ENA - TS - 41-37 - Part - 3 CB
ENA - TS - 41-37 - Part - 3 CB
www.energynetworks.org
PUBLISHING AND COPYRIGHT INFORMATION
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording or otherwise, without the prior written consent of Energy Networks Association.
Specific enquiries concerning this document should be addressed to:
Operations Directorate
Energy Networks Association
6th Floor, Dean Bradley House
52 Horseferry Rd
London
SW1P 2AF
This document has been prepared for use by members of the Energy Networks
Association to take account of the conditions which apply to them. Advice should be taken
from an appropriately qualified engineer on the suitability of this document for any other
purpose.
Revised, 2015
Contents
Foreword ................................................................................................................................7
1 General ............................................................................................................................9
1.1 Scope .....................................................................................................................9
1.2 Normative references..............................................................................................9
2 Normal and special service conditions .............................................................................9
2.2.1 Pollution level ..............................................................................................9
2.2.100Flood resilience ...........................................................................................9
3 Terms and definitions .....................................................................................................10
4 Ratings ..........................................................................................................................10
4.1 Rated voltage (Ur) .................................................................................................10
4.2 Rated insulation level ............................................................................................10
4.3 Rated frequency (fr) ..............................................................................................10
4.4 Rated normal current (Ir) and temperature rise......................................................10
4.5 Rated short-time withstand current (Ik) ..................................................................10
4.7 Rated duration of short time withstand circuit (t) ...................................................10
4.101 Rated short-circuit breaking current (Isc) ................................................................10
4.104 Rated operating sequence ....................................................................................11
4.107 Rated capacitive switching currents ......................................................................11
4.111 Classification of circuit-breakers as a function of electrical endurance ................. 11
Sub-clause 4.110 of IEC 62271-100 Class M1 shall apply ............................................. 11
5.1 Requirements for liquids in circuit-breakers..........................................................11
5.2 Requirements for gases in circuit-breakers ..........................................................11
5.3 Earthing of switchgear and controlgear ................................................................12
5.4 Auxiliary equipment..............................................................................................12
5.4.1 Enclosures ...............................................................................................12
5.4.2 Protection against electric shock ..............................................................12
5.4.3 Fire hazard ...............................................................................................12
5.4.4 Components installed in enclosures .........................................................12
5.4.4.5.1Cables and small wiring ................................................ 12
5.4.4.5.2 Terminals and terminal blocks .................................. 12
5.4.4.5.3 Auxiliary switches. ....................................................12
5.4.4.5.4 Trip circuit supervision ...............................................................12
5.4.4.5.5 Trip and close coil isolation ........................................................12
5.4.4.5.6. Forced opening .........................................................................12
5.4.4.5.7 Control circuits ...........................................................................12
5.4.4.5.7.100 Trip coil 1 & 2 ......................................................................13
5.4.4.5.102Closing Coil .............................................................................15
5.5 Dependent power closing.....................................................................................15
5.5.100 Slow operation devices ............................................................................15
5.5.101 Anti-pumping ............................................................................................15
5.5.102 Operating systems interlocks ...................................................................16
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 4
5.5.103 Circuit-breakers with independent drive mechanisms one per pole .......... 16
5.5.104 Non-simultaneous pole operation .............................................................16
5.6 Stored energy operation.......................................................................................16
5.6.3 Manual charging ......................................................................................16
5.6.4 Motor charging .........................................................................................16
5.9.202 Tripping mechanism .................................................................................17
5.9.203 Independent manual operation .................................................................17
5.9.204 Local manual closing................................................................................17
5.9.205 Interlocking of manual operation ..............................................................17
5.9.206 Slow closing/opening ...............................................................................17
5.9.207 Operations counter...................................................................................17
5.10 Nameplates..........................................................................................................17
5.11 Interlocking devices and padlocking facilities .......................................................17
5.11.200 Mechanical key interlocking (open terminal) .............................. 17
5.12 Position indication ................................................................................................17
5.13 Degrees of protection by enclosures ....................................................................18
5.14 Creepage distances .............................................................................................18
5.100 Ergonomics and access ......................................................................................18
5.110 Air Insulated bushings ...............................................................................18
5.115 Surface temperature .................................................................................18
5.116 Expected operating life..............................................................................18
5.118 Circuit identification ..................................................................................18
6.1.1 Grouping of tests .......................................................................................18
6.2.6 Tests of circuit-breakers of Ur ≤ 245 kV ..................................................19
6.2.8 Artificial pollution tests ..............................................................................19
6.2.9 Partial discharge tests ..............................................................................19
6.2.100 Voltage test as a condition check .............................................................19
6.3 Radio interference voltage (r.i.v) tests ..................................................................19
6.4 Measurement of the resistance of the main circuit ............................................... 19
6.5 Temperature-rise tests .........................................................................................19
6.6 Short-time withstand current and peak withstand current tests............................. 19
6.7 Verification of the IP coding ......................................................................19
6.8 Tightness tests.....................................................................................................19
6.9 Electromagnetic compatibility tests (EMC) ...........................................................19
6.10 Additional tests on auxiliary and control circuits ...................................................19
6.11 X–Radiation test procedure for vacuum interrupters ............................................ 20
6.102.10.2.6 Tests with specified TRV ............................................................21
6.200 Solar radiation......................................................................................................22
6.206 Single phase arc durations ........................................................................22
6.207 General-purpose circuit-breakers ..............................................................22
6.208 Sound pressure measurement ..................................................................22
6.209 Breaking test with asymmetrical current ....................................................22
7. Routine tests ..................................................................................................................22
8 Guide to the selection of circuit-breakers for service ...................................................23
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 5
Figures
Figure 1 — Trip coil 1 ...........................................................................................................13
Figure 2 — Trip coil 2 ...........................................................................................................14
Figure 3 — Closing coil ........................................................................................................15
Tables
Table 1 — Rated DC time constants .......................................Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 3.1 — TRV requirements ...............................................Error! Bookmark not defined.
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 6
Foreword
This Technical Specification (TS) is published by the Energy Networks Association (ENA)
and comes into effect from date of publication. It has been prepared under the authority of
the ENA Engineering Policy and Standards Manager and has been approved for publication
by the ENA Electricity Networks and Futures Group (ENFG). The approved abbreviated title
of this engineering document is “ENA TS 41-37 Part 3”.
This document replaces and supersedes Technical Specification 41-37 Issue 1 2004.
This Technical Specification has been prepared by the Energy Networks Association.
ENA TS 41-37 is a suite of engineering documents that sets out ENA Member Company
requirements for specification of switchgear for use on 66 kV to 132 kV distribution systems.
ENA TS 41-37 is a multi-part document comprising of the following parts.
This specification should be read in conjunction with the relevant International and British
Standards, and to assist in cross-reference, the document follows the format of the major
International Standards. Where possible, the International Standards’ clause numbers have
been used preceded with the number of the relevant part of this specification.
The Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 made under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act
1974, apply to switchgear whenever manufactured, purchased or installed. Appendix 2 of the
Memorandum of guidance on the Regulations lists Standards, Codes of Practice and other
publications which contain guidance relevant to the Regulations and electrical safety.
Part 1 of the document covers all common clause requirements of switchgear, as defined.
This document covers all the additional clauses required by the ENA in order to fulfil the
requirements of ENA conformance.
Annex A, of the document is the ‘Self Certification Conformance Declaration’ sheets, Annex
B is a summary of range, technical requirements and ratings for each type of equipment for
completion by the Purchaser
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 8
1 General
The common clauses (ENA TS 41-37part1), and the requirements of International Standard
IEC 62271-100 apply except where modified by the following clauses.
1.1 Scope
This specification defines technical requirements for circuit-breakers rated at voltages within
the range 72.5 kV to 145 kV and supersedes Electricity Networks Association Technical
Specification, ENA TS 41-37 issue 1, “Switchgear for use on 66,132 kV systems” and applies
to alternating current circuit-breakers, designed for indoor or outdoor installation, cable or
overhead conductor connected, and for operation at service frequency of 50 Hz on systems
having voltages at 66 kV and up to and including 132 kV.
Equipment covered by this specification is for use on systems with the neutral point earthed
solidly, or effectively earthed through a resistor or reactor.
This specification only includes the additional clauses that apply to circuit-breakers specified
by ENA Member Companies, which are in addition to the requirements of IEC 62271-100
Standards publications
IEC 60815, Guide for the selection and dimensioning of high-voltage insulators for polluted
conditions
IEC 62271-100, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear – Part 100: Alternating current
circuit-breakers
Other publications
[N1] ENA TS 41-37 Part 1, Switchgear for use on 66 kV to 132 kV distribution systems –
Common clauses
[N2] ENA TS 98-1, Environmental classification and corrosion protection of structures, plant
and equipment
Clauses 3 to 3.7.158 inclusive of IEC 62271-100 and Clauses 3.100 to 3.106 inclusive of
ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1]. Shall apply
4 Ratings
Clause 4 of IEC 62271-100 shall apply
4.8 Rated supply voltage of closing and opening devices and of auxiliary and control
circuits (Ua)
Clauses 4.8 to 4.8.4 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply.
4.9 Rated supply frequency of closing and opening devices and of auxiliary circuits
4.10 Rated pressure of compressed gas supply for controlled pressure systems
The rated short-circuit breaking current values are equal to the rated short-time withstand
current values listed in Table 2 of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1].
4.102 Transient recovery voltage related to the rated short-circuit breaking current
Clause 4.102 to 4.102.4 inclusive of IEC 62271-100 shall apply
4.103 Rated short-circuit making current
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 11
25 kA 45 ms
31.5 kA 45 ms/120 ms
40 kA 120 ms
5.4.1 Enclosures
Sub-clauses 5.4.1.1 to 5.4.1.4 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply.
5.4.4.5.102Closing Coil
145kV Circuit Breaker Closing circuit S
SET
Q
NAND
R CLR
Q
Negative input
Circuit breaker
open
& SET
S Q 0 &
0
and
0
Remote Initiation
& R CLR
Q or
or
Time delay
Local remote
or
selector switch
&
Local initiation
Closing
&
coil
Trip system 1 DC
fail
or
Trip system 2 DC
fail
DAR
inhibit
5.5.101 Anti-pumping
In the event of a continuous close signal being maintained after a failure to latch in the closed
position, or an opening operation immediately following a closing operation, and a continuous
close signal being maintained. There shall not be repeated attempts to close the circuit-
breaker.
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 16
Manual operation of devices normally operated by motor shall only be allowed if the manual
operation is interlocked to provide the operational and safety features provide by motor
operation.
Note 1: Access points to the manual operation facility that do not comply with 5.5.105 shall be covered to prevent
access, and the securing screws such that special tools are required to gain access.
Note 2: A warning label shall be fitted to the cover of the assess point warning that manual operation is not fully
interlocked.
5.6 Stored energy operation
Sub-clauses 5.6 to 5.6.2.101 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and sub-clause 5.6 of
IEC 62271-100 and the limitations shown in sub-clause 3.5.5 above shall apply.
Sub-clauses 5.8 to 5.8.101 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply with the
following additions:-
Additionally, the local manual tripping device shall be protected by means of a padlockable
device (shrouded to avoid inadvertent operation).
Where push buttons are provided for electrical operation they shall be coloured red for
tripping and black for closing.
Sub-clauses 5.9 to 5.9.105 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and Sub-clause 5.9 of IEC
62271-100 shall apply
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 17
Sub-clauses 5.9,100 to 5.9.105 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply
5.10 Nameplates
Sub-clauses 5.10 to 5.10.105 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and Sub-clause 5.10 of
part 1 of IEC 62271-100 shall apply
Attempted removal of the key from the circuit-breaker mechanism when the circuit-breaker is
closed shall not trip the circuit-breaker. It shall not be possible to close the circuit-breaker
unless the key is inserted and secured in the interlock.
Sub-clauses 5.15 to 5.15.2 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply.
5.17 Flammability
Labels shall also be provided inside the cabinet describing the functions of the various items
of equipment and giving the relevant details of the current transformers as specified in IEC
61869-2
6 Type tests
Clause 6 of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and Clause 6 of IEC 62271-100 Amendment 2 shall
apply with the following additional sub-clauses.
Sub-clause 6.2 to 6.2.5 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply.
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 19
Sub-clause 6.2.7 to 6.2.6.2 inclusive of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall not apply.
Sub-clause 6.102 10 to 6.102.10.2.5 inclusive of IEC 62271-100 shall apply with the
following additional requirements.
Rated Current TRV peak Time t3 Time First ref Time t1 Rate of
voltage (kA) Uc (kV p) (µS) delay td voltage rise Uc/t
(kV) (µS) U1 (kVp) (kV/µs)
145 30% of 285 38 7.6 89 19.5 7.5
rating
72.5 30% of 160 32 6.4 44.5 15.3 5
rating
6.112 Special requirements for making and breaking tests on class E2 circuit-breakers
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 22
7. Routine tests
Clause 7 of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and Sub clauses 7.1 to 7.101 inclusive of IEC 62271-
100 shall apply.
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 23
11 Safety
Clause 11 of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] and Clause 11 of IEC 62271-100 shall apply.
12 Environmental aspects
Clause 12 of ENA TS 41-37 Part 1 [N1] shall apply.
ENA Technical Specification TS 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2014
Page 24
Annex A
Self Certification Conformance Declaration
CLAUSE BY CLAUSE CONFORMANCE WITH ENA TS 41-37 – PART 3 ADDITIONAL CLAUSES FOR CIRCUIT-BREAKERS
Switchgear covered by ENA TS 41-37 shall comply with the latest issues of the relevant International and British Standards. ENA TS
41-37 is intended to amplify and/or clarify the requirements of those Standards.
This check sheet identifies the clauses in ENA TS 41-37 - Part 3 and the clauses of the aforementioned Standards relevant to clauses
for circuit-breakers.
The manufacturer shall declare conformance or otherwise, clause by clause, using the following levels of conformance declaration
codes.
Conformance declaration codes* Instructions for completion
Manufacturer:
Product Reference:
Name: Signature: Date:
1 General
1.1 Scope
4 Ratings
5.5.101 Anti-pumping
5.17 Flammability
6 Type tests
6.1 General
6.101.2.1 General
6.101.3.1 General
6.101.4.1 General
6.101.6.1 General
6.101.6.2 tests
6.102.1 General
ENA Technical Specification TS 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2014
Page 34
6.102.3.1 General
6.102.9.1 General
11 Safety
12 Environmental aspects
ENA Technical Specification TS 41-37 Part 2
Issue 2 2015
Page 38
Annex B
(normative)
Anti-pumping 5.5.101
Three pole operation 5.5.104
ENA Technical Specification 41-37 Part 3
Issue 2 2015
Page 39
*Delete as appropriate
ENA Technical Specification TS 41-37 Part 2
Issue 2 2015
Page 40
Bibliography
Standards publications
For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition
of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.
IEC 60073, Basic and safety principles for man-machine interface, marking and identification
– Coding principles for indication devices and actuators
Other publications
[1] Statutory Instrument 1989 No. 635, The Electricity at Work Regulations 1989
[2] Statutory Instrument 2007 No. 320, The Construction (Design and Management)
Regulations 2007
[3] ENA TS 50-19, Specification for standard numbering for small wiring for switchgear and
transformers together with their associated relay and control panels