= INHAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AHMEDABAD TIMA/TSOL2
MILAAP - Crowdfunding for All: Helping Patients by
Facilitating Philanthropy
Je was an unusually cold moming in Bengaturs in November 2019. Anoj Viswanathan, ti
cofounder of Milaap, walked briskly and rubbed brs palme to generate warmth a5 he proceeded
tewards the elevatur tu atknd the annual strategy mecting As he waited for the elevator. be
reflected on the journey of Milaap, which had emerged as 4 major crowdfunding platform far
‘Oredical treatments. Milsapolfered two ype Fuca pee a a
do-it-yourself (D4V). Aa the nena echoed, eg eae support to the
patients/ relatives in designing and disseminating relevant information in the supported
campaigns, DIY campaigns, an the ather hand, were completely driven by the patients/ families
themselves. with Milaap's role restricted to offering the jplatiorm and assurance ta donors
through beneficiaries and need verification As Milaap became increasingly popular,
‘Viswanathan contemplated the challenges of achieving. balance between doing goed and doing
well. Though incorporates as a private limited company, Milaap was conceptualised as a social
enterprise, where social pursuit was as important, if nat more so, as financial profitability.
‘Today's meeting, was crucial for the future of the company as the top management was going: to
discuss a key issue. ‘Which type ef sereace should be priors”.
The company had lo chem one of the business processes cut of the tere mentioned above (Le,
supported campaigns of DIY) and concentrate sts effort andl use its limited resources to scake both
profitably and sustainably in the Furure
‘Health expenditure as 4 cause af poverty.
Expersive medical ueadentals are one of the biggest reasons for personal bankruptcies. It is
‘estimated that shout &(7E af the population are pushed to poverty because of expenses related to
medical treatments According to estimates, about 3 milion citizens in india were forced into,
poverty in 2011-12 due to medical expenses’. The number is estimated to have grown tn 55.
anullion annually by 2019. ln a country where health inswrance penetration is extremely low’, the
[papubetion depends on out-of-pocket (OOP) expenses to meet healthcare expenses.
ere only sioeS07 cla ees ea
‘none Swe ee
10.1186 /benjopen- 2017-01800,Dos
___TMaA/taniaa
pationts
that the conti
d op bearing nearly 70% of health expenses*. This is despite the fact
Gower eee oie governments have provided Pea to how.
Income isnujs through various wellare selemes such as Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana
(RSBY)! from the central gowernment
RSDY, which was initiated iin 2008, was criticised for inadequate coverage of various procedures
Gra restrictions om total benefits, As a refult, the central government replaced RSBY with the
tscheme in 2018, uncler which there was a provision of a broad health assurance
bof called Pradhan Mantri Jan Acogya Yojana or PM.JAY. PMJAY was launched
rembwi 2. 2018, by Ue Hon'ble Prime Minister of India, Shri Narendra Modi. It aime tor
*verage of INK 500,000 (LISD 6,667 8) per family per year for secondary and.
on Se
re hospi
and provides fo:
7 8 the scheme te all the needy households’. Further, as the package costs
of each procedure were kept toa minimum, some private hospitals still charged the patients who
ay the remaining amount as COP expendi i
Sovering health expencliture, several gaps remain to be addressed. This is especially critical as the
‘costs of diagnosis and treatment is burgeoning across the world, Furthermore, a majority of the
lowermiddle-class population who
are also vulnerable to catastrophic health expenditure
remains uncovered under PMJAY?,
have to p
Crowdfunding for medical expenditure
—uWwW0@i_
» Rao, N. @O18, April 14), ‘Who ls Paying for India's Healthcase? The Wire. Wepfewire. alot paying fr
inudias-healtheare
‘ Bima Yojana (n.d). Howe Jt Works, toad wwe rsby gov infhow works heen,
eae eerie c
« eaten (nud). About Pradhan Manin Jan Avrogya Yojana (PM-JAY),
itp / panjay.gov.in/abaut/ pony F
’ ys aaa 2) Fe dea Bharat Cards, Foe ica oe Sees uP.
-thewire inf health/ ay ushman-bhatat-uttar-pradesl -prnjay-mabeba,
rong BON July, ieee Bharat, Poor Patents Are Not Going Cashiteas but With Leu Cesh, The Wire,
ttpsif / science thewire in/ health al-prjay-scheme-Lealth-insurunce-packages-cashh
Kumar, R. (2019, September 23). Nol covered under Ayushina: Bharnt-PAIJAY? Fou midlie class can ape to bemefit too ~
Explained, Finacial Expsesa, hitya/fwvrvfinancaler press com Westyls/ealh fovectoenn thartectore:
‘benalits-for-poor-midde-class-how-ab-pavjay-beneeits-peaple-rt-covexed/ iriaasoysemi TIMA/1S0142
Crowdfunding platforms are becoming popular as they overcome distance related « hallenges.
There are three fundamental properties of crowdfunding that help in reducing market frictions
as. enumerated below.
+ Easier search; an online application allows the funders tosearch with ease and participate
in the project of their choice
* Less need for monitoring: as the channel allows small contributions and broad
Participation, the downside risk and need for monitoring reduces
* Information on what other funders have done: the toot provides the appartunity for
‘everyone to see what others have done and comununicate with each other®, These
properties make crowdfunding an attractive channel for funding and fundraising.
These platforms allow individuals to raise funds for their causes by charging a nominal fee for
the service offered. They act as a trusted, intermediary for people to donate and make sure they
reach the right/worthy cause. For instance, Milaap, a decade old -socia! enterprise has now
berome a pioncer in developing person to person giving in India,
Milaap™
Milaap is an online crowdfunding platform that enables anyone across India tu raise funds for
healthcare, education, sports, disaster relief and other personal causes with great ease.
Founded in 2010 by a team of young and passionate entrepreneurs, Milaap has pioneered the
development of person to person giving in India™, Anoj Viswanathan, cofounder and president
Milaap, who studied engineering at National University of Singapore, and Mayukh Choudhury,
cofounder and CED, a Blech from [I T-Madras, met while working at a social enterprise selling
solar lanterns in villages®, Milaap started operations at a ime when the internet was beginning,
to change the way Indians shopped and travelled, The cofeunders wanted to see how that could
be extended to lending and donating. "So, we showcased rural projects online, to connect therm
to individuals across the world who could give microloans,” Viswanathan says. Thus, Milaap-
began its journey as a platform that allows people to donate to Indian NGOs selected after due
diligence. E
Requests to expand the scope of Milaap beyond microloans first came during the Uttarakhand
floods of 2013 when regular donors asked if the platform could be used for flood relief. What
nudged the founders to pivot and focus an crowdfunding medical care was "Abhishek’s case", as
they have come to call it. In 2015, a group of friends wanted to raise money for their friend's heart
transplant quickly. “Here was a situation where the family was not poor, and the friends were
tech-savvy. Within a week, they raised Rs 30lakh via Milaap- It made us re-examine fundraising,"
says Choudhury, 37. They wondered if the platform could be helpful in similar cases. The data
they dug up on healthcare enhanced their resolve to double down Onemergency medical care.
9 Agrawal, A, Catalini, C., & Goldfarb, A. (2015). Crowd humdi ‘Geogiaphy, social nerworks, timing:
Serer decison fowl of Ecos & Manager Stage ET ee cece
® batps://onilaapoeg/ :
https: /{milaapocg/ about-us/overview
© hhitps:/ /ecanomictimes indiatimes.com industry /hesltheare/biokeck/healthcare/how- us E
row dfurvling-todel-to-raise-money for mofical-care/atticeshow/ M@207G3aarafromends TsTIMA/tso145
wer eneurs became widely util
1 proj d micro-entreprencurs B a ie
f rural projects an ehensive social network for
pea tite Fash aaah Brae N Te oes causes, funding
ti i nd " sat for va : :
€ died vend Though the platform allowed for ee daa Renner ineels aon
medical needs, ' Wii
ificant aspect over en
for medical expenses emerged a5 a cement ae pre recreated then critica
becoming the gato platform for funding
e c ait ions i
i donations for medicai
‘urrently, 80% of the funds raised are related to
Mergencies, ently, fF
dof —_—_—___
emergencies \¢
‘culty in discovering the right
Milaap addressed the many challenges of giving (such as ain cee Pan p's open-
causes, trust deficit, and averall donor apathy), Sitting in a pee aes xaica giving
Plan office in Bengalumu's JP Nagar, Viswanathan, 32, emphasised, "Gur gt Recta
a9 everyclay behaviour ane Jacilitate the pracess using technology. We wan ee leeigehtedd
anywhere can raise money for their medical expenditure anytime, and no ene sho
treatment for lack of funds,"
: ee aap bling
The smartphone revolution sped up Mila: Serowth, with the number of Milaap users dau!
yeaz-on. me from 2018 to DOE, The aie penetration of mobile phones ‘has also increased
the reach of the platform to tier 2cities and tormuacross India. Over 45% of campaigns on Milaap
come from autside the seven biggest cities, and a similar Proportion of payments are made
through mobile phones. Some danations are os small as INR 5 or INR 10, Asa result, Milaap
Fapidly grew both in popularity and size — ty 2000, Milaap employed more than 80 people. As
‘of March 2021, the Platform had raised awarly INR 120 billion to Support around 290,000 causes,
acting millions of lives across the country.
The impact of Milaap was substantial as several Patients benefited from the crowdlunding
Process that allowed them ta access costly treatment in private hospitals. The success stories also
highlighted the combined pawer of offline and online. An example case was Mohammad Vasees,
who ran a digital printing shap in Vellare. He hac Put Up posters in the shop about his infant
Gaughter’s liver ailment and a payment gateway for donations that Milaap had set up. He says
donations went directly to hospitals, Increasing the credibility af medical campaigns. Over the
years, Milaap earned credibility prompting the donors tn return repeatedly to engage in
Philanthropy, Mayank Jain, far example, a 40-year-old businessman from Gurgaon, retums to
Milaap every few «lays to donate on behalf of his mother, Usha Jain, "E could see that the ruses
the eerfied. Medical reports af the patient wert also available, A\ times, [have also spaken to
the doctors involved’, says Jain, who Conates between INR 2.000 and INR 7,000, depending on
the urgency of the cause.
Milaap hes been appreciated for ite Plilanthropic work in several reports, It was one of the
finalists for Economic Times' Social Entrepreneurship Award - 2016". It hav also reveived
——————
fe dllaap tr). Chereseen. tps? /ilaan. ong foverview
ET Buea re ge feo ee UTS Fw mS aig eps ating cifras
Boonomie Times. hifps:// indiatimes: mh vaaage t/Sartups/ebatartep-avvacde2016-how-agunlar
while making-a-difference/articleshow/£389ur47 st meMMA /IS014>
Es
appreciation for being instrumental in saving lives 1, [ts support during
appreciated as India's Selfless heroes!”, i
pandemic was also
Business Model of Milaap
scial goad usually depend upon donor funding. Some
ustainability while attempting to achieve social goals. Such
tions ar socia esterprises, attempt to balance financial
bitity with the averarching organisational mission. This dual purpose of doing, good
doing well is critical for n organisations, As most founders administrators of non-
profits lack the proper training or background pertaining to managing organisations and
financial acumen, the ‘often an imbalance in retaining, steady funds while upholding, the
mission of the organisation"*. However, the founding team in Milaap had the expertise in bath
technical as well as managerial competencies, Therelare, thaugh Milaap was.a social veriture, the
founders designed the offerings so as to onsure financial sustainability af the organisation.
hat attempt to. ack
1s pursue inane
cations, called hybrid organi
Two different types of campaigns
Milaap provides two types of campaigns: Do-it-Yourself (DIY) and Supported Campaigns (SC).
DIY: In this model, the fundraiser manages the entire campaign. The fundraiser needs to write
the story of the campaign, promotes it and raises funds. This information is shared with donors.
on the Milaap platfarm and within the person s internal network, People wha wish to donate can
and above. At the end af the carmpaign, 5% of the total collection
donate in any range from INR 5 :
of the donor is deducted as a service fee by Milaap and the rest ts transferred to the fundraisers’
bank account
SC: Realising that most users need assistance to reach out to a larger audience, network and
professional help ta write and upload convincing and poignant stories and pictures, Milaap
launched its Supported Campaigns Product. The fundraiser gets professional help from story
writers and photographers to build a donation profile in this product, The team visits the patient
and fundraiser and provides adequate sapport to build convincing material for crowdfunding.
The typical flow of these campaigns is depicted in the following flowchart. Milaap is directly
involved in the supported campaigns. Milaap assists the client opting for the supported
campaigns to design and set up the campaign. In retum, Milaap charges 15% service fee for
assisting in the campaign.
© The New Indian Express (2029, Navember 28), Crowfiecting plaiform saves yume life.
itps,/ fy newindiamexpress.com jcilies/kochi/ AM /nov /28/ermwdfundiny,-platkorm-saves-yourg-life-
(2228931 btm)
1 Discovery Chanmel India (2020, November 4). iihurat Ke Mahuceer | incha's Selfiec: Marces, YouTube.
‘watch?y=bYS
Bake H'M, Qt), The omelet she of ony onions
-hipa,/ fooreacake/downlead, pdf) 7284124 pall aTbof —_——<$_———
‘The process occurs 08 follows:
an initial sereening of bath types of campaigners, They
am undertakes.an initial screening ol puma:
» The onboarding te them through the process of setting up
connect with the respective campaigners to guide
a campaign. ‘ a
«Inthe case of SC, one team member visits the hospital to ve rify the identity, diagn
1 facts, This typically costs around INR 3000/- per visit per campaign.
pported campaigns.
scertain the options for
and med
= Milaap also assigns a dedicated relationship manager (RM) for th
* The RM coordinates with the hospital and the doctor in charge to
treatment available, costs of the procedure, the prognasis and other related information.
The RM touch with the campaigner, social media team, hospital and doctor
throughout the campaign and also consults with the respective stakeholder to make the
campaign successful.
+ While the RM takes care of the coordination work, the creative work required for SC is
autsourced, Each SC entails a detailed assessment of the patient's socio-economic and
health status, and a story is built up to kindle the philanthropic side of the donors.
rele and video footage are supplemented to make the story authentic and
appealing to the donors. The outscurcin| é
ee 8 agency charges about INR 30,000/- per
+ The media relations team then circulates the o forms
4 tories on appropriate social media platf
passer fortes ‘These social media campaigns are supported iar ataea
penditure to enhance the visibility of the i relevant audiences, Details
these expenditure overheads are provided in kB nt .
The CEO also shared thal the sx
pported ca w
predetermined goal amount than DIY arpa eee ene pea ae
smount is reached, the money is still given to the campaign organisers to meet mele eee
One of the issues in raising money for medical treatments is fake or Spurious waigns
the fundraiser participates for personal financial gain. While itis Pole ke gave a sa
without an illness, to start a campaign in the DIy mode, the same is impossible in the rah
career The supported campaign involves aclose connection with the patient and the hospital,
such ag a visit to the hospital, talking to the patients and the concerned doctors, examinit sand
sharing clinical documents etc., which minimizes the chances of fraud, However, Feagh
theoretically posstble, frauds in DIY campaigns are also rare. According to. Viswanathan
terestingly, the crowd itself screens out fraudulent campaigns. As the fundraising: process
reaches near and lear ones and the broader social circle, some of them will identify that the
campaign is fraud, anc we come to know. I would say, the fraud campaigns would be less than
9.005 % in DIY alsa. And they are not possible in the supported campaigns.”‘BI Gamalgrs,
Fundraiser Creates 3 |
Corpaign, |
Mexia fies
1 _AlmageesVideos)
ae i —
| ‘Share it wity his, |
EE |
hetworle
wach the goal or
auomatically costa
He can clas the
| SEs
atthe end dsio |
ted the committee room, he reali
sources had evolved it type of campaign over the
‘Other. That would be the major agenda for discussion today — whether to nriorit:
campaign aver another and, iy wondered
mene IIMA/ Ispige
Sumnonms Conmaions
Fundraisos Creates 9 |
Campaign
Seay
Mong Chects tha
Eholbiity of The
‘Samp=I9N for Support h
Ho Vos: yg
Ma
Writes a Slory with)
tora flex
Easloce}
‘nap Shame
the car pangr a
Seaton on
suet red
rumetoi
‘He cin close the |
‘Seryraign ence bn
each the goal ort
Iydoses |
ste end daex
TMa/isouz
Exhibit
Exhibit 1 A: Number of Subscriptions
Mii
Do. Yourself
Supaarted Campsic7s |
Toi 12,008 | 17,166 | 24,547
Exhibit 1 G: Total numbor of successful campaigns
= | 207
| ¢5a0776| ease |
© 18.20,438
| 20.22.500 |
| Gust af Retationship Manage
‘On boarding team cost par campaign (Ver fication and Appr 9,000 (fF St) and Soo
Cunscurced- Fie cost for phelography and viry witng
20,000
Network and Socal Vedia Promntions