Review DC Current
Review DC Current
Review DC Current
Abstract — Current sensor plays an important role in power stations, etc. and needs accurate measurement of DC current.
industries, the information obtained from the current sensor is Saturable core reactor method provides a very simple means
used for controlling, motoring and protection. The paper gives of controlling AC current proportionally through load where
comprehensive review regarding various current measurement the current is approximately proportional to the direct current
schemes used in industries and utilities for DC current through the control winding. Another method of using shunt
measurement. Especially, the technical issues including resistor are having advantages over saturable core reactor
difficulties in hardware implementation among all current method. Shunt resistor is simple and economical too. This
sensing schemes like Hall Effect based current transducer, method can be used for both AC as well for DC current
typical shunt resistor method, saturable core reactor technique
measurement. The disadvantage of this method is voltage
and fiber optic current sensor have been extensively discussed.
The comparative analysis of these methodologies have been
drop that is the power gets dissipated in the shunt resistor and
presented. hence it needs proper cooling mechanism else it affects the
accuracy. Hall Effect principle is mostly used in DC current
Keywords — DC Current Measurement, Hall Effect, Fiber measurement due to its several merits. The disadvantage of
Optic Current Sensor, Shunt Resistor, Saturable Core Reactor shunt resistor gets overcome by this method having 0.1%
accuracy of the measured value. The Hall Effect current
I. INTRODUCTION transducer principle is based on magnetic flux nullification.
In electrical engineering, current sensing/detection is very This method also having certain disadvantages like little bit
important factor in case of transmission and supply of power complexity and weight goes upto several kgs for very high
to a particular load. The measurement of current ranging ampere of current. It also requires complex setup procedures
typically from few ampere to thousands of amperes or even so that the asymmetric magnetic field and cross talk problem
more. The selection factor of a current sensing method can be avoided. With advance technologies and development
depends on various requirements like accuracy, magnitude, in optical fiber, symmetry in magnetic field issues occurred
bandwidth, isolation, robustness, resolution, size, reliability in hall sensor gets overcome by fiber optic current sensor.
including cost. The current magnitude may be directly Fiber optic current sensor is based on well known Faradays
displayed on an instrument or converted into digital form for effect. The advantage of this method is negligible power
the purpose of monitoring or feedback control system with consumption, higher accuracy, less weight, better current
the help of appropriate design schematic. stability and no need of onsite calibration which ultimately
saves considerable amount of time [1].
Measurement of high AC and DC current can be achieved
by various methods. For measurement of AC current, several II. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS FOR
techniques have been used like Current Transformer (CT), MEASUREMENT OF HIGH DC CURRENT
Rogowski coil, Shunt resistor, etc. Measurement of AC There are various methods available to measure high DC
current is simply possible with conventional CT but in case of current of the order of several kilo amperes. Each method has
DC current, due to absence of frequency, core saturation its own advantages as well as few disadvantages because of
takes place including some other technical important issues some technical issues or problems related with hardware
and use of such CT is impossible. An alternating current implementation. The overall design of measuring
carrying conductor generates magnetic field around it which devices/instruments should look for the provision of suitable
is alternating in nature, however, in case of DC current, the display with required resolution which shows magnitude of
magnetic field is not alternating and is constant around the current and the key terms like accuracy, rangability including
conductor. Hence, in most of the power electronics and robust construction, techno-economical product, appropriate
power system applications, as the direct measurement of DC input/output isolation, compactness and less weight. The
current is not feasible, the magnetic field nearby conductor is mechanical stresses including vibration as well as
sensed and corresponding current flowing through a atmospheric conditions like moisture, dust particles, ambient
conductor is determined. DC current measurement techniques temperature should not affect the instrument. For working
are very special like Hall Effect based current transducer, out design considerations for measuring high DC current, DC
Shunt resistor, Saturable core reactor and innovative Fiber current magnitude range from 500 Amp to 6000 Amp has
optic current transducer. been considered. To avoid core saturation problems, it is
The high DC current sources have been used in electro recommended to use core material having high magnetic flux
winning industries, high voltage DC transmission network, density and higher permeability. It helps in overcoming core
electroplating, feeding power to electrical vehicle charging saturation problem as well as accurate flux mapping
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
including minimization of leakage flux is also possible. The [3]. Hall Effect transducer is used to measure the magnetic
accuracy of technique has to be 0.1% of set current and the field around a conductor and then the transducer converts
current stability is also 0.1% of the reading. The resolution the magnetic field into an electric quantity which can be
should be 1.0 ampere achievable and there should not be any easily measured with the help of appropriate instrument.
drift in the hardware design due to temperature and any other Hall Effect element is shows in Fig.2.
parameter. As the mV derived from the hardware
proportional to the current is to be used in feedback control
action, suitable isolation is needed.
III. METHODS FOR DC CURRENTMEASUREMENT
The following methods have been considered, designed
and further analyzed to measure high DC current.
A. Hall Effect based current transducer:
The Hall Effect was discovered by Dr. Edwin H. Hall in
1879 while he was a doctoral candidate at Johns Hopkins
University in Baltimore. With the arrival of semiconductor
material in the 1950's, first time it is being used combined
with integrated amplifiers and Hall switch is introduced for
world. The basic diagram of Hall Effect is shown in Fig.1[2].
Fig. 2. The Hall Effect element
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
2) Hall Effect current sensor without compensating x Path a-b-c: Now, while decrease in the magnetic
winding force, the magnetic field also decrease but the same
value is not repeated. At point 'o', magnetic force
Hall Effect sensor without compensating winding is becomes zero but magnetic field does not become
shown in Fig.4. The main purpose of compensating winding zero, because some magnetic material retained in
is to nullify the main field flux generated by the DC current. ferromagnetic material. To decrease this magnetizing
Absence of compensating winding will lead to increase in the field, applying magnetic force in opposite direction
saturation of core and it further increases the hysteresis loss. and at the point of 'c', magnetizing field will
Current flowing in forward and reverse direction in core completely become zero.
produces the magnetization and demagnetizing of core and
due to which hysteresis loss is produced [7]. The area under x Path c-d: If magnetic force is further increase on
the BH curve is directly proportional to the losses as the loop negative side, then magnetic field also increase in
area reduces losses. The B-H curve of DCCT core is shown negative side, after certain time at point 'd' the
in Fig.5. magnetic field is not increase. This is called
saturation point in opposite direction.
x Path d-e-f: Now, while decrease in magnetic force,
the magnetic field is also decreases, at point 'e' the
magnetic force become zero, but magnetic field is
not zero and it's retained in core material. When
magnetic force is increases in positive direction and
at the point 'f' magnetic field becomes zero.
x Path f-a: While keeping on increasing magnetic force
in positive direction and magnetic field gets
developing positive direction, at certain value a
magnetic field becomes Bmax and is called saturation
point [8].
B. Shunt Resistor:
This scheme works on the principle of the ohm's law, as
voltage across a resistor is commensurate with the amount
of current flowing through the conductor. This method is
simple, techno-economical and accurate, that is why it is
used in many applications and it is often preferred. The
voltage across the shunt resistor is proportional to the
Fig. 4. Hall Effect DCCT without compensating winding
amount of current flowing through the conductor. The rating
of a shunt resistor is 1500 Ampere at 75 mvolts. The ohm
law based shunt resistor scheme can be used for both DC
and AC system. The shunt resistor value is kept very small
to reduce the loss of power due to heating. The shunt is
connected in series and the voltage measuring instrument
i.e. voltmeter is connected in parallel to shunt. The current
flowing through the shunt will generate a voltage drop
which is measured and the voltmeter scale is calibrated in
terms of current. Fig.6 shows the DC current from high
current rectifier which is measured with the help of shunt
resistor method [9].
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
R - Resistance of shunt resistor The effect of Faraday is proportional to the magnetization
of the material given by the equation (2).
The calculation of current is very easy as from above
equation (1), as the voltage drop is measured with the help of θ = ݇ǤԦܯ
ԦԦԦԦԦǤԦԦ݀ԦԦ݈ (2)
voltmeter and the ܮresistance of shunt resistor is known.
However, addition of resistor in the circuit will generate Where, M is the magnetization, l is the length of the light
heating loss corresponds to the value of resistor added. path and k is constant depending on the propagating material,
Preventing shunt from getting over heated, its value is kept wavelength and temperature, θ is the polarization rotation.
very low around milliohms. With the advance technologies
The rotation of polarization is directly proportional to the
shunts are available in various forms such as metal layer
magnetic field intensity. The rotation defines the power of
technology, full metal shunt resistor, typical four wire shunt
the magnetic field H and the constant V of the Verdent.
configuration. Shunt resistor method can be used up to
current value of 2000 Ampere beyond which due to I2R Practical polarization rotation is given by equation (3).
losses, temperature increases and need cooling mechanism. θ = ܸǤԦܪ
ԦԦԦԦǤԦԦ݀ԦԦ݈ (3)
While selecting
the material for shunt wire, temperature
ܮ
The V is Verdet constant which is material's specific
coefficient 'α' for material has to be taken into consideration. rotation and is defined as the angle over the magnetic field
Temperature coefficient 'α' is the rate of change of resistance times the length (°/T•m). The expression of Verdet constant
value per degree of temperature change so it has to be keep is given by equation (4).
very low or nearby constant. The material used for shunt is
Nichrome (alloy of nickel, chromium and soft iron), V = (μ.θ)/(B.l) (4)
Manganin (alloy of 84% copper, 12% manganese, 4% nickel)
[10], Constantan (alloy of 55% copper, 45% nickel). These Where, V depends on the material's magnetic properties.
materials have less and almost constant 'α' and hence they are B is the magnetic flux density parallel to the light
mostly preferred [11]. Various materials used for shunt and propagation path [12]. The light may be explained as
their parametric values are given in Table 1. follows.
¾ Polarized light: It is a light in which the electrical and
TABLE I. PARAMETRIC VALUES OF VARIOUS SHUNT MATERIALS magnetic field vectors in the wave have a preferred
Shunt Material direction.
Property
Constantan Manganin Nichrome German silver ¾ Unpolarized light: There is no desired direction of the
Resistivity (ρ) at waves coming in in random directions with electrical
200C 0.49 0.43 1.33 0.23 and magnetic field vectors.
(Ω-m) X 10-6
Temperature Three kinds of polarization are exist and they are (1)
coefficient per 30 20 20 ؆50 Linear polarization, (2) Circular polarization and (3)
0C X (10-6) Elliptical polarization. In this scheme, only two type of
polarization linear and circular have been considered.
Density at 200C
8.9 8.4 8.1 ؆7.5
gram/cc x Linear polarization: When the electric field vector
Specific heat vibrates or travels in a constant direction in the xy
0.098 0.097 0.11 ؆0.1
kcal/kg 0C plane, a beam of light is said to be a linear polarization
state. It occurs if two oscillator elements are either in
phase or out of phase.
C. Fiber Optic Current Sensor (FOCS):
x Circular polarization: When the electric field vector
Effect of Faraday: The effect of Faraday is a magneto- undergoes uniform rotation in the xy plane, a light
optic effect which causes the polarization of light to change. beam is said to be circularly polarized [13].
When a light beam is passed through a material, the influence
Working principle is described next.
of the faraday is rotated by an angle in the dependence of the
magnetic field intensity parallel to the light. Faradays effect is A light wave is passed through a semiconductor light
shown in Fig.7. source. The optical modulator means an optical element that
controls light volume, phase and polarization state by a
signal given from the outside circuit. With liquid crystal or
optical crystal, the polarization state or phase of the light to
be injected changes with the electric field applied (voltage
applied across electrodes). Change of the light volume can be
also be possible by disposing an appropriate polarization
filter at the incident side and the injection side. Phase
modulation or frequency shift is caused to the light injected
from here and light intensity modulation can be performed by
changing the frequency of the ultrasonic wave [14].
First of all, two light waves with orthogonal linear
polarization in nature pass from the light source to the
sensing fiber coil through an interconnecting fiber. Then the
linear polarize d light can be transformed to circular
Fig. 7. Faraday's effect polarization with the aid of the quater wave sheet. When this
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
two circularly polarized light wave passing through the
magnetic field produced by the current caring conductor the
light waves starts travelling at different speed and thus they
create a phase displacement between the two waves ∆ Φ.
At the other end of the sensing fiber there is a mirror or
reflector whose angle of reflection is equal to the angle of
incidence, so light wave retraces its optical path back to the
optoelectronics module or it can also be supplied to the
interfero meter[15](another method) where the phase
displacement is measured and a phase displacement can be Fig. 9. Saturable core reactor
converted with th e aid of the signal processor. The total
difference in the round trip process is proportional to the line In control winding, variable DC current can be injected to
integral of the magnetic field along the closed path defined by control saturation amount. The AC current in the main
the sensing fiber and is therefore possible to directly calculate winding is not affected by the saturation of core in the DC
the current [3]. control winding [17]. Since the two windings are orthogonal
When the optical fiber is used for optical path of the in nature, mutual interconnection between them is negligible.
interferometer, single-mode optical fiber is used because light Under normal device conditions, unit works in the
with single phase is handled [14]. Working of fiber optic saturation region and must be removed quickly from
current sensor is shown in Fig.8. saturation at the beginning of short circuit process.
Impedances generally increases in nature and is low and
may not be appropriate if significant current limitations are
needed. A typical type of iron core saturable reactor can also
be used to achieve saturation by injecting DC current into
the main winding. In case of DC voltage and CT, these
provide separate DC output for use with integrated or
complex circuits from DC sources. Elemental DCCT
consists of two specific saturable reactor linked in series
opposition to common primary winding. On high
permeability (square loop) magnetic alloy, the reactors are
toroidally wounded. Typical practical circuit of saturable
Fig. 8. Basic working of Fiber optic current sensor core reactor is shown in Fig.10.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TABLE II. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF VARIOUS METHODS FOR considering various parameters of interest keeping the typical
MEASUREMENT OF KA RANGE DC CURRENT
application of the DC current sensors.
Fiber optic
Saturable
Parameter Hall efffect Shunt resistor current REFERENCES
core reactor
sensor [1] A. K. Sawhney and Puneet Sawhney, "A Course in Electrical and
Working Simpler than Electronic Measurements and Instrumentation" 1985 4th edition
Very simple Complex Simple
principle FOSC pubished by Dhanpet Rai and sons, pp.126.
0.2 to 1.5%
High upto ± [2] Paul Peter Urone, Roger Hinrichs, "College Physics", Published by
Accuracy ± 0.5%, ±0.1% for 50 -100
0.1% OpenStax on Jun 21, 2012, ch 22.6.
microsecond
Current Uptp 2000 [3] "Hall Effect Sensing and Application", Honeywell Inc. Chapter no-
Upto 100 KA Upto 600 KA Upto 100 KA 1.Hal effect sensing , pp.1.
range Amp
Current [4] Klaus Bohnert and Peter Guggenbach, "Highly accurate fiber optic
Excellent Good Excellent Better DC current sensor for the electrowinnig industriees", IEEE Trans. on
stability
Temperature Industry application, vol. 43, 2007.
300C to 700C 400C to 600C 400C to 850C 500C to 800C
range [5] R.D.Kulkarni, D.S.Bisht, P.K.Bhaumik, H.P.Vyas and R.K.Sinha,
Required less "High Current Regulated, Variable DC Power Supplies for Simulating
On site
Required times than Not required Required Power Transients Expected in Nuclear Reactors", Proc. IEEE Int.
calibration conf. on Industry and Technology, vol.1, Jan 2000.
Hall Effect
Less space [6] Mehrdad Biglarbegian, Shahriar Jalal Nibir, Hamidreza Jafarian and
Compactness Bulky required than Compact Moderated Babak Parkhideh, "Development of Current Measurement Techniques
Hall Effect for High Frequency Power Converters", 2016 IEEE Int.
1.Proximity 1.DC to DC 1.Drive the Telecommunication Energy Conf. (INTENEC), Oct 2016.
1.Nevigation
sensor converter various loads [7] R.D.Kulkarni, P.K.Bhaumik, H.N.Karandikar and Miss. Ushakumari,
Applications system in air,
2.Positioning 2.Digital like motor, "High Current Regulated 600 kW Variable DC Power Supplies for
land and sea.
speed detector. motor control. furnace. Reactor component studies'', Proc. IEE DC and RF power source in
research and industry, Year 1990, pp.cp1.1 to 1.8.
IV. CONCLUSION [8] B.L. Theraja and A.K.Theraja, "A Textbook of Electrical Technology
The paper gives detail design considerations including in Volume I Basic Electrical Engineering", year 2005, published by
S.Chand and Company Ltd. pp.318 to 320.
comparative analysis of various high DC current
[9] Harumichi kato, Masashi Saito, Kuniyoshi Yoshino, et.al, 2018, "
measurement techniques/methodologies and contrasts them Shunt module development for simple DC High current
with parameters such as overall current range, current measurement", Conf. on precision electromagnetic measurements
stability, precision/accuracy, calibration, etc. Saturable core (CPEM2018 ), July 2018.
reactor system, which provides a very simple means of [10] Roman Malaric, "Instrumentation and Measurement in Electrical
remotely and proportionally regulating the AC current Engineering", published in 2011, pp.32.
through a given load. The current in the control winding is [11] J. Everhart, "Engineering properties of nickel and nickel alloys",
equal to the DC current. The system of shunt resistor has 1971, Chapter no-8, pp.160.
advantages over the method of saturable core reactor. Shunt [12] Sascha Liehr, "Optical Measurement of Currents in Power
resistor works on a very simple and techno-economical Converters", Microsystem Technology Group, School of Electrical
Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, March 2006.
principle. This approach can be used both in AC and DC
[13] A Yariv and P Yeh, “Photonics”, Oxford (2007), ch.1.6 - Introduction
systems. The main drawback of the shunt approach is power to Polarization.
loss, thereby reducing the accuracy of the current to be [14] Toru Yoshizawa," Handbook of Optical Metrology", Principles and
measured. Hall Effect is mainly used for the measurement of Applications. ch.4.8, 4.10, 25.1.3 (Retardation and Diattenuation)
very high DC current. It has 0.1% accuracy of the measuring [15] A. Sanchez-Castillo, S. Eslami, F. Giesselmann and P. Fischer,
value, can overcome the shunt resistor disadvantage. Hall Circular polarization interferometry: "Circularly Polarized Modes of
Effect needs sophisticated set-up procedures because of Cholesteric Liquid Crystals".
asymmetric field distribution and cross discussion problems. [16] Saturable Reactor for Power Flow Control in Electric Transmission
These problems are also overcome by the optical current Systems: Modeling and System Impact Study.
sensor of Fibre. The fibre optic current sensor is based on the [17] Nasser D. Tleis, BSc, MSc, PhD, CEng, FIEE, in Power system
effect of Faradays. The advantages of this method are modelling and fault Analysis, 2008.
negligible power consumption, very high precision, less [18] P.Odier, CERN AB/BDI, Geneva, Switzerland, "DCCT Technology
Review".
weight, longer durability and no on-site calibration is
necessary. Several merits and demerits have been mentioned
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT. Downloaded on August 16,2020 at 15:59:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.