Medicine Through Time
Medicine Through Time
Medicine Through Time
TOPIC 5 – MEDIEVAL
Background Information
Wars destroyed the Roman public health systems and medical libraries.
The rulers of the small kingdoms built up armies rather than improving medical skills or public health.
War disrupted trade so countries became poorer.
Travel became more dangerous, reducing the communication between doctors.
Training of doctors was abandoned. Copies of Galen’s books were either lost, or hidden away for safety.
HOWEVER, LATER…
Medieval Hospitals
Medical care for the poor came from hospitals set up by monasteries, and run by monks and nuns.
They provided “hospitality” for visitors.
Genuinely ill people were often turned away due to fear of disease spreading.
Galen’s ideas were rediscovered. Church leaders looked carefully at Galen’s works and decided that they
fitted in with Christian ideas because he referred to “the creator” in his works.
Doctors in the believed his ideas were correct and it was nearly impossible to improve his work.
Galen had great influence on the doctors in the Arabic world and in medieval Christian Europe
Medical schools began to appear in Western Europe, starting with the one in Salerno, Italy. Translations of
Galen’s and Hippocrates’ work were accepted as absolute truth in medical schools.
Arab Medicine – Islamic scholars picked up and developed ideas from the Greeks whom they greatly admired.
Aristotle’s four humours, Galen’s treatment by opposites and Hippocrates’ clinical observation lived on.
Books were written that brought together the ideas of Aristotle, Galen and Hippocrates. These books were
important means by which these ideas got back to Western Europe.
The attitude of Muslims towards the Koran meant that they were unwilling to criticise the works of Galen.
Medieval doctors believed illness was caused by an imbalance of the four humours.
The theory developed into a more complex system, based on the position of the stars.
Although human dissection was carried out in medical schools, findings were interpreted as the theory of
the four humours – although some later doctors began to challenge traditional understandings.
More schools sprang up and human dissection was allowed. There were some doubts about classical texts.
New techniques included diagnosis by urine sample. This is a good aid to diagnosis, which is done today!
Doctors also believed the stars caused disease and relied on astrology when deciding on treatments
Trained doctors were very expensive. Medicine practised amongst the most was provided by monasteries
and housewife-physicians, using traditional cures and their experience.
The church believed that illness was a punishment for sins – they prayed to god if they became ill.
Some believed that pilgrimages to holy shrines could cure illness.
Doctors had superstitious beliefs, saying magical words when treating patients and consulting stars.
Developments in Surgery
In the Middle Ages, there was great demand for surgery because of warfare.
Surgery was held in such low regard that many procedures were often left to untrained barber-surgeons.
Wine was first used as an antiseptic.
Surgical treatments were still simple, as major surgery was risky.
Spread by coughs and sneezes or by black rat flea bites – black rats were carried overseas by ships.
Arrived in Britain in 1348. Its victims were struck down suddenly and most died.
Symptoms included exhaustion, high temperatures, swellings and difficulty breathing.
Ships were made to wait 40 days before landing – they were quarantined.
What did people think caused the plague and how did they treat it?
Miasma – carried sweet smelling herbs, sat between two large fires.
God – tried to appease god by praying, or becoming flagellants (whipping themselves as a punishment).
Humours out of balance – use of opposites, purging, vomiting and blood letting.
Poisoned water – blamed the Jews.
Doctors followed the ideas of Galen. They believed illness was caused by an imbalance in humours.
Believed that God and the Devil influenced health. Disease was seen as God’s punishment for sins.
Astrology became important. Doctors studied star charts because they believed that the movement of the
planets affected people’s health.
TOPIC 6 – RENAISSANCE
Background to the Renaissance
Renaissance means rebirth. It began with close study of classic texts and was critical of old translations
There was a greater interest in how the human body worked based on observation and dissection.
Artists attended dissections of human corpses and did wonderful illustrations for medical books.
Return of classical texts led to a renewed faith in the four humours theory and treatment by opposites.
Studied anatomy, became professor of surgery and anatomy at Padua. He was allowed to do dissections.
Did his own dissections and wrote books based on his observations using accurate diagrams to illustrate
his work. His most famous book was ‘On The Fabric of the Human Body’ written in 1543.
He was able to point out some of Galen’s mistakes. Vesalius said there were no holes in the septum of the
heart and that the jaw bone is not made up of two bones.
Vesalius encouraged doctors to dissect and look for themselves.
Paré was a battlefield surgeon; this was still a low status profession.
In battle, he ran out of boiling oil which was used for treating gunshot wounds. Paré made an old Roman
ointment of roses, turpentine and egg yolk.
Paré develops ligatures to seal wounds instead of using a cauterising iron.
Carried out an experiment to disprove Galen by proving the bezoar stone isn’t a treatment for position.
Writes ‘Notes on Surgery’ and becomes the King’s surgeon.
This was the worst of the reappearances of the Black Death. The death toll in London was about 100 000.
Efforts were made to control the spread of disease. Households were locked in and red crosses were
painted on their doors with the words, “Lord have mercy upon us.”
Carts organised by the authorities roamed the city to the now infamous cry of “Bring out your dead!”
collecting corpses for mass burial in “plague pits”.
People realised disease was contagious, but they still didn’t understand about germs causing disease.
The Great Fire of London in 1666 effectively sterilised large parts of London, killing the plague bacteria.
Public Health
There were many wars during the renaissance. Warfare gobbled up resources.
Populations were beginning to increase in the towns and cities, placing more strain on the available clean
water supplies and sewage disposal systems.
The Printing Press – new ideas could spread more easily and rapidly now that books could be printed.
The Weakening Power of the Church – people did not have religious beliefs about the causes of diseases,
meaning that people started to look for natural causes. Doctors could now dissect.
Artists Drawing from Life – medical drawings could be drawn and shared among doctors through medical
books, new anatomy books were produced.
Renewed Interest in Ancient Learning – people wanted to learn how to read, they began to challenge old
medical ideas (e.g. Galen holes in the septum).
New understanding of the body and Galen’s descriptions were incomplete and sometimes wrong.
The invention of the proved that Harvey’s ideas were right.
Theory of the four humours no longer accepted. People initially thought that miasma, caused disease.
Doctors carried out dissections and used microscopes. Galen’s books were no longer important.
Inoculation
In the 18th century, smallpox was a big killer. Lady Mary Wortley Montagu brought inoculation to Britain.
She discovered that a health person could be immunised against smallpox using pus from the sores of a
sufferer with a mild form of the disease.
However, inoculation sometimes led to smallpox and death.
Jenner was a country doctor. He heard that milkmaids didn’t get smallpox, but instead a milder cowpox.
Jenner investigated and discovered people who had already had cowpox didn’t get smallpox.
In 1796 he took a small boy and injected him with pus from the sores of a milkmaid with cowpox. Jenner
then injected James with smallpox. James didn’t catch the disease!
Developments in Nursing
Florence Nightingale
Nightingale brought discipline and professionalism to a job that had a bad reputation at the time.
From a wealthy background, she became a nurse despite the opposition of her family.
Went out to the Crimean War to sort out nursing care in the English camp.
She made huge improvements in the death rate, due to improvements in ward hygiene.
When she returns home, she writes a book ‘Notes on Nursing’ and sets up a hospital in London.
Mary Seacole
From a poor background in Jamaica. Seacole volunteers to help as a nurse in the Crimean War, she is
rejected, but goes anyway self-financing her journey.
She nursed soldiers on the battlefields and built the ‘British Hotel’.
Goes bankrupt when she returns to England – but receives support due to the press interest in her story
and she writes an autobiography.
Scientists thought microbes were caused by disease and appeared because of illness. This was the theory
of spontaneous generation. Instead of blaming microbes, people looked for miasmas.
Louis Pasteur was employed in 1857 to find the explanation for the souring of sugar beet used in
fermenting industrial alcohol. His answer was to blame germs in the air.
He proved there are germs in the air by sterilising water and keeping it in a flask that didn’t allow airborne
particles to enter. This stayed sterile – but sterilised water kept in an open flask bred microbes again.
German scientist. He began linking diseases to the microbe that caused that specific disease.
Koch developed a solid medium to grow cultures, and dyeing techniques to colour microbes, which he
viewed through high-powered microscopes.
He identified anthrax spores and the bacteria that cause septicaemia, tuberculosis and cholera.
Hearing of Koch’s, Pasteur came out of retirement and competed to find new microbes and combat them.
Pasteur looked for cures to anthrax and chicken cholera. Both he and Koch worked with large teams of
scientists. Charles Chamberland was in Pasteur’s team.
Chamberland was told to inject chickens with chicken cholera, but it was the day before his holiday and he
forgot. He left the germs on his desk and injected the chickens when he returned from his holiday.
The chickens survived, Pasteur and Chamberlain tried again with new germs, but the chickens survived.
The cholera had been weakened by being left out, and the weakened cholera made the chickens immune.
Chamberland’s error had produced a chance discovery.
Pasteur’s team managed to produce a weakened version of the anthrax spore that would make sheep
immune to the disease. They demonstrated this in a public experiment.
Surgery in the early 1800s was dangerous and painful. Infection was the greatest danger to patients.
In 1800, surgeons tried various ways to ease suffering of patients – e.g. getting them drunk, knocking them
out and giving them opium.
Nitrous Oxide or ‘laughing gas’ was discovered by Sir Humphry Davy. It was never really widely used as Davy’s
findings were published in a book that was not well known, the book was given an obscure name.
Ether used by J.R. Liston during a leg amputation. However, it had very unpleasant side effects.
Chloroform used by James Simpson and some friends at his home. They realised that it could be used as
during surgery. However, it led to unexplained deaths. The dose given could not be measured or controlled.
The final breakthrough came when Queen Victoria accepted the use of chloroform as an anaesthetic during
the delivery of her eighth child.
Until germ theory in the 1850s, surgeons didn’t take precautions to protect open wounds. They reused
bandages, didn’t wash their hands before operations and didn’t sterilise surgical equipment.
Heard that carbolic spray was used on sewage. He knew sewage had a similar smell to gangrene.
He had read the work of Pasteur on his germ theory.
He was prepared to take risks.
By the late 1890s Lister’s antiseptic methods led to aseptic surgery. This is the removal of all possible germs
from theatres to ensure absolute cleanliness. The following methods were introduced…
Once William Harvey had discovered the circulation of the blood, the first blood transfusions were attempted.
During the late 1700s and the first half of C19th, conditions in British towns became worse than ever.
Houses were built as close together as possible as more people crowded into factory towns to work.
Towns could not cope with the need to provide people with water and sewage disposal facilities.
In these squalid conditions, diseases spread easily and rapidly.
The conditions were so bad that many people’s health may have even become worse than ever before.
Some thought that the government should force local councils to clean up their towns.
However, many believed that the government shouldn’t interfere – this attitude is called laissez-faire.
They believed the government should allow each local area to control its own affairs.
This meant that local ratepayers made all the decisions. Local ratepayers didn’t want the government to
force them to pay for improvements to their towns.
Edwin Chadwick
In 1842 he was asked by the government to report on the living conditions and health of the poor.
Chadwick concluded that poverty was caused by ill health which was caused by the terrible conditions in
which people lived.
He said that ratepayers can cut their taxes and save money in the long-term by looking after the poor and
to spend money improving their health.
In his “Report on the Sanitary Conditions of the Labouring Population” he said industrial towns should:
For over 30 years an argument went on about the need for town councils or the government to take action.
Towns such as Liverpool and Manchester did start to build sewage and water-supply systems.
In 1854 John Snow proved that there was a link between cholera and water supply. He used research,
observation and door-to-door interviews to build a detailed map of a cholera epidemic in Broad Street.
Nearly all the deaths had taken place within a short distance of the water pump.
Near to the pump, there was a brewery and none of the people there had cholera. The brewery had its
own water pump, and the men had been given free beer. They didn’t use the Broad Street Pump at all.
After collecting evidence, John Snow removed the handle from the Broad Street pump.
There were no more deaths. It later came to light that a cesspool near to the pump had a cracked lining
which allowed the contents to contaminate the drinking water.
Snow put pressure on water companies to clean up their water supplies.
For years human waste made its way from the latrines in London into the River Thames.
In 1858 the hot weather caused a ‘great stink’. The putrid smell was right under Parliament’s nose.
Parliament considered moving and had to coat their curtains with a deodorant to get rid of the smell.
The Great Stink prompted Parliament to sort out London’s sewage and drainage system and to clean up
the River Thames.
Within a year Sir Joseph Bazalgette had begun to build an extensive system of sewers and drains that are
still in operation today.
Unlike the 1848 Public Health Act, the 1975 Public Health Act actually forced local authorities to introduce the
following measures:
Factor Explanation
In 1861 Louis Pasteur published his germ theory which proved the link between dirt
Scientific
and disease. With scientific proof, people were more willing to pay taxes to cover the
Developments
costs of public health reforms.
Working-class men were given the vote in 1867. MPs were more likely to take notice
New Voters
of the victims of poor public health.
The government published statistics of where death rates were highest and what
Statistics
people died of. The statistics shamed some unhealthy towns into action.
Cholera When cholera returned in 1865 and the link between disease and dirty water had
Outbreaks been proven by John Snow, ratepayers were finally prepared to take action.
Weakening of The government saw it could no longer leave public health measures to individuals or
Laissez Faire councils, and realised that they had to take action.
The Public Health Act of 1875 was very effective. By 1900 most British towns had built effective hygiene and
water systems.
What Medical Progress Did the First World War Bring About?
Surgeons had the opportunity to experiment with new techniques. Surgeons developed techniques to
repair broken bones, and perform skin grafts – plastic surgery.
Soldiers promised good housing when they returned. This helped to get rid of unhealthy slum housing.
Surgery of the eye, ear, nose and throat all improved rapidly. Brain surgery also advanced.
In the renaissance, Harvey proved blood circulates and this encouraged experiment with transfusions.
It sometimes worked and sometimes failed. Scientists didn’t know about different blood groups.
Blood groups were discovered in 1901 by Karl Landsteiner. The discovery made transfusions successful.
During the First World War vast amounts of blood was needed. On-the-spot donors were impractical.
Many soldiers bled to death in the trenches before blood could get to them.
The search began for a better method of storage and transfusion. Doctors discovered how blood can be
bottled, packed in ice and stored where it was needed. This discovery helped to save many lives.
1 Fleming discovered mould killed germs. Writes articles but publishes them in book with an obscure name.
2 Chain and Florey begin research in Oxford after reading an article by Fleming. They experiment with mice.
3 Penicillin is first tested on a human being in Oxford.
4 U.S. and Britain fund production of penicillin.
5 Enough penicillin is produced to treat all the allied forces wounded in the D-Day invasion of Europe.
In the 1930s two Oxford scientists, Florey and Chain, became interested in Fleming’s 1929 paper.
In 1939 they gathered a skilled research team and three days after the outbreak of the Second World War
Florey asked the British Government to fund the team’s research into penicillin.
British chemical firms were too busy making explosives to start mass production – so Florey went to US.
America helped to mass produce penicillin, the casualties of the Second World War added to the urgency.
By 1944 mass production was sufficient for the needs of the military medics. Fleming, Florey and Chain
were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1945.
Government – British government funded Florey’s research, U.S. government funded mass production.
Technology – microscopes and bacteria growing mediums.
Scientific experiment – testing on mice.
Individuals – Florey and Chain were skilled scientists supported by a skilled team of researchers.
War – the growing casualties of World War Two added to the urgency to mass produce penicillin.
Chance – Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin by chance in 1928.
Blood transfusion –blood could be stored for longer, civilians donated blood.
Diet – rationing improved some people’s diet, government encouraged healthy eating.
Drugs – penicillin was developed as the first antibiotic.
Poverty – evacuation took children out of urban areas. Highlighted contrast between rich and poor.
Surgery – developments in the use of skin grafts and treatment of burns.
Hygiene – government posters education people about health and hygiene.
Influence of WW2
Sir William Beveridge published his famous Beveridge Report in 1942. In it he called for the state provision
of social security “from the cradle to the grave”. The report became a bestseller.
Aneurin Bevan was the Labour Minister for Health who introduced the National Health Service.
National Insurance was introduced to pay for the NHS. Doctors and dentists were wooed with a fixed
payment for each patient. They were also allowed to continue treating private fee-paying patients.
Governments have reduced how much of the NHS is free – charging for prescriptions and dental health.
Long waiting lists and doubts about the quality of treatment have led to paying for treatment outside NHS.
Longer life expectancies have meant more need for care of the elderly and increased costs for the NHS.