Consumer Behaviour in E-Tourism
Consumer Behaviour in E-Tourism
Annette Steinbauer
Hannes Werthner
Department for Information Systems/ e-tourism
Leopold-Franzens-University, Austria
[email protected]
Abstract
During the last decades Tourism as an information intensive business has been strongly
affected by the rapid changes in technology, especially the Internet,. One of the major results is
the changing in traveller's behaviour. Therefore the challenge of identifying, attracting and
retaining customers in the online market as well as the issue of understanding consumer's
perceptions is becoming a critical success factor. The aim of this paper is to identify the
determinants that influence potential travellers to use the Internet for travel planning and to
show their interrelations. A major result of thesefindingsis a causal model of e-tourism usage.
Constructs such as Internet affinity, attitudes and self-efficacy prove to have a major impact on
the actual use of the Internet for travel planning, whereas moderating variables such as gender
or customer involvement prove to be important as well.
Keywords: e-tourism; onhne travel planning; consumer behaviour; travel websites.
1 Introduction
Travel and Tourism as one of the world's highest priority industries has an important
economic impact on the global as well as on the local level (Werthner & Klein, 1999).
Information is the crucial factor for tourists while planning, booking and being on
vacation as well as after their trips. The nature of tourism and its products makes
tourism an information intensive business (Werthner & Klein, 1999). These issues
lead to the insight that tourism belongs to the industries most affected by the rapid
changes in technology during the last decades. The role of information explains the
importance of Information Technology (IT) applications in tourism. The Internet can
be seen as one of the most influential technologies that change traveller's behaviour.
While the number of Internet users increases and is reported to have reached 957
million (IWS, 2005), the diffusion of IT has improved the travel service supply in
efficiency, quality and flexibility (Jung & Baker, 1998; Werthner & Klein, 1999).
According to these facts, the European Online Travel Market is estimated to generate
€ 41 bn in 2006, and 15-20% of all travel expenses are forecasted to be made via the
Internet in 2006 (PhoCusWright, 2004). Even though the Internet is an important tool
for information search and purchase of products, most consumers are using multiple
channels in their decision making process. 60% of online mformation searchers are
finally buying offline (Fittkau & Maass, 2005). And in the travel industry 68% of
online travel buyers are not only purchasing via the Internet, but use multiple
channels for purchasing their travel products (PhoCusWright, 2005).
66
The aim of this study is to identify the determinants that influence potential travellers
to use the Internet for travel plarming and to show their interrelationships. The result
of these findings is a causal model of e-tourism usage (e-tourism within this context is
defined as the process of potential travellers using the Internet for travel planning).
Special focus is also on differences in model structure for exclusive information
searching travellers compared to online booking travellers as well as business versus
private travellers. Based on the results from the e-Tourism Usage Model, the study is
also going to identify current barriers and problems of potential travellers in using the
Internet for travel plarming.
The paper is starting with presentmg theoretical considerations and the literature
background for developing the research model. The literature overview is followed by
the presentation of the theoretically derived "e-Tourism Usage Model". Furthermore,
the applied methodology as well as empirical results concerning the overall model
structure and the moderating effects of the e-Tourism Usage Model are introduced
and discussed.
Consumer's use of the Internet at any stage of the decision making process has
become a major subject within the consumer behaviour research during the last
decade (e-shopping acceptance). The present study will contribute to research in the
field of tourists' behaviour by looking at their behaviour while using the Intemet as
information and/or booking channel. Therefore, theories describmg the acceptance of
technology and satisfaction of consumers with using the Intemet were an interesting
subject in deriving the "Model of e-Tourism Usage". Most common theories in
explaining the acceptance of new technologies are the "Innovation Diffusion Theory"
(IDT), "Theory of Reasoned Action" (TRA), "Theory of Planned Behaviour" (TPB)
and the "Technology Acceptance Model" (TAM). The IDT describes the process of
technology acceptance by five characteristics of the technology influencing the
consimier's attitude leading to adopting or refusing the technology (Rogers, 1995).
These crucial characteristics include relative advantage, compatibility, complexity,
trialability and observability. The TRA points at the attitude as a critical constmct
towards adopting or refusing thie use of a certain technology. While individual
attitudes and subjective norms form a person's behavioural intention, an individual's
actual behaviour is the natural consequence (Fishbein & Ajzen, 1975). Introducing
perceived behavioural control as an additional determinant of behavioural intention,
the TPB was built upon the TRA (Ajzen & Madden, 1986). The most common and
most adopted theory of accepting a new technology is the TAM (Davis, 1989; Davis,
Bagozzi, & Warshaw, 1989)The TAM states attitude as the central construct
influencing the behavioural intention and thereby the actual use or non-adoption of
the technology. This theory explains a person's attitude towards using a certain
technology by three determmants: perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness and
perceived enjoyment.
Theories addressing the issue of accepting the Internet as information and/or booking
channel focus rather on the consumer's evaluation of the system than on the process
of adoption. Highly acquainted and effective in this field of research was the
"Information System Success Model" (IS Success Model) introduced by (DeLone &
McLean, 2003). The theory introduces six constructs to quantify the success of an
information system in the e-commerce environment: system quality, information
quality, service quality, usage, user's satisfaction and net benefits. Assigning these
theories to the subject of tourism a couple of highly useful empirically proved models
have been published focusing on travel website quality (Mills & Morrison, 2003;
Sigala & Sakellaridis, 2004; DeLone & McLean, 2003) and usability (Essawy, 2005;
DeLone & McLean, 2004; Kao, Louvieris, Powell-Perry, & Buhalis, 2005). Based
upon these theoretical considerations the "e-Tourism Usage Model" (eTUM) was
derived. Fig 1. shows the simplified version of the determinants hypothetically
contributing to the attitude towards using and actual use of the Internet for travel
planning.
Transactjon phases
The objective of the eTUM is to identify determinants of using the Internet for travel
planning, to elaborate the model structure as well as to quantify the effects between
the identified determinants. By showing quantitative differences in the model
structure between different types of travellers the model is contributing to identifying
problems and barriers in using the Internet for travel planning.
3 Methodology
3.1 Study Design
To validate the theoretical model described above an online questionnau-e for
potential travellers was designed. The data were collected on four different travel
websites, which were selected by their range of supply and the available transaction
phases they offer with their services. The websites should on the one hand be able to
offer all phases of the customer buying process from information gathering to buying
the travel product online. On the other hand they should represent different supply
ranges from offering only individual travel products to offering individual products as
well as complete travel packages. The Tiscover AG, Thomas Cook Touristik GmbH,
Travel Scout 24 and Nix-wie-weg.de supported the study by placing a link to the
questionnaire on their website and/or in their newsletter(s). The questionnaire was
formulated in German, so only German-speaking travellers were addressed to take
part in the study. The questioimaire was placed on the website of the Institute of
Information Systems/Department for e-Tourism at the University of Innsbruck. To
70
encourage persons who were visiting these websites, to take part in the study, travel
vouchers were promised to be raffled as incentives for participants.
3.2 Sample Characteristics
1.458 users took part in the study by filling out the online questionnaire. The gender
distribution was nearly equal. 53% of the participants were female and 47% male.
With more than one third the survey's age peak was between 41 and 50 years. Rather
surprising is that 25% of all respondents aimounced to be older than 50 years. All
groups of income were represented in the study. On average the interviewed persons
are traveling three times a year. Most of these people mainly travel for private
purpose, but there are still 21% that are doing at least a quarter of their journeys for
business reason. And 71% of these potential travellers declared to have already
booked a travel product online. The people that were interviewed while surfmg on
one of the four travel websites showed to be rather Internet affme. More than one
third has seven or more years of Internet experience and over 50% of the interviewed
persons use the Internet at least 10 hours per week. The sample was dominated by
travellers searching for information on the homepage of Tiscover. 79% of the
participants took part in the survey via Tiscover, 14% via Travel Scout 24 while
24,5% were generated by nix-wie-weg.de and 2% by Thomas Cook.
Experience 2 0.87
Involvement 2 0.62
Trust 3 0.80
Intensity 2 0.70
Usage
Loyalty 2 0.78
Cmin/df 2,164
SRMR 0,043
AGFI 0,909
CFI 0,956
RMSEA 0,047
To quantify the influences the total effects were considered. Total effects result as the
sum of direct and indirect causal effects one latent construct has on another construct.
Indirect effects are obtained if a construct influences another construct via
intermediary constructs. W hile analysing and modifying the theoretically derived
model the constructs ease of use of the website, trip features, motivation and
involvement did not prove to have any significant causal interdependencies with the
other mentioned constructs. Involvement still showed significant correlations with all
other constructs so this latent variable was later on analysed for having a moderatmg
impact on the model. The actual use of the Internet for travel plaiming is mainly
driven by the traveller's Internet-affinity (tot.eff = .40). The more someone is Internet
literate the more he is likely to use the Internet when planning a journey. Following
psychological-behavioural theories, the attitude towards using the Internet for travel-
information search plays also a major role for the actual use of e-tourism (tot.eff =
.37). The importance of someone's attitude towards performing a behaviour for the
actual behaviour has been discussed in many empkical studies and is also confirmed
in this study. Rather surprising is the finding that in this study the attitude towards
booking a travel product online does not have a direct impact on the actual use of e-
tourism (tot.eff = .09). This cognition leads to the insight that a positive attitude
towards using the Internet as an information channel is a precedent condition for the
traveller's consideration to increase his usage of the Internet as a booking channel as
well. The potential traveller's self-efficacy towards booking a travel product online is
the last of the three constructs having a direct impact on the actual use of e-tourism
(tot.eff = .23). The more a person is confident in knowing how to book a travel
73
product online the more he will consider the Internet as a useful channel for planning
the journey.
After showing its importance for the actual use of e-tourism it is interesting to look at
the determinants of someone's attitude towards using the Internet for travel planning.
The attitude towards using the Internet for travel information search is mainly driven
by someone's self-efficacy (tot.eff. = .28). Similar impact on the attitude towards
using the Internet for travel information gathering shows the attitude towards booking
as well as the evaluation of the website's usefulness (both tot.eff. = .25). The two
facets of attitude, information search and booking, are influencing each other by
showing significant positive causal correlations in between them (tot.eff. = .25/ .23).
Experience and self-efficacy towards booking online have rather little and only
indirect influence on the attitude towards information search (tot.eff. = .17/ .14).
Attitude towards booking a travel product online is mainly dependent on the self-
efficacy towards booking online (tot.eff. = .58). The potential traveller's attitude
towards booking is thus the more positive the more the person feels capable of
proceeding with the online booking transaction. Experience and self-efficacy towards
information search are also pushing the attitude towards booking a travel product
online (tot.eff. = .30/ .27). The construct of trust plays surprisingly a rather small role
within the e-tourism usage model but is having its main impact on the attitude
towards booking (tot.eff = .13). Trust itself is mainly causally influenced by
experience (tot.eff. = .42). Self-efficacy towards booking and the evaluation of the
website's usefulness are also strengthening a potential traveller's trust (tot.eff. = .28/
.32). Interesting is also the fmding that loyalty towards a travel website is mainly
driven by the self-efficacy towards the capability of booking a travel product at the
specific travel website. The more a person is confident of his own abilities to proceed
with the online booking process the rather he will be loyal and using the same website
again for the next travel planning. The more a potential traveller is using the Internet
for travel planning the less he is loyal to a specific website. This negative impact of
actual e-tourism usage on loyalty is rather minor (tot.eff. = -.07). As also shown by
the descriptive analysis the online travel brand loyalty seems to be rather low. The
large variety of travel offerings all over the World Wide Web seems to cause a rather
small emotional commitment to specific websites of travellers planning their journey
online.
seem to be far more influenced by the website's perceived usefulness than highly
involved people. Low-involved people also perceive the usefulness of the website and
ease of use significantly less positive than people with high involvement. While
highly involved people have a more positive attitude towards using the Internet for
travel planning, low-involved people show significant less trust into travel websites.
They also have less experience and seem to be less Intemet-affine than people being
highly involved in their travel plans. Recapitulating the hypotheses about the
variables gender, type of traveller, online booking experience and involvement having
moderating influences on the validated structural model could be corroborated.
While the supply of online travel information sources and booking facilities in the
Internet is permanently increasing, the issue of consumer and customer relations is
becoming even more important for tourism market players. An enhanced
understanding of the customer and his specific needs, perceptions and motives in the
decision making process is the critical success factor in providing a successful and
profitable online customer relationship. The Internet's key attraction as a marketing
tool lies in the level of interactivity that can be developed between suppliers and
75
consumers. The findings and results of this study show perceptions, motives and
barriers of online travelers. Thus, the study intends to contribute to developing
advanced effective online marketing strategies to attract tourists to use the online
channel for travel planning. The study was constructed on the assumption of
addressing only middle European and German-speaking countries. The cultural
dimension was hence excluded to be influencing in this context. Therefore the
construct of culture is recommended to be included in further analysis.
References
Ajzen, I. & Madden, T. (1986). Prediction of goal-Directed behaviour: Attitudes, Intentions,
and Perceived behavioural Control. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 22 (4),
453-474.
Bieger, T., Beritelli, P., Weinert, R., Wittmer, A. (2005). Building Trust and Identity on the
Web - New IT Transaction Platforms to Overcome Psychological Barrier to Rent. In A.
Frew (Eds.). Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2005 -
Proceedings of the International Conference in Innsbruck. Wien.
Davis, F. (1989). Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User Acceptance of
Information Technology. MIS Quarterly, 13, 319-340.
Davis, F. D., Bagozzi, R. P., Warshaw, P. R. (1989). User Acceptance of Computer
Technology: A Comparison of two Theoretical A/otfe/^.Maryland.
Delago-Ballester, E. (2003). Development and Validation of a Brand Trust Scale. International
Journal of Market Research, 45(1), 35-54.
DeLone, W. H., & McLean, E. R. (2003). The DeLone and McLean Model of Information
Systems Success: A Ten-Year Update. Journal of Management Information Systems,
19(4), 9-30.
DeLone, W. H., & McLean, E. R. (2004). Applying the DeLone&McLean Information Systems
Success Model. International Journal ojfElectronic Commerce, 9(1), 31-47.
Essawy, M. (2005). Testing the Usability of Hotel Websites: The Springboard for Customer
Relationship Building. Leeds.
Fesenmaier, D. & Jeng, J. (2000). Assessing structure in the pleasure trip planning process.
Tourism Analysis, 5, 13-27.
Fesenmaier, D., & Johnson, B. (1989). Involvement-based segmentation: implications for travel
marketing in Texas. Tourism Management, 10, 293-300.
Fesenmaier, D., Pan, B., Gretzel, U., Hwang, Y., Grabler, K., Zins, A., & Mazanec, J. (2002).
Tourist Decision Model Report. Project DieToRecs on Intelligent Recommendation for
Tourist Destination Decision Making.
Fishbein, M., & Ajzen, I. (1975). Belief Attitude, Intention and Behavior. London.
Fishbein, M., Ajzen, J. (1980). Understanding Attitudes and Predicting Social Behaviour.
London.
Freter, H. (1983). Marktsegmentierung. Stuttgart.
Frew,A. J. (Ed.) (2005). Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2005.
Proceedings of the International Conference in Innsbruck. Vienna.
Gretzel, U,, Mitsche, N., Hwang, Y.-H., Fesenmaier, D. (2004). Tell me who you are and I will
tell you where to go - Use of Travel Personalities in Destination Recommendation
Systems. Information Technology & Tourism, 7(1), 3-12.
GrSppel-Klein, A. (2001). Konsumentenverhaltensforschung. In M. Bruhn & C. Homburg
(Eds.): Gabler Marketing Lexikon. 325-328. Wiesbaden.
Gursoy, D. & McCleary, K. (2004). An Integrative Model of Tourists' Information Search
Behaviour. Annals of Tourism Research, 31(2), 353-373.
Heinemann, M. (1974). Einkaufsstdttenwahl und Firmentreue des Konsumenten. Mtlnster.
Hildebrandt, L.; Homburg, C. (1998). Die Kausalanalyse - Ein Instrument der empirischen
betriebswirtschaftlichen Forschung. Stuttgart.
Kao, Y., Louvieris, P., Powell-Perry, J., Buhalis, D. (2005). E-Satisfaction of NTO's Website
Case Study: Singapore Tourism Board's Taiwan Website. In A. Frew (Ed.) Information
and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2005 - Proceedings of the International
Conference in Innsbruck, lll-llil. Wien.
Kroeber-Riel, W. & Weinberg, P. (1996). Konsumentenverhalten. Munchen.
Kroeber-Riel, W. & Weinberg, P. (1999). Konsumentenverhalten, 7.Aufl.. Miinchen.
76