Final Black Book Project
Final Black Book Project
PROJECT REPORT
ON
SATISFACTION OF TAX FILER
TOWARDS FUNCTIONING OF IT
DURING PANDEMIC
SUBMITTED BY
SAIF AHMED JAMIL AHMED SHAIKH
PROJECT GUIDE
PROF.SUBHASH SHENGALE
SUBMITTED TO
UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI
Anna Leela College of Commerce and Economics and
Shobha Jayaram Shetty College for BMS
Shashi Manmohan Shetty Higher Education Complex,
Buntara Bhavana Marg, Kurla East, Mumbai – 400070
March 2022
2
PROJECT REPORT
ON
SATISFACTION OF TAX FILER
TOWARDS FUNCTIONING OF IT
DURING PANDEMIC
SUBMITTED TO
UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI
Anna Leela College of Commerce and Economics and
Shobha Jayaram Shetty College for BMS
Shashi Manmohan Shetty Higher Education Complex,
Buntara Bhavana Marg, Kurla East, Mumbai – 400070
IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF REQUIREMENT
FOR THE DEGREE OF
BACHOLOR OF
MANAGEMENT STUDIES
(FINANCE)
SUBMITTED BY
SAIF AHMED JAMIL AHMED SHAIKH
BMS (FINANCE)SEM :VI
PROJECT GUIDE
PROF. SUBHASH SHENGALE
March 2022
3
Certificate
This is to certify that Ms./Mr. SAIF AHMED JAMIL AHMED
SHAIKH has worked and duly completed her/his project work
for the degree of Bachelor of management studies under the
Faculty of Commerce in the subject of FINANCE and his/her
project is entitled, “SATISFACTION OF TAX FILER
TOWARDS FUNCTIONING OF IT DURING PANDEMIC ”
under my supervision. I further certify that the entire work has
been done by the learner under my guidance.
It is her/his own work and facts reported by her/his personal
findings and investigations.
Date of Submission:
4
Declaration by learner
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
To list who all have helped me is difficult because they are
so numerous and the depth is so enormous.
I would like to acknowledge the following as being idealistic
channels and fresh dimensions in the completion of this
project.
I take this opportunity to thank the University of Mumbai
for giving me chance to do this project.
I would like to thank my Principal, PRASHANT SHINDE,
for providing the necessary facilities for completion of this
project.
I would like to express my sincere gratitude towards my
guide, Prof. SUBHASH SHENGALE whose guidanceand
care made the project successful.
I would like to thank my College Library, for having
provided various reference books and magazine related to
my subject.
Lastly, I would like to thank each and every person who
directly or indirectly helped me in the completion of the
throughout my project.
6
INDEX
INTRODUCTION:
MEANING:
In modern economies taxes are the most important sourceof governmental
revenue. Taxes differ from other sourcesof revenue in that they are compulsory
levies and are unrequited i.e., they are generally not paid in exchange forsome
specific thing, such as a particular public service, the sale of public property, or
the issuance of public debt. While taxes are presumably collected for the welfare
of taxpayers as a whole, the individual taxpayer’s liability is independent of any
specific benefit.
EXISTING TAX
STRUCTURE
IN INDIA
INDIRECT
DIRECT TAX
TAX
CEBTRAL VAT(SALES
CUSTOM SERVICE TAX OTHER TAX INCOME TAX
EXCISE TAX)
9
The word ‘tax’ is derived from the Latinword taxare or taxo. It means
‘toassess the worth of something’. Taxes are imposed by government for
the useand service of the State. They are levied and collected by the
State for the purchase or sale of merchandise or a service. Taxes provide
revenue to the state, and is therefore one of the most significant
aspects of any system of administration by any form of government.
The strength of an economy depends upon how good thetax system is. A just tax
system can propel the economicgrowth of a country and lead to its prosperity.
This in turns makes its citizens happy and more productive. An efficient taxation
policy leads to growth in GDP; it is considered sound if it performs allocative,
distributionaland stabilization function in the economy.
There are two types of taxes – direct and indirect. Direct taxes are those that an
entity remits to the government directly, and include income tax, property tax, etc.
indirect taxes are those that an entity remits through third parties. Service tax is an
example of indirect tax imposedby the government of India.
The income tax as we know today was first introduced inIndia in 1860 by the
British. It was introduced to compensate for the losses sustained by the
government due to the rebellion of 1857. Income tax is defined as theannual
charge levied on both earned income (wages, salaries or commission) and
10
This income tax Act was in place till 1922, when it was replaced by another Act.
After 40 years, and 15 years after India gained freedom from the British, the
income tax Act was modified again. The current Income Tax Act has been adopted
in 1961, and bought into force with effect from April 1, 1962. It encompasses the
whole of India, including Sikkim, Jammu and Kashmir. The Central Board of
Revenue bifurcated and created a separate Board for Direct Taxes called as the
Central Board of Direct Taxes under the aegis of Central Board ofRevenue Act,
1963.
Currently, there are five broad heads under whichincome is taxed
by the govt. of India:
India currently has a three tier setup for taxation. The central government and the state
government can both impose tax. The State government in turn can delegate taxation to
the local governing bodies like the municipalcorporations and gram panchayats. It is
said that that theIndian tax system is one of the most complex in the world, including
the likes of income tax, wealth tax, property tax, gift tax, sales tax, VAT, custom duty,
exciseduty (now replaced by GST), corporate tax, income tax and a plethora or other
taxes? Indeed, it is one of the reasons why there is a high demand in India for income
tax consultants, GST consultants, auditors, and other professionals.
During the 19th century the prevalent idea was that taxes should serve mainly to
finance the government. In earlier times, and again today, governments have
utilized taxation for other than merely fiscal purposes. One useful way to view the purpose of
taxation,
attributable to American economist Richard A. Musgrave, is to distinguish between objectives of
resource allocation, income redistribution, and economic stability. (Economic growth or
development and international
competitiveness are sometimes listed as separate goals, but they can generally be subsumed
under the other three.) In the absence of a strong reason for interference,
such as the need to reduce pollution, the first objective, resource allocation, is
furthered if tax policy does not interfere withmarket-determined allocations.
The second objective income redistribution, is meant to lessen inequalities in the distribution of
income and
wealth. The objective of stabilization implemented
through tax policy, governmentexpenditure policy, monetary policy, and
debt management is that of maintaining high employmentand price stability.
12
DATES EXTENTION:
Indian FM announced economic stimulus plan, and relaxation of due dates due
to the issues faced by the taxpayers & companies amid complete lockdown in
Indiato control COVID-19 (Corona Virus). Covering various statutory,
regulatory compliance such as Income Tax, GST, Corporate Affairs, Banking
Charges,PM Cares Fund.
Announcements in 2021
(latest)Income Tax
1. The due date for Filing Income Revised or BelatedTax Return for FY
2019-20 is extended to31st May 2021 from 31st Mar 2021.
2. The due date for filing appeal to Commissioner (Appeal) (for which the
last date is after April 1st 2021) is now extended to 31st May 2021 or
date specified in the section whichever is later.
3. The due date for filing Income Tax return in response to notice u/s
148 (for which the last dateis after April 1st 2021) is now extended to
31st
May 2021 or date mentioned in notice whichever islater.
4. Payment of tax u/s 194IA, 194IB and 194M andFiling of Form
26QB, 26QC and 26QD which is required to be paid/filed before
30th April 2021 isnow extended to 31st May 2021.
14
1. The due date for filing GSTR 1 IFF (Monthly) forquarterly tax payers is
extended by 15 days i.e 28/05/2021 from 13/05/2021
2. The due date for filing GSTR 1 (Monthly) is extended by 15 days i.e 26th
May 2021 from 11thMay 2021.
3. The due date for filing form GSTR 4 for FY 2020-21 is extended to 31st
May 2021 from 30th Apr
2021
6. Private Limited Companies, OPC & LLPs who arerequired to file GST
Returns with DSC are allowedto file with EVC from 27th Apr 2021 to 31st
May 2021. Taxpayers who wants to opt for Quarterly GSTFiling for FY
2021-22 can change from 1st Feb2021 to 30th Apr 2021.
15
Ministry of CorporateAffairs
The date for making investments & payments forclaiming deduction under Section 80C
(LIC, PPF, NSC etc.), 80D (Mediclaim), 80G (Donations), extended to Jun 30th 2020 31st July
2020 for FY 2019-20 June 2021 from 31st March 2020 The due date
for Filing Income Tax Return for FY 2018-19 is extended to 30th Jun
2020 31st Jul 2020 30th September 2020 30th November 2020 from 31st
Mar 2020
4. The due date for TDS, TCS Returns by deductorother than Govt. for
Q4 FY 2019-20 is 30th Jun 2020 31st Jul 2020.
16
5. The TDS rate on payments for contract, professional fee, rent, commission,
dividend, brokerage etc shall be reduced by 25% of existingrates. Now this
TDS rates reduction is further extended upto Nov 30th 2020.
6. The date for making investments & payments forclaiming deduction
under Section 80C (LIC, PPF, NSC etc.), 80D (Mediclaim), 80G
(Donations), extended to Jun 30th 2020 31st July 2020 for FY 2019-20
The date for making investments under Sec 54*, 54GB for claiming
re-investment benefits, extendedto 30th Sep 2020 for FY 2019-20 All
delayed payments of advance tax, self assessment tax, TDS, TCS,
equalization levy, STT, CTT made between 20th Mar 2020 and30th
Jun 2020 31st Jul 2020 will be charged at reducedinterest rate i.e., 9%
p.a instead of 12% p.a
8. The due date for issue of notice, intimation, order, investment in tax
saving instruments, investments for roll over benefit of capital gains
under Income Tax has been extended to 30th Jun2020 31st Jul 2020
9. Due date for Form-16 generation has been extended to 15th Aug 2020 to
give an opportunityforthose employers who are unable to meet the
timelines.
17
PM Cares Fund
DUE DATES
1. The due dates for filing Feb, March and April GSTreturns has been
extended till the last weekof 30/06/2020 for those whose turnover is
below 5 Crores.
2. Interest will be charged at reduced rate of 9% p.a instead of 18% p.a
for the companies with turnovermore than Rs 5 crores. No Late Fee and
18
Banking Laws
Other Announcements
1. Due Date for filing Employee Provident Fund (EPF) electronic challan
cum return for the month of March is extended to 15th May 2020 from
15thApr 2020
2. Rs 3 lakh crores. Collateral-Free Automatic Loans for Businesses,
including MSMEs. To pay after 12 months of moratorium
3. Pending refunds to co-operatives, charitabletrusts, non-
corporates will be processed immediately to relieve Statutory
PF Contribution by Employer and employee hasbeen reduced
to 10% from 12% for May, Jun, Jul 2020.
3. .Income Tax Department is set to launch a new 'taxpayer friendly' income tax filing portal on
June 7 as the Central Board of Direct Taxes said earlier this month that
the existing portal will be phased out after a
'blackout period' of six days beginning next month. An IT Department communicate on May 19
21
said the 'transition' from the old website - www.incometaxindiaefiling.gov.in to the new -
www.incometax.gov.in - will
be completed and madeoperational from June 7. It further stated, "In preparation of this launch
and for migration activities, the existing portal of the department
www.incometaxindiaefiling.gov.in would not be available for a brief period (taxpayers as well
as external stakeholders) of six days from June 1 to 6.
The Central Board of Direct Taxes urged the taxpayers tobe patient during this
transition, addingany compliance dates won't be fixed during this timeto ensure
'no inconvenience to taxpayers'
Various features of new portals:
The government has so far paid Rs 164.5 crore to Infosys between January 2019 to June 2021
for developing the portal. Sitharaman had on June 22 called a meeting with keyofficials of
Infosys to review the issues on the portal in whichthe ICAI representatives highlighted the
issues faced by taxpayers and tax professionals on the portal.
the new Income Tax Department website, which has beenmarred by glitches, has successfully
received over 25 lakhreturns, more than 3.57 crore unique logins and has allocated over 7.90
lakh e-PANs, according to the latest official data on Thursday.
The portal was launched on June 7 with the new domain name www.incometax.gov.in, but it hit
rough weather as anumber of its functionalities did not function properly.
Official sources in the tax department, however, say that the e-filing 2.0 website is now
"gathering pace and processes aregetting smooth".
also been received at the portal during the last two weekstime period, it said.
Glitches in the new income tax e-filing portal have not been fullyfixe over two months after
it was launched.
Major IT services provider Infosys has got a fresh deadline to fix glitches in the income tax e-
filing portal after its CEO Salil Parekh met with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitaraman on
Monday.
The finance minister said she was deeply disappointed over glitches in the new tax filing portal
and ordered the IT vendorto fix all the issues by September 15.
24
Nirmala Sitharaman summoned Infosys CEO Parekh to explainwhy the new income tax e-
filing portal has not been fixed fully after such a long time.
It has been more than 2.5 months since the new income tax e- filing portal was launched.
Earlier, the IT services provider said itwould resolve all pending glitches within a few weeks.
Nirmala Sitharaman also said Infosys needs to devote more resources and step up efforts to
ensure the portal is deliveredwithout glitches.
“The finance minister demanded that the issues faced by taxpayers on current
functionalities of the portal should be resolved by the team by 15th September so taxpayers
and professionals can work seamlessly on the portal,” the ministrysaid in a statement.
Nirmala Sitharaman also informed Salil Parekh about the difficulties taxpayers were facing due
to the glitches
on the portalincluding delays in tax filing.
the website will not be available for a certain amount of time between Saturday and Sunday.
As per a ticker on the new incometax portal, "Alert: Website will not be accessible due to
scheduledmaintenance activity from Saturday 23rd Oct 10.00PM to Sunday24th Oct
10.00AM IST".
A month after its launch in August 2021, the site was not accessible and the
message that appeared once landing onthe was that it was under maintenance.
Previously, the finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman had given time till September 15, 2021
to Infosys (the company that creatednew income tax portal) to fix all the glitches on the
websites. Dueto recurrent glitches, many chartered accountant associations, taxpayers asked
the government.
25
2.REVIEW OF LITRATURE
1. The fiscal policy of both developed and developing countries has put tax avoidance
Geetanjali & Venugopal (2016) cracked down the impact of direct tax contribution on
GDP.
The authors took time series data from 2000-2016. The test of stationary, normality, serial
correction has been employed. The OLS method is used to interpret the results.
Regression results show the significant impact of net collection of direct taxes on GDP. This
research work suggests that “Policy makers have to therefore emphasize on tax evasion and
tax collection.”
Musa et al (2016) contemplated tax buoyancy and elasticity in Nigeria. The authors applied
standard multiple regression with vector error correction model (VECM) model.
Researchers took aggregate tax revenue as endogenous variable and national income,
government
expenditure, external grant, inflation rate as exogenous variable along with a dummy
variable.
This paper concluded that the “aggregate revenue is relatively elastic and significantly
buoyant”.
26
Sharma (2016) wrote about the tax system and tax collection of ancient India. The book
reflects a detail idea about philosophy of taxation, ways and means of tax collection in
ancient India. The author opined that revenue collection was core aspects of administration
and governance in that period. Further the study concluded that systems, followed in respect
of taxation and revenue collection in ancient India, are still relevant, and if adopted, may
provide the contemporary fiscal system with a humanitarian face
Bagchi (2013) made a theoretical study on priorities of a tax programme, pointed that the
objective of maximising the yield of direct tax raising tax rate, widening tax base and curve
evasion. The focus of a tax reform must suggest the means for talking problems of black
money, tax evasion and tax arrears as well. The author also indicated that the corporate
taxation should be in principle oriented to promote efficiency rather equity.
The paper concluded that even with a widened base and the best of intentions, it may not be
possible to achieve the desired results merely though the income-tax or, for that matter,
through direct taxes alone.
Yusuf & Huq (2013) analysed tax buoyancy of major taxes in Bangladesh. The authors
Used time series data from 1980 to 2011. The authors applied exponential smoothing
method and used dummy variable in slope. The research work employed Johansen Co-
integration test for
long term relationship, Augmented Dickey Fuller test for unit presence of unit root, VEC
Residual Correlation LM Test for auto-correlation or serial correlation and Jarque-Bera
statistics
to test the normality of residuals.
The above study highlights the revenue performance of the country. The author concluded
that “with an uninterrupted economic growth and changes triggered by the discretionary
measures, revenue
structure of the country experience the structural shift where the role of Income Tax and
VAT hasbecome more prominent than that of the Customs Duties”.
27
Jenkins & Newell (2013) critically examined the connections between corporate social
responsibility, tax and development. This paper further focuses on tax payment and tax
evasion, the role of taxation on development of the state. The impact of tax evasion and tax
avoidance on government is also being studied. They author opined that the law makers
should provide a CSR platform where tax strategy is key. The paper also highlights the
excess reliance on corporate tax revenue by the developing countries. The authors arrived
different conclusions which are as follows.
Lucotte (2012) made an empirical study on inflation targeting and tax revenue
performance
in 59 emerging countries. The author investigated whether adoption of inflation targeting in
emerging economies has encouraged governments to increase domestic tax revenue.
Propensity score matching tool has been used to analyse the data. The independent variable
Is interest which is a binary variable, taking the value one if the country operates within an
share of GDP. The paper concludes that adoption of monetary policy framework by
maintaining inflation low levels encourages the government to improve collection of
domestic tax revenue. The author found most of the attributes on the level of total public
revenue are positive and highly significant and larger in magnitude.
Yi (2012) synthesized the relation of democracy in tax programmes and vice versa. It is
hypothesized that affects of taxation on democracy tend to be relatively stronger and event
history model is being used for data analysis purpose. A pooled time series dataset from
1970 to 2000 of thirty countries is taken. The author found that taxation has conditional
impact on democratization. It is critiqued that tax-GDP ratio has less impact than
tax-EXP ratio to fit the second hypothesis which is effect of income inequality on taxation
reforms.
This article can be annotated on the ground that democracy structure and/or income
inequality are the sole variable for taxation of a country as other variants as economic
Policy and fiscal condition are ignored.
28
Thomas (2012) published a paper which shows the elasticity taxable income with tax
Reform in New Zealand from the 1986 reform. The author used Auten and Carroll (1999)
model to
analyse the elasticity. It is argued in support of model that it has also been followed in
Several other studies, including: Sillamaa and Veall (2001) for Canada; Hansson (2007) for
Sweden;
and Auten, Carroll and Gee (2008) for the US. The author regressed the change in the
logarithm of taxable income against the change in the logarithm of the ‘net-of-tax rate’ (one
minus the marginal tax rate) as well as a number of additional control variables. The
empirical model is as follows:
These results imply a significant behavioural response to tax rate changes well in excess
Of that implied by standard labour supply elasticity estimates, and suggest that the welfare
costs of taxation in New Zealand are larger than may have previously been considered.
Acharya (2011) diagnosed the tax elasticity of India for the period 1991-2010.
Tax elasticity is calculated by dividing Marginal Tax Rate to the Average Tax Rate.
The author has employed regression analysis to the time series data. Natural Log Total
Direct Tax Natural Log Total Indirect Tax and Natural Log Gross Tax is taken as
Regress and and Natural Log GDP at current prices factor cost Natural Log GDP at current
prices market price are taken as regressor. The author used “Discretionary tax measures
(DTMs) to describe changes in the tax system which includes changes in statutory tax rates
tax bases, tax allowances and This research work found that direct tax elasticity is 1.62
percent, elasticity of indirect tax is0.89 percent and gross tax elasticity is 1.20 percent.
The author opined that “Tax Elasticity of Direct tax is high at 1.62 compared to other taxes
and thus showing that change in taxes has been higher than the changes in tax base and thus
showing that more and more people from the tax base are paying more taxes. This is a
healthy sign and can lead to lowering of effective tax rate with time”
Palande (2011) dig out different income tax problems and recommends certain suggestions
for improvement of income tax revenue, efficient compliance, administration etc.
29
This paper deals with different problem variants like lower tax-GDP ratio, greater reliance
on indirect taxes, exemptions of agricultural income, widening of tax base etc. The author
emphasised on the simplification of tax structure which ultimately accelerate tax
compliance, widening of tax base to increase tax revenue, improving of tax administration
to strengthen tax system, minimising compliance cost as an austerity measure.
It is accented that nullifying the distortions of economy is the key when tax reforms
took place. It is added that simplifications of tax structure can yield in win-win way for both
state and tax payer. Exemptions for bothsenior citizens and handicapped should be
eliminated including interest on house loan. The author argued that deduction of interest in
respect of housing loan is not a beneficial multiplier for industries like steel, cement, brick
making, tile, wood, sanitary etc. The author strictly concluded that no government should
take money from the people more than what itneeds for genuine capital and revenue
generations.
30
31
CHP:3Research Methodology
PRIMARY DATA
The primary data are those, which are collected afresh andfor the first
time, and thus happened to be original in character. We can obtain primary
data either through observation or through direct communication with
respondent in one form or another or through personal interview.
Cluster sampling
Convenient samplingEmail
survey Telephone survey
SECONDARY DATA
The secondary data on the other hand, are those which have already been collected
by someone alse and which have alreadybeen passed through the statistical
processes. When the researcher utilizes secondary data then he has to look into
various sources from where he can obtain them. For e.g. books,magazine,
newspaper, internet, publications and reports.
In this study data have been taken from various secondarysources like:
Internet
Books
Magazines
Newspapers
Journals
32
OBJECTIVES:
1. To know the functioning of income tax departmentduring such kinds of
pandemic situation.
2. What measures IT had adopted for convenience oftax payer.
3. Individual reaction on such measures.
4. Government supports for IT measures.
5. Benefits availed by individual.
HYPOTHESIS:
H1 : Government are provide most effective measures to tackle such
covid-19pandemic.
H2 : New income tax portal 2.0 needs to more monitoring ,
organizing, and effective necessaryremedial measures.
33
On the above data representation shows that for all respondents 50% are
belongs to25-35 age group, whichshows that 50% of all responses are this age
groups.
34
On the above representation of data we can say that 40.9%are belongs to self
occupation which is highly ratedand lower occupational rate are business man
with a 13.6%.
35
With respect to the all responses that I have been receiveddue to some age porpose
with show in above too,the people are educated and hence they had file there
returns for themselves i.e 54.5% and remaining due to some complexity and busy
scheduled file by others.
36
The above pie chart shows that 40.9% respondent are good opinion about the
functioning of IT 18.2% responses opinion are excellent, and 27.3%
consideredgood and remaining are satisfactory.
37
Networkfacility 11 2 4 5
Sites 5 7 10 -
functioning
approvals 4 12 6 -
38
With above reference about 77.3% are agreed that morework are done during
this pandemic.
39
Extended 18 3 1 -
dates
Refunds 7 5 10 -
concessions 7 4 11 -
41
6.Annexure
9. did earlier sites is far better then new 2.0 income taxPortal?
Yes
No
10. Are you think that the govt needs some extra efforts for properworking
during such kind of pandemic?
Yes No
Maybe
7. SUGGESTIONS
1.Previous portal is more efficient.
2. Govt brings suitable changes with help of concerned competentauthorities.
3. Scrutiny of software
4. Properly grievance handling procedure without any delay.
5. Bring old portal.
6. Govt is successful for their effective measures.
52
8. CONCLUSION
With respect to this project the information which Imentioned, what I comprehend is
that the government provide an good initiate during pendamic.(H1:proved)
Newportal is not succesfull for working (H2:proved)
9,82,71,116
Individual Registered Users
4,15,69,670
No. of returns filed (AY 21-22)
3,59,59,714
No. of returns verified (AY 21-22)
2,75,07,462
No. of verified ITRs (AY 21-22) processed
The conclusion that I had drawn above is purely the data that I had collected through Primary
and secondary data responses and on my personel analysis skills
53
9.BIBLIOGRAPHY:
News paper
Times of india
Hindustan time
Income tax sites
www.hindustantimes.com
www.indiatoday.in
www.fb.org
`www.ndtv.in
Textbook
International monetory fund sites Books
Manan prakashan (direct tax) T.Y.B.M.S
Semester 5
Sheth publications - direct tax