and-other-exudates
Making Grape as an ink. (2016, Jul 21). Retrieved September 22, 2020, from
https://newyorkessays.com/essay-making-grape-as-an-ink/
https://www.studymode.com/essays/Ink-Out-Of-Teabags-46026204.html)
35
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Singh, N., & Sharma, V. DETAIL STUDY OF INK FORMULATION FROM NATURAL
COLOURANTS.
Erbe, M. M. (2020). Sustainable Stationery (Doctoral dissertation, The Ohio State University).
Talines et. al, 2015. Plant Extracts as an Alternative Ink for Markers.
Extract_as_an_Alternative_ Ink_for_Markers
Espanola et.al, 2014, The Potential of Tannin Found In Avocado Seeds as Ink
seeds-as-ink/
Bulusan et. al, 2013, Printer Ink made from Camellis Sinensis (tea)
Project?fbclid=IwAR1vLn4Zop70StQGRa91HNNbndDpR-
5PECdbx99vsGs6bOOUb9aopDu0YRU
Publishing
36
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
APPENDICES
37
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Appendix: Table
38
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
Equipment
Appendix Figure 5. Mortar and Pestle Appendix Figure 6. Electronic Weighing Scale
Appendix Figure 9. Amber Glass Bottle Appendix Figure 10. pH Tester Strips
39
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
40
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
1.8 Weight: 75 kg
41
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
42
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
43
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
44
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
45
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
46
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
47
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
48
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
1.8 Weight: 38 kg
49
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
50
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
1.8 Weight: 71 kg
51
Western Colleges, Inc.
High School Department
Naic, Cavite
52