Chapter 6
Chapter 6
Valuation of Securities
Instructor’s Resources
Overview
This chapter begins with a thorough discussion of interest rates, yield curves, and their relationship to required
returns. Features of the major types of bond issues are presented along with their legal issues, risk characteristics,
and indenture convents. The chapter then introduces students to the important concept of valuation and
demonstrates the impact of cash flows, timing, and risk on value. It explains models for valuing bonds and the
calculation of yield-to-maturity using either an approximate yield formula or calculator. Students learn how
interest rates may affect their ability to borrow and expand business operations or assets under personal control.
The U.S. Treasury would face many of the same considerations as those faced by a company that is considering
revision of its average debt maturity. Short-term rates are normally lower, reducing total financing costs.
However, if the U.S. Treasury relies on short-term rates and short-term rates rise, the cost of financing the
federal debt could end up being higher. Even more serious is the risk that the U.S. Treasury may not be able to
find buyers of new Treasury bills when old Treasury bills mature. According to market segmentation theory,
there is a limited amount of demand for short-term securities. Excessive short-term demand might push up the
cost of seasonal business loans higher, hindering business and tax revenues.
Another concern that the U.S. Treasury would have to face is whether the financing adjustment would diminish
the high regard with which Treasury bills are held. Currently, Treasury bills are as close as we can get to a risk-
free rate in the real world. If the amount of short-term financing becomes excessive, the ability of the federal
government to make good on its short-term repayment promises may come into question, no longer make it a
“risk-free” surrogate, and increase Treasury bill rates.
b. The average maturity of outstanding U.S. Treasury debt is a little more than 5 years. Suppose a newly
issued 5-year Treasury note has a coupon rate of 2 percent and sells for par. What happens to the value
of this bond if the inflation rate rises 1 percentage point, causing the yield-to-maturity on the 5-year note
to jump to 3 percent shortly after it is issued?
Debt priced at par provides a coupon payment sufficient to pay the required rate of return. Hence, if the
required rate of return is 2 percent, it must be paying $20 annually. If the discount rate increases, the coupon
payment is no longer sufficient. Hence, the price would drop to create a one percent capital gain per year,
leading up to $1,000 at maturity. The price would be
c. Assume that the “average” Treasury security outstanding has the features described in part b. If total
U.S. debt is $16 trillion and an increase in inflation causes yields on Treasury securities to increase by 1
percentage point, by how much would the market value of outstanding debt fall? What does this suggest
about the incentives of government policy makers to pursue policies that could lead to higher inflation?
Based on the information provided in the Opener, a few calculations can lead us to an approximation for this
complex and complicated question. We are informed that $360 billion is the 2012 interest expense and that the
national debt was about $15.8 trillion in 2012 (i.e., $16.8 trillion less, more than $1 trillion accrued in 2012).
Division of the interest payment by the total debt results in an interest rate of 2.28 percent (i.e., $360 billion
$15.8 trillion). Assuming the Treasuries are priced at par, one ends up with $22.80 per thousand being the
annual payment needed to result in Treasuries being priced at par.
If interest rates rise by 1 percent to 3.28 percent, the price of the federal debt would fall to $954.57, as
computed below.
2. The term structure of interest rates is the relationship of the rate of return to the time to maturity for any class
of similar-risk securities. The graphic presentation of this relationship is the yield curve.
3. For a given class of securities, the slope of the curve reflects an expectation about the movement of interest
rates over time. The most commonly used class of securities is U.S. Treasury securities.
a. Downward sloping: Long-term borrowing costs are lower than short-term borrowing costs.
b. Upward sloping: Short-term borrowing costs are lower than long-term borrowing costs.
c. Flat: Borrowing costs are relatively similar for short- and long-term loans.
The upward-sloping yield curve has been the most prevalent historically.
4. a. According to the expectations theory, the yield curve reflects investor expectations about future interest
rates, with the differences based on inflation expectations. The curve can take any of the three forms. An
upward-sloping curve is the result of increasing inflationary expectations, and vice versa.
b. The liquidity preference theory is an explanation for the upward-sloping yield curve. This theory states
that long-term rates are generally higher than short-term rates due to the desire of investors for greater
liquidity, and thus a premium must be offered to attract adequate long-term investment.
c. The market segmentation theory is another theory that can explain any of the three curve shapes. Because
the market for loans can be segmented based on maturity, sources of supply and demand for loans within
each segment determine the prevailing interest rate. If supply is greater than demand for short-term funds at
a time when demand for long-term loans is higher than the supply of funding, the yield curve would be
upward sloping. Obviously, the reverse also holds true.
5. In the Fisher equation, r r* IP RP, the risk premium, RP, consists of the following issuer- and issue-
related components:
Default risk: The possibility that the issuer will not pay the contractual interest or principal as scheduled.
Maturity (interest rate) risk: The possibility that changes in the interest rates on similar securities will cause
the value of the security to change by a greater amount the longer its maturity, and vice versa.
Liquidity risk: The ease with which securities can be converted to cash without a loss in value.
Contractual provisions: Covenants included in a debt agreement or stock issue defining the rights and
restrictions of the issuer and the purchaser. These can increase or reduce the risk of a security.
Tax risk: Certain securities issued by agencies of state and local governments are exempt from federal, and
in some cases state and local taxes, thereby reducing the nominal rate of interest by an amount that brings
the return into line with the after-tax return on a taxable issue of similar risk.
The risks that are debt specific are default, maturity, and contractual provisions.
6. Most corporate bonds are issued in denominations of $1,000 with maturities of 10 to 30 years. The stated
interest rate on a bond represents the percentage of the bond’s par value that will be paid out annually,
although the actual payments may be divided up and made quarterly or semiannually.
Both bond indentures and trustees are means of protecting the bondholders. The bond indenture is a complex
and lengthy legal document stating the conditions under which a bond is issued. The trustee may be a paid
individual, corporation, or commercial bank trust department that acts as a third-party “watch dog” on behalf
of the bondholders to ensure that the issuer does not default on its contractual commitment to the
bondholders.
7. Long-term lenders include restrictive covenants in loan agreements in order to place certain operating and/or
financial constraints on the borrower. These constraints are intended to assure the lender that the borrowing
firm will maintain a specified financial condition and managerial structure during the term of the loan.
Because the lender is committing funds for a long period of time, he seeks to protect himself against adverse
financial developments that may affect the borrower. The restrictive provisions (also called negative
covenants) differ from the so-called standard debt provisions in that they place certain constraints on the
firm’s operations, whereas the standard provisions (also called affirmative covenants) require the firm to
operate in a respectable and businesslike manner. Standard provisions include such requirements as providing
audited financial statements on a regular schedule, paying taxes and liabilities when due, maintaining all
facilities in good working order, and keeping accounting records in accordance with generally accepted
accounting procedures (GAAP).
Violation of any of the standard or restrictive loan provisions gives the lender the right to demand immediate
repayment of both accrued interest and principal of the loan. However, the lender does not normally demand
immediate repayment but instead evaluates the situation in order to determine if the violation is serious
enough to jeopardize the loan. The lender’s options are: Waive the violation, waive the violation and
renegotiate terms of the original agreement, or demand repayment.
8. Short-term borrowing is normally less expensive than long-term borrowing due to the greater uncertainty
associated with longer maturity loans. The major factors affecting the cost of long-term debt (or the interest rate),
in addition to loan maturity, are loan size, borrower risk, and the basic cost of money.
9. If a bond has a conversion feature, the bondholders have the option of converting the bond into a certain
number of shares of stock within a certain period of time. A call feature gives the issuer the opportunity to
repurchase, or call, bonds at a stated price prior to maturity. It provides extra compensation to bondholders for
the potential opportunity losses that would result if the bond were called due to declining interest rates. This
feature allows the issuer to retire outstanding debt prior to maturity and, in the case of convertibles, to force
conversion. Stock purchase warrants, which are sometimes included as part of a bond issue, give the holder
the right to purchase a certain number of shares of common stock at a specified price.
10. Current yields are calculated by dividing the annual interest payment by the current price. Bonds are quoted
in percentage of par terms, to the thousandths place. Hence, corporate bond prices are effectively quoted in
dollars and cents. A quote of 98.621 means the bond is priced at 98.621 percent of par, or $986.21.
Bonds are rated by independent rating agencies such as Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s with respect to their
overall quality, as measured by the safety of repayment of principal and interest. Ratings are the result of
detailed financial ratio and cash flow analyses of the issuing firm. The bond rating affects the rate of return on
the bond. The higher the rating, the lower the risk and the lower the yield.
11. Eurobonds are bonds issued by an international borrower and sold to investors in countries with currencies
other than that in which the bond is denominated. For example, a dollar-denominated Eurobond issued by an
American corporation can be sold to French, German, Swiss, or Japanese investors. A foreign bond, on the
other hand, is issued by a foreign borrower in a host country’s capital market and denominated in the host
currency. An example is a pound-denominated bond issued in Great Britain by a French company.
12. A financial manager must understand the valuation process in order to judge the value of benefits received
from stocks, bonds, and other assets in view of their risk, return, and combined impact on share value.
14. The valuation process applies to assets that provide an intermittent cash flow or even a single cash flow over
any time period.
15. The value of any asset is the PV of future cash flows expected from the asset over the relevant time period.
The three key inputs in the valuation process are cash flows, the required rate of return, and the timing of cash
flows. The equation for value is:
where:
V0 value of the asset at time zero
CFt cash flow expected at the end of year t
r appropriate required return (discount rate)
n relevant time period
16. The basic bond valuation equation for a bond that pays annual interest is:
where:
V0 value of a bond that pays annual interest
I interest
n years to maturity
M dollar par value
rd required return on the bond
To find the value of bonds paying interest semiannually, the basic bond valuation equation is adjusted as
follows to account for the more frequent payment of interest:
a. The annual interest must be converted to semiannual interest by dividing by two.
b. The number of years to maturity must be multiplied by two.
c. The required return must be converted to a semiannual rate by dividing it by two.
17. A bond sells at a discount when the required return exceeds the coupon rate. A bond sells at a premium when
the required return is less than the coupon rate. A bond sells at par value when the required return equals the
coupon rate. The coupon rate is generally a fixed rate of interest, whereas the required return fluctuates with
shifts in the cost of long-term funds due to economic conditions and/or risk of the issuing firm. The disparity
between the required rate and the coupon rate will cause the bond to be sold at a discount or premium.
18. If the required return on a bond is constant until maturity and different from the coupon interest rate, the
bond’s value approaches its $1,000 par value as the time to maturity declines.
19. To protect against the impact of rising interest rates, a risk-averse investor would prefer bonds with short
periods until maturity. The responsiveness of the bond’s market value to interest rate fluctuations is an
increasing function of the time to maturity.
20. The yield-to-maturity (YTM) on a bond is the rate investors earn if they buy the bond at a specific price and
hold it until maturity. The YTM can be found precisely by using a hand-held financial calculator and using
the time value functions. Enter the B0 as the PV, and the I as the annual payment, and the N as the number of
periods until maturity. Have the calculator solve for the interest rate. This interest value is the YTM. Many
calculators are already programmed to solve for the internal rate of return (IRR). Using this feature will also
obtain the YTM because the YTM and IRR are determined the same way. Spreadsheets include a formula for
computing the yield to maturity.
21. Answers will vary for question because values are algorithmically generated in MyFinanceLab.
22. Answers will vary for question because values are algorithmically generated in MyFinanceLab.
23. Answers will vary for question because values are algorithmically generated in MyFinanceLab.
The cost of the I-bond when issued is the face value ($25 or more). Because the bond has an inflation protection
feature, the Treasury Department can issue the I-bond at slightly lower interest rates than comparable bonds.
The rating agencies have an incentive to keep their customers (i.e., the issuers) happy in order to secure future
business. Some suggest that the relationship between the agencies’ and the issuers is one of the factors that
contributed to the subprime crisis. The concern is that rating agencies might hesitate to give low ratings, fearing
that bond issues would no longer pay to have their bonds rated.
d. Yield curves may slope up for many reasons beyond expectations of rising interest rates. According to
liquidity preference theory, long-term interest rates tend to be higher than short-term rates because
longer-term debt has lower liquidity, higher responsiveness to general interest rate movements, and
borrower’s willingness to pay a higher interest rate to lock in money for a longer period of time. In
addition to the expectations theory and the liquidity preference theory, the market segmentation theory
allows for additional increase in interest rate arising from either limited availability of funds or greater
demand for funds at longer maturities.
Asset 2:
E6-7. Calculating the PV of a bond when the required return exceeds the coupon rate
Answer: The PV of a bond is the PV of its future cash flows. In the case of the 5-year bond, the expected cash
flows are $1,200 at the end of each year for 5 years, plus the face value of the bond that will be
received at the maturity of the bond (end of year 5). You may use the bond valuation formula found in
your text or you may use a financial calculator. The solution presented below is derived using a
financial calculator. Set the calculator on 1 period/year.
PV of interest: PMT 1,200
I 8%/year
N 5 periods
Solve for PV $4,791.25
PV of the bond’s face value: FV $20,000
N 5 periods
I 8%/year
Solve for PV $13,611.66
The PV of this bond is $4,791.25 $13,611.66 $18,402.91.
This answer is consistent with the knowledge that when interest rates rise, the values of previously
issued bonds fall. The present value is a cash outflow or cost to investor.
Solutions to Problems
P6-1. Interest rate fundamentals: The real rate of return
LG1; Basic
Nominal return = risk free rate + risk premium = 6% + 5% = 11%
b. The real rate of interest creates an equilibrium between the supply of savings and the demand for
funds, which is shown on the graph as the intersection of lines for current suppliers and current
demanders; r 4%.
c. See graph.
d. A change in the tax law causes an upward shift in the demand curve, causing the equilibrium point
between the supply curve and the demand curve (the real rate of interest) to rise from r0 4% to
r0 6% (intersection of lines for current suppliers and demanders after new law).
b. The yield curve is slightly downward sloping, reflecting lower expected future rates of interest. The
curve may reflect a general expectation for an economic recovery due to inflation coming under
control and a stimulating impact on the economy from the lower rates. However, a slowing economy
may diminish the perceived need for funds and the resulting interest rate being paid for cash.
Obviously, the second scenario is not good for business and highlights the challenge of forecasting the
future based on the term structure of interest rates.
The yield curve for U.S. Treasury issues is upward sloping, reflecting the prevailing expectation of
higher future inflation rates.
d. Followers of the liquidity preference theory would state that the upward-sloping shape of the curve is
due to the desire by lenders to lend short term and the desire by business to borrow long term. The
dashed line in the part c graph shows what the curve would look like without the existence of liquidity
preference, ignoring the other yield curve theories.
e. Market segmentation theorists would argue that the upward slope is due to the fact that under current
economic conditions there is greater demand for long-term loans for items such as real estate than for
short-term loans such as seasonal needs.
b. The real rate of interest decreased from January to March, remained stable from March through
August, and finally increased in December. Forces that may be responsible for a change in the real
rate of interest include changing economic conditions such as the international trade balance, a federal
government budget deficit, or changes in tax legislation.
c.
d. The yield curve is slightly downward sloping, reflecting lower expected future rates of interest. The
curve may reflect a current, general expectation for an economic recovery due to inflation coming
under control and a stimulating impact on the economy from the lower rates.
b. and c.
Five years ago, the yield curve was relatively flat, reflecting expectations of stable interest rates. Two
years ago, the yield curve was downward sloping, reflecting lower expected interest rates, which
could be due to a decline in the expected level of inflation. Today, the yield curve is upward sloping,
reflecting higher expected future rates of interest.
d. Five years ago, the 10-year bond was paying 9.5%, which would result in approximately 95% in
interest over the coming decade. At the same time, the 5-year bond was paying just 9.3%, or a total of
46.5% over the 5 years. According to the expectations theory, investors must have expected the
current 5-year rate to be 9.7% because at that rate, the total return over 10 years would have been the
same on a 10-year bond and on two consecutive 5-year bonds. The numbers are given below.
{(9.5% 10) (9.3% 5)} 5
{95% 46.5%} 5
48.5% 5 9.7%
b.
nominal return = real rate + inflation rate + risk premium
A: 2% + 6% +4% = 12%
B: 2% + 5.5% + 5% = 12.5%
C: 2% + 5% + 2% = 9%
D: 2% + 4.8+ 3% = 9.8%
E: 2% + 6% + 6% = 14%
c.
It is because the security has different maturity, the expected inflation is an average inflation over the
period until its maturity.
b. The company need to pay both coupon ($60) and par ($1,000)
The total expense =
c. As interest payments are tax-deducible, the after-tax cost of interest payment is:
r =7.8%
b.
current yield =
c.
Current yield only reflect the yield of the bond at the current moment, not the total return over the
duration of the bond.
d.
Total return =
b.
Using Calculator:
N 5, I 6, PMT $1,200, FV $5,000
Solve for PV: $8791
The maximum price you should be willing to pay for the car is $8,791 because, if you paid more than that
amount, you would be receiving less than your required 6% return.
Present Value of
Asset End of Year Amount Cash Flows
A 1 $ 5,000 N 3, I 18 $10,871.36
2 $ 5,000 PMT $5,000
3 $ 5,000
C 1 0 N 5, I 16 $16,663.96
2 0 FV $35,000
3 0
4 0
5 $35,000
b. The maximum price Laura should pay is $13,030.92. Unable to assess the risk, Laura would use the
most conservative price, therefore assuming the highest risk.
c. By increasing the risk of receiving cash flow from an asset, the required rate of return increases,
which reduces the value of the asset.
New Price:
b. New Price:
c. Bond Y is riskier than bond X. It is because bond Y has fewer coupons, it has more interest rate risk.
b.
c. When the required return is less than the coupon rate, the market value is greater than the par value,
and the bond sells at a premium. When the required return is greater than the coupon rate, the market
value is less than the par value; the bond therefore sells at a discount. When the required return is
equal to the coupon rate, the market value is equal to the par value.
d. The required return on the bond is likely to differ from the coupon interest rate because either
(1) economic conditions have changed, causing a shift in the basic cost of long-term funds, or
(2) the firm’s risk has changed.
b.
c. From the graph we can conclude that, all else remaining the same, when the required return differs
from the coupon interest rate and is assumed to be constant to maturity, the bond value approaches the
par value.
b.
Bond Table Values Calculator Solution
(1) N 15, I 8%, PMT $110, FV $1,000 $1,256.78
(2) N 15, I 11%, PMT $110, FV $1,000 $1,000.00
(3) N 15, I 14%, PMT $110, FV $1,000 $ 815.73
c.
Value
Required Return Bond A Bond B
8% $1,119.78 $1,256.75
11% 1,000.00 1,000.00
14% 897.01 815.73
The greater the length of time to maturity, the more responsive the market value of the bond to
changing required returns, and vice versa.
d. If Lynn wants to minimize interest rate risk in the future, she would choose Bond A with the shorter
maturity. Any change in interest rates will impact the market value of Bond A less than if she held
Bond B.
r = 2.1250%
yield to maturity =
b. You should buy the bond. The relationship between bond price and bond yield is inverse. If the
interest rate drop in a near future, the bond price will increase.
A 12.36% 12.71%
B 12.00% 12.00%
C $10.38% 10.22%
D 13.02% 12.81%
E 8.77% 8.95%
b. The market value of the bond approaches its par value as the time to maturity declines. The yield-to-
maturity approaches the coupon interest rate as the time to maturity declines. Case B highlights the
fact that if the current price equals the par value, the coupon interest rate equals the yield to maturity
(regardless of the number of years to maturity).
e. The difference is due to the differences in interest payments received each year. The principal
payments at maturity will be the same for both bonds. Using the calculator, the yield to maturity of
Bond A is 11.76%, and the yield to maturity of Bond B is 11.59% with the 10% reinvestment rate for
the interest payments. Mark would be better off investing in Bond A. The reasoning behind this result
is that for both the bonds the principal is priced to yield 12%. However, Bond B is more dependent
upon the reinvestment of the large coupon payment at the yield to maturity to earn the 12% than is the
lower coupon payment of Bond A.
r = 4%.
Price = $1,099.54
Case
Case studies are available on MyFinanceLab.
a. Annie should convert the bonds. The value of the stock if the bond is converted is
50 shares$30 per share $1,500
If the bond was allowed to be called in the value, it would be on $1,080.
b. Current value of bond under different required returns – annual interest
1. N 25, I 6%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $1,255.67
The bond would be at a premium.
2. N 25, I 8%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $1000.00
The bond would sell at its par value.
3. N 25, I 10%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $818.46
Under all three required returns for both annual and semiannual interest payments the bonds are consistent in
their direction of pricing. When the required return is above (below) the coupon the bond sells at a discount
(premium). When the required return and coupon are equal the bond sells at par. When the change is made
from annual to semiannual payments, the value of the premium and par value bonds increase while the value
of the discount bond decreases. This difference is due to the higher effective return associated with
compounding frequency more often than annual.
d. If expected inflation increases by 1%, the required return will increase from 8% to 9%, and the bond price
would drop to $901.77. This amount is the maximum Annie should pay for the bond.
N 25, I 9%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $901.77
e. The value of the bond would decline to $924.81 due to the higher required return and the inverse relationship
between bond yields and bond values.
N 25, I 8.75%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $924.81
f. The bond would increase in value and a gain of $110.61 would be earned by Annie.
N 22, I 7%, PMT $80, PV $1,000
Solve for PV $1,110.61
g. The bond would increase in value and a gain of $91.08 would be earned by Annie.
Bond value at 7% and 15 years to maturity.
N 15, I 7%, PMT $80, FV $1,000
Solve for PV $1,091.08
The bond is more sensitive to interest rate changes when the time to maturity is longer (22 years) than when the
time to maturity is shorter (15 years). Maturity risk decreases as the bond gets closer to maturity.
h. Antilier Industries provides a yield of 8% ($80) and is priced at $983.80 (0.98380 1,000). Hence, the current
yield is 80/983.80 0.0813, or about 8.13%. Using the calculator, the YTM on this bond assuming annual
interest payments of $80, 25 years to maturity, and a current price of $983.80 would be 8.15%.
i. Annie should probably not invest in the Atilier bond. There are several reasons for this conclusion.
1. The term to maturity is long, and thus, the maturity risk is high.
2. An increase in interest rates is likely due to the potential downgrading of the bond, thus driving the price
down.
3. An increase in interest rates is likely due to the possibility of higher inflation, thus driving the price
down.
4. The price of $983.75 is well above her minimum price of $901.77, assuming an increase in interest rates
of 1%.
Spreadsheet Exercise
The answer to Chapter 6’s CSM Corporation spreadsheet problem is located on the Instructor’s Resource Center at
www.pearsonglobaleditions.com/gitman under the Instructor’s Manual.
Group Exercise
Group exercises are available on MyFinanceLab.
This chapter is concerned with credit ratings. Each group is asked to use current information from their shadow
firm to flesh out the details for their fictitious firm. The first lesson students will learn is the lack of transparency in
the bond market, particularly when compared to the stock market. Updated information is not as easily compared
across multiple sites and details are often sketchy. Because a recent debt issuance is needed, the assignment can be
redirected from publicly accessed websites to the most recent filings with the SEC.
The steps for the assignment are very straightforward. Each group is asked to retrieve the interest rate of a recent
debt issuance. For many firms there will be multiple offerings; any recent filing will suffice. This information on
rates is then combined with the credit rating of the offering. Students should realize the same firm can be given
different ratings on different offerings according to each offering’s covenants. Using the current yield on a
comparable Treasury, the risk premium can then be calculated.
The final step for the group is to address a potential capital investment. The interest rate will be derived from the
information of the shadow firm; however ,the details of the project are entirely up to the discretion of the group.
Students should be encouraged to get creative, as this is the firm they will be living with for another two months.