A S I N G A P O R E

H OUSING
J O U R N E Y
A n d y & Ma n d y ’s S t o r y

KNIGHT FRANK SINGAPORE 2021

Knight Frank Sinapore | 1
 CONTENT

Introduction 04
Disclaimers
a Our Cashflow’s Premise 06
This paper is subject to the following limiting conditions:
b Assumptions 07
a) This paper proposes just one possible opinion in a wide range of
possible housing scenarios and disclaims all responsibility and
will accept no liability from any other party.
Build-To-Order flat 08
b) Reproduction of this paper in any manner whatsoever in whole or Stage 1
in part or any reference to it in any published document, circular or
statement without Knight Frank’s prior written approval of the form
and context in which it may appear is prohibited. Condominium 11
Stage 2
c) References to any authority requirements and incentive schemes
are made according to publicly available sources as at the date of
writing of this paper. Technical and legal advice ought to be sought Landed home 14
to obtain a fuller understanding of the requirements involved. Stage 3

d) Projections or forecasts in the course of the paper are based on

Resale HDB flat 18
past quantitative trends and made to the best of the Knight Frank’s
judgment at the time of report submission. However, Knight Stage 4
Frank disclaims any liability for these projections or forecasts as
they pertain to future market conditions, which change due to Outlook 21
unforeseen circumstances.

e) Knight Frank is not obliged to give testimony or to appear in Court

with regard to this paper. Authors Leonard Tay
Head, Research

Nor Adila Rahim

f) The statements, information and opinions expressed or provided Senior Analyst, Research
are intended only as a possible guide to some of the important Khoo Zi Ting
considerations that relate to the property market. Neither Knight Analyst, Research

Frank nor any person involved in the preparation of this report

Evan Chung
give any warranties as to the contents nor accept any contractual, Other
Contributor Head, KF Property Network &
tortuous or other form of liability for any consequences, loss or Project Marketing

damage which may arise as a result of any person acting upon or Editorial & Hector Tan
using the statements, information or opinions in the paper. Design Head, Marketing & Communications

Selvi Widjaja
Multimedia Producer,
Marketing & Communications

Michelle Bong Lejtenyi

Content Marketing Manager,
Marketing & Communications

Jane Sng
Assistant Manager,
Marketing & Communications

This report is issued in November 2021.

Photo Credit Shutterstock

Unsplash

2 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 1

 Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Stage 4
Snapshot of

Andy
Ma&
n d y ’s

Housing Journey
Upgrading to Upgrading to Downgrading
Getting a BTO
a Condominium a Landed Home to a resale HDB

Started Work

25 23 30 28 35 33 50 48 63 61

Age Age Age Age Age Age Age Age Age Age

Andy Mandy Andy Mandy Andy Mandy Andy Mandy Andy Mandy

Number of years since Andy

Year 6 Year 11 Year 26 Year 39
and Mandy started working

Combined Monthly
S$9,000 – S$12,000 S$12,000 – S$14,000 S$20,000 – S$25,000 S$26,000 – S$28,000*
Gross Salary

Purchase Price S$315,000 S$1.6 million S$3.5 million S$1.1 million

Selling Price S$504,000 S$2.4 million S$3.9 million N.A.

*Amount just before Andy retires at age 63.

2 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 3

A SINGAPORE HOUSING JOURNEY

Introduction
The housing market in Singapore can sometimes be a scary place for
homebuyers. With headlines of million-dollar Housing Development Board (HDB)
homes, escalating prices of suburban condominiums, and the ultra-rich buying
up penthouses and good class bungalows (GCBs) hitting the press, there can
be an undercurrent of anxiety among homebuyers, fearing that their housing
aspirations might vanish in the dust of runaway home prices.

And more often than not, when prices start to run upwards driven by brisk sales
volumes, there is a tendency of herd mentality where homebuyers join in the
urgency of frenzied home purchases fuelled by the fear of missing out, or by peer
or societal pressure. However, any household’s housing journey is not a sprint. It
is more akin to a marathon.

The housing market is by nature characterised by periods of volatility, triggered

by bull runs and bear markets. In similar fashion, during a bull run, a perfect
combination of heightened demand, diminishing saleable stock, low interest rates,
and steadily growing household savings and incomes create a homebuying herd.
The converse is also true in a bear market: economic recession and uncertainty
punctures demand, causing falling sales and prices.

Over the long term, such as the time-horizon of a typical couple from graduation
to retirement, the volatility of bull and bear periods is often also accompanied by
extended periods of stability. The volatility can even itself out over the course of
INTRODUCTION decades that typify the housing journey of ordinary households. Especially so in
Singapore, where almost ten years (from 2010 to 2018) of government measures
a. Our Cashflow’s Premise have effectively removed speculation from the market. From 2013 onwards, after
the implementation of the Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR), the price movement
b. Assumptions of private and public housing generally moved in tandem with demand and
supply, as well as growth in per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP), household
incomes and affluence.

Andy and Mandy’s housing journey by Knight Frank Singapore is meant to present
the various stages of housing transition of a couple in Singapore — a limited
sampling of the housing market in one sitting. They are a married couple who
met in university. They purchased their first home through the Build-To-Order
(BTO) programme by the HDB before slowly moving up the housing ladder in
Singapore. They are both professionals whose salaries have benefited from the
growth in household incomes in the past decade, as reflected in the Singapore
Census of Population 2020, and might even be considered fortunate to have
done fairly well in their careers.

Andy and Mandy’s housing journey is not meant to exhaustively represent the
housing choices and decisions of all Singaporean families, but perhaps at one
time or other, Singaporean homebuyers would be able to relate to certain parts
of our protagonists’ real estate adventure insofar as it might be relevant to the
multitude of the many diverse households living in Singapore. Andy and Mandy’s
housing journey is just one possible route that Singaporean homebuyers could
take from graduation to retirement.

Knight Frank Sinapore | 5

a Our Cashflow’s Premise
The housing journey of Andy and Mandy takes place under the assumption
that Singapore’s economy, political and social structure, as well as public
infrastructure, remain relatively stable and intact, barring any catastrophic
events such as war or natural disaster of the sort that could damage
Singapore’s built environment unalterably.

Even when Singapore was steeped in the COVID-19 pandemic, the housing
market bolstered by healthy demand from homebuyers did not crash. While
the URA private residential property price index (PPI) dipped by 1.0% quarter-on-
quarter (q-o-q) in the first quarter of 2020 when the first cases of COVID-19 were
reported, prices have been on an uptrend ever since. More recently, the private
residential PPI recorded a 5.3% jump in the first nine months of 2021.

The private residential market was largely spared and even thrived amid
the pandemic, proving that the build-up of long-term fundamental growth
undergirds resilience. But this has given rise to another set of worries on housing
affordability in Singapore. Is the “Singapore Dream” of scaling the property ladder
still accessible to those who aspire and have the wherewithal to achieve it? As
we step through the housing journey of Andy and Mandy, a prudent, generally b Assumptions
conservative couple can navigate the housing market with a steady build-up of Andy and Mandy started working at the ages of 25 and 23 respectively. Their
financial resources to suit their different stages in life. starting salaries fresh from university were adapted from the Ministry of Manpower
(MOM) statistics, released on 24 December 2020. Across the different courses in
Knight Frank Singapore ran a simple cashflow model in nominal dollars using the respective local universities, the median monthly gross starting salary stood
assumptions that are possible for a young graduate professional couple to at S$3,600. By adopting an adjusted gender pay gap of 6%, as published by
realise their housing aspirations slowly and steadily. This cashflow model MOM in a report in January 2020, Andy’s starting monthly salary is assumed
charts each stage of Andy and Mandy’s housing journey through a selection of at S$3,800 and Mandy’s at S$3,600.
housing options given their affordability and savings under projected market
conditions based on the growth of the URA private residential PPI together A range of varying annual salary growth rates from 0% to 6% is apportioned to
with household income norms over the last 10 years. While their journey cannot them throughout the different stages of their lifetime to take into account their
represent all Singaporean households, perhaps along the way there might career progression. This is of course in consideration that during their early to
be certain scenarios that Singaporean homebuyers could find applicable to peak earning years, there would be a higher chance of getting promoted and
themselves, and the attendant references and information useful. For example, having their salaries increase at a faster rate compared to the later years of their
upgrading from a HDB flat to a private condominium. careers where salary growth starts to slow down.

Despite being relatively successful in their careers, having steady income The housing journey of one homebuyer will not likely not be the same as another
growth and being fortunate enough not to be affected by job disruptions, as individuals and families have their own unique set of needs, preferences and
Andy and Mandy have kept to one property at a time throughout their ambitions. Other indicators such as lifestyle, type of job, age, saving habits and
housing journey. The homes that they have upgraded to are always for their own the amount of disposable income spent on living expenses, play a part in their
use and enjoyment, and within reach of their financial resources through cash, decision when making a financial commitment with regards to purchasing a
Central Provident Fund (CPF) savings and housing loans. In addition, they have property. Furthermore, the household structure (i.e. whether it is a single home
shied away from additional investment property beyond the home in which they occupier or an individual purchasing a home with their spouse) would definitely
reside, and so are not liable for extra tax from the Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty influence housing requirements, especially so if couples decide to have children.
(ABSD). The size of a home, proximity to facilities and amenities such as shopping malls,
schools, and parks, as well as accessibility to transportation networks are some
of the important features that homebuyers look out for.

In the case of Andy and Mandy, it is assumed that they have two children, and
this will act as one of the determining factors in their homebuying decisions,
compelling them to upgrade to larger homes to accommodate for the expansion
in household size. However, as Andy and Mandy reach retirement age, the high
likelihood that their children have moved out of their home is factored into the
model. Faced by empty nest syndrome and the hassle of maintaining a large
home, Andy and Mandy decide to downgrade back to a HDB flat to spend their
retirement years.
6 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 7
 STAGE 1 BALLOTING FOR A STARTER HOME
Since April 2001, the BTO system by HDB has been the mode of sale for new
public housing. The system provides prospective buyers with the flexibility of
choosing the locations of their potential housing units as well as information on
the expected date of completion of the upcoming flats.

Given that Andy and Mandy are new to the property market, and that BTO flats
are generally more affordable when compared to resale flats or private residential
homes, they decide to book a 4-room unit of a newly launched BTO development
at Sengkang.

As of March 2020, there were 69,169 HDB dwelling units in Sengkang. Even
though Sengkang has undergone rapid development in the past decade, there
are possibilities to increase the existing HDB stock by another 26,804 units to
a projected ultimate total of 96,000 units according to the HDB Annual Report
2019/2020. It would not be inconceivable that a few more BTO projects could be
launched in the medium-term.

This would fit their budget at the start of their housing journey at a purchase price
of S$315,000.

Andy and Mandy are fairly conservative and opt for a loan provided by HDB,
thinking that this would be more predictable with less chances of fluctuating
interest rates disrupting the repayment. Moreover, they like that they can make
prepayments without penalty. This HDB housing loan would finance the remaining
purchased amount after deducting monies from their CPF Ordinary Account (OA)
— having already worked for about five years — as well as the amount that they are
BUILD -TO - ORDER FL AT eligible to receive from the Enhanced Housing Grant (EHG) of S$10,000.

The HDB housing loan serves as an alternative to private bank housing loans,
providing Singaporean public housing homebuyers a concessionary interest
rate pegged at 0.1% above the current CPF OA interest rate. The couple is
eligible for the HDB housing loan and they can take a mortgage that ranges from
S$180,000 to S$210,000 given the prevailing interest rate of 2.6% per annum
(p.a.). They elected to loan 62% of the total cost price.

Additionally, given the couple’s frugal nature and how they have no commitments
prior to the purchase of their BTO flat, Andy and Mandy potentially saved up to
about 40% of their net income. As a result, by Year 6, before they received the
keys to their BTO flat, they were able to furnish some S$188,000 of cash savings

8 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 9

Exhibit 1
Andy and Mandy have sufficient cash and CPF savings to pay the STAGE 2
downpayment of up to 38% of the HDB BTO flat’s purchase price
P RO P E R T Y D E TA I L S ( N E W BTO F L AT )

LO C AT I O N SENGKANG

T YPE 4-ROOM

TENURE LEASEHOLD

PROPERT Y PRICE S$315,000

AFFORDABILIT Y

TOTA L CO M B I N E D M O N T H LY S$9,000 - S$12,000* As the couple approaches

GROSS SAL ARY the five-year Minimum
TOTA L C A SH S AV I N G S* * ABOUT S$188,000++ Occupation Period (MOP)
on their HDB BTO flat, the
TOTA L C PF OA B A L A N C E * * ABOUT S$140,000++
family size expands with the
*A t t h e p o i n t o f k e y c o l l e c t i o n . T h e i r c o m b i n e d i n c o m e a t t h e p o i n t o f
addition of two children. Andy
a p p l i c a t i o n w a s b e t w e e n $ 8 ,0 0 1 a n d $ 8 ,5 0 0 t o q u a l i f y f o r t h e E H G .
**Before property purchase.
and Mandy now look towards
upgrading to a new home that
can accommodate a larger
Exhibit 2 household and is situated
HDB Loan Details within the vicinity to schools,
shopping malls, and transport
nodes — among other deciding
LOAN AMOUNT S$195,000 factors.
LOAN TENURE 15 YEARS
In order to upgrade, Andy
CONDOMINIUM
I N T E R E S T R A T E ( P. A . ) ~2.6 %
and Mandy sell their HDB
A N N U A L LOA N R E PAY M E N T ABOUT S$16,000++ BTO flat for S$504,000 to
finance their next property
purchase. This represents a
60% appreciation. In the current
Exhibit 3 market 4-room HDB units in
Allocation of Cash and CPF for Downpayment and Property Loan Sengkang are already achieving
prices beyond S$500,000 with
D O W N PA Y M E N T ( 3 8 % ) LOAN (62 %)
top line transactions of certain
CASH (5 %)* CPF (95 %) CASH (0 %) CPF (100 %) units breaching the S$600,000
* T h e c o u p l e c h o s e t o t o p u p c a s h b e y o n d t h e m i n i m u m S $ 2 ,0 0 0 o p t i o n f e e .
mark.

10 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 11

 MOVING TO A PRIVATE APARTMENT
As their BTO flat passes the MOP of five years, Andy and Mandy have both
progressed well in their careers and are promoted to managerial positions within
their respective companies. The couple contemplates upgrading to a resale
condominium, so they can enjoy the convenience of having facilities at their
doorstep while raising their two children. Exhibit 5
The OCR resale condominium that Andy and Mandy selects is within their
The couple settles on a resale 3-bedroom condominium in the Outside Central budget and means
Region (OCR) that sufficiently accommodates their growing family without P RO P E R T Y D E TA I L S ( R E S A L E CO N D O M I N I U M )
overstretching their finances. This will also allow the couple to avoid the waiting
time needed for a new launch condominium or executive condominium to finish LO C AT I O N OCR
construction and to be in control of their moving timeline.
T YPE 3-BEDROOM
With their existing cash and CPF OA savings, the couple considers areas such as TENURE LEASEHOLD
Hougang, Yishun, Pasir Ris, Bukit Batok and even Sengkang which they are familiar PROPERT Y PRICE S$1.6 MILLION
with. The couple is also careful to pick a project with sufficient remaining
tenure to ensure the value of their property does not run down when they decide T h e a p p l i c a t i o n o f a h i s t o r i c a l C AG R t o e s t i m a t e t h e f u t u r e p u r c h a s e p r i c e o f A n d y a n d
M a n d y ’s p r i v a t e c o n d o m i n i u m i s n o t i n t e n d e d a s a n i n v e s t m e n t p r o j e c t i o n .
to sell, providing them the flexibility to settle down in the condominium for the
longterm if they choose to.

Exhibit 6
Mortgage Loan Details

Exhibit 4 LOAN AMOUNT ABOUT S$1,200,000 ++

Andy and Mandy have sufficient CPF and Cash savings to pay off their
LOAN TENURE 20 YEARS
existing liabilities and upgrade to a suburban resale condominium after
residing five years in their HDB BTO flat I N T E R E S T R A T E ( P. A . ) ~1.3 %

A F F O R DA B I L I T Y ( A N DY A N D M A N DY ) A N N U A L LOA N R E PAY M E N T S$70,000 ++

TOTA L CO M B I N E D M O N T H LY S$12,000 – S$14,000

GROSS SAL ARY

TOTA L C A SH S AV I N G S* ABOUT S$350,000

SALE PRICE OF THE Exhibit 7

H D B BTO F L AT S$504,000
Allocation of Cash and CPF for downpayment and property loan
O U TS TA N D I N G H D B LOA N
ABOUT S$140,000++ D O W N PA Y M E N T ( 2 5 % ) LOAN ( 75 %)
BALANCE**
CASH PROCEEDS FROM SALE CASH (40 %) CPF (60 %) CASH (55 %) CPF (45 %)
S$175,000 – S$185,000
O F T H E H D B BTO F L AT * *
TOTA L CO M B I N E D
OA CPF BAL ANCE**
ABOUT S$320,000
(after CPF utilised plus accrued Andy and Mandy opt to pay about 25% of the cost upfront with their
i n te r e s t f r o m sa l e of t h e H D B BTO
flat have been refunded and before accumulated savings and proceeds from the BTO sale, while financing the
the purchase of the condominium)
other 75% with a private bank loan after paying off their outstanding HDB
*A m o u n t i s b e f o r e t h e p u r c h a s e o f r e s a l e c o n d o m i n i u m a n d d o e s n o t i n c l u d e t h e p r o c e e d s f r o m loan (Exhibit 6 and 7). The couple applies for a bank loan at an assumed
t h e s a l e o f t h e i r H D B BTO f l a t.
* * T h e o u t s t a n d i n g H D B L o a n w i l l b e p a i d o f f w i t h p r o c e e d s f r o m t h e H D B BTO s a l e a f t e r r e f u n d i n g interest rate of 1.3% p.a., which considers the potential refinancing of the
the CPF utilised plus accrued interest and cash proceeds into the respective accounts.
* *A l l p r o p e r t y e x p e n s e s s u c h a s B u y e r ’s S t a m p D u t y, m i s c e l l a n e o u s f e e s s u c h a s l e g a l f e e a n d existing loan. In the following years, their yearly mortgage repayment follows
valuation fee are paid by cash.
the allocation of 45% CPF and 55% cash savings.
Given that they purchased the condominium 10 years from when they first entered
the workforce, the value of the property would have changed from today’s prices. After 15 years of living in a private condominium, the couple has amassed enough
To adjust for this, the compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of the URA to upgrade again — this time to a landed home. Again, they sell their current
non-landed private residential PPI in the OCR over the past 10 years was home to make the transition, at just under S$2.4 million (estimated by applying
calculated. The CAGR was then applied to current prices to arrive at the possible the CAGR to the year of sale).
future value of their resale condominium purchase ten years thereafter (Exhibit
5).

12 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 13

 STAGE 3 UPGRADING TO A LANDED HOME
Andy and Mandy start to consider moving towards their third leg of asset
progression — upgrading to a landed home. By this stage in their lives, the couple
are in their late 40s and early 50s and are at the peak of their professions.

According to the Singapore Census of Population 2020, over the past decade,
the average total household income from work increased 35.8% from S$7,812
in 2010 to S$10,608 in 2020. Of these, the percentage of resident households
earning S$20,000 and over more than doubled from 6.6% in 2010 to 13.9%
in 2020. This growth was in tandem with the progression of the Singapore’s
economy, as the population became more educated and skilled over the years.
Andy and Mandy’s incomes have grown, and the prospect of a landed property
has become financially possible.

Landed houses comprise about 5% of all housing in Singapore and can be

considered to be the top of the residential pyramid in terms of property types.
While generally providing home occupiers with a greater sense of privacy and
freedom of space, these homes are not typically within the financial reach of
most except for the top income-earning brackets in Singapore.

At this juncture, Andy and Mandy’s combined monthly income total above
S$20,000, with their career fortunes remaining intact with Singapore’s assumed
continued growth and stability. The duo considers a freehold terrace house in
District 19, taking into account transportation networks such as the expressways
as well as the myriad of amenities within the region. Their budget for this new
home ranges between S$3.4 million and S$3.5 million.

LANDED HOME Being financially-disciplined all their lives, the couple finance at least 35%
of the purchase price through their savings accumulated over the years
in their CPF OA as well as cash, including the proceeds from the sale of their
previous condominium unit. Hence, assuming an interest rate of about 1.4% p.a.,
the loan amount could be well around the range of S$2.2 million to S$2.3 million.

14 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 15

 Exhibit 8
Andy and Mandy use a mix of CPF and cash savings to pay off their existing
liabilities and upgrade to a landed home after residing in their private
condominium for 15 years
P RO P E R T Y D E TA I L S ( L A N D E D R E S I D E N T I A L )

LO C AT I O N DISTRICT 19

T YPE TERR ACE

TENURE FREEHOLD

PROPERT Y PRICE S$3,463,000

AFFORDABILIT Y

TOTA L CO M B I N E D M O N T H LY S$20,000 – S$25,000

GROSS SAL ARY

TOTA L C A SH S AV I N G S ABOUT S$560,000++

S A L E PR I C E O F T H E PR I VAT E S$2,391,000
CO N D O M I N I U M *
O U TS TA N D I N G PR I VAT E
CO N D O M I N I U M LOA N ABOUT S$330,000++
BALANCE Exhibit 10
Allocation of Cash and CPF for downpayment and property loan
CASH PROCEEDS FROM
T H E S A L E O F T H E PR I VAT E S $ 1 .1 M I L L I O N – S $ 1 . 2 M I L L I O N D O W N PA Y M E N T ( 3 5 % ) LOAN (65 %)
CO N D O M I N I U M
CASH (43 %) CPF (57 %) CASH (65 %) CPF (35 %)
TOTA L CO M B I N E D OA C P F
BALANCE
(after the CPF utilised plus ABOUT S$988,000++
accrued interest from the sale of
the private condominium have
After 13 years, the couple reaches retirement age. They have lived their property
been returned to CPF before dream working their way up from their first HDB home to a landed house. In
purchase of the landed house)
this season of their lives, Andy and Mandy find that maintaining a landed home
* T h e a p p l i c a t i o n o f a h i s t o r i c a l C A G R t o e s t i m a t e t h e f u t u r e s e l l i n g p r i c e o f A n d y a n d M a n d y ’s becomes increasingly inconvenient and costly, bearing in mind that once they
private condominium is not intended as an investment projection.
*A m o u n t i s b e f o r e t h e p u r c h a s e o f t h e l a n d e d h o m e a n d d o e s n o t i n c l u d e t h e p r o c e e d s f r o m t h e stop working their disposable income is substantially reduced. As their children
s a l e o f t h e i r p r e v i o u s p r o p e r t y.
*The outstanding loan will be paid off with proceeds from the private condominium sale
have grown up and moved out, they feel the pull to transition back down the
after refunding the CPF utilised plus accrued interest and cash proceeds into the respective
accounts.
housing hierarchy, considering a smaller HDB resale flat for their retirement living.
*A l l p r o p e r t y e x p e n s e s s u c h a s B u y e r ’s S t a m p D u t y, m i s c e l l a n e o u s f e e s s u c h a s l e g a l f e e a n d
valuation fee are paid by cash.
The added attraction of cashing out on their landed property investment would
also serve to bolster their savings. Andy and Mandy sell their landed home for
S$3.9 million and with the proceeds downgrade to a HDB resale unit, husbanding
the rest of the funds to enjoy retirement.
Exhibit 9
Mortgage Loan Details
M O R TG AG E LOA N D E TA I L S

LOAN AMOUNT S$2,251,000++

LOAN TENURE 25 YEARS

I N T E R E S T R A T E ( P. A . ) 1.4 %

A N N U A L LOA N R E PAY M E N T ABOUT S$110,000

16 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 17

 STAGE 4
D O W N S I Z I N G T O A COS I E R S PA C E
The children have all flown the nest, traversing up and down stairs becomes a chore
for the two who are getting on in years, and the property now feels cumbersome
to maintain – a situation faced by many empty nesters, who no longer require
such a large living space.

Andy retires at the age of 63, while 61-year-old Mandy plans to retire in two years.
They agree to downgrade to a HDB resale flat in the Greater Southern Waterfront,
where they can enjoy the waterfront promenade and the recreational offerings in
their retirement. They choose a HDB 4-room flat that can comfortably host their
children and grandchildren on occasion even after downgrading. Perhaps they
might even rent out a room to supplement their retirement nest egg or employ a
live-in domestic helper when they eventually face mobility issues.

Exhibit 11
Andy and Mandy decide to unlock the asset value of their landed property
nearing retirement by downgrading to better suit their lifestyle needs

AFFORDABILIT Y
RESALE HDB FL AT
TOTA L CO M B I N E D M O N T H LY S$26,000 – S$28,000
GROSS SAL ARY ( J U S T B E F O R E A N DY R E T I R E S )

TOTA L C A SH S AV I N G S* ABOUT S$1,340,000

SALE PRICE OF THE S$3,941,000

LANDED HOME

O U TS TA N D I N G L A N D E D
A BO U T S $ 1 ,1 8 0 , 0 0 0 +
HOME LOAN BAL ANCE**

CASH PROCEEDS FROM

THE SALE OF THE LANDED S$670,000 – S$690,000
HOME**

TOTA L CO M B I N E D OA C P F
BALANCE** ABOUT S$988,000++
(after CPF utilised plus accrued
interest from sale of the landed have
been refunded and before the HDB
resale purchase)

*A m o u n t i s b e f o r e t h e p u r c h a s e o f r e s a l e H D B f l a t a n d d o e s n o t i n c l u d e p r o c e e d s f r o m t h e s a l e
o f t h e i r l a n d e d p r o p e r t y.
**The outstanding Landed Home Loan will be paid off with proceeds from the landed property
sale after refunding the CPF untilised plus accrued interest and cash proceeds into the
respective accounts.
* *A l l p r o p e r t y e x p e n s e s s u c h a s B u y e r ’ s S t a m p D u t y, m i s c e l l a n e o u s f e e s s u c h a s l e g a l f e e a n d
valuation fee are paid by cash.
Disclaimer: Andy and Mandy did not top up their Special Account with their OA balance to have
more fluid cashflow – their special account is enough to fund the retirement account at the age
of 55 up to the full retirement sum. After their Medisave Account reaches the limit, the excess
is transferred to the Special Account.

18 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 19

 A SINGAPORE HOUSING JOURNEY
Exhibit 12
Attracted by the waterfront and nature offerings in the vicinity, Andy and
Mandy relocate to live in the residential precinct of the Greater Southern
Waterfront
P RO P E R T Y D E TA I L S ( H D B R E S A L E )

LO C AT I O N G R E AT E R S O U T H E R N WAT E R F RO N T

T YPE 4-ROOM

TENURE LEASEHOLD

PROPERT Y PRICE S $ 1 ,1 0 0 , 0 0 0

Exhibit 13
Allocation of Cash and CPF for Downpayment and Property Loan

D O W N PA Y M E N T ( 1 0 0 % )
CASH (100 %)

Combined with the proceeds from their landed property, the couple can pay the
full price of the HDB resale flat using their existing CPF OA balance without
needing to take a loan. The remaining balance in their individual retirement
accounts at age 65 is also enough to qualify them for the upper tranche of OUTLOOK
the CPF Life Premium (extrapolated as of 2021) for monthly pay-outs, even in
scenarios when the amount of premium is adjusted upwards. Their substantial
cash savings from prudent spending and conservative financial decisions made,
and the remaining savings in their retirement account can be used to fuel an
active retirement lifestyle in their golden years.

20 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 21

 A General View
Andy and Mandy’s housing journey might not represent everyone else’s, but
there are different parts that would be relevant to various families at one
point in time or another. Admittedly, not everyone can be so fortunate to have
their careers progress as successfully as the couple’s. However, the opportunities
mentioned in their story exist in an environment such as Singapore, and there are
possibilities that elements of Andy and Mandy’s housing journey can come true
for Singaporean households.

After all, household net worth grew by 320% between Q2 1996 and Q2 2021 over
25 years, and more recently increased by 84.6% in the last 10 years from Q2 2011
to Q2 2021 based on data from the Singapore Department of Statistics (Singstat).
Household net worth does not include only growth in property assets, but also
savings, as the amount in deposits held have doubled in the past ten years. The
bottom line is that Singapore’s population continues to grow more affluent.

A well-governed political landscape, pro-business economy, increasingly

educated workforce, pro-home ownership housing policies and efficient civil

The Singapore Housing Journey

service have created a stable nation in the face of a volatile and constantly
changing world. Economic recessions, pandemics and other disruptions might
have interrupted Singapore’s progress at various points in time, but more than
55 years of these traits intentionally applied to nation building have led to The first stage of Andy and Mandy’s housing journey was a subsidised HDB flat
steady, incremental headway and also increasing household incomes. According bought direct from the government. For newly-married couples who have worked
to Singstat, the average monthly household income from work per household a few years to accumulate some cash and CPF savings under their belt and are
member increased by 48.5% between 2010 and 2020 or at a CAGR of 4.0%, willing to wait until the unit is ready for occupation, such a home would generally
with the percentage of wage earners in the “above S$20,000” bracket more than be within their financial reach. And even though couples might gripe about the
doubling from 6.6% in 2010 to 13.9% in 2020. less-than-ideal conditions and circumstances of the HDB BTO market (for e.g.
waiting time, high over-subscription rate, few mature locations, etc), this avenue
During the same period, the URA private residential PPI grew by 12.8% or at a allows almost every family with employed members to own their own homes. The
CAGR of 1.2%. Similarly, the HDB resale index rose 11.0% with a CAGR of 1.1%. financial outlay for a first home will seem daunting to most first-timers, but after
Income growth outpacing increases in both public and private residential prices a few years of regular mortgage repayment, income progression and a bit of luck,
would naturally lead to a real estate upgrading culture along with the aspirations of some households might be primed for an upgrade into the private home market.
the affluent. Andy and Mandy’s story incorporates quantitative characteristics of
these income and housing trends in the past 10 years to transcribe one possible Passage from a private condominium to a landed residence is more challenging.
destiny for Singaporean couples. Fortunes in career, business and/or investments would have to be relatively
benign over a lifetime to create an opportunity where a family such as Andy and
Mandy’s would have the resources for a terrace house. Such opportunities are
not typically available to all, but more so for the lucky and/or the successful.

It is hoped that the story of Andy and Mandy will be helpful to homebuyers as a
guide that provides some ballpark estimates to the types of potential real estate
options that can be considered, as well as the approximate corresponding amount
of savings, cash-on-hand and income levels generally needed to navigate from
one property to the next.

22 | Knight Frank Singapore Knight Frank Sinapore | 23

Contact us for market insights, and real estate opportunities.

RESEARCH PROPERTY NETWORK, CONTENT & PARTNERSHIPS

PROJECT MARKETING
Leonard Tay Evan Chung Hector Tan
Head, Research Head, KF Property Network Head, Marketing & Communications
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
+65 6228 6854 +65 6228 6878 +65 6228 7337

About Knight Frank Singapore

KnightFrank.com.sg Knight Frank LLP is the leading independent global property consultancy. Headquartered in London, Knight Frank
has more than 16,000 people operating from 384 offices across 51 territories. The Group advises clients ranging
from individual owners and buyers to major developers, investors and corporate tenants. Knight Frank has a
strong presence in Singapore with a head office and two subsidiaries: Knight Frank Property Asset Management
and KF Property Network. For further information about Knight Frank Singapore, please visit www.knightfrank.
com.sg.

© Knight Frank 2021

This report is published for general information only. Although high standards have been used in the preparation
of the information, analysis, views and projections presented in this report, no legal responsibility can be
accepted by Knight Frank for any loss or damage resulting from the contents of this document. As a general
report, this material does not necessarily represent the view of Knight Frank in relation to particular properties or
projects. References to survey findings (Knight Frank Retailers’ Sentiment Survey 2021) presented in this report
are allowed with attribution to Knight Frank Singapore. Any reproduction of the interview profiles, however, will
require expressed consent from Knight Frank Singapore and the interviewees.

24 | Knight Frank Singapore