Tea Consumption and Risk of Incident Dementia: A Prospective Cohort Study of 377 592 UK Biobank Participants
Tea Consumption and Risk of Incident Dementia: A Prospective Cohort Study of 377 592 UK Biobank Participants
com/tp
ARTICLE OPEN
As a widely consumed beverage, tea boasts diverse health benefits. Herein, we aimed to investigate the association between tea
consumption and dementia risk. We conducted a prospective cohort study with 377 592 UK Biobank participants during a 9-year
follow-up. Cox regression models adjusted for age, sex, ethnicity, Townsend deprivation index, education, body mass index, lifestyle
factors, dietary factors and apolipoprotein E4 status were used to examine the association of tea consumption with dementia risk.
Subgroup analyses stratified by age, sex and forms of dementia (Alzheimer’s disease [AD] and vascular dementia [VD]) were
performed. Moreover, the restricted cubic splines were used to calculate the nonlinear relationship between daily dosage of tea
and dementia risk. After adjustment for all covariates, tea drinkers were 16% (95% confidence interval: 8–23) less likely to develop
dementia compared with non-drinkers. Moderate consumption (1–6 cups/day) of tea exerted significant protective effects.
Subgroup analyses showed that mid-aged participants or males benefited more from tea consumption. Moreover, moderate
1234567890();,:
drinkers had a 16–19% lower hazard of AD and a 25–29% lower hazard of VD. Furthermore, a U-shaped association between tea
consumption and dementia risk was shown (Pnon-linearity = 7E−04), and the consumption of around three cups per day showed the
strongest protective effect. Within 3 cups/day, drinking one extra cup of tea per day brought a 6% reduction of incidence. In
conclusion, moderate consumption of tea was significantly associated with a reduced risk of dementia, suggesting that tea
consumption could be a modifiable lifestyle factor for dementia.
1
Department of Neurology, Qingdao Municipal Hospital, Qingdao University, Qingdao, China. 2Department of Neurology and Institute of Neurology, Huashan Hospital, Shanghai
Medical College, Fudan University, Shanghai, China. 3Institute of Science and Technology for Brain-Inspired Intelligence, Fudan University, Shanghai, China. 4These authors
contributed equally: He-Ying Hu, Bang-Sheng Wu. ✉email: [email protected]; [email protected]
Fig. 1 Flowchart of participant selection. TDI Townsend deprivation index, BMI Body mass index, APOE4 apolipoprotein E4.
0.721–0.890) for 3–4 cups/day, HR = 0.859 (95% CI: 0.769–0.960) for pronounced associations were found in males, and the consump-
5–6 cups/day. However, no significant difference was found in tion of 1–6 cups/day led to a 19 to 22% reduction in dementia
dementia risk between individuals who consumed more than 6 cups incidence in the fully-adjusted model (see Supplementary Fig. 2).
of tea per day and non-drinkers, with the specific results as follows: Results from the subgroup analyses stratified by the form of
model 1, HR = 0.910 (95% CI: 0.802–1.032) for 7–8 cups/day, HR = dementia (AD/VD) were summarized in Supplementary Table 9. In
0.952 (95% CI: 0.817–1.108) for ≥9 cups/day; model 2, HR = 0.891 model 1, the consumption of 1–6 cups/day was associated with a
(95% CI: 0.766–1.037) for 7–8 cups/day, HR = 0.946 (95% CI: lower incidence of AD. In model 2, participants who consumed
0.788–1.136) for ≥9 cups/day. 1–4 cups of tea a day were 16 to 19% less likely to develop AD, but
Results of subgroup analyses stratified by age were shown in the HR for 5–6 cups/day was not significant (Fig. 3). In terms of
Supplementary Table 7. In midlife, there were significant associa- incident VD, a similar picture to ACD was seen in both adjusted
tions of tea consumption with a reduced risk of dementia in both models. Moderate consumption (1–6 cups/day) led to a 25 to 29%
two models, and the dementia incidence was approximately reduction in VD incidence (Fig. 3).
17–26% lower among individuals with tea consumption of 1–6
cups per day in the fully-adjusted model. However, this association Non-linear relationship between tea consumption and
disappeared in the late-life after controlling for all covariates (see dementia
Supplementary Fig. 1). In Fig. 4, we used restricted cubic splines to flexibly model and
Results of subgroup analyses stratified by sex were shown in visualize the association of tea-consumption with dementia. After
Supplementary Table 8. Females who consumed 3–4 cups of tea a adjusting for all the covariates, the risk of incident dementia
day were less likely to develop dementia in both two models (HR = substantially decreased until it reached bottom at around 3 cups/
0.800 [95% CI: 0.687–0.933] in the fully-adjusted model). More day, and increased thereafter (P for non-linearity = 7E−04). Within
3 cups/day, the HR for dementia was 0.943 (95% CI: 0.907–0.981) consumption of 2 to 3 cups per day (AD: P for non-linearity =
per cup increase, indicating an approximately 6% reduced risk for 0.046, Supplementary Fig. 5A; VD: P for non-linearity = 0.019,
one extra cup a day. Supplementary Fig. 5B).
A similar U-shaped relationship was observed in midlife, and the
risk of dementia reached bottom at around 3 cups of tea per day Sensitivity analyses
(P for non-linearity = 8E−04, Supplementary Fig. 3A). We didn’t When we restricted participants to those with a follow-up time of
observe any nonlinear relationship in the late-life (see Supple- ≥4 years (n = 355 114), the HRs were similar to the main results in
mentary Fig. 3B). The non-linear relationships were observed in both of the adjusted models (see Supplementary Table 10).
both females and males. The largest reduction of dementia Sensitivity analyses after excluding dementia cases that occurred
incidence was associated with intake of around 3 cups per day for within the first 1 year follow-up (n = 57) to control the reverse
females (P for non-linearity = 0.006, Supplementary Fig. 4A) and causality showed that the HRs were of similar magnitude to the
intakes of 3–6 cups per day for males (P for non-linearity = 0.022, main results (see Supplementary Table 11). Exclusion of partici-
Supplementary Fig. 4B). Furthermore, the U-shaped associations of pants who had a history of stroke at baseline (n = 11 643) also did
tea-consumption with AD and VD were shown, and the largest not change these associations significantly (see Supplementary
reductions in both incidences were associated with tea Table 12).
Fig. 2 Association between tea consumption and the risk of incident dementia. In both adjusted models, tea consumption was associated
with a reduced risk of dementia (model 1: HR = 0.819 [95% CI:0.760-0.884]; model 2: HR = 0.841 [95% CI: 0.767–0.921]). Moderate consumption
(1–6 cups/day) of tea exerted significant protective effects. P values were computed by Cox proportional hazard regression. Model 1 was
adjusted for age, sex and ethnicity. Model 2 was adjusted for age, sex, ethnicity, TDI, education, BMI, typical sleep duration, smoking status,
alcohol status, total consumption of vegetables, total consumption of fruit, total consumption of fish and APOE4 status. HR Hazard ratios, CI
Confidence interval, TDI Townsend deprivation index, BMI Body mass index, APOE4, apolipoprotein E4.
DISCUSSION from the small sample size (81 AD cases among 1836 individuals)
Leveraging data from 377 592 individuals from the UKB, this study and excessive category combination. By the way, although
investigated the association between tea consumption and inconsistent results were shown regarding coffee intake, most of
dementia over the 9-year follow-up. Our results showed that the studies showed a reduction for the risk of dementia [33–35]. It
moderate drinkers (1–6 cups/day) were less likely to develop ACD, should be noted that tea and coffee shared some molecules (e.g.,
AD, and VD after adjustment for covariates. Another major finding polyphenols and caffeine) which are considered to reduce
was the U-shaped association of tea consumption with dementia dementia risk. Compared with previous researches, this cohort
risk, and the optimal intake was around 3 cups per day. These study used a larger sample of non-demented older adults.
findings suggested tea to be a modifiable lifestyle factor for Sufficient cases of ACD, AD and VD were observed during a long
dementia prevention. follow-up time. Our study focused on the dosage-dependent
Previous studies yielded inconsistent results. A study among associations of tea consumption with ACD, AD and VD, obtaining
9375 Chinese older adults showed that participants who nonlinear relationships between daily dosage and dementia
consumed <2 cups/day, 2–4 cups/day, and ≥4 cups/day were incidences. Compared to Zhang et al.’s, our study considered
less likely to have cognitive impairment compared with non- APOE4 status as a covariate in the full-adjusted model and focused
drinkers, which supported our findings; however, the design was on AD in addition to VD. The age range of the total participants
cross-sectional and the reference selection was different from our (≥45 years old) was larger in this study, and the effect modification
analyses [14]. A longitudinal study among 1305 older adults also by age or sex was observed in subgroup analyses. When
found that tea consumption could reduce the risk of cognitive calculating the relationships between categories of tea consump-
decline compared with non-consumption over 5.3 years of follow- tion and dementia risk, we used more specific category
up [32]. The Ohsaki Cohort Study among 13,645 Japanese found combinations, and thus the dosage-dependent relationships were
that green tea consumption was associated with a lower risk of more convinced and were in accordance with the results of non-
incident dementia over 5.7 years of follow-up, which was linear analyses. Besides, we performed a great deal of sensitivity
consistent with our major finding [26]. In addition, Zhang et al. analyses to examine the stability of results.
conducted a large-scale cohort study and found that tea Although the mechanisms underlying the associations between
consumption was associated with lower risks of dementia as well tea consumption and dementia are unclear, some possibilities
as VD [29]. However, with tea consumption at low frequency (≤1 may explain these findings. Firstly, oxidative stress was suggested
times per week) as the reference, a longitudinal study found no to be involved in the pathogenesis of both AD and VD [36]. Recent
significant association of frequent tea consumption (≥3 times per vivo and vitro studies have focused on the antioxidant effects of
week) with AD [28]. The insignificant association probably resulted tea biomolecules [37, 38]. For example, EGCG could chelate the
Fig. 3 Associations of tea consumption with risks of AD and VD in the fully-adjusted model. After adjusting for all covariates, participants
who consumed 1–4 cups of tea a day were 16–19% less likely to develop AD compared with non-drinkers. Besides, the tea consumption of
1–6 cups/day brought a 25 to 29% reduction in VD incidence. P values were computed by Cox proportional hazard regressions. Covariates
included age, sex, ethnicity, TDI, education, BMI, typical sleep duration, smoking status, alcohol status, total consumption of vegetables, total
consumption of fruit, total consumption of fish and APOE4 status. HR Hazard ratios, CI Confidence interval, AD Alzheimer disease, VD Vascular
dementia, TDI Townsend deprivation index, BMI Body mass index, APOE4 apolipoprotein E4.
bivalent metal-ions and prevent oxidation resulting from reactive could cross the blood-brain barrier to reach the brain parenchyma
hydroxyl radicals [39]. EGCG was also found to scavenge the free [48, 49].
radicals, and thus alleviating the neuronal apoptosis as well as Amyloid precursor protein (APP) could play an important role in
promoting the neuronal differentiation [37, 38, 40–42]. Methyl- the deposition of Aβ, thus accelerating AD progression [50].
xanthines, a group of biomolecules derived from tea (especially Noteworthily, tea polyphenols including epicatechin (EC) and
black tea), included theophylline (1,3-dimethylxanthine) and epigallocatechin (EGC) were found to suppress APP processing by
caffeine. Caffeine was suggested to have significant antioxidant neutralizing excessively free iron via chelation reactions [51].
effects [43, 44]. In human clinical trials, an increase in plasma Besides, AD mouse models have showed reduced Aβ pathology in
antioxidant capacity after moderate intakes of green or black tea brain after a long-term oral delivery of tea polyphenols [16–18].
was observed [8, 30]. The antioxidative function might be a key Furthermore, previous studies in cognitively normal individuals
factor in the neuroprotective role of tea in brain diseases and showed that the components of green tea could alleviate
cognitive performance. Secondly, neuroinflammation has been abnormal tau metabolism and mitigate the detrimental effects
demonstrated to play an important role in the progression of of tau pathology, suggesting green tea as a potential prophylactic
dementia [45]. Animal studies found that EGCG could decrease the for AD [15].
expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines (e.g., interleukin [IL]-1β The association of green or black tea with VD was partly due to
and tumor necrosis factor [TNF]-α), increase the expression of anti- their protection against transient ischaemic attack (TIA) and
inflammatory cytokines (e.g., IL-10), inhibit astrocyte activation stroke, as suggested by population-based studies [23, 52, 53].
and promote microglial activation. Methylxanthines were also Besides, the protective effects of tea on VD might relate to its
found to increase the production of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) as positive impacts on cerebral blood vessels. For example, tea was
well as promote the clearance of neurotoxins, which might suggested to have vasodilative functions by enhancing the
attenuate neuroinflammation and thereby provide biological releases of prostacyclin and NO, as well as reducing oxidative
plausibility for the prevention of dementia [20, 21]. Thirdly, l- stress [54]. Accumulating evidence has shown that tea consump-
theanine, a specific amino acid extracted from tea leaves, was tion could reduce blood pressure as well as serum lipid levels,
suggested to be an intervention for cognitive improvement [46]. improving cerebral perfusion and reducing the risk of VD [55–58].
In a randomized controlled trial (RCT) study, electroencephalo- Moreover, caffeine in tea was revealed to protect against ischemic
grams showed that participants treated by l-theanine had higher neuronal injury by blocking the receptors of neurotransmitter
levels of theta waves, interpreted to be an indicator of cognitive adenosine [59–61]. However, VD represents a heterogeneous
alertness, in the temporal, frontal, parietal, and occipital lobes after group of dementia with different pathophysiologies depending
3 h of reading compared with the placebo group [47]. Note- on the source (e.g., small vessel disease versus large ischemia) and
worthily, since the beneficial compounds in tea are small, they also shares some pathologies with AD [62]. Therefore, advances in