Reporting Sexual Violence Guidelines - Full
Reporting Sexual Violence Guidelines - Full
Reporting Sexual Violence Guidelines - Full
SEXUAL
VIOLENCE
CONTENTS page 4
01 IT'S THE SAME OLD STORY
It’s the Same Old Story: Rape Representation in New Zealand page 5
Newspapers (1975 – 2015)
Facts page 8
1
News media remain
the major and most
influential source of
information, ideas
and opinion about
crime for most
people around the
world.
Very few people have first opinions towards victims of
hand experiences of criminal sexual violence. Not only is
incidents and issues, hence the reality of sexual violence
news media (online and in our society distorted
hardcopy) are a primary source by being largely hidden
of information for most (Greer, (unreported) but further
2013; Thakker, 2012; Ujevic, bias can be introduced in
2015). In New Zealand, this media accounts of actual
is no different. cases if reporting reinforces
rather than challenges
Newspaper reporting on rape
misunderstandings about
is shaped and influenced by
sexual violence.
a variety of factors including
the journalists’ attitudes and
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
WHY HAVE
REPORTING
GUIDELINES?
Previous research has shown media
Sexual violence reporting has depictions can promote victim-blaming
historically been influenced attitudes which affect society’s understanding
toward sexual violence, promoting false
by myths and misconceptions narratives and rape-supportive beliefs
and presented in ways (Boyle, 2005; Carter, 2002; Kitzinger, 2004;
Moore, 2009). Rape myths – first defined by
that typically focus on Brownmiller (1975) – encompass prejudicial,
isolated incidents instead stereotyped, or false beliefs about rape, rape
victims and rapists.
of exploring trends or the
Ethical and responsible media sexual violence
broader context; asking why reporting guidelines for journalists can
it happens; or seeking out encourage victims and survivors of sexual
violence to come forward and seek help.
solutions that could prevent Media sexual violence reporting guidelines
it from happening again. can provide journalists with a greater
understanding and awareness of the realities
of sexual violence by equipping them with
resources to improve their reporting and help
them tell an accurate story. Moreover, they
would help change the way the public think
and talk about sexual violence. This would
involve shifting the conversation towards the
acknowledgement that sexual violence is a
broad and prevalent social problem, how we
can prevent it and how to encourage victim-
survivors to report to police.
3
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
HONOURING
TE TIRITI O
WAITANGI
AND CHALLENGING RACISM
WHEN REPORTING ABOUT
SEXUAL VIOLENCE
The Te Puāwaitanga o te Kākano report
Racism and sexual violence (2009) emphasised that sexual violence is
are intimately connected. viewed as a tool of colonisation against Māori
people, their whenua and resources. In other
Sexual violence has historically been words, sexual violence was not prevalent in
and continues to be used as a tool of Te Ao Māori prior to colonisation and where it
racist oppression against Māori and other did occur the consequences were rapid. Māori
communities of colour (Pennsylvania saw sexual violence and especially incest as
Coalition Against Rape, 2017). transgressing the mana, the status, the dignity
and the future birthright of not only the victim
Colonisation and the importation of colonial but also the abuser and his people. Shame
belief systems had a complex impact on was seen, lain, addressed, actioned and put
knowledge and relationships within Te Ao in its place (Pitman, 1996).
Māori. There is widespread acknowledgement
that colonisation has led to collective trauma Furthermore, literature highlights links between
for Māori and has had ongoing effects that the denial of Māori knowledge and tikanga
continue to be experienced today through and increased acts of sexual violence against
structural oppression. Today, those historical and amongst Māori (Te Puāwaitanga o te
experiences are repeated through ongoing Kākano, 2009). These beliefs and stereotypes
violence associated with racism, stereotyping about Māori and other communities of
and internalised oppression (Family Violence colour serve as justification for sexualized
Death Review Committee, 2020). violence and systematic oppression. Social
conditions and experiences of Māori and other
communities of colour have also translated
into higher rates of victimisation.
4
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
trc.org.nz/sites/trc.org.nz/files/
NEGATIVE EFFECTS INCLUDE:
AlternativesA4-booklet.pdf
Creating a fear of Māori; makes Pākehā
violence and abuse invisible; focuses the
stigma of violence on Māori whānau; reinforces
stereotypes of Māori as violent; increases
Māori belief in these negative stereotypes;
encourages media to sensationalise Māori
crime, and ignores state violence against
Māori (e.g. Ruātoki raids, being beaten for
speaking Māori at school, the systemic
removal and widespread abuse of Māori
children in state care, the Land Wars)
(Kupu Taea, 2014).
5
01
IT’S THE
SAME OLD
STORY
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
7
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
FIGURE 1:
Total number of articles (n=1833) concerning rape cases across time
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
1975 1985 1995 2005 2015
FIGURE 2:
Gender breakdown of voices
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
1975 1985 1995 2005 2015
This graph illustrates that the dominant the implications of a gendered voice on rape
gender that commits rape (men) is also the and seek out women’s voices to counter them.
dominant gender coming through in reporting The overall trend indicates that New Zealand
practices and speaking on behalf of women. newspaper media prioritise men’s voices in
This serves to doubly silence women; by rape reporting, which only serve to remind us
firstly raping her and then retaining the how strong patriarchal legacies are and how
controlling voice through media commentary. much more work needs to be done.
Therefore, reporters need to be conscious of
8
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
FIGURE 3:
Women’s voices across time
120%
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
1975 1985 1995 2005 2015
While positive changes have occurred, the on specific incidents that fail to engage in
reporting and representation practices over wider critiques of the societal attitudes that
the 40-year period Barton (2017) analysed support and perpetuate rape (Jordan, 2012;
can still be seen today. The media focused on Kitzinger, 2009; Meyers, 1997). New Zealand
stranger attacks, objectifies victims, reflects news media still predominantly reports rape
court-based discourse (which can excuse in terms that are titillating, arousing, and
perpetrators and perpetuate stereotypes sensationalist to readers.
about victims and victimisation), or focused
9
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
FACTS
Sexual Violence Young people are statistically at
in New Zealand 05 the highest risk of being sexually
assaulted; the 16 – 24-year-old age
Sexual violence can include any sexual act, group is four times more likely to be
attempted sexual act, sexual harassment, sexually assaulted than any other age
sexual coercion and sexual contact with force. group. This has nothing to do with
Lack of consent is crucial to sexual violence. Tinder or any other dating app.
Sexual violence can be perpetrated by, or
against, anyone regardless of age, gender,
People who are marginalised in some
socio-economic background, sexuality,
ethnicity or ability and has a wide prevalence
and high impact. The statistics listed below
06 way are also a more common target
for sexual abuse. Counting ourselves:
The health and wellbeing of trans
are provided by HELP Auckland (2019).
and non-binary people in Aotearoa
New Zealand (2019) found that
Māori are substantially over- disabled participants were more likely
02
1 out of 3 girls may be sexually
abused before she turns 16 years old.
08 crimes are reported and 3 of those
get to court. Sadly, only one of those
Most of this abuse (90%) will be done is likely to get a conviction. That’s 1%
by someone she knows and 70% will of all incidences.
involve genital contact.
Victims of childhood sexual abuse
03
1 in 7 boys may be sexually abused by
adulthood.
09 are twice as likely as non-victims to
experience later personal violence.
04
Approximately 1 in 5 New Zealand
women experience a serious sexual
assault. For some women, this
10 physical and mental health problems
resulting from sexual abuse and rape
happens more than once. can be significant. The long-term
effects of sexual abuse on children
have been correlated with almost
every known mental health disorder.
10
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
Consent
New Zealand law states sexual consent
cannot be given under these seven situations:
→ the survivor was under the age of 16
→ the survivor was threatened with force,
threat or coercion
→ the survivor was asleep or unconscious
Sexual Violation,
→ the survivor was intoxicated due to alcohol
Section 128 of the or drugs that they were unable to consent
Crimes Act 1961 → the survivor was affected by an intellectual,
The Crimes Act 1961 protects mental, or physical condition or impairment
everyone in New Zealand from
→ the survivor was mistaken about the
sexual violation. Under Section 128,
identity of the person (for example, they
the crime of sexual violation can
were tricked into thinking the perpetrator
be committed in one of two ways:
was someone else)
either by “rape” or by “unlawful
sexual connection”. → the survivor was mistaken about the nature
of the act (for example, they consented
only to vaginal sex but not to anal sex).
02 experiences
→ Informed – those involved know exactly
“Unlawful sexual connection” what they are consenting to
includes a much wider range of
offending – forcing someone to → Enthusiastic – an enthusiastic yes means
give or receive anal sex or oral those involved are really excited and keen
sex, same-sex offending, and to engage in activity. There is a damaging
offending with an object. It is still sexual script that exists which purports
a “sexual connection” no matter ‘male pursuer/female gatekeeper.’ It is
how slight the contact with the important to remember that non-consent
offender’s genitalia or anus, or with should not be the victim-survivors
the survivor’s genitalia or anus responsibility to prove.
– it includes penetration, and it
includes touching.
11
02
BEST PRACTICE
FOR NEWS
REPORTING
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
nsvrc.org/blogs/five-reasons-sexual-
violence-increases-disasters
cgdev.org/publication/pandemics-and-
violence-against-women-and-children
Consider word choice when
creating headlines
It’s distressing for victim-survivors and their
loved ones to read distorted headlines when
they’re already having to make sense of a
difficult situation.
13
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
!
Mention content/trigger/ Discuss prevention
graphic warnings at the Covering real, identifiable solutions and those
beginning of articles working toward them helps shift perceptions
of this issue and demonstrate that prevention
Sexual violence can lead to PTSD (among is possible, no matter the scale. If unsure,
other conditions) and it is vital to acknowledge contact sexual violence prevention experts.
these lived experiences and how trigger
warnings can empower survivors to look after
themselves day to day.
Represent diversity
Across reporting include a wide range
Describe sexual of people who are assaulted or who are
otherwise affected by sexual violence.
violence accurately This is not always possible, but journalists
It’s important to avoid euphemisms and must strive for different voices in their
common misconceptions. The following coverage. For example, think about survivors
suggestions were developed by Rachel across the lifespan, survivors of different
Harrison (2020): ethnicities, male survivors, LGBTQI* survivors,
people living with disabilities and other
→ Instead of saying child paedophile, child
underrepresented voices.
sex offender, child predator or perpetrator,
say children who have problematic sexual
behaviour. Instead of saying child porn,
say child sexual abuse images, child sexual
exploitation or child abuse material (if
referring to a sound clip).
→ Instead of saying they (the survivor/victim) Provide accurate information
didn’t fight back, or the child and adult
had a sexual relationship that lasted two about the severity of sexual
years, or non-consensual sex, say they violence and its impacts on
(the person doing the behaviour) did not
check that there was consent, or the adult
victim-survivors
sexually abused the child for two years, or Sexual violence is a broad and prevalent social
sexual violence/assault/abuse/rape. problem, journalists need to emphasise that
and critically discuss this, why do people
→ Instead of saying alleged victim, alleged
commit sexual violence? (Challenge patriarchy
perpetrator, alleged abuse, say survivor/
and traditional gender roles, challenge common
victim/person who experienced harm, or
myths and stereotypes, avoid pathologising).
person who has done harm (or offender if
there is a conviction).
14
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
Examples of helpful/non-
damaging reporting
stuff.co.nz/national/113090659/a-
third-of-women-university-students-
report-being-sexually-assaulted-
what-do-we-owe-them
stuff.co.nz/national/112654442/
slutshaming-for-women-and-
protection-for-men-is-this-system-
fair
stuff.co.nz/opinion/117440651/
courts-should-be-about-justice-not-
more-trauma FixedIt
Below is an example from
stuff.co.nz/opinion/117282610/ Jane Gilmore’s campaign
alison-mau-the-cycle-of-silencing- ‘FixedIt’ – aimed at rewriting
victims-is-beyond-frustrating news headlines to accurately
reflect the crime.
nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.
cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12287715
newsroom.co.nz/2018/11/28/91634/
law-firm-faces-new-sex-claims
15
03
RECOMMENDED
SOURCES
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
17
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
malesurvivor.nz
18
REPORTING SEXUAL VIOLENCE
References
Barton, A. (2017). It’s the same old story: Rape Lynch, E. (2015). Policy report prepared
representation in New Zealand newspapers (1975 for Wellington Rape Crisis: Sexual violence
- 2015). Master’s thesis. Victoria University of representations in New Zealand news media
Wellington. (Honours Thesis, Victoria University of Wellington,
New Zealand).
Brownmiller, S. (1975). Against Our Will: Men,
Women, and Rape. New York: Simon & Schuster. Marhia, N. (2008). Just Representation? Press
reporting and the reality of rape (pp. 1–59). London:
Boyle, K. (2005). Media and Violence: Gendering the
Eaves Lilith Project.
Debates. London: Sage Publications.
Meyers, M. (1997). News Coverage of Violence
Caringella-MacDonald, S. (1998). The Relative
against Women: Engendering Blame. California:
Visibility of Rape Cases in National Popular
Sage Publications.
Magazines. Violence Against Women, 4(1), 62–80.
Moore, S. E. (2009). Cautionary tales: Drug-
Carter, C. (2002). When The ‘Extraordinary’ Becomes
facilitated sexual assault in the British media.
‘Ordinary’: Everyday news of sexual violence. In S.
Crime Media Culture, 5(3), 305–320.
Allan, G. Branston, & C. Carter (Eds.), News, Gender
and Power (pp. 219–232). London: Routledge. New Zealand Crime and Victims Survey. (2018)
Key findings, Cycle 2, (October 2018 – September
Counting Ourselves (2019). The health and
2019), Descriptive Statistics. Wellington: Ministry of
wellbeing of trans and non-binary people in
Justice. Retrieved from https://www.justice.govt.nz/
Aotearoa New Zealand. Retrieved from https://
assets/Documents/Publications/NZCVS-Y2-core-
countingourselves.nz/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/
report-for-release.pdf.
Counting-Ourselves_FINAL.pdf (November 21, 2019).
Crimes Act 1961. Section 128. Retrieved from http:// Pennsylvania Coalition Against Rape (2017).
www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1961/0043/ Racism & Sexual Violence: What’s the Connection?
latest/DLM329051.html (November 21, 2019). Retrieved from https://pcar.org/resource/racism-
sexual-violence-whats-connection-1.
Family Violence Death Review Committee. (2020).
Sixth report: Men who use violence. Wellington: Pitman, M. (1996). ‘The Māori Experience’. In J.
Health Quality & Safety Commission. Retrieved Broadmore, C. Shand, T. J. Warburton & Doctors for
from: http://www.hqsc.govt.nz/assets/FVDRC/ Sexual Abuse Care (N.Z.) (Eds.), The proceedings
Publications/FVDRC6thReport_FINAL.pdf. of rape: ten years’ progress? An interdisciplinary
conference (pp. 301 p.). Wellington, New Zealand:
Gilmore, J. (2019). #FixedIt. Retrieved from https:// DSAC.
janegilmore.com/ (November 21, 2019).
Soothill, K. & Walby, S. (1991). Sex crime in the
Greer, C. (2003). Sex Crime and the Media. Devon:
news. London: Routledge.
Willan Publishing.
Te Puāwaitanga o te Kākano. (2009). A Background
Harrison, R. (2020). Social Media Guidelines. Tauiwi
Paper Report, prepared by Māori and Indigenous
Caucus: Te Ōhaakii ā Hine – National Network
Analysis Ltd for Te Puni Kōkiri. Wellington:
Ending Sexual Violence Together (TOAH-NNEST).
New Zealand. Retrieved from http://toah-nnest.
org.nz/images/Releasing_Te_Puawaitanga_o_
Heath, L., Gordon, M. T., & LeBailly, R. (1981). What
te_K%C4%81kano__FIXED.pdf.
Newspapers Tell Us (And Don’t Tell Us) About Rape.
Newspaper Research Journal, 2(4), 48–55.
Thakker, J. (2012). Public attitudes to sex offenders
HELP Auckland. (2019). Sexual Abuse Statistics. in New Zealand. Journal of Sexual Aggression,
Retrieved from https://www.helpauckland.org.nz/ 18(2), 149–163.
sexual-abuse-statistics.html (November 21, 2019).
Ujevic, D. (2015). (Re)presentations of sexual violence
Jordan, J. (2012). Silencing rape, silencing women. against women: An analysis of media reports of rape
In J. M. Brown & S. L. Walklate (Eds.), Handbook on (Master’s thesis, University of Ottawa, Canada).
Sexual Violence (pp. 253–286). New York: Routledge.
Wood, N., & Dickson, S. (2013). Reporting Sexual
Kitzinger, J. (2004). Media Coverage of Sexual Violence in Aotearoa New Zealand (pp. 1–19).
Violence Against Women and Children. In Karen Wellington, New Zealand: Tauiwi Caucus: Te
Ross & Carolyn M. Byerly (Eds.), Women and Media: Ōhaakii ā Hine – National Network Ending Sexual
International Perspectives (pp. 13–38). Oxford: Violence Together (TOAH-NNEST). Retrieved
Blackwell Publishing. from: http://toah-nnest.org.nz/images/pdfs/
ReportingSexualViolence.pdf.
Kupu Taea: Media and te Tiriti Project. (2014).
Alternatives to anti-Māori themes in news media.
Te Rōpū Whāriki, Treaty Resource Centre – He
Puna Mātauranga o Te Tiriti, Massey University.
Retrieved from https://trc.org.nz/sites/trc.org.nz/
files/AlternativesA4-booklet.pdf.
19