Legal Medicine Reviewer
Legal Medicine Reviewer
Legal Medicine Reviewer
I. INTRODUCTION:
This handout is intended to familiarize the participants with the principles of medicine as applied to law, and to correlate the same to other
scientific investigative procedures leading to the solution of crimes.
1858 – The first textbook in Legal Medicine and its practice by Dr. Rafael Genard Y Mas, who is a Spanish chief army physician was
published and is entitled “Manual deMedecina Domestica.”
1871 – Legal medicine was included in the curriculum of the college of medicine in the University of Santo Thomas.
March 31, 1876 – The “ medico titulares” which took charge of the public sanitation and medico-legal aid for the purpose of justice
was created by the King of Spain in his Royal Decree No. 188.
1894 – The “Medico Titulares of Forensic” which is about the regulation and its practice was published.
1895 – A medico-legal laboratory was established in Manila to handle medico-legal cases.
1898 – During the American regime, the Spanish Forensic Medicine System was preserved.
1901 – The provincial, insular and municipal board of health (Acts 157, 307, 308) was created by the Philippine Commission which is
about the medico-legal duties of “medico titulares” of the Spanish regime and its assignment to the health officers of the respective
areas.
1908 – Legal Medicine was taught in all medical schools in the Philippines.
1919 – The Department of Legal Medicine and Ethics of the University of the Philippines was created under Dr. Sixto de Los Angeles
as the chief.
January 10, 1922 – The Department of Legal Medicine and Ethics of the University of the Philippines with its Department head was
incorporated to the Philippine General Hospital.
March 10, 1922 – The Philippine Legislature enacted Act No. 1043 which became incorporated in the administrative code as Section
2465 and provides that the Department of Legal Medicine and Ethics of the University of the Philippines became a branch of the
Department of Justice.
December 10, 1937 – The creation of the Division of Investigation under the Department of Justice was done by the Commonwealth
Act 181 in which a medico-legal section was under the division with Dr. Gregorio T. Lantin as the head.
March 3, 1939 – The Department of Legal Medicine and Ethics of he University of the Philippines was abolished and its functions
were transferred to the medico-legal section of the Division of Investigation.
July 4, 1942 – A medico-legal section of the Manila Police Department was created under Dr. Pablo Anzures.
1945 – The Provost Marshall of the United States Army created the criminal investigation laboratory with the Medical Examiner as an
integral part under Dr. Mariano Lara as the Chief Medical Examiner.
June 28, 1945 – the Division of Investigation was reactivated under the Department of Justice.
June 19, 1947 – The Bureau of Investigation was created by the Republic Act 157. then, the Bureau of investigation was made the
National Bureau of Investigation by the Executive Order from the President of the Philippines. The medico-legal section was created
under the National Bureau of Investigation with its head Dr. Enrique V. de Los Santos.
The existence of the medico-legal division in the criminal laboratory of the G-2 of the Philippine Constabulary also occurred.
At that time, all provincial, municipal and city health officers, physicians of hospitals, health centers, asylums, penitentiaries and colonies
became the ex-officio medico-legal officers.
In remote places, the service of a “Cirujano Ministrante” or the Sanitary Inspector may perform the medico-legal work if a registered physician
is not available.
The medico-legal system adopted in a particular country depends upon the laws of such country. The ones commonly used are the Medico-
legal Office System, Medical Examiner System and the Coroner System. Some countries employed the three systems at the same time but other
countries preferred two or a certain system.
This is the medico-legal system used in the Philippines at present which is handled by a Medical Jurist or Medico-legal Officer who is a
registered physician duly qualified to practice medicine in the Philippines. The National bureau of Investigation, Manila Police Department and
the Philippine Constabulary had their own medico-legal offices with their own respective Medico-legal Officers. The Medico-Legal Officer is
the one who investigates medico-legal cases of death, physical injuries, rape and other sexual crimes. His duty is to examine the victim of
assistant, to make a report and to appear in court as expert witness when summoned by the proper authorities.
In spite of several medico-legal cases in the Philippines, the medico-legal investigation is still insufficient because of the following reasons:
In some parts of the United States, the Medical Examiner System is the preferred, although the Coroner System is still used in some states.
The Medical Examiner System is handled by the Chief Medical Examiner who is a Doctor of Medicine and appointed by the Mayor from the
classified lists compiled by the Civil Medical Examiner is on a 24-hour work with clerical staff always present.
The duty of the Medical Examiner is to investigate the cause of death especially violent death or other circumstances leading to the death of
the victim. The Medical Examiner on duty after being informed by the police officer of a certain crime that needs to be investigated will go to
the place of the crime, interview witnesses, examine the victim and then take specimens if any, for examination.
During trial, the Medical Examiner will then present his medical report to the court.
C. Coroner System
The Coroner System probably originated in England, although there are no records of its actual origin. In common law, the office of the
Coroner is a very ancient one. The name “Coroner” is probably derived from the title “Custodes Placitorum Coronne” or “Keeper of he King’s
Pleas” as mentioned in Articles of Eyre of 1194. Magna Charta (1215) refers to the coroner as “Coronator”. A report although there is evidence
that coroner existed in Australia, United States and other colonies of England.
a. Evidence – is the means, sanctioned by law, of ascertaining in a judicial preceding the truth respecting a matter of fact.
b. Forensic Medicine – is a branch of medical science which deals with application of medical knowledge to elucidate legal problems.
c. Law – Criminal Law – Civil Law – Remedial Law -
d. Legal -
e. Legal Medicine – is a branch of medicine which deals with application of medical knowledge to the purposes of law and justice.
f. Medical -
g. Medical Jurisprudence – is a branch of law which deals with the organization and regulation of the medical profession.
h. Medicine - Internal Medicine – Surgery – Pathology – Gynecology – Obstetrics –
c. Experimental
d. Documentary
Kind of Witnesses:
1. Expert witnesses - opinion of a witness regarding a question of science, art or trade, when he is skilled therein, may be received in
evidence.
2. Ordinary Witnesses - all persons who, having organs of sense, can perceives, and perceiving, can make their their perception to others.,
may be witnesses.
A. When an unknown body is found, the following should be noted by the unvestigator to facilitate idebtifcation.
1.. Place where body is found
2. Time when found
3. Cause of Death
4. Time when death occurred
5. Approximate age
6. Supposed profession
7. Description of the body
B. Points of Identification applicable to both living and dead before onset of decomposition.
1. Occupational marks
2. Race .
a. Color of skin
b. Shape of skull
c. Shape of skull .
3. Stature
4. Teeth
5. Tattoo marks
6. Weight
7. Deformities
8 Birth marks
9. Injuries leaving permanent result
10. Moles
11. Scars
12. Tribal marks
13. Sexual organ
14. Blood group
15. Fingerprints
A. DEATH – is the termination of life. It is the complete cessation of all the vital functions without possibility of resuscitation.
B. TYPES OF DEATH:
1. Brain death – death occurs when there is irreversible coma absence of electrical brain activity and complete cessation of all
the vital functions without possibility of resuscitation.
2. Cardio-Respiratory Death – death occurs when there is continues and persistent cessation of hearth action and respiration.
C. KINDS OF DEATH:
1. Somatic or Clinical Death – state of the body in which there is complete, persistent and continues cessation of the vital functions
of there brain, hearth and lungs which maintain life and health.
2. Molecular or Cellular Death – 3-5 hours later death of individual cells.
3. Apparent Death or State of Suspended Animation – not really death but merely a transient loss of consciousness or temporary
cessation of the vital functions of the body on account of disease, external stimulus, it may arise especially in hysteria, uremia,
catalepsy and electric shock.
D. SIGNS OF DEATH:
“Tache Noir de la Sclerotique - a spot which maybe oval or round triangular with the base towards the cornea and may appear in the
selera a few hours after death. (yellowish-black ) due to thin.
1. Coagulation of blood
2. Post mortem lividity
a. Hypostatic lividity- inside blodd vessels
b. Diffusion lividity - outside the blood vessels in the tissue of the
body
G. Causes of Death
1. Natural Death
2. Violent Death - a. Accident, b. Negligent, c. Infanticidal, d. Parricidal ,
e. Murder, f. Homicidal
3. Judicial Death
D. Classification of Wounds:
1. As to severity
a. Mortal wounds
b. Non-mortal wounds
3. As to manners of Inflection
a. Hit by means o9f bolo, blunt instrument, etc.
b. thrust stab
c. Tearing or stretching
d. Gunpowder explosion
e. Sliding or rubbing
5. As regards the relation of the site of the application of force and location of
injury
a. Coup injury - injury found at site of the application of force
b. Contre Coup - injury found opposite the site of the application of
force.
c. Coup Contre Coup - injury found at the site and also opposite the
application of force
d. Locus minoris resistancia - injury found both at the site or opposite
the site of the application of the force but in some areas offering least
resistance to the force applied.
e. Extensive Injury - injury involving a greater area beyond the site of
the application of force.
6. As to Regions of Organs
7. Legal Classification
a. Mutilation - intentional act of lapping or cutting of any part of the
living body
b. Serious Physical Injury - injury that will incapacitate the subject
for more than 90 days
c. Less Serious Physical Injury - Injury that will require medical
attendance for 10 days or more but not more than 30 days
d. Slight Physical Injury & Maltreatment - Injury that will
incapacitate subject and require medical attendance from 1 to 9 days
1. Forms of Abrasion
a. Linear
b. Multi-linear
c. Confluent – almost indistinguishable due to severity of
friction and roughness of the object.
d. Multiple - several abrasion noted on the body surface
of a person.
2. Types of Abrasion:
a. Scratches c. Impact or imprint abrasion
b. Grazes d. Pressure or friction
abrasion
b. Examination of clothing, stains, cuts, hairs and other foreign bodies that may be found in the scene of the crime.
c. Investigation of those persons who may be witnesses to the incident or which could give light to the case.
d. Examination of the wounding instrument.
e. Photography, sketching, or accurate description of the scene of the crime for purposes of preservation.
5. Determination whether the wounds were inflicted during life or after death:
a. Hemorrhage - more profuse when wound was inflicted during lifetime of the victim
b. Signs of inflammation - there may be swelling of the area surrounding the wound. Other vital reaction maybe present
whenever the wound was inflicted during life.
c. Signs of repair - fibrin formation, scab or scar formation conclusively show that wound was inflicted during life.
d. Retraction of the edge of the wound - Owing to the vital reaction of the skin and contractility of the muscular fibers, the
edges of the wound inflicted during life retract and cause gaping.
6. Points to consider in the determination whether the wound is homicidal, suicidal or accidental:
a. External signs and circumstances related to the position and attitude of the body when found.
b. Location of the weapon or the manner in which it is held.
c. The motive underlying the commission of the crime or the like.
d. The personal character of the deceased.
e. The possibility of the offender to have purposely changed the truth of the condition.
h. Other information:
1. Signs of struggle
2. Number and directions of wounds
3. Nature and extent of the wound
4. State of the clothing
11. Relative Position of Victim and Assailant when Injury was inflicted:
The ff. has to be considered:
a. Location of the wound in the body of the victim
b. Direction of the wound
c. Nature of the instrument used in inflicting the injury
d. Testimony of witnesses
1. Production of Combustions:
a. Bullet - Gunshot wound
b. Flame - Singeing
c. Smoke -smudging
d. Gun powder residue - tattooing
e. Grime - tattooing
2. Firearm Wounds:
a. Gunshot Wound
ENTRANCE EXIT
1. Appears to be smaller than missile owing to elasticity of 1. Always bigger than missile
tissue except contact fire.
2. Edges inverted 2. Edges averted
3. Usually ovaloid or rounded 3. Variable shape
4. Contusion collar present 4. Contusion collar absent
5. Other product of combustions when firing is near 5. Always absent
6. Paraffin test may be positive 6. Always negative
a. Contusion Collar - the wider side points to the source of the missile.
rkmfiles 2008/reviewer in Criminalistics 9
ANGELES UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
CRIMINOLOGY REVIEW CENTER
www.rkmfiles.net
b. Smudging & Tattooing - the side with more or intense deposit points to the source of the missile.
4. Determination of the probable caliber of the firearm used in the infliction - measure in centimeter of the cross diameter of the
gunshot wound fro collar to collar - the shortest is the probable caliber.
G. Shotgun Wound
d. Distance of 2 to 3 yards –
1. The wound of entrance has big central hole with rugged edges with few stray wound of entrance wound.
2. Smudging & tattooing – no longer evident
e. Distance of 4 yards – pellets may enter skin area of about 6 to 8 inches diameter although there may be a central care where
a group might have entered.
H. Death by Asphyxia – all forms of violent death which results primarily from the interference with the process of respiration or to
condition in which the supply of oxygen to the blood or tissue or both has been reduced below normal level.
1. Hanging
2. Strangulation
a. by ligature
b. manual or throtting
c. special forms of strangulation
c.1. palmer
c.2. garroting
c.3. mugging or yoking
3. Suffocation –
a. smothering – closing mouth and nostrils by solid objects
b. choking
KINDS OF VIRGINITY:
a. Moral virginity
b. Demi-virginity
c. Virgo-Inacta
d. Physical virginity
1. True physical virginity
2. False physical virginity
a. superficial – 2 to 3 days
b. extensive tear – 7 to 10 days
c. complicated – if with intervening infection will require longer to heal
b. SEXUAL CRIMES
1. rape
2. seduction : qualified - simple
3. Acts of lasciviousness
4. Abduction : forcible, consented
5. Corruption of minors
6. White slave trade
7. Adultery
8. concubinage
9. Unnatural sexual offenses
PREGNANCY – is a state of a woman who has within her body the going product of conception.
a. Legitimacy
b. Abortion
c. Infanticide
d. Concealment of birth
e. In slander or libel
4. Methods of delivery
b. Surgical Route –
* Abdominal caesarian section
* Vaginal caesarian section
* Post-mortem caesarian section
Willful killing of the fetus in the uterus, or violent expulsion of the fetus from the natural womb and which results to the death of the
fetus.
Elements:
a. The woman is pregnant
b. Abortion is intended to be committed
c. Abortion is induced by
1. The pregnant woman
2. Other person with consent of the pregnant woman
3. The presents of the woman, or either of them for the purpose of concealing her dishonor and with the
consent of the woman herself
4. Abortion practiced by a physician or midwife and dispensing of abortions, Elements:
a. The woman is pregnant
b. The physician induced or assisted in causing the abortion
c. The acts done by the physician or midwife intended to cause an abortion.
There must be intention of the physician to produce abortion and the absence of intention will not make the physician criminally liable.
C. Kinds of Abortion
1. Spontaneous or natural
2. Induced
a. therapeutic
b. criminal
INFANTICIDE – is the killing of a child less than three (3) days old.
b. By commission
PATERNITY – is the civil of the father with respect to the child begotten him.
FILIATION – is the civil status of the child in relation to its mother or father.
b. Kinds of children
1. Legitimate children (proper) – born in lawful wedlock or within 300 days after the dissolution of marriage.
Presumption of Legitimacy – children born after 180 days following the celebration of marriage, and before 300 days following its
dissolutions or the separation of the spouses shall be presumed to be legitimate.
Against their presumption no evidence shall be admitted other than that of the physical impossibility of the husband’s having access to
his wife within the 180 days of the 300 which preceded the birth of the child.
2. Legitimate Children
Legitimation – is defined as a remedy or process by which a child born out of lawful wedlock and are therefore considered
illegitimate are by fiction of law considered by subsequent valid marriage of the parents.
Natural children are those born outside lawful of parents who, at the time of the conception of the former were not disqualified by any
impediment to marry each other.
C. Adopted Children
ADOPTION – is defined the act or proceeding by which of paternity and filiation are recognized as legally existing between persons not so
related by nature.
2. Illegitimate Children
A. Natural Children
3. Natural children by presumption - are those natural children acknowledge the father or the mother separately if the acknowledging parent
was legally competent to contact marriage at the time of conception.
b. Spurious Children
Illegitimate who are not natural are considered spurious children may be:
ARTIFICIAL INSEMINATION – is the introduction of seminal fluid with spermatozoa in the generative of a woman by any means of
springe, pipette, irrigator, etc.
1. Medical Evidences
a. Parental likeness
b. Blood grouping
2. Non-Medical Evidences:
IMPOTENCY – is the physical incapacity of either sex to allow or grant to the other legitimate sexual gratification.
b. Cause of impotency
1. General or functional, unconnected directly with the sexual organs:
* age
* Illness
* Emotion
* Hormonal dysfunction
2. Local or organic, in direct connection with the sexual organs:
* Congenital defects
a. In males
* Non-development of the penis
* Mal development of the penis
* Penis adherent to the scrotum
* Duplex organ
b. In females
* Absence of vagina
* Vagina ill-developed
*Vagina occluded by intra-uterine disease
* Disease of Accident
a. In males
*Penis
- acute disease of the penis as gonorrhea
- chronic disease of the penis as epithelioma
- complete amputation of the penis
*Testes
- removal of the testes
- sexual abuse
b. In the females
- Vaginal laceration
- Disease of the vulvae
- Obstruction of the vaginal canal due to tumor cyst or fibroid
STERILITY – is the loss of power procreation and is absolutely independent of whether or not impotency is present. A man or a woman maybe
sterile and yet impotent impotent yet not sterile.
b. Acquired conditions:
1. in the male
o Complete amputation of the penis
o Excision of the testicle
o Diseases of the testicle
o Atrophy of the testicle
2. in the female
o Excision of the ovary
o Diseases of the ovary
o Occlusion of the vagina from the diseases
o Diseases of the vagina
o Occlusion of the fallopian tubes