Group 5 - Assignment 5
Group 5 - Assignment 5
AA 3102
Group 5
Capote, Shan P.
Lagudas, Roselene D.
Macasaet, Kent Paul Walter N.
Manliguez, Rhea Joy D.
Pingoy, Vilda Jeanette R.
Vasquez, Kristina Loren M.
Zosa, Andria B.
Problem
Henry Martin is responsible for preparing checks, recording cash disbursements, and preparing bank reco
Corporation. While reconciling the October bank statement, Martin noticed that several checks totaling P9
outstanding for more than one year. Concluding that these checks would never be presented for payment
check for P9,370 payable to himself, forged the treasurer’s signature, and cashed the check. Martin made
accounts for this disbursement and attempted to conceal the theft by destroying the forged check and omi
standing outstanding checks from subsequent bank reconciliations.
Requirements
1. Identify the weaknesses in Star Corporation’s internal control.
No segregation of duties - Bank reconciliations as well as preparation of checks and recording of c
are done by the same employee. Should there be proper segregation of duties, Henry Martin would
conceal the theft because the existence of the forged check and unrecorded disbursement will be de
knowledge that as an internal control, bank reconciliations should be done by an employee with no o
cash transactions to make sure that any discrepancies will be found and no records are manipulated
No periodic examination of outstanding checks - Star Corporation’s checks have been outstandi
year. Usually, checks are good for 6 months (180 days) and are then considered stale checks. Othe
explicitly indicate in their checks “void after 90 days"). Should there be a periodic review of outstandi
separate employee, Star Corporation would know whether payments should be stopped and to reco
cash in bank.
2. Explain several audit procedures that might disclose the fraudulent disbursement.
Since it is known that there is no segregation of duties for the aforementioned tasks, the auditor shal
Test of controls of the client’s periodic bank reconciliations - To check whether controls are in e
bank reconciliations. Usually, an employee who prepares the reconciliation does not handle cash dis
case of Henry Martin, the auditor must inspect the reconciliation made by the former and should take
or high-risk transactions.
Inquire and observe about the check signer’s procedures - The auditor must inquire and observ
signer’s procedures for reviewing the documents in support of cash disbursements to make sure tha
authorized and transactions are not fictitious.
Accounting for serial numbers of all checks issued - This is done to examine that all checks issu
and are recorded properly. The auditor must be aware that checks issued are in numerical/chronolog
the date issued and then matched with the recorded checks in the bank statement.
Vouching all checks paid by the bank - To make sure that all checks issued by Star Corporation w
the bank to creditors, the auditor must vouch such checks. Should there be any discrepancies, missi
recorded checks but paid to a fictitious creditor, then the possibility of fraud arises.
List outstanding checks - The auditor must ask or prepare a list of outstanding checks to determin
checks were paid during the period or were listed as outstanding at the end of the period. Should the
discrepancies, then necessary adjustments must be made.
ts, and preparing bank reconciliations for Star
t several checks totaling P9,370 had been
r be presented for payments, Martin prepared a
hed the check. Martin made no entry in the
g the forged check and omitting the long-
sbursement.
oned tasks, the auditor shall do the following:
eck whether controls are in effect when preparing
on does not handle cash disbursements. In the
y the former and should take note of any unusual
1. Identify the potential audit problems that may be indicated by the schedule.
Rectangle Corporation's stock is not publicly traded and it is not a listed business. Consequently, it
challenging scenario when attempting to calculate the stock's fair value, and a valuation model mus
do so.
As convertible bonds of Line Corporation are securities with implanted derivatives, therefore the ma
account for each option individually. This calls for a valuation model that takes the value of the optio
into account independently.
2. To value the shares of Rectangle Corporation, management has employed a securities valuation firm. E
considerations involved in auditing the value developed by the valuation firm.
When there is no active market for a security, management may hire an appraiser to determine the
As a result, the auditor should consult SAS 73, which places a strong emphasis on the need to get t
the securities from a third-party, qualified assessor. Auditor should analyze the reasonableness and
relevant model. Auditors should also ensure that the model considers all areas of risk such as risk o
market conditions, risk of legal and political nature. (PSA 620) USING THEIR GUIDELINES.
investments, you have just been given the
Required:
For each of the six preceding questions, provide the following information about Mama Company’s interna
Identify the financial statement assertion related to the control addressed in each question.
Identify a potential misstatement that could arise from the absence of the control you identified in part
Identify the test of controls an auditor might perform for the controls you identified in part a.
Indicate the substantive tests of transactions an auditor might perform after the test of controls if the co
Financial
# Statement There Potential
Payroll Misstatement
ismight include of
a possibility Test of Controls
Existence or
Assertion fabricated Approval
Examine signatures on musttime
1 employees
There is a or evenpaid
being retired
possibility offor
Occurrence
Rights and employees. be inspected.
cards to ensure that
Examine signatures on time
2 more hours being
employees than they
paid for Examine
Obligations
Rights and work - overpayment of employees
cards to are paid
verify
to ensure for the
whether
that
3 more hours
Payroll than
might they
include hours they
paychecks rendered.
are pre-
Obligations
Existence or work
salaries. employees
Examine
Approval to are paid
verify
signatures for
whether
mustthe
4 There - is
overpayment
fabricated a or
possibilityof
even retired
that numbered, and examine if a
Occurrence salaries. hours they
paychecks
be inspected.rendered.
are pre-
5 Completeness There employees.
paychecks may be issued
is a possibility bank reconciliation
that numbered, is
and examine if a
but not recorded. executed
6 Completeness paychecks may be issued bank reconciliation is by a person
but not recorded. unaffiliated
executed bytoathe payroll
person
operations. to the payroll
unaffiliated
operations.
ernal control questionnaire for Mama Company:
yee to the payroll?
nt to payroll?
people involved in supervising employees, personnel,
b. Outline the audit steps that you would take to enable you to render an unqualified opinion with
respect to the inventory. (You may omit consideration of a verification of unit prices and clerical
Perform and account a detailed computation of the closing inventory on the date of audit by
accuracy.)
1 reducing purchases and adding back sales to arrive at the inventory value of a previous
date.
2 Compare and verify the inventory value of the previous date with the inventory value
maintained in the records, and make note of any discrepancies found.
3 To ensure and satisfy that the records and the physical inventory match, inquire concerning
the items whose counts were most recently performed and perform a reverse calculation of
the current inventory.
Monitor the company's inspection process and examine patterns in order to make sure that
4
at every inventory taking, a different item is chosen and no material item is overlooked for
the entire year.
nventory? Discuss briefly.
inventory value
d.
tch, inquire concerning
reverse calculation of
List the items on the statement of comprehensive income and statement of financial position for 20X6 that
give the amount of error in the balance of each item affected.
List the items on the statement of comprehensive income and statement of financial position for 20X6 that
give the amount of error in the balance of each item affected.
Financial Amount of the
Item Solution
Statementof
Statement Errors
Inventory 72,533 250,000 - 177,467 = 72,533
Income Tax Financial Position
Statement of
29,013 72,533 * 40% = 29,013
Payable
Retained Financial Position
Statement of
Statement of 43,520 72,533 - 29,013 = 43,520
Earnings
Income Tax Financial Position
Comprehensive
Statement of 29,013 72,533 * 40% = 29,013
Expense
Net Income Income of
Comprehensive
Statement 43,520 72,533 - 29,013 = 43,520
Cost of Goods Income of
Comprehensive
Statement 72,533
Sold
Pretax Income Income
Comprehensive 72,533
Income
The accounts have been closed for 20X6. Therefore a correcting entry in January 20X7 is needed. Give th
250,000
10,000
4,000
5,000
2,500
271,500
40%
Explanation
uld be included in the ending inventory as such are still owned
e given amount includes the markup, to find cost, divide the
50% (Markup). It is to be noted that inventory should be
not constitute sale as the seller retains the title and control
uch goods are still part of the company’s inventory. It is to be
d be recorded at cost.
position for 20X6 that should be corrected for the above errors;
position for 20X6 that should be corrected for the above errors;
Value
Overstated
Overstated
Overstated
Overstated
Overstated
Understated
Overstated
WP1_a
Y COMPANY
Adjustments to Initial Amounts
December 31, 2017
Reference
SI#969, SI#970,
Goods sold in 2017
already but no
received shipments
and have
inventoried butmade
invoice was SI#971
received in 2018 RR#1060
Goods sold and paid but not shipped and inventoried SI#965
Goods
Goods received by 2017
sold, loaded but unloaded
and sealed in 2017inand
2018
switched off the RR#1063
company's siding in 2018
Goods sold and shipped FOB Destination but temporarily SI#968
stranded
Goods purchased and shipped FOB Destination and received SI#966
in 2018 RR#1064
Goods inventoried but deemed unsalable
TOTAL ADJUSTMENTS
PAJE 1
Sales (P5,841+P7,922+P2,010) 15,773
Accounts Receivable
PAJE 2
Purchases 2,183
Accounts Payable
PAJE 3
Accounts Receivable 12,700
Sales
PAJE 5
Sales 19,270
Accounts Receivable
PAJE 6
Claimed receivable 1,600
Merchandise Inventory
Freight in
PAJE 7
Inventory (P19,270/1.25) 22,286
Cost of Goods Sold
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
he client’s physical
:
8,120
15,416
23,536
1,250
24,786
Accounts Accounts
Inventory Reference Sales Purchases Reference
Receivable Payable
(15,773.00) (15,773.00) PAJE 1
2,183.00 2,183.00 PAJE 2
8,120.00
12,700.00 12,700.00 PAJE 3
15,416.00 (19,270.00) (19,270.00) PAJE 4
(1,250.00) PAJE 5
22,286.00 PAJE 6 (6,570.00) 2,183.00 (6,570.00) 2,183.00
15,773
2,183
12,700
19,270
1,250
350
22,286
a Prepare all adjustments for cutoff errors in accounts payable, assuming no acquisitions are made for c
WP2_a
ENGINE WAREHOUSE SUPPLY COMPANY
Inventory Cut-Off (Acquisition)
August 31, XXXX
Receiving Date Peso Amount
Date Received FOB
Report No. Shipped of Acquisition
682 8-27 09-01 4,674 Destination
684 8-30 09-02 -106 Shipping Point
TOTAL 4,568
PAJE 1
Accounts payable 4,568
Purchases 4,568
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP2_b
ENGINE WAREHOUSE SUPPLY COMPANY
Inventory Cut-Off (Sales)
August 31, XXXX Should be Was actually
Shipping Date Peso Amount of recorded in recorded in
Document No. Shipped Sale August? August?
311 09-01 56 No Yes
312 09-01 3,194 No Yes
313 09-01 635 No Yes
314 09-02 193 No Yes
TOTAL 4,078
PAJE 2
Sales 4,078
Accounts Receivable 4,078
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP2_c
ENGINE WAREHOUSE SUPPLY COMPANY
Adjustments to Initial Amounts
As of August 31, XXXX
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23 This transaction was
This transaction was
recorded
This in the books
transaction was
excluded as inventory
as a reduction
recorded
This in the to
books
from transaction
the books but was
inventory
b What is the amount of the client’sas
Thisa when
reduction
transaction
recorded in the itwas
to
books
was included in the
error in inventory assuming a periodic inventory method and no adju
should
inventory notasbeinventory
when since
recorded
as
affected inventory? For retail sales, aassume
reduction
physical thetoitgross margin is approximately 30%.
count.
goods
should were
when it not shipped
be since
should not
it be
Error (P2,405.5) inventory
Nevertheless,
Overstatement
after
goods August
were
when
31.
this
shippedSince
because
should
transaction goods
not be have
since
should not Overstated or
the
after
been
goodsgiven
Augustamount
received
were 31. is
Since
after
shipped
Receiving Date be recorded because Amount of Understated
the selling
August
after 31
August price,
Explanation
given amount
(FOB
31. tois
Since
Report No. goods have
Received compute for the cost, been Error with Regards
682 09-01 the selling
Destination).
the givenafter
received price,
amount tois
August -4,674 Overstated
multiply the given to Inventory
683 09-02 compute
the sellingfor the
price,
31 (FOB Destination). cost,
to -450 Overstated
amount
computeby
multiply forthe
the given
the cost, Overstated or
Shipping Date difference
amount by
multiply of
thethe 100%
given Amount of Understated
Explanation
Document No. Shipped and amount30%
difference bywhich
ofthe100%is Error with Regards
311 09-01 70%.
and (56 which
30%
difference *of70%)
100%is 39.2 Understated
to Inventory
312 09-01 70%.30%
and (3194 * 70%)
which is 2,235.80 Understated
313 09-01 70%. (635 * 70%) 444.5 Understated
WP3_a
ISABELA COMPANY
Inventory Reconciliation
December 31, 20X7
Inventory
Unadjusted Balance GL 1,250,000
Add (Deduct) Adjustments:
Parts held on consignment (155,000)
Goods sold included in inventory (22,000)
Goods sold F.O.B. shipping point
Goods held by retailers 0.00 210,000
Goods in transit 25,000
Bill on freight 2,000
Purchase discount (5,300)
Adjusted Balance 1,304,700
PAJE 1
Accounts payable 155,000
Merchandise inventory 155,000
PAJE 2
Cost of sales 22,000
Merchandise inventory 22,000
PAJE 3
Accounts receivable 40,000
Sales 40,000
PAJE 4
Merchandise inventory 210,000
Finished Goods 210,000
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_b
ISABELA COMPANY
Accounts Receivable Reconciliation
December 31, 20X7
Accounts Receivable
Unadjusted balance 0.00
Goods sold from F Company 40,000.00 PAJE 4
Balance 40,000.00
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_c
ISABELA COMPANY
Accounts Payable Reconciliation
December 31, 20X7
Accounts Payable
Unadjusted balance 1,000,000.00 GL
Consigned Goods 155,000.00 PAJE 1
Goods sold F.O.B. shipping point 25,000.00 PAJE 5
Quarterly freight bill 2,000.00 PAJE 6
Purchases from B Company 5,300.00 PAJE 7
Adjusted balance 1,187,300.00
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_d
ISABELA COMPANY
Sales Cut-off Testing
December 31, 20X7
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_e
ISABELA COMPANY
Purchases Cut-off Testing
December 31, 20X7
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_f
ISABELA COMPANY
Inventories Lead
December 31, 20X7
20X7
Description W/P Unadjusted
Ref Balance PAJE
Merchandise inventory WP3_a 1,250,000 1
WP3_a 2
WP3_a 4
WP3_a 5
WP3_a 6
WP3_a 7
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
WP3_g
ISABELA COMPANY
Proposed Audit Adjustments
December 31, 20X7
PAJE 1
Accounts payable 155,000
Merchandise inventory 155,000
PAJE 2
Cost of sales 22,000
Merchandise inventory 22,000
PAJE 3
Accounts receivable 40,000
Sales 40,000
PAJE 4
Merchandise inventory 210,000
Finished Goods 210,000
PAJE 5
Merchandise inventory 25,000
Accounts payable 25,000
PAJE 6
Merchandise inventory 2,000
Accounts payable 2,000
PAJE 7
Accounts payable 5,300
Merchandise inventory 5,300
Prepared by:
GFIVE 3.23.23
Sales
9,000,000.00
NONE
NONE
40,000.00
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
40,000.00
9,040,000.00
(22,000)
40,000
9,040,000 (22,000)
PAJE 5
Merchandise inventory 25,000
Accounts payable 25,000
PAJE 6
Merchandise inventory 2,000
Accounts payable 2,000
PAJE 7
Accounts payable 5,300
Merchandise inventory 5,300
Record as sale?
Cost Terms Date of shipment Per books Per Audit
22,000.00 Net 30 - Yes Yes
34,000.00 F.O.B. Shipping Point December 28 , 20X7 No Yes
20X7 20X7
Adjusting Report
PAJE Entries Balance
1 (155,000) 1,304,700
2 (22,000)
4 210,000
5 25,000
6 2,000
7 (5,300)
54,700 1,304,700
ecord as sale? Included in Inventory?
Per Audit Per books Per Audit
Yes Yes No
Yes No No