Asi HPHT Development Hermetic Gtfos
Asi HPHT Development Hermetic Gtfos
Asi HPHT Development Hermetic Gtfos
Fiber optic physical contacts (PC) are extensively used in land based and topside offshore
communication systems. A majority of these systems utilize epoxies to secure the fiber in the
ferrule. This method has been proven over time to be very reliable and cost effective for
utilizing fiber optics in traditional terrestrial environments. As technologies are adapted for new
offshore, subsea and downhole uses many of these technologies can be directly utilized. This
epoxy process has been adapted for capturing the fiber in the optic ferrule as well as in
maintaining pressure barriers in many subsea systems. The extended use of the epoxy
technology has been verified through some additional qualification and accelerated life testing,
specific to the new applications. As the push for reliability increases and the demand for higher
temperature and high pressure well completions are desired, these more extreme operating
conditions come too close to or exceed the capability of epoxies. Consideration of existing
epoxy technologies might not particularly suit the desired HPHT application and new
advancements are needed to have a viable solution.
This paper will present AMETEK’s experience in developing Fiber Optic Contacts and Optical
Penetrators without the use of epoxies for securing the fiber in environments in excess of 15K
PSI and 200 deg C. A review of the current concerns of the use of epoxies and how they have
been overcome in AMETEK’s development program will be discussed in detail.
Using adhesives or epoxy to create the bond and seal of the fiber optic element to its metal
housing is a very valid and viable method of providing a reliable seal and mechanical hold on the
fiber with temperatures at or below 125deg C.
The epoxy when curing shrinks to the fiber creating a mechanical hold putting a slight
compression on the fiber.
When terminating a fiber with epoxy it is critical to control the cleanliness, limit air voids and
control the epoxy expansion. These three factors are the most common reasons for a broken
fiber in a ferrule or penetrator.
When curing epoxy it is very process and product dependent to ensure the correct shrinkage rates
and proper outgassing.
There is one significant consideration to make when selecting an Epoxy for higher temperatures.
This being the Epoxy Tg or Glass Transition which will relate to its mechanical strength.
The Tg temperature is the point at which the epoxy transforms from hard and glassy to soft and
rubbery.
Epoxies designed for higher strength at higher temperatures have a Tg of 142 deg C, while
typical epoxies have a Tg of 90deg C to 120deg C.
Ensuring the stability of the fiber in its package either in an optical ferrule or feedthrough
penetrator are critical to its long-term performance optically and mechanically.
The Tg will affect the ability of the epoxy to work in differential pressure and hold the fiber in
place at high temperatures over time.
Movement of the fiber in the optical ferrule or its holder will affect the optical performance in
respect to Insertion Loss and or Back Reflection due to offset, spacing, bending or physical
breakage of the glass fiber (commonly referred to as “pistoning”).
Glass Sealing Method
Our problem was how to increase the strength of the fiber terminations at Temperatures above
125deg C.
We felt we had the necessary elements to develop and prove out a Glass Sealing method to a
fiber termination and fiber optic feedthrough (FOFT) penetrator for high temperatures, with our
experience with glass sealing techniques for electrical connectors and feedthroughs.
Our developments and testing with glass seals having an Glass Transition or Tg of 520 deg C.
giving adequate safety margins for current HPHT applications.
STRENGTH
As an engineering material, glass is unique. Two of the most significant properties that make it
so, are (1) the mechanical strength, and (2) viscosity. Glass is a brittle material but one that is
truly elastic with no plastic deformation to failure. The intrinsic strength of glass is extremely
high and certain experiments have substantiated that glass may be stressed in the order of
3,000,000 PSI before failure. However, it is difficult to achieve, in current practice, more than a
small fraction of these strengths. Measurements of the strength of glass are not true
measurements of the strength, but the weakness of the surface. It is the condition of the surface
that limits our utilization of this high strength material. The surface irregularities create stress
risers, and, as a result, surface stress variations, and by the virtue of the lack of plasticity, these
stresses are not relieved by plastic deformation and will generate a catastrophic type of failure by
virtue of a crack. In other words, it is extremely notch sensitive.
VISCOSITY
Actually, at room temperature, glass is a viscous material. At this temperature, however, the
viscosity is so high that for all practical purposes, it is considered a solid. The fantastic reduction
in viscosity between 500°C and room temperature is significant; however, the difference
between 500°C and 1500°C will be approximately 1,000,000,000,000 times as great. It should be
pointed out that glasses do not have true melting points. They simply become less viscous at
elevated temperatures, and the viscosity reduction is approximately exponential with
temperature.
THERMAL ENDURANCE
One other notable property of glass is its relatively high thermal endurance. The thermal
endurance is enhanced when under compressive stress.
ELASTICITY
For all ordinary purposes, it can be assumed that glass is perfectly elastic up to the point of
fracture. The Young's modulus of elasticity varies from 6,000,000 to 17,000,000 PSI depending
on the composition, but most commercial glasses have values between 9,000,000 and 12,000,000
PSI.
GLASS IN COMPRESSION
Glass has a very high capacity to withstand compression stresses. By virtue of inducing and
maintaining only compression stresses in the glass, the glass member can be loaded in many
ways; as long as the imposed loading does not exceed the compressive preload, the glass will
withstand the applied preload without a stress reversal and not generate tensile stresses where its
notch sensitivity would limit its usefulness.
“Compression Type” Hermetic Glass Seals
Housing material and fiber optic material thermal expansion rate much higher than that of the
glass.
Upon solidification of the seal during the manufacturing process, the housing will contract
around the glass
Applying a desirable compression stress on the glass bead
The strength of the glass-to-metal seal is reinforced mechanically as well as chemically.
Conclusion:
Glass sealing of fiber optics is a viable technological advance to increase the pressure and
temperature of fiber optic connectors and feedthrough penetrators given the higher Glass
Transition Tg temperatures. More deployment history and testing is still required, however
initial results are proving its advantage over existing epoxy technologies.
Steve Thumbeck
Cell: 401-369-4970