05 ETCS Industry Resolution Guide
05 ETCS Industry Resolution Guide
Version: 1.0
Version Control
Issue Date Comments
1 01 February 2018 First Issue
Contents Page
1) INTRODUCTION 3
2) PURPOSE 3
3) SCOPE 3
4) PROCESS 3
5) ETCS SCENARIO TABLES 5
6) ATO SCENARIOS TABLE 8
7) PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM 9
8) ABBREVIATIONS 10
9) GLOSSARY OF TERMS 11
ETCS failure modes within this document have been determined through analysis of historic faults
and failure data from the Cambrian trials, and cross-checked against the planned operational modes
for Thameslink operation.
Thameslink also introduces Automatic Train Operation to UK heavy rail for the first time, and ATO
failure modes have been extrapolated from the planned operational mode for the Thameslink
operations.
2) Purpose
The purpose of this guide is to assist Industry Delay Resolution staff in gaining an accurate
understanding of the cause of reported ETCS and ATO faults and failures that lead to delays and
cancellations associated with operating using those operational systems.
This guide supplements, but is not incorporated into, the Delay Attribution Principles and Rules
(DAPR).
3) Scope
This document is applicable to the reporting and recording of faults and operational failures of the
ETCS or ATO systems. For any GSM-R related issues please refer to the GSM-R IRG.
This IRG provides supplementary guidance to that provided in Section G3 of the DAPR.
4) Process
This document will be continually reviewed and updated as new failure modes are identified
through live operation or are identified through new or amended system capabilities.
All such circumstances, as and when identified, should be advised to the Delay Attribution Board for
review, consideration and inclusion in subsequent versions of this document.
Input from train operators’ fleet and/or operations staff and Network Rail’s maintainers and
operations staff may be required to conclude the cause of individual incidents raised in TRUST or
CCIL. To support this, Driver reports / TRUST reports will need to be sufficiently detailed to enable
further investigation to take place and conclusions made as to cause.
This guide contains various tables to assist in identifying the cause of failures and allocating the
correct delay cause code:-
1) The ‘Scenario’ column covers the various overarching events that may occur in relation to
ETCS / ATO operation. These scenarios should be used as the first point of investigation.
2) The ‘Signaller Incident Report’ column sets out the what the Signaller / Controller is likely to
report as an ‘Event’ and which is required to be reported to aid further investigations
Communications issue:
* Loss of coverage.
* Message transmission delay. GSM-R IRG J0 NR E4.01
* Lineside GSM-R / FTN equipment fault.
Unexpected brake application: * GSM-R turned off.
Any known location coverage issues.
* emergency brake application and train transitioned to TR mode &
Any known location interference issues. RBC & JRU / OTMR downloads. On-board GSM-R equipment fault. M0 TOC / FOC E4.02
loses MA; or
Loss of GSM-R Data Connection. Train stops at, or short of, EoA. Any planned GSM-R outages. Telecoms Engineering Centre investigation.
* service brake application & MA shortened to current position.
T&V national value in RBC. DRACAS investigation.
(Depends on operations and system set-up.) GSM-R interference beyond the extent that can be
"Communication error" message on DMI. accommodated by radios compliant to the latest version of ETSI J0 NR E4.03
TS 102 933-1-2
1
ETCS and ATO IRG January 2018 Page 5
ETCS TABLE 2
Wrong route set by signaller. No opportunity for driver to challenge wrong route. OF NR E7.01
Unexpected brake application. Line-side system version fitted.
Unknown Incompatibility between Line-side version.
Train transitioned to TR mode. On-board system version fitted. Wrong stock allocated to diagram (train presented with onboard As per DAPR for stock diagram errors -performance issues from not
line-side & on-board system MA revoked. On-board version. MS / TA TOC / FOC E7.02
Train loses MA. (If on-board system version is lower than line-side system version it causes not upgraded) upgrading
versions. Fleet diagram.
"Trackside not compatible" message on DMI. this problem).
Network change error/omission/failure to notify operators or
Error in project planning for upgrades / system design. IM NR E7.03
uncommunicated supplier fixes resulting in the above.
MA revoked. Unexpected brake application. Train in SH or SR mode prior to trip. Driver error (didn't press 'over ride'). FI/TS TOC / FOC E9.01
Train transitioned to TR mode. Detail of balise list which was sent (balises on list and recipient train). RBC & JRU / OTMR downloads.
Stop Order Received. Error with balise list:
MA revoked. Train loses MA. Detail of balise layout at the affected location. DRACAS investigation.
"SH stop order" message on DMI OR "SR stop order" message on DMI. Information in balises is correct. * wrong information. System fault IM NR E9.02
Balise list sent (or not).
* sent to wrong train.
Line-side GSM-R / FTN equipment fault.
Failure to transition ETCS level.
Level transition areas. Balise failure. System/Infrastructure/Software fault IM NR E10.01
Failure message on DMI.
Failure to Complete ETCS Level Location of train at time of incident. RBC & JRU / OTMR downloads. RBC failure.
MA not extended (depending on application). Unexpected brake application (depending upon operation).
Transition Know coverage issue hotspots. DRACAS investigation. On-board ETCS equipment fault:
Train may or may not receive MA into L2 area (depending upon
Issue on approach to overlay or no signals area. * Balise not read. Train fault M2 TOC / FOC E10.02
operation).
* GSM-R equipment fault.
Lineside GSM-R / FTN equipment fault
System/Infrastructure/Software fault JR NR E11.01
Driver cannot connect to RBC upon start of mission. RBC failure.
DMI may display lost connection icon. On-board GSM-R equipment fault.
Train fault/Driver error M0 / TS / FI TOC / FOC E11.02
Driver error.
Communication failure (loss of coverage).
Driver loses connnection to the RBC during journey. As per DAPR /
RBC failure. Refer to relevant section of the DAPR / GSM-R IRG NR E11.03
DMI may display lost connection icon. GSM-R IRG
Power supply failure / blip.
SIM card configuration details & allocation to train / NR GSM-R network
Base ETCS SIM card configuration is incorrect ETCS SIM card configuration specifier (usually NR) NR E11.04
configuration
On board configuration / RBC configuration ETCS cryptographic keys issued by NR were not valid NR error JR NR E11.11
Train is not within MA area (incorrect data in RBC). Error with programming RBC data JR NR E14.01
Unexpected brake application. Location of train.
Train Attempts RBC Connection or
Train transitioned to TR mode. Signalling design - train begins connection to RBC and then continues down a RBC & JRU / OTMR downloads.
Handover outside of expected MA revoked.
Train loses MA. non-fitted route. Incorrect RBC details entered into the train / by balise, DRACAS investigation.
Area.
"No track description" message on DMI. resulting in a call out of area.
Wrong RBC selected Driver/operator manually entering RBC number does so incorrectly. TS / FI / M2 TOC/FOC E14.02
DMI visibility issues (too bright, too dark). M2 TOC / FOC E15.01
Other Miscellaneous Equipment JRU / OTMR downloads.
None Audible alarm issues (too loud, too quiet). Cab-equipment standards & settings. Train fault M2 TOC / FOC E15.02
Issues DRACAS investigation.
Erratic DMI behaviour (speedo, odometry, planning area etc.) M2 TOC / FOC E15.03
Train running at permitted speed, but still lost time Insufficient SRT/TT allowance. To train planning code QA / QM NR E16.02
More onerous supervision Reason for degraded running - causal event As per DAPR NR / TOC / FOC E16.07
System slow to update MA. GSM-R system slow to respond. To GSM-R code. J0 NR E16.08
Level NTC train following ETCS train through ETCS L2 section (can't make use
TRUST time loss in running report. Cause of train running in Level NTC Causal Event NR / TOC / FOC E16.09
of virtual blocks so delay occurs). Attribute to reason train was running in level NTC
DRACAS investigation.
ETCS train following Level NTC train through ETCS Level 2 section (catches up Train Planning Values in affected area.
Cause of train running in Level NTC Causal Event NR / TOC / FOC E16.10
train and delayed).
Sectional running time performance (consistently over-achieving SRT). Incorrect TT allowance. To train planning code. QA / QM NR E17.01
Train booked to run in front of this train has been Early Running Principles / Train Planning Code (if booked)
Driver unaware of any issues Sectional running time performance (one-off) RBC & JRU / OTDR downloads. OF / QM NR E17.02
Train presents early causing removed/late/cancelled Unplanned / Planned
Train faster than expected through section. DRACAS investigation.
regulation decision to be required. Speedometer/odometry fault, causing train to under-report its
Sectional running time performance (consistently over-achieving SRT). Train Planning Values in affected area. Train fault M2 TOC/FOC E17.03
own speed
FI / TS /
Driver put train into TR mode - overriding ETCS and going faster than planned
Driver put train into TR mode Driver error/decision To reason for train being put into TR mode Causal TOC / FOC E17.04
speed
incident
EoA shortened to protected affected area.
Application of Proceed On-Sight
Observes lineside POSA aspect. Reactionary delay.
Authority for Right Side Train Sent POSA authority. Track circuit / axle counter failure. J3 NR E18.01
Train transitions from FS to OS. Track circuit / axle counter failure.
Detection Failure.
ATO reverts to manual.
As per primary cause of incident requiring diversion As per primary cause of diversion Causal Event As per primary cause E19.01
QA / QM / QN
ETCS not available on unit NR E19.05
/ OF
Other identified cause As per identified cause As per DAPR identified cause E19.06
Time lost in running (train does not operates in ATO) Train drops out of ATO ATO behaves erratically JRU / OTMR etc. download Driver takes manual control owing to ATO system fault various (on board fault / infrastructure fault) IM / JR / M2 NR / TOC / FOC A2.01
Driver error (must take manual control in advance of ATO border) Driver / TOC FI / TS TOC / FOC A6.01
Minor delay Train stopped Train brought to a stand at ATO border Check logs, check signal aspect / movement authority
System fault (onboard / trackside /comms) Per fault M2 / IM / J0 / JR NR / TOC / FOC A6.02
Delay as a result of
an ATO / ETCS
related issue
No
No No
M2
Has a train borne
software issue been Yes
identified?
No M2
No
Is it a driver
Yes FI / TS
error?
No
Is it a Network Rail
Yes OF
Ops staff error?
No
Further investigation
required
bote 2: When both parties agree that an investigation has been concluded, and no cause has
been identified, the incidents will be coded to betwork wail responsibility.
bote 3:Cor DSa-w related issues affecting ATh or ET/S operation please refer to the DSa-w
LwD
Abbr. Meaning
Term Meaning
Adhesion Refers to rail-head conditions. Where weather conditions (e.g. ice, rain) or rail
head contamination (e.g. leaves) result in reduced friction at the wheel/rail
interface, trains wheels may slip on the rail, resulting in faster acceleration /
slower deceleration than planned. Adhesion settings in ETCS and ATO can
amend the acceleration / braking profiles to be used by the train in the event of
poor adhesion.
Causal Event The event that caused the primary delay
Control Centre A Network Rail role with duties for the management and maintenance of
Technical signalling equipment within control centres.
Co-operative Describes the shortening of the distance ahead a train is authorised to travel. In
Movement co-operative shortening, the RBC proposes a new End of Authority at a location
Authority closer to the train than the current End of Authority. The on board equipment
shortening checks if the train can be stopped without a brake intervention by the revised
location. If that is possible the new End of Authority will be accepted by the
ERTMS on board equipment. If it is not possible the request will be rejected and
the previous Movement Authority remains valid.
Emergency Stop An instruction issued by the Radio Block Centre to a train or to trains
Order commanding them to perform an emergency stop.
End of Authority The End of Authority marks the limit of the train's authority to proceed along a
(EoA) line of route, broadly analogous to a 'red' aspect signal in conventional signalling.
ETCS Level NTC, 1, Descriptions of the type of ETCS technology deployed in a particular area. Under
2, 3 Level 1, movement authority information is typically only provided from trackside
to train through balises in fixed locations on the track. Train detection
/separation is undertaken using fixed blocks. Under Level 2, movement authority
information is typically provided over the air via GSM-R radio, and train detection
/ separation is undertaken using fixed blocks. Under Level 3, movement authority
information is typically provided over the air via GSM-R radio, and train detection
/separation is undertaken dynamically using train position.
Level NTC describes trains operating in accordance with prevailing national train
protection systems (e.g. AWS & TPWS), where this is processed through the ETCS
on-board.
Full Supervision Mode within ETCS. Gives full protection against overspeed and overrun.
mode
Movement The authority provided by the signalling system permitting a train to proceed to a
Authority (MA) given location along the trackside.
National Values Configurable values within ETCS that can be customised for a particular ETCS
deployment, for operational or safety reasons. These describe, for example,
maximum permitted speeds or distances to travel in particular ETCS modes for a
given ETCS deployment.
On Sight mode Mode within ETCS. Provides the driver partial responsibility for the safe control
of the train. In this mode the train possesses a movement authority but the track
ahead might be occupied by another train.
Overlay An area of line which has both ETCS and conventional signalling fitted, over which
train in ETCS would use ETCS, trains which are not fitted with, or have failed to
transition into ETCS, use conventional train protection systems.
Revocation The cancellation of a previous instruction. For example, revocation of a
movement authority cancels the previous granting of a movement authority.
Revocation of a movement authority could take place:
• In a safety critical situations where a train must be stopped as quickly as
possible, e.g. if a wrong route has been set or due to an external event on track.
• To make new routeing arrangements - e.g. to run a train ahead of another at a
junction.
• As a result of a system failure
Shunting mode Mode within ETCS designed for shunting movements. Provides limited protection
against overspeed and overrun.
Staff Responsible Mode within ETCS. Allows a driver to take full responsibility for the movement of
mode a train in an equipped area. ETCS will impose a speed limit in this mode.
Supervised In ETCS, the track location beyond the End of Authority which the train protection
Location (SvL) functions of ETCS will act to minimise the risk of a train passing. Broadly
analagous to a signalling overlap in conventional signalling.
System National Equivalent to level NTC.
mode
system version The Version of ETCS being deployed. Versions describe the specification to which
the ETCS system (trackside/train) has been designed, and are determined and
published by the European Rail Agency.
T_NVCONTACT The maximum time a train is permitted to continue travelling without receiving
updated safety-related data from the RBC. Determined by National Values, and
designed to protect the movement of trains in the event of communications
failure.
T2 Describes a line blockage
T3 Describes a possession of a running line for engineering work
Telecoms The centre from which the GSM-R network is monitored and managed.
Engineering Centre
train category Type of train (passenger / freight etc.)
Trip Mode The mode of ETCS when a train has passed its End of Authority (equivalent of
passing a signal at danger). Causes the emergency brake to be applied and
special arrangements are required before the train can move off again.