Cfa Fra R23-24
Cfa Fra R23-24
Cfa Fra R23-24
For accounting
For tax purposes
purposes
Disposal of a car 20 20
Purchase without
0 (20)
supporting documents
Profit for tax purpose is also (see the next slide) Profit for accounting purpose is
called taxable income also called accounting profit
5
Difference between the recognition of revenue and expense for tax and
accounting purposes may result in taxable income differing from accounting
profit. As a result, the amount of income tax expense recognized in the
income statement may differ from the tax payable to the taxing authorities.
Note: In actuality, to calculate taxable income for tax purposes, we start from
accounting profit with some adjustments for taxable (or non-taxable) and
deductible (or non-deductible) items (incomes or expenses), rather than start
from sales as mentioned in the previous slide.
Deductible expense -
Accounting profit
Non-taxable items
Temporary Permanent
difference difference
(refer to LOS 23b) (refer to LOS 23b)
Non-deductible expense
Temporary Permanent
different different
Year 1 (20) 20
Year 2 (20) 20
Accounting
Year 3 (20) 20 100
perspective
Year 4 (20) 20
Year 5 (20) 20
For each year from year 1 to year 4, depreciation charge for tax purpose is higher than
accounting treatment. However, the total impacts on the pre-tax income is the same
between two perspective, on the other hand, that is expected to reverse in the future.
12
Accounting Deductible
P&L approach
expenses expenses
Temporary
Accounting profit difference in Taxable income
pre-tax income
This approach
Change in Deferred tax asset, Deferred
is popularly
tax asset/liability is charged to P&L
used to
statement (∆DTA or ∆DTL)
calculate
Recorded
Deferred tax asset/liability
in BS
Temporary
Carrying amount
difference in Tax base
of asset/liability account balance
14
Year 1 2 3 4 5
CA opening 100 80 60 40 20
Depreciation 20 20 20 20 20
CA ending 80 60 40 20 0
• Tax perspective
Year 1 2 3 4 5
CA opening 100 75 50 25 0
Depreciation 25 25 25 25 0
• P&L approach
Year 1 2 3 4 5
Accounting profit ↓ 20 ↓ 20 ↓ 20 ↓ 20 ↓ 20
Taxable income ↓ 25 ↓ 25 ↓ 25 ↓ 25 ↓0
• In the first 4 years, the depreciation expense under tax is greater than
depreciation expense under accounting, the taxable income is then lower than
the accounting profit.
→ The company receives tax relief, which means that its tax payment is deferred
till the next years.
→ To be specific, the amount of tax that is deferred each year in the first 4 years
is: (Accounting profit – taxable income) x tax rate.
• However, in year 5, when the depreciation expense under accounting is greater
than depreciation expense under tax law, the taxable income is then higher
→ the company is charged additional tax, so the difference is only temporary.
16
Year 0 1 2 3 4 5
CA ending 100 80 60 40 20 0
Temporary difference 0 5 10 15 20 0
in account balance (1)
DTL (2) 0 1 2 3 4 0
CA ending 100 80 60 40 20 0
Temporary difference 0 5 10 15 20 0
in account balance
(1)
DTL (2) 0 1 2 3 4 0
Year 0 1 2 3 4 5
Note: The treatment for deferred tax asset (DTA) is the same as the
treatments for DTL mentioned above.
19
Temporary differences
Assets: Carrying amount > Tax base Assets: Carrying amount < Tax base
Liabilities: Carrying amount < Tax base Liabilities: Carrying amount > Tax base
• Revenue (or gains) are recognized • Revenue (or gains) are taxable
in the income statement before before they are recognized in the
they are included on the tax income statement
return due to temporary • Expenses (or losses) are
Occur if
1. Dividends receivable: Although the dividends received are economic benefits from the
subsidiary, we are assuming that dividends are not taxable. Therefore, the carrying
amount equals the tax base for dividends receivable.
2. Development costs: We assume that development costs will generate economic
benefits for Entiguan Sports it may be included as an asset on the balance sheet for the
purposes of this example. The amortization allowed by the tax authorities exceeds the
amortization accounted for based on accounting rules.
The carrying amount is €0 because the full amount has been expensed for financial
reporting purposes in the year in which it was incurred. Therefore, there would not have
been a balance sheet item “Research costs” for tax purposes, and only a proportion may
be deducted in the current fiscal year. The tax base of the asset is (€500,000 - €500,000/4)
= €375,000.
4. Accounts receivable: The economic benefits that should have been received from
accounts receivable have already been included in revenues included in the calculation of
the taxable income when the sales occurred. Because the receipt of a portion of the
accounts receivable is doubtful, the provision is allowed. The provision, based on tax
legislation, results in a greater amount allowed in the current fiscal year than would be
the case under accounting principles.
1. Donations 0 0 0
4. Loan 0 0 0
Interest paid 0 0 0
Items Calculation
Solution:
For tax reporting and financial reporting, taxable income and taxes payable for two years
are:
In year 1,
• The firm reports $1,960 of tax expense in the income statement, but $2,000 of taxes
payable are reported on the tax return taxes payable are initially higher than tax
expense and the $40 difference is reported on the balance sheet by creating a DTA.
• The carrying value of the warranty liability is $100 (the warranty expense has been
recognized in the income statement but it has not been paid), and the tax base of the
liability is 0 (the warranty expense has not been recognized on the tax return) we
get the balance of the DTA of $40 [($100 carrying value - zero tax base) × 40%].
We can reconcile income tax expense and taxes payable with the change in the DTA. In
this example, the DTA increased $40 (from zero to $40) during year 1. Thus, income tax
expense in year 1 is $1,960 ($2,000 taxes payable – $40 increase in the DTA).
In year 2,
The firm recognizes $1,960 of tax expense in the income statement but only $1,920 is
reported on the tax return (taxes payable). The $40 deferred tax asset recognized at the
end of year 1 has reversed as a result of the warranty expense recognition on the tax
return. So, in year 2, income tax expense is $1,960 ($1,920 taxes payable + $40 decrease
in DTA).
32
Back to some formula about deferred asset and deferred tax liability
From above formulas we know that when tax rate change, deferred tax
asset/liability will be adjusted. If tax rates decrease:
• Deferred tax asset will decrease Decrease in value toward the offset
of future tax payments to the tax authorities.
• Deferred tax liability will decrease Decrease in value off future tax
payments to the tax authorities.
Due to the relationship between income tax expense and deferred tax
asset/ liability (above formula), the decrease in the DTL would result in
lower income tax expense and the decrease in the DTA would result in
higher income tax expense
33
Retained earnings
Retained earnings increase
decrease
Example:
A firm owns equipment and bad debt that will be shown below. (The tax
rate is 40%)
Calculate the effect on the firm’s income tax expense if the tax rate
decreases to 30%.
35
Solution:
Ratios Effect
• Deferred tax assets are assessed at each balance sheet date to determine the
likelihood of sufficient future taxable income to recover the tax assets. (Without
future taxable income, a Deferred tax assets is worthless)
• Under U.S. GAAP, DTA are reduced by creating a contra-asset account known as the
valuation allowance.
(>50%) account
Example: If a company has cumulative losses over the past few years or a
history of inability to use tax loss carry forwards, then the company would
need to use a valuation allowance
38
Tax losses: A tax loss (tax loss carryforward) is a provision that allows
a taxpayer to move a tax loss to future years to offset a profit.
Tax credit: A tax credit is an amount of money that taxpayers can
subtract directly from taxes owed to their government.
IFRS and US GAAP allow the creation of a deferred tax asset in the
case of tax losses and tax credits. The recognition is specified below:
IFRS US GAAP
IFRS allows the recognition of A deferred tax asset
unused tax losses and tax is recognized in full but is then
credits only to the extent reduced by a valuation
that it is probable that in the allowance if it is more likely
future there will be taxable than not that some or all of the
income against which the deferred tax asset will not be
unused tax losses and credits realized.
can be applied
40
The existence of tax losses may indicate that the entity cannot reasonably be
expected to generate sufficient future taxable income
→ there are concerns about the uncertainty of future taxable profits
→ in this case, we follow these criteria:
• Taxable temporary differences are available to offset deferred tax
payable
• Assess the probability that the entity will in fact generate future taxable
profits before the unused tax losses and/or credits expire (*)
• Verify that the above is with the same tax authority and based on the
same taxable entity
• Determine whether the past tax losses were a result of specific
circumstances that are unlikely to be repeated
• Discover if tax planning opportunities are available to the entity that will
result in future profits. (**)
(*) Taxable profit → DTA (**)
opportunity
+
Unused tax loss profit
Details on the source of the temporary differences that cause the deferred
tax assets and liabilities reported.
Typically, the following deferred tax information is disclosed:
• Deferred tax liabilities, deferred tax assets, any valuation allowance, and
the net change in the valuation allowance over the period.
• Any unrecognized deferred tax liability for undistributed earnings of
subsidiaries and joint ventures.
• Current-year tax effect of each type of temporary difference.
• Components of income tax expense.
• Reconciliation of reported income tax expense and the tax expense
based on the statutory rate.
• Tax loss carry forwards and credits.
43
Some firms’ reported income tax expense differs from the amount based
on the statutory income tax rate. Thus, firm need explain the differences
between:
• The statutory rate tax (the tax rate of the jurisdiction where the firm
operates)
Income tax expense
• The effective tax rate (= )
Pretax income
The differences are generally the result of:
• Different tax rates in different tax jurisdictions (countries).
• Permanent tax differences: tax credits, tax-exempt income, nondeductible
expenses, and tax differences between capital gains and operating income.
• Changes in tax rates and legislation.
• Deferred taxes provided on the reinvested earnings of foreign and unconsolidated
domestic affiliates.
• Tax holidays in some countries (watch for special conditions such as termination
dates for the holiday or a requirement to pay the accumulated taxes at some point
in the future)
44
Explain the effect of the change in the valuation allowance on WCCO’s earnings for 20X5
• Management decreased the valuation allowance by $33 million in 20X5 a reduction
in deferred income tax expense and an increase in reported earnings for 20X5
46
IFRS GAAP
Undistributed profit Deferred taxes are recognized No deferred taxes for joint
from an investment unless the parent is able to venture that meet the
in a joint venture control the distribution of indefinite reversal criterion
profit and it is probable the
temporary difference will
reverse in the future
49
IFRS GAAP
23.b. Explain how deferred tax liabilities and assets are created Question 1, 2
and the factors that determine how a company’s deferred tax
liabilities and assets should be treated for the purposes of
financial analysis
23.c. Calculate the tax base of a company’s assets and liabilities Question 3
23.g. Describe the valuation allowance for deferred tax assets Question 6
when it is required and what effect it has on financial statements
23.i. Analyze disclosures relating to deferred tax items and the N/A
effective tax rate reconciliation and explain how information
included in these disclosures affects a company’s financial
statements and financial ratios
4 A firm acquires an asset for $120,000 with a 4-year useful life and no
salvage value. The asset will generate $50,000 of cash flow for all four
years. The tax rate is 40% each year
The firm will depreciate the asset over three years on a straight-line
(SL) basis for tax purposes and over four years on a SL basis for financial
reporting purposes. Taxable income in year 1 is:
A $6,000.
B $10,000.
C $20,000
5 A firm acquires an asset for $120,000 with a 4-year useful life and no
salvage value. The asset will generate $50,000 of cash flow for all four
years. The tax rate is 40% each year
The firm will depreciate the asset over three years on a straight-line
(SL) basis for tax purposes and over four years on a SL basis for
financial reporting purposes. Pretax income in year 4 is:
A $4,000.
B $6,000.
C $8,000
54
3. A For revenue received in advance, the tax base is equal to the carrying
value minus any amounts that will not be taxed in the future. Since the
advance has already been taxed, $100,000 will not be taxed in the future.
Thus, the textbook advance liability has a tax base of $0 ($100,000
carrying value – $100,000 revenue not taxed in the future)
Bonds
Leases
1. Bond Terminology
Face or Par The amount of principal that will be paid to the bondholder at
value maturity and is used to calculate the coupon payments.
Coupon The interest rate stated in the bond that is used to calculate
rate the coupon payments and is typically fixed for the term of
bonds.
1. Bond Terminology
Effective • The market rate of interest that is used to value the bond
rate of and depends on the bond’s risks as well as the structure of
interest interest rates and the timing of the bond’s cash flows.
• The market rate will likely change over the bond’s life,
which changes the bond’s market value as well.
The • Known as the book value or the carrying value of the bond,
balance equals to the present value (PV) of its remaining cash flows
sheet (coupon payments and par value), discounted at the market
liability rate of interest at issuance.
• At maturity, the liability will equal the face value of the
bond.
1. Bond Terminology
1. Bond Terminology
Answer:
1. Bond Terminology
Answer:
a. The market rate of 9% < the coupon rate of 10% → the bond is issued at
premium.
The bond proceeds = the book value at issuance = $102.531 > Par
(N = 3, PMT = 10, FV = 100, I/Y = 9, CPT → PV = - 102.531)
b. The market rate of 10% = the coupon rate of 10% → the bond is issued
at Par.
The bond proceeds = the book value at issuance = Par = $100
c. The market rate of 11% > the coupon rate of 10% the bond is issued at
discount.
The bond proceeds = the book value at issuance = $97.556 < Par
(N = 3, PMT = 10, FV = 100, I/Y = 11, CPT → PV = - 97.556)
65
Premium bond
Market rate < coupon rate → interest expense < the coupon payment
→ premium amortization each year = coupon payment – interest expense
Discount bond
Market rate > coupon rate → interest expense > the coupon payment
→ discount amortization each year = interest expense – coupon payment
67
Zero-coupon bond
Answer:
Beginning
$102.531 $101.759 $100.917 $97.556 $98.287 $99.099
book value (1)
Interest
expense (2) = $9.228 $9.158 $9.083 $10.731 $10.812 $10.901
(1) × r decreases over time increases over time
Coupon
payments (3) $10 $10 $10 $10 $10 $10
= $10
Ending book
value
$101.759 $100.917 $100 $98.287 $99.099 $100
= (1) – (3) +
(2) decreases over time increases over time
70
Income Interest expense = market rate at issuance × the book value of bond
statement liability at beginning of each period
Cash flow The coupon payments are reported as cash outflow from operating
statement (CFO) under U.S.GAAP and cash outflow from operating (CFO) or
financing (CFF) under IFRS
71
Income statement –
Answer:
Asset Cash ↓ $6
Answer:
Year 1 ↓ $6 ↑ $4 $6 ↑ $2 ↓ $2
Year 2 – ↓ $2 ↑ $2 ↓ $2
Year 3 – ↓ $2 ↑ $2 ↓ $2
Issuance cost is
allocated equally in
the income statement
77
Under effective interest rate method, the book value of the bond is based
on the market rate at issuance → If market interest rates fluctuate → the
actual value of the firm’s debt deviates from its reported book value:
Book value > fair value of debt Book value < fair value of debt
Gains and losses that result from changes in bonds’ market yields are
reported in the income statement.
78
A firm may redeem the bond before maturity due to some reasons:
When bonds are redeemed before maturity, a gain or loss is recognized
by subtracting the redemption price from the book value of the bond
liability at the reacquisition date:
o Maturity dates.
1. Types of lease
Lessee
Answer:
IFRS U.S.GAAP
(2)
• Finance lease: the ROU asset is straight-line amortized.
• Operating lease: the ROU asset is not straight-line amortized:
Amortization = the reduction of lease liability each period
= lease payment – interest expense
88
IFRS U.S.GAAP
(6)
• Finance lease: interest expense and amortization expense are reported
separately in the income statement.
• Operating lease: Lease expense = Lease payment
(the interest expense and amortization expense are reported as a single
line titled “lease expense”)
90
(7)
• Finance lease: interest and principal (reduction of lease liability)
repayment are reported separately.
• Operating lease: the entire lease payment is reported as cash
outflow from operating.
91
Answer:
The present value of lease payments:
N = 2; I/Y = 6%; PMT = - $60,000; FV = 0; CPT → PV = $110,000
The accounting for lessors is substantially identical under IFRS and US
GAAP:
Operating lease: lease payments are simply reported as lease income in
the P&L and CFO inflow over the period.
Finance lease: Lessors under US GAAP recognize finance leases as either
“sales-type” or “direct financing” lease:
• Sale-type lease: PV of lease payments (sales) > the book value of
leased asset (COGS)
• Direct financing lease: PV of lease payments = the book value of
leased asset
(continue in the next slide)
93
Leased
Lease
asset (de- Liability Equity
receivable
recognize)
Operatin
No effect No effect No effect No effect
g lease
Direct PV of lease
fair value
financing payments No effect No effect No effect
= $110
lease = $110,000
Direct financing
Sale-type lease
lease
Liability –
95
Cash flow
CFO inflow 60 60 Same
statement
96
Year 1 Year 2
Liabilities –
Liability – –
Answer
A retiree who served the company for 20 years and had a final salary at
retirement of $200,000 would, under the terms of this defined-benefit
plan, be entitled to an annual pension payment of 0.02 x $200,000 x 20 =
$80,000 each year during her retirement until her death.
0 1 19 20 21 22
Final salary at
retirement
103
Answer:
At the end of the 1st year of service, the employee’s annual pension
benefit = 2% × $50,000 × 1 = $1,000 per year from retirement until death.
Step 1: The PV of payments on the retirement date = $8,560
(I/Y = 8, PMT = 1,000, N = 15, FV = 0, CPT → PV = -8,560)
Step 2: At the end of the 1st year of employment, the PV of the annuity
that begins in 24 years = The pension obligation (PBO) of the first year =
$8,560/(1.08^24) = $1,350.
0 1 2 24 25 26 39 40
Balance sheet • The fair value of plan assets > the pension
obligation → the plan has a surplus → reflect a
net pension asset.
• The fair value of plan assets < the pension
obligation → the plan has a deficit → reflect a
net pension liability.
Answer
During the 2nd year of service, the PBO increased $1,566. The increase is a
result of current service cost and interest cost as follows:
1st PBO = $1,350
+ Current service cost = $1,458 (PV of 15 payments of $1,000 ($2000 –
$1000) starting in 23 years)
+ Interest cost = $108 (= $1,350 × 8%)
2nd PBO = $2,916
If the fair value of the plan assets at the end of 2nd year = $2,000
→ report a net pension liability = $2,916 - $2,000 = $916
112
Leverage ratios
• Debt-to-assets ratio = total debt / total assets
→ Measures the percentage of total assets financed with debt
o The higher the ratio, the higher the financial risk and → the weaker
the solvency
• Debt-to-capital ratio = total debt / (total debt + total equity)
→ Measures the percentage of total capital financed with debt. It is
different from debt-to-asset ratio by the non-interest-bearing liabilities.
o The higher the ratio → the weaker the solvency
• Debt-to-equity ratio = total debt / total equity.
→ Measures the amount of debt financing relative to the firm’s equity
base.
→ A debt-to-equity ratio of 1.0 indicates equal amounts of debt and equity
→ a debt-to-capital ratio of 50%.
o The higher the ratio → the weaker the solvency
• Financial leverage ratio = average total assets / average total equity.
→ Measure of leverage used in the DuPont formula
o The higher the financial leverage ratio, the more leveraged the
company in the sense of using debt and other liabilities to finance
assets.
114
Coverage ratios
• Interest coverage = EBIT / interest payments
→ Measures the number of times a company’s EBIT could cover its
interest payments.
o The higher interest coverage ratio, the stronger solvency → greater
assurance that the company can service its debt from operating
earnings
• Fixed charge coverage = (EBIT + lease payments) / (interest payments +
lease payments).
→ Measures the number of times a company’s earnings (before interest,
taxes, and lease payments) can cover the company’s interest and lease
payments.
→ Fixed charge coverage is more meaningful for firms that engage in
significant operating leases
115
Answer:
31-Mar-18 31-Mar-17
Answer:
Practice questions
119
1. A company issues €1 million of bonds at face value. When the bonds are
issued, the company will record a:
A. cash inflow from investing activities.
B. cash inflow from financing activities.
C. cash inflow from operating activities.
2. At the time of issue of 4.50% coupon bonds, the effective interest rate was
5.00%. The bonds were most likely issued at:
A. par.
B. a discount.
C. a premium.
3. Oil Exploration LLC paid $45,000 in printing, legal fees, commissions, and
other costs associated with its recent bond issue. It is most likely to record
these costs on its financial statements as:
A. an asset under US GAAP and reduction of the carrying value of the
debt under IFRS.
B. a liability under US GAAP and reduction of the carrying value of the
debt under IFRS.
C. a cash outflow from investing activities under both US GAAP and
IFRS.
122
4. Midland Brands issues three-year bonds dated 1 January 2015 with a face
value of $5,000,000. The market interest rate on bonds of comparable risk
and term is 3%. If the bonds pay 2.5% annually on 31 December, bonds
payable when issued are most likely reported as closest to:
A. $4,929,285.
B. $5,000,000.
C. $5,071,401
10. Beginning with fiscal year 2019, for leases with a term longer than one
year, lessees report a right-to-use asset and a lease liability on the balance
sheet:
A. only for finance leases.
B. only for operating leases.
C. for both finance and operating leases.
11. A company enters into a finance lease agreement to acquire the use of an
asset for three years with lease payments of €19,000,000 starting next
year. The leased asset has a fair market value of €49,000,000 and the
present value of the lease payments is €47,250,188. Based on this
information, the value of the lease liability reported on the company’s
balance sheet at lease inception is closest to:
A. €47,250,188.
B. €49,000,000.
C. €57,000,000.
125
13. For a lessor, the leased asset appears on the balance sheet and continues
to be depreciated when the lease is classified as:
A. a finance lease.
B. a sales-type lease.
C. an operating lease.
$ Millions
2. B is correct. The effective interest rate is greater than the coupon rate and
the bonds will be issued at a discount.
3. A is correct.
• Under US GAAP, expenses incurred when issuing bonds (issuance cost)
are generally recorded as an asset and amortized to the related expense
(legal, etc.) over the life of the bonds.
• Under IFRS, they are included in the measurement of the liability.
• The related cash flows are financing activities.
5. B is correct. Book value of bond liability is equal to the present value of the
remaining future cash flow.
At the beginning of 2010, book value of bond = £978,938 and it is also a
cash inflow from financing in 2010
Interest expense in 2010 = £978,938 × 6% = £58,736
2010
6. C is correct. A gain of €3.3 million (carrying amount less amount paid) will
be reported on the income statement.
7. C is correct.
• Affirmative covenants require certain actions of the borrower. Requiring
the company to perform regular maintenance on equipment pledged as
collateral is an example of an affirmative covenant because it requires
the company to do something.
• Negative covenants require that the borrower not take certain actions.
Prohibiting the borrower from entering into mergers and preventing the
borrower from issuing excessive additional debt are examples of
negative covenants.
9. C is correct. At the end of a lease, the lessee often returns the leased asset
to the lessor → does not bear the risk of an unexpected decline in the
asset’s end-of-lease value → the interest rate implicit in a lease contract
may be less than the interest rate on a loan to purchase the asset.
• The terms of a lease may not require all the covenants typically included
in loan agreements or bond indenture.
10. C is correct. Beginning with fiscal year 2019, lessees report a right-of-use
asset and a lease liability for all leases longer than one year. An exception
under IFRS exists for leases when the underlying asset is of low value.
11. A is correct. Under the revised reporting standards under IFRS and U.S.
GAAP, a lessee must recognize an asset and a lease liability at inception of
each of its leases (with an exception for short-term leases):
→ The lessee reports a “right-of-use” (ROU) asset and a lease liability = the
present value of fixed lease payments on its balance sheet → the company
will record a lease liability on the balance sheet of €47,250,188.
131
12. A is correct. A sales-type lease treats the lease as a sale of the asset, and
revenue is recorded at the time of sale equal to the value of the leased
asset. Under a direct financing lease, only interest income is reported as
earned. Under an operating lease, revenue from lease receipts is reported
when collected.
14. B is correct. The company will report a net pension obligation of €1 million
equal to the pension obligation (€10 million) less the plan assets
(€9 million).