Setting and Testing A Two-Terminal SEL-311L PDF
Setting and Testing A Two-Terminal SEL-311L PDF
INTRODUCTION
The SEL-311L Line Current Differential System is a digital line current differential relay with an
integrated communications interface. The SEL-311L-1,-7 Instruction Manual, available at
http://www.selinc.com, demonstrates how to set and test an application consisting of two
SEL-311L Relays protecting a line when each relay receives current from a current transformer
(CT) with the same CT ratio (CTR). However, when the CTRs do not match, setting and testing
the application are more complex. This application guide explains the issues that arise during this
type of scenario, as well as how to compensate for them in settings and testing procedures.
1200:5 2000:5
5 secondary A 3 secondary A
87L Tx 87L
ILeft IRight
Tx
Fiber Optics
IChannelX_Left = Rx IChannelX_Right =
3 secondary A Rx 5 secondary A
CTR = 240 CTR = 400
CTR_X = 400 CTR_X = 240
The differential element processing in the SEL-311L works as shown in Figure 2, which is a
simplified diagram of the differential element figures found in Section 3 of the SEL-311L-1,-7
Instruction Manual. The SEL-311L is capable of processing up to three terminals; however, a
two-terminal application is demonstrated in this application guide for simplicity.
Y • InL
Y • InX
Y • InL
Y • I nLocal Y • InL Y • InR
Y • InR
Y • I nChannelX
Figure 2 Phase, Negative-Sequence, and Ground Differential Element Processing for Channel X
To obtain primary currents, the local current is multiplied by the CTR, while the Channel X
current is multiplied by CTR_X. Then each of these currents is divided by the maximum CTR, or
CTRmax, to obtain the local and remote secondary currents referenced to CTRmax. The addition
of these two currents is the difference current.
The SEL-311L compares the difference level current 87LmP settings (where m = P for A-, B-, or
C-phase, 2 for negative-sequence, or G for zero-sequence differential) with the absolute value of
the difference current in secondary amperes. The comparison allows the relay to decide to assert
or deassert the various differential operate 87LOPk elements (where k = A for A-phase, B for
B-phase, C for C-phase, 2 for negative-sequence, or G for zero-sequence differential).
Event reports and meter displays report the primary values for the currents. The 87LmP settings
are in secondary amperes, referenced to CTRmax.
The local and remote currents used in the differential element processing for each relay are
calculated using (1) and (2).
Y • InLocal • CTR
Y • InL (1)
CTRmax
Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X
Y • InR (2)
CTRmax
where:
InL local n current in secondary amperes, referenced to the maximum CTR.
InLocal n current injected at the local relay.
CTR = CTR for the local relay.
InR remote n current in secondary amperes, referenced to the maximum CTR.
InChannelX n current injected at the remote relay.
CTR_X = CTR for the remote relay.
CTRmax = maximum CTR (i.e., the larger of CTR or CTR_X).
where:
InL Pr imary I nLocal • CTR local n current in primary amperes.
InR Pr imary I nChannelX • CTR _ X remote n current in primary amperes.
Y • InL Pr imary Y • InR Pr imary difference current.
The logic shown in Figure 2 is affected by the 3PO (three-pole open) Relay Word bit. The 3PO
bit is supervised by the APP and OPO settings, the positive-sequence voltage, the phase currents,
and the 52A breaker status, as shown in Figure 4. When 3PO asserts, the 87LPP setting value
doubles and the 87L2P and 87LGP values triple. The 52A setting is set to 0 in Table 1 for
simplicity during testing. If 52A is left at the default value of IN101 and IN101 is asserted during
testing, Scenario 2 (when one of the breakers is open) can be affected.
APP = 87LSP
Relay
OPO = 27 Word
27PO Bits
+ 0
(Setting)
3PO
V1 –
3POD
OPO = 52
52A
50LP –
(Setting)
Ia +
–
50L
Ib +
Ic +
1200:5 2000:5
87L 87L
Step 1
Apply the following currents:
Left relay: IA = 0.26 ∠0° A, IB = 0 A, and IC = 0 A.
Right relay: IA = 0.26 ∠0° A, IB = 0 A, and IC = 0 A.
Step 2
Increase the magnitude of IA in the left relay at 0 degrees until 87LOPk asserts (where k = A, 2,
or G). Use the human-machine interface (HMI) in ACSELERATOR QuickSet® SEL-5030 Software
or the TAR 87LOPk command to observe when 87LOPk asserts.
Step 3
Record the left A-phase current that asserts 87LOPk.
Step 4
Ensure that the recorded left current is equal to its expected value [see (5b) and (5e)] using (4b).
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (4a)
Y • InLocal
87LmP • CTRmax Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X
(4b)
CTR
Equations (5a) and (5b) use (4b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the left
relay) that asserts 87LOPA in both relays. Assume that 87LPP is equal to the default value of 6.
IaLocal
6 • 400 0.26 • 400 9.5667 A (5a)
240
IaLocal 9.5667 A (5b)
Equations (5c) through (5e) use (4b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
left relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in both relays. Assume that 87L2P and 87LGP are
equal to the default value of 0.5.
3I 2Local
0.5 • 400 0.26 • 400 0.4 A (5c)
240
3I 2Local 0.4 A (5d)
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaLocal 0.4 A (5e)
Step 5
Return the magnitude of IA in the left relay to 0.26 ∠0° A.
Step 6
Increase the magnitude of IA in the right relay at 0 degrees until 87LOPk asserts (where k = A, 2,
or G). Use the HMI or the TAR 87LOPk target command to observe 87LOPk assert.
Step 7
Record the right A-phase current that asserts 87LOPk.
Step 8
Ensure that the recorded right current is equal to its expected value [see (6b) and (6e)] using (4b).
Equations (6a) and (6b) use (4b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the right
relay) that asserts 87LOPA in both relays.
IaChannelX
6 • 400 0.26 • 240 5.844 A (6a)
400
IaChannelX 5.844 A (6b)
Equations (6c) through (6e) use (4b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
right relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in both relays.
3I 2ChannelX
0.5 • 400 0.26 • 240 0.344 A (6c)
400
3I 2ChannelX 0.344 A (6d)
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaChannelX 0.344 A (6e)
Table 2 shows the values required to assert 87LOPk in Scenario 1. Table 2 is divided to show
when the current is increased in each relay separately. The left side of Table 2 shows the results
of Steps 1 through 4 and the right side shows the results of Steps 5 through 8. In this scenario, the
87LOPk operate elements in both the left and the right relay assert at the same time.
The results in Table 2 demonstrate that when the current in the left relay (smallest CTR) is
increased, a greater amount of secondary current is required. When the current is increased in the
left relay, 87LOPA asserts in both relays when the current reaches 9.5667 A. When the current is
increased in the right relay, 87LOPA asserts in both relays when the current reaches 5.844 A.
This happens because the difference current (in secondary amperes) is referenced to CTRmax but
the left relay local current is calculated using its CTR (240), which is smaller than CTRmax
(400).
Note that whether the current is increased from the left side or from the right side, the amount of
phase difference current in primary amperes required to assert 87LOPA, 87LOPB, or 87LOPC in
both relays is 6 • 400 = 2,400 A. Also, the amount of negative-sequence or zero-sequence
difference current required to assert 87LOP2 or 87LOPG is 0.5 • 400 = 200 A [see (3)].
Case 1
In Case 1, the secondary current is injected only into the left relay (see Figure 6).
Left Bus Right Bus
62.4 A
Open
1200:5 2000:5
0.26 0 A
87L 87L
Step 1
Apply the following currents:
Left relay: IA = 0.26 ∠0° A, IB = 0 A, and IC = 0 A.
Right relay: IA = IB = IC = 0 A.
Step 2
Increase the magnitude of IA in the left relay at 0 degrees until 87LOPk asserts (where k = A, 2,
or G). Use the HMI or the TAR 87LOPk command to observe 87LOPk assert.
Step 3
Record the left A-phase current that asserts 87LOPk.
Step 4
Ensure that the recorded left current is equal to its expected value using (7c) and (7f).
Each relay processes the logic shown in Figure 2 independently, and Steps 1 through 4 must be
performed for each relay separately. Equations (7a) through (7c) simplify the logic processed by
the left relay (notice that InChannelX = 0). Equations (7d) through (7f) simplify the logic processed
by the right relay (notice that InLocal = 0). Both InLocal [in (7a) through (7c)] and InChannelX [in (7d)
through (7f)] refer to the current injected in the left relay.
The left relay logic follows.
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (7a)
Because InChannelX 0:
Y • InLocal • CTR 0 87LmP • CTRmax (7b)
Y • InLocal
87LmP • CTRmax (7c)
CTR
The right relay logic follows.
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (7d)
Because InLocal 0:
0 Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (7e)
87LmP • CTRmax
Y • InChannelX (7f)
CTR _ X
Equations (8a) and (8b) use (7c) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the left
relay) that asserts 87LOPA in the left relay.
IaLocal
6 • 400 10 A (8a)
240
IaLocal 10 A (8b)
Equations (8c) and (8d) use (7c) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the left
relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in the left relay.
3I 2Local
0.5 • 400 0.833 A (8c)
240
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaLocal 0.833 A (8d)
Equations (9a) and (9b) use (7f) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the left
relay) that asserts 87LOPA in the right relay. No current is injected into the right relay, and
therefore, 3PO is asserted (see Figure 4), and 87LPP doubles (from 6 to 12).
IaChannelX
12 • 400 20 A (9a)
240
IaChannelX 20 A (9b)
Equations (9c) and (9d) use (7f) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the left
relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in the right relay. No current is injected into the right
relay, and therefore, 3PO is asserted (see Figure 4), and 87L2P and 87LGP triple (from 0.5 to
1.5).
3I 2ChannelX
1.5 • 400 2.5 A (9c)
240
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaChannelX 2.5 A (9d)
Table 3 shows the values required to assert 87LOPk in Case 1. Because no current is injected into
the right relay, 3PO in the right relay is asserted. Therefore, the right relay 87LmP settings are
larger (as shown in Table 4), and more current is needed to assert its 87LOPk elements.
Table 3 Minimum Injected Current Values Required to Assert 87LOPk in Scenario 2, Case 1
(Current Injected Into the Left Relay)
Left Relay Assert Values Right Relay Assert Values
Left Relay Right Relay Left Relay Right Relay
87LOPA 10 A 0 20 A 0
87LOP2 0.8333 A 0 2.5 A 0
87LOPG 0.8333 A 0 2.5 A 0
Case 2
In Case 2, the secondary current is injected only into the right relay (see Figure 7).
0.26 0 A
Step 1
Apply the following currents:
Left relay: IA = IB = IC = 0 A.
Right relay: IA = 0.26 ∠0° A, IB = 0 A, and IC = 0 A.
Step 2
Increase the magnitude of IA in the right relay at 0 degrees until 87LOPk asserts (where k = A, 2,
or G). Use the HMI or the TAR 87LOPk command to observe 87LOPk assert.
Step 3
Record the right A-phase current that asserts 87LOPk.
Step 4
Ensure that the recorded right current is equal to its expected value using (10c) and (10f).
Each relay processes the logic shown in Figure 2 independently, and Steps 1 through 4 must be
performed for each relay separately. Equations (10a) through (10c) simplify the logic processed
by the right relay (notice that InChannelX = 0). Equations (10d) through (10f) simplify the logic
processed by the left relay (notice that InLocal = 0). Both InLocal [in (10a) through (10c)] and
InChannelX [in (10d) through (10f)] refer to the current injected in the right relay.
The right relay logic follows.
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (10a)
Because InChannelX 0:
Y • InLocal • CTR 0 87LmP • CTRmax (10b)
Y • InLocal
87LmP • CTRmax (10c)
CTR
The left relay logic follows.
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (10d)
Because InLocal 0:
87LmP • CTRmax
Y • InChannelX (10f)
CTR _ X
Equations (11a) and (11b) use (10f) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
right relay) that asserts 87LOPA in the left relay. No current is injected into the left relay, and
therefore, 3PO is asserted (see Figure 4), and 87LPP doubles (from 6 to 12).
12 • 400
IaChannelX A (11a)
400
IaChannelX 12 A (11b)
Equations (11c) and (11d) use (10f) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
right relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in the left relay. No current is injected into the left
relay, and therefore, 3PO is asserted (see Figure 4), and 87L2P and 87LGP triple (from 0.5 to
1.5).
3I 2ChannelX
1.5 • 400 1.5 A (11c)
400
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaChannelX 1.5 A (11d)
Equations (12a) and (12b) use (10c) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
right relay) that asserts 87LOPA in the right relay.
6 • 400
IaLocal 6 A (12a)
400
IaLocal 6 A (12b)
Equations (12c) and (12d) use (10c) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the
right relay) that asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG in the right relay.
0.5 • 400
3I 2Local 0.5 A (12c)
400
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaLocal 0.5 A (12d)
Table 5 shows the values required to assert 87LOPk in Case 2. Because no current is injected into
the left relay, 3PO in the left relay is asserted. Therefore, the left relay 87LmP settings are larger
(as shown in Table 6), and more current is needed to assert its 87LOPk elements.
Table 5 Minimum Injected Current Values Required to Assert 87LOPk in Scenario 2, Case 2
(Current Injected Into the Right Relay)
Left Relay Assert Values Right Relay Assert Values
Left Relay Right Relay Left Relay Right Relay
87LOPA 0 12 A 0 6A
87LOP2 0 1.5 A 0 0.5 A
87LOPG 0 1.5 A 0 0.5 A
The results obtained in both Case 1 and Case 2 demonstrate that the relay with the open breaker
(no current injected) requires twice as much phase current and three times more negative- and
zero-sequence current injected than the opposite relay to assert its 87LOPk elements.
Step 1
Set Channel X in test mode using the TST X command. Select N when prompted to disable 87L
communications and E when selecting loopback mode. Choose a test mode duration time.
Step 2
Apply the following currents:
Left relay: IA = 0.26 ∠0° A, IB = 0 A, and IC = 0 A.
Because the fiber-optic Tx and Rx channels are interconnected, the currents at the local
and remote channels are the same.
Step 3
Increase the magnitude of IA in the relay at 0 degrees until 87LOPk asserts. Use the HMI or the
TAR 87LOPk command to observe 87LOPk assert.
Step 4
Record the left A-phase current that asserts 87LOPk.
Step 5
Ensure that the current is within the expected range using (13a) and (13b).
Y • InLocal • CTR Y • InChannelX • CTR _ X 87LmP • CTRmax (13a)
Because InLocal InChannelX :
Y • InLocal
87LmP • CTRmax
(13b)
CTR CTR _ X
Equation (14a) uses (13b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the relay) that
asserts 87LOPA.
IaLocal
6 • 400 3.75 A (14a)
240 400
Equation (14b) uses (13b) to calculate the minimum A-phase current (injected into the relay) that
asserts 87LOP2 and 87LOPG.
3I 2Local
0.5 • 400 0.3125 A (14b)
240 400
Because Ib = Ic = 0 and 3I0 = 3I2 = Ia:
IaLocal 0.3125 A (14c)
Table 7 shows the values required to assert 87LOPk in Scenario 3. If the test is repeated on the
right relay, the same current values are required because the difference current is identical.
CONCLUSION
The following are important points when testing line current differential on a two-relay
application with different CTRs:
When current is injected into both relays, the relay with the smallest CTR (the left relay
in this example) requires a greater amount of injected (local or remote) secondary current
to assert its 87LOPk elements compared with the other relay. However, the same primary
difference current is required to assert 87LOPk in both relays.
When current is injected into one relay (with an open remote breaker), the remote relay
requires twice as much local phase current and three times more local negative- and zero-
sequence current for its 87LOPk elements to assert. Also, the relay with the smallest CTR
(the left relay in this example) requires a greater amount of injected current to assert its
87LOPk elements compared with the other relay.
When current is injected into one relay in loopback mode, the test values simulate an
internal fault with identical local and remote currents.
The SEL-311L has many other functions besides line current differential testing, such as distance
and directional protection. However, in this application guide, we only demonstrate the proper
testing of the line current differential capability under different scenarios.
FACTORY ASSISTANCE
We appreciate your interest in SEL products and services. If you have questions or comments,
please contact us at:
Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.
2350 NE Hopkins Court
Pullman, WA 99163-5603 USA
Telephone: +1.509.332.1890
Fax: +1.509.332.7990
www.selinc.com • [email protected]