Society Part 1
Society Part 1
www.visionias.in
SOCIETY PART – 1
S.N. TOPIC PAGE NO.
1. Salient Features of Indian Society 1-34
2. Regionalism 35-47
3. Secularism 48-59
4. Urbanization 60-79
5. Communalism 80-93
6. Role of Women and Women's Organisation 94-143
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
3.3.1. Kinship.......................................................................................................................... 6
3.3.2. Marriage....................................................................................................................... 7
m
co
possessions and physical comfort as more important than spiritual values. Indian society is
l.
ai
outlook that stresses human independence, self-reliance and liberty. Whereas collectivism
ha
si
is the practice of giving a group priority over each individual in it. There exists a fine balance
between them in Indian society.
• Blood and kinship ties- Blood relations and kinship ties enjoy a stronghold over other social
relationships. They continue to govern the political and economic spheres of life.
polluted.
l.
ai
which involves the removal of untreated human excreta from bucket toilets or pit latrines.
27
• Caste based violence in India: Increasing trend of caste-based violence are related to
instances of inter-caste marriage and assertion of basic rights by Dalits including land
rights, freedom of expression, access to justice, access to education etc. e.g. A group of
Dalits were attacked in Una, Gujarat when they had participated in the movement for
demand of land ownership for the Dalits.
• Policy of caste based reservation: The system of caste-based reservation in India
comprises of a series of affirmative action measures, such as reserving access to seats in
the various legislatures, to government jobs, and to enrollment in higher educational
institutions. E.g. Scheduled Caste groups are given 15% reservation in government services
and educational institutions.
3.1.2. Transformation of the Caste system
The traditional caste system was based on purity and pollution. It included the necessary
aspects like- hierarchy, separation of contact and occupational division of labour. However, due
to various factors, this traditional structure of caste system has been witnessed changes over
the last few decades.
reservations etc.
co
l.
• Changes in occupation: Occupational mobility has become the new feature. Leaving behind
ai
gm
their traditional roles, Brahmins have become traders whereas Vaishyas have joined
@
• Improvement in the position of lower caste: Due to steps initiated by the government,
ha
• Lack of funding for setting new enterprise, as they have very low security to get loans.
ai
gm
There should efforts to further promote participation of people in free market. Increased
si
prosperity would further dilute the caste identities. Also, there is a need to strengthen Section
123 of RPA 1951, to prevent parties from invoking votes solely on caste grounds. The
reservation system should be rationalized to target benefits only to deserving candidates so as
to usher in egalitarian society.
3.2. Religious Pluralism
3.2.1. Different Religious Groups in India
India is a secular country comprising various religions of the world, which are further
subdivided into several sects and cults. Religion in India is characterized by a diversity of
religious beliefs and practices. The Indian subcontinent is the birthplace of four world
religions—Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism and Jainism.
Further, variants of Hinduism such as Vaishnavism, Shaivism, etc. is practiced. Even in Islam,
multiple variants such as Shia, Sunni tenets are followed. Animistic and naturistic religions are
also followed by tribal groups. Thus, there is a plurality of multiple religions and each religion
has individual salient tenets and associated festivals and customs.
Our multiculturalism, on the other hand, means showing respect and tolerance to other
co
cultures and faith. It holds that all minority values must have equal status to those of the
l.
ai
gm
majority. It also allows assertion of different identities in every sphere of life. The Indian
@
constitution also provides fundamental rights for the preservation of this variety.
27
gn
representation, rise in demand for minority rights, indigenous rights, anti-hindi movements etc.
si
These assertions present a new way of assimilation where all communities find their respective
place in making of nation-state. No community is left out in creating a rainbow nation.
Multiculturalism and pluralism provides a new paradigm for stability which increases
cohesiveness and integrity of nation.
Thus, from the above discussion we can say that pluralism is the more general term for any kind
of plurality while the multiculturalism is the proactive application of plurality to maintain and
harmonize the diversity and heterogeneity in society in general and nation-state in particular.
3.3. Kinship, Marriage and Family
3.3.1. Kinship
Kinship system refers to a set of persons recognized as relatives either by virtue of a blood
relationship or by virtue of a marriage relationship. According to the Dictionary of
Anthropology, kinship system includes society recognized relationships based on supposed as
well as well actual genealogical ties. These relationships are the result of social interaction and
are recognized by society.
sanctioned by custom and law. It is also a set of cultural mechanisms which ensure the
l.
ai
The marriage system had undergone radical changes especially after independence. Even
ha
though the basic religious beliefs associated with marriage have not crumbled down, many of
si
the practices, customs, and forms have changed. The recent changes in the marriage system are
as follows:
• Changes in the aim and purpose of marriage: In traditional societies the primary objective
of marriage is ‘dharma’ or duty; especially among Hindus. But today the modern objective
of marriage is more related to ‘life-long companionship’ between husband and wife.
• Changes in the form of marriage: Traditional forms of marriages like polygamy, polygyny
are legally prohibited in India. Nowadays, mostly monogamous marriages are practiced.
• Change in the age of marriage: According to legal standards, the marriageable age for boy
and girl stands at 21 and 18 respectively. Average age of marriage has gone up and pre-
puberty marriages have given place to post-puberty marriages.
• Increase in divorce and desertion rates: Relaxed legislative provisions for divorce have
virtually affected the stability of the marriage, particularly in the urban areas. . It is mainly
due to economic prosperity and internet connectivity. Internet has exposed people to the
different social trends prevalent across the world and has revolutionized the institution
in an otherwise conservative Indian society.
o Agent of socialization
ai
gm
• Secondary function
ha
consuming unit than a producing one. Members are engaged in earning wages for
ensuring socio-economic well-being of the family.
o Educational functions: Family provides the basis for the child’s formal learning. In spite
of great changes, the family still gives the child his basic training in the social attitudes
and habits important to adult participation in social life
o Religious functions: Family is a center for the religious training of the children. The
children learn from their parents’ various religious virtues.
o Recreational functions: Family provides the opportunities to parents and children for
engaging in various recreational activities such as playing indoor games, dancing,
singing, reading etc.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
the household over those earning members. In many cities even women too joined men in
co
l.
• Influence of urbanization: Various sociologists have revealed that the city life is more
@
favorable to small nuclear families than to big joint families. Thus, urban living weakens
27
gn
• Legislative measures: Prohibition of early marriage and fixing the minimum age of marriage
si
by the child marriage Restraint Act, 1929, and the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 have
lengthened the period of education. Even other legislations such as the Widow Remarriage
Act, 1856, Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, Hindu succession Act, 1956, all have modified
interpersonal relations within the family, the composition of the family and the stability of
the joint family.
• Changes in marriage system: Changes in the age of marriage, freedom in mate-selection
and change in the attitude towards marriage has diminished marriage is not very much
considered a religious affair but only a social ceremony. Modern marriage does not
symbolize the superior authority of the family head over other members.
• Influence of western values: Values relating to modern science, rationalism, individualism,
equality, free life, democracy, freedom of women etc. have exerted a tremendous change
on the joint family system in India.
• Changes in the position of women: Main factor causing changes in the position of women
in our society lie in her changing economic role. New economic role provided a new
position in society and especially with respect to men.
sense of we-ness. It stands for the bonds, which hold the members of a society together.
l.
ai
gm
Unity in diversity essentially means “unity without uniformity” and “diversity without
@
27
When we say that India is a nation of great cultural diversity, we mean that there are many
si
different types of social groups and communities living here. These are communities defined by
cultural markers such as language, religion, sect, race or caste.
3.4.1. Various forms of diversity in India
• Religious diversity: India is a land of multiple religions. Apart from the tribal societies,
many of whom still live in the pre-religious state of animism and magic, the Indian
population consists of the Hindus (82.41%), Muslims (11.6%), Christians (2.32%), Sikhs
(1.99%), Buddhists (0.77%) and Jains (0.41%). The Hindus themselves are divided into
several sects such as Vaishnavas, Shaivates, Shaktas, Smartas etc. Similarly, the Muslims are
divided into sects such as Shias, Sunnis, Ahmadiyas etc.
• Linguistic diversity: Languages spoken in India belong to several language families, the
major ones being the Indo-Aryan languages spoken by 75% of Indians and the Dravidian
languages spoken by 20% of Indians. Other languages belong to the Austroasiatic, Sino-
Tibetan, Tai-Kadai, and a few other minor language families and isolates. India has the
world's second highest number of languages, after Papua New Guinea.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
In addition to the above described major forms of diversity, India also has diversity of many
other types like that of settlement patterns - tribal, rural, urban; marriage and kinship patterns
along religious and regional lines and so on.
• Climatic integration via monsoon: The flora and fauna in the entire Indian subcontinent,
co
l.
agricultural practices, life of people, including their festivities revolve around the monsoon
ai
gm
season in India.
@
• Sports and Cinema: These are followed by millions in the country, thus, acting as a binding
27
gn
1. The life cycle of a joint family depends on economic factors rather than social values.
gn
ha
Discuss.
si
2. Describe any four cultural elements of diversity in India and rate their relative significance
in building a national identity.
3. In the context of the diversity of India, can it be said that the regions form cultural units
rather than the States? Give reasons with examples for your view point.
4. The spirit of tolerance and love is not only an interesting feature of Indian society from very
early times, but it is also playing an important part at the present. Elaborate.
5. “Caste system is assuming new identities and associational forms. Hence, caste system
cannot be eradicated in India.” Comment.
6. Has the formation of linguistic States strengthened the cause of Indian Unity?
7. Debate the issue of whether and how contemporary movements for assertion of Dalit
identity work towards annihilation of caste.
1. Caste in India has maintained its political significance despite dilution of its social
character. Discuss with relevant examples.
Approach:
• Introduce by giving a brief account of caste and its basis in India.
• With the help of appropriate examples, explain in brief how there has been dilution
of its social character.
• Also, explain how its political significance is maintained.
• Conclude on the basis of the above points.
Answer:
Caste is a social institution in India in which people are ranked in a status hierarchy,
shaping their identity, experiences, relations with others, as well as their access to
resources and opportunities. Several developments since independence have reduced
the importance of caste as a basis of power and status in the Indian society. These
include affirmative state policies and acts that diluted the social character of caste, such
as:
• The concept of purity and pollution has been diluted due to the implementation of
strict laws to punish caste discrimination.
• Further, growing urbanisation has undermined caste. The relative anonymity of an
individual’s identity in a city makes it difficult for rules of purity and pollution to be
observed and enforced in the public sphere.
• There has been more inter-mingling amongst castes such as in dining behaviour,
where unlike earlier, now people from different castes eat together in social
functions such as marriages etc. The number of inter-caste marriages have also
increased. Modern modes of transportation and communication have increased
the volume of interaction between members of various caste groups.
• The nature of economic relationships has transformed fundamentally wherein
caste association does not hold as much importance in a modern market based
m
positive discrimination by the state has led to upward economic mobility amongst
l.
ai
gm
Despite the dilution of caste system in social sphere, it has maintained its political
27
gn
significance i.e.
ha
si
• Caste plays a very important role in elections and voting. It is being seen that the
political parties select their candidates on the basis of caste composition in the
constituency. The voting in elections and mobilization of political support from top
to bottom moves on the caste lines.
• Caste has influenced the policy-making of the government, for example the policy
of reservation in favour of certain castes. Indian politics changed dramatically after
the report of Mandal commission and since then there has been emergence of
explicitly caste-based political parties.
• Caste also functions as a pressure group in politics. Political bargaining is also done
on the caste lines. Caste organizations have emerged to organize caste members for
collective bargaining with each other.
Despite the retention of the political significance of caste in India, some progressive
trends are being witnessed. People have started looking beyond caste identity and are
considering parameters like socio-economic development, education & criminal
background of candidate etc. as criteria while voting. There seems to be a transition
from an attempt to make casteless society but to end caste-based discriminations.
Muslims (converts from the lower castes) don't remain in close social relations and
l.
ai
Christianity:
27
gn
• Syrian Christians in Kerala (converted Brahmin families who trace their origins to St.
Thomas) also exhibit caste characteristics. They organize annual gatherings
attended by prominent priests to proclaim the “artificially cultivated upper-caste
identity and lineage”.
• The Indians baptized by the Christian missionaries have remained mostly in the
same status they had before. Many untouchables who converted to Christianity are
still treated as untouchables by other Christians.
Sikhs:
Sikhism rejected the caste system in principle.
• However, in practice, the Jats who adopted Sikhism usually act along traditional
caste lines and marry within their caste boundaries. They don’t give equal respect
to Sikhs who belong to the lower levels of Indian hierarchy.
• The presence of castes like Arora, Khatri, Ramgarhia, Jat, Saini, Kamboh, etc. among
Sikhs proves that the features of Hindu caste system have percolated Sikhism too.
3. The present form of caste as an institution has been shaped both by developments
during the colonial period as well as changes witnessed in independent India. Discuss.
m
co
Approach:
l.
ai
gm
• Give a brief overview of the origin of caste system and its evolution.
@
• Discuss the caste system prevailing during British rule and how it got shaped by it.
27
• Then briefly discuss the measures taken to improve upon it post-independence and
gn
ha
4. While democratic institutions in India have led to changes in the caste structure,
these changes have at best led to only partial re-distributive outcomes for the
backward castes. Discuss.
Approach:
Introduce by defining the caste structure in brief. Then bring out the reasons which led
to changes in caste structure while illustrating on the changes. Further, point out the
positive and negative aspects of such changes and conclude accordingly.
Answer:
Caste as a social institution has existed historically and had been characterized by
hierarchical relations between different social groups. However, this hierarchical nature
of social order violates the trinity of liberty, equality and dignity enshrined in
constitution and recognised in Ambedkar's words "one man one vote and one vote one
value".
Also it has also been lamented that rather than weakening caste consciousness
ai
gm
democracy has strengthened it and this has been seen by some as impeding the aim of
@
Perhaps this examples support the thesis that democratic institution in India though
ha
si
have succeeded in imparting some changes in the caste structure but it were limited to
partial redistributive outcomes as far as backward caste categories has concerned.
• Setting up of National Commission for SCs and STs as well as setting up of National
gm
@
To compensate for past and current discrimination, the government has taken steps
ha
like:
si
• Providing reservation which involves the setting aside of some places or ‘seats’ for
members of the Scheduled Castes in different spheres of public life.
• Introduction of reservation for SCs and STs in 73rd and 74th Amendment Acts to
contest elections at the Panchayat level.
6. The mixing of caste and politics resulting into ‘politicization of caste’ and ‘casteization
of politics’ in contemporary India has become a grave challenge to our democracy.
Comment.
Approach:
• Briefly explain the status of caste and politics in contemporary India.
• Explain the relationship between caste and politics in reference to the terms,
politicization of caste and casteization of politics.
• Describe the challenges posed by the interaction between class and politics.
politics solely based on caste identity is indeed posing a challenge to the democratic
l.
ai
framework of India.
gm
@
27
gn
7. What are Personal Law Boards? Are their decisions binding on citizens? How can the
ha
si
incongruence between the principles followed by them and those of the common law
courts be reconciled? Discuss.
Approach:
• Give a brief overview about personal laws.
• Define personal law boards.
• Bring out some measures from the past as well the problem that need to be solved
to reconcile the incongruence.
Answer:
In India different religions are governed by their own personal laws. Every religion
follows its own personal law in the matters pertaining to marriage, adoption,
successions etc. All these matters are decided and mobilized by various personal law
boards representing the religion.
Personal Law Boards are non-governmental organization constituted to adopt suitable
strategies for the protection and continued applicability of Personal laws in India. The
8. In recent times, there has been a clamor for implementing Article 44 of the Indian
Constitution. To what extent is such a demand justified, given the socio-cultural
diversity of India.
Approach:
Introduce the answer by mentioning what Article 44 is. The answer should discuss the
m
co
Answer:
@
27
Article 44 of the Part IV directs the Indian State to implement Uniform Civil Code in the
gn
country. Uniform civil code means to replace the personal laws based on the scriptures
ha
si
and customs of each religious community with a common set governing every citizen.
These laws cover marriage, divorce, inheritance, adoption and maintenance.
The Indian-state is socially and culturally one of the most diverse countries in the world,
in terms of religion, language etc. Historically, most states feared that, identity politics,
recognition of social differences, was a threat to state unity. In such a context, time and
again, there has been a repeated demand to impose uniform civil code in India. There
seems to be some substance in the argument, considering the examples of some states,
like in Spain, Sri Lanka, and erstwhile East Pakistan.
Further, different communities have their separate Personal laws that often go against
the law of the land, apart from violating the rule of law, basic humanistic and rational
law. Therefore, it may be desirable that there is a common legal system which is equally
applicable to all the communities residing in India.
However, deeper analysis reveals that, it was the imposition of majoritarian culture and
the corresponding neglect of the customs and social symbols of the minority that led to
social unrest in the above mentioned countries. Moreover, suppressing cultural
9. Even after years of independence and despite modern legislation, the antiquated
practice of child marriage still persists in certain sections. What are the reasons for
persistence of child marriage in India? How does it affect our society? What can be
done to eradicate this practice?
Approach:
• Give reasons encompassing social, cultural and economic issues for child marriages.
These reasons should be more specific with respect to the persistence of child
marriage.
• Secondly mention the impact that child marriage has on society as a whole in this
modern context.
m
Answer:
gm
@
Child marriage is a traditional practice that in many places happens simply because it
27
gn
has happened for generations – and straying from tradition could mean exclusion from
ha
the community. On top of this, there is limited capacity among officials and lack of
si
willingness to go against community decisions, since officials are themselves part of the
community.
In communities where a dowry or ‘bride price’ is paid, it is often welcome income for
poor families; in those where the bride’s family pay the groom a dowry, they often
have to pay less money if the bride is young and uneducated.
Many parents marry off their daughters young because they feel it is in her best
interest, often to ensure her safety in areas where girls are at high risk of physical or
sexual assault. Limited education opportunities, low quality of education, inadequate
infrastructure, lack of transport and therefore concerns about girls’ safety while
travelling to school significantly contribute to keeping girls out of school and therefore
tend to favour child marriage.
Girls are often seen as a liability with limited economic role. Women’s work is confined
to the household and is not valued. Archaic laws such as those of Muslim Personal Law
allows the marriage of girls aged between 15 and 18.
10. Examine the contemporary trends and reasons for change in the traditional family
structure in India. Discuss the reforms needed in the existing social security protection
measures in this regard.
Approach:
• Briefly explain the traditional family structure in India.
• Bring out recent changes in the existing structure and the reasons thereof.
• Enlist the reforms required in the existing social security protection measures in
view of the changing family structure in India.
Answer:
m
co
The traditional family structure in India has been the joint family system, which has
l.
ai
been witnessing a change in contemporary times, i.e. a shift towards nuclear family
gm
system, perhaps as a part of the family cycle. The 1991 Census data suggested that
@
27
though nuclearisation of the family has been the dominant phenomenon, the extent of
gn
joint living is also increasing, especially in the urban areas. Also, in terms of composition
ha
si
of the family there has been a growth in the number of single parent families,
reconstituted families (step families) and same sex couples’ families.
Reasons for change in the traditional family structure in India:
• Historical/Political
o Land Reforms: They imposed ceiling restriction on the landholdings leading to a
theoretical partition, which further hastened formal partition and sowed the
seeds for separate living.
• Demographic
o Migration: The increase in the joint living in urban areas is mostly because of
the migration of the rural people and their sharing of common shelter and
hearth with other migrants from the same region.
• Economic
o Growing urbanisation and industrialisation: Lack of employment opportunities
in rural areas and regional imbalances fuel urbanization, putting a severe stress
on the joint family structure and in many cases it has developed a tendency
towards nuclearisation of families.
left without care. This need is more prominent in case of older women and widows.
co
l.
• Legal reforms: Review the working of Unorganised Workers Social Security Act,
ai
gm
2008 to ensure its effective implementation, as most of the urban nuclear families
@
• Extensive coverage: Provide paternity benefits along with the existing maternity
benefits. Also, extend the social security measures to single parent and same sex
families.
• Emotional support measures should be included as a part of social security due to
growing depression, alcoholism and drug addiction amongst youth because of
weakening emotional bondage in the families.
The social protection measures should be reformed not merely to guarantee survival,
but also to ensure social inclusion and preservation of human dignity within the family
structure.
• Middle class in India is often accused of ‘self exclusion’ i.e. withdrawing themselves
l.
ai
from the society e.g. gated communities, increased use of private sector even for
gm
• Growth of middle class in India is primarily led by the lower middle class, which is
gn
construction activities.
• There are deep inequalities within the middle class and between it and other social
classes. The primary beneficiary of liberalisation have been those belonging to
upper middle class and involved in high paying services (ICT, finance etc.)
• Upper caste Hindu’s dominate the new middle class. Other social groups such as
STs, as well as SCs and OBCs fare among the underprivileged and marginalized
groups within the middle class.
12. Marriage and family institutions in India are marked by continuity as well as change.
Discuss in the context of legislations and socio-economic changes that have been
taking place over the past few decades in India.
Approach:
• First, give a brief introduction to the answer on how marriage and family
institution in India are important .
• Social Changes
@
27
have influenced the outlook of educated young men and women. Hence, they
want to take their own decisions and make choices on the main events of their
life such as line of education, job and marriage.
• Influence of legislations on Marriage:
o Dowry Prohibition Act, 1996, Domestic Violence Act( DVA) , 2005, etc - have
made the position of women stronger .Now the women are given justice
against the "invisible violence" at home-physical and verbal abuse,etc which
they used to go through either because of dowry demands or otherwise.The
DVA, 2005, includes in its ambit live-in partners caters to the changing
dynamics of relationships.
o The ‘divorce’ laws have been made more flexible with the amendment of The
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 in 1986, by including the ground of ‘incompatibility’
and ‘mutual consent’ apart from the reasons provided earlier like adultery,
conversion of religion, etc. This has led to the institution of marriage more
susceptible to conflicts, fights, giving lesser scope to “compromise” and time to
save marriage and family. But on the other hand, it also gave the option to both
13. Explain India’s 'diversity in unity’. Illustrate from the socio- cultural life of people.
Approach:
• Write down how India is a plural society with extensive diversity in religion, races,
languages, culture, heritage etc.
• Provide some examples for each
Answer:
India's Diversity in Unity:
India's Diversity in unity refers to the existence of plural-ethnic, racial, religious and
linguistic cultures together within the nation of India.
The concept heralds the geo-political unity of the nation state of India encompassing
several diverse cultures within its uniform matrix.
The test examples of 'Diversity in Unity' can be highlighted through the following
examples from the socio-cultural life of the Indian people.
The Indian festivals are known for their enhancement and liveliness throughout the
world. The most important example, Diwali is celebrated by all. However, the meaning
and methods of celebration change across various religions and regional communities.
m
The architectural heritage symbolizes India's historic past and glory. The Taj Mahal is
co
famous as the symbol of love and dedication across all people. At a broader level, it is
l.
ai
gm
quite interesting to see people of various cultures visiting such heritage monuments;
@
14. “Linguistic, regional and tribal identity rather than religion has provided the most
important basis for the formation of ethno-national identities in India”. Explain.
Approach:
• Briefly describe different basis like language, region, tribe and religion as the basis
of identification with a community. Then examine how these identities have played
a role in determining the identity discourse in the country.
mobilization were:
co
l.
ai
The most important basis for the formation of identity was language. Community
si
aspirations vented out as the demand for linguistic states, ultimately leading to major
redrawing of the internal boundaries on the basis of language.
Secondly, the postcolonial development process tried to integrate and assimilate ethnic
communities towards the mainstream development process while ignoring their
cultural and economic specificities. The centralized planning and the capitalist
modernization further lead to the exclusion of various tribal communities from
mainstream. This led to the mass displacement of tribals from their historical and
traditional lands, without commensurate benefits of development being provided to
them.
As a result, a combination of ethnicity based on tribal identity, language, regional
deprivation and ecology provided the basis for intense regionalism resulting in the
formation of states like Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and very recently
Telangana.
Similarly, the ethnic demand for homeland created a number of smaller states in the
15. Indian society in ancient, medieval and modern times always exhibited an underlying
unity that created a composite culture, which is decisively pan-Indian in nature.
Elucidate.
Approach:
m
• Highlight how the cultural system stayed independent of the political system in
co
l.
India.
ai
gm
• Discuss the impact of the unity in creating a composite culture which is pan-Indian
@
Answer:
Unity has been the main underlying character of the Indian society. Various rulers in
their internal dynamics were frequently involved in wars at the regional level. However,
the aspect of cultural unity largely remained untouched and the mainstream composite
culture maintained its own status independent of the political system.
Ancient India saw the birth of Hinduism, Jainism, and Buddhism, but all these cultures
and religions intermingled and interacted. Co-mingling of cultural elements also
happened through language. Many Pali and Sanskrit terms developed in the Gangetic
plains, appear in the Sangam literature. Similarly, many Dravidian terms are also found
in the Indo-Aryan languages. The Aryans, Sakas, Kushanas with different socio-cultural
practices like language dressing, coinage, etc. became Indianized and cultural exchange
and assimilation further strengthened the underlying unity in Indian society.
Medieval India marked the advent of Islam into the Indian culture. Even during the
period of conflict and tension, there were movements that promoted cultural
unity
co
l.
ai
Answer:
gm
@
In India, there are more than 200 languages, being spoken by different groups. There
ha
si
17. It has been pointed out that in recent times, while the proportional share of nuclear
households has dipped in urban areas it has risen in rural areas. Analyse the reasons
behind this trend.
Approach:
• Distinguish between nuclear and joint families.
• Mention the relevant data to support the statement in the question.
• Elaborate on reasons for decline in nuclear families in urban areas.
• Elaborate on reasons for rise in nuclear families in rural India.
m
co
l.
Answer:
ai
gm
living alone or with unmarried children. While joint family is an extended multi-
gn
generational unit that includes parents, children, children’s spouses and their offspring
ha
si
as well.
Comparing the data of Census 2001 and 2011 of the division of households in
percentage terms it can be inferred that the share of nuclear households has declined
in urban areas, while it has increased in rural areas. Further, the fall in the share of joint
families has been sharper in rural areas as compared to urban areas.
TYPE OF RURAL AREAS URBAN AREAS
HOUSEHOLD Census 2001 Census 2011 Census 2001 Census 2011
Nuclear 50.7% 52.1% (+1.4%) 54.3% 52.3% (-2%)
households
Joint families 20.1% 16.8% (-3.3%) 16.5% 14.6%(-1.9%)
This is inconsistent with the generally assumed trend of rise in nuclear families with
rapid urbanization.
Reasons for decline in nuclear families and rise in joint families in urban areas:
• Lack of adequate housing challenged by increased migration, especially of the
labour is forcing people to stay together.
18. Separation, and not divorce, is the dominant form of marriage dissolution for most
women in India. What could be the possible reasons behind this? Also, discuss why
there are striking differences in divorce rates between the different regions in India.
Approach:
• Introduce the answer by explaining the issue of marriage dissolution in India.
• Clarify the difference between separation and divorce.
• Highlight why separation is a dominant feature.
• Also, account for varied divorce rates in different regions in India.
Answer:
Divorce is the annulment of marriage, while separation means the couple no more lives
together, however the institution of marriage remains intact legally. Separation may or
may not be followed by divorce.
m
co
According to Census 2011, the number of people separated in India is almost three
l.
ai
gm
times the number of people divorced. Reasons for higher percentage of separation are:
@
27
• Delayed judicial procedure: As divorce requires legal procedure, people settle for
separation fearing long-lasting, adversarial and costly court hearings.
• Changing gender equations: Many financially independent urban women who are
victims of harassment tend to separate to live a life of dignity.
Census 2011 points that divorce and separation rates vary widely across States and
regions. While the divorce rate for India as a whole was 0.24%, it was as high as 4.08%
in Mizoram. It stands at 0.32% in Kerala, 0.34% in tribal-dominated Chhattisgarh and at
0.63% in Gujarat. These are accounted for as follows:
• North-eastern States have a higher rate than rest of the country. This might be
because in North east India, tribal laws allow for informal relations and women
enjoy relatively higher social status because of existing matrilineal system.
• North Indian states like UP, Bihar, Haryana and Rajasthan which are known to be
deeply patriarchal have much lower divorce rates.
• Gujarat has the highest rate among larger states. The state has higher per capita
income and high literacy among bigger states.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
A region is a homogenous area which is culturally and physically distinct from the neighbouring
areas. In a region, people are aware of their similarities, however distinct they may be from
others. Based on this idea, they develop an identity. And based on this identity, they start
professing their political loyalties towards the region rather than to the state or the nation to
which they belong.
Regionalism is rooted in India's diversity w.r.t. (with respect to) caste, religion, language, class
etc. When all these factors get geographically concentrated, along with the feeling of relative
deprivation (i.e. a feeling that their community is not able to have access or benefit from such
access to the resources of the land), it is referred to as regionalism.
So, regionalism can be defined as a phenomenon in which people’s political loyalties become
focused upon a region. In other words, it implies people’s love for a particular region in
preference to the country and in certain cases in preference to the state of which the region is
a part. Thus the phenomenon of regionalism is centered around the concept of region.
here.
co
l.
ai
1. Demand for State Autonomy: Regional politics manifested in the form of people in certain
gn
states or regions demanding to secede from the Indian Union and become independent
ha
sovereign states. Such demands occurred soon after independence and are largely non-
si
existent now. The important examples in this context are that of the Plebiscite Front
(Kashmir), Mizo National Front (Lushei Hills of Assam), Nagaland Socialist Conference (Naga
Hills District of Assam) etc.
2. Supra-state Regionalism: It emerges in the form of expression of group identity of some
states. Some states unite to take a common stand on the issues of mutual interest. The
group identity is usually in relation to certain specific issues. It does not in any way imply
the total and permanent merger of identity of the states into the identity of group.
Rivalries, tensions and even conflicts do take place among a few states belonging to a
group.
Eg: Dravida Nadu demand prior to the re-organisation of the states,1956. Similarly, the
grouping of the North Eastern States for greater access to economic development is
another instance.
3. Inter-state Regionalism: It is related to state boundaries and involves overlapping of one or
more state identities, which threaten their interests. River water disputes, in general, and
other issues like the Maharashtra-Karnataka border dispute in particular can be cited as
examples.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
Princely States with the Indian Union, the loyalties of citizens were torn between old
gm
However, in the present day context, geographical factors are more closely tied to factors
gn
ha
resource-competition and relative deprivation amongst states. For instance, owing to North
East India facing problems of connectivity with the Indian mainland, its development
remains sub-par. This brings in a sense of discontent amongst locals and negatively affects
social solidarity. Consequently, North-East India has been a breeding ground for
regional/Secessionist politics and dissent.
Similarly, buffer-areas is another crucial geographical factor. For example, Bundelkhand
belongs to UP and MP. Neither do any of these states want to give up control, nor do they
want to take up the responsibility to develop it
2. Historical and Social Basis: Historical and social basis together are not only important
individually but also in conjunction with each other. They have contributed to Regionalism
in India in various ways:
a. History: History provides regionalist tendencies via some ideological bases through
cultural heritage, folklore, myths and symbolism.
For example, the demand for Dravida nadu was supported by the theory that the
Dravidian speaking area once had non-Brahminical polity, which was destroyed by
language is not the sole generator of regionalism. It is one of the several bases of
l.
ai
regionalism in India.
gm
@
also a major reason behind providing impetus to linguistic regionalism. For instance,
ha
castes of Tamil speaking region had been able to provide a powerful united thrust
against Brahmins who had earlier enjoyed unquestioned dominance in economy,
society and polity.
d. Religion: Religion may combine with other factors like economic dominance/ linguistic
homogeneity, etc., to push regionalistic tendencies. For example, the demand for
Punjabi Suba had religious undertones even though it was presented under a linguistic
garb. Similarly, secessionist movement in J&K also feeds off a sense of religious
orthodoxy and economic deprivation.
3. Economic Basis: In a developing country like India, resources are limited while the demand
for resources for the development of various regions is disproportionate to resources.
Economic policies have led to regional imbalances and wide economic disparities among
various regions resulting in discontentment among them.
Most of the demands for constituting new states were primarily based on allegedly unfair
and unequal distribution of development benefits and expenditure in multi-lingual states.
on these subjects, fall under the developed and advanced states, for example Tamil Nadu,
l.
ai
where health care services in Primary health centre is bench mark for other states.
gm
5. Political and administration failure: This is source of tension and gives birth to sub-regional
@
27
movements for separate states. Jharkhand, Chattisgarh, Uttrakhand and recently Telangana
gn
are result of these failures. Many such demands are in pipeline such as- Vidarbha,
ha
si
Saurashtra, Darjeeling and Bodoland, etc. These failures also weakens the confidence of
private players and do not attract investors in the states.
national integration. Both can exist together in a creative partnership. Both are in favour of
gn
ha
development.
si
Regionalism stresses the development of a region and national integration for the development
of the nation as a whole. If we want to reconcile the competing claims of regionalism and
national integration, the political system of the country should remain federal and democratic.
Regionalism is not disruptive of national solidarity. The important condition for national
solidarity is that nationalism should be able to hold the different types of regional sub-
nationalities together. In other words, there should be healthy reconciliation between
regionalism and nationalism.
Regionalism can make federalism a greater success. In this aspect, the accentuation of regional
identities should not-become problematic. It is quite natural that regional communities, who
are conscious of their distinctive culture, should interact with federal government on the basis
of a more equal partnership.
It will reduce the centralizing tendencies in a nation and power will shift from the centre to the
states. Conceived in any form, regionalism and sub-regionalism are unavoidable in a country as
vast and diverse as India.
Regionalism often poses a question with respect to the role played by Indian federalism in
ensuring India’s unity, stability and survival as a polity. Persistent regionalism, sometimes
coming on the verge of separation, is rooted in manifold and complex cultural, economic,
geographical issues as have been discussed before. The question around the role of Federalism
in India assumes special significance when looked from the historical examples of Balkanisation
of several large states in the past. For instance, the disintegration of the multi-ethnic and multi-
national Soviet Union, and the split up of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia are some examples.
The need for federalism becomes all the more important in countries with ethnically distinct
regions where the territorial accommodation of distinct groups of people is of paramount
importance. Such countries may utilise a combination of shared rule (analogous to a Union
Government) and some kind of self-rule (for regional/local governance) to maintain unity and
integrity.
India’s rich diversity sometimes looks like an obstacle to unity. But time and again, by remaining
committed to democracy, India has proved its capability in terms of resolving differences
peacefully and democratically, thereby transforming its diversity into a source of strength.
However, a few suggestive measures can still be followed to further strengthen the same:
• Doing away with regional imbalance
• Check on regional political parties
• Top priority to the economic development of deprived zones
• Restructuring of the society
• Acculturation
• Developed means of transport and communication
• Proper education
• Create enough growth and employment opportunities
• Special attention to backward states
• Improve National Integration
m
1. Linguistic Reorganization of States: Starting with the demand raised by Potti Sriramulu and
gm
creation of Andhra state(Initially in 1953, it was called Andhra State; Later in 1956 it was re-
@
27
principle. Sriramulu’s death forced Jawaharlal Nehru to agree to the various demands from
ha
si
other parts of the country with similar demands. Consequently, in 1954, a States
Reorganisation Committee was formed, which recommended the formation of 16 new
states and 3 Union Territories based on language.
2. Demand for Dravida Nadu: Dravidian Movement started in Tamil Nadu in 1925. This
movement, also known as ‘Self-Respect Movement’ initially focused on empowering Dalits,
non-Brahmins, and poor people. Later it stood against imposition of Hindi as sole official
language on non-Hindi speaking areas. But it was the demand of carving out their own
Dravidastan or Dravida Nadu, which made it a secessionist movement. As early as 1960s the
DMK and the Nan Tamil organized a joint campaign throughout Madras state demanding its
secession from India and making it an independent sovereign state of Tamiland. DMK
proposed that the states of Madras, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Mysore should secede
from the Indian union and form an independent “Republic of Dravida Nadu”.
3. Telangana Movement: In the years after the formation of the Andhra Pradesh, people of
Telangana expressed dissatisfaction over how the agreements and guarantees were
implemented. Discontent with the 1956 Gentleman’s agreement intensified in January
1969, when the guarantees that had been agreed on were supposed to lapse. Student
agitation for the continuation of the agreement began at Osmania University in Hyderabad
should remain federal and democratic. It is quite natural that regional communities,
l.
ai
who are conscious of their distinctive culture, should interact with federal
gm
@
government on the basis of more equal partnership. It will reduce the centralizing
27
tendencies in a nation and power will shift from the Centre to the states.
gn
ha
si
3. The roots of regionalism in India lie not only in the diversity of languages, cultures,
tribes and religions, but also in the sense of regional deprivation. Explain.
Approach:
m
co
Answer:
Regionalism is the expression of a common sense of identity and purpose combined
with the creation and implementation of institutions that express a particular identity
and shape collective action within a geographical region.
Regionalism in India is rooted in its manifold diversity of languages, cultures, tribes,
religions, communities, etc. It originates from the feeling of regional concentration,
which can often be fuelled by a sense of regional deprivation.
• Uneven development, marginalization, continued poverty, apathy of concerned
authorities, apparent rich-poor divide were some of the main factors that led to the
Naxalite Movement in India. The Naxalites are primarily active in relatively
backward states such as West Bengal, Jharkhand, Odisha.
• Similarly, states in the North- East have witnessed secessionist tendencies and
violent outbursts as there is regional imbalance in matters of industrial, agricultural
and above all, economic development. Lack of employment opportunities and
industrial initiatives remain persistent problems.
regionalism.
l.
ai
gm
Answer:
@
27
Regionalism is an ideology and political movement that seeks to advance the causes of
gn
regions. It has both positive and negative connotation. Positive regionalism means love
ha
The concept of secularism emerged in the context of the European societies. Often, one of the
earliest manifestations of secularism can be seen in the French Revolution, 1789, where the
people were inspired by Voltaire’s ‘Treatise on Tolerance’(1763). The legal foundation of French
Secularism (modern western secularism) can be found in a French law passed in 1905,
separating the church and the state (laïcité).
The rationale was to curtail the authority of the church and domesticate religion. Secularisation,
in the west was related to the arrival of modernity and the rise of science and rationality as
alternatives to religious ways of understanding the world.
Thus, secularism is a principle which advocates the separation of religion from politics. It is the
principle of separation of government institutions and persons mandated to represent the state
from religious institutions and religious dignitaries. Thus, religion should be separate from
aspects of state and governance.
Secularism seeks to realize a society that is devoid of either inter-religious domination or intra-
religious domination. It promotes freedom within religions and equality between, as well as,
within religions.
1.1. Manifestations of Secularism
The term secularism includes a separation between the state and religion. In fact, the nature
and extent of separation may take different forms, depending upon the specific values it is
meant to promote and the way in which these values are spelt out.
Thus, it has 3 manifestations:-
1. Differentiation: Religion will no longer be all encompassing and its presence will only be
restricted to the cultural domain.
2. Privatisation: Since religion is a matter of faith, it will be confined to the domestic space.
3. Decline in the social significance of Religion: The presence of religion in public space will
be prohibited and hence its social significance will decline.
m
1. Soft secularism argues for a legal separation of Religion & the State. It is tolerant of
27
religion and religious differences, and favours political accommodation of the religion while
gn
ha
rejecting the state interference that may undermine religious freedom. Seen in USA.
si
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
religious equality ( i.e., equal rights for all citizens irrespective of their religious preferences,
l.
ai
along with added protection for religious minorities) but also intra religious equality ( by
gm
ensuring that one sect of a religion does not dominate over other).
@
27
gn
The desirability of state intervention into religious matters has been upheld under the Indian
ha
conception of secularism to give space to progressive voices within every religion and to allow
si
disagreement with some aspects of religions. For example, the abolition of untouchability, sati,
dowry, the amendment of Hindu marriage & inheritance laws & the demand for establishing
the uniform civil code etc. can be seen as an application of this concept.
At the same time, the Indian ideal of secularism clearly cautions against allowing religion to
interfere in state matters, thereby disallowing mobilizing the electorate on religious lines for
winning elections on one hand while strictly spelling out that the Indian nation-state shall have
no state religion.
Some Judicial Pronouncements Regarding Secularism & Religious aspects in India
• In the Shirur Mutt case, 1954, the ‘Doctrine of essentiality’ was coined by the Supreme Court. Here
the court opined that only the religious practices which were essential and integral to the religion
shall be protected.
This doctrine was also applied in the Ayodhya case,1994, whereby the court opined that mosque is
not integral to Islam and that the ‘namaz’ can be offered anywhere. This doctrine was also applied in
the recent Sabarimala case, 2018.
This doctrine has been criticized on the fact that the court is entering into a domain that is beyond
its competence and gives power to the judges to decide purely religious questions.
In the separation of religion and state, political institutions i.e., those associated with varying
co
l.
levels of public government and administration, are removed from both direct and indirect
ai
gm
religious control. While religious organizations can air their opinions about public and political
@
issues, those views cannot be imposed upon the public, or be used as the sole basis for public
27
gn
policy. Therefore, while secularization is a state policy, secularism is largely a social process.
ha
si
Also, secularisation is not just the increase or decrease in visible markers of religiosity or in the
attendance count of religious places, but also a fundamental shift in religious belief towards
rationalisation and objectification.
5. Contemporary Issues
In contemporary times, various issues regarding secularism and freedom to practice and
administer religion have come to the forefront. These include the following:
• Implementation of UCC might interfere with the principle of secularism, particularly with
@
the provisions of Articles 25 and 26, which guarantee freedom relating to religious
27
practices.
gn
ha
In Sabarimala temple, Kerala, women between the age of 10 and 50 are not allowed to enter
@
27
the temple, since they are in the menstrual age group. A 1991 Kerala High Court judgement
gn
supported the ban on women entry. However, the case was referred to a three judge bench of
ha
the Supreme Court to deem whether excluding menstruating women constitutes “essential
si
religious practice.”
The Supreme Court in a 4:1 judgment gave the verdict that women were to be allowed entry to
the temple and that there should be no discrimination on grounds of religion. The court,
further, found such a ban on women entry to the temple to be a violation of Article 17 (form of
untouchability)
In Sep 2019, the SC re-considered its judgment on grounds of “constitutional morality”, and has
referred the case to a higher bench. It will now, not only consider this case, but all cases
allowing women’s entry into temples, etc.
5.3.2. Haji Ali Dargah
In 2012, the Dargah Trust barred women from entering the sanctum sanctorum of the Haji Ali
Dargah. The trust cited verses from the Quran and Prophet Mohammed to claim that Islam
does not permit women to enter dargahs/mosques. The trust also claimed the fundamental
right “to manage its own affairs” under Article 26 of the Indian Constitution. This was opposed
by several women’s organizations. Eventually, the Bombay High Court lifted the ban saying it
religious harmony. Argue how secularism is a pre-requisite for harmony, not the
ai
gm
other way around. Also examine whether secularism should be seen exclusively
@
• While doing so, consider the three keywords mentioned in the question – equality,
ha
social justice and democracy. Analyze how these are a prerequisite if secularism is
si
society. But it is not sufficiently inclusive to reconcile the cultural differences. For
co
l.
equality. Integral to the concept of secularism, therefore, is cultural equality; so also are
@
democracy and social justice. Without these three interrelated factors – equality,
27
gn
democracy and social justice – secularism cannot exist as a positive value in society.
ha
si
2. How are minorities defined in India? Does the commitment to ensure special rights for
minorities contradict the idea of secularism? Discuss in the context of India.
Approach:
• Explain how minorities are defined in India.
• Discuss the special rights given to minorities in India and whether it contradicts
secularism.
Answer:
The Constitution of India uses the word ‘minority’ (in Article 29 to 30 and 350 A to 350
B) but does not define the word ‘minority’ as such. The minorities in India include:
• Religious minority- As per National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992 it include
Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, Zoroastrians (Parsis) and Jains. Sects within a
religion are not considered a religious minority.
Special rights for minorities were designed not to create inequalities but to bring about
co
l.
Counter-views and debate on this arrangement should be seen as the trait of a healthy
democracy.
3. The framing of a uniform civil code is an acid test of India’s commitment to secularism
and modernisation. Critically analyse the statement in the light of post-independent
developments in India.
Approach:
The answer should provide a balanced perspective and refrain from making politically
incorrect assertions.
• The answer should define what a uniform civil code means and its necessity
• It should specify the constitutional basis of uniform civil code and discuss the post-
independence developments in the direction of a uniform civil code and the
impediments to it
• A Uniform civil code seeks to replace the personal laws based on the scriptures
and customs of a religious community with a common set governing every citizen.
• At its core, Uniform Civil Code (UCC) deals with issues of secularism, equality and
women’s rights. The secular argument is that the laws of the state should not be
religion, caste or community specific. Further, a modern state should treat all
citizens equally and should not discriminate against women.
• In the Constituent Assembly, a UCC was supported by leaders such as Nehru,
Ambedkar and women members but due to stringent opposition from orthodox
members, it was included only in the form of Directive Principles as a compromise.
• Later a Hindu Code Bill to provide for a uniform civil code for Hindus, Sikhs, Jains
and Buddhists also met with opposition but was eventually passed in a diluted
form through 4 separate acts.
• The Muslim Personal Law continued to exist and is considered as discriminatory
towards Muslim women as it permits unilateral divorce and polygamy.
• However, the demand to include the Muslim community under a UCC was resisted
by India’s leaders as there was a feeling that partition had left Indian Muslims
feeing vulnerable and any tampering with their traditions at that stage would have
made them feel even less secure. Hence, it was decided to delay such a move to a
more apt time.
• However, the controversial case of Shah Bano once again led to demands for a
UCC.
• At the same time, there is another perspective that the state should not
unilaterally change personal laws, based on religion. Support for such changes
should come from the community itself. For instance, the demand for uniform
personal laws for all Hindus was the result of a vigorous social-reform movement
among them. Despite opposition from some orthodox sections, there was
m
co
widespread support for such a move. On the other hand, such a demand did not
l.
ai
through a process of debate and consensus and not through top-down law making.
gn
ha
si
4. Is the Indian notion of secularism, based on uniform respect for all religions by the
state and separation of religion from public institutional practices, adequate to
ensure a secular state? Discuss.
Approach:
• Briefly explain Indian secularism as per given statement.
• Discuss with appropriate arguments if it has lead to a secular state. Cite the
challenges.
• Give suggestions, if any.
Answer:
India being a secular state there is no preferred state religion and all religious groups
enjoy the same constitutional protection without any favour or discrimination.
Secularism in India unlike the western notion does not mean separate state from
religion. It means equal respect for all faiths and religions. The same has been
elaborated as:
Urbanization (or the growth of urban settlement),is the process of becoming urban, moving to
cities, changing from agriculture to other pursuits common to cities, such as trade,
manufacturing, industry and management, and corresponding changes of behavior patterns
An increase in the size of towns and cities leading to growth of urban population is the most
significant dimension of urbanization. In ancient times there have been great many cities such
as Rome or Baghdad, but ever since industrialization and increasing industrial production, cities
have grown phenomenally and now urbanization is very much part of our contemporary life.
Urbanization in India was mainly a post-independence phenomenon, due to adoption of mixed
system of economy by the country, which gave rise to the development of private sector. It has
been taking place at an increasingly fast rate in India. The following table shows the increase in
urban population from Pre independence till date:
According to a survey done by UN state of World Population Report, by 2030, 41% of the Indian
population will reside in urban areas and also as per “World Cities Report 2016 – Urbanisation
and Development: Emerging Futures”, India’s urban population is expected to become 55
percent of the total population by 2050.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
2.2. Outgrowth
According to Census 2001, an Out Growth (OG) is has been defined as a viable unit such as a
village or a hamlet or an enumeration block made up of such village or hamlet and clearly
identifiable in terms of its boundaries and location. Some of the examples are railway colony,
university campus, port area, military camps, etc., which have come up near a statutory town
outside its statutory limits but within the revenue limits of a village or villages contiguous to the
town.
An outgrowth possesses urban features like infrastructure and amenities such as pucca roads,
m
electricity, taps, drainage system for disposal of waste water etc. educational institutions, post
co
l.
offices, medical facilities, banks etc. and is physically contiguous with the core town of the
ai
gm
Urban Agglomeration. In the 2011 Census, 475 places with 981 outgrowths have been
@
identified as Urban Agglomerations as against 384 Urban Agglomerations with 962 outgrowths
27
gn
in 2001 Census.
ha
si
2.3. Over-Urbanization
Over-urbanization is a phenomenon wherein the level of urbanization surpasses the level of
industrialization. In an over urbanized area, population growth outstrips its job market and the
capacity of its infrastructure. This phenomenon can also be referred as Urbanisation without
Industrialisation. E.g. Mumbai, Kolkata, Delhi are some of the over urbanized cities.
2.4. Sub-Urbanization
It is closely related to over-urbanization of a city. Over a period of time, people from the Over-
Urbanized area start moving towards the fringe area around the cities. Such areas around the
cities gradually start developing asan urban area. This phenomenon is known as Sub
Urbanisation.
There are several factors which leads to the process of Sub-urbanisation such as :
1. High cost of living in over urbanized area,
2. Development of transport facility around the horizons of over urbanized area,
3. New Work culture that does not necessitate the physical presence on every day.
4. inclusion of surrounding areas of towns within its municipal limits
Delhi is a typical example; wherein the all the above mentioned factors have led to the
development of sub urbanized area. E.g. Ghaziabad, Faridabad, Meerut etc.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
It is a demographic and social process whereby people move from urban areas to rural areas. It
first took place as a reaction to inner-city deprivation and overcrowding. Counter urbanization
occurs when some large cities reach a point where they stop growing further or actually begin
to decrease in size as their population start moving into suburban areas or smaller cities
thereby leapfrogging the rural-urban fringe. There are instances which show that the
phenomenon of counter urbanization is occurring in India.
2.6. Census Towns
In 2011, a new definition of census town has been developed. This urban classification of
'census towns' helps differentiate between India's small farming communities and the larger
market town-type settlements that are experiencing rapid and haphazard growth.
To be classified as a census town, a village must fulfil three criteria;
• it need at least 5,000 inhabitants,
• a density of 400 people per sq. km, and
at least three quarters of its male working population must be "engaged in non-agricultural
pursuits".
3. Process of Urbanization
Urbanization as a structural process of change is generally related to industrialization but it is
not always the result of industrialization. Urbanization results due to the concentration of large-
scale and small scale industrial ,commercial, financial and administrative set up in the cities;
technological development in transport and communication, cultural and recreational activities.
The excess of urbanization over industrialization that makes it possible to provide employment
for all persons coming to urban areas is, in fact, what sometimes leads to over urbanization.
In India, a peculiar phenomenon is seen: industrial growth without a significant shift of
population from agriculture to industry and growth of urban population without a significant
rise in the ratio of the urban to the total population. While in terms of ratio, there may not be a
m
co
great shift from rural to urban activities, but there is still a large migration of population from
l.
ai
rural areas to urban areas. This makes urban areas choked; while at the same time there is lack
gm
Urbanization affects not only the family structure but also intra and inter-family relations, as
well as the functions the family performs. With urbanization, there is a disruption of the bonds
of community and the migrant faces the problem to replace old relationships with new ones
The relationships of community living tend to become impersonal, formal and goal oriented.
I.P. Desai (1964) showed that though the structure of urban family is changing, the spirit of
individualism is not growing in the families. He found that 74 percent families were residentially
nuclear but functionally and in property joint, and 21 percent were joint in residence and
functioning as well as in property and 5 percent families were nuclear.
Aileen Ross (1962) in her study of 157 Hindu families belonging to middle and upper classes in
Bangalore found that
• about 60 percent of the families are nuclear
• the trend today is towards a break with the traditional joint family form into the nuclear
family form into the nuclear family unit.
• Small joint family is now the most typical form of family life in urban India.
• Relations with one’s distant kin are weakening or breaking.
4.2. Urbanization and Caste
• It is generally held that caste is a rural phenomenon whereas class is urban and that with
urbanization, caste transforms itself into class. But it is necessary to note that the caste
system exists in cities as much as it does in villages although there are significant
organizational differences.
• Caste identity tends to diminish with urbanization, education and the development of an
orientation towards individual achievement and modern status symbols. It has been
pointed out that among the westernized elite, class ties are much more important than
caste ties.
• However, caste system continues to persist and exert its influence in some sectors of urban
social life while it has changed its form in some other sectors. Caste solidarity is not as
m
strongin urban areas as in the rural areas. Caste panchayats are very weak in cities. There
co
exists a dichotomy between workplace and domestic situation and both caste and class
l.
ai
gm
situations co-exist.
@
27
• Women constitute an important section of rural urban migrants. They migrate at the time
si
of marriage and also when they are potential workers in the place of destination. While
middle class women get employed in white collar jobs and professions, lower class women
find jobs in the informal sector. Women are also found in the formal sector as industrial
workers.
• Many positive developments took place in the socio economic lives of women as a result of
increasing urbanization. Increasing number of women have taken to white-collar jobs and
entered different professions. These professions were instrumental in enhancing the social
and economic status of women, thereby meaning increased and rigorous hours of work,
professional loyalty along with increased autonomy. Average age of marriage of girls is
higher in urban areas.
• However, the traditional and cultural institutions remaining the same, crises of values and a
confusion of norms have finally resulted. The personally and socially enlightened woman is
forced to perform dual roles - social and professional. Also, Urbanisation has not brought
about any radical change in the traditional pattern of arranged marriage with dowry. Urban
women want new opportunities but old securities as well.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
Various factors responsible for the process of urbanization like migration, better economic
gn
opportunities led to settling down of people either in already densely populated cities or the
ha
si
fringe areas around the cities. This rapid urbanization leads to the development of cities
without any urban planning and eventually that becomes unsuitable for living. It poses a serious
threat to the development in terms of delivery of services and living conditions. Also, rapid
urbanization forces government to build cities which actually lacks proper infrastructure, public
facilities and employment opportunities.
5.2. Housing and Inflated Land Prices
It is one of the most intense problems which have emerged due to increased urbanization.
Overpopulation puts a lot of pressure on limited urban land area. This problem is particularly
more severe in those urban areas where there is large invasion of jobless or underemployed
immigrants. The major factors for housing problems are lack of building materials and financial
resources, insufficient expansion of public utilities into sub-urban areas, and lack of enough
transportation to sub-urban areas where most of the available land for new construction is to
be found.
There is acute shortage of housing in urban areas and much of the available accommodation is
of sub-standard quality. This problem has worsened over the years due to rapid increase in
population, fast rate of urbanization and proportionately inadequate addition to the housing
stock.
With large scale migration to urban areas many find that the only option they have is
substandard conditions of slums. Slums are characterized by sub-standard housing,
overcrowding, lack of electrification, ventilation, sanitation, roads and drinking water facilities.
They have been the breeding ground of diseases, environmental pollution, demoralization and
many social tensions.
As per the census 2011, 17% of the urban population in India lives in slum which is expected to
increase rapidly considering the huge migration from rural to urban area. Notably, this
percentage is even higher in some of the cities. For e.g., the ratio is more than 50% in Greater
Mumbai.
and municipal corporations in Indian cities. There is a total lack of motivation to tackle the basic
co
l.
sanitation needs of the cities. The spread of slums in congested urban areas and lack of civic
ai
gm
sense among the settlers in these slums further adds to the growing mound of filth and
@
diseases. Diseases like dengue, malaria, typhoid, flu and respiratory ailments are on the rise in
27
gn
Our towns and cities are major polluters of the environment. Several cities discharge 40 to 60
percent of their entire sewage and industrial effluents untreated into the nearby rivers. Urban
industry pollutes the atmosphere with smoke and toxic gases from its chimneys. All these,
increase the chances of disease among the people living in the urban centres. According to
UNICEF, lakhs of urban children die or suffer from diarrhea, tetanus, measles etc. because of
poor sanitary conditions and water contamination. As a long-term remedy, what is needed is
using new techniques of waste collection, new technology for garbage-disposal and
fundamental change in the municipal infrastructure and land-use planning.
absence of social security for them, enhanced role and sphere of market has led to the poor
l.
ai
and marginalized suffering the most. Studies have also shown that stress levels are found high
gm
@
in cities, which in turn has deleterious impact on the health of the people.
27
gn
Urbanization in India has not only been fast but also unplanned. This leads to an imbalance in
resource availability that manifests itself in dearth of space, shelter, food and basic amenities
for the rising population leading to competition, rivalry, insecurity and crimes. As per National
Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), in 19 selected Metropolitan cities with population more than 2
million, the Crimes under IPC (Indian Penal Code) and SLL (Special and Local Laws), witnessed
an increase of 7.3% and 5.2% respectively in 2016 over 2015. These include heinous crimes
such as murder, rape, kidnapping and abduction, and robbery.
Development
• Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana - Housing for All (HFA) (Urban Mission) was launched in June
2015 to provide housing to all in urban areas by 2022.
• Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation (AMRUT)- launched with the
objective to provide hard infrastructure for universal coverage of piped drinking water,
sewerage and green spaces and parks. AMRUT also incentivizes governance reforms in the
cities.
• Developing Smart Cities-Launched in June 2015, Smart Cities Mission aims at driving
economic growth and improving the quality of life through area based development and
city-level smart solutions. The mission would convert 100 existing cities into smart cities
• Swachh Bharat Mission (Urban)-Launched on 2nd October 2014, Swachh Bharat Mission
(SBM) (Urban) is the key mission driving the campaign to make our cities clean. The mission
aims to eliminate open defecation in all statutory towns by 2nd October 2019. It also
proposes to eradicate manual scavenging, introduce modern and scientific solid waste
management, induce behavioural change with respect to healthy sanitation practices and
generate awareness for sanitation and its link to public health, augment the capacity of
ULBs and create an enabling environment for the private sector in waste management.
• Deen Dayal Antodaya Yojana– National Urban Livelihood Mission (DAY – NULM)-aims at
creating opportunities for skill development leading to market based employment and
helping the poor to set up self-employment ventures. This Mission’s interventions are
implemented through five key components:
1. Social Mobilization and Institutional Development (SMID);
2. Self-Employment Programmes (SEPs);
3. Employment through Skill, Training & Placement (EST&P);
4. Shelter for Urban Homeless (SUH); and
5. Support to Urban Street Vendors (SUSV).
• National Heritage City Development & Augmentation Yojana (HRIDAY) Mission was
launched in January 2015 with an aim to rejuvenate the heritage cities, with special
attention to others issues such as sanitation, tourism, and livelihood. The Mission is
m
co
targeted for completion by November 2018. The HRIDAY mission will be concluded in 12
l.
ai
• Urban transport - All the interventions in the urban transport by the Ministry of Urban
@
27
Development such as Bus Rapid Transit System (BRTS), urban transit infrastructure or
gn
financing of metro rail projects etc, are carried out as per the provisions of National Urban
ha
si
India needs to work on several areas to manage its unplanned urbanization: Inclusive cities,
funding, planning, capacity building and low-income housing.A political process must also be
started where the urban issues are debated with evolution of meaningful solutions:
7.1. Improved Governance
Governance forms an integral part of Urbanization. Governance is the weakest and most crucial
link which needs to be repaired to bring about the urban transformation so urgently needed in
India. Financing the large sums required to meet the investment needs of urban infrastructure
is crucially dependent on the reform of institutions and the capacity of those who run the
institutions for service delivery and revenue generation. It is seen that large expenditures on
Indian cities and towns have to be combined with better governance structures, strong political
and administrative will to collect taxes and user charges, and improved capacity to deliver.
Cities must be empowered, financially strengthened, and efficiently governed to respond to the
needs of their citizens and to contribute to the growth momentum. Following are the areas
where governance needs to be improved further:
1. Strengthening Municipalities: The municipal entities need to be strengthened as local
governments with ‛own’ sources of revenue, predictable formula-based transfers from
state governments, and other transfers from the Government of India and state
governments to help them discharge the larger responsibilities assigned to them by the
74th Constitutional Amendment. Improved tax revenues combined with rational user
charges will enable cities to leverage their own resources to incur debt and also access
new forms of financing through public private partnership (PPP). NITI Aayog’s suggestions
are also on the same line, A well-run ULBs should have the power to raise financial
resources including through municipal bonds. Indian cities also need to overhaul their
municipal staffing and introduce appropriate skills to achieve administrative efficiency
2. Creation of Waste to Energy plants: To speed up the process of cleaning up municipal
solid waste, NITI Aayog suggests the creation of an authority at the Centre to spread the
use of Waste to Energy plants. Such an authority may be called Waste to Energy
m
Corporation of India (WECI) and placed under the Ministry of Urban Development. WECI
co
may set up world class Waste to Energy plants through PPP across the country. It can play a
l.
ai
gm
key role in fast-tracking coverage of waste to energy plants across 100 smart cities by 2019.
@
3. Strict enforcement of traffic rules: It can be done through fines in case of violations. It will
27
induce behavioural change and could greatly reduce both the travel time and pollution.
gn
ha
Facilitating new age technology cab aggregators: Incentives may be created to encourage
si
vehicle-sharing systems such as Ola and Uber. This will reduce the number of vehicles on
the road reducing both congestion and pollution.
4. National metro rail policy: It will ensure that metro projects are not considered in
isolation, but as part of a comprehensive plan of overall public transportation. Further, the
policy should provide clear guidelines on various aspects of metro projects, such as
planning, financing, PPP, etc.
7.2. Inclusive Cities
The poor and lower income groups must be brought into the mainstream in cities. Regulations
intended to manage densities and discourage migration both limit the supply of land and
require many households to consume more land than they would choose. This drives urban
sprawl and pushes up the price of land and the cost of service delivery for all. High standards
for parking, coverage limits, setbacks, elevators, road widths, reservations for health centres,
schools etc. (often not used) prevent the poor from choosing how much to consume of the
costliest resource (urban land) to put a roof over their heads, and comply with legal
requirements.
Devolution has to be supported by more reforms in urban financing that will reduce cities’
dependence on the Centre and the states and unleash internal revenue sources. Consistent
with most international examples, there are several sources of funding that Indian cities could
tap into, to a far greater extent than today: Monetizing land assets; higher collection of
property taxes, user charges that reflect costs; debt and public-private partnerships (PPPs); and
central/state government funding. However, internal funding alone will not be enough, even in
large cities. A portion has to come from the central and state governments.
7.4. Planning
India needs to make urban planning a central, respected function, investing in skilled people,
rigorous fact base and innovative urban form. This can be done through a “cascaded” planning
structure in which large cities have 40-year and 20-year plans at the metropolitan level that are
binding on municipal development plans. Central to planning in any city is the optimal
allocation of space, especially land use and Floor Area Ratio (FAR) planning. Both should focus
on linking public transportation with zoning for affordable houses for low-income groups. These
plans need to be detailed, comprehensive, and enforceable.
future we want”, recognized both the plight of the urbanpoor and the need for sustainable
co
cities as matters of great urgency for the United Nationsdevelopment agenda. Time has come
l.
ai
gm
1. Discuss the various social problems which originated out of the speedy process of
urbanization in India. (2013)
2. Smart cities in India cannot sustain without smart vilages. Discuss this statement in the
backdrop of rural urban integration. (2015)
3. With a brief background of quality of urban life in India, introduce the objectives and
strategy of the ‘Smart City Programme.” (2016)
1. Give an account of the factors driving people to migrate from the countryside to
urban areas even if it entails living in slums. Highlight some important facts about
slums unique to India. Also discuss some strategies which can be adopted for
transforming India's slums.
Approach:
• Introduce upon Rural-Urban migration in India and resultant growth of slums.
• Discuss the factors that drive people to migrate to cities and even live in slums.
• Discuss the important facts about slums unique to India.
• Discuss strategies to transform India’s slums.
Answer:
Urbanization accompanied by large scale migration leads to mushrooming slums.
India's slum population will constitute roughly 9% of the total projected national
population of 1.28 billion in 2017.
Driving factors
• A Higher and More Stable Income: Productive employment opportunities in an
urban centre likely generate a higher and more consistent personal disposable
income than in the place of origin – likely a rural, farming centre.
• Social Mobility for the Next Generation: Raising children in an urban environment
creates a higher “option value” for the next generation. Typically, cities offers a
wider choice of education and employment opportunities.
• Distress Migration: Political disturbances and inter-ethnic conflicts forces people
away from their homes. People also migrate to urban areas in the aftermath of
major natural disasters.
• No other option except slums: Poor migrant families are unable to afford decent
housing and transportation cost which forces them to settle in slum areas in the
city near to their work place.
m
Unique Facts
co
l.
ai
• Unprecedented Scale: No country has or is facing the issue of slums on the scale at
gm
which India is. By 2017, India is expected to have over 100 million people living in
@
27
slums and another 10 million migrants moving to the cities each year.
gn
• Political Clout Cuts Both Ways: India’s slum-dwellers are fully enfranchised and
ha
si
actively vote for national and local leaders who they feel will protect their
interests. Slum-dwellers’ today know they represent a strong and highly influential
vote and politicians know that delivering things of value to this constituency plays
an important part in their ability to win their vote.
• No Control: Some other developing countries have more effective political tools to
control urban migration. However, India’s democracy which assures the free
movement of people throughout the country prevents any such controls from being
even remotely feasible.
Strategies for Transformation
A viable solution to transform the slums would have to take a holistic view dealing with
India’s larger macro challenges. Such a solution should include the following
strategies:
• Rural Re-Visioning and Investment: There is need to create other cities as counter-
magnets so that the migration to major cities like Mumbai can be arrested.
2. Whereas the UN Habitat report calls cities “the highest pinnacles of human creation”,
the moot question is what form the cities of developing world should take. In context
of this statement, examine the contending strategies of urbanisation, with respect to
India.
Approach:
• In the introduction briefly explain the context in the statement and provide the
reason for a careful consideration of the shape cities would take in developing
world.
• Further delineate the strategies involving large and small cities as models of
urbanisation.
• Conclude by underlining the optimal combination required for future urban growth.
Answer:
Cities have been termed as pinnacles of human creation owing to their historic role and
future potential as sites of human collaboration, engines of growth and vehicles of
social mobility. The UN habitat estimates that by 2050 2/3rd of the global population
would reside in cities. According to the World Bank 90 % of the urban growth would
m
occur in the developing world. Thus, the inevitability of urbanization and concerns of
co
l.
In this context cities in India have largely grown organically and in an unplanned
@
27
manner, this has led to pressure on the resources at disposal. Similarly the tier two
gn
cities would be expanding in the future. Thus, India requires strategies suited to both
ha
si
• The slum region is marked by lack of adequate living space, insufficient provision of
co
l.
public goods, and the poor quality of basic amenities like clean drinking water and
ai
gm
sanitation. All of which lead to extremely poor health and diminishing human
@
capital not only for the slum dwellers but for the vicinity as well.
27
•
gn
women, substance abuse, crowding and depersonalisation and other social and
humanitarian problems.
• Other issues relate to displacement of population from settlements, unregulated
encroachment cases such as Kathputli Colony in Delhi.
Policy challenges
• Tackling rural urban migration–It is closely relate to factors like globalisation and
lack of income opportunities in rural areas. Experts estimate that by 2050 approx.
60 % of the population shall live in cities. This invariably requires complimentary
schemes to develop smart villages on the lines of smart cities.
• Developing social security nets for slum dwellers in cities.
• Sustainable urban development-Making cities safe and sustainable means ensuring
access to safe and affordable housing, upgrading slum settlements, ensuring basic
necessities like clean drinking water, health clinics and toilets. It also includes
reducing vulnerability of women and elderly.
advanced stages of development. In India, it’s happening much more quickly than
ai
gm
expected.
@
27
Reasons:
gn
ha
• Suburbs are seen as safer and cheaper place to live and raise a family due to lower
si
5. Magnitude of India’s urbanisation is not unusual but the pattern is. In this context,
@
27
examine the issues in the governance of cities in India. Also suggest the reforms
gn
Approach:
• Briefly, explain the magnitude and pattern of urbanisation in India.
• List the issues in the governance of cities in India and elaborate them.
• Suggest the reformative steps required to make Indian cities dynamos of
competitive sub-federalism.
• Conclude your answer.
Answer:
Urbanization defines the trajectory of development. In India, urbanisation is rapidly on
the rise as 31.16 percent of population lives in urban areas. According to United
Nations report, India is expected to add an extra 300 million new urban residents
by 2050. The magnitude of urbanization in India is usual and in line with transition
phase seen in a developing country. However, the pattern of urbanization is haphazard
and lopsided marked with severe governance deficit.
Suggested reforms
l.
ai
gm
• State government needs to cede power and share resources with local bodies.
@
Here, State Finance Commissions should also play a vital role by allocating more
27
resources.
gn
ha
• Ensure efficient collection of existing tax base by adopting the latest satellite based
si
techniques to map urban properties in order to tap the full potential of property
tax.
• Regular and reliable fiscal and economic performance database linked with grants
to local bodies could help in ensuring transparency.
• NITI Aayog should also compile actual comparative indices of municipalities’
performance annually.
• The ULBs should be provided with capable manpower in adequate numbers, by
creating an independent specialised cadre.
• There should be an annual audit of the performance of ULBs, along with regular
organisation of Ward Sabhas for increasing accountability.
• Any development plan should include all aspects of infrastructure development to
make it viable providing services to every section and sector.
• Initiatives like Swachhta Dashboards: platform that show information on cities
across the country based on their cleanliness.
• Promoting financing options like municipality bonds.
6. Rapid ubanization not only requires addressing the deficits in urban areas but also
addressing those that are created because of it in rural areas. Comment. Also,
evaluate the success of government programmes to reduce the stress on rural
population because of urbanization.
Approach:
• Give a brief account of urbanization and its resultant impact.
• Discuss its outcomes for rural areas.
• Mentioning few schemes evaluate the success of these programmes.
• Conclude by briefly mentioning remedial suggestions.
Answer:
As per census data, 31% of Indian population lived in urban areas in 2011. It is expected
to reach 50% in the next decade or so. This is the result of both rural push & urban pull
factors. But, this has brought along several problems like growth of slums,
homelessness, unemployment, poverty, pollution, shortage of resources, crimes, drug
trafficking, prostitution, beggary and psychological problems like alcoholism, depression
and stress.
While the focus has been to remedy these urban malaises, what is often neglected is
the resultant negative impact of urbanization on rural areas. Some of these are:
• Out-migration of youth and consequent decline in economic productivity of these
regions.
• Declining investment in agriculture and allied activities, reducing employment
m
co
psychological problems.
@
27
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
The origins of communalism can be traced back to history, particularly the British Raj. After the
Revolt of 1857, the British started to follow the ‘divide and rule’ policy consciously and
deliberately. The antagonistic feelings got strengthened during their rule and ultimately led to
the partition of British India on the basis of religious identity. This did not steam out post-
independence, and time and again we witness communal clashes in various parts of the
country. For example, the 2020 Bangalore riots, Delhi riots.
2. Definition of Communalism
In English, the word “communal” means something related to a community or collectivity as
different from an individual. In common parlance, the word ‘communalism’ refers to aggressive
chauvinism based on religious identity.
Chauvinism is an attitude that sees one’s own group as the only legitimate or worthy group,
with other groups seen as inferior, illegitimate and to be opposed.
Thus, communalism is an aggressive political ideology linked to religion. This is a peculiarly
Indian, or perhaps South Asian, meaning that is different from the sense of the ordinary English
word. The English meaning is neutral, whereas the South Asian meaning is strongly charged.
The charge may be seen as positive – if one is sympathetic to communalism – or negative, if
one is opposed to it.
Therefore, communalism, in the Indian context, is most commonly perceived as a
phenomenon of religious differences between groups that often lead to tension, and even
rioting between them. In its not so violent manifestation, communalism amounts to
discrimination against a religious group in matters such as employment or education
The causes of communal clashes as such are rarely religious in its fundamental character. In
India, communalism arises when religion is used as a marker to highlight socio-economic
disequilibrium between communities and as a force multiplier to demand concessions.
3. Elements of Communalism
m
co
Communalism or communal ideology consists of three basic elements or stages- one following
l.
ai
the other:
gm
@
• Mild Communalism: It is the belief that people who follow the same religion have common
27
gn
For example, nobles of different communities (Hindustani, Turani, Afghan, Irani etc.) co-
si
Communalism is more about politics rather than religion. Although communalists are intensely
involved with religion, there is no necessary relationship between personal faith and
communalism. A communal person may or may not be a devout religious person, and devout
believers may or may not be communal beings.
However, all communalists believe in a political identity based on religion. The key factor is the
attitude towards those who believe in other kinds of identities, including other religion-based
identities. Communalism claims that religious identity overrides everything else- such as
poverty, occupation, caste or political beliefs.
It rules out the possibility that Hindus, Muslims and Christians who belong to Kerala, for
example, may have as much or more in common with each other than with their co-religionists
from Kashmir, Gujarat or Nagaland. It also denies the possibility that, for instance, landless
agricultural labourers (or industrialists) may have a lot in common even if they belong to
different religions and regions
So, communalists cultivate an aggressive political identity, and are prepared to condemn or
attack everyone who does not share their identity
Thus, some of the features of communalism are:-
• It is a multifaceted process based on orthodoxy and intolerance.
• It also propagates intense dislike for other religions
• It stands for elimination of other religions and its values.
• It adopts extremist tactics including use of violence against other people. For example, the
ISIS blasted and brought down the famous Bamiyan temple, the last remnant of the
Gandhara style architecture
• It is exclusive in outlook. A communalist considers his own religion to be superior to other
religions.
5. Types of Communalism
m
smaller ones such that the latter's culture gets subdued. For example, the Hindu Code Bill
ai
gm
is applicable to Sikh, Buddhists and Jains as well. Tribals were considered as backward
@
• Welfarist Communalism: Working for the welfare of one’s own community. Example-
ha
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
(a) Historical factors: British policy of divide and rule led them to focus on using religion to
divide India. A prominent reason why this policy gained currency was that the Muslim
middle class lagged behind the Hindus in terms of education, which contributed to their
also pitted various religious communities against each other. Communalist elements
l.
ai
exploited these circumstances. In fact, the main social base for communalism was &
gm
@
after the British left India and thus, the only recourse would be a separate state for Muslims
co
• Hindu communalism too did not lag behind. The Hindu Mahasabha and the Rashtriya
@
Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), began propagating extreme communalism. They demanded that
27
the non-Hindu groups of India adopt the Hindu culture and language and hold Hindu
gn
ha
religion in reverence. They too espoused that Hindus and Muslims are two separate social
si
•
gm
Indian Hindu organizations such as the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Rashtriya
27
organizing groups claimed that people voluntarily came forward to convert to Hinduism,
si
some participants claimed that they were forced to do so. Also, raising the fear of ‘Love
Jihad’ for inter-faith marriages.
• Delhi Riots 2020: In the year 2020, Delhi witnessed its first major riot since 1984 between
Hindu-Muslim communities. In a series of bloodshed, property destruction, and rioting in
North East Delhi, 53 people were killed.
The slow development of the economy, improper cultural synthesis, perceived or relative
deprivation, regional or social imbalance in development and political mobilization in the age of
democracy has led to the consolidation of communal sentiments and the persistence of
communalism in the post-independence period.
Muslims.
ai
gm
The challenge is, therefore, bigger than just inflicting electoral defeats on communal parties and
@
27
organisations. Even if such parties are defeated electorally, institutional communalism remains
gn
pervasive in varying degrees in India's Constitution, judiciary, civil services, electoral and
ha
parliamentary institutions, security forces, prisons, academia, media, corporate business, and
si
• Secular education should be taught in all educational institutions, which will lead to
gm
@
history into ancient, medieval and modern has contributed to communal thinking as it has
si
effectively divided history into the Hindu period, Muslim period and Christian period
respectively. This has given rise to notions that India was a Hindu country which was
‘invaded’ by Muslims and Christians.
• Increased employment opportunities for minorities can lead to decrease in communal
discord. Thus, there should be focus on skilling members of minority communities through
various programmes and initiatives.
• Uniform Civil Code should be formulated and implemented with the consensus of all
religious communities so that there is uniformity in personal laws.
• The administration and the police fail to anticipate and read indicators which
gm
• Even after the appearance of first signals, the administration and police are slow
gn
to react;
ha
si
• Field functionaries tend to seek and wait for instructions from superiors and
superiors tend to interfere in local matters undermining local initiative and
authority;
• The administration and police at times act in a partisan manner and
• At times there is failure of leadership, even total abdication on the part of those
entrusted with maintenance of public order.
• Rehabilitation is often neglected, breeding resentment and residual anger and
• Officials are not held to account for their failures, thus perpetuating slackness and
incompetence.
Developmental Deficit
• In most cases, inadequate development creates genuine grievance in a community.
Their grievance can then be harnessed by opportunistic communal element to
breed animosity towards other groups.
2. The growth of communalism after 1857 in India was a result of societal differences,
communal politics and divisive British policies. Discuss.
Approach:
• Elaborate on the growth of communalism after 1857.
• Focus on how it was result of societal differences, communal politics and divisive
British policies.
Answer:
The Revolt of 1857 gave a severe jolt to the British administration in India and made its
reorganization inevitable. Consequently, after the revolt, the British followed the policy
of divide and rule. Such policies led to societal differences which fuelled communal
politics in India.
Societal differences
• Role of socio-religious reform movements: Reform movements such as Wahabi
movements among Muslims and Shuddhi movements among Hindus made the role
of religion more vulnerable to communalism.
• Role of socio-economic differences: There was rivalry for jobs, trade and industry
between Hindus and Muslims and bourgeoisie class used the lower middle classes
of the Hindus and Muslims against each other to further their class interest. For
example, the case in Western Punjab where the Muslim landlords opposed the
m
co
Hindu moneylenders and in East Bengal where the Muslim jotedars (small
l.
ai
Communal Politics
27
gn
Formation of Muslim league in 1905 and of Hindu Mahashabha in 1915 further fuelled
ha
Government of India Act, 1909 and later the Communal award of 1932, etc. These
l.
ai
•
@
Politicians have also played a role in creating serious communal situations in India
27
community and caste, flaring up religious sentiments at the time of elections etc.
The communities thus have become different watertight compartments leading to
conflicts such as Anti-Sikh riots, 1984, Ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Hindu Pundits in
1989, Babri masjid demolition in Ayodhya, 1992, Gujarat riots, 2002, Muzaffarnagar
violence, 2013, etc.
• Political appeasement, prompted by political considerations as seen in Shah Bano
case wherein the Central government overturned SC judgement extending
maintenance to Muslim divorcee in protraction of Shari’ah law also fuels
communalism.
Socio-economic disparities fuelling Communalism
• The stagnant economy of India during the British rule led to the growth of
communalism in India. It was deeply rooted in and was an expression of the
interests and aspirations of the middle classes in a social set up in which
opportunities for them were inadequate.
• Muslim disadvantage in terms of few policies in place to protect them as well as
lack of effective political mobilization in their interest, has been widely noted by the
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si
3.2. Unpaid Work in Household, Home-Based Production and Family Farms ....................... 104
4.2.1. First to Fifth Five Year Plans: Welfare Approach ...................................................... 116
4.2.2. Sixth Five Year Plan: Shift from Welfare to Development ........................................ 117
4.2.3. Seventh Five Year Plan: Women and Development ................................................. 117
4.2.4. Eighth Five Year Plan: Shift from ‘Development’ to ‘Empowerment’ of Women .... 117
7.2.3. Initiatives for Education, Skilling and Training of Women ........................................ 132
gn
ha
si
8. Conclusion.............................................................................................................................. 133
• As against this, the second position argues that they result from socially constructed power
co
l.
Sex is the biological trait that societies use to assign people into the category of either male or
female, through physical ascription. Differences between men and women are often drawing
on sex – on rigid ideas of biology – rather than gender.
Gender is more fluid – it may or may not depend upon biological traits. More specifically, it is a
concept that describes:
• how societies determine and manage sex categories;
• the cultural meanings attached to men and women’s roles;
• how individuals understand their identities.
Gender involves social norms, attitudes and activities that society deems more appropriate for
one sex over another.
The sociology of gender examines how society influences our understanding and perception of
differences between masculinity (what society deems appropriate behaviour for a “man”) and
femininity (what society deems appropriate behaviour for a “woman”). This, in turn, influences
identity and social practices, power relationships that follow from the established gender
order in a given society, as well as how these changes over time.
• India is the only country where the economic gender gap (0.354) is larger than the political
gm
@
• India is among the countries with very low women representation on company boards
gn
ha
1) Sex Ratio, Mortality Rate, and Life Expectancy Rate – Sex ratio is used to describe the
number of females per 1000 of males. As per census 2011, sex ratio for India is 940 females
per 1000 of males, i.e., females form a meager 47% of the total population. The State of
Haryana has the lowest sex ratio in India with 877 females to that of 1000 males while
Kerala has the highest of 1084 females per 1000 males.
Mortality rate or the death rate measures the frequency of deaths. This is an annual rate
and is calculated for different age groups as the number of deaths for 1000 live births. The
age-specific death rate data indicates a high rate of female infant mortality (0-4 years) and
maternal mortality (5-24 years), adult mortality (15-60 years).
● Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) in India has declined to 113 in 2016-18 from 122 in
2015-17 and 130 in 2014-2016
● In 2018, the mortality rate for women was at 147.16 per 1,000 female adults, while the
mortality rate for men was at 203.62 per 1,000 male adults in India.
• There has been commodification of women as well, with practices of purchasing of brides from
ai
gm
poor areas.
@
• Economic consequences are that there is a huge proportion of the productive population which is
27
gn
missing. Lack of women impairs the ability of men to work, and has led to increased work pressure
ha
on the men.
si
The government has tried to counter the declining sex ratio through initiatives like Beti Bachao, Beti
Padhai; Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana etc.
2) Women’s Health - Studies on hospital admissions and records show that males get more
medical care compared to girls. More than half the women of reproductive age (15-49
years) in India are anaemic. The prevalence of anaemia among women has consistently
been high over the last 20 years. 12% of the female population of the country suffers from
repeated pregnancy (80% of their productive life is spent in pregnancy) & lack of nutrition.
Reproductive Health
• Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) in India has declined to 113 in 2016-18 from 122 in 2015-17 and
130 in 2014-2016.
• The number of contraceptives has increased, but is far from reaching the 100% mark
• According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-4), institutional deliveries have increased
from 39% in 2005-06 to 79% in 2015-16.
o Deliveries in government hospitals rose by 22%, and it fell by 8% in private hospitals
• Increase in unwanted pregnancies, maternal mortality and neonatal mortality are expected to
co
women in 114 low-and middle-income countries may lack access to modern contraceptives,
27
• Restricted mobility, confinement within the household and lack of social connectivity is increasing
ha
si
the risk of violence faced by women and girls who are already vulnerable to abuse.
• Continued access to SRH services is critical for a woman or a girl to prevent an unintended
pregnancy, and to have control over her fertility and life trajectory.
3) Literacy - According to Periodic Labour Force Survey 2018-19, literacy rate in both rural and
urban areas was higher among males than females: In rural areas, literacy rate was 81.9%
among males compared to 65.7% among females and in urban areas, literacy rate was
91.9% among males compared to 82.6% among females.
4) Education - Female participation as per the All India Survey on Higher Education (AISHE)
report show that:
a. Women’s enrolment in higher education has risen to 48.6% in 2018-19 from 10% in
1950-51. The total enrolment in higher education is at 18.2 million females out of 37.4
million. Females per 100 male students have also increased significantly in central
universities, deemed universities, and government-aided institutions.
b. However, the share of male students enrolled in engineering and technology is 71.1%
compared to female enrolment, which is just 28.9%.
been passed. The Women’s Reservation Bill proposes that 33% of the seats would be reserved for
l.
ai
• In the Panchayats, 33% of the seats are reserved for women. This has led to development of many
@
women leaders, but in many places the concept of sarpanch pati has emerged where woman is just
27
gn
the nominal sarpanch, whereas her husband is the real decision-making authority.
ha
• Such practices need to be discouraged, and women should be provided with more political
si
empowerment.
• Political empowerment to women can have the following impacts:
o More focus on women related issues.
o Political parties nurturing women leadership.
o More sensitive handling of women related issues at the top level can have an immense impact
on the status of women.
o It would help in inspiring other women to take up such roles, and thus it can help create
multiple women leaders.
Citizen activism like Shakti – Political Power to Women, National Association of Women’s Organisations
(NAWO) and others, exert public pressure towards policies requiring half the election tickets to be
accorded to women.
What are the reasons behind such a low status being accorded to women in India?
Because of the biological and physical differences between men and women, gender inequality
is often treated as natural. However, despite appearances, scholars have shown that the
inequalities between men and women are social rather than natural. For example, there are no
The constraints on women that vary from upper to the lower castes are reinforced by the
27
class structure as well. The class structure appears to build upon the existing gender
gn
ha
1. Women of upper castes/classes are secluded, and participate mostly in activities within
the domestic sphere.
2. Women from middle castes with medium and small holdings are more likely to work on
their own fields and in certain cases work for wages.
3. Women from artisan castes/classes contribute to the home-based production They
belong to the bottom of the hierarchy where seclusion and restriction on social mobility
are not practiced.
In the urban context, where there is a transition to non-agricultural occupations,the upper
castes form the predominant group among middle classes. Women of this class emerged
from seclusion during the century to acquire education and employment. The important
aspect is that the economic dependence on men is broken. However, this did not drastically
change the subordination of women. Women’s subordination is entrenched in the caste
and class hierarchies which have to be understood. Otherwise, women’s issues will be
misunderstood as mere cultural accidents and violence on women as stray incidents.
The belief is that the male child will support the parents in old age and the female child will leave
@
on marriage resulting in families investing more in a male child. Despite the biological fact that a
27
female baby has better chances of survival than a male baby the rate of infant mortality among
gn
ha
female children is higher in comparison to male children in lower age groups in India.
si
nikah halala (the practice requiring women to marry and divorce another man so that her previous
co
l.
husband can re-marry her after triple talaq) –were unconstitutional. Specifically, she claimed that they
ai
gm
In 2017, the Court, by a majority set aside the practice of triple talaq. This judgment became the
foundation of the present Act passed by Parliament.
Why the government criminalized the Triple Talaq?
The Government held that 473 cases of Triple Talaq have taken place even after two years of
judgement pronounced by the Supreme Court. The law has been placed as a deterrent to eradicate
social evils. To eliminate atrocities faced by women in domestic space parliament enacted:
• The Dowry Prohibition Act in 1961
• Prevention of domestic violence Act 2005
In 2020, one year has passed since the law against triple talaq was passed and there is a decline of
about 82% in triple talaq cases thereafter. According to Ministry of Minority Affairs.
Terming Triple Talaq as unconstitutional as a step towards establishing Uniform Civil Code (Enshrined
in Article 44 of directive principle of state policy), but criminalising it goes against the ethos of
Fundamental rights i.e. article 25 and 26 the freedom of religion. Triple Talaq has led to the
subjugation of Muslim women even after 72 years of independence but its solution must come
through coexistence rather than coercion.
Women were the major producer of food, textiles and handicrafts throughout human history
and continue to provide a major labour input where production is still in the small -scale
subsistence sector. It is essential to categorise various types of work done by women in terms of
paid and unpaid work. This will give us a broad idea to understand the significance of women’s
work both in the family and in society.
fuelwood, fodder and water, collection of forest produce, preparation of cow dung cakes, care
l.
ai
of livestock and cattle and house repair and maintenance. Much of this work, which is
gm
important for the maintenance of families, is largely done by women. However, this work is
@
27
unpaid and is not accounted for as productive work as it is meant for self-consumption. Much
gn
of the work that women do in household industries and processing of agricultural products, if
ha
unpaid, is not recognised as ‘work’ in the data systems. Activities like dairying, small animal
si
husbandry, fisheries, handloom weaving, handicrafts, pottery etc. are family activities and a
major part of the work is done within the home and yet a woman is not accorded the status of
a worker. Non-valuation of women’s unpaid work within the home results in non-recognition of
women’s crucial economic contribution.
India’s amended Maternity Benefit Act 2017 stipulates that employers must provide women
with 26 weeks of paid time off. Given the absence of a corresponding benefit for new fathers, it
perpetuates the gender stereotype of women being the primary caregivers. The law also covers
only formal and large-sized firms which, overall, employ only a small proportion of the country’s
female workers.
Quantifying Women’s Work in GDP
Overwhelming presence of unpaid work of women act as barrier for women to freely access labour
markets, reduce income-earning potential and also lead to persistent inequalities. Unpaid work of
women forms the core of ‘double burden’ that women workers experience over a lifetime. Unpaid work
imposes costs in terms of missed opportunities for education, skill acquisition or improvement and public
participation.
Female Education
• As per Right to Education (RTE), all children (both girls and boys) are entitled to free primary school
m
education till the age of 14. But still, primary education in India is not universal. The most
co
disadvantaged of the lot include the girls, for whom education is not seen as necessary.
l.
ai
gm
o Parents consider teaching household chores to girls are more important than education, and
27
this is due to the ingraining of patriarchy and the confinement of girls inside the house.
gn
o Another reason which keeps girls away from school is the concern for their safety and sexuality.
ha
si
o Also, schools are generally located at a distance, with zero or very few number of female
teachers.
o Lack of toilet facilities inside school premises or lack of separate toilets for girls and boys is
another disincentive
• Literacy Rate of women is 65%, whereas it is 82% for men according to Census 2011. This difference
reflects how far women are behind men in terms of education.
• Illiteracy of women has far reaching consequences, and it has an impact on their children also. Also,
low schooling leads to poor quality of care for their children, leading to higher infant and child
mortality, and it sometimes leads to malnutrition because lack of education makes it difficult for
women to adopt appropriate health promoting behavior such as immunization of children.
• Government measures: 'Sarva Siksha Abhiyan' and 'Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao' are initiatives to
promote the education of girl child.
affects their status as workers with no control on their labour and earnings.
co
l.
ai
As far as women in services and professions are concerned, they are concentrated in certain
27
gn
types of soft skill jobs like teachers, nurses, typists and stenographers and very few occupy
ha
Despite the impressive increase in the number of educated women in urban areas the gap
between men and women in the services and professions is large. It can be attributed to
the following factors-
a) Girls are generally socialised for their domestic roles.
b) Less investment in the vocational and technical training of women
c) Male stereotypes determine attitude to work and differential expectations from girls
education, which is rarely seen as an investment for the future.
d) Higher concentration of girls is found in humanities and social sciences rather than
vocational and technical courses.
e) There is less physical mobility among women after marriage.
(NSSO) and Periodic Labour Force Surveys (PLFS) estimates, female labour force participation rate
@
(LFPR) for productive age-group (15- 59 years) declined by 7.8 % from 33.1 % in 2011-12 to 25.3 % in
27
2017-18 and rate of decline is sharper in rural areas as compared to urban areas. As a result of this,
gn
economies. With reverse migration, demand for work has increased in rural areas, and employment has
co
l.
Moreover, for women in the lower-income strata in rural areas, opportunities in non-farm employment
@
are few, and those in traditional sectors like agriculture and handicrafts have declined. In sectors like
27
gn
construction, jobs have become increasingly masculinised. In urban conglomerations, women are
ha
largely engaged as informal workers and have little reserves. A majority of the jobs in cities are
si
saw the rise of many new women’s groups, which rejected the politics of earlier women’s
co
organizations. These groups sprang up as part of the movement for democracy and against
l.
ai
gm
gender discrimination and later emerged as autonomous organizations without any explicit
@
party affiliations though many of them were drawn from political parties. They mainly intended
27
to raise feminist issues in mass organizations such as trade unions or kisan samitis. Many
gn
ha
autonomous groups, which were mostly women-only groups, without party affiliations and
si
conventional hierarchical organizational structures, were also formed mainly dealing with
domestic issues such as domestic violence.
Women’s movements of the late 1970s and early 1980s were dominated by such autonomous
women’s groups, which were mostly city based. At the same time feminist consciousness had
taken place in some of the rural movements too.
4.1.2. Pre-Independence Women’s Movements
The roots of the Indian women’s movement go back to the early 19th century when social
reformers, beginning with Ram Mohan Roy (1772-1833), began to focus on issues concerning
women. Following them, improving the condition of women became the first tenet of the
Indian social reform movement. Women’s inferior status, enforced seclusion, early marriage,
condition of widows and lack of education were the main facts documented by reformers
throughout the country. However, women's movement is linked to both social reform
movements & the nationalist movement.
Brahmo leader, and sister of the poet Rabindranath Tagore, who formed the Ladies Society
gm
@
in Calcutta in 1882 for educating and imparting skills to widows and other poor women to
27
make them economically self-reliant. She edited a women journal, Bharati, thus earning
gn
2. In 1882, Ramabai Saraswati formed the Arya Mahila Samaj in Pune and a few years later
started the Sharda Sadan in Bombay.
3. The early women’s organizations were confined to a particular locality or city. In 1910,
Sarala Devi Chaudhurani, daughter of Swarnakumari Devi formed the Bharat Stree Mandal
(Great Circle of India Women) with the object of bringing together “women of all castes,
creeds, classes and parties… on the basis of their common interest in the moral and
material progress of the women of India.”
4.1.2.2. National Freedom Movement
At the time when women’s organizations were fighting for women’s political and economic
rights and trying to improve their position by education and social reform, women’s struggle
entered a new phase with the arrival of Mahatma Gandhi on the Indian political scene. Women
had been associated with the freedom struggle before that too. The National Conference was
formed at the third session of the Indian National Congress in 1887 to provide a forum for the
discussion of social issues. The Bharat Mahila Parishad was the women’s wing of this and was
inaugurated in 1905. It focused on child marriage, condition of widows, dowry and other “evil”
Women participated along with men in agrarian struggles and revolts originating in tribal and
ai
gm
rural areas in the colonial period. Tebhaga movement in Bengal, Telangana armed struggle
@
from the erstwhile Nizam’s rule, and the Warli tribal revolt against bondage in Maharashtra are
27
gn
some examples.
ha
si
The growing economic hardships of rural poor and urban women and failure to take up
l.
ai
gm
women’s issues by the general agrarian and industrial workers’ movements led to the
@
emergence of separate women’s organisations in various parts of the country which seriously
27
attempted to organise poor women for a positive change. In Ahmedabad, the first attempt at a
gn
ha
women's trade union was made with the establishment of the Self-Employed Women's
si
and civil rights groups. In the 1980s several women’s and other progressive organisations
@
formed a joint front in Delhi called “Dahej Virodhi Chetna Manch”. Organisations in other
27
major cities also campaigned through protest, demonstrations, discussions, street theatre,
gn
ha
posters etc. against the ghastly murders of young brides for dowry. After much deliberation,
si
the Dowry Prohibition (Amendment) Act, 1984 was passed. The Act sets a limit to the
amount given in dowry but does not ban dowry. Cruelty by the husband and his relatives
leading to suicide or death has become an offence, punishable with imprisonment.
ii) Ecological Movement
a. Economic hardships faced by women in the Himalayan region due to cutting down of
forests resulted in spontaneous mobilisation of women. They hugged the trees to
prevent the contractors from felling them. This is popularly known as the Chipko
movement. The disappearance of forests means acute hardships to women who are
primarily responsible for the collection of fuel, fodder, fruits, herbs for medicine and
other forest produce which give them income and employment. This is why we find
that women are even now in the forefront of these ecological agitations.
b. Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) led by Medha Patkar first started as a protest for not
providing proper rehabilitation and resettlement for the people who have been
displaced by the construction of Sardar Sarovar Dam. Later on, the movement turned
its focus on the preservation of the environment and the ecosystems of the valley.
7) Kasturba Memorial Trust and Bharatiya Grameen Mahila Sangh (Indian Rural Women’s
co
Organisation) with the objective to assist the rural women in developing leadership
l.
ai
gm
potential.
@
27
Feminism consists of social, economic and political movements and theories that are concerned
si
3. An officer who doesn’t report a FIR or delays it for a rape case should be punished
co
5. The government should tackle the issue of trafficking of children and it should also maintain data
@
on the same
27
6. All marriages in India should be registered mandatorily in the presence of a magistrate who would
gn
Towards Equality- A Report, which Actually Set the Government and Voluntary Groups Thinking
co
l.
The United Nations declared 1975–1985 as the International Decade of the Woman and organised the
ai
gm
first UN women's conference in 1975 (Mexico). The World Plan of Action formulated during the
@
Conference stressed the need for research, documentation and analyses into processes in society that
27
In India, the Committee on the Status of Women in India (CSWI) had been set up to examine the status
si
of women in the country and to investigate into the extent to which the constitutional and legal
provisions had impacted on women’s status including their employment and education. The Committee
was the first major attempt to review and evaluate data on various aspects of women’s status. It was
also empowered to comment on the directions of change in women’s roles, rights and opportunities
due to development.
The Committee came out with its findings in the form of a report, popularly known as the Towards
Equality Report (1974), which became a major landmark for the women’s movement. The beginnings of
the women’s movement in India, has often been traced back to this report. The report revealed the
deplorable condition of women in the country evident from demographic data, an analysis of the socio-
cultural conditions prevalent, the legal provisions and safeguards, economic role played by women in all
sectors, women’s access to education, political participation, the policies and programmes for welfare
and development, the impact of mass media, etc.
This Report paved the way for serious thinking on the status of women in different social institutions in
India, because it showed that women far behind men in enjoying the equal rights conferred on them by
them by the constitution. This Report led to a debate in the parliament and showed the failure of the
welfare approach, which treated women as recipients of benefits and not as equal partners in the
development efforts.
A new consciousness that emerged after the publication of Toward Equality led to the setting
up of the Women's Welfare and Development Bureau in 1976 under the Ministry of Social
Welfare. Four Separate working groups on employment of Women, Adult Education
Programmes for Women, Women in Agriculture and Rural Development were also up to work
out strategies for action.
4.2.2. Sixth Five Year Plan: Shift from Welfare to Development
From the Sixth Plan (1980-85) onwards, a marked shift took place from the Welfare to a
Development approach. While the welfare approach treated women as beneficiaries or
recipients of benefits, the development approach recognized women as participants in
development and not as development targets.
• It marked a landmark in the history of women’s development by including a separate
chapter and adopting a multi-disciplinary approach with the three-pronged thrust on
health, education and employment.
• It reviewed the status and situation of women in general and came to the conclusion that
inspite of legal and constitutional guarantees, women had lagged behind men in all sectors.
• For the first time, it clearly spelt out that economic independence would accelerate
improvement in the status of women and suggested the setting up of cells at the district
level for increasing women’s participation through self-employment.
• Emphasised need for increasing enrollment of the girls at the elementary level, thus
encouraging the promotion of education for women in backward areas.
Towards the end of the Sixth Five Year Plan, in 1985, the Department of Women and Child
m
co
Development was set up as part of the Ministry of Human Resource Development. This
l.
ai
Department was created to function as a central agency to formulate and implement plans,
gm
The main objective of Seventh Five Year Plan (1985-1990) was to raise women’s economic and
social status in order to bring them into the mainstream of national development.
• It laid emphasis on generation of employment opportunities for women, both skilled and
unskilled employment through proper education and vocational training. Two new schemes
– Support to Training and Employment (STEP) and Awareness Generation Programme for
Rural and poor Women (AGP) were introduced.
• The plan emphasized on “Beneficiary Oriented Schemes” (BOS) in various development
sectors which extended direct benefits to women.
• The plan also recognised the need for organisation of women workers and unionization.
4.2.4. Eighth Five Year Plan: Shift from ‘Development’ to ‘Empowerment’ of
Women
The Eighth Plan period also saw a revolutionary amendment to the Constitution of India, which
provided for the reservation of one-third of the seats in Panchayati Raj Institutions and urban
local self-governing bodies such as municipalities and corporations to women. The 73rd and
74th constitutional amendments of 1992, which made this reservation possible, have gone
through a network of Self-Help Groups of women. It aimed to bring together all the women
ai
gm
related schemes of the central and state governments at the block level.
@
destitute windows, women prisoners released from jail and without family support, women
ha
three years.
l.
• It gave a large number of women their first opportunity to earn income in cash, reduced reliance
ai
gm
on moneylenders
@
• It has led to a substantial increase in women’s control over resources, including cash in hand and
27
gn
the likelihood of having a bank account, and improvement in women’s ability to make
ha
1) Article 39(a)- State shall direct its policy towards securing all citizens men and women,
@
27
2) Article 39(d)- Equal pay for equal work for both men and women.
ha
si
3) Article 42- The State to make provision for ensuring just and humane conditions of work
and maternity relief.
Fundamental Duties
Article 51 (A)(e)- To renounce the practices derogatory to the dignity of women
Other Provisions
1) Article 300 (A)- Right of property to women.
2) 73rd & 74th Amendment Act 1992- Reservation of 1/3rd of seats in local bodies of
panchayats and municipalities for women. (The day on which 73rd amendment became
operational i.e April 24th is also declared as Women’s Empowerment Day.
11) Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2013 – In the backdrop of Delhi 2012 gang rape, this Act
l.
ai
was passed amending the CrPC. The new law has provisions for increased sentence for rape
gm
convicts, including life-term and death sentence, besides providing for stringent
@
27
punishment for offences such as acid attacks, stalking and voyeurism. Through the revised
gn
Bill, the government has amended various sections of the Indian Penal Code, the Code of
ha
si
Criminal Procedure, the Indian Evidence Act and the Protection of Children from Sexual
Offences Act.
12) Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (Amended in 2017) – It regulates the employment of women
in certain establishments for certain period before and after child-birth and provides for
maternity and certain other benefits.
13) Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 – It provides for payment of equal remuneration to both
men and women workers for same work or work of a similar nature. It also prevents
discrimination on the ground of sex, against women in recruitment and service conditions.
14) Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act,
2013 – The Act provides protection to women from sexual harassment at all workplaces
both in public and private sector, whether organised or unorganized.
15) Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act,
1994 – The Act prohibits sex selection before or after conception and prevents the misuse
of prenatal diagnostic techniques for sex determination leading to female foeticide.
• Insufficient budgetary allocation to states: states could not assign 'Protection officers'
27
gn
Way forward:
ha
si
• Media can sensitize the public against gender-based violence, publicise resources and services
available and encourage the equitable sharing of domestic tasks at home.
• Increase resourcing for NGOs that respond to domestic violence and aid — including shelter,
counselling, and legal aid — to survivors, and promote those that remain open.
• Ensure women’s timely access to necessary and comprehensive sexual and reproductive health
services during the crisis, such as maternal health services, safe abortion etc.
• Finally, the perpetrators of domestic violence must be brought to trial and repeated offenders
must be dealt with strictly as per the provisions of law.
VISION: A society in which, women attain their full potential and are able to participate as
ai
gm
equal partners in all spheres of life and influence the process of social change.
@
programmes and practices which will ensure equal rights and opportunities for women in the
ha
PRIORITY AREAS:
A. Health including food security and nutrition:
• Bring down the high rates of MMR and IMR
• Focus on recognizing women’s reproductive rights, shifting family planning focus also to
males
• Address health care challenges related to nutrition/sexual and reproductive health/
hygiene of adolescents
• Expansion of health insurance schemes
• Nutritious and safe food through PDS for households especially the unreached women
and children with high nutritional vulnerabilities.
A. Education:
• Improve access to pre-primary and primary education
• Improve enrolment and retention of adolescent girls
• Encouraging the enrolment of women in professional/scientific courses, by provision of
financial assistance, coaching, hostels, child care etc.
• Gender perspective in housing and include safe and gender sensitive infrastructure and
co
l.
facilities
ai
gm
• Ensure safe drinking water and sanitation, increase the running water facilities in
27
gn
• Gender parity in the mass media and sports, gender sensitisation and non-
si
• high Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR), Infant Mortality Rate (IMR), malnutrition and
l.
ai
• growing urbanisation and resultant migration of women in relation to the availability of safe
@
27
• women have been sidelined in debates about managing climate change and environmental
ha
si
resources;
• misuse of rapid advances in Information Technology (IT) and telephony has resulted in new
and varied forms of sexual abuse such as cybercrimes and harassment of women through
mobiles and internet.
poverty line and are very often in situations of extreme poverty, given the harsh realities of
l.
ai
programmes will specifically address the needs and problems of such women.
@
27
gn
According to the Economic Survey 2017-18, a rise in migration of men from rural to urban areas
has resulted in feminization of agriculture. Agriculture, contributing around 16% of the GDP, is
increasingly becoming a female activity. As per the 10th Agriculture Census (2015-16), the
percentage of female operational holdings in the country have increased from about 13%
percent during 2010-11 to around 14% during 2015-16. Agriculture sector employs 80% of all
economically active women; they comprise 33% of the agricultural labour force and 48% of self-
employed farmers. About 18% of the farm families in India, according to NSSO Reports are
headed by women.
Gender equity is an important concern for sustainable agricultural development. With
increasing feminization of agriculture and the critical role of women in the agriculture and
allied sectors, as producers, concentrated efforts will be made to ensure that benefits of
training, extension and various programmes will reach them in proportion to their numbers.
The programmes for training women in soil conservation, social forestry, dairy development
and other occupations allied to agriculture like horticulture, livestock including small animal
husbandry, poultry, fisheries etc. will be expanded to benefit women workers in the agriculture
sector.
1. According to NFHS-IV, female sterilization is still the most popular contraceptive method,
ai
gm
2. The sex ratio improved from 914 to 919 at the national level over the last decade, with the
27
gn
top three states being Kerala (1,047), Meghalaya (1,009) and Chhattisgarh (977).
ha
3. Female child mortality (neo-natal, infant, under-5) is lower than male child.
si
4. About two-thirds (67%) of women report at least one problem for themselves in obtaining
medical care – money, distance to health facility, transport.
5. The proportion of women (aged 15-49) who received antenatal care rose from 80% in 2005-
06 to 84% in 2015-16. Deliveries at health facilities has increased from 39% to 79%.
6. The total fertility rates range from 1.2 in Sikkim to 3.4 in Bihar. All states except Bihar,
Madhya Pradesh and Meghalaya have either achieved or maintained replacement level of
fertility.
7. Though anaemia has declined, it still remains widespread. The prevalence of anaemia
among women aged 15 to 49 years is 53% and among adolescent girls aged 15-19 years is
54%.
8. Women are at high risk for nutritional deficiencies in all the stages of their life cycle.
9. Over two-thirds of households in every State/UT have access to an improved source of
drinking water.
10. More than 50% of households have access to improved sanitation facilities in all states/UTs
except Bihar and Madhya Pradesh.
violence and for taking effective action against the perpetrators of such violence. A special
co
l.
emphasis will also be laid on programmes and measures to deal with trafficking in women and
ai
gm
girls.
@
27
As women are highly affected by climate change, environmental degradation, distress migration
si
and displacement in times of natural calamities, policies and programmes for environment,
conservation and restoration will compulsorily incorporate gender concerns. An integral part of
this discourse will be to enable equitable ownership control and use of natural resources and
secure the asset base of marginalised poor women to counter poverty and climate shocks.
The current status of women with respect to human development parameters, legal rights for
women to life and freedom from violence, economic and social discrimination and their rights
to equality and equity shows that a lot still remains to be done. It is necessary therefore, to
reinforce the rights-based approach for creating an enabling environment in which women can
enjoy their rights.
7. Government Response
7.1. Institutional Mechanisms:
1) Central Social Welfare Board - It was established in 1953 to carry out welfare activities for
promoting voluntarism, providing technical and financial assistance to voluntary
organisations for the general welfare of family, women and children. The objective of
setting up Central Social Welfare Board was to work as a link between the government and
the people. The Central Social Welfare Board obtained its legal status in 1969. It was
registered under section 25 of the Indian Companies Act, 1956.
The scheme of Family Counselling Centre (FCC) was introduced by the CSWB in 1983. The
m
co
scheme provides counselling, referral and rehabilitative services to women and children
l.
ai
who are the victims of atrocities, family maladjustments and social ostracism and crisis
gm
@
intervention and trauma counselling in case of natural/ manmade disasters. Working on the
27
concept of people’s participation, FCCs work in close collaboration with the Local
gn
Administration, Police, Courts, Free Legal Aid Cells, Medical and Psychiatric Institutions,
ha
si
improvement in the status of women in India, and also the increasing cases of violence against women.
l.
ai
gm
Issues:
@
• The Commission lacks autonomy and in the performance of its role has been restricted by its
27
gn
institutional design.
ha
• NCW Act makes it mandatory for the governments to involve the Commission in the policymaking
si
process and take action on the recommendations of the Commission. But hardly on any issues is
the NCW consulted.
• There is also a problem with the composition of the Commission. Most of the members are either
ill-informed or uninformed about the issues concerning women.
• Complaint redressal and counselling work of the Commission has not been much success.
• The Commission has often been alleged of red-tapism, callousness and laidback attitude in case of
investigating crimes and atrocities against the rural women.
Some of the reasons for this are:
• The financial assistance provided to the commission is less to cater to its needs, and to fulfill its
mandate
• The members are appointed by the government, and this is a major shortcoming, as the
commission cannot select its own members
• The recommendations of the commission are not mandatory; therefore, the NCW lacks any
concrete legislative power. Recommendations of the commission are not binding on the
government
All these reasons have led the commission to be more of a toothless tiger.
accommodation for working women, with day care facility for their children, wherever
gm
@
possible, in urban, semi urban, or even rural areas where employment opportunities for
27
women exist.
gn
ha
• Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (BBBP): Joint Initiative of Ministry of Women and Child
co
Development, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and Ministry of Human Resource
l.
ai
gm
Development to prevent gender biased sex selective elimination, ensure survival and
@
protection of the girl child, ensure education and participation of the girl child.
27
gn
• National Policy for Skill Development and Entrepreneurship 2015: For training and skill
upgradation of women in traditional, new and emerging areas to promote women
employment in both organized /unorganized sectors.
• Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Grameen Kaushalya Yojana: To bridge the skill gap that prevents
India’s rural poor from competing in the modern market. Mandatory coverage of socially
disadvantaged groups (SC/ST 50%; Minority 15%; Women 33%).
• Vigyan Jyoti: To encourage the women to pursue science and to create a level-playing field
for the meritorious girls in high school to pursue Science, Technology, Engineering, and
Mathematics (STEM) in their higher education.
• Support to Training and Employment Programme for Women (STEP) - MWCD launched
this program in the year 1986, for training and employment for women below poverty line
in traditional sectors like agriculture, small animal husbandry, dairying, fisheries etc. where
women are employed on a large scale. Its basic aim is to upgrade skills of women for self
and wage employment.
• Sukanya Samruddhi Yojana: To motivate parents to open an account in the name of a girl
child to meet the requirement of higher education expense.
commercial sexual exploitation in India. The Scheme is being implemented mainly through
co
• Cyber Crime Prevention against Women and Children (CCPWC): An online cybercrime
@
pornography/ child sexual abuse material, rape/gang rape imageries or sexually explicit
gn
ha
content.
si
Investment in basic social infrastructure and services such as education, health, food security
and nutrition, social protection, legal empowerment and poverty alleviation programs, will
continue to be of paramount importance.
8. Conclusion
Empowerment of women is a socio-political ideal envisioned in relation to the wider
framework of women’s rights. It is a process that leads women to realise their full potential,
their rights to have access to opportunities, resources and choices with the freedom of decision
making both within and outside home. Empowerment would be achieved only when
advancement in the conditions of women is accompanied by their ability to influence the
direction of social change gained through equal opportunities in economic, social and political
spheres of life
Looking back at the last four decades we can say with a fair amount of certainty that women’s
position in Indian society has changed. This change has been to women’s advantage. There has
no doubt been a wider recognition of women’s rights, several steps taken towards equality
among genders, a greater sensitivity towards gender discrimination, etc.
the new emerging ‘women’ be able to realize her complete potential in India.
l.
ai
gm
2. What are the continued challenges for women in India against time and space? (2019)
si
3. ‘Women’s movement in India has not addressed the issues of women of lower social
strata. Substantiate your view. (2018)
4. How do you explain the statistics that show that the sex ratio in Tribes in India is more
favourable to women than the sex ratio among Scheduled Castes? (2015)
5. How does patriarchy impact the position of a middle-class working woman in India?
(2014)
6. Discuss the various economic and socio-cultural forces that are driving increasing
feminization of agriculture in India. (2014)
7. Why do some of the most prosperous regions of India have an adverse sex ratio for
women? Give your arguments. (2014)
8. Male membership needs to be encouraged in order to make women’s organization free
from gender bias. Comment. (2013)
market participation.
l.
ai
gm
The effects of gender inequality, though primarily seen through the prism of
@
discrimination against women, can impoverish the lives of men as well. Gender
27
gn
inequality hurts the interests not only of girls and grown-up women, but also of boys
ha
and men, through biological connections. For instance The neglect of the care of girls
si
and of women in general would tend to yield more maternal undernourishment, and
through that more foetal deprivation and distress, underweight babies, and child
undernourishment. The children start deprived and stay deprived and increases
incidences of cardiovascular diseases etc. in adults.
Similarly in the sphere of economy the ill effects percolates throughout. The inherent
failure to recognize women as economic agents has economic costs. On the other hand,
financial independence allows access to greater decision making power and
opportunities According to the IMF India’s GDP can expand by 27% through gender
parity in workforce.
In the social sphere it hampers socio-economic diversification due to limited
participation. While new developments in popular culture are inhibited, cultural
stereotypes are sustained. In political sphere gender inequality undermines the
promise of democracy and good governance. True liberty and equality cannot be
achieved without addressing gender inequality.
As discussed above inequality between women and men can take very many different
2. Give an account of the factors which influence gender equality in basic education.
What can be done to bridge the existing gender gap in this context?
Approach:
• Give a detailed description of the factors which influence gender equality in basic
education.
• Then explain what steps should be taken to bridge the gender gap in basic
education.
Answer:
The interplay of socio-economic inequalities and gender relations creates a complex
web that impedes girl education.
Several factors are impeding the education of girls.
• Economic disparities: Below poverty line households and top quartile households
have high gender disparities.
• Social inequalities: Girls are doubly affected by the absence of effective early
childhood education programmes as they are invariably burdened with the
responsibility of caring for younger siblings.
• Distance norms go against girls as they are often not allowed to go out of the
village for schooling.
• Cultural beliefs: Norms like early marriages discourage girl education.
• Regional characteristics: Rural – urban differences in enrolment, attendance and
completion of female education.
• Poor infrastructure, teacher abseentism and over-crowded classrooms are some
other discouraging factors.
m
•
ai
• Better infrastructure in the schools especially toilets for girls can reduce dropout
gn
rates.
ha
• The founding of a women’s wing of the Textile Labour Association (TLA), in the form
@
unorganized sector who worked as vendors and hawkers and at home in the
si
putting-out system and organized them into a union which along with collective
bargaining provided training, credit and technical help.
• In the field of environment the role of women, was key in Chipko movement in
1974, named after the the actions of women who hugged trees in order to prevent
them from being cut down by timber contractors.
• The Bhopal Gas Peedit Mahila Udyog Sangathan played the leading role in the
effort to secure justice for the victims of the chemical gas leak in the Union Carbide
factory in Bhopal in 1984.
• In politics women have emerged as keen voter group and through one-third
reservation in panchayats they have been able to exert important influence in
governance at grass roots level.
TFR rate is lower for women who are part of formal workforce. Even participation
co
• Social status of females and prevalence of dowry affects the TFR. In regions where
@
such trend is present, parents having girl child produce more children in hope of
27
having boy.
gn
ha
• TFR rate is lower in those states where women empowerment index is relatively
si
5. In the Global Wage Report of International Labour Organisation, India has the worst
levels of gender wage disparity. Comment. Enumerate briefly the factors that
contribute to the existing gender pay gap in India.
Approach:
• Briefly state some of the findings of Global Wage Report with regard to India.
• On the basis of these facts, decipher the possible reasons which contribute to
gender pay gap in India.
• Also suggest some measures, which would help ameliorate the existing gender pay
gap.
Answer:
Gender pay gap refers to the difference in earnings between women and men in the
paid employment and labor market for the same amount of work. It is generally
expressed as a percentage of men’s earnings and is often used as a statistical tool to
measure the levels of social inclusion in a country.
As per the Global Wage Report 2016-17, India has among the worst levels of gender
wage disparity with the gap exceeding 30 per cent, which means that women are paid
30 per cent less than men in hourly wages in India in the similar job profiles.
According to the report, women in India make up 60% of the lowest earning paid wage
labour but just 15% of the highest paid wage earners. This despite the fact that the
2011 Census showed that among recent graduates in their early 20s, there are now
more female doctors and teachers than male, and there are now more female post-
m
Gender gap pay is pervasive both at the bottom as well as in the top bracket of wage-
gm
earners. Not only women are paid less, there were fewer women in highly paid
@
27
occupations.
gn
ha
• Occupational segregation
o Rate of female participation in the paid labor market is generally low, and is
primarily concentrated in rural areas in the agricultural sector towards less
productive economic activities.
• Cultural and biological barriers
o Status and caste based segregation of labour has been a common feature in
India, especially in society which scores high on patriarchy.
o Spatial movement of the women is tied up with the movement of their family
members (especially husband), which is not so much pervasive in the case of
men.
• Educational and training
o Literacy rate for women in India has been far lower than the literacy rate for
men.
o Investment in education and training has also been strongly in favor of men as
they are brought up with the expectation of being bread earners for the whole
family.
identity to a mere object of desire but also reinforces the patriarchal structure of the
gm
@
Approach:
ha
si
• Introduce by giving the current status of women i.e. how they are portrayed.
• With examples provide the true picture of different sectors which portray women
as commodities.
• Discuss how it reinforces patriarchy.
• Conclude by providing a solution to this problem.
Answer:
It is said that there is no tool for development more effective than the empowerment
of women but many a times this empowerment gets disguised when women are
portrayed on various forums in either of the two characters - as an object of desire or
as their all-pervasive stereotypical roles.
Literature and media are two streams which portray women in different yet similar
light. Though the recognition of women’s identity in literature and media is similar to
each other but both claim to redefine the women’s position in their own ways.
Literature promises a holistic representation of women’s self, lending them an enviable
comparable status with men. On the one hand women is portrayed as divine in our
7. The relegation of women to private sphere of life is the main cause behind gender
inequality and exploitation in India. Discuss.
m
co
l.
Approach:
ai
gm
like India that pushes women into the private spheres of life i.e.
ha
si
domestic/household work.
• Discuss how this relegation leads to gender inequality and exploitation of women.
• Conclude with a brief discussion on the importance of addressing both private and
public patriarchy to achieve gender equality.
Answer:
Gender inequality signifies a form of socially constructed and predefined gender roles
that defy the notion of equal value of the roles of women and men. It has deep cultural
and historical roots in India’s socio-cultural fabric. India has historically been a
patriarchal society where men dominate and exercise control over women both within
and outside the family. It is argued that relegation of women to private spheres of life is
the main cause behind gender inequality and discrimination in India.
Women have traditionally been restricted to the private spheres of life through
compulsory domesticity. The segregation of roles is biased in favour of men by
confining women within the premises of the house. While role of women consist of
tending to family needs such as child rearing, men were assigned the task of protecting
8. Discuss why women continue to bear an uneven burden of the terminal methods of
family planning in India. What can be done to address this unevenness?
Approach:
• Discuss the reasons for reluctance of Indian men to undergo sterilisation.
• Suggest strategies to improve the gender balance in the sterilisation process.
• Conclude by citing some current initiatives and the way forward.
Answer:
m
co
l.
The latest National Health Mission report has flagged the “uneven burden” women
ai
gm
bear in family planning. As per the report, women account for more than 93 per cent of
@
sterilisations in the country, even though male sterilisation is regarded as safer, quicker
27
gn
and easier.
ha
si
There are several reasons for reluctance of Indian men to undergo sterilisation:
• Paucity of knowledge about appropriate and alternate contraceptive methods.
• Myths and misconceptions like sterilisation leading to loss of virility.
• Social taboo and sheer logistical limitations.
• Non availability and untimely access to male sterilisation services.
• Poor access to information and counselling on available methods of contraception
and their associated side effects.
• Reluctance of the women health workers at the village level to discuss the socio-
culturally sensitive issue of sterilisation with men.
Suggestions
• Countrywide campaign to promote the adoption of vasectomy, break gender
stereotypes, dispel myths and position men as responsible partners in family
planning.
• Providing incentives for vasectomy.
• Enhanced access to male sterilisation services; promoting “No Scalpel Vasectomy”.
m
co
l.
ai
gm
@
27
gn
ha
si