Supaporn p,+Journal+manager,+Ruchi
Supaporn p,+Journal+manager,+Ruchi
Supaporn p,+Journal+manager,+Ruchi
Ruchi Agarwal
Abstract
Introduction
In the 60 years since Independence, Indian cinema has gone
through a lot of changes including a shift from classic mythological block-
busters to “Bollywoodised” remakes of Hollywood’s successful films.
Women in the Indian film industry have played an important role in the
success of individual films. Their roles however have changed overtime,
from being dependent on their male counterparts to very independently
carrying the storyline forward. Before referring to the changes, it is rel-
evant to understand the importance of Indian Cinema in the world today.
According to studies and surveys, Indian films are screened in over a hun-
dred countries and watched by nearly four billion people worldwide. The
Indian film industry is considered to be the largest film industry in the
world with over 1000 films produced each year in more than 20 languag-
es where Hollywood produces less than 400 films per year, according to
available records. With the highest number of theatre entrances, about 3.3
billion tickets are sold annually in India . Another set of statistics states
about 750 films are made yearly in 72 studios and shown in about 12,000
cinema houses to weekly audiences estimated at almost 70 million; some
unusual records include Lata Mangeshkar in the Guinness Book as the
world’s most recorded artist; and Helen danced in a thousand films.
The Indian film market gets 90% of its revenue from non-Eng-
lish language films, mostly in Hindi followed by South Indian and other
regional language films . The CRISIL Research (2010) projects that the
industry is expected to grow from US$3.2 Billion to 2010 to US$ 5 Bil-
lion by 2014. Since this industry contributes a lot to the business and the
society, it is interesting to see the changing trends in Bollywood from the
past to the present time. The paper will start with a focus on the reasons
Mumbai was chosen as an important city for film production. The next
section provides a brief history of Bollywood and the rise of well-known
Bollywood stars. The later section will analyze the changes taken place
since 1940s followed by a focus on women and their changing role in the
Hindi cinema with reference to some specific films. The paper concludes
with some remarks and contribution of Bollywood and the important role
146
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
147
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
148
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
er generation still remember them. This was also the time when the women
were playing a very important role in the films holding a lot of responsibil-
ity on their shoulders to sell the films in the market. Women were given an
equally dominant role in the Hindu films along with the male actors. A few
examples include Mother India made in 1957 by Mehboob. The film was
made ten years after India gained independence from the British rule. In
this film the director, Mehboob, attempts to combine socialistic ideals with
the traditional values.
149
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
could not bear to see her starving children. She goes to Sukhilala’s place
and just when she is about to submit herself to Sukhilala, she gets a divine
signal that her husband is alive and leaves immediately with a new hope.
Next she is seen in the film as an old woman and her two sons Birjoo (Sunil
Dutt) and Ramoo (Rajendra Kumar) as grown men. Ramoo is a responsible
young man while his brother Birjoo is a good-for-nothing and resents that
Sukhilala continues to take three-fourths of their produce. Birjoo’s lack
of ability to control his anger bothers the villagers and is finally forced to
leave the village turning him into a dacoit. When Sukhilala’s daughter is
getting married Birjoo threatens to abduct her. Radha assures Sukhilala
protection of his daughter’s honor and, when Birjoo tries to abduct her,
Radha shoots him dead
The film opens with Radha as an old woman being asked to in-
augurate a new canal constructed through her village. The men presiding
over the function are dressed simple wearing Gandhi caps referring to Rad-
ha as the mother of the village and refuse to let anyone but her inaugurate
the canal. The film begins with this opening note that Radha is a survivor,
a woman who will lead in the new period of prosperity and development.
The film shows the importance of a woman and that women identified with
India is not surprising. The term Bharat Mata (Mother India) is a part of the
Indian consciousness. There is a song accompanying the bridal procession
proclaiming that the woman’s fate is to leave home.
Radha is portrayed as every other woman as an ideal wife and a
daughter-in-law. Her love for her husband is comparable to the divine love.
She is responsible and full of common sense. Women watching this film
are expected to identify with her and the men are supposed to look at her
non-sexually and identify her as their own wives or mothers. This initial
process of forming a bond with the audience by having clear notions of
woman on the street is an important strategy. At different times the film
emphasizes on this connection.
Radha has three sons while Shamoo ridicules Sukhilala for hav-
ing a daughter. Her sons are shown leading her by the hand even though
they are very small. But even in the beginning act when Radha is a submis-
150
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
sive bride the counterpoint is playing along. Shamoo’s only parent, Sundar
Chachi, is a woman who has raised her only son alone and got him married
in style. She is a strong woman who is good to her daughter-in-law and
handles household matters and agriculture with equal competence. With
three-fourths of the produce going to Sukhilala, Shamoo and Radha have
to work hard to survive. There are many images of Radha and Shamoo
harvesting the grains together. She is alongside him all the time uncon-
strained by her gender. There is no contradiction shown between her role
as a farmer and that of a traditional wife.
When Shamoo leaves and goes away with his inability, Radha
takes over the family responsibilities. She never lost hope and the hope is
shown to be the source of her strength as things get bad to worse. In one
of the scenes, Sukhilala has taken her bullocks away; she is shown pulling
the plow herself. The close-up of Nargis Dutt as Radha with a plow on her
shoulder with an expression of pain and concentration is an image that still
survives in the mind of every Indian.
The song accompanying the scene nullifies the contradiction be-
tween the socialist working woman and the traditional Indian woman. The
lyrics of this song are so intense that every word is still remembered today.
It goes on to state that in this life only laaj is a woman’s dharma . The film
intends to show that a woman can carry these accepting beliefs as part of
her conditioning and can make use of them as part of the positive ethic of
fighting against the odds.
The second half of the film shows Radha as a typical mother who
showers her love and affection on her grown sons. Her son Birjoo turns
into a dacoit but is protected by Radha who tries to plead for forgiveness
from the villagers. But when Birjoo abducts a woman from her marriage,
Radha takes a stand and tells him to return the girl or she will shoot him.
Radha’s act of unity with the girl being abducted is not because of any at-
tachment but an act of unity with the whole of womanhood.
151
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
an era that brought a lot of changes. The Bollywood heroines lost their
strength and space to the hero. She was reduced to being a glamorous com-
ponent of the films, dancing around trees, being kidnapped, raped or killed.
One such example is of the film, Mirch Masala directed by Ketan Mehta in
1989, showing this changing role of women in the Indian cinema. A story
of Sonbai (Smita Patil) working in a chili factory in the western part of
pre-independence India. Her husband gets a job in the railways and leaves
for the city. In the meantime the Subedar (or tax collector, played by Nas-
eeruddin Shah) arrives to collect taxes and is attracted by Sonbai. He asks
the village headman, the Mukhi, to bring her but the headman brings the
wrong woman. The next day Sonbai passing by the Subedar’s camp where
she is stopped and grabbed by the Subedar. She frees herself and runs into
the chilli factory where she works. An old Muslim watchman Abu Miyan
(Om Puri) provides her with the protection. A parallel track is of Mukhi’s
wife, the Mukhiain, who is not treated well by her husband. She tries to
get support for Sonbai after learning that the males of the village includ-
ing her own husband have alied with the Subedar to handover Sonbai to
him. Mukhiain’s protest is rudely crushed by the men, and the Subedar,
accompanied by all the men of the village, reaches the factory breaking
the factory doors killing the watchman. In the final scene the Subedar ap-
proaches Sonbai when suddenly the other women in the factory throw bags
of chili powder on his face. A number of scenes in this film show women in
glamorous characters, like women dancing and the lustful Subedar looking
at them. In another scene he looks at Sonbai through a telescope.
152
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
The example of Mirch Masala does not mean that the females in
films were always left behind. Several films depict a more dominant image
of women as well. In the recent history of cinema the body became an es-
sential part of a success of an actress. Their bodies speak of time in the gym
spent in working out. For example, the leading lady of the I98os, Sri Devi,
is known as ‘thunder thighs’. Sri Devi, like other female stars, spends hours
in the make-up room and portrays the aggressive, dominating character. In
Himmatwala, an earlier film, she out-danced and out-fought the men. She
deals with the villains herself, defeating them. In some films she needs two
or three male stars to balance her role. In Joshila (1989) two of the top male
heroes in the film would barely hold on their role on their own when casted
against her. This was specially shown by a cover story in one of the magazine
saying: ‘Is Sridevi a hero?’ (Showtime, September, I987). This shows that
the attitude and the perception of women had totally changed by this time.
Later came the period of the 1990s bringing about more changes
seen in the Hindi Cinema. By this time came several films showing the
changing role of female component of Indian Cinema. One of them was
Mohra, made in 1994 featuring Akshay Kumar (as Amar Saxena), Ravee-
na Tandon (as Roma Singh), Sunil Shetty (as Vishal Agnihotri) and Nas-
eeruddin Shah (as Mr. Jindal). The story starts with the plot that Vishal
153
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
154
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
155
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
career. In Dil Toh Pagal Hai, Karisma Kapoor is a dancer loses to Madhuri
Dixit, whose main aim in life is to look for her life partner. Sushmita Sen
was shown as a model in ‘Biwi No.1’ but then she was also a home breaker,
and the forgiving homemaker wife in the same movie, Karisma Kapoor,
‘wins’ back her man.
Even the film Dil Chahta Hai, known to be a Generation X mov-
ie, made by a young director, caught to the traditional role for its female
leads. While the three male characters in the film had identities apart from
their romantic ones, the females didn’t have any identity of their own. Only
one character (Dimple Kapadia) is having a career but does not have a
happy ending while the man who loves her (Akshay Khanna) finds a nor-
mal girlfriend.
Among the directors of the above-mentioned films, several stud-
ied abroad and have their lifestyle influenced by the west values. They
have seen Hollywood films but still returned to traditional Indian values
and conservatism through the female characters in their films.
Yet another depiction of the changing role and image of women
would be the way a clear distinction is shown between the heroine and the
vamp, the good girl and bad girl. The vamp always smoked, bared flesh,
and was punished for her bad deeds. As Saira Banu a ‘foreign’-returned
girl- a smoker, a spoilt-brat, was shown in Manoj Kumar’s Purab Pachim
and then was taught a lesson by the hero. The good ones are always shown
as the very nice girls. The image of an ideal daughter or wife or daughter-
in-law was used in different avatars with only a change of name and loca-
tion. Singh (2007) shows how the popular cinema has drawn heavily upon
Indian mythology for its popular appeal. It mainly shares the interests and
values of male prejudice, dramatizing male fantasies of the female. Hence
a woman is depicted either as an angel or as a monster.
Sometime afterwards, in the 90s especially, the line between the
heroine and vamp disappeared. The heroine dressed as boldly and moved
as provocatively as the bad girl of old times. Some critics opined that as
an effect of globalization and consumerism where mass production de-
manded heroines to become more ornamental than real woman. She might
156
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
157
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
dian films are now competing with western productions on the world stage,
winning prestigious international awards. The success of Indian cinema
across the world is spreading the rich cultural traditions of Indian dance
and music to a global audience. Culture is the essential factor in the mod-
ern society and cinema in particular is acting as a mirror of the society. It
reflects many trends, existing virtues, social struggles, and the living pat-
terns. The Indian cinema portrays the essence of the Indian society. The
ethnic and traditional values of the Indian society, its cultural diversity
and the unity among the varied cultural and religious sects, is highlighted
by Indian cinema. Thus it plays a very important in depicting the Indian
values to the world. The Indian films are very popular all around Asia and
also in other parts of the world.
With globalization, the Indian cinema is becoming increasing-
ly influenced by Western cinema. Bollywood imports technical expertise
from overseas and many films are shot on western locations. Many Bol-
lywood films are also based on Hollywood blockbusters. However at the
same time Indian media has several reports on Bollywood’s increasing
influence in the world film industry and how it is competing with Hol-
lywood. Bollywood started in 1899 with the production of a short film
by a portrait photographer, Harischandra Sakharam Bhatavedekar, called
The Wrestlers. Hollywood’s birth however happened 11 years later in 1910
with a Biography melodrama. Since the coming of sound in 1931, Bolly-
wood has produced over 9,000 films (Mishra 2006: 1).
Today India is the world’s largest producers of films with a total
of 1,288 feature films produced only in 2009 compared to Hollywood that
produces 500 films per year on an average (BBC News 2011). Hollywood
has a worldwide audience of 2.6 billion while Bollywood produces more
than 1000 (not consistently) films every year and has a worldwide audi-
ence of 3 Billion. In terms of vieweship, Bollywood overtook Hollywood
in 2004 and has been leading ever since. The NRI also are playing an im-
portant role contributing a lot to the Indian film industry. The Bollywood
films are now changing according to the need of the modern world and
are also made according to the demand of the NRI’s. It is estimated that
158
Silpakorn University
Journal of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts
159
Changing Roles of Women in Indian Cinema Ruchi Agarwal
References
Ahmed, S. Akbar (1992). ‘Bombay Films: The Cinema as Metaphor for
Indian Society and Politics’. Modern Asian Studies 26, 2 (I992),
pp. 289-320. Great Britain.
Burra, R. (ed.) (1981). ‘Film India: Looking Back 1896-1960’. The Direc
torate of Film Festivals, New Delhi.
Husain, S. (I989) ‘Cinema’, in Robinson.
Bagchi, Amitabha. (1996). Women in Indian Cinema. Retrieved from
http://www.cs.jhu.edu/~bagchi/women.html
Laura Mulvey (1988), ‘Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema’. In Con
stance Penley (ed), Feminism and Film Theory, New York:
Routledge.
Mahmood, S & Mitra, M (2011), Bollywood sets sights on wider market.
BBCAsian Network, 24 June 2011. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.
co.uk/news/business-13894702
Misra, Vijay (2006). ‘Bollywood Cinema: A Critical Genealogy’. Asian
Studies Institute, Victoria University of Wellington.
Monica Motwani (1996), The Changing Face of the Hindi Film Heroine,
G Magazine Online.
Singh, Indubala (2007). Gender Relations and Cultural Ideology in Indian
Cinema: A Study of Select Adaptations of Literary Texts, Deep
& Deep Publications.
Spotlight on India’s entertainment economy: Seizing new growth opportu-
nities, Ernst & Young report, 2011.
Woke (2007). Bollywood vs Hollywood – The Complete Breakdown,
Advertising and Marketing, Bollywood, Business & Industry.
Retrived on 29 March 2009 from http://mutiny.wordpress.
com/2007/02/01/bollywood-vs-hollywood-the-complete-break
down/
‘Update on Indian M&E industry.’ CRISIL Research, December 2010.
160