Loading… The Journal of the Canadian Game Studies Association 74

Vol 13(21): 74-76

http://loading.gamestudies.ca

Review: A Play of Bodies: How We Perceive
Videogames by Brendan Keogh

Kate Euphemia Clark

Monash University
[email protected]

Many theorists have discussed the ways video games, as a medium, are unique (Boutler, 2015;
Cairns et al., 2014), and the confusion around subject-avatar that often arises while playing video
games (Sundén, 2012; Wilde & Evans, 2017). Brendan Keogh (2018) takes this notion in his
book A Play of Bodies, and closely examines the relationship between embodiment and video
games. Keogh’s book describes how the sensorial experience of playing video games is
fundamental not only to understanding video games as texts, but also to how we think about
what video games are and how they come to be implicated in our sense of embodiment. Bringing
the body back into video game studies allows us to question the autonomy of the video game
player, as Keogh states, “all videogame play augments and restricts the player’s corporeal
experience in particular, cyborgian ways through sights, sounds, and interfaces” (189).
In order to develop this new narrative surrounding the experience of playing video games, Keogh
takes time in the first chapter to develop a phenomenological understanding of video games. A
Play of Bodies lingers on the sensorial experiences of playing video games – in terms of how
things such as sight, touch, audio, and aesthetics are understood through our bodies. The
understanding of bodies as something that we are, rather than things that we possess, lays the
foundation for Keogh to cleverly theorize the co-constitutive relationship between video game
and player that arises through play. This fresh perspective on how video games operate, that
moves beyond analysis pointed towards an external object, instead focusing on the intermingling
of body and machine, opens up a new avenue of exploration for video games.
A Play of Bodies opens with the material body re-centered in the video game experience. After
this is established, Keogh makes three main theoretical claims throughout the book. Firstly, he
details the co-attentiveness that the player experiences when playing video games. The analysis
of video game play on smart phones, such as Flappy Bird (2013) and Fruit Ninja (2013), and the
modes of co-constitution that these draw our attention to demonstrates the co-attentiveness
across worlds that is an element of video game play, “where the player is fully aware of the
hybrid assemblage across actual/virtual worlds and bodies that all video games demand” (73).
Mobile games make explicit what all video games require – an attentiveness to both virtual and
nonvirtual worlds.
Once this co-attentiveness is established, A Play of Bodies details different sensorial experiences
that establishes how the player and the video game are elements that exist in a complex and
irreducible form of embodiment. Keogh unpacks how controllers and other devices we use to
play video games become incorporated into our material bodies through learning and repeating
certain gestures. Once we learn certain inputs (that X equals jump for example), they come to be

 75

seen as natural. In other words, we develop a feel for playing video games, and this feel
reconfigures the body, these learned actions become natural, and “alternative modes of input that
contradict the learned mode become explicitly unnatural” (83). This line of thought is furthered
by detailing how sight and sound converge to produce an “experience that is not available with
visuals alone” (111). Our senses must work together when playing video games. Keogh does this
to demonstrate that the irreducible nature of “audiovisual flesh” (117) operates in conjunction
with mechanics to create meaning in videogames.
Finally, A Play of Bodies shifts to describe the ways that a games’ rhythms come to be embodied
in the player. This is explored through the ways that different forms of death in video games
influence “the player’s life experience of the player-and-videogame assemblage and constitution
of played time” (159). Here Keogh details how player death is a learning experience and can
send the player both back and forward in time. Video game texts are “caught up in broader
corporeal rhythms and contexts where pasts and futures make themselves present through failure
and repetition or through the threat thereof” (165).
Keogh uses Donna Harraway’s Cyborg Manifesto (2006), in order to demonstrate how video
games are more than a tool to be mastered. Instead, we are in a constant process of integrating
the video game itself into ourselves – video games augment our corporeal experience. A Play of
Bodies poses an understanding of video games that allows us to move beyond the perception of
video games as something to be dominated or mastered. Instead, it provides us with an image of
the video game player as merely a part in a larger circuit, decentralizing the narrative of the
hegemonic dominance of the player and recognizing the hybridity and co-attentiveness of the
player-game relationship.
A Play of Bodies does excellent work to deconstruct the notion of video games as sites of active,
aggressive domination. However, this is often constructed in a way that emphasizes textual
elements that are active. There is room in A Play of Bodies to explore more subtle forms of
material embodiment. Although the examples presented do an excellent job in working through
these forms of embodiment, more attention to what Lauren Berlant (2015) would term
underperformed affective experiences would allow for a more robust critique of dominant
understandings of what video games are and how they are presented. Underperformed affect
details uncertain and flat reactions to events that “destabilize the conventional relation between
high intensity and importance” (p. 195). For example, when Keogh explores games such as Dear
Esther (2012), where the player walks up a mountain, interacting very little with the game while
the narrator divulges the events surrounding a car crash that happened in the past (183),
underperformed emotion could provide a more nuanced and subtle understanding of the forms of
‘recessive action” (p. 193) that underlie the way in which these games often limit the player’s
freedoms (186).
However, this is a minor critique. A Play of Bodies explores our co-constitutive relationship to
video games both eloquently and effectively. A Play of Bodies opens many doors in the field of
video game scholarship, that pays careful attention to perceptions of video games that often lie at
the margins, both within academia and in the gaming community. Keogh’s A Play of Bodies is
insightful and invigorating, drawing our attention towards the sensorial experience of playing
video games. We are all cyborgs, after all.

 76

References

Berlant, L. (2015). Structures of unfeeling: Mysterious skin. International Journal of Politics,
Culture, and Society, 28(3), 191-213. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10767-
014-9190-y
Boulter, J. (2015). Parables of the posthuman: Digital realities, gaming, and the player
experience. Detroit, MA: Wayne State University Press.
Cairns, P., Cox, A., & Nordin, A.I. (2014). Immersion in digital games: Review of gaming
experience research. Handbook of Digital Games, 1, 767-798.
Dear Esther [Software]. (2012). UK: The Chinese Room.
Flappy Bird [Software]. (2013). Vietnam: Nguyen, D.
Fruit Ninja [Software]. (2010). Brisbane, Australia: Halfbrick.
Haraway, D. (2006). A cyborg manifesto: Science, technology, and socialist-feminism in the late
20th century. In: Weiss J., Nolan J., Hunsinger J., Trifonas P. (eds). The international
handbook of virtual learning environments (pp. 117-158). Springer, Dordrecht.
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4020-3803-7_4
Keogh, B. (2018). A play of bodies: How we perceive video games. The MIT Press.
Sundén, J. (2012). Desires at play: On closeness and epistemological uncertainty. Games and
Culture, 7(2), 164-184.
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1555412012451124
Wilde, P., & Evans, A. (2017). Empathy at play: Embodying posthuman subjectivities in
gaming. Convergence, 25(5-6), 1-16.
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1354856517709987