Receiving-Coil Structure Reducing Stray AC Resista
Receiving-Coil Structure Reducing Stray AC Resista
Receiving-Coil Structure Reducing Stray AC Resista
Research Article
Kazuhiro Umetani1 , Toru Honjo1, Takahiro Koyama1, Masataka Ishihara1, Eiji Hiraki1
1Graduate School of Natural Science and Technology, Okayama University, 3-1-1 Tsushima-naka, Kita-ku, Okayama, Japan
E-mail: [email protected]
Abstract: Resonant inductive coupling wireless power transfer is widely known to be a possible convenient power supply
method for the small mobile apparatus. However, the limited receiving-coil size tends to lower the efficiency and limit the output
power owing to the small mutual inductance and comparatively large stray alternating current (AC) resistance of the receiving-
coil. This study mitigates this issue by proposing a novel receiving-coil structure. This proposed structure comprises a coil and a
drum core with a thin axis. The coil is wound on the axis to form a single winding layer. The proposed structure can reduce stray
AC resistance by suppressing the proximity effect and reducing the wire length without deteriorating the mutual inductance
significantly. Therefore, better efficiency and larger output power can be achieved. Simulations and experiments were performed
to verify the proposed structure. Consequently, both simulations and experiments supported the reduction in AC resistance
compared to the conventional structure. Furthermore, the experiment revealed improvements by the proposed structure in both
efficiency and output power. These results support the effectiveness of the proposed structure for wireless power transfer to
small mobile apparatus.
1 Introduction Hence, the practical RIC–WPT system for small mobile apparatus
must be improved for better efficiency and output power.
The recent progress in consumer electronics has resulted in small As reported in the literature [7–9], the maximum efficiency of
mobile electric apparatus such as mobile phones [1, 2] and capsule the RIC–WPT system is determined by the figure-of-merit F,
endoscopy [3–7]. On account of the limited size of these apparatus, which is defined as
their internal battery tends to exhibit insufficient electric capacity,
thus resulting in the need for frequent power charging from outside
F = k2QTQR, (1)
the apparatus. However, the cable connection for the power supply
to these apparatus may deteriorate mobility.
Resonant inductive coupling–wireless coupling transfer (RIC– where k is the magnetic coupling coefficient, QT and QR are the
WPT) [1–16] is a promising method to overcome this issue. The quality factor of the transmitting and receiving resonators,
RIC–WPT technique can supply electric power without a cable respectively, defined as follows:
connection to the external power source.
Fig. 1 illustrates a typical RIC–WPT system. The system 1 LT 1 LR
QT = , QR = , (2)
comprises a transmitting resonator and a receiving resonator, each rT CT rR CR
comprising a coil and a resonating capacitor. The transmitting and
receiving coils are coupled magnetically through a vacant space. r is the stray AC resistance of the coil, L is the self-inductance of
These resonators are designed to exhibit the same resonant the coil, and C is the resonating capacitance. Subscripts T and R
frequency such that the resonance in the transmitting resonator can correspond to the transmitting and receiving resonators,
trigger the resonance in the receiving resonator. respectively (the power load is not included in rR).
However, the RIC–WPT to a small mobile apparatus tends to Substituting (2) into (1) yields
demonstrate low efficiency and small output power owing to the
limited size of the receiving-coil [3–7]. Consequently, a large
k2 LT LR 1 M2
alternating current (AC) current is required in the transmitting coil F= = , (3)
rTrR CT CR rT LTCT LRCR rR
to generate sufficient magnetic flux linkage with the receiving-coil,
thus causing a significant heat generation in the transmitting coil.
where M is the mutual inductance between the transmitting and
receiving coils.
The figure-of-merit F contains parameters relevant to both the
transmitting and receiving resonators. However, focusing on the
receiving-coil, we can extract a factor of the receiving-coil to
achieve a larger F. Since LRCR is typically determined by the
specification provided for the resonance frequency, the receiving-
coil with a larger M2/rR achieves a larger F, i.e. better efficiency.
Similarly, M2/rR determines the maximum output power of the
RIC–WPT system, as discussed in [16]. Therefore, increasing
M2/rR is essential for improving both the efficiency and output
power.
To increase this factor, a number of designs have been
Fig. 1 Resonant inductive coupling wireless power transfer system developed to increase M [4, 5, 10–12]. Two approaches are
typically utilised in the receiving-coil design: one is to wind the
IET Power Electron., 2019, Vol. 12 Iss. 9, pp. 2338-2344 2338
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
Fig. 2 Conventional and proposed receiving coil structures
(a) Conventional structure,
(b) Proposed structure
Fig. 3 Schematic illustration of flux lines in conventional and proposed receiving coil structures
(a) Conventional structure,
(b) Proposed structure
receiving coils to encompass a large area, and the other is to wind possible area such that the core can collect a large flux from the
the receiving-coil on a magnetic core. Particularly, the magnetic transmitting coil.
core for the receiving-coil can offer a low reluctance flux path to Meanwhile, the proposed structure is composed of a drum core
collect the magnetic flux from the transmitting coil. Consequently, with a thin axis and a receiving-coil wound on the axis. The
M can be increased effectively, as is confirmed in this study; receiving-coil is wound to form a single winding layer. The top and
therefore, it is utilised in a number of preceding studies [4, 5, 13]. bottom surfaces of the core are designed to encompass the largest
However, these two approaches generally increase rR. The possible area, similarly as in the conventional structure, although
former tends to involve a long wire length, thus increasing rR. The the axis has a significantly smaller sectional area than the top and
latter may increase the eddy current [14, 16–18] in the winding in bottom surfaces. Hence, the proposed structure can occupy the
many cases because many magnetic structures with the magnetic same volumetric area as the conventional structure. The drum core
core can cause an intense local magnetic field near the winding, as is a typical shape of the ferrite core. Therefore, the proposed
discussed in Section 2. Therefore, further improving M2/rR may structure can be constructed of commercially available ferrite core.
The magnetic core is assumed to exhibit a significantly larger
involve reducing rR. permeability than air. Hence, the magnetic cores of the proposed
Reducing rR has been performed by using special wires such as and conventional structures offer a low reluctance flux path for the
the Litz wire and magnetoplated wire [18, 19]. However, this flux from the transmitting coil. Since the top and bottom surface
approach may be inconvenient for applications produced in a small areas of the cores of both the structures are the same, these
scale because they are typically custom made. An alternative structures can collect a similar amount of flux from the
approach may be improving the magnetic structure because the transmitting coil. Furthermore, almost all of the flux passing
ferrite core is supplied commercially in various shapes, although through the top and bottom surfaces of the core interlinks with the
this approach is rarely investigated for RIC–WPT systems. receiving-coil. Consequently, these structures can exhibit a similar
A magnetic structure that can reduce rR using a solid copper mutual inductance M.
wire without deteriorating M is proposed herein. First, the However, the AC resistance rR of the receiving-coil can be
conventional receiving-coil structure reported in [5, 13] is small in the proposed structure because
presented; it employed the aforementioned two approaches to
improve M. Then, this paper sought for a magnetic structure that i. The thin axis can reduce the wire length of the receiving-coil;
could further reduce rR while maintaining an M as high as that of ii. The winding edges are covered by the top and bottom brims of
the conventional structure. The basic principle of this structure was the core, thus suppressing the eddy current inside the winding;
originally proposed in a conference paper [16]. However, this iii. The single winding layer can avoid the proximity effect caused
paper includes additional simulation and experimental evidences to by multiple winding layers, thus further suppressing the eddy
elucidate the validity of each feature of the proposed structure for current.
improving the efficiency and output power.
The first reason is apparent. Hence, the second and third reasons
2 Proposed receiving-coil structure are discussed below.
The second reason is discussed first. In addition to the small
Fig. 2 illustrates the proposed and conventional receiving-coil amount of flux interlinking both the transmitting and receiving
structures. The conventional structure contains a cylindrical core. coils, a comparatively large flux is generated by the leakage
The top and bottom surfaces are designed to encompass the largest inductance of the receiving-coil. Particularly, the core increases
efficiency and the output power in the evaluation of the output [8] Pinuela, M., Yates, C.D., Lucyszyn, S., et al.: ‘Maximizing DC-to-load
efficiency for inductive power transfer’, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 2013,
power. The optimum load resistance was calculated according to 28, (5), pp. 2437–2447
[15] for the efficiency and to [16] for the output power. [9] Baker, W.M., Sarpeshkar, R.: ‘Feedback analysis and design of RF power
Consequently, the load resistance was set as the value shown in links for low-power bionic systems’, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Circuits Syst.,
Table 5. 2007, 1, pp. 28–38
[10] Haldi, R., Schenk, K., Nam, I., et al.: ‘Finite-element-simulation assisted
Fig. 11 shows the evaluation results of the frequency optimized design of an asymmetrical high-power inductive coupler with a
dependencies of the efficiency and output power. The proposed large air gap for EV charging’. Proc. IEEE Energy Conversion Congress
structure demonstrated both the highest peak efficiency and peak Exposition (ECCE2013), Denver, USA, September 2013, pp. 3635–3642
output power. Hence, the experiment supported the effectiveness of [11] Li, S., Mi, C.C.: ‘Wireless power transfer for electric vehicle applications’,
IEEE J. Emerging Sel. Top. Power Electron., 2015, 3, (1), pp. 4–17
the proposed structure for better efficiency and larger output power. [12] Mohammad, M., Kwak, S., Choi, S.: ‘Core design for better misalignment
tolerance and high range of wireless power charging for HEV’. Proc. IEEE
Applied Power Electronics Conf. (APEC2016), Long Beach, USA, March
2016, pp. 1748–1755
5 Conclusions [13] Itoh, R., Sawahara, Y., Ishizaki, T., et al.: ‘Construction of a secure wireless
power transfer system for robot fish’. Proc. IEEE Wireless Power Transfer
The RIC–WPT system for a small mobile apparatus suffers from Conf., Boulder, USA, May 2015, pp. 1–4
limited efficiency and output power owing to the size restrictions [14] Cove, R.S., Ordonez, M., Shafiei, N., et al.: ‘Improving wireless power
of the receiving-coil. For improving the efficiency and output transfer efficiency using hollow windings with track-width-ratio’, IEEE
power, a receiving-coil structure was proposed herein. The Trans. Power Electron., 2016, 31, (9), pp. 6524–6533
[15] Awai, I.: ‘Basic characteristics of ‘magnetic resonance’ wireless power
proposed structure could reduce the AC resistance using a solid transfer system excited by a 0 Ohm power source’, IEICE Electron. Express,
copper wire without deteriorating the mutual inductance 2013, 10, (21), p. 20132008
significantly. The simulations supported the basic principles of the [16] Honjo, T., Koyama, T., Umetani, K., et al.: ‘Novel receiving coil structure for
proposed structure. In addition, the experiment verified the improving efficiency and power transfer capability of resonant inductive
coupling wireless power transfer’. Proc. Int. Conf. on Electrical Machines and
improvement in the efficiency and output power, thereby Systems (ICEMS), Chiba, Japan, November 2016, pp. 1–6
supporting the effectiveness of the proposed structure for RIC– [17] Perry, P.M.: ‘Multiple layer series connected winding design for minimum
WPT to small mobile apparatus. losses’, IEEE Trans. Power Appar. Syst., 1979, PAS-98, (1), pp. 116–123
[18] Shinagawa, H., Suzuki, T., Noda, M., et al.: ‘Theoretical analysis of AC
resistance in coil using magnetoplated wire’, IEEE Trans. Magn., 2009, 45,
6 References (9), pp. 3251–3259
[19] Mizuno, T., Yachi, S., Kamiya, A., et al.: ‘Improvement in efficiency of
[1] Li, Q., Liang, C.Y.: ‘An inductive power transfer system with a high-Q wireless power transfer of magnetic resonant coupling using magnetoplated
resonant tank for mobile device charging’, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., wire’, IEEE Trans. Magn., 2011, 47, (10), pp. 4445–4448
2015, 30, (11), pp. 6203–6212 [20] Umetani, K., Itoh, Y., Yamamoto, M.: ‘A detection method of DC
[2] Riehl, S.P., Satyamoorthy, A., Akram, H., et al.: ‘Wireless power systems for magnetization utilizing local inhomogeneity of flux distribution in power
mobile devices supporting inductive and resonant operating modes’, IEEE transformer core’. Proc. IEEE Energy Conversion Congress Exposition
Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., 2015, 63, (3), pp. 780–790 (ECCE2014), Pittsburgh, USA, September 2014, pp. 3739–3746
[3] Na, K., Jang, H., Ma, H., et al.: ‘Tracking optimal efficiency of magnetic [21] Umetani, K.: ‘Improvement of saturation property of iron powder core by flux
resonance wireless power transfer system for biomedical capsule endoscopy’, homogenizing structure’, IEEJ Trans. Electr. Electron. Eng., 2013, 8, (6), pp.
IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., 2015, 63, (1), pp. 295–304 640–648
[4] Badr, M.B., Somogyi-Gsizmazia, R., Delaney, R.K., et al.: ‘Wireless power [22] Dale, E.M., Sulivan, R.C.: ‘General comparison of power loss in single-layer
transfer for telemetric devices with variable orientation, for small rodent and multi-layer windings’. Proc. IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conf.,
behavior monitoring’, IEEE Sens. J., 2015, 15, (4), pp. 2144–2156 Recife, Brazil, June 2005, pp. 582–589
[5] Theilmann, T.P., Asbeck, M.P.: ‘An analytical model for inductively coupled [23] ‘Hitachi Metals Corp., Product guide, Soft ferrites, p.16’. Available at http://
implantable biomedical devices with ferrite rods’, IEEE Trans. Biomed. www.hitachi-metals.co.jp/e/products/elec/tel/pdf/hj-b3-d_c.pdf, accessed 16
Circuits Syst., 2009, 3, (1), pp. 43–52 February 2018
[6] Mao, S., Zhang, J., Song, K., et al.: ‘Wireless power transfer using a field- [24] ‘FDK Corp., Material characteristics 7H series’. Available at http://
enhancing coil and a small-sized receiver with low coupling coefficient’, IET www.fdk.co.jp/cyber-e/pdf/fe_7h.pdf, accessed 16 February 2018
Power Electron., 2016, 9, (7), pp. 1546–1552 [25] Ayachit, A., Kazimierczuk, K.M.: ‘Steinmetz equation for gapped magnetic
[7] RamRakhyani, K.A., Lazzi, G.: ‘On the design of efficient multi-coil cores’, IEEE Magn. Lett., 2016, 7, Article ID: 1302704
telemetry system for biomedical implants’, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Circuits [26] Van den Bosshe, A., Valchev, C.V.: ‘Inductors and transformers for power
Syst., 2013, 7, (1), pp. 11–23 electronics’ (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2005, 1st edn.), pp. 118–122