FPM - Terrain Resolver v2.2
FPM - Terrain Resolver v2.2
2.0 2012-04-20 Veronika Podest Updates for new functionality up to FPM version 4.2.17.0
Adopted Sabre document format
2.1 2012-06-18 Veronika Podest Clarification on Icing (affected scenarios and altitude profile)
2.2 2012-06-26 Veronika Podest Added note on ED Profile TAS correction for wind
This document describes the basic logic of the Terrain Resolver module within the
Sabre® AirCentre™ Flight Plan Manager system, how to configure it, and how to
interpret its results.
It does not explain the legal requirements to plan terrain avoidance according to
regulations.
This document describes the features of Sabre® AirCentre™ Flight Plan Manager
system version 4.2.17.0.
1.3 Overview
On regular routings with normal aircraft performance, FPM will calculate optimum
altitudes in terms of aircraft weight, wind, Cost Index and restrictions. Terrain is, in
most cases, already considered in the en-route restrictions of airways. However, an
aircraft in distress will no longer adhere to published minimum altitudes or restrictions.
The safe continuation of the flight and landing at the next available airport are a priority.
The Terrain Resolver is similar to EROPS, insofar as that both techniques aim to
provide safe diversion and landing options in case of emergencies, such as rapid
decompression of the cabin or failed engines. But while EROPS only calculates the fuel
requirements and equal time points between airports (for decision-making whether to
continue on or turn back) along the route, Terrain Avoidance also looks at the maximum
altitudes achievable by an aircraft with degraded performance and the actual terrain
along the route.
Routes leading over high mountain ranges (such as the Rocky Mountains or the
Himalayas) might not be able to clear all terrain in such emergencies, particularly when
decompression forces the plane to flight levels with breathable air. The system
recognizes such sections, and looks for routes to divert safely. Of course, the additional
fuel requirements for the diversion routes are calculated as well.
A regular great-circle diversion from a critical point to the emergency airport might not
be able to clear terrain either, in which case the system can be allowed to create simple
escape routes (using another waypoint in between), or in particularly complicated
situations use manually created, predefined escape routes.
Figure 1 – If cabin decompression forces a plane to quickly descend into lower altitudes, it is
important to check for and avoid high terrain.
Engine failure scenarios are known in FPM as either Method 1 (M-1) or Method 2
(M-2) calculations.
M-1 ensures that along the route, the aircraft will be able to clear all encountered
terrain by a given distance during a one-engine-out failure (refer chapter 2.1).
Otherwise the amount of ATOG reduction is reported, which would be required to
be able to clear the terrain successfully.
M-2 also checks terrain along the route (although typically against a larger padding
than M-1) during an engine failure. On twin engine aircraft a one-engine-out failure
is calculated, while on 3- or 4-engine aircraft it is a two-engines-out. Wherever
terrain cannot be cleared along the route, emergency alternate airports are used to
divert to (refer chapter 2.2).
If M-1 was already calculated and was able to clear the terrain, M-2 will usually not be
triggered anymore (with one exception, refer chapter 5.2).
Depressurization is known in FPM as the Oxygen (O2) scenario. It follows a step-down
procedure into altitudes with breathable air, and uses emergency alternate airports to
divert to (refer chapter 2.3).
Note FPM will not add Additional Fuel (like it does for EROPS) during terrain checks. The system however
recognizes and may warn a dispatcher that not enough fuel is on board at a critical point to reach the
emergency alternate via the escape route (refer chapter 4.4.3). This limitation is due to the fact that the
terrain clearance checks currently occur at the end of the flight calculation, when all masses and
altitudes are fixed values.
Which scenarios are calculated can be configured system-wide (refer chapter 5.2) and, if
allowed via configuration, overridden by the dispatcher (refer chapter 5.2.1.2).
Method 1 (M-1) ensures that within 5NM along either side of the route, the aircraft will
be able to clear all encountered terrain by a given distance during a one-engine-out
failure. Additionally, it must be possible to hold at 1,500ft above the destination airport.
The amount by which terrain has to be cleared by M-1 is configurable per aircraft
subtype in FPM Administrator (refer chapter 6.2), but is usually set to 1,000ft according
to regulations.
If M-1 is not able to clear all terrain, the system may report the amount of ATOG
reduction required to be able to succeed. If both M-1 and M-2 are enabled for
calculation, a failed M-1 would automatically trigger M-2 to resolve the high terrain.
Method 2 (M-2) ensures that within 5NM along either side of the route, the aircraft will
be able to clear all encountered terrain by a given distance during an engine failure
(one-engine-out on 2-engine aircraft, two-engines-out on 3- or 4-engine aircraft).
Additionally, it must be possible to hold at 1,500ft above the destination airport.
The amount by which terrain has to be cleared by M-2 is configurable per aircraft
subtype in FPM Administrator (refer chapter 6.2), but is usually set to 2,000ft according
to regulations.
The system then looks for diversion options (refer chapter 3) to reach an emergency
alternate airport. Any escape route also is checked against the M-2 requirements.
If the position of terrain and route is such that no escape route can be found which
sufficiently avoids the terrain, M-2 and the flight calculation as a whole fails.
FPM may also be set up to only trigger an M-2 calculation on 3- or 4-engine aircraft, if
the route lies outside of a configurable coverage of suitable airports. The radius of the
coverage can be controlled via the speed ("TAS IA" field on the Aircraft Subtype
Planning tab, refer document [R1]) and the flight time in minutes (please contact Sabre
Support).
Similar to M-2, O2 will report escape routes (refer chapter 3) to emergency alternate
airports if the encountered terrain requires it.
Figure 5 - Continuing point (green star) lies before no-return point (yellow star), terrain is cleared
Figure 6 - Continuing point (green star) lies after no-return point (yellow star), escape routes have
to be found for route section in between
FPM offers three types of escape routes: direct diversion, simple escape routes and
predefined escape routes.
Direct diversion uses directs from the planned route to the available emergency alternate
airports to escape high terrain.
In configurable intervals, the system checks that a direct from this point in the route to
the airport meets the M-2 requirements. If it finds that a direct diversion does not
achieve terrain avoidance, it will try to find other emergency alternate airports, where
the plane can divert to safely.
Figure 7 - Direct escape routes (green) for a route section, using two emergency alternate airports.
(T1) is the no-return point, from where FPM diverts to airport A. (T2) is the last point where a
diversion to airport A is possible as any later diversion would not achieve terrain clearance, and the
system switches to airport B instead. (T3) is the continuing point, i.e. the last point where the plane
would have to turn back to airport B in order to divert safely.
The no-return and continuing waypoints will be reported as two critical terrain
waypoints (Tx). Additionally, any points in the route where the system "switches" from
one emergency alternate airport to another will be reported.
Simple escape routes continue or return to a point along the planned route (either an
official or coordinate waypoint) before diverting to the emergency alternate airport. This
allows the system to cover a larger section of route with one airport.
Figure 8 – Same as on Figure 7, the system uses a direct diversion where possible, i.e. between
(T1) and (T2). Then it switches to a simple escape route (dashed green) via another point, which
causes airport A to be sufficient for terrain clearance on the entire section, e.g. if airport B is
unsuitable on the flight's day. Between (T2) and (T3), the plane should turn back and divert to
airport A via (T2). After passing (T3), it should instead continue along the route and divert via (T4).
The VIA point (its name or coordinate) will be reported alongside the critical terrain
waypoints (Tx).
Depending on the terrain and the planned route, the system may switch between using a
direct diversion and a simple escape route quite often on a longer section without terrain
clearance, causing a rather complex-looking solution even with few different emergency
airports.
Predefined escape routes are manually created routings which take advantage of lower
terrain (e.g. valleys in a vast mountain range) leading into an airport. These are of use
mostly in situations where direct diversions or simple escape routes would be unable to
find a valid escape route.
Predefined Escape Routes are maintained in FPM Administrator (refer chapter 3.3.1).
During terrain calculation, the system checks each potential emergency alternate if
predefined escape routes are available. If so, it will try to connect to any of the
waypoints along the escape route, to check whether this would lead to a useful coverage.
Otherwise the route will not be used.
If multiple escape routes are available for one emergency alternate, FPM will prioritize
shorter routes over longer ones.
FPM will try to connect with a direct from the planned route to any waypoint of the
predefined escape route – although it will prefer the closest which does not require a
turn back (i.e. no more than 90° angle from the original flight path) – and follow its path
into an airport. The system will consider turn-back if the preferred waypoint is not an
option due to terrain on the diversion.
Note The functionality of predefined escape routes is implemented in FPM system version 4.2.16.0 and
higher. It is not available in 4.1.
Figure 9 - A predefined escape route (orange) leads into airport A. FPM connects from the planned
route to one (in this case the second) waypoint along the predefined escape route.
The system may also have to try different options of connecting to the predefined
escape routes, if e.g. the direct to a waypoint does not clear terrain, or if further down
the escape route the terrain cannot be resolved.
Figure 11 - Connecting to the third waypoint of the predefined escape route finally allowed
successful terrain avoidance.
3.3.1 Administration
Predefined escape routes are not connected to citypairs; they only relate to a specific
airport. The system automatically determines if and how to use any predefined escape
route based on the flight's planned route and suitability of the airport as an emergency
alternate.
They are created and maintained within FPM Administrator like regular Subroutes
(refer document [R1]).
Figure 12 - FPM Administrator; Routings; Data tab; Typ selection now offers the option "Terrain" for
predefined escape routes.
The FPID of a new predefined escape route have to start with the airport's ICAO code,
otherwise FPM Administrator will show an error message when trying to save the route.
In the Route Definition field, similar to creating Subroutes, enter the desired waypoints
(refer document [R1]).
The last waypoint of the Route Definition of a predefined escape route has to be an
airport (waypoint type 'PA'), otherwise saving the route will display an error popup.
Note Even though predefined escape routes may be created over airways, it is recommended to use only
DCTs. Airways may be modified or deleted, which would then lead to either modified escape routes
over different areas which in turn can lead to unsuccessful terrain calculations if the terrain cannot be
cleared anymore, or the escape route could not be used because of missing airway definition.
The column "Con" (Connection) was added to the dialog. Enter an "N" here to prevent
terrain diversions from connecting to the waypoint. Keep the field blank to allow
connections.
Constraints for fleets, engine types, and weight categories limiting the availability of the
predefined escape route can be applied on the Constraints tab, analogous to other
Routing types.
As the Terrain Resolver has common functionalities with EROPS, e.g. looking for
alternate airports along the route, it can also be managed through FPM's EROPS Page.
The first step, taking place before the actual calculation, is to select all available airports which
may be used as Terrain alternates (TA).
All airports need to be authorized for usage as TA, as per company policy, by enabling the
checkboxes in the "Emergency Altn" column in the Airport Usage tab (refer document [R1]).
The search range for airports available as emergency alternates initially is linked to the
corridor set to use for EROPS (configurable; by default 100NM). Next, the radius is
widened to the aircraft's THT.
If the system then still couldn't cover the entire route with safe diversion routes, the
search can be
stopped (i.e. the maximum distance is based on the aircraft's THT),
extended to a multiple of the aircraft's THT (if the configured multiple of the THT
results in a value higher than the MDT, the MDT is used as the upper limit), or
extended to the aircraft's MDT.
Note By default, the maximum search range is the aircraft's THT. Please contact Sabre Support to configure
this option. This feature is only available in 4.2.16.0 and higher.
The user may also add airports manually to the list, either by typing the airport IATA or ICAO
code into the QuickEROPS field, or by searching for airports close-by.
To search for en-route alternates, pick a waypoint in the Routing list on the right-hand side of
the EROPS Page, adjust the radius (in NM), and click the Search button. By double-clicking an
airport from the result list, it will be added into the QuickEROPS string.
Additionally the search may be configured to only return "suitable" airports.
If the filter "Suitable only" is not enabled, unsuitable airports are highlighted red in the result
list.
Please refer document [R4] for details about the manual search for Enroute Alternates.
4.1.3 QuickEROPS
The selected airports will show in the QuickEROPS field on the EROPS Page in FPM.
4.1.3.1 Suitability
Figure 15 – QuickEROPS string with airports authorized for EROPS and Terrain within a corridor
along the route. KHAF is unsuitable, and the failed suitability check is overridden.
Other Suitability Checks (next to authorization) also need to be passed for the airports to be
used during Terrain Calculation. Those depend on the system configuration, and can include
weather minima, runway lengths, opening times, etc. The timeframes, within which these
suitability checks need to be passed, are estimations as long as the flight is not calculated.
Airports which are considered "unsuitable" due to failed Suitability Checks will appear red in
the QuickEROPS field.
In order to allow the system to use an "unsuitable" airport, e.g. if the airport is unsuitable due to
a corrupted TAF (weather forecast), it can be added in the Ignore Suitability Check textbox.
Airports with overridden failed suitability checks will still appear red in the QuickEROPS field.
In Mode Auto, airports are displayed with prefixes, according to allowed airport usages:
N N Y prefix XT:
N Y Y prefix XI:
Y N Y prefix XE:
Y Y N no prefix, unsuitable
Y Y Y no prefix
The XT: prefix can also be added manually to any airport, to exclude it from EROPS
calculations yet allowing it as a Terrain airport.
However, there is currently no way to exclude airports from the Terrain calculation while still
allowing it for EROPS, other than by disallowing Emergency airport usage.
In order to view whether any airport in the QuickEROPS list will not be considered for Terrain,
click the "Check Airports" button.
The message "EMG: […]: Airport not authorized" will be displayed for every airport lacking
authorization for Terrain. The airports' ICAO codes in the QuickEROPS field will also be
highlighted in red to indicate the failed Suitability Check.
4.1.5 Paddings
Altitude ("Pad Alt") and weight ("Pad GM") buffers may be added, which cause the
system to consider the aircraft to start out a failure scenario at a lower altitude/with
higher gross mass than would be calculated. This increases the length of route sections
without terrain clearance, the fuel consumption, and the risk of the system being unable
to find resolutions for areas with high terrain.
The fields are populated with values according to the "Pads" settings on the aircraft
subtype in FPM Administrator (refer chapters Note and 6.2.4), and allow the dispatcher
to adjust them as desired.
After successful calculation of an M-2 (and O2) scenario, the "Airports used" field will
display the order of airports on an additional line labeled "TA:".
If M-2 and O2 were calculated separately (refer chapter 5.2), they might use different
airports for their purposes. In this case O2 airports will be shown on their own line,
labeled "O2:".
Note The labels "TA:" and "O2:" for the used Terrain airports are configurable.
As soon as the flight was calculated successfully, and the system used TA airports, the
critical terrain points are shown on the map as (T1), (T2), etc.
In order to view escape routes, right-click into the map and select "Show/hide Escape
Routes".
You may also select "Individual Escape Routes" to choose from which critical points
the escape routes should be overlain.
Simple Escape Routes are displayed similar to direct diversions, with the exception that
they follow the route before turning towards the emergency airport.
Predefined Escape Routes are shown in a different color, with escape routes from
various critical points connecting to its waypoints.
The color used to draw predefined escape routes on the map can be configured for M-2
and O2 escape routes individually. If M-2 and O2 calculations were 'combined', the M-2
color will be used. Please contact Sabre Support to change the colors.
The Altitude Profile offers a similar overlay. Right-click into the profile to choose from
which critical point the escape routes should be overlain. Due to display constraints,
only one critical point's escape routes can be shown at the same time.
Figure 19 – The green curved line shows the M-2 decompression scenario's driftdown path, the
other the emergency descent stepdown procedure of the O2 scenario.
The initial altitudes of escape routes often are slightly off from the calculated cruise
altitude en-route. The latter are displayed in pressure altitudes, while escape routes are
shown in true altitude in order to give a proper relation to the underlying terrain.
If the Terrain overlay is enabled as well (see Figure 19), the black shaded area is the
terrain encountered along the planned route. Shaded in blue is the terrain underneath the
escape routes.
The Terrain Report – either as the TERRA Message Type on the FPM Comm Page or as
part of the OFP – will display the results of the terrain calculation.
Terrain Reports can be created as PDF files, which increases readability.
If M-1 already cleared the terrain, the Terrain Report only states that fact:
Note In this case, M-2 will be calculated even if M-1 already managed to clear the terrain.
[… report continues …]
[… report continues …]
Figure 23 - M-1, M-2 and O2 calculation, without being combined in the report
3 4 5 6
9
8
10
3 4 5 6
9
8
10
A warning about insufficient fuel at the most critical terrain decision point can be issued
on the Errors Page, e.g. "Planning Error #280: Terrain Clearance: Insufficient fuel,
check (T2)".
Note By default, this warning is disabled. Please contact Sabre Support to change this option.
The TERRA Report will in this case indicate negative Surplus Fuel (SRP) on the terrain
decision point.
The system may use other critical terrain points or en-route waypoints to specify the
point where to turn off-route for simple escape routes (refer chapter 3.2). These points
are then reported on the VIA line on Terrain Reports.
Figure 24 - TERRA Report excerpt with Simple Escape Routes. Before (T1), the aircraft simply
returns to OMDB. After passing (T1) however, it will first continue along the route to (T2) and then
turn off the route and fly a direct towards OIZH. The VIA line specifies the name of the point where
to turn off-route, its coordinates as well as the distance from the previous en-route waypoint.
Only the TERRA Report will print all waypoints used in a predefined escape route.
Elsewhere only the first waypoint of the escape route is displayed. This logic has been
designed as not all FMGCs are capable of storing secondary routes. In such cases,
during a real emergency scenario with extremely high pilot workload, the pilot would
only turn towards the first waypoint and would add further routing details later during
the emergency descent, once the workload has decreased.
Figure 25 – TERRA Report excerpt with Predefined Escape Routes. Before (T2), the plane will
divert directly to SKCL. After passing (T2) however, it will first turn off towards the stated waypoint
TUNGI and follow this route, in order to finally land safely at SEMT.
Since the system prefers direct or simple escape routes, the report might feature critical
terrain decision points where both return and continuing lines show the same emergency
alternate, however the way to reach the airport might change: e.g. before T7 divert via a
DCT into the emergency alternate, after T7 continue to the same airport via a predefined
escape route (see Figure 18).
To automatically enable terrain calculations on all flights, please contact Sabre Support.
Additionally, Citypairs in FPM Administrator allow overriding the system-wide default.
FPM may be configured to allow dispatchers to decide which terrain scenarios should
be calculated on a flight in the Extended Terrain Options dialog (refer chapter 5.2.1.2).
If this is not enabled, the system-wide default settings from the configuration file
determine the calculated scenarios. To verify or change the system-wide default, please
contact Sabre Support.
A "…" button may also be displayed next to the Terrain checkbox on FPM's Flight Page.
This button opens a Terrain Options dialog, which in turn may give either simple or
extended terrain options.
The availability of certain options (e.g. in Figure 27 and Figure 28 the "Predefined"
checkbox is disabled), as well as the default settings (checked/unchecked) are
configurable through Sabre Support (refer chapter 5.2.1.3).
5.2.1.1 Escape Routes
The dispatcher may manually allow/disallow the system to use simple (refer chapter
3.2) and predefined (refer chapter 3.3) escape routes.
5.2.1.2 Calculation Options
In the extended version of the Terrain Options dialog, the dispatcher may select which
kind of terrain calculation shall be performed by the system. Please note:
due to dependencies, clicking "O2" will automatically enable "M-2", while disabling
"M-2" will also disable "O2", and
clicking "Combined" will automatically enable "M-2" and "O2" calculations.
If no Calculation Option is enabled, also the overall Terrain checkbox will be
deselected.
The following list shows the available combinations of enabled terrain scenarios, the
performed calculation and report types.
M-1 M-1
M-2 M-2
Remarks about the terrain calculation can be generated automatically, which are then
visible in the Edit Info dialog in FPM, and depending on the customer's OFP format,
also in the OFP remark section.
Remarks can be created in the following scenarios:
1. Terrain was not requested (according to default configuration).
2. Terrain was disabled by the dispatcher (enabled through default configuration, but
the Terrain option was manually unchecked in FPM).
3. Although requested, Terrain calculation was never started, i.e. no terrain above the
"Min Check Height" encountered (refer chapter 6.2)
4. Terrain was successfully resolved, i.e. a full terrain report for M-1, M-2 and/or O2
are available. In this case the remark will state only the most basic information,
while the report holds the full terrain calculation data.
5. If terrain could not be resolved, a critical error is displayed on FPM's Error Page and
the flight calculation fails. Therefore, no remark will be produced.
Terrain Remarks are generally triggered by a single system-wide configuration, as well
as an aircraft subtype setting which overrides it individually for scenarios (1) and (2).
Figure 29 - FPM Administrator Aircraft Subtype, Emergency Profiles tab, Options checkbox
disabled [DEFAULT] no no no no no
disabled [OFF] no no no no no
Automatically enable or disable bleed air deicing conditions. The dispatcher may
override the default settings on each individual flight on the EROPS Page.
Figure 30 - FPM Administrator Aircraft Subtype, Emergency Profiles tab, Bleed default settings
The emergency profiles list at the top holds profiles for both EROPS (refer documents
[R2] and [R3]) and Terrain.
Field Description
Type Terrain scenarios always have Type "TA", whereas "IA" and "EA" stand for EROPS.
Mode The first two characters of the Mode column make up the failure code and are, together with
the speed, used to look up performance data, and must therefore match a set of aircraft
performance data.
1st character: number of failed engines
O2 calculations look for a 0 Engine Out profile; M-1 calculations will always use 1 Engine
Out profiles. M-2 calculations will either use the 1 Engine Out profile (on 2-engine
aircraft) or the 2 Engine Out profile (on 3- or 4-engine aircraft).
2nd character: gear position – either U (up) or D (down)
3rd character: either D (decompression/emergency descent) or N (norm cruise)
For O2 profiles (Mode 0xxx), this needs to be set to D in order to consider the emergency
descent profile.
4th character: APU – either A (additional APU fuel flow) or '–' (no APU fuel added)
The APU fuel flow can be set on the Aircraft Subtype Planning tab, in the ApuFF field
(refer document R1]).
Speed The speed used for the terrain calculation. Only the first character is currently used by the
system to determine the speed setting for the performance data lookup (together with the first
two characters of the Mode column).
A "C" stands for cost index 0 (minimum fuel), while an "I" means cost index 999 (minimum
time). There is currently no option to specify a fixed MACH value or a different cost index
value.
Driftdown scenarios (M-1, M-2) use the speed column, while the Oxygen scenario (O2) relies
entirely on data provided in the Emergency Descent Profile (refer chapter 6.2.2).
Note Engine + Airfoil Anti Ice already includes Engine Anti Ice. Therefore it is not possible to
have both checkboxes on the FPM EROPS Page ticked at the same time. If both the
first and second character of the Ice column are set to Y, the checkboxes in FPM decide
which percentage is added to the fuel.
Each of the icing checkboxes in FPM can be set up to be ticked or unticked by default on all
flights of an aircraft subtype (refer chapter 5.4).
The percentage of fuel added can be set on the on the Aircraft Subtype Planning tab, in the
Eng.AntiIce and E+A Anti Ice fields (refer document R1]).
The bottom half of the Emergency Profiles tab holds various terrain options.
As of system version 4.1.16.0 and 4.2.14.1, the aircraft subtype checkboxes "Perform
M-1 Calculation", "Consider E/D for M-1 Calc" and "Consider E/D for M-2 Calc" have
been disabled (refer chapter 5.2).
For details about the "Bleed default settings", please refer chapter 5.4. For "Options",
refer chapter 5.3.
6.2.1 Heights
FPM will – as the very first step – check if it encounters any terrain higher than the
"Min Check Height" along the route. If not, terrain avoidance calculations are not
started at all.
If M-1 is enabled, the system will check it against the "M-1 Clearance Height" value.
Typically, M-2 will use the "M-2 Clearance Height", except where configured to use
M-1 clearance heights (refer chapter 2.2).
Field Description
Desc the time in seconds required to descent from the previous row's altitude to this FL
Level the time in seconds for which the aircraft maintains the current FL before continuing to
descend to the next row's altitude
cTAS True Air Speed during level flight (and descent, if dTAS is empty)
Note In FPM system versions prior to 4.2.15.0, only one TAS column is available, used for both level and
descent speeds. With the introduction of a separate descent speed, TAS was renamed to cTAS.
Therefore, if dTAS is left empty, cTAS will also be applied to descents.
Note Both cTAS and dTAS will be corrected for forecasted winds during calculation, but not for ISA.
The altitude lowers the calculated cruising FL as it is applied to the terrain scenarios. A
flight planned at FL390, using an aircraft set up with an Altitude Padding of 1,000ft,
would be considered to only be at FL380 during driftdown and/or emergency descent.
The dispatcher may still change the altitude padding on the FPM EROPS Page.
The weight padding increases the assumed weight of the aircraft during driftdown
calculations. For different trip distances, different weight paddings may be configured.
Field Description
Weight Pads added mass (kg or lbs, depending on the aircraft's weight unit setup)