Brihanu - Research Paper-Comments
Brihanu - Research Paper-Comments
Brihanu - Research Paper-Comments
The main source of income for the government is taxes, which are imposed on taxpayers based
on their ability to pay without any return benefits. To establish an effective and efficient tax
system, certain principles and regulations must be followed, such as taxpayers being taxed
according to their ability to pay and ensuring the time, manner, and quality of payment is certain.
The tax levying and collecting system should be economical for the government and simple to
understand and administer.
Ethiopia has undergone tariff and tax reforms since 1992/93, with outdated tax laws being the
main reason. Legislative, administrative, and judicial sources provide the basis for Ethiopian tax
laws, with the legislative sources being the most important. Traditional taxation systems have
continued to modern times, with personal income tax, business income tax, agricultural income
tax, land tax, education tax, health tax, road tax, salt tax, tobacco tax, the tithe, and alcohol tax
being the main elements of the tax system.
The initial tax review by the tax authority of the taxpayer's declaration and verification of the
declared tax liability and tax payable is known as tax assessment. Tax collection is done by a unit
whose primary function is to collect revenue and return it to the treasury unit for maintenance
and disbursement.
In the researcher study area there are some problems of tax collection for Instance In 2009 E.C
the proposed amount of tax was greater than the amount that actually collected and also some
problem related with awareness and willingness of tax payers. According to research done on
assessment of tax revenue collection effectiveness and it is accounting system in case of revenue
Kefale Yamret conducted a study on tax administration in Axum town in June 2015 and
identified several major problems (Yamret, 2015). Taxpayers commonly complained about
taxation, and there was a lack of efficient administration staff to ensure effective tax collection.
Additionally, tax collectors did not have good working conditions or incentives, and tax rules and
ethics were often violated. The tax revenue assessment in the town was found to be full of
subjective measurements, and committee members for tax assessment may not have had
sufficient knowledge about business activity (Yamret, 2015).
Similarly, Mizan Abeto conducted research on land use tax collection problems in June 2017 at
Arba Minch University (Abeto, 2017). The study identified several issues, including the
performance of the revenue authority office in relation to land use tax, the awareness of
taxpayers about land use tax, and land use tax assessment problems. However, Abeto's study did
not investigate the determinants of land use tax payments by taxpayers.
Therefore, the current study focuses on land use tax and how it impacts taxpayers with special
reference to the land use tax in Axum town. Based on data collected from the revenue authority
office, most respondents said that the assessment processes were well-designed, and a well-
designed assessment process is critical to increasing town revenue (Yamret, 2015). To achieve
this, the study recommends that all tax assessment committee members have adequate
knowledge to determine how much tax is paid by taxpayers, and that action be taken to correct
any errors in revenue collection even if the time limit for repair or amendment has passed
(Yamret, 2015).
In conclusion, tax administration in Axum town and land use tax collection problems are critical
issues that require careful attention. By addressing the problems identified in previous studies
and implementing the recommendations of the current study, the town can increase its revenue
and improve the welfare of its citizens.
There is a difference between the gap and my title based on the assessment of tax revenue
collection effectiveness and accounting systems. However, the gap assessment does not address
the problem of tax collection. Thus, I conducted research to identify the major problem in tax
collection in the case of Gulele Sub-City Administration. I presented some findings and
recommendations. Therefore, the purpose of this research was to assess the problems related to
the assessment and collection of category "C" taxes in Gulele Sub-City Administration by filling
out the following questionnaire.
1. How to tax payer can understand the rule and regulation of tax?
2. What are the cause for the inadequacy of tax assessment and collection?
3. How to compliance tax evasion and avoidance problem by the tax payer?
4. What are the problem and weaknesses in the side of government bodies (tax collectors)
or the system?
1. To assess whether taxpayers can understand the rules and regulations of taxation.
2. To check for the existence of tax avoidance and tax evasion.
3. To evaluate the knowledge and awareness of taxpayers about taxation.
4. To identify problems and weaknesses on the side of government bodies, particularly tax
collection systems.
1.4. Significance of Study
The significance of the study was to give a clue to the office how to improve its tax assessment
and collecting and the amount of tax revenue collected. It was also provide some points on how
to improve tax payer’s participation toward tax.
1. To provide a positive contribution in finding a solution to the focused area.
2. To develop the researcher's experience in conducting future research.
3. To provide information to employees of the office regarding tax and collection-related
problems in the area.
4. To raise awareness among the revenue authority and take corrective action for the
identified problems.
5. To raise awareness among taxpayers and encourage compliance.
6. To assist the researcher in partial fulfillment of a seminar course in accounting.
7. To identify tax and collection-related problems
It will be used as abases for another researcher who want to make further study on the area.
2.1Overview
The researcher was using descriptive method of data analisis .For this purpose of
the study tabulation, percentage and proportion data presentation tools will be
used. Do to time and other resource constraint,the the researcher take sample from
the population by simple random and systematic sampling methods.The data was
collected through by using primary and secondary, primary data was obtain
through questionnaires and interview. Whereas secondary data are obtained from
website and manual report of the city administration. The detail is presented as the
following.
n= sample size
Z2 = from table of using confidence level
P = probability to be selected
q = probability not to be selected
N= Total population of category “C” tax payers in Dire dawa city Administration = (tax
officers’ stratum(N1) +tax payers’ stratum(N2))
e = error of confidence level
For tax payers
n=(1.64)2 ×0.5×0.5×27864
(0.1)2×(27864-1) + (1.64)2 × 0.5×0.5
n= 8741.2 = 67
130.22
And for tax officers which was stratified in to 5 departments
3.1 Overview
Taxation is revenue of the goverment which is collected from the public to finance government
service and activities. When we talk about tax we talk about it's
structure,purpose,form ,type ,category of tax payer ,tax adiministration ,merit and demerit of
tax.The the content is briefly explained below.
A progressive tax structure is one where the tax rate increases as the taxpayer's income increases.
A proportional tax structure, on the other hand, applies a constant tax rate regardless of the
taxpayer's income level. In contrast, a regressive tax structure imposes a higher tax burden on
lower-income earners compared to those with higher incomes. Lastly, a digressive tax structure is
one where the tax rate decreases as the taxpayer's income increases up to a certain level, after
which it becomes progressive.
It is essential to note that the choice of tax structure depends on various factors, including the
government's fiscal policies, economic conditions, and social objectives. The aim is to strike a
balance between fairness and efficiency in the tax system ( OECD, 2019; IMF, 2020)
2.4 Main types of tax structures
1. Progressive taxes are based on the idea that people with higher incomes should pay a higher
percentage of their income in taxes. In other words, the tax rate increases as income increases.
This type of tax structure is often used in countries with social welfare programs that aim to
reduce income inequality.
2. Regressive taxes, on the other hand, take a larger percentage of income from people with
lower incomes than from those with higher incomes. This means that the tax rate decreases as
income increases. This type of tax structure is often criticized for being unfair to low-income
earners and contributing to income inequality.
3. Proportional taxes, also known as flat taxes, are based on the principle that everyone should
pay the same percentage of their income in taxes. This means that the tax rate remains the same,
regardless of income. Proportional taxes are often used in countries with simpler tax systems and
lower levels of government spending.
It is important to note that each type of tax structure has its advantages and disadvantages, and
different countries may choose to implement different tax structures based on their unique
economic, social, and political contextsDigressive tax structure
According to Gebrie Worku (2006), this tax structure represents an alternative form of
progressive tax structure, characterized by a gradual decrease in the progressive tax rates as
income increases (p. 35).
2.4 Effective of taxation
Economists have devoted considerable export to studying the effects of taxes. In particular, they
study how taxes affect people’s behavior, including their choosing in working, saving and
investing.
To understand the effect of any tax, one must determine who bears the burden of the tax. The
way a tax affects people is called the tax incidences the statuary incidences of tax refer to the
individual group who must legal pay in contrast, the economics of a tax refers to its actually
effect s on people incomes. The economics incidences of a tax depends on how buyer and seller
of the commodity when the tax is imposed. It have also been used to reducing the inequality of
income and wealthy.
2.4 The effect on ability to work, save and invest
Put appropriate references to the Paragraph "Taxation refer the money income from the
public to the government and their by reducing their purchasing power. The reduction in
purchasing power reduces their ability to obtain necessity luxuries of life.
Thus, the levies of tax on peoples reduce their competitions of necessities and comforts,
which lower the standard of living, when the standard of living is affected. This effect is
strongly felt by the poor people. However, the efficiency and ability of rich people is not so
much affected by taxation.
2.4.2 Effects of taxation on willingness to work, save and invest
Taxation affects the design of the people to work, saving invest. If the willingness of the
people to work, save and invest is affected by taxation, the production will automatically be
affected. It is universal recognized that direct taxes have more adverse effects all the
willingness of the people to work, save and invest.
It is all the ground psychology reaction of the people. That is when the higher progressive
of taxation is levied, the government takes the major of protection of the additionally
income book. This many create a trends in the mind of the people not to take risk to work,
hard to earn a manager income.
However, fair and justices tax system may not have any such bad effective on the
willingness to the work save and invest.
2.4.3 Effects of taxation on the divers of economic resources
Will the value of production of the encounter depend up on ability and willingness to a
work, save and invest, the patterns of production depends up on the allocation of economic
resources amount the industry and region and consumes. If the product certain industry
are taxed, their prices would rise and therefore, the demands for their product would
reduce and there bathe profits also Is reduced, this may result in the diversion of resources
from this industries to some other industries whose product is subjected to no tax or low
rate.
If there is original imbalance with in the country, government can uses taxation to remove
such imbalance by tax examination and tax concession to investors who made investment in
under developed regions. The diversion may be beneficial diversion or harmful diversion.
Taxation on the commodities that has injuries to the health like cigarettes and liquid may
discourage their consumption, which in turn affects their production. The factors of
production engaged in these industries may be diverted some other industries. This is
“beneficial diversion”. The taxation on the goods of common consumption will increase
their price.
Hence may be diverted to the production of some other commodities which may be in the
nature of luxury or harmful to healthy, it is known as “harmful diversion
2. Old and loose tax legislation due to changes in economic structure and fiscal federalism.
3. Lack of comprehensiveness and strong enforcement power.
4. Weak administration, such as the lack of a modern operational system and inefficient
services.
5. Openness to unfair dealing with taxpayers.
The tax reforms have involved the following measures:
References
Musgrave, R. A., & Musgrave, P. B. (1989). Public finance in theory and practice. New
York: McGraw-Hill.
Bird, R. M. (2008). Taxation and development: Lessons from Colombian experience. In
Taxation and development: Lessons from Colombian experience (pp. 1-14). Inter-
American Development Bank.
Tanzi, V. (1995). Fiscal federalism and decentralization: A review of some efficiency and
macroeconomic aspects. Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics
1994, 335-359.
Slemrod, J., & Gillis, M. (2019). Tax systems. In Handbook of Public Economics (Vol. 5,
pp. 1-146). North-Holland