Expert Opinion On Risk Level For Factors Affecting Time and Cost Overrun Along The Project Lifecycle in Malaysian Construction Projects
Expert Opinion On Risk Level For Factors Affecting Time and Cost Overrun Along The Project Lifecycle in Malaysian Construction Projects
Expert Opinion On Risk Level For Factors Affecting Time and Cost Overrun Along The Project Lifecycle in Malaysian Construction Projects
net/publication/268630164
Expert opinion on risk level for factors affecting time and cost overrun along the
project lifecycle in Malaysian Construction Projects
CITATIONS READS
25 1,892
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
STRUCTURAL RELATIONSHIPS MODELOF DELAY FACTORS IN MAKKAH CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Aftab Hameed Memon on 23 November 2014.
Abstract—Construction projects in Malaysia are currently occurrence throughout the project life. Hence, it is very
facing a severe problem of time and cost overrun. It is critical to recognize the risk of factors and their risk on
increasing with the rapid growth in development. The time and cost overruns. This will be very helpful in taking
problem of time and cost overrun in resulted from various appropriate actions for overcoming these problems.
factors. These factors occur in construction projects at
various phases and have different level of risk which is very
essential to determine. Hence, this study is carried out II. TIME AND COST OVERRUN PROBLEM IN
through risk matrix for assessing risk level of various factors CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
of time and cost overrun throughout the life cycle of a The sensation of a construction project is considered by
construction project. This research work involved 35 achieving the completion of projects on estimated time,
common factors of time and cost overrun identified from budget, quality, and no dispute. However, more commonly
reviewing previous studies published worldwide. For time and cost are adopted as fundamental criteria for
assessing the relatively of those factors and determining their
measuring success of a project because of their simplicity
occurrence in various phase of project lifecycle, structured
and relate between each other (Iyer and Jha, 2006). Based
interviews were conducted with 5 experts from construction
industry. Experts were asked about the occurrence and
on previous studies, time and cost overrun has been
severity level of each factor along each phase which were defined in different ways. In construction project, time and
analyzed with average index calculation and risk matrix. cost overrun is a common issue and categorized as a
The findings revealed that the factors have low and medium worldwide problem (Murray and Seif, 2013). In the study
risk on time and cost overrun during planning and design of Pai and Bharath (2013), leisurely performance of works
phase. While, in the construction phase majority of factors where activities were not stopping completely, was
have medium risks and 5 factors have a high risk on time considered as time overrun. This time overrun often results
overrun while 6 factors have a high risk on cost overrun. The in disruption of work, low productivity, delayed projects,
findings of this study give a better understanding to the cost will increase, claims of third parties, and
construction practitioners for risk level of the factors causing termination of the contract. It also results in consuming
time and cost overrun in each phase of construction projects. long construction period (Kikwasi, 2012). From
This will help the practitioners in taking proper actions for perspective of cost overrun, Park and Papadopoulou
improving construction time and cost performance. (2012) highlighted that additional expenditure than the
contract amount agreed between client and contractor
Keywords-Time Overrun, Cost Overrun, Risk Level, consumed in any project is regarded a cost overrun. It is
Project Life Cycle also named as budget increase, cost increase, or cost
growth (Love et. al. 2013).
I. INTRODUCTION
In Malaysia, various researchers have investigated time
Success of any project is highly dependent on project and cost performance issues. Memon et al (2011a)
completion within time and cost. These are key parameters conducted a case study on 30 MARA (Majlis Amanah
in measuring the behavior and success of the projects Rakyat) large projects and found that all projects has time
throughout its life cycle. Unfortunately, many projects overrun at an average of 23.74% of the contracted time
experience time and cost overrun and these issues are a period. While Memon et. al. (2014) through a survey in
common phenomenon in construction industry (Odeh and southern region of Penisular Malaysia found that for large
Battaineh, 2002). This is caused by risk of factors that projects, amount of cost overrun ranges from 5-10% of the
effect on the progress of works from beginning until the estimated cost while in small projects, it was found as 10-
final stage of construction. Therefore, it can because initial 15% of estimated cost. Another study conducted by Endut
estimates of time and cost exceed or considered as time et. al. (2009) in investigation of public and private sector
and cost overrun. These problems are occurred due to revealed that, out of 308 investigated public sectors, only
various risk factors such as accidents, price fluctuation, 20.5% of projects were completed on time and 46.8% of
inadequate materials and unfavorable weather condition as projects were completed within budget. While, in private
cited by (Zaini et. al. 2010). In Malaysia, there is lack of sector projects only 33.35% and 37.2% of 51 investigated
investigation of the risk factors and their relative projects were completed on time and cost respectively.
10
www.zwgm.org International Journal of Construction Technology and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2014
More recently, problem of time and cost overrun issue researchers have divided PLC into several stages and
happened in construction of Kuala Lumpur International phases as shown in table 2.
Airport 2 (known as KLIA2). This project was targeted to
be opened in September 2011 but the opening is postponed TABLE II. SUMMARY OF REVIEW ON PHASES IN PLC
until May 2014. Because of the delay, project has faced the
cost overrun run of about RM500 million (Nie, 2013). Authors Year Phases in PLC
Novick 1990 1. Capital programming
This problem of time and cost overrun arise due to 2. Concept Study/Alternatives Analysis
several factors that affect the time and cost in construction. 3. Preparation of Design and Contract
Several researchers have pout efforts in revealing these Documents
4. Construction
responsible factors which were reviewed carefully. Aziz 5. Operations, Inspection, and
(2013) conducted questionnaire survey to identify the Maintenance
factors perceived to affect delay in the Egyptian 6. Repair and Rehabilitation
construction project. 99 factors causing delay was 7. Reconstruction or Replacement
determined and classified under 9 major categories. The Kartam 1996 1. Conceptual planning and feasibility
findings revealed top twenty factors based on 3 most studies
2. Design and engineering
significant factors for each group was identified as (1) 3. Construction
Contractor category : ineffective project planning and 4. Operation and maintenance.
scheduling, poor site management and supervision, poor Alshubbak et. al. 2009 1. Feasibility phase
financial control on site, (2) Equipment category: shortage 2. Design phase
of equipment, frequent equipment breakdowns, equipment 3. Construction phase
4. Exploitation phase
allocation problem, (3) Owner category: delay in progress 5. Dismantling phase.
payments, selecting inappropriate contractors, inadequate Saad 2011 1. Conceptual planning and economics
planning, (4) Project category: complexity of project, legal phase
disputes between project participants, ineffective delay 2. Engineering and functional design
penalties, (5) Design category: design changes by owner, phase
misunderstanding of owner’s requirements by design 3. Phase III (Preparing Drawings and
Specifications; Tender and Award;
engineer, design errors and omissions made by designers, Procurement)
(6) Consultant category: delay in approving major changes 4. Construction and completion of the
in scope of work by consultant, lack of consultant project phase
experience in construction projects, poor communication 5. Operation and utilization phase.
and coordination between owner and contractor, (7)
External category: different tactics patterns for bribes,
However, for this study lifecycle of projects is
sudden failures actions, global financial crisis, (8) Material
classified into four phases which consists of the planning
category: shortage of construction materials, late delivery
phase, design phase, construction phase and finishing
of materials, delay in manufacturing materials, (9) Labor
phase as illustrated in figure 1.
category: unqualified/inadequate experienced labor,
shortage of labor, and low productivity of labor.
IV. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Gündüz et. al. (2013) in his study of construction
industry in Turkey mentioned that the most significant This research work was done through interviewing the
factors causing delays are inadequate contractor experts of construction industry from private and
experience, ineffective project planning and scheduling, government sector. The panel which was interviewed
poor site management and supervision, design change by consisted of personnel from clients, consultants, and
owner, late delivery of materials, unreliable contractors. All the experts were given list of 35 factors
subcontractors, delay in performing inspection and testing, contributing to time and cost overrun based on table 1
unqualified workers, change orders, delay in site delivery, discussed in earlier sections. The experts rated each factors
delay in approving design documents, delay in progress for probability of occurrence and level of severity in each
payments, slowness in decision making, poor phase of project lifecycle using a scale from 1 to 5. The
communication and coordination with other parties and rating was analyzed with Average Index (AI) formula as
unexpected surface and subsurface conditions. In study of below:
Nigerian construction industry, Amu and Adesanya (2011) Average Index = ∑ (1X1 + 2X2 + 3X3 + 3X4 + 3X5) (1)
found that factors that contributed time overrun in
construction project are funding and payment, contractor N
and client factors are the major factors contributed to the Where,
delay of projects. Together with these, several published
research works in identifying time and cost overrun factors N= Number of respondents,
were reviewed which resulted in identification of 35 X = Rating scale are explained in table 3
common factors as mapped in table 1.
11
www.zwgm.org International Journal of Construction Technology and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2014
12
www.zwgm.org International Journal of Construction Technology and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2014
Based on the probability of occurrence and severity Client Degree 11-20 Government Engineer
level of the factors, risk of each factor was calculate using Deputy
Client Master 21-30 Government
risk matrix as adopted from Mahamid (2011). director
31 Deputy
Client Degree Government
above director
13
www.zwgm.org International Journal of Construction Technology and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2014
14
www.zwgm.org International Journal of Construction Technology and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2014
[6] Amu, O. O., Adesanya, D. A., 2011. Mathematical expression fpr Project : Perspective of Project Management Consultant. Journal of
explaining project delays in Southwestern Nigeria. Singapore Construction Engineering and Management, 1(2):41–54.
Journal of Scientific Research, 1(1):59–67. [26] Memon, A. H., Rahman, I. A., Abdullah, M. R., Azis, A. A. A.,
[7] Assaf, S. A., Al-Hejji, S., 2006. Causes of delay in large 2011. Time Overrun in Construction Projects from the Perspective
construction projects. International Journal of Project Management, of Project Management Consultant (PMC). Journal of Surveying,
24(4):349–357. Construction and Property, 2 (1):54-66
[8] Azhar, N., Farooqui, R. U., Ahmed, S. M., 2008. Cost Overrun [27] Memon, A. H., Rahman, I. A., 2014. Budget overrun issue in
Factors In Construction Industry of Pakistan. In First International construction projects of southern part of Malaysia. International
Conference on Construction In Developing Countries (ICCIDC–I), Journal of Civil Engineering and Built Environment, 1(1):1-6
Advancing and Integrating Construction Education, Research & [28] Marzouk, M. M., El-Rasas, T. I., 2013. Analyzing delay causes in
Practice, August 4-5, 2008, Karachi, Pakistan (pp. 499–508). Egyptian construction projects. Journal of Advanced Research.
[9] Aziz, R. F., 2013. Ranking of delay factors in construction projects 5(1):49–55
after Egyptian revolution. Alexandria Engineering Journal, [29] Murray, M., Seif, M., 2013. Causes of f Project Delays in Nigerian
52(3):387–406 Construction Industry . European Journal of Civil Engineering and
[10] Creedy, G., 2005. Risk factors leading to cost overrun in highway Architecture, 10:1–7.
projects, Sidwell, A. C. (Ed.). Proceeding of Queenland University [30] Nie, Y. Y., 2013. New KL budget terminal faces delay, cost
of Technology Research Week International Conference, Brisbane, overruns. The Straits Times, Newspaper, 8 June 2013
Australia, 4-8 July.
[31] Novick, D., 1990. Life ‐ Cycle Considerations in Urban
[11] Danso, H., Antwi, J. K., 2012. Evaluation of the Factors Infrastructure Engineering. Journal of Management in Engineering,
Influencing Time and Cost Overruns in Telecom Tower 6(2):186–196.
Construction in Ghana. Civil and Environmental Research,
2(6):15–25. [32] Odeh, A. M., Battaineh, H. T., 2002. Causes of construction delay :
traditional contracts. International Journal of Project Management,
[12] El-razek, M. E. A., Bassioni, H. A., Mobarak, A. M., 2008. Causes 20: 67–73.
of delay in building construction projects in Egypt. Journal of
Construction Engineering and Management, 134(11):831–841. [33] Pai, S. K., Bharath, J. R., 2013. Analysis of Critical Causes of
Delays in Indian Infrastructure Projects. International Journal of
[13] Endut, I. R., Shehu, Z., Akintoye, A., Jaafar, A., 2009. Cost and Innovative Research & Development, 2(3):251–263.
Time of Construction Projects in Malaysia. In Fifth International
[34] Park, Y. I., Papadopoulou, T. C., 2012. Causes of cost overruns in
Conference on Construction in the 21st Century (CITC-V),
transport infrastructure projects in Asia: Their significance and
Collaboration and Integration in Engineering, Management and
Technology, May 20-22, 2009, Istanbul, Turkey. relationship with project size. Built Environment Project and Asset
Management, 2(2):195–216.
[14] Enshassi, A., Mohamed, S., Abushaban, S., 2009. Factors affecting
the performance of construction projects in the gaza strip. Journal [35] Rahman, I. A., Memon, A. H., Abd.Karim, A. T., 2013a.
of Civil Engineering and Management, 15(3):269–280. Significant Factors Causing Cost Overruns in Large Construction
Projects in Malaysia. Journal of Applied Sciences, 13(2): 286–293.
[15] Fugar, F., Agyakwah-Baah, A., 2010. Delays in building
[36] Rahman, I. A., Memon, A. H., Abd. Karim, A. T. 2013b.
construction projects in Ghana. Australasian Journal of
Construction Economics and Building, 10(1/2):103–116. Relationship between Factors of Construction Resources Affecting
Project Cost. Modern Applied Science, 7(1): 67–75.
[16] Gündüz, M., Nielsen, Y., Özdemir, M., 2013. Quantification of
[37] Saad, A. 2011. Factors Impacting The Project’s Life Cycle.
Delay Factors by Using Relative Importance Index (RII) Method
Retrieved from g-casa.com.
for Construction Projects in Turkey. Journal of Management in
Engineering, 29(2):133–139. [38] Sambasivan, M., Soon, Y. W. 2007. Causes and effects of delays in
[17] Iyer, K. C., Jha, K. N., 2006. Critical Factors Affecting Schedule Malaysian construction industry. International Journal of Project
Management, 25(5):517–526.
Performance : Evidence from Indian Construction Projects. Journal
of Construction Engineering and Management, 132(8):871–881. [39] Sweis, G., Sweis, R., Abu Hammad, A., Shboul, A., 2008. Delays
in construction projects: The case of Jordan. International Journal
[18] Kartam, N., 1996. Making effective use of construction lessons
of Project Management, 26(6): 665–674.
learned in project life cycle. Journal of Construction Engineering
and Management, 122(1):14–21. [40] Tumi, S. A. H., Omran, A., Pakir, A. H. K., 2009. Causes of delay
in construction industry in Libya, The International Conference on
[19] Kikwasi, G. J., 2012. Causes and Effects of Delays and Disruptions
Economics and Administration (ICEA), Faculty of Administration
in Construction Projects in Tanzania. Australasian Journal of
and Business, University of Bucharest, Romania, 14-15 November
Construction Economics and Building, Conference Series, 1(2):52–
59. [41] Zaini, A. A., Adnan, H., Haron, R. C., 2010. Contractors’
[20] Le-Hoai, L., Lee, Y. D., Lee, J. Y., 2008. Delay and cost overruns Approaches to Risk Management at the construction Phase in
in Vietnam large construction projects: A comparison with other Malaysia. In Proceedings of the International Conference on
selected countries. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 12(6):367– Construction Project Management (ICCPM) Chengdu, China: 330–
377. 334.
[42] M. Young, The Technical Writer's Handbook. Mill Valley, CA:
[21] Long, N. D., Ogunlana, S., Quang, T., Lam, K. C., 2004. Large
University Science, 1989.
construction projects in developing countries: a case study from
Vietnam. International Journal of Project Management, 22(7):553–
561.
[22] Love, P. E. D., Wang, X., Sing, C., Tiong, R. L. K., 2013.
Determining the Probability of Project Cost Overruns. Journal of
Construction Engi neering and Management, 139(3):321–330.
[23] Mahamid, I., 2011. Risk matrix for factors affecting time delay in
road construction projects: owners’ perspective. Engineering,
Construction and Architectural Management, 18(6):609–617.
[24] Majid, I. A., 2006. Causes and Effects of delays in ACEH
Construction Industry. Thesis of MSc in construction management,
Faculty of Civil Engineering, University Technology Malaysia.
[25] Memon, A. H., Rahman, I. A., Abdullah, M. R., Asmi, A., 2010.
Factors Affecting Construction Cost in Mara Large Construction
15