E Recruitment and Its Impact On Human Re
E Recruitment and Its Impact On Human Re
E Recruitment and Its Impact On Human Re
1. Introduction
Recruitment is a roller coaster, becoming more thrilling with advancement in
technology and innovations. It started with the word of mouth and now is just a
click far away. Recruitment involves practice and activities by companies with
main purpose of identifying and attracting the prospective potential employees. It
is a crucial segment of human resource management as it delivers the critical
function of drawing human assets in organization (Baber, 1998). Recruitment is
an essential tool to hire candidates in organizations. The mediums for recruitment
have been drastically changed over the past years. During industrial revolution, a
simple sign on factory front was prime recruitment media. Newspapers ruled as a
recruitment source from 1950’s – 1980’s by sourcing candidates over newspaper
advertisements. In 1980’s the recruitment consultants used telephone, local as
well as national newspapers and specialist job seekers to hire candidates. In
1990’s the World Wide Web was introduced. It revolutionized the recruitment
methods, sources and tools. Technology affected the entire recruitment process
and recruitment market modifying traditional recruitment to Electronic
recruitment or E-recruitment. Organizations changed their recruiting medium
from publishing job requirement in newspapers or magazines to posting job
descriptions and vacancies online. Since then online recruitment has grown
rapidly and is used widely by recruiters and job aspirants throughout the world
(Cobra and Brown, 2006). According to Kaur (2015), following are the
commonly used e-recruiting methods by organizations to acquire talent:
● Job Boards: A medium where employers post job and find the prospective
employees. The aspirants are notified about vacancy.
● Employer Website: The official website of the organization or employer
owned website.
● Professional Website: The websites specific for profession, talent, trait or
skill.
The influence of internet has impacted the service sector organizations working in
Hyderabad, Sindh. Many organizations have their own established human
resource departments. With an increase in use of online platforms, they are using
E-Recruitment 51
Methods/Process of E-Recruitment
1. Company’s website: The firms can use their website for the positing of
vacant positions in organization and the future employee can follow this
provided link in order apply these vacant positions. HR department is
52 The Catalyst
Figure 1
Attractiveness
Job Fit
E-
recruitment
Cost
Time
Sources: Barney and Wright (1998)
The applicant usually updates their personal information on social media websites
that might leak the personal information to general public (Madejski et al., 2011).
Most of times, the candidates may be face the unusual comments on social media
websites and this create misunderstanding between both parties such as employer
and potential employees. When applicant sees the malpractices on these social
media websites the potential jobseekers left these website and personal
54 The Catalyst
information can be theft (Connerly et al., 2001). The employer may reject the
jobseeker based on provided information on these social media websites
(Kluemper, 2012). These reasons can be which are practically observed such as
inappropriate pictures, information related to drugs, poor communication skills
and sharing confidential information related to past organization so on.
Pessis and Frederick (2012), focused different ways of electronic recruiting and
their impact on Human Resource Department in comparison of traditional
recruitment methods and tools. Secondary data was gathered from 529 businesses
of Auckland Rosebank Business Precinct. A random stratified cluster sample was
used for collecting the data. The research resulted that in job categories like cost-
time efficiency and wider audience targeting, e-recruitment is effective, while in
others like effective talent acquisition and quality applicants, electronic
recruitment has same impact as that of traditional recruitment. The online
recruitment has many benefits but key it can attract the suitable candidate for job
and this will help to firms for achieving their selective targets and goals in future.
E-Recruitment 55
Holm (2010), analyzed the undeniable effect E-recruitment has on design and
structure of recruitment process. This is a qualitative exploratory research
conducted in Human resource departments of 3 large organizations of Denmark in
2008-10. Findings of the study revealed that e-recruitment not only saves time but
also changes whole structure of recruitment process. Usefulness of e-recruitment
depends on certain factors that includes such as security, reliability, performance
and cost-effectiveness.
Holme (2009) talks about the appropriate definition of E-recruitment and its
execution in recruitment process. The main objective of this research is to
understand whether E-recruitment is only limited to virtualizing of recruitment
process or something greater than that. Data for this exploratory research is
gathered from secondary as well as primary sources. The primary data was
collected through questionnaire and interviewing high-level managerial staff of
fourteen different types of multinational companies of Denmark. The research
describes all the possible elements of E-recruitment and how it is influenced by
56 The Catalyst
Mar (2007), analyzed the source of E-recruitment that examines pre-hire criteria.
Longitudinal approach was used to focus pre-hire quality and quantity of
applicants. The total five hundred and thirteen respondents participated in the
research. The methods to assess source include secondary data, survey data and
interviews. Distributing questionnaires and surveys to real participants assessed
applicants, whereas the organizational perspective was obtained by interviewing
Human Resource practitioners. The findings show quality of applicant chosen by
E-recruitment process is equal to and less than other practices of recruitment.
Nike (2005), was getting around 800-900 resume’ per month for average 120
openings at Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA) Headquarter (HQ) in
Hilversum, the Netherlands. The task of handling applicants was challenging as
the head quarter increased in size. This created further issues to track the progress
of prospects rather than aimlessly circulating the resume’ among different
departments. The methodology used was to standardize the HR process, reduce
the cost associated and improve the quality hired. An integrated e-recruiting
mechanism ‘Active Recruiter’ was included in PeopleSoft software. These steps
helped Nike reduce 54 percent of the total recruiting cost, decrease average time
to fill vacancy up to 20 days and reducing the overall recruitment time.
thesis is calculated using rule of thumb the formula proposed by (Roscoe, 1975)
and is given as:
In order to get better response and results optimal sample size determined is 120
but authors have distributed among 200 respondents in the service sector of
Hyderabad, Pakistan. In this study the participants were selected through
convenience sampling technique which is a form of non-probability sampling
technique. The data collection process continued for 1 month from 200
respondents. 250 copies were successfully completed, returned and utilized for
analysis out of 250. The response rate was 80%. The various service sectors such
as Telecom, Banking and Education industry has been considered for respondent
of this study.
3.2 Measure
The questioner included structured close-ended questions and consists of two
parts. In 1st part personal profile of respondent was needed to be filled while in the
2nd part both dependent and independent variables of was measured for testing the
hypotheses. The questioner is developed and adopted from (Singh, 2016). In this
study 5-Point Likert scale is used for determining the respondent’s response by
using negative to positive approach that ranges from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5
(Strongly agree).
Table 1
Respondent Profile Descriptive Analysis
Construct Category Frequency Percentage
Male 104 52%
Gender
Female 96 48%
Intermediate 27 13.5%
Education Graduate 120 60%
Post-graduate 53 26.5%
Managers 18 09%
Occupation level
Lower Employees 182 91%
Source: Author’s Estimation
Table 2
Summarizes the results of Reliability analysis
Name of variable Cronbach's No of Items Remarks
Alpha
E-recruitment 0.776 3 Excellent
Table 3
Summarizes the results of multiple regression analysis
Dependent variable Independent variable β-value P-value
E-recruitment Attractiveness 0.230 .000**
Job fit 0.126 .000**
Cost -0.359 .001**
Time -0.106 .003**
R-Square 0.421
Note: **significance level at 0.05
Source: Author’s Estimations
5. Discussion on Findings
5.1 Attractiveness
Based on these results, hypotheses discussed in section and reproduced here are
accepted. That is:
In this case null hypothesis is rejected and its alternative hypothesis is accepted.
This is because estimate of attractiveness is positive and significant. This implies
that attractiveness of job has positive and significant effect on e-recruitment.
Candidates data can be obtained automatically that is stored in server of
organization and this data may be utilized for other related vaccines within
60 The Catalyst
As far as second hypothesis is concerned, null is rejected and its alternative that e-
recruitment places right people on the job is accepted. The basis of this conclusion
is that the estimated slope parameter of job fit is positive and significant. This
mean job fit does have significant positive effect on e-recruitment, which enables
us to reject that null that it is irrelevant determinants of e-recruitment. The
findings of this study strongly suggest that the e-recruitment in most of
organizations for hiring the right person for the right job. With respect to
traditional method of hiring the online method of recruitment develop appropriate
strategy for successful implementation and use of it in effective manner.
5.3 Cost
: Cost has significant negative effect on E-recruitment in service sector of
Hyderabad, Pakistan.
5.4 Time
Time has significant negative effect on E-recruitment in service sector of
Hyderabad, Pakistan.
E-Recruitment 61
individuals who fulfill the job requirements will be notified automatically this
could reduce time of e-recruitment. To partner or associate with online job
searching platforms like Rozee.pk and others. This will help the organizations
advertise as many job vacancies as they want on a platform that is accessed by
millions of users daily, which would save cost of posting jobs traditionally and
will reduce time to process e-recruitment strategy. To continue evaluating the
existing e-recruitment system and the employees hired through it to identify the
possible loopholes as early as possible. Making the necessary improvement in the
e-recruitment system should then rectify those loopholes.
References
Anderson, N., Lievens, F., Van Dam, K., & Ryan, A. M. (2004), “Future
Perspectives on Employee Selection: Key Directions for Future Research
and Practice”, Applied Psychology: An International Review, 53(4), pp.
487–501.
Barney, J., and Wright, P.M. (1998), “On Becoming a Strategic Partner: The Role
of Human Resources in Gaining Competitive Advantage”, Human
Resource Management, 37 (1), pp. 31-46.
Brown, V., and Vaughn, E. (2011), ‘The Writing on the (Facebook) Wall: The
Use of Social Networking Sites in Hiring Decisions”, Journal of Business
and Psychology, Vol. 26, No. 2, pp. 219-225.
Compton, R., Morrissey, W., Nankervis, A., (2009), “Effective Recruitment and
Selection Practices,’’
Cober, R. T., Brown, D. J., Levy, P. E., Cober, A.B., and Keeping, L. M. (2003),
“Organizational Web Sites: Web Site Content and Style as Determinants
of Organizational Attraction”, International Journal of Selection and
Assessment, 11(2/3), pp. 158–169.
Dutta, D. (2014),“Tweet Your Tune - Social Media, the New Pied Piper in Talent
Acquisition. Vikalpa”, The Journal for Decision Makers, 39(3), pp. 93-
104.
Ma, L., and Ye, M. (2013), “The Role of Electronic Human Resource
Management in Contemporary Human Resource Management”, Open
Journal of Social Sciences, 1 (2), pp. 71-78.
Parry, E., and Tyson, S. (2008), “An Analysis of the Use of Success of Online
Recruitment Methods in The UK”, Human Resource Management
Journal,18 (3), pp. 257-274.