Influence of Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan in The English-Speaking Proficiency of College Students
Influence of Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan in The English-Speaking Proficiency of College Students
Influence of Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan in The English-Speaking Proficiency of College Students
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Abstract:- This study was conducted to determine the ingredient of a successful individual, an important tool widely
dialectal influence of Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan in use all over the world. To actually broaden once world, open
the speaking proficiency of the college students. This study oneself to great job opportunities and connect with diverse
gives information on the English proficiency level of people of different nationalities, English proficiency is a must.
college students in Cawayan and Balud and how their
pronunciation is influenced by Hiligaynon and Cebuano- Filipinos are non-native speakers of English; they are a
Visayan language and the proposed activity to enhance the multilingual race that consider English language as their
English-speaking proficiency. The respondents were the second language. Filipino language is consist of several
college students of Balud Municipal College and dialects being spoken in the different regions of the country
DEBESMSCAT- Cawayan Campus. Quantitative research and the combination of the vernacular and international
method and random sampling were employed, simple language become habitual among them. This combination of
frequency count and percentage were used. Fifty-two point any dialect and international language in communication
six percent of the college students who are speakers of results to what is called code switching and the sounds of the
Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan are proficient in terms vernacular sometimes influence the utterance of English
of pronunciation based on the written pronunciation test language which results to unusual or different pronunciations
and 43.3% are highly proficient in terms of pronunciation of English words. The combination of English and dialect is a
based on the oral reading exercise. The sound [ou] and [θ] common phenomenon among Filipinos. In Jacoby’s
are the most mispronounced sound based on the written Psycholinguistic theory, this combination of language should
and oral pronunciation test. The 2-Hour Pro-Fun Drill is not be encouraged in the second language classroom because
proposed to address the mispronunciation of the least it can heighten the use of non-target forms producing deviant
mastered sounds and to enhance the English-speaking linguistic patterns. This production of deviant linguistic
proficiency of the college students. patterns among nonnative speakers increases the need to be
proficient in the use of English. Today, educators are faced
Implementation of a school policy that will require with the challenge of addressing the needs of the growing
students to use English in speaking is recommended, make number of students whose primary language is not English
the school an English-speaking zone. Also, teachers who (Gibbons, 2003 as cited by Vizconde (2006). There is the
are handling subjects with English as medium of necessity for the learners to gain proficiency in English while
instruction may strictly observe the use of English mastering other skills and content in other subject areas,
language. Give students opportunities to speak and Vizconde( 2006).
provide activities that will enhance their English-speaking
skills which include pronunciation. Language proficiency is one of the country’s strengths
that helped in the increase of the economy and made the
Keywords:- Cebuano-Visayan, Hiligaynon, Pronunciation, Philippines the top destination, surpassing India in 2012.
Speaking Proficiency According to Andrew King, country director of IDP Education
Pty. Ltd. Philippines, Malaysians had an average overall score
I. INTRODUCTION of 6.71, leading among countries in Asia in overall English
proficiency. Philippines was second to Malaysia with 6.69;
According to Murray Goldenberg a retired EAL third was Indonesia with 5.99; fourth was India with 5.79; and
Instructor and IIELTS/IDP Examiner, as cited by Baeta, Thailand fifth with 5.71. Also, foreign learners are encouraged
Galvan, Solomo, Zamudio, Haber & Osea (2012), proficiency to study English in the country because aside from the reason
in English is usually defined by a combination of skills: that education is affordable it has also quality programs
reading, writing, listening and speaking. These are the skills a offered in English as Second Language.
person should be competent of to be able to deal with the
demand of the society, the demand of internalization. English However, it was acknowledged in the roundtable
happened to be the language of global communication. discussion organized by the British council, key stakeholders
Globalization made English language a very important from the government, academe, private, and non-government
Table 1a Distribution of Students’ Level of English-Speaking Proficiency in terms of Pronunciation based on Written Pronunciation
Test
Level of English-Speaking
Range of Scores Proficiency Balud Municipal College DEBESMSCAT Overall
Cawayan Campus
f % f % f %
9-10 Exemplary 0 0 1 1.9 1 1.1
7-8 Highly Proficient 7 16.3 9 17.3 16 16.8
5-6 Proficient 24 55.8 26 50 50 52.6
3-4 Less Proficient 8 18.6 16 30.8 24 25.3
0-2 Not Proficient 4 9.3 0 0 4 4.2
Total 43 100 52 100 95 100
The table reveals that 52.6% which means majority of students are from BMC and 9.5% are from DCC. 4.2% belong
the students, gained the proficient level based on the written to the not proficient level, these students are from BMC. Only
pronunciation test with scores ranging from five to six; 25.3% 1.1% got the exemplary level, this student is from DCC.
of these students are from Balud Municipal College and 27.4%
are from DEBESMSCAT- Cawayan Campus. Meanwhile, Table 1b presents the least mastered sound during the
25.3% obtained the less proficient level, 8.4% of these written pronunciation test. Showing the data of the college
students are from BMC and 16.8% are from DCC. 16.8% students from both schools separately and the overall data.
students attained the highly proficient level, 7.4% of these
The table indicates that the most mistaken sound is the [ou] in the word “road” and the sound [u:] in the word “food”. The
students pronounced the word “road” same with the pronunciation of the word “broad”- which sound [ͻ]. The word “food” is
pronounced the same way as “good”-which sounds [u]. It seems that they also based on the spelling of the words because they
pronounced it the same way if the two different words have the same vowels
Table 2a presents the English-speaking proficiency of the college students based on the oral reading exercise. Showing the data
of the college students from both schools separately and the overall data.
Table 2a Distribution of Students’ Level of English-Speaking Proficiency in terms of Pronunciation based on Oral Reading
Exercise
Level of English-Speaking
Range of Scores Proficiency Balud Municipal College DEBESMSCAT Overall
Cawayan Campus
f % f % f %
25-30 Exemplary 11 28.9 10 19.2 21 23.3
19-24 Highly Proficient 12 31.6 27 52 39 43.3
13-18 Proficient 7 18.4 13 25 20 22.2
7-12 Less Proficient 8 21.1 1 1.9 9 10
0-6 Not Proficient 0 0 1 1.9 1 1.2
Total 38 100 52 100 90 100
It can be deduced from the table that majority of the students (43.3%) gained the highly proficient level in the oral reading with
scores ranging from nineteen to twenty-four. 13.3 of these students are from Balud Municipal College and 30% are from
DEBESMSCAT- Cawayan Campus. Meanwhile, 23.3% (12.2% from BMC and 11.1% from DCC) obtained the exemplary level,
22.2% (7.8% from BMC and 14.4% from DCC) attained the average level of proficiency, 10% (8.9% from BMC and 1.1% from
DCC) gained the less proficient level and 1.1% (from DCC belong) to the not proficient level.
Table 2b presents the least mastered sound during the oral reading exercise. Showing the data of the college students from both
schools separately and the overall data of these college students.
Vowel and Consonant Balud Municipal College DEBESMSCAT- Cawayan Campus Overall
Sounds
f % f % f %
[æ] 21 55.3 21 40.4 42 46.7
[e] 13 34.2 17 32.7 30 33.3
[i:] 10 26.3 25 48.1 35 38.9
[i] 1 2.6 4 7.7 5 5.5
Table 2b shows the errors made during the oral reading road into ‘rud’ and man (m[æ]n) into m[a]n. Wordsworth
exercise. For the college students of Balud, [æ] in the word (2019) stated that errors made in pronunciation are due to the
‘man’ have the highest number of error (55.3%) in the vowel difference in the sound system and the word symbols between
sounds and [θ] in the word ‘think’ have the highest number of the mother tongue and English.
error (52.6%) in the consonants sounds. For the lowest number
of errors, vowels sound [i] in the word ‘kick’ have 5.5% and The least mastered sound based on the written
consonant sound [f] in the word ‘first’ have 4.4%. pronunciation test are the [ou] in the word “road” and the
sound [u:] in the word “food”, while in the oral reading
For the college students of Cawayan, vowel sound [ou] exercise, the least mastered sounds are [æ] in the word ‘man’
in the word ‘road’ have the highest number of errors which is and [θ] in the word ‘think’.
57.7% and consonant sound [θ] in the word ‘think’ have the
highest number of errors which is 44.2%. For the lowest Boonkit (2009) in his study entitled Enhancing the
number of errors, [i] in the word ‘kick’ for vowels sounds and Development of Speaking Skills for Non-native Speakers of
[f] in the word ‘first’ for consonant sounds are least English found out the strengths and weaknesses of speaking
mispronounced. performance of non-native speakers, weaknesses were found
in pronunciation and grammatical structure but the errors
In the overall, the voiceless /th/ or [θ] is the most found in pronunciation are in word stress and not in vowel and
mispronounced consonant sound and [ou] and [æ] are the most consonant sounds. This shows why majority of the college
mispronounced vowel sounds. Meanwhile, [i] and [f] are the students are highly proficient when it comes to pronunciation
least mispronounced. of the consonant and vowel sounds. One of the theoretical
perspectives in language acquisition which is the socialization
The results indicate that 52.6% of the college students theory is link in this. This theory views that language
are proficient in terms of pronunciation based on the written development is facilitated by corrective feedbacks and this
pronunciation test, 25.3% of them are less proficient, 16.8 are corrective feedback includes correction in pronunciation. It
highly proficient, 4.2% are not proficient and there is 1.1% emphasizes that an individual expands his vocabulary through
who is exemplary. Meanwhile, based on the oral reading hearing others speak. This means that if an individual is
exercise, only 43.3% of the college students are highly exposed to the correct use of the language, he or she will
proficient in English speaking in terms of pronunciation. acquire the same correctness. Another theory that will give
23.3% of them are exemplary, 22.2% are proficient, the 10% light to the result is the skill theory which emphasizes the
belong to less proficient and there is 1.2% that is not importance of cognitive learning and practice and the theory
proficient. of communicative competence by Hymes (1972) discussed in
the theoretical framework. These imply that college students
The least mastered sound based on the written from Balud and Cawayan are in the environment of school
pronunciation test are the [ou] in the word “road” and the where in the use of English language occurs which they can
sound [u:] in the word “food”, while in the oral reading hear and learn from it, they are surrounded by people who give
exercise, the least mastered sounds are [æ] in the word ‘man’ corrective feedback about the use of the language including
and [θ] in the word ‘think’. pronunciation. These people include teachers, administrators,
staff and other students. According to these college students,
The influence of Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan is they use English language during recitations, when answering
evident in the pronunciation of some students who are native the teachers’ questions, and during reporting. These are
speakers of the said languages. The sound of the voiceless /th/ opportunities to not just learn the language but also used it.
or [θ] in the word ‘think’ does not exist in both languages, the These exposure to English language helped these college
students are not used or exposed in this sound that is why they students in their English-speaking proficiency in terms of
pronounce it with /t/, like ‘tink’ for think and ‘tot’ for thought. pronunciation. This further implies that the students’
The vowel sounds [ou] and [æ] are also not common in both pronunciation of the vowel and consonant sounds is not
Hiligaynon and Cebuano-Visayan language, the vowel sounds influenced by their mother tongue because of their exposure to
of the said languages are more on short ‘u’ in the word book the use of it. Thus, the students still have to be more exposed
and [a] in the word rat. That is why they pronounced ’the word to the use of English language in oral exercises to maintain the