Unit 3
Unit 3
Work to remember:
Activity 4:
Say why you chose design 1 instead of design 2 or 3 (The folding method is
better than the others)
Materials:
Based on all the considered materials, Medium carbon steel is chosen
because it meets all the correct requirements to help the product reach it’s
8-year life cycle. This material is much more suitable than the original
material (Low carbon steel)
Low carbon steel bends easily under load and has low strength
Medium carbon steel can be heat treated to increase strength
Having some ductility (ability to stretch/flex) for Medium carbon steel is
useful as the table will not instantly fracture under high load
Manufacturing:
In order to manufacture the portable table, several processes must be
followed. Firstly...
Once manufacturing has taken place, the components can be treated...
(galvanising)
The bolts and fittings can be heat treated, this will increase durability and
strength
In conclusion, by using effective manufacturing methods, and by treating
components after production, a portable table with an appropriate life cycle
can be produced.
Sustainability:
In order to create a sustainable product, the environment should be
considered
The impact of mining and processing steel should be assessed, as steel
produces harmful greenhouse gasses. From this assessment more
sustainable steel production methods can be considered and evaluated
One environmental advantage of this product is recyclability
As it is made from steel, after the product life cycle is over, it can be melted
down and reused. This reduces the need for steel to be mined in the future.
Safety:
When manufacturing any product, safety is crucial
Firstly, the correct safety regulations should be followed during production.
An example of this would be the 1974 Health And Safety At Work Act
Along with this, the product itself must be safe for use. This means no sharp
edges
Must not collapse if being used properly
In order to make sure the product is used safely, the customer should be
provided with the appropriate assembly and safety documentation.
Activity 5:
In conclusion, the redesign solves many issues from the original design
Firstly, the new design allows for the table to be portable and easily movable
from one location to another.
Secondly, the new modified material choices result in the table being strong,
durable and being able to meet the intended 8-year life cycle expectancy
In addition, the folding mechanism along with the bolts used for pivots allow
for the table to be quickly assembled and disassembled. This is extremely
effective for the transportation of the the portable table
Besides the benefits, the redesigned solution also has some constraints.
Firstly, the design may not have as much strength as other alternative
materials
Secondly, the legs for the table had to be reduced in order to be foldable.
This may not be the strongest option, however it reduces the height of the
table resulting in easier transportation
In conclusion, despite these drawbacks I believe the redesigned portable
table effectively fixes the problem with the original design, and would meet
the required life cycle
Things to research:
Sheer stress/strain
Turning milling and drilling
Steels and aluminium and others below
Polymers and plastics I can use for the clips/holders
Casting for the clips maybe???
Remember to look for anything like risks e.g. high voltage-electrocution
Toughness hardness brittleness and others
Anodising galvanising and painted finishes – how long will it last till it wears
away – friction resistant
Corrosion resistance
Activity 2 – specification e.g. has to be able to withstand 5kg weight
Say if it meets or does not meet the specifications
If it doesn't, say ill add this/focus on this in the next design
Die casting and other manufacturing processes – accuracy and other factors
M6, M8, M10 bolts are standard and easy to source – can be make or buy
decision
Welding for joining supports to legs
Mechanically attached:
Socket screw caps
Nuts and bolts
Machine screws
Product - Car
Market pull (a need or a want) - a car is a need and a want. It is a need because it is
needed for people to transport to work efficiently and reduces risk of not arriving on
time. It is also a want because it provides ease of access to the user whilst being able to
carry more than one user such as passengers.
Technology push - Sir Clive Sinclair was a well-known entrepreneur most known for his
work in consumer electronics in the late 1970s and early 1980s. He invented an
electronic car known as the Sinclair C5. Elon Musk is a famous for being CEO of a well
profitable brand, Tesla and SpaceX. Elon invented an electric car that is comfortable and
futuristic which grabs the attention of customers.
Demand - The electric car market is growing quickly, with nearly 260,000 pure-electric
cars on UK roads at the end of May 2021, and more than 535,000 plug-in models if
including plug-in hybrids. There is also a high demand of electric cars because of how
environmentally friendly they are
Profitability - By 2025 20% of all new cars sold globally will be electric
Innovation / Competitives - Tesla is fighting off competition from legacy manufacturers
such as Ford, Volkswagen, and General Motors as well as new entrants that include
China-based companies including NIO and XPeng. The automotive industry is shifting
towards electric vehicles (EV) at a frantic pace therefore creating more competition.
Sustainability - Cars such as Tesla use sustainable energy as they are battery powered.
They also are recyclable and reusable when charged
Performance issues - Some issues related to electrical cars include limited driving range,
high costs, battery issues, and a spotty charging infrastructure are the main challenges
for battery electric vehicles. In addition, there are issues with various power
semiconductors and other devices
Design out risk - Some risks involved in an electric car include the risk of the Lithium-ion
battery is combustible and can catch fires, also it has power cells that can cause short-
circuiting if it is damaged.
Physical security – guards and lanyards for workers so no unauthorized person enters the
manufacturing process.
Property – m
Intellectual property definition- refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions; literary
and artistic works; designs; and symbols, names and images used in commerce.
Copyright© - Copyright denotes the legal owner of an item, whose permission is
required to use that item in any recognizable form.
Trademark™ - As the name implies, a “Trademark” is a logo or a company name that is
uniquely distinctive.
Designs Registration® - No one can copy a unique design.
Patents - Technology registration. (PATENTS DONT LAST FOREVER).
Licenses - Licensing involves obtaining permission from a company (licensor) to
manufacture and sell one or more of its products within a defined market area.
Design Compromises:
Need to be compromises between different aspects within a design
Quantity of products that can be manufactured in the time available to have them ready
Size vs weight
Aesthetics vs safety requirements
Design compromises for Tesla:
Tesla made their car fully electrical but the compromise is that it takes long to charge. Cyper
truck doesn't look very appealing but the design forces the car to be more safe. Tesla also
added batteries to the chassis as it was too big to place at the back of the vehicle, similarly the
battery was is placed underneath the car to help with the distribution of the weight which
results is better overall handling. Tesla is also fitted with many cameras to see blind spots
which helps the driver to park more easily. Model 3 has flat door handles to help with
aerodynamics so the car can drive smoothly. Tesla has butterfly doors for ease of access for
the driver to get in the car. Tesla has auto pilot so the car can drive on its own safely which
gives the driver ease of access.
Form vs Function:
Form: Shape, Colour, Size, Aesthetics, Feel/Texture, Sound (artistic side of a product) (e.g. Car)
Function: Job of the product/how it works (e.g. Rocket and computer components)
Resilience to environmental factors (damp, heat, cold)
Material strength
Safety
Ergonomics – ensuring that humans can interact with, and use the product easily
Accessibility for maintenance
WRITE A ½ SIDE ABOUT THE BALLANCE BETWEEN FORM VS FUNCTION OF TESLA
CONSIDER OBSOLESCENCE
As an overall product Tesla is pretty much a complete car with minor setbacks with a good
aesthetic, nice colour selection, good size body, and a luxury feel and texture of the car in
certain places, it also has a quiet sound as it is electric which does not make noise which is
calming to the driver. Similarly the Tesla is also a fully well-functioning car as it does the job of
transporting the driver with efficiency and is strong which is good for safety, the tesla also has
an AC and heater to match the needs of the driver and the current environment, also being
waterproof. The driver is also able to interact with the car via the screen and the buttons for
the AC and the heater. Tesla also is able to be maintained very well as the battery is
replaceable and reusable so it’s functions can be used more than once. Tesla’s back two
butterfly doors do not match the front two normal doors which can be a bad aesthetic but it
functions well as it allows the driver to get out the car when parked in a tight spot.
Features vs Benefits:
Benefit: what is the benefit you get from the feature
High demand is for the Benefits
Upgrading to prevent Obsolescence
Feature: a physical thing
PRODUCT: Car
FEATURE: ABS (anti-lock braking system)
BENEFIT: The car will stop quicker and under more control
INTRODUCTION STAGE
GROWTH
MATURITY
DECLINE
IN YOUR PRODUCT REPORT, LIST POTENTIAL ORIGINAL CUSTOMER FOR THE DESIGN/
REDESIGN
For a Tesla, the customer would most likely be a rich person or an environmentally friendly
customer who is looking for a more sustainable car that has a high-performance rate and is
reliable with no addition to global warming. Also other customers attracted to the unique
build of the Tesla.
Market Research-
Surveys- ask people to answer questions about your product
focus groups – get potential buyers and talk to them about the product
Mood boards/mind maps/Brainstorming- (coggle on google)
Analyse the competition – Dismantle/tear down the competition to find out how they work
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Graphs:
Discrete data is like shoe size e.g., 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5...
Continuous data Is like noise of an engine e.g., 1.2345, 1.2456
Graph lines:
Histogram
Positive skew/ negative skew – lines with a tail
Symmetrical distribution – bell curve
Mode: Most common number
Mean: Add up all the values divided by the number of values
Median: List the data lowest to highest and find the middle value
Range: Highest take away the lowest
Variance: Work out the mean, then for each number: subtract the mean and square the result
Standard deviation: the square root of the variance
Cumulative Frequency: A cumulative frequency curve can be useful to show how many tests
reach a certain level
24.5 25.2 26.2 27.2 28.2 28.9 29 29.5 30 30.4 30.9 31.1 31.7 32.1 32.3 32.5 32.9 33.8
34.3 34.7 34.8 35 36.4 36.5 37.4 38.2 39.2
Mode:
Mean: 32.02143
Median: 32.2
Range: 14.7
Variance: 14.13883
Standard:
Cumulative Frequency
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Design a safe, Ergonomic key holder for car ignition.
It will be produced in batches of 50,000.
Use of materials is important in relationship to recycling and production methods.
You are required to produce 3 sketches, with distinctly different features.
A final design will be chosen with reasons stated drawings/sketches to be isometric on
A3 paper, with annotations.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ergonomics & Anthropometrics – designed to fit the user/ease of use
5th percentile & 95th percentile – the people who are not an interest for a product
arthrometric distribution.
5th percentile = 0.05 x number of data sets (discount the lowest two values)
95th percentile = 0.95 x number of data sets (discount the highest two values)
Engineering Materials:
What sort of materials do you need?
What happens if you choose the wrong materials?
Properties of materials:
What is strength? - Definition: the quality or state of being physically strong. the capacity of
an object or substance to withstand great force or pressure.
Engineering discipline concerned with the ability of a material to resist mechanical forces
when in use. A material's strength in a given application depends on many factors, including its
resistance to deformation and cracking, and it often depends on the shape of the member
being designed.
AN EXAMPLE OF A STRONG MATERIAL IS...
Properties of materials:
1) Electrical conductivity – How easily electricity can pass through an object
2) Thermal conductivity – How easily heat can pass through an object
3) Elasticity - The ability of a material to bend or stretch, then returning to it’s original shape
or size
4) Plasticity - The ability of a material to permanently change it’s shape (does not bend back to
original shape)
5) Ductility – The ability for a material to deform under tension in all directions without
cracking (ability to stretch)
6) Malleability – The ability of a material to deform in compression in all directions without
cracking (ability to shape)
7) Strength - The ability of a material to withstand tensile or compressive force without
breaking
8) Stiffness – The ability of a material to resist bending when a load is applied
9) Hardness - The ability of a material to resist surface scratching and indentation
10) Toughness - The ability of materials to withstand impact or sudden shocks without
breaking (impact resistance)
11) Durability – The ability of material to withstand repeated rubbing
12) Corrosion resistance
13) Density - mass per unit volume
Polymers (plastics)
Ceramics
Composites
Natural materials
Smart materials
Types of joining:
Welding - Continuous/spot
Soldering
Rivets
Adhesives
Brazing
Nuts and bolts - Nut, washers and bolt. Machine screws
Self-tapping screws
Polymers (plastics)
Thermoplastic polymers – If you heat it up it softens, and you can remould it (can be
recycled). No strong chemical bond between the long molecules.
High-density polyethene (HDPE): plumbing pipes, hard hats, bottles
Expanded polystyrene: packing and insulation
High impact polystyrene(HIPS): vacuum forming
Acrylic(poly(methyl methacrylate): visually attractive, hard-wearing consumer products
Polypropelyne
Thermosetting polymers – cannot be recycled. An irreversible chemical reaction bonds the
long molecules together. Heating cannot break the bond.
Urea-formaldehyde – electrical fittings
Epoxy resin – used in adhesives and in some glass reinforced composites
Medium density polyurethane
Elastomers:
synthetic rubber – rubber bands
Neoprene – wet suits
Lycra in clothing
Polycarbonates:
Water bottles for commercial water stations; cheap reading glasses and layers in bullet proof
glass (things with good transparency/good optical properties)
Casting: sheets of thermoplastics
Injection moulding: Hot liquid thermoplastic or thermoset is injected into Mould and rapidly
cooled (chilled).
Blow Moulding
Vacuum forming
Extrusion
3D printing – thermoplastic feed stock – mainly ABS (Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene), PLA
(Polylactic acid), but many others.
Compression Moulding – Thermoset powder is added to Mould and cured by application of
heat and pressure. Complex shapes can be formed.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Topics:
Levers and linkages
Belts and pulleys
Chains and sprockets
Gears
Bearings and cams
Lubrication
Electrical power
Mechatronics
There are four types of motion which are used to transfer power:
Rotary – bicycle wheel
Reciprocating - piston
Oscillating - clock
Linear – locomotive
Mechanical power is transferred from one place to another by different types of linkages using
the four types of motion. Linkages may increase or decrease the force through mechanical
advantage.
Lever:
There are three classes of lever:
- Class 1 –> see saw
- Class 2 –> wheel barrow
- Class 3 –> fishing rod
Load & effort move in oscillating motion
Depending on the location of the effort and load, levers may amplify or reduce forces
Picture 1- class 2
Picture 2- class 3
Picture 3- class 1
Picture 4- class 1
Picture 5- class 1
Picture 6- class 2
Picture 7- class 2
Picture 8- class 2
Picture 9- class 2
Picture 10- class 3
Picture 11- class 1
Lever equations --> balance across a lever:
Effort x distance of effort from fulcrum = load x of load from fulcrum
Mechanical advantage:
Load/effort = distance of effort from fulcrum/ distance of load from fulcrum =
distance moved by effort/distance moved by load
Levers in a skeleton:
Fulcrum – Toes (Joint)
Load – The bodyweight
Effort – Achillies
Lever problems:
1. Bobby’s maximum effort is 75N at distance 3.5m from fulcrum. The load will be
positioned is 1.9m from fulcrum. What is the greatest load that Bobby can raise?
Compound levers:
These use the load from one lever to become the effort in the lever in a series of
interconnected levers
Linkages:
A linkage can:
Transfer force from one place to another
Change the direction of motion
Increase or decrease the force
Convert the type of motion (rotary, linear, reciprocating, oscillating)
o A linkage is an assembly of parts to direct force and movement to where it is needed
o A linkage can convert the type of motion (rotary, linear, reciprocating, oscillating)
(Piston linkage, peg and slot, bell crank)
Shafts:
Move by rotary motion - attached to pulleys
pulleys:
What is the difference in the rotational speed (RPM) for different sized pulleys attached
to the same shaft?
All pulleys attached to the same shaft rotate at the same rotational speed (RPM) as the
shaft
A cross in the belt will result in the driven pulley and the driver pulley rotating in
opposite directions.
Belts and pulleys:
Driver pulley is powered, usually by an electric motor
Both pulleys rotate in the same direction
Quiter than a chain/sprocket drive
Not much grip and low belt strength so only for low-applications (vacuum cleaners,
washing machine, pillar drill)
Increased grip by using V-shaped belt and grooved pulley (increased contact surface
area), or using toothed belt e.g. in car cam belts
Must keep tension correct in critical applications as belt stretch with use and may slip or
jump off the pulley – use belt tensioners
o Maths behind belts and pulleys: Mechanical advantage (a.k.a. gear ratio) = diameter of
driven pulley/diameter of driver pulley
Lubricants:
Oils, greases, solids, metal cutting fluids, cutting compound
Viscosity – how thick or runny it is. the state of being thick, sticky, and semi-fluid in
consistency, due to internal friction.
Pneumatics component:
SAC - (Single Acting Cylinder)
DAC - (Dual Acting Cylinder)
- Stroke – distance from the smallest the push rod pushes out and also the biggest the
push rod pushes out
- Outstroke
- instroke
Lubrication:
Oils, greases, solids, metal cutting fluids and cutting compounds
Lubricants reduce wear resistance between 2 objects and reduces friction and also
reduce temperature and also reduce temperature
Main properties of lubricants:
Wear resistance
Viscosity
Temperature tolerance
Oils: rating
W = usually uses for winter
The higher the number the higher the viscosity
Mineral oil – more natural based oil
Semi-synthetic oil
synthetic oil – man-made oil and most expensive
Equipment health monitoring (EHM)
Analyse the deposits in oil to work out how much an engine has worn out, and which
components are wearing out
Electrical Power:
Hand crank
Probably rotational motion from an engine/motor
Steam engine
Internal combustion engine
Gas-turbine engine
Electrical motor
Mains electricity
- What is the “energy mix” of mains electricity
- i.e. how is mains electricity generated?
Fossil fuel alternatives:
Biofuels: a renewable energy source, made from specially-grown organic matter or from
wastes – can help reduce carbon dioxide emissions.
Nuclear energy: advantages include long term power from small fuel source
Generators:
- Stand by emergency power e.g. in hospitals (up to 40,000 watts)
Renewable energy:
Solar panel, Wind turbine, Hydroelectric
Direct sources of electrical power:
Thermoelectric generator (TEG) - a solid state
Clockwork - a hand wound clockwork mechanism drives a small electrical generator
which then powers the radio
Piezoelectric material - Power generation from flexing of clothing
Storage of electrical power:
Conventional batteries
Large-scale battery arrays
Every-day batteries: lead acid
Victorian technology
Why are they still used:
- Low cost
- Rechargeable
- Heavy, but has a relatively large power-to-weight ratio; able to supply high surge
Every-day batteries: Zinc-Carbon
Every-day batteries: Alkaline
Every-day batteries: Rechargeable
Every-day batteries: Li-lon
Mechatronics:
Mechatronics is a branch of engineering that focuses on both electronic and mechanical
systems, controlled by a microprocessor
Input --> micro controller --> output
Outputs: motion
- Solenoid
- DC motor (not too accurate)
- Servo motor (more accurate)
- Stepper motor
- Brushless motor
- Piezo actuator
Actuators: worm gear boxes for use which DC motor actuators to produce smooth
controllable movement (not too accurate)
Sometimes mechatronic systems have no input sensors, but most mechatronic systems
have sensors to enable input of information about the surroundings
Passive (e.g. microphone) vs active (receives and outputs)
Digital (yes or no measurement) vs analogue (variety of answers i.e. temperature in a
room)
LDR – light dependent resistor (analogue and passive)
LIDAR – Light detection and ranging (analogue and active)
PIR – passive Infared sensor (digital)
Machine vision:
Machine vision deals with the ability of mechatronics systems to see, and interpret
information from, visible and IR/UV
Automated solutions:
Manufacturing and processing industries: automation
The feature: humans coexisting with robots-cobots
Haptics:
Detecting and creating the sense of touch
- Input and output
- Pressure sensors
When making 500 chairs the seat can be vacuum formed and cut down with saws and sanded
down.