Sample 1
Sample 1
Sample 1
Student Name:
Student Number:
Module: Dynamic Leadership Development
Lecturer: Keelin Lee
Due Date: 25th July 2021
Table of Contents
Part A: Overview of the Leader and Leadership Style..............................................................4
1. Introduction.........................................................................................................................4
3.7 Analysis..........................................................................................................................16
3.8 Conclusion......................................................................................................................17
1
References................................................................................................................................19
Appendices...............................................................................................................................22
Table of Figures
2
Figure 1: Sir Alex Ferguson.......................................................................................................4
Figure 2: Sir Alex Fergusons Success........................................................................................5
Figure 3: Daniel Goleman's Leadership Theory........................................................................6
Figure 4: Ferguson Quote on Leadership...................................................................................7
Figure 5: Kurt Lewin's Change Management Theory................................................................8
Figure 6: McClelland's Human Motivation Theory.................................................................10
Figure 7: Ferguson Motivation Quote......................................................................................10
Figure 8: Goleman's Competences Model...............................................................................12
Figure 9: Ferguson Quote about Emotional Support...............................................................12
Figure 10: Gibbs Reflective Learning Cycle...........................................................................14
Figure 11: SWOT Analysis......................................................................................................18
3
Part A: Overview of the Leader and Leadership Style
1. Introduction
One leader who has inspired and motivated me throughout my childhood up until today is Sir
Alex Ferguson due to his winning mentality and high standards he sets for everyone around
him. He leads by example and is an excellent leader and mentor for players of all ages. He
emphasises the importance of continuous improvement and he consistently communicates
with his players and staff to ensure they feel valued and part of the family he creates at
Manchester United. This study will be assessing the leadership characteristics of Sir Alex
Ferguson, the former manager of Manchester United. It will focus on his leadership styles,
change management leadership capability, motivation techniques and his high level of
emotional intelligence. His leadership qualities will also be aligned with The Leadership
Theory of Daniel Goleman, The Change Management Theory of Kurt Lewin, McClellan’s
Human Motivation Theory and Goleman’s Competences Model.
4
Interestingly, Alex Ferguson failed to win a single trophy during his first four years at
Manchester United (Results, 2020). However, Ferguson believed that he was building a solid
structure for the future (Results, 2020). Alex Ferguson’s main talent was the ability to
repeatedly build a series of great teams where he combined a range of experiences, skill sets
and personalities (Results, 2020). Ferguson knew that his role involved enrolling, engaging,
delegating, motivating, and communicating at a distance (Results, 2020). He recognised the
importance of delegation through clear communication, using that communication to praise
when appropriate (Results, 2020).
5
Figure 3: Daniel Goleman's Leadership Theory
Authoritative: From the moment Ferguson arrived at Manchester United he had a vision to
change the club as a whole and not just the first team that he managed. He knew success
would take some time, but he had the ability to look a few years into the future and envision
what his team would look like and what it took to be successful. Fergusons clear mission was
to win every game. Every one of his decisions and actions from the moment he arrived at the
club was informed by this vision, which helped everyone in the organization understand why
their work mattered (Letros, 2017).
Fergusons authoritative leadership was effective as the club needed a complete revamp from
the youth set up all the way to senior and he was the one who drove this change. He also
tackled the clubs famous drinking culture which he believed was affecting performance.
Pacesetting: Due to Fergusons upbringing in a poor family with a strict father in Glasgow,
Scotland, where he was ingrained with a pull-yourself-up-by-your bootstrap mentality, he
was always early to meetings and rarely wasted time (Letros, 2017). He believed that in order
to achieve your potential as a leader you must be disciplined and that there was simply no
substitute for hard work. As the manager of Manchester United he was always the first one to
arrive in the morning and the last one to leave. This style works particularly well with hungry
and motivated staff, like his top performers, who emulated his self-discipline (Letros, 2017).
6
Figure 4: Ferguson Quote on Leadership
Coercion: Sir Alex’s coercive nature was on display during the training sessions and
matches where Ferguson demanded an extreme level of intensity, concentration, and
commitment. Any raining session that failed to meet that standard had to be repeated until he
was satisfied (Letros, 2017). Ferguson had full control over what was going on in the club.
He controlled the transfers, the training sessions, and the hiring of staff.
Ferguson developed a reputation as being ruthless and ensuring that players knew that no
player is bigger than the club as there tended to be some egos in the squad at times. He was
seen as a father figure to many of the young players. However, he had no problem selling a
player if they believed things should be done differently or disobeyed him in anyway.
Coaching: Ferguson got the best out of people by gaining their respect, getting them
accustomed to winning and convincing them that they are capable of continuously improving
as a player. Fergusons coaching was done off the field by instructing them and giving them
advice to ensure they were feeling confident and were all on path to achieve a common goal.
He understood that the central element of his job was to help everyone else believe they could
do things that they did not think they were capable of and to make everyone understand that
nothing was impossible (Letros, 2017).
Ferguson relied on youth and emphasised the importance of having youth in a squad as they
give you a future and loyalty as they always remember the coach that gave them their first
opportunity. He would regularly have discussions with young players about their future and
old players who were coming to the end of their career. Players respected this and they would
always give 100% despite being aware that their future does not lie at Manchester United.
7
2.2 Change Management
2.2.1 Change Management Theory of Kurt Lewin
The underpinning theory in present research is the Kurt Lewin theory of change who has
developed three step-levels to implement planned change within organizations. Change
literature extensively employed his model due to its solid back-up in dealing with the
managers insights through the change process (Stouten et al., 2018).
Kurt Lewin’s change management theory defines three stages of change management
unfreezing, changing, and re-freezing.
Unfreezing- This stage involves understanding the organisations status quo, to clarify the
desired end state, to identify the forces promoting change and the forces resisting change.
This stage uncovers the employee’s insight and their natural struggle to cope with the change
(Memon, Shah & Khoso, 2021).
Changing – This stage involves deploying changes and taking action within the organization
through guiding the employees by the means of supporting them (Memon, Shah & Khoso,
2021).
Refreezing – This stage includes consistently implementing change within the organization
which can be attained by engaging the employees in the change process (Al-Haddad &
8
Kotnour, 2015). This stage involves making permanent changes and embed the new way of
doing things.
Once the youth system was set up, the benefits began to show as talented young players came
through the academy to the senior squad every year. Ferguson is a world-class leader who
promotes youth, protects youth, and shows them consistency in their talent practices.
9
2.3 Motivating The Team
2.3.1 McClelland’s Human Motivation Theory
Ferguson was famous for his man management which involved adapting McClelland’s
Human Motivation Theory when motivating players. He accepted the idea that some players
needed different approaches due to the difference in their motivation needs (Lits, 2014).
Ferguson nurtured Cristiano Ronaldo and sometimes forgave his actions that he would not
forgive for other players. This was because Ferguson understood that Ronaldo was motivated
by achievement and aspired to become the greatest player in the world and managed him in
the way that corresponded with this motivation. He was rewarded for using the Human
Motivation Theory as Cristiano Ronaldo would go onto score many very important goals
which won Manchester United many trophies.
10
2.3.2 Symbolic Management Theory
Another frame that adds another point of view is called Symbolic management theory which
was developed by Bolman and Deal in 2008 (Lits, 2014). The Symbolic management theory
addresses people's needs for a sense of purpose and meaning in their work (Chapman &
Scouller, 2020). It focuses on inspiring people by making the organisation's direction feel
significant and includes creating a motivating vision and recognising superb performance
(Chapman & Scouller, 2020).
One of Fergusons motivation techniques was that he would regularly discuss players
upbringing with them so he could get an idea of their character and personality. It was
massively important to him for players to not forget where they had come from in life. He
would ask them what their grandfather, father and grandmother did. He felt that he had to get
the feeling inside them that what their grandfathers and grandmothers worked for is part of
them. He thinks that they must display that meaning as where they come from is important.
11
Figure 8: Goleman's Competences Model
Ferguson has been credited with spending time and being dedicated to his team members
(Elberse and Ferguson, 2013). From experience he knows the feeling and position that his
players are in. By doing this, Ferguson showed concern for people around him, and his team
members knew that he had their backs (Mohamed, 2016). When people feel valued and cared
for, they will push themselves to hit targets for that person.
12
Ferguson says understanding the power of emotional intelligence was one of his greatest
lessons as a leader (Morris, 2016). He used it to assess each squad members’ mental and
emotional wellbeing, and to build trust when talking to them in private (Morris, 2016). He
believes that whatever industry you’re in, you have to create trust so people can come to you
about anything. Understanding each player’s unique character dominated Ferguson’s thinking
(Morris, 2016). Leaders blessed with world-class talent need world class emotional agility
and they cannot fake compassion or concern for their people (Morris, 2016).
13
Part B: Personal Reflection and Learning
While I was studying in Maastricht, The Netherlands as part of my Erasmus, I saw playing
football as a great way to make friends in a new city. I also took upon the role as captain,
which had many responsibilities as we had no manager due to it being a student football club
ran by students. In my role as captain, I had the responsibility to select the team for every
match and lead the training sessions. My affiliative leadership style was suited for the
position as we were all students and just cause I decided who played I did not want them to
feel that I had power over them in any way. It is important to have an atmosphere where
14
anyone can freely voice their opinion to the group on anything that could improve our
chances of achieving the groups common goal which was to win.
15
3.5 Feelings – Being Lead
This situation made me feel very undervalued as I felt that I was not being noticed or given a
fair chance to show what value I could add to the team. I am not sure if the reason for his
actions was due to my talent, or the impact my vocal and honest personality was having on
the team environment. It affected my involvement and drive to improve as I felt that no
matter how hard I worked or improved I would not get a fair chance. As a result, I felt less
motivated to show up and did not enjoy playing as much as I was not willing to work for my
manager.
My experience was a realisation that maybe his approach was different to mine and his vision
clashed with the style I was bringing to the team.
However, this leader in particular was not very clear what he wanted , he was too controlling
and not very organised with regards to preparation for matches which affected the overall
performance of the team which affected my morale and attitude.
3.7 Analysis
In order to identify the skills, I need to improve, I have completed several tests which have
given me an insight into my leadership styles. Having scored 33/35 for an affiliative leader
this is due to what I learned while being a leader as captain (Appendix 4). This result pointed
out my qualities of empathy and the ability to build relationships through a range of
communication styles. However, my coercive and commanding leadership needs
improvement, but I may not have been in a suitable role to demand orders as it may have had
a negative effect. However, I will need to improve my coercive leadership as I will need to be
commanding in future positions. I possess high relationship management and self-
management qualities upon completion of the emotional intelligence test (Appendix 7).
16
I also completed the VIA Character Strengths Test (Appendix 5) which identified honesty,
humour, kindness, judgement, and humility as my key strengths which I believe are key to
my approach as a leader. From the Belbin Team Test (Appendix 1) I was identified as a co-
ordinator and an implementer. I believe this matches up with my strengths as I take a
practical, logical, and calm approach to situations which I believe helped me to make
decisions and speak publicly to my team.
3.8 Conclusion
One of the key lessons I have learned from Alex Ferguson is to have empathy for members of
my team to create trust. His man management skills also had a major influence on me as I
learned that not everyone is the same and different people require different motivation
approaches to be motivated. Analysing his leadership style has further helped to understand
the importance of regular communication and having a vision that is realistic and one that I
believe in and can achieve.
In the future, I will continue to enforce an affiliative leadership style. However, depending on
the situation, I will look to adapt to the most relevant leadership style to ensure I perform to
the best of my ability. I intend to further develop my coercive leadership skills and implement
them when necessary. I also hope to improve my lesser strengths of spirituality, zest, and
gratitude as they are all very important to succeed as a great leader.
17
Opportunities Threats
- To gain experience in a leadership role - Picking up bad habits from poor
in an organisation leaders
- Develop a variety of leadership skills - Developing as a person in a negative
- Improve confidence way
- Losing appreciation and perspective
- Allowing any power to take over me
and ruining relationships
I believe these skills will allow me to motivate and encourage employees to perform to a high
standard. I also feel that my organisation skills and hardworking attitude will result in all
work and projects being completed in an efficient and effective manner.
18
References
Al-Haddad, S., & Kotnour, T. (2015). Integrating the organizational change literature: a
model for successful change. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 28(2), 234-262.
doi:10.1108/jocm-11-2013-0215 [Accessed July 19, 2021]
Chapman, A. & Scouller, J., (2020). What is Bolman and Deal's Four Frame Model of
Leadership? Four-Frame Model - Bolman and Deal. Available at:
https://www.businessballs.com/leadership-models/four-frame-model-bolman-and-deal/
[Accessed July 24, 2021].
Denton, A. (2013), "Can business leaders build teams like Alex Ferguson?", Strategic
Direction, vol. 29, no. 9, pp. 3-5. [Accessed July 22, 2021)
Elberse, A., 2018. Ferguson's Formula. Harvard Business Review. Available at:
https://hbr.org/2013/10/fergusons-formula [Accessed July 23, 2021].
19
Foulston, J., 2010. LEAD: Leadership principles learnt from Sir Alex Ferguson and Sir
Bobby Robson. Tomorrow Trends. Available at:
https://www.tomorrowtodayglobal.com/2010/05/25/lead-leadership-principles-learnt-from-
sir-alex-ferguson-and-sir-bobby-robson/ [Accessed July 16, 2021].
Hytner, R. (2015) ‘Sir Alex Ferguson’s Winning Way’, London Business School Review,
26(4), pp. 48–52. doi: 10.1111/2057-1615.12078. [Accessed July 19, 2021)
Iregbu, J., 2020. 8 Secrets of Successful Leadership: Sir Alex Ferguson: Joseph Iregbu.
Joseph Iregbu | Purpose Guy. Available at: https://josephiregbu.com/alex-ferguson/
[Accessed July 23, 2021].
LaBier, D., 2014. Why Humble, Empathic Business Leaders Are More Successful. HuffPost.
Available at: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/why-humble-empathic-busin_b_6042196
[Accessed July 16, 2021].
Lits, Y., 2014. Organizational Behavior in Sir Alex Ferguson's Manchester United. LinkedIn.
Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/20141112160950-58663646-organizational-
behavior-in-sir-alex-ferguson-s-manchester-united/ [Accessed July 23, 2021].
Memon, F.A., Shah, S. & Khoso, I.U. 2021, "Improving Employee's Engagement in Change:
Reassessing Kurt Lewin's Model", City University Research Journal, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 144-
164. [Accessed July 23, 2021]
Mohamed, N., 2016. 5 successful traits that business leaders can take from Sir Alex
Ferguson. Geneva Business News | Actualités: Emploi, RH, économie, entreprises, Genève,
Suisse. Available at: https://www.gbnews.ch/5-successful-traits-that-business-leaders-can-
take-from-sir-alex-ferguson/ [Accessed July 23, 2021].
Morris, R., 2016. Sir Alex Ferguson and Paul McGinley . London Business School. Available
at: https://www.london.edu/think/fergie-and-mcginley-feature [Accessed July 16, 2021].
20
Results, 2020. How to build a team like Alex Ferguson. The Results Centre. Available at:
https://theresultscentre.com/2013/09/10/how-to-build-a-team-like-alex-ferguson/ [Accessed
July 23, 2021].
Robbins, S.P. & Judge, T.A., 2016. Organisational Behaviour, Melbourne, Vic.: Pearson
Australia. [Accessed July 22, 2021]
Spirit, 2017. Could emotional intelligence be holding you back? Spirit Ventures. Available
at: https://spiritventures.co.uk/emotional-intelligence-holding-back/ [Accessed July 23,
2021].
Stouten, J., Rousseau, D., De Cremer, D., 2018 . Successful Organizational Change:
Integrating the Management Practice and Scholarly Literatures.
DOI: 10.5465/annals.2016.0095 [Accessed July 24, 2021]
21
Appendices
Appendix 1: Belbin Teams Role Test
SH CO PL RI ME IMP TW CF
A 3-1 7- 4-3 6-2 5-3 1- 8- 2-1
B 1- 6-4 5-2 8- 4- 7- 3-2 2-2
C 7- 4- 6- 2- 3-4 5-6 8- 1-
D 2-4 3-3 6-2 4- 5- 1- 8-1 7-
E 6- 5-2 1- 7- 3- 4-4 2-1 8-3
F 6-1 4-3 5- 1-2 3-4 8- 7- 2-
G 5- 7-1 6- 3- 2- 1-3 8-2 4-4
Total 6 13 7 4 11 13 6 10
22
Appendix 3: Do I Have a Fixed or Growth Mindset?
23
Appendix 5: VIA Signature Character Strengths
24
Appendix 6: Team Effectiveness Questionnaire
25
26