menu

 PID TUNING

 APC

 APPLICATIONS

 INCATOOLS
 BLOG
  CASES

 CONTACT

Boiler Steam Drum Level Control Strategies

 Share

Steam drum is a vital part of boiler system in chemical industries. Proper and
safe functioning of boiler depends on various parameters such as level of
steam drum, flow of feedwater and flow of steam. The pressure, temperature
and level of boiler system cannot be regulated directly but depends on the
feed-water flow. The pressure or temperature in a boiler system can be
maintained by controlling the flow of fuel and air whereas the level can be
maintained by regulating the flow of feed water. The purpose of drum level
controller is to keep the level at desired value, optimal interface level requires
between steam and water within the steam drum. It is essential that the level
of liquid must be low enough to assure that there is appropriate separation
between steam and water and high enough to guarantee that the water exists
in every steam generating tube. 
 
In this blog we will show the 3 most common drum level control schemes and
what tuning strategy you should adopt for every strategy.
 
Components of Steam Drum Level Control

There are various components that affect the level of steam drum:
 The bubbles exist under the interface level between steam and water
into the steam drum due to boiling of water.
 The increased/decreased volume of steam bubbles leads to the
variations in water level that result in the phenomenon of ‘false water
level’.
 steam drum pressure. The contraction or expansion of steam bubbles
depend on the variations in steam drum pressure due to changes in
the steam demand.
The design of the boiler drum level control strategy is normally described as: 
 1. Single-element
2. Two-element
3. Three-element control

1. Single Element Drum Level Control

The first design: Single Element Drum level Control' is explained below

Scheme

Single element drum level control is the easiest strategy suitable for small boilers that have low
and moderate variations in load/disturbances. In this approach, the level is being measured that
helps in controlling the flow of feed water to maintain the steam drum level. Due increase or
decrease in demand of steam, phenomenon like swelling & shrinking occur in steam drum
which makes boiler operation tedious. The drawback of this approach is that level of steam
drum is affected by uncontrolled feed water and steam disturbances.

PID tuning strategy 

From a controls point-of-view, the boiler drum is an integrating process. This means that any
mismatch between inflow (water) and outflow (steam) will cause a continuous change in the
drum level. Integrating loops are difficult to tune and can easily become unstable if the
controller’s integral time is set too short (i.e., high integral gain). The process-imposed
requirement for a long integral time makes the loop slow to recover from disturbances to the
drum level.
Addition to above, the boiler drum level is notorious for its inverse response. If the drum level is
low, and more feedwater is added to increase it, the drum level tends to decrease first before
increasing. This is because the cooler feedwater causes some of the steam in the evaporator to
condense, causing the volume of water/steam to decrease, and hence the drop in drum level.
Conventional feedback control has difficulty in coping with this inverse response. A control loop
using high controller gain and derivative action may work well in other level applications, but it
will quickly go unstable on a boiler drum level. Stability is best achieved by using a low controller
gain, long integral time, and no derivative. However, these settings make the controller’s
response very sluggish and not suitable for controlling a process as critical as boiler drum level.

Drum level is affected by changes in feedwater and steam flow rate. But because of the very
slow response of the feedback control loop, changes in feed flow or steam flow can cause very
large deviations in boiler drum level. Single-element drum level control can work well only if the
residence time of the drum is very large to accommodate the large deviations, but this is seldom
the case – especially in the power industry. For this reason, the control strategy is normally
expanded to also include feedwater and steam flow.

LEARN MORE — PID TUNING

2. Two Element Drum Level Control

Two element drum level control strategy is effective for the boilers with moderate variations in
load. In double element level controlling the swelling and shrinking effect of boiler drum is taken
care. Pressure of the drum varies according to steam flow. if load increases and drum pressure
drops. In two element controller this effect is compensated by measuring steam flow along with
drum level. Steam flow will give incorrect feedback if it is not compensated suitably according to
stem pressure and temperature. Flow of steam has direct relationship with pressure and
temperature. So, in most of the causes measurement of steam flow is compensated by pressure
and temperature. The drawback of this strategy is that the disturbances due to steam drum
pressure and variations in load cannot be adjusted in feed water supply as this variable is not
measured in this control strategy.

PID tuning strategy

Many boilers have two or three feed pumps that will be switched on or off depending on boiler
load. If a feed pump is started up or shut down, the total feedwater flow rate changes. This
causes a deviation in drum level, upon which the drum level controller will act and change the
feedwater control valve position to compensate. As explained above, the level controller’s
response is likely very slow, so switching feed pumps on and off can result in large deviations in
drum level.
A faster control action is needed for dealing with changes in feedwater flow rate. This faster
action is obtained by controlling the feedwater flow rate itself, in addition to the drum level. To
control both drum level and feedwater flow rate, cascade control is used. The drum level
controller becomes the primary controller, and its output drives the set point of the feedwater
flow controller, the secondary control loop.

3. Three Element Drum Level Control

A three-element boiler water level control system is one which typically uses the measured
water level, the steam flowrate from the boiler, and the water flowrate into the boiler to regulate
the flow of water into the boiler. It is a most common boiler drum level control strategy and
effective to use three element drum level control so that shrinking and swelling effects can be
taken care of. Figure 2.3 shows the control scheme of three element drum level control. The
shrink and swell introduce the phenomenon of false water level that leads to the measurement
of three parameters including drum water level, feed water flow and steam flow.

With the addition of feed water flow and steam flow measurement in the control system, one can
easily determine any major discrepancy between the two and take the control action to maintain
the water level. The same results can be attained by using two element control, but there are
some disadvantages of two element control such as it cannot change for the load disturbances
take place in feed water supply. Secondly, the phasing interaction between the drum level and
feed water flow cannot be eliminated by the two-element control.

Thus, to deal with these issues, three element steam drum level control is used in which a third
variable feed water flow rate is added which is used to manipulate the feed water control valve.
The output of two element drum level controller is cascaded with feed water flow controller. The
steam flow act as the set point to the feed water controller and feed water flow is used as the
process variable. Thus, amount of steam leaving the drum results in the addition of equal
quantity of feed water to the drum. The three-element drum level control strategy is effective for
rapid variations in load because it can easily handle the balance between feed water flow and
steam flow.

PID tuning strategy

Like feed flow, changes in steam flow can also cause large deviations in drum level and could
possibly trip the boiler. Changes in steam flow rate are measurable and this measurement can
be used to improve level control very successfully by using a feedforward control strategy.
For the feedforward control strategy, steam flow rate is measured and used as the set point of
the feedwater flow controller. In this way the feedwater flow rate is adjusted to match the steam
flow. Changes in steam flow rate will almost immediately be counteracted by similar changes in
feedwater flow rate. To ensure that deviations in drum level are also used for control, the output
of the drum level controller is added to the feedforward from steam flow.

It is a tedious & critical job to tune these controllers, Manual PID tuning require a lot of time &
detail knowledge of loop interaction. PID tunning tools (Like Aptitune) makes it easy to tune
these loops. One of the examples explained below.

The above figuree explains the three-element control scheme where IPCOS has tuned &
stabilized level with Aptitune software. As per control strategy drum level will be master loop &
make up water slave, steam flow act as feed forward for tuning. The figure below shows the
improvement in level with tuning.
Above all proposed schemes can be implemented easily in DCS by using the standard DCS
blocks and calculations. Other than implementing a correct control scheme, it is equally
important to tune the PID loops correctly and how it helps to stabilize drum level explain above
with example. software can calculate the right parameters; you don’t have to look at it again. In
the end, the software helps you achieve the desired result faster.

Like to get more information?

Would you like to receive more information about PID tuning software like INCATools PID
Tuner? Schedule a meeting with one of our control experts. We are happy to help you with
information tailored to your needs. Talk to an expert today!

TALK TO AN EXPERT

Or do you want to know what INCATools PID Tuning can offer you? Request your demo here.

Topics: PID tuning, PID tuning methods

Subscribe Here!

Email*
Recent Posts

 How to approach a PID tuning project in a phased way

 How to keep PID loops optimal

 How to Successfully Configure and Tune a Split Range PID Control Strategy and Not
Die Trying

 3 ways to find out more about INCATools

 Temperature Control for Batch Reactors in your industry

Posts by Tag

 PID tuning (33)
 PID tuning methods (13)
 Advanced Process Control (8)
 PID tuning parameters (7)
 Plant performance (6)

See all

IPCOS BV
Bosscheweg 135B
5282 WV Boxtel
The Netherlands
CONTACT US
Tel. +31 411 613 500
Fax. +31 411 616 710
[email protected]
Join us

o INCATools


o Blog

o Cases

o Contact


o IPCOS Shop

o Cart

o My account

Disclaimer & Cookie & Privacy Policies