Sail RSP Blast Furnace No. 5 - A Greenfield Project in A Brownfield Optimization Context
Sail RSP Blast Furnace No. 5 - A Greenfield Project in A Brownfield Optimization Context
Sail RSP Blast Furnace No. 5 - A Greenfield Project in A Brownfield Optimization Context
Abstract
Rourkela Steel Plant (RSP), which is operated by the Steel Authority of India Limited
(SAIL), was inaugurated in 1959 and was the first Integrated Steel Plant in the public
sector in India. In 2013, RSP commissioned their No. 5, 4060 m³ Blast Furnace,
India's largest. It was built as a turn-key project by a consortium consisting of Danieli
Corus and Tata Projects Ltd. and is entirely based on the technology and know-how
of Danieli Corus. The new Blast Furnace is the key element of an expansion program
that doubles the plant's production capacity and with much of the existing ironmaking
capacity reaching the end of its technical and economic life span, it enables RSP to
meet existing as well as growing demand for its products. This article discusses how
this greenfield Blast Furnace was built in an existing and operating Integrated Steel
Plant. It covers the accommodation of land, planning of the new installation to fit the
available plot as well as the updated logistical lay-out of the plant. Technical details
of the installation are presented, including their consequences for RSP's
environmental performance and new perspectives for campaign planning.
Keywords: Blast furnace; Greenfield; Brownfield; Expansion; Construction.
1
Director Operations, Danieli Corus BV, IJmuiden, The Netherlands.
2
Marketing & Sales, Danieli Corus BV, IJmuiden, The Netherlands.
3
Manager Ironmaking, Danieli Corus BV, IJmuiden, The Netherlands.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1060
ISSN 2176-3135
1 INTRODUCTION
Rourkela Steel Plant (RSP), operated by the Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL),
was inaugurated in 1959 and was the first Integrated Steel Plant in the public sector
in India. In 2013, RSP commissioned their 4060 m³ Blast Furnace No. 5, India's
largest. It was built as a turn–key project by a consortium consisting of Danieli Corus
and Tata Projects Ltd. (TPL) and is entirely based on the technology and know–how
of Danieli Corus.
The new furnace is the key element of an expansion program that doubles the plant's
capacity. With much of the existing ironmaking capacity reaching the end of its
technical and economic life span, the new furnace enables RSP to meet existing as
well as future demand for its products.
RSP was set up in 1959 by Hindustan Steel Limited, a company that would be
integrated into SAIL upon its formation in 1973. The plant’s initial capacity was
around 1 Mtpa, which over the following decades would grow towards 2 Mtpa with
four blast furnaces and two BOF plants operating at the plant’s hot side.
India’s current accelerated economic growth accelerates the country’s steel
consumption: in the 2001–2012 period, India saw a growth of annual steel
consumption from 28.5 MT to 73.6 Mt for an average annual growth rate of 9.0%.
With the country’s per capita consumption at around 25% of the global average and
at around 12.5% of that of China, there is substantial growth potential for the near
future. SAIL decided on an expansion plan in 2006, with the objective to double the
company’s total capacity. Table 1 below presents key figures for this ambitious
expansion plan with respect to the integrated steel plants operated by SAIL.
Table 1. Expansion Plan for SAIL Integrated Plants (hot metal production figures in Mtpa)
Production After
Plant 2011–2012 Expansion
Bhilai 5.1 7.5 +47%
Durgapur 2.1 2.5 +19%
Rourkela 2.3 4.5 +96%
Bokaro 4.0 5.8 +45%
Burnpur 0.5 2.9 +480%
Total 14.0 23.2 +66%
RSP set out on an expansion program towards 4.5 Mtpa for the site. In addition, RSP
initialized modernization to reduce the environmental emissions of e.g. the coke
batteries and sinter plants. When the expansion program for RSP was started, the
upstream hot metal capacity was produced by four blast furnaces, three with an inner
volume of 995 m³ and one with an inner volume of 1448 m³. All of these are of a
1960s design of German origin. For the expansion, RSP decided upon a fifth,
greenfield blast furnace of substantially larger inner volume and in full accordance
with best available technology principles.
The new blast furnace was designed with a 4060 m³ inner volume for an average
production of 8000 thm/d. The pulverized coal injection system is rated for 150
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1061
ISSN 2176-3135
kg/thm with a design provision for 200 kg/thm. Hot blast is provided by three hot blast
stoves with internal combustion chambers operating at a 1425°C dome temperature.
The furnace has four tapholes, operated in two casthouses.
The furnace lining design is based on the “Hoogovens” high conductivity integrated
cooling and lining concept with copper cooling plates and graphite refractory. This
modern lining design minimizes sliding effects in the bosh and the equilibrium lining
profile enables the creation of a stable accretion, which protects against erosion. The
belly and lower stack include a combination of graphite and silicon carbide refractory
and machined copper plate coolers, which enables the creation of an accretion, but
also provides sufficient erosion resistance if the accretion may not be present. 25
year campaign lives can be achieved at high PCI and productivity levels and/or when
operating on lower or varying quality raw materials. Figure 1 illustrates the General
Arrangement of the furnace, Figure 2 the design of the bosh and belly.
The gas cleaning system is based on the Danieli Corus cyclone dustcatcher with a
single tangential inlet and an annular gap scrubber. The main advantage of this type
of dustcatcher as opposed to traditional, gravity–based dustcatchers is that the
characteristics are such that all of the zinc poor fraction of dust is separated here (i.e.
85%), leaving the smallest possible zinc contaminated fraction for the scrubber. With
gravity dustcatchers, 50% of the dust is separated, with the other 50% still made up
of zinc poor dust for about two–thirds; this introduces a far larger amount of dust that
cannot be recycled to the sinter plant and/or strongly increased additional cost for
processing.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1062
ISSN 2176-3135
Finally, the plant is equipped with a slag granulation system based on a dewatering
wheel, a Top Gas Recovery Turbine (TRT) and raw materials are belt–charged to the
bell–less top.
4 THE PROJECT
On October 2nd 2008 (M.K. Gandhi’s birthday), RSP signed a contract with a
consortium consisting of Danieli Corus and TPL for the lump–sum turn–key supply of
the new Blast Furnace No. 5. Danieli Corus was responsible for the engineering and
supply of technological items as well as erection supervision, operational assistance
and training. TPL was responsible for the engineering and supply of the balance of
the scope (e.g. civil) as well as erection. In projects of this magnitude, project
management is pivotal in coordinating all processes pertaining to areas such as but
not limited to engineering, procurement, inspection, logistics and erection. This
particular project was executed under conditions that called for specific measures.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1063
ISSN 2176-3135
Since the majority of the scope was with TPL, this party acted as Consortium Leader,
taking care of all communication with the Client on behalf of the Consortium.
Extensive document control systems were set up within all parties (TPL, Danieli
Corus, Mecon and RSP) as well as between them. Numbering systems were
established for engineering documents but also for email messages and letters.
Furthermore, much attention was paid to tracking of documents and issues to be
solved. This has proved to pay, since not a single document was missed and not one
single issue was left unfinished. Finally, the contractual planning was detailed into a
Level 4 Planning, in which the schedules of the Consortium members and their
subcontractors were merged. Monthly meetings were organized by RSP’s Project
Department, which kept tight control.
4.3 Logistics
A total of 950 containers and various break bulk transports with foreign supplies
landed at Kolkata, to be trucked to Rourkela. The haul from the Kolkata Dock System
(KDS) to RSP is around 350 miles and given the time consuming nature of road
travel in India, transport had to be scheduled meticulously, also with respect to the
site’s maximum ability to accept containered as well as oversized shipments at the
same time.
Foreign materials came from all continents. Canadian and Northern European
winters brought challenges given the risk of waterways and vessels freezing. At one
point, a ship had to be chartered from the warmer Mediterranean area to pick up
cargo in Antwerp, Belgium, since all ships in that area were suffering from frozen
cranes and decks.
Besides the above and the extensive exercise required for importing goods into India,
logistics ran relatively smoothly.
On site, two indoor storage facilities were made available specifically to Danieli Corus
for the dry storage of materials, the larger of which was designated for the storage of
refractories. In addition, RSP stored an amount of materials in other facilities within
the plant, some of which were areas in the open air.
For the pre–assembly of larger components, such as segments or rings of the blast
furnace and hot blast stove shells, lay–down areas were allocated within the final plot
plan of the blast furnace plant. With designated areas for each of the several pre–
assembly activities, scheduling and execution of these activities could be optimized.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1064
ISSN 2176-3135
4.4 Climate/Monsoon
Temperatures well over 100 degrees Fahrenheit in the May–July period and
monsoon rains in the July–September period added a level of complexity to the
project execution. Day–time work was shifted towards the early morning and late
afternoon. Lighting was set up to enable work in the darker, yet cooler hours. Work
on refractories inside the furnace shell and stoves was mostly carried out in cooler
seasons.
In the hot seasons, wind may at times make working outside impossible given the
risk of facial burns in case of prolonged exposure. Foundations and cable tunnels
needed to be finished before July, and ditches for water evacuation were excavated
every year before the start of the monsoon. Finally, blowing in a furnace during
monsoon requires special safety measures to avoid steam explosions, e.g. in the
slag pits and dry pits. These measures will be discussed further on in conjunction
with the furnace’s blow–in and ramp–up.
As indicated in the plot plan in Figure 7, the new furnace and its ancillary equipment
(in color) had to fit existing plants (in black). Space available was sufficient for the
entire blast furnace plant, albeit with adjustments to accommodate existing logistics
for the supply of coke and ferrous raw materials and tie–ins with routing for hot metal
transfer towards the steel plant and downstream slag processing. Whereas during
the early phases, the plot plan was sufficiently spacious to carry out several erection
activities (with or without requirement for lay–down area) simultaneously, the final
revised plot plan for the plant is clearly a precise and tight fit. However, none of the
logistical movements are hampered and the lay–out proved to be well–thought–out.
On August 6th of 2013, the new Blast Furnace No. 5 was blown in by a joint
commissioning team consisting of RSP operators and Danieli Corus specialists. The
furnace was filled with wood up to tuyere level and on top of that, a 1260 metric ton
coke blank was charged (1389 short tons). The remainder of the working volume
received a burden with an 800 kg/thm (1600 lbs/thm) coke rate. Around 29 hours
after the furnace was lit, the first cast was made through Taphole No. 1. During the
first hours, the coke rate was decreased relatively aggressively. As a consequence,
hot metal–slag separation started faster than planned. Also, the lower coke rates
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1065
ISSN 2176-3135
ensured that all hot metal tapped after the start of separation had a sufficiently low
silicon content to be used in the steel plant.
0
Figure 9. Hot metal silicon content (%) during first days after blow–in
Given the monsoon, there were large amounts of water in the blast furnace area,
especially in the slag pits. Major safety precautions had to be taken. This was largely
driven by SAIL management that wanted to make RSP No. 5 their flagship furnace.
This paid off, as no accidents happened.
During the ramp–up, the furnace appeared to be very forgiving, accepting e.g. many
low–blast periods with causes within and beyond the blast furnace complex. Danieli
Corus had provided extensive training for RSP operational, maintenance and
automation personnel, with good results; during the months after the blow–in,
assistance was hardly required. RSP operators took over the furnace and proceeded
forward.
After the blow–in and ramp–up periods, transition to normal operation was made
quite quickly. With these labor intensive periods and the need to have direct access
to the trough and runner systems belonging to the past, the several working areas
and platforms could be cleared and housekeeping straightened out. Both of the
casthouses set excellent examples, where the flush and flat design offers all of the
intended ergonomic advantages now that the area is cleared and operations have
normalized.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1066
ISSN 2176-3135
7 CONCLUSIONS
The RSP No. 5 project proves that plant capacity can be doubled within a few
years in a smooth way with dedication of the workforce and provided that plant
management is willing to demonstrate leadership. Especially under circumstances
such as those described, these steps can be taken sustainably by investing in
superior, best available technology as well as training of operational as well as
maintenance personnel.
Current technology allows for greenfield plants to be fitted into tight plot plans and
tied in to existing plant logistics without problems. However, technology
development may be beneficial for this process when equipment such as hot blast
systems and gas cleaning systems would become more compact rather than
allow for increasingly complicated connection and tie–ins.
The perspectives for the Indian economy are promising for the medium and
longer turn and more, similar projects can be expected where the lessons learned
will prove their value in design as well as construction. In many other developing
economies in the region, greenfield projects are expected on the slightly longer
term, mostly without the brownfield aspects of those in India.
* Technical contribution to the 44th Ironmaking and Raw Materials Seminar, 15rd Brazilian Symposium
on Iron Ore and 2nd Brazilian Symposium on Agglomeration of Iron Ore, September 15th to 18th,
2014, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
1067